Press "Enter" to skip to content

Dark matter in our universe | Glenn Starkman | TEDxCWRU


[Music]

[Music] at first scientists thought it was a

at first scientists thought it was a

at first scientists thought it was a comet but it had no tail and so it

comet but it had no tail and so it

comet but it had no tail and so it couldn’t be a comment and people

couldn’t be a comment and people

couldn’t be a comment and people concluded it must be an asteroid now I’m

concluded it must be an asteroid now I’m

concluded it must be an asteroid now I’m known as moooo moooo mwah

known as moooo moooo mwah

known as moooo moooo mwah it had hurled down from above the solar

it had hurled down from above the solar

it had hurled down from above the solar system narrowly missing the Sun coming

system narrowly missing the Sun coming

system narrowly missing the Sun coming within the orbit of mercury and that was

within the orbit of mercury and that was

within the orbit of mercury and that was whizzing past the earth just 30 million

whizzing past the earth just 30 million

whizzing past the earth just 30 million kilometres away

astronomers believe it is made of rock

astronomers believe it is made of rock but might it be made instead of dark

but might it be made instead of dark

but might it be made instead of dark matter when we look out at galaxies much

matter when we look out at galaxies much

matter when we look out at galaxies much like our own Milky Way they looks many

like our own Milky Way they looks many

like our own Milky Way they looks many of them looks something like this spiral

of them looks something like this spiral

of them looks something like this spiral galaxy m81 if you went to an amusement

galaxy m81 if you went to an amusement

galaxy m81 if you went to an amusement park and we’re about to get on one of

park and we’re about to get on one of

park and we’re about to get on one of those fun rides where we’re a swing goes

those fun rides where we’re a swing goes

those fun rides where we’re a swing goes goes goes whizzing around a central

goes goes whizzing around a central

goes goes whizzing around a central pillar and you’re held on by nice strong

pillar and you’re held on by nice strong

pillar and you’re held on by nice strong chains if you got up to the ride and

chains if you got up to the ride and

chains if you got up to the ride and notice that instead of chains it was

notice that instead of chains it was

notice that instead of chains it was held together by dental floss you

held together by dental floss you

held together by dental floss you probably wouldn’t want to get on that

probably wouldn’t want to get on that

probably wouldn’t want to get on that ride you’d be too worried that those

ride you’d be too worried that those

ride you’d be too worried that those that dental floss would break allowing

that dental floss would break allowing

that dental floss would break allowing you to go hurtling out into space and

you to go hurtling out into space and

you to go hurtling out into space and crash to the ground and yet when we look

crash to the ground and yet when we look

crash to the ground and yet when we look at spiral galaxies like this one we see

at spiral galaxies like this one we see

at spiral galaxies like this one we see that they are spinning far too fast to

that they are spinning far too fast to

that they are spinning far too fast to be held together by the gravity of the

be held together by the gravity of the

be held together by the gravity of the stars and gas and dust that must be

stars and gas and dust that must be

stars and gas and dust that must be providing gravity well there’s two

providing gravity well there’s two

providing gravity well there’s two possibilities one is that we don’t

possibilities one is that we don’t

possibilities one is that we don’t understand the laws of gravity properly

understand the laws of gravity properly

understand the laws of gravity properly that we need to change general activity

that we need to change general activity

that we need to change general activity Einstein’s theory of how gravity works

Einstein’s theory of how gravity works

Einstein’s theory of how gravity works his improvement on Newton’s were that in

his improvement on Newton’s were that in

his improvement on Newton’s were that in fact the laws of gravity on these very

fact the laws of gravity on these very

fact the laws of gravity on these very large scales aren’t quite the same as

large scales aren’t quite the same as

large scales aren’t quite the same as they are within the solar system or on

they are within the solar system or on

they are within the solar system or on earth but subtly different that’s

earth but subtly different that’s

earth but subtly different that’s possible but we have so far failed to

possible but we have so far failed to

possible but we have so far failed to change those laws of gravity in a way

change those laws of gravity in a way

change those laws of gravity in a way that hangs together and so the other

that hangs together and so the other

that hangs together and so the other possibility is that there’s a lot of

possibility is that there’s a lot of

possibility is that there’s a lot of missing matter inside this galaxy and

missing matter inside this galaxy and

missing matter inside this galaxy and inside of every galaxy we see we call

inside of every galaxy we see we call

inside of every galaxy we see we call that missing matter dark matter because

that missing matter dark matter because

that missing matter dark matter because we can’t see it now for a long time we

we can’t see it now for a long time we

we can’t see it now for a long time we thought that that missing matter must be

thought that that missing matter must be

thought that that missing matter must be particles too many particles

particles too many particles

particles too many particles that are whizzing through space that are

that are whizzing through space that are

that are whizzing through space that are filling this room and the only reason we

filling this room and the only reason we

filling this room and the only reason we don’t feel them is that they are so

don’t feel them is that they are so

don’t feel them is that they are so weakly interacting that they manage to

weakly interacting that they manage to

weakly interacting that they manage to pass through the earth

pass through the earth

pass through the earth we have particles like that that we know

we have particles like that that we know

we have particles like that that we know about called neutrinos they come from

about called neutrinos they come from

about called neutrinos they come from the center of the Sun go unimpeded

the center of the Sun go unimpeded

the center of the Sun go unimpeded through the Sun most of them go unheeded

through the Sun most of them go unheeded

through the Sun most of them go unheeded through the earth and they can travel

through the earth and they can travel

through the earth and they can travel through light-years of ordinary material

through light-years of ordinary material

through light-years of ordinary material and it’s only by many many of them to

and it’s only by many many of them to

and it’s only by many many of them to pass through the detectors we build that

pass through the detectors we build that

pass through the detectors we build that we’ve never been able to see them so

we’ve never been able to see them so

we’ve never been able to see them so we’ve thought for a long time that dark

we’ve thought for a long time that dark

we’ve thought for a long time that dark matter must be like that and so we built

matter must be like that and so we built

matter must be like that and so we built detectors like the one on the left and

detectors like the one on the left and

detectors like the one on the left and we put them deep underground in old

we put them deep underground in old

we put them deep underground in old mines or underneath dams where cosmic

mines or underneath dams where cosmic

mines or underneath dams where cosmic rays can’t get to them and we’ve waited

rays can’t get to them and we’ve waited

rays can’t get to them and we’ve waited for for dark matter particles to hit the

for for dark matter particles to hit the

for for dark matter particles to hit the nuclei or the electrons of these dark

nuclei or the electrons of these dark

nuclei or the electrons of these dark matter detectors and heat them up just a

matter detectors and heat them up just a

matter detectors and heat them up just a tiny little bit because they’re an

tiny little bit because they’re an

tiny little bit because they’re an incredibly sensitive thermometers or

incredibly sensitive thermometers or

incredibly sensitive thermometers or make a very tiny sound because they’re

make a very tiny sound because they’re

make a very tiny sound because they’re incredibly sensitive microphones and so

incredibly sensitive microphones and so

incredibly sensitive microphones and so far after 40 years we failed to register

far after 40 years we failed to register

far after 40 years we failed to register anything in these dark matter detectors

anything in these dark matter detectors

anything in these dark matter detectors we’ve also built enormous machines

we’ve also built enormous machines

we’ve also built enormous machines called in this particular one called the

called in this particular one called the

called in this particular one called the Large Hadron Collider at the CERN in

Large Hadron Collider at the CERN in

Large Hadron Collider at the CERN in Geneva hoping to make particles of dark

Geneva hoping to make particles of dark

Geneva hoping to make particles of dark matter well we’ve made lots of things at

matter well we’ve made lots of things at

matter well we’ve made lots of things at the Large Hadron Collider and

the Large Hadron Collider and

the Large Hadron Collider and particularly we’ve discovered the Higgs

particularly we’ve discovered the Higgs

particularly we’ve discovered the Higgs boson the last unknown particle

boson the last unknown particle

boson the last unknown particle undiscovered particle of the standard

undiscovered particle of the standard

undiscovered particle of the standard model but so far we haven’t made any

model but so far we haven’t made any

model but so far we haven’t made any Dark Matter what could it be that our

Dark Matter what could it be that our

Dark Matter what could it be that our idea of what dark matter is is just

idea of what dark matter is is just

idea of what dark matter is is just wrong that it’s not little particles

wrong that it’s not little particles

wrong that it’s not little particles whizzing through space but large chunks

whizzing through space but large chunks

whizzing through space but large chunks of matter like this one this is an

of matter like this one this is an

of matter like this one this is an artist’s conception of a neutron star

artist’s conception of a neutron star

artist’s conception of a neutron star now it’s not a very good picture because

now it’s not a very good picture because

now it’s not a very good picture because I’m not much of an artist I’m a

I’m not much of an artist I’m a

I’m not much of an artist I’m a physicist but what is it what is it

physicist but what is it what is it

physicist but what is it what is it about a neutron star that makes a good

about a neutron star that makes a good

about a neutron star that makes a good dark matter or what is it about pieces

dark matter or what is it about pieces

dark matter or what is it about pieces of pieces of neutron star smaller

of pieces of neutron star smaller

of pieces of neutron star smaller neutron stars chunks of nuclear matter

neutron stars chunks of nuclear matter

neutron stars chunks of nuclear matter much like the nuclei at the centre of

much like the nuclei at the centre of

much like the nuclei at the centre of atoms but bigger that would make them

atoms but bigger that would make them

atoms but bigger that would make them good dark matter after all didn’t I tell

good dark matter after all didn’t I tell

good dark matter after all didn’t I tell you that dark matter had to be dark that

you that dark matter had to be dark that

you that dark matter had to be dark that you couldn’t see it and we can see

you couldn’t see it and we can see

you couldn’t see it and we can see neutron stars we can

neutron stars we can

neutron stars we can see nuclei but actually neutron stars

see nuclei but actually neutron stars

see nuclei but actually neutron stars and things like it chunks the nuclear

and things like it chunks the nuclear

and things like it chunks the nuclear matter make wonderful dark matter

matter make wonderful dark matter

matter make wonderful dark matter because although you can see the nuclei

because although you can see the nuclei

because although you can see the nuclei the matter at the surface you don’t get

the matter at the surface you don’t get

the matter at the surface you don’t get to see the inside

to see the inside

to see the inside so in fact most of them most of the

so in fact most of them most of the

so in fact most of them most of the matter is invisible the other thing is

matter is invisible the other thing is

matter is invisible the other thing is unlike particles which are very have

unlike particles which are very have

unlike particles which are very have very little mass and so there have to be

very little mass and so there have to be

very little mass and so there have to be lots and lots of lots of them a neutron

lots and lots of lots of them a neutron

lots and lots of lots of them a neutron star is really big if the neutron star

star is really big if the neutron star

star is really big if the neutron star was a dark matter we would only need one

was a dark matter we would only need one

was a dark matter we would only need one of them in every thousand cubic

of them in every thousand cubic

of them in every thousand cubic light-years and so there’s not much

light-years and so there’s not much

light-years and so there’s not much chance of it hitting our detector or

chance of it hitting our detector or

chance of it hitting our detector or even passing through the solar system

even passing through the solar system

even passing through the solar system very often now if they were smaller

very often now if they were smaller

very often now if they were smaller chunks of nuclear matter its chunks of

chunks of nuclear matter its chunks of

chunks of nuclear matter its chunks of neutron star they would pass through

neutron star they would pass through

neutron star they would pass through more often and we might have a hope of

more often and we might have a hope of

more often and we might have a hope of seeing them we would want really big

seeing them we would want really big

seeing them we would want really big detectors things that are so large that

detectors things that are so large that

detectors things that are so large that it was pretty much inevitable that dark

it was pretty much inevitable that dark

it was pretty much inevitable that dark matter would hit one of them well here

matter would hit one of them well here

matter would hit one of them well here are two really good big detectors the

are two really good big detectors the

are two really good big detectors the first one is the planet we live on the

first one is the planet we live on the

first one is the planet we live on the planet Earth

planet Earth

planet Earth and the other is the moon and they’re

and the other is the moon and they’re

and the other is the moon and they’re nice and close to us and so we can

nice and close to us and so we can

nice and close to us and so we can imagine putting putting instruments on

imagine putting putting instruments on

imagine putting putting instruments on them to use them as dark matter

them to use them as dark matter

them to use them as dark matter detectors well what would it look like

detectors well what would it look like

detectors well what would it look like if dark matter hit the earth it depends

if dark matter hit the earth it depends

if dark matter hit the earth it depends where it hits and so we can use the

where it hits and so we can use the

where it hits and so we can use the different places that it could hit as

different places that it could hit as

different places that it could hit as different ways of looking for dark

different ways of looking for dark

different ways of looking for dark matter

matter

matter for example dark matter streaking

for example dark matter streaking

for example dark matter streaking through the atmosphere would heat up and

through the atmosphere would heat up and

through the atmosphere would heat up and it would heat the atmosphere around it

it would heat the atmosphere around it

it would heat the atmosphere around it and it might glow just like a meteor now

and it might glow just like a meteor now

and it might glow just like a meteor now you might say well are the meteors we’re

you might say well are the meteors we’re

you might say well are the meteors we’re seeing dark matter

seeing dark matter

seeing dark matter the thing is meteors from the solar

the thing is meteors from the solar

the thing is meteors from the solar system move relatively slowly only 20

system move relatively slowly only 20

system move relatively slowly only 20 kilometers a second or 30 kilometers a

kilometers a second or 30 kilometers a

kilometers a second or 30 kilometers a second

second

second whereas dark matter would might be

whereas dark matter would might be

whereas dark matter would might be moving 300 or 400 kilometers a second so

moving 300 or 400 kilometers a second so

moving 300 or 400 kilometers a second so we can tell whether a meteor was made of

we can tell whether a meteor was made of

we can tell whether a meteor was made of dark matter but probably if if we were

dark matter but probably if if we were

dark matter but probably if if we were having enough of these to detect they

having enough of these to detect they

having enough of these to detect they would be much smaller chunks and they

would be much smaller chunks and they

would be much smaller chunks and they wouldn’t glow as brightly as a meteor so

wouldn’t glow as brightly as a meteor so

wouldn’t glow as brightly as a meteor so we would have to use very large

we would have to use very large

we would have to use very large detectors that look for things like

detectors that look for things like

detectors that look for things like meteors they’re called cosmic ray

meteors they’re called cosmic ray

meteors they’re called cosmic ray detectors ultra high cosmic ray

detectors ultra high cosmic ray

detectors ultra high cosmic ray detectors them we built

detectors them we built

detectors them we built huge ones we have one down in southern

huge ones we have one down in southern

huge ones we have one down in southern Argentina that’s tens of thousands of

Argentina that’s tens of thousands of

Argentina that’s tens of thousands of square kilometers staring out into space

square kilometers staring out into space

square kilometers staring out into space looking for ultra high-energy cosmic

looking for ultra high-energy cosmic

looking for ultra high-energy cosmic rays that can also look for these chunks

rays that can also look for these chunks

rays that can also look for these chunks of matter as dark matter we’re planning

of matter as dark matter we’re planning

of matter as dark matter we’re planning to build one that looks down from space

to build one that looks down from space

to build one that looks down from space at a huge fraction of the Earth’s

at a huge fraction of the Earth’s

at a huge fraction of the Earth’s surface of the atmosphere and we can

surface of the atmosphere and we can

surface of the atmosphere and we can watch for those cosmic rays or for these

watch for those cosmic rays or for these

watch for those cosmic rays or for these chunks of dark matter running through

chunks of dark matter running through

chunks of dark matter running through the atmosphere incredibly quickly much

the atmosphere incredibly quickly much

the atmosphere incredibly quickly much faster than any and than any meteor but

faster than any and than any meteor but

faster than any and than any meteor but much slower than any typical cosmic ray

much slower than any typical cosmic ray

much slower than any typical cosmic ray and we can look for the glow of dark

and we can look for the glow of dark

and we can look for the glow of dark matter passing through the atmosphere we

matter passing through the atmosphere we

matter passing through the atmosphere we also see craters for example on the moon

also see craters for example on the moon

also see craters for example on the moon the moon is a wonderful detector of

the moon is a wonderful detector of

the moon is a wonderful detector of things that hit it because they leave

things that hit it because they leave

things that hit it because they leave behind craters now the different thing

behind craters now the different thing

behind craters now the different thing about dark matter is if a chunk of dark

about dark matter is if a chunk of dark

about dark matter is if a chunk of dark matter hit the moon it would be moving

matter hit the moon it would be moving

matter hit the moon it would be moving it would be so dense and moving so fast

it would be so dense and moving so fast

it would be so dense and moving so fast that not only would go into the moon it

that not only would go into the moon it

that not only would go into the moon it would come out the other side not too

would come out the other side not too

would come out the other side not too many things do that imagine having a

many things do that imagine having a

many things do that imagine having a piece of jell-o and sending a really

piece of jell-o and sending a really

piece of jell-o and sending a really really fast tiny little VB through the

really fast tiny little VB through the

really fast tiny little VB through the jello what would happen if you went in

jello what would happen if you went in

jello what would happen if you went in you’d make a little tiny hole but as you

you’d make a little tiny hole but as you

you’d make a little tiny hole but as you went out you’d make a big splat we can

went out you’d make a big splat we can

went out you’d make a big splat we can imagine looking on the moon and on

imagine looking on the moon and on

imagine looking on the moon and on Mercury and on other bodies for to see

Mercury and on other bodies for to see

Mercury and on other bodies for to see are there any splats like that are there

are there any splats like that are there

are there any splats like that are there any distinctive craters that look like

any distinctive craters that look like

any distinctive craters that look like they came from the inside rather than

they came from the inside rather than

they came from the inside rather than the outside now there are other more

the outside now there are other more

the outside now there are other more mundane you know everyday ways that we

mundane you know everyday ways that we

mundane you know everyday ways that we can look for dark matter for example you

can look for dark matter for example you

can look for dark matter for example you might want to go home and look at your

might want to go home and look at your

might want to go home and look at your windows because as a little chunk of

windows because as a little chunk of

windows because as a little chunk of dark matter passed through your window

dark matter passed through your window

dark matter passed through your window it would comment a very very tiny

it would comment a very very tiny

it would comment a very very tiny cylinder through your winter a little

cylinder through your winter a little

cylinder through your winter a little tiny track and so if we got all of you

tiny track and so if we got all of you

tiny track and so if we got all of you to go home and look at the windows in

to go home and look at the windows in

to go home and look at the windows in your homes and in your offices and in

your homes and in your offices and in

your homes and in your offices and in your friends offices in their homes we

your friends offices in their homes we

your friends offices in their homes we might be able to by looking at these

might be able to by looking at these

might be able to by looking at these vast expanses of windows that fill our

vast expanses of windows that fill our

vast expanses of windows that fill our cities be able to tell whether particles

cities be able to tell whether particles

cities be able to tell whether particles of dark matter had come hurtling through

of dark matter had come hurtling through

of dark matter had come hurtling through them leaving behind these little tracks

them leaving behind these little tracks

them leaving behind these little tracks what about muah-muah

what about muah-muah

what about muah-muah well it may or may not be a chunk of

well it may or may not be a chunk of

well it may or may not be a chunk of dark matter it’s going to be very hard

dark matter it’s going to be very hard

dark matter it’s going to be very hard for us to tell unless we take a trip

for us to tell unless we take a trip

for us to tell unless we take a trip there

there

there and people are planning to send a

and people are planning to send a

and people are planning to send a mission if they can to a mu a mu and try

mission if they can to a mu a mu and try

mission if they can to a mu a mu and try to catch it but whether or not o Momoa

to catch it but whether or not o Momoa

to catch it but whether or not o Momoa is a chunk of dark matter there’s a very

is a chunk of dark matter there’s a very

is a chunk of dark matter there’s a very good chance that our galaxy is being

good chance that our galaxy is being

good chance that our galaxy is being held together by stuff that we simply

held together by stuff that we simply

held together by stuff that we simply cannot see so far and that is out there

cannot see so far and that is out there

cannot see so far and that is out there for us to discover and we hope to do

for us to discover and we hope to do

for us to discover and we hope to do that soon thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *