Press "Enter" to skip to content

Can Computers Think Creatively? | Dishita Turakhia | TEDxBeaconStreet


hi everyone my name is deshita and I’m a

hi everyone my name is deshita and I’m a researcher at the human-computer

researcher at the human-computer

researcher at the human-computer interaction lab at MIT

interaction lab at MIT

interaction lab at MIT my background is an architecture and

my background is an architecture and

my background is an architecture and computer science and my passion is to

computer science and my passion is to

computer science and my passion is to build machines that can help designers

build machines that can help designers

build machines that can help designers with creative problem-solving the

with creative problem-solving the

with creative problem-solving the motivation for my research comes from my

motivation for my research comes from my

motivation for my research comes from my personal experience as an architect I

personal experience as an architect I

personal experience as an architect I was never the lone creative genius

was never the lone creative genius

was never the lone creative genius being a designer for the last 10 years

being a designer for the last 10 years

being a designer for the last 10 years has made me realize that creative

has made me realize that creative

has made me realize that creative thinking is a social exercise every time

thinking is a social exercise every time

thinking is a social exercise every time I struggled with a problem that required

I struggled with a problem that required

I struggled with a problem that required a creative solution that out-of-the-box

a creative solution that out-of-the-box

a creative solution that out-of-the-box thinking I seeked perspectives of those

thinking I seeked perspectives of those

thinking I seeked perspectives of those around me and somehow they our way of

around me and somehow they our way of

around me and somehow they our way of looking at the problem differently than

looking at the problem differently than

looking at the problem differently than me opened up so many avenues of

me opened up so many avenues of

me opened up so many avenues of solutions for me the environments we

solutions for me the environments we

solutions for me the environments we thrive in the context and cultures we

thrive in the context and cultures we

thrive in the context and cultures we engage with but most importantly the

engage with but most importantly the

engage with but most importantly the people we interact with directly

people we interact with directly

people we interact with directly influence our creative abilities so when

influence our creative abilities so when

influence our creative abilities so when I came to MIT I started researching on

I came to MIT I started researching on

I came to MIT I started researching on building machines that could be creative

building machines that could be creative

building machines that could be creative partners I wanted to understand why and

partners I wanted to understand why and

partners I wanted to understand why and how did my interactions with others

how did my interactions with others

how did my interactions with others enabled me to develop creative solutions

enabled me to develop creative solutions

enabled me to develop creative solutions as I dug deeper I realized that creative

as I dug deeper I realized that creative

as I dug deeper I realized that creative thinking was not as mysterious as I

thinking was not as mysterious as I

thinking was not as mysterious as I believed it to be in fact each one of us

believed it to be in fact each one of us

believed it to be in fact each one of us can be creative all the time

can be creative all the time

can be creative all the time let me show an example take a moment and

let me show an example take a moment and

let me show an example take a moment and look at this image what did you just see

look at this image what did you just see

look at this image what did you just see more importantly what did you think if

more importantly what did you think if

more importantly what did you think if you were a Beatles fan you probably

you were a Beatles fan you probably

you were a Beatles fan you probably thought of their Blackbird song if you

thought of their Blackbird song if you

thought of their Blackbird song if you were a mother of a toddler you probably

were a mother of a toddler you probably

were a mother of a toddler you probably thought of the nursery rhyme for in 20

thought of the nursery rhyme for in 20

thought of the nursery rhyme for in 20 blackbirds baked in a pie or if you’re a

blackbirds baked in a pie or if you’re a

blackbirds baked in a pie or if you’re a Game of Thrones fan like me you’re

Game of Thrones fan like me you’re

Game of Thrones fan like me you’re probably thought of the three-eyed Raven

probably thought of the three-eyed Raven

probably thought of the three-eyed Raven why we all looked at the same thing we

why we all looked at the same thing we

why we all looked at the same thing we had our own unique ways of looking at

had our own unique ways of looking at

had our own unique ways of looking at the blackboard and if you a poet Wallace

the blackboard and if you a poet Wallace

the blackboard and if you a poet Wallace Stevens you had not one but 30 in

Stevens you had not one but 30 in

Stevens you had not one but 30 in different ways of looking at the

different ways of looking at the

different ways of looking at the blackboard

blackboard

blackboard Wallace’s poem highlights the most

Wallace’s poem highlights the most

Wallace’s poem highlights the most extraordinary ability of human minds

extraordinary ability of human minds

extraordinary ability of human minds creative thinking by merely able to see

creative thinking by merely able to see

creative thinking by merely able to see different meanings in the same object

different meanings in the same object

different meanings in the same object and this form of creative thinking is

and this form of creative thinking is

and this form of creative thinking is not just evident in poetry and

not just evident in poetry and

not just evident in poetry and storytelling but also in visual art for

storytelling but also in visual art for

storytelling but also in visual art for example Wallace’s poem inspired artist

example Wallace’s poem inspired artist

example Wallace’s poem inspired artist Michael Spafford to create his

Michael Spafford to create his

Michael Spafford to create his interpretations of Wallace’s poem as

interpretations of Wallace’s poem as

interpretations of Wallace’s poem as paintings interestingly ten years later

paintings interestingly ten years later

paintings interestingly ten years later he revisited his own paintings to form

he revisited his own paintings to form

he revisited his own paintings to form new expressions our ability to see

new expressions our ability to see

new expressions our ability to see different meanings in the objects around

different meanings in the objects around

different meanings in the objects around us and then express these visions across

us and then express these visions across

us and then express these visions across different mediums is what makes us a

different mediums is what makes us a

different mediums is what makes us a creative society creative thinking is

creative society creative thinking is

creative society creative thinking is nothing but seeing different meanings

nothing but seeing different meanings

nothing but seeing different meanings that adds value to our knowledge and

that adds value to our knowledge and

that adds value to our knowledge and sometimes it’s revisiting and re looking

sometimes it’s revisiting and re looking

sometimes it’s revisiting and re looking at our interpretations and forming new

at our interpretations and forming new

at our interpretations and forming new meanings it is as if the world is one

meanings it is as if the world is one

meanings it is as if the world is one giant painting and we are constantly

giant painting and we are constantly

giant painting and we are constantly playing around with it to discover new

playing around with it to discover new

playing around with it to discover new meanings discover hidden connections and

meanings discover hidden connections and

meanings discover hidden connections and this simple idea is powerful because

this simple idea is powerful because

this simple idea is powerful because what it means is that each one of us can

what it means is that each one of us can

what it means is that each one of us can be creative as long as we can develop

be creative as long as we can develop

be creative as long as we can develop our own unique ways of looking at the

our own unique ways of looking at the

our own unique ways of looking at the world and this way of looking uniquely

world and this way of looking uniquely

world and this way of looking uniquely on the world is a term that is

on the world is a term that is

on the world is a term that is scientifically called

scientifically called

scientifically called as cognitive diversity as a visual

as cognitive diversity as a visual

as cognitive diversity as a visual analogy consider for example you and me

analogy consider for example you and me

analogy consider for example you and me were looking at the same object a prism

were looking at the same object a prism

were looking at the same object a prism based on how we look at it where we are

based on how we look at it where we are

based on how we look at it where we are looking from we would form different

looking from we would form different

looking from we would form different rules to parse this object we would form

rules to parse this object we would form

rules to parse this object we would form different interpretations of this object

different interpretations of this object

different interpretations of this object and we will embed different meanings in

and we will embed different meanings in

and we will embed different meanings in this object this is what makes this

this object this is what makes this

this object this is what makes this cognitively diverse from each other

cognitively diverse from each other

cognitively diverse from each other computationally speaking cognitive

computationally speaking cognitive

computationally speaking cognitive diversity is merely being able to use

diversity is merely being able to use

diversity is merely being able to use different perspectives and breaking

different perspectives and breaking

different perspectives and breaking objects in different

objects in different

objects in different opponents using different rules and then

opponents using different rules and then

opponents using different rules and then using different heuristics to form new

using different heuristics to form new

using different heuristics to form new interpretations so if you’re all

interpretations so if you’re all

interpretations so if you’re all cognitively diverse from each other how

cognitively diverse from each other how

cognitively diverse from each other how does it affect our creative ability this

does it affect our creative ability this

does it affect our creative ability this brings me to the second most

brings me to the second most

brings me to the second most extraordinary ability of human

extraordinary ability of human

extraordinary ability of human intelligence social interaction when we

intelligence social interaction when we

intelligence social interaction when we socially interact with each other it’s

socially interact with each other it’s

socially interact with each other it’s as if we exchange our rules of parsing

as if we exchange our rules of parsing

as if we exchange our rules of parsing the world with each other and in the

the world with each other and in the

the world with each other and in the process we transform each other’s way of

process we transform each other’s way of

process we transform each other’s way of looking at things together we engage not

looking at things together we engage not

looking at things together we engage not just in a dialogue but in a creative

just in a dialogue but in a creative

just in a dialogue but in a creative thinking process in the end it doesn’t

thinking process in the end it doesn’t

thinking process in the end it doesn’t even matter whether we understood each

even matter whether we understood each

even matter whether we understood each other completely or not as long as we

other completely or not as long as we

other completely or not as long as we succeeded in transforming our own ways

succeeded in transforming our own ways

succeeded in transforming our own ways of looking at the world so the case that

of looking at the world so the case that

of looking at the world so the case that I’m making is that with just these two

I’m making is that with just these two

I’m making is that with just these two abilities one the ability to be

abilities one the ability to be

abilities one the ability to be cognitively diverse and second the

cognitively diverse and second the

cognitively diverse and second the ability to socially interact is what

ability to socially interact is what

ability to socially interact is what makes us creative Society however we are

makes us creative Society however we are

makes us creative Society however we are spending less time embracing our diverse

spending less time embracing our diverse

spending less time embracing our diverse thoughts and ideas we are spending less

thoughts and ideas we are spending less

thoughts and ideas we are spending less time problem-solving with humans and

time problem-solving with humans and

time problem-solving with humans and more times with machines and this

more times with machines and this

more times with machines and this machines are programmed to give us the

machines are programmed to give us the

machines are programmed to give us the exact same answer every single time we

exact same answer every single time we

exact same answer every single time we query it so this got me thinking can

query it so this got me thinking can

query it so this got me thinking can machines ever learn to be cognitively

machines ever learn to be cognitively

machines ever learn to be cognitively diverse can machines ever learn to give

diverse can machines ever learn to give

diverse can machines ever learn to give us different perspectives every single

us different perspectives every single

us different perspectives every single time we ask it the challenge and making

time we ask it the challenge and making

time we ask it the challenge and making such algorithms is that creative

such algorithms is that creative

such algorithms is that creative thinking is neither strictly logical nor

thinking is neither strictly logical nor

thinking is neither strictly logical nor is it entirely random our thinking is so

is it entirely random our thinking is so

is it entirely random our thinking is so ephemeral one moment we might look at

ephemeral one moment we might look at

ephemeral one moment we might look at something one way another moment

something one way another moment

something one way another moment completely differently it is as if we

completely differently it is as if we

completely differently it is as if we dynamically decomposed our thoughts fuse

dynamically decomposed our thoughts fuse

dynamically decomposed our thoughts fuse them embed new meanings and recreate new

them embed new meanings and recreate new

them embed new meanings and recreate new thoughts it is as if the units of

thoughts it is as if the units of

thoughts it is as if the units of thoughts are evanescent in nature and

thoughts are evanescent in nature and

thoughts are evanescent in nature and they serve the purpose of explaining the

they serve the purpose of explaining the

they serve the purpose of explaining the meaning only momentarily and then

meaning only momentarily and then

meaning only momentarily and then disappear and reappear to make new

disappear and reappear to make new

disappear and reappear to make new meanings this is because we do apply

meanings this is because we do apply

meanings this is because we do apply rules but we are constantly changing

rules but we are constantly changing

rules but we are constantly changing rules to form new interpretations and

rules to form new interpretations and

rules to form new interpretations and then form new rules again

then form new rules again

then form new rules again and making machines that can exhibit

and making machines that can exhibit

and making machines that can exhibit such kind of behavior is computationally

such kind of behavior is computationally

such kind of behavior is computationally challenging given the current frameworks

challenging given the current frameworks

challenging given the current frameworks with machine learning it’s required

with machine learning it’s required

with machine learning it’s required using a different paradigm a

using a different paradigm a

using a different paradigm a computational framework called shape

computational framework called shape

computational framework called shape grammar conceptualized by George Stinney

grammar conceptualized by George Stinney

grammar conceptualized by George Stinney a professor at MIT provided a way for me

a professor at MIT provided a way for me

a professor at MIT provided a way for me to address this challenge using shape

to address this challenge using shape

to address this challenge using shape grammars we can now build machines that

grammars we can now build machines that

grammars we can now build machines that can compute multiple perspectives

can compute multiple perspectives

can compute multiple perspectives consider an example of these three

consider an example of these three

consider an example of these three triangles if I ask people what do they

triangles if I ask people what do they

triangles if I ask people what do they see most will say three triangles some

see most will say three triangles some

see most will say three triangles some however would see two triangles some

however would see two triangles some

however would see two triangles some would see four triangles somebody like

would see four triangles somebody like

would see four triangles somebody like me would see nine lines and the

me would see nine lines and the

me would see nine lines and the possibilities are endless our human mind

possibilities are endless our human mind

possibilities are endless our human mind is capable of incorporating all these

is capable of incorporating all these

is capable of incorporating all these different answers machines on the other

different answers machines on the other

different answers machines on the other hand are programmed algorithmic ly to

hand are programmed algorithmic ly to

hand are programmed algorithmic ly to give the exact same answer three

give the exact same answer three

give the exact same answer three triangles but what if our frameworks

triangles but what if our frameworks

triangles but what if our frameworks were not so static and rigid shape

were not so static and rigid shape

were not so static and rigid shape grammars provides us with a framework to

grammars provides us with a framework to

grammars provides us with a framework to compute all these multiple possibilities

compute all these multiple possibilities

compute all these multiple possibilities this is because the machine computes

this is because the machine computes

this is because the machine computes with new set of rules and new components

with new set of rules and new components

with new set of rules and new components every single time the asker it can

every single time the asker it can

every single time the asker it can either have full partial or no memory of

either have full partial or no memory of

either have full partial or no memory of the previous state

the previous state

the previous state so in short using using shape grammars

so in short using using shape grammars

so in short using using shape grammars we can encompass all these indefinite

we can encompass all these indefinite

we can encompass all these indefinite possibilities and perspectives using a

possibilities and perspectives using a

possibilities and perspectives using a same simple mechanism but here is the

same simple mechanism but here is the

same simple mechanism but here is the incredible part this framework can be

incredible part this framework can be

incredible part this framework can be applied not just to compute with shapes

applied not just to compute with shapes

applied not just to compute with shapes and visual forms in my research I use

and visual forms in my research I use

and visual forms in my research I use the principles of shape grammar and

the principles of shape grammar and

the principles of shape grammar and applied it to creative thinking now

applied it to creative thinking now

applied it to creative thinking now imagine that instead of computing which

imagine that instead of computing which

imagine that instead of computing which shapes the machine is now computing with

shapes the machine is now computing with

shapes the machine is now computing with abstract thoughts and instead of making

abstract thoughts and instead of making

abstract thoughts and instead of making rules of placement of shapes the machine

rules of placement of shapes the machine

rules of placement of shapes the machine is now making rules of placement of

is now making rules of placement of

is now making rules of placement of abstract thoughts this meaningful

abstract thoughts this meaningful

abstract thoughts this meaningful arrangement of thoughts or spatial

arrangement of thoughts or spatial

arrangement of thoughts or spatial relations is nothing but ideas so if

relations is nothing but ideas so if

relations is nothing but ideas so if thoughts were shapes not

thoughts were shapes not

thoughts were shapes not literally and ideas were spatial

literally and ideas were spatial

literally and ideas were spatial relations then creative thinking can be

relations then creative thinking can be

relations then creative thinking can be computed using shape grammar using this

computed using shape grammar using this

computed using shape grammar using this framework we can now build parser

framework we can now build parser

framework we can now build parser machines that can break complex ideas

machines that can break complex ideas

machines that can break complex ideas into simpler thoughts we can build

into simpler thoughts we can build

into simpler thoughts we can build interpreter machines that can combine

interpreter machines that can combine

interpreter machines that can combine simpler thoughts and make complex ideas

simpler thoughts and make complex ideas

simpler thoughts and make complex ideas or we can make inference machines that

or we can make inference machines that

or we can make inference machines that can compute with multiple ideas and

can compute with multiple ideas and

can compute with multiple ideas and start connecting these thoughts and help

start connecting these thoughts and help

start connecting these thoughts and help us discover meanings which our human

us discover meanings which our human

us discover meanings which our human mind was incapable of discovering in

mind was incapable of discovering in

mind was incapable of discovering in short I’m saying we can build machines

short I’m saying we can build machines

short I’m saying we can build machines that can think might not think is

that can think might not think is

that can think might not think is logically written still think and if

logically written still think and if

logically written still think and if these machines can learn to share their

these machines can learn to share their

these machines can learn to share their rules of parsing with us they can become

rules of parsing with us they can become

rules of parsing with us they can become true creative partners instead of being

true creative partners instead of being

true creative partners instead of being passive interfaces they can now actively

passive interfaces they can now actively

passive interfaces they can now actively start interacting with us to augment our

start interacting with us to augment our

start interacting with us to augment our creative abilities my vision for the

creative abilities my vision for the

creative abilities my vision for the future of creativity is not where

future of creativity is not where

future of creativity is not where machines are more creative than us but

machines are more creative than us but

machines are more creative than us but one where machines inspire each one of

one where machines inspire each one of

one where machines inspire each one of us to be more diverse in our thinking

us to be more diverse in our thinking

us to be more diverse in our thinking more creative in our thinking with

more creative in our thinking with

more creative in our thinking with access to wast knowledge an incredible

access to wast knowledge an incredible

access to wast knowledge an incredible computing power machines can now provide

computing power machines can now provide

computing power machines can now provide us with different diverse perspectives

us with different diverse perspectives

us with different diverse perspectives as we bring in our diverse experiences

as we bring in our diverse experiences

as we bring in our diverse experiences to make the sense of the world so let us

to make the sense of the world so let us

to make the sense of the world so let us build machines that can help us step

build machines that can help us step

build machines that can help us step outside our own fixed ways of thinking

outside our own fixed ways of thinking

outside our own fixed ways of thinking so that we can understand the world not

so that we can understand the world not

so that we can understand the world not in one way or 13 ways but in definite

in one way or 13 ways but in definite

in one way or 13 ways but in definite ways because like Minsky said if we

ways because like Minsky said if we

ways because like Minsky said if we understood something one way then he

understood something one way then he

understood something one way then he would not have understood it at all

would not have understood it at all

would not have understood it at all thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *