Press "Enter" to skip to content

Can Citizen Science Save Us? | Mary Ellen Hannibal | TEDxStanford


[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Music]

[Music] so I am a citizen scientist and by the

so I am a citizen scientist and by the

so I am a citizen scientist and by the time I’m through with you today I hope

time I’m through with you today I hope

time I’m through with you today I hope that you will all find a way to become a

that you will all find a way to become a

that you will all find a way to become a citizen scientist and the way I’m going

citizen scientist and the way I’m going

citizen scientist and the way I’m going to try to get you there is to tell you

to try to get you there is to tell you

to try to get you there is to tell you about my own journey to becoming a

about my own journey to becoming a

about my own journey to becoming a citizen scientist so it started about 10

citizen scientist so it started about 10

citizen scientist so it started about 10 years ago I was researching a book that

years ago I was researching a book that

years ago I was researching a book that I was writing about evolution and to

I was writing about evolution and to

I was writing about evolution and to better understand how evolution works

better understand how evolution works

better understand how evolution works it’s actually pretty complicated when

it’s actually pretty complicated when

it’s actually pretty complicated when you really drill down into it I went

you really drill down into it I went

you really drill down into it I went over to the California Academy of

over to the California Academy of

over to the California Academy of Sciences in Golden Gate Park a lot of

Sciences in Golden Gate Park a lot of

Sciences in Golden Gate Park a lot of those scientists that work at the

those scientists that work at the

those scientists that work at the Academy are taxon amidst s’ so taxon

Academy are taxon amidst s’ so taxon

Academy are taxon amidst s’ so taxon amidst study speciation when a new

amidst study speciation when a new

amidst study speciation when a new life-form comes into being and they name

life-form comes into being and they name

life-form comes into being and they name it if they’re lucky they get to discover

it if they’re lucky they get to discover

it if they’re lucky they get to discover a new species they name it and they put

a new species they name it and they put

a new species they name it and they put it on this vast Tree of Life the vast

it on this vast Tree of Life the vast

it on this vast Tree of Life the vast tree of life we are all on so the moment

tree of life we are all on so the moment

tree of life we are all on so the moment when Homo sapiens became separate from

when Homo sapiens became separate from

when Homo sapiens became separate from our ape ancestors that earned our place

our ape ancestors that earned our place

our ape ancestors that earned our place on the Tree of Life now all life-forms

on the Tree of Life now all life-forms

on the Tree of Life now all life-forms have common ancestors so Earth Day

have common ancestors so Earth Day

have common ancestors so Earth Day should really be celebrated as a big

should really be celebrated as a big

should really be celebrated as a big family reunion taxonomy is an old

family reunion taxonomy is an old

family reunion taxonomy is an old profession typical kind of I’ve very

profession typical kind of I’ve very

profession typical kind of I’ve very ivory tower science very sure of its

ivory tower science very sure of its

ivory tower science very sure of its pathway and most of the scientists at

pathway and most of the scientists at

pathway and most of the scientists at the Academy especially ten years ago

the Academy especially ten years ago

the Academy especially ten years ago were old white guys very certain of the

were old white guys very certain of the

were old white guys very certain of the truth so imagine I’m talking to one and

truth so imagine I’m talking to one and

truth so imagine I’m talking to one and he’s a classic cut in the mold so

he’s a classic cut in the mold so

he’s a classic cut in the mold so taxonomist are also the ones they have

taxonomist are also the ones they have

taxonomist are also the ones they have the big trays of pinned butterflies

the big trays of pinned butterflies

the big trays of pinned butterflies pinned ants the Academy I think last

pinned ants the Academy I think last

pinned ants the Academy I think last time I checked had something like 25

time I checked had something like 25

time I checked had something like 25 million specimens that’s birds in

million specimens that’s birds in

million specimens that’s birds in drawers and fish in jars so this guy has

drawers and fish in jars so this guy has

drawers and fish in jars so this guy has eyebrows out to here he’s sitting behind

eyebrows out to here he’s sitting behind

eyebrows out to here he’s sitting behind his desk he’s got you know gigantic

his desk he’s got you know gigantic

his desk he’s got you know gigantic piles of books all around him and he’s

piles of books all around him and he’s

piles of books all around him and he’s emphatic and as he’s talking to me his

emphatic and as he’s talking to me his

emphatic and as he’s talking to me his his glasses come down off his face and

his glasses come down off his face and

his glasses come down off his face and skitter off of his desk and he says yes

skitter off of his desk and he says yes

skitter off of his desk and he says yes I will tell you how life-forms originate

I will tell you how life-forms originate

I will tell you how life-forms originate but let me first tell you how they are

but let me first tell you how they are

but let me first tell you how they are prematurely being terminated so it’s ten

prematurely being terminated so it’s ten

prematurely being terminated so it’s ten years later right now you’ve probably

years later right now you’ve probably

years later right now you’ve probably all heard this term sixth mass

all heard this term sixth mass

all heard this term sixth mass extinction but this is ten years ago and

extinction but this is ten years ago and

extinction but this is ten years ago and I had never heard that and he said we

I had never heard that and he said we

I had never heard that and he said we are today ten years ago and we are still

are today ten years ago and we are still

are today ten years ago and we are still in it we are experiencing the loss of

in it we are experiencing the loss of

in it we are experiencing the loss of species at a rate and magnitude that

species at a rate and magnitude that

species at a rate and magnitude that equals that which took out the dinosaurs

equals that which took out the dinosaurs

equals that which took out the dinosaurs this event is already discernible in the

this event is already discernible in the

this event is already discernible in the fossil record and in geological time

fossil record and in geological time

fossil record and in geological time that is happening like this and he

that is happening like this and he

that is happening like this and he starts to cry and I was taken aback you

starts to cry and I was taken aback you

starts to cry and I was taken aback you know I just was like oh this is not a

know I just was like oh this is not a

know I just was like oh this is not a touchy-feely guy this is not somebody

touchy-feely guy this is not somebody

touchy-feely guy this is not somebody who cries in an interview and I thought

who cries in an interview and I thought

who cries in an interview and I thought I felt sorry for him I thought maybe he

I felt sorry for him I thought maybe he

I felt sorry for him I thought maybe he was having trouble at home maybe his

was having trouble at home maybe his

was having trouble at home maybe his wife I was unhappy with him so I go to

wife I was unhappy with him so I go to

wife I was unhappy with him so I go to the next scientist who also wants to

the next scientist who also wants to

the next scientist who also wants to talk extinction and he wants to talk he

talk extinction and he wants to talk he

talk extinction and he wants to talk he wants to tell me that as he goes around

wants to tell me that as he goes around

wants to tell me that as he goes around the world and he’s lucky enough to study

the world and he’s lucky enough to study

the world and he’s lucky enough to study subjects in Africa in Asia and in the

subjects in Africa in Asia and in the

subjects in Africa in Asia and in the u.s. he goes back once a year to each of

u.s. he goes back once a year to each of

u.s. he goes back once a year to each of his study sites and he says I go back

his study sites and he says I go back

his study sites and he says I go back and they’re disappearing we’re did we

and they’re disappearing we’re did we

and they’re disappearing we’re did we were losing species before we even know

were losing species before we even know

were losing species before we even know they’re there because the habitats the

they’re there because the habitats the

they’re there because the habitats the wild places are being transformed for

wild places are being transformed for

wild places are being transformed for human use to agriculture to buildings to

human use to agriculture to buildings to

human use to agriculture to buildings to roadways it’s happening at such a pace

roadways it’s happening at such a pace

roadways it’s happening at such a pace that it’s driving this extinction and

that it’s driving this extinction and

that it’s driving this extinction and this is the major cause of extinction

this is the major cause of extinction

this is the major cause of extinction this extinction crisis is loss of

this extinction crisis is loss of

this extinction crisis is loss of habitat so this is the xerxes blue

habitat so this is the xerxes blue

habitat so this is the xerxes blue butterfly it’s the first invertebrate

butterfly it’s the first invertebrate

butterfly it’s the first invertebrate known to have gone extinct due to human

known to have gone extinct due to human

known to have gone extinct due to human impacts and that happened when Golden

impacts and that happened when Golden

impacts and that happened when Golden Gate Park was made when the coastal

Gate Park was made when the coastal

Gate Park was made when the coastal scrub dunes of the San Francisco

scrub dunes of the San Francisco

scrub dunes of the San Francisco Peninsula were transformed into a green

Peninsula were transformed into a green

Peninsula were transformed into a green leafy idea of a park

leafy idea of a park

leafy idea of a park the butterfly lost its habitat and went

the butterfly lost its habitat and went

the butterfly lost its habitat and went extinct this is an ivory-billed

extinct this is an ivory-billed

extinct this is an ivory-billed woodpecker these are two ivory-billed

woodpecker these are two ivory-billed

woodpecker these are two ivory-billed woodpeckers and that specimen at the

woodpeckers and that specimen at the

woodpeckers and that specimen at the academy which was on the exhibit floors

academy which was on the exhibit floors

academy which was on the exhibit floors is almost as tall as I am

is almost as tall as I am

is almost as tall as I am so those birds are huge and a rule of

so those birds are huge and a rule of

so those birds are huge and a rule of thumb is that the bigger an animal of

thumb is that the bigger an animal of

thumb is that the bigger an animal of species is the more habitat it needs so

species is the more habitat it needs so

species is the more habitat it needs so the ivory-billed woodpecker lived in the

the ivory-billed woodpecker lived in the

the ivory-billed woodpecker lived in the vast forests of the east coast and as

vast forests of the east coast and as

vast forests of the east coast and as that forest was fragmented by human

that forest was fragmented by human

that forest was fragmented by human impacts by buildings and roadways it

impacts by buildings and roadways it

impacts by buildings and roadways it lost enough habitat

lost enough habitat

lost enough habitat for itself that couldn’t survive in

for itself that couldn’t survive in

for itself that couldn’t survive in smaller spaces so it went extinct so

smaller spaces so it went extinct so

smaller spaces so it went extinct so this guy is telling me that and today

this guy is telling me that and today

this guy is telling me that and today even more than losing this number of

even more than losing this number of

even more than losing this number of species that are having their life

species that are having their life

species that are having their life histories terminated we’re also losing

histories terminated we’re also losing

histories terminated we’re also losing vast numbers of bodies of plants and

vast numbers of bodies of plants and

vast numbers of bodies of plants and animals so this is maybe species that

animals so this is maybe species that

animals so this is maybe species that are included in this are not exactly

are included in this are not exactly

are included in this are not exactly going extinct yet but the numbers of

going extinct yet but the numbers of

going extinct yet but the numbers of their bodies on the earth is vastly

their bodies on the earth is vastly

their bodies on the earth is vastly decreasing so this issue of science

decreasing so this issue of science

decreasing so this issue of science magazine is from 2014 you’ll see that

magazine is from 2014 you’ll see that

magazine is from 2014 you’ll see that the title of it is vanishing fauna and

the title of it is vanishing fauna and

the title of it is vanishing fauna and the main article the main scientific

the main article the main scientific

the main article the main scientific publication in this issue was the main

publication in this issue was the main

publication in this issue was the main author on that is a scientist here at

author on that is a scientist here at

author on that is a scientist here at Stanford Rodolfo deers oh and God bless

Stanford Rodolfo deers oh and God bless

Stanford Rodolfo deers oh and God bless him the title of the paper is D

him the title of the paper is D

him the title of the paper is D formations of planet Earth

formations of planet Earth

formations of planet Earth so deformation I think that’s an

so deformation I think that’s an

so deformation I think that’s an argument that scientists should not get

argument that scientists should not get

argument that scientists should not get to name anything like that sounds like

to name anything like that sounds like

to name anything like that sounds like something you get done at the salon and

something you get done at the salon and

something you get done at the salon and don’t talk about at the dinner table

don’t talk about at the dinner table

don’t talk about at the dinner table right in fact honestly I don’t know why

right in fact honestly I don’t know why

right in fact honestly I don’t know why we are talking about anything else so in

we are talking about anything else so in

we are talking about anything else so in the past 40 years we have 28 percent

the past 40 years we have 28 percent

the past 40 years we have 28 percent fewer vertebrates 35% fewer butterflies

fewer vertebrates 35% fewer butterflies

fewer vertebrates 35% fewer butterflies and moths and 1.5 billion fewer birds

and moths and 1.5 billion fewer birds

and moths and 1.5 billion fewer birds living on this earth and we did 40 years

living on this earth and we did 40 years

living on this earth and we did 40 years ago and this is not just from one study

ago and this is not just from one study

ago and this is not just from one study this is from a lot of studies so

this is from a lot of studies so

this is from a lot of studies so actually that’s also happening in your

actually that’s also happening in your

actually that’s also happening in your backyards it’s not just Africa it’s not

backyards it’s not just Africa it’s not

backyards it’s not just Africa it’s not just Asia it’s in our own backyards but

just Asia it’s in our own backyards but

just Asia it’s in our own backyards but it’s cryptic we don’t know exactly how

it’s cryptic we don’t know exactly how

it’s cryptic we don’t know exactly how it’s happening we can make these big

it’s happening we can make these big

it’s happening we can make these big assessments of a loss based on how much

assessments of a loss based on how much

assessments of a loss based on how much habitats gone and then there are ways

habitats gone and then there are ways

habitats gone and then there are ways that we’ve counted so what are we going

that we’ve counted so what are we going

that we’ve counted so what are we going to do about it he starts to cry the

to do about it he starts to cry the

to do about it he starts to cry the second scientist starts to cry and I’m

second scientist starts to cry and I’m

second scientist starts to cry and I’m thinking like this is crazy but now I’m

thinking like this is crazy but now I’m

thinking like this is crazy but now I’m really getting it right they’re all

really getting it right they’re all

really getting it right they’re all going to freaking cry on me so like the

going to freaking cry on me so like the

going to freaking cry on me so like the next guy I go to talk to I bring my

next guy I go to talk to I bring my

next guy I go to talk to I bring my tissues and when the third scientist

tissues and when the third scientist

tissues and when the third scientist cried I cried with him there’s no way to

cried I cried with him there’s no way to

cried I cried with him there’s no way to overstate this we have to face this

overstate this we have to face this

overstate this we have to face this but how so the second part of my journey

but how so the second part of my journey

but how so the second part of my journey to becoming a citizen scientist took me

to becoming a citizen scientist took me

to becoming a citizen scientist took me to the spine of the continent that’s

to the spine of the continent that’s

to the spine of the continent that’s this vast mega linkage of the Rockies

this vast mega linkage of the Rockies

this vast mega linkage of the Rockies from Alaska all the way down to Mexico

from Alaska all the way down to Mexico

from Alaska all the way down to Mexico by the way there’s still a lot of

by the way there’s still a lot of

by the way there’s still a lot of wildlife left there’s plenty to save and

wildlife left there’s plenty to save and

wildlife left there’s plenty to save and when you bring habitat back they come

when you bring habitat back they come

when you bring habitat back they come back when you build it they come so

back when you build it they come so

back when you build it they come so along the spine of the continent we

along the spine of the continent we

along the spine of the continent we still have grizzly bears and wolves in

still have grizzly bears and wolves in

still have grizzly bears and wolves in the north we still have Jaguar in the

the north we still have Jaguar in the

the north we still have Jaguar in the south and we’ve and sometimes people

south and we’ve and sometimes people

south and we’ve and sometimes people call this a biotic conveyor belt because

call this a biotic conveyor belt because

call this a biotic conveyor belt because so much wildlife lives along the spine

so much wildlife lives along the spine

so much wildlife lives along the spine of the continent and I found some

of the continent and I found some

of the continent and I found some stories that were real success stories

stories that were real success stories

stories that were real success stories along the spine of the continent not

along the spine of the continent not

along the spine of the continent not only animals and plants being saved but

only animals and plants being saved but

only animals and plants being saved but according to some models that could

according to some models that could

according to some models that could actually scale to the level of the

actually scale to the level of the

actually scale to the level of the problem so I’ll just tell you about this

problem so I’ll just tell you about this

problem so I’ll just tell you about this one which is the path of the pronghorn

one which is the path of the pronghorn

one which is the path of the pronghorn and the pronghorn antelope is an ancient

and the pronghorn antelope is an ancient

and the pronghorn antelope is an ancient species goes dates back to the

species goes dates back to the

species goes dates back to the Pleistocene today that pronghorn

Pleistocene today that pronghorn

Pleistocene today that pronghorn antelope is the second fastest land

antelope is the second fastest land

antelope is the second fastest land animal on the earth bested only by an

animal on the earth bested only by an

animal on the earth bested only by an African cheetah and it’s so fast because

African cheetah and it’s so fast because

African cheetah and it’s so fast because it evolved with an American cheetah that

it evolved with an American cheetah that

it evolved with an American cheetah that no longer exists and the pronghorn don’t

no longer exists and the pronghorn don’t

no longer exists and the pronghorn don’t have to keep running that fast but they

have to keep running that fast but they

have to keep running that fast but they do they’re a little OCD also so they

do they’re a little OCD also so they

do they’re a little OCD also so they come up to that fence you can see

come up to that fence you can see

come up to that fence you can see they’re like I’m going to try to go

they’re like I’m going to try to go

they’re like I’m going to try to go through it so there’s a single herd of

through it so there’s a single herd of

through it so there’s a single herd of antelope that makes a single migration

antelope that makes a single migration

antelope that makes a single migration in Wyoming they spend the summer in

in Wyoming they spend the summer in

in Wyoming they spend the summer in Jackson Hole who wouldn’t right and then

Jackson Hole who wouldn’t right and then

Jackson Hole who wouldn’t right and then they go south and there were some

they go south and there were some

they go south and there were some scientists studying this herd of

scientists studying this herd of

scientists studying this herd of antelope and noticing in the southern

antelope and noticing in the southern

antelope and noticing in the southern part of the range that they were there

part of the range that they were there

part of the range that they were there were carcasses of them all over the

were carcasses of them all over the

were carcasses of them all over the place

place

place and it didn’t take a rocket scientist to

and it didn’t take a rocket scientist to

and it didn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out the reason was that fracking

figure out the reason was that fracking

figure out the reason was that fracking had just been invented there so when you

had just been invented there so when you

had just been invented there so when you do something like fracking is invented

do something like fracking is invented

do something like fracking is invented somewhere immediately quickly hundreds

somewhere immediately quickly hundreds

somewhere immediately quickly hundreds and hundreds of wells are being dug

and hundreds of wells are being dug

and hundreds of wells are being dug human infrastructure comes in very fast

human infrastructure comes in very fast

human infrastructure comes in very fast I mean buildings go up to house workers

I mean buildings go up to house workers

I mean buildings go up to house workers and schools go up to educate their

and schools go up to educate their

and schools go up to educate their children we’re going to get that gas and

children we’re going to get that gas and

children we’re going to get that gas and we’re going to start shipping it out and

we’re going to start shipping it out and

we’re going to start shipping it out and we’re going to start making money so

we’re going to start making money so

we’re going to start making money so again this huge infrastructure and the

again this huge infrastructure and the

again this huge infrastructure and the pronghorn just plow right into it plow

pronghorn just plow right into it plow

pronghorn just plow right into it plow right into the semies right into the

right into the semies right into the

right into the semies right into the trains and they die so the scientists

trains and they die so the scientists

trains and they die so the scientists did a couple of

did a couple of

did a couple of things that today would be called

things that today would be called

things that today would be called citizen science and that are critical to

citizen science and that are critical to

citizen science and that are critical to what citizen science is so they convened

what citizen science is so they convened

what citizen science is so they convened people they didn’t just get other

people they didn’t just get other

people they didn’t just get other scientists to study this they didn’t

scientists to study this they didn’t

scientists to study this they didn’t just get politicians to support it

just get politicians to support it

just get politicians to support it they didn’t just connect with nonprofit

they didn’t just connect with nonprofit

they didn’t just connect with nonprofit activists they most importantly

activists they most importantly

activists they most importantly connected with regular people like you

connected with regular people like you

connected with regular people like you and I who live near or along the path of

and I who live near or along the path of

and I who live near or along the path of the pronghorn and they said you know

the pronghorn and they said you know

the pronghorn and they said you know they went door-to-door like we want to

they went door-to-door like we want to

they went door-to-door like we want to see if pronghorn go through your

see if pronghorn go through your

see if pronghorn go through your backyard and that person would say well

backyard and that person would say well

backyard and that person would say well you know once a year we see pronghorn in

you know once a year we see pronghorn in

you know once a year we see pronghorn in our front yard when we are on our way to

our front yard when we are on our way to

our front yard when we are on our way to work and then when we come home they’re

work and then when we come home they’re

work and then when we come home they’re gone but we didn’t know that we were on

gone but we didn’t know that we were on

gone but we didn’t know that we were on this pathway that what we’re not we’re

this pathway that what we’re not we’re

this pathway that what we’re not we’re seeing this one moment in time right but

seeing this one moment in time right but

seeing this one moment in time right but that moment in time is not only

that moment in time is not only

that moment in time is not only connected to that yearly migration that

connected to that yearly migration that

connected to that yearly migration that one moment in time is connected to a

one moment in time is connected to a

one moment in time is connected to a migration that has gone on for at least

migration that has gone on for at least

migration that has gone on for at least 6,000 years of course we want to protect

6,000 years of course we want to protect

6,000 years of course we want to protect the path of the pronghorn of course we

the path of the pronghorn of course we

the path of the pronghorn of course we want to be part of this beautiful

want to be part of this beautiful

want to be part of this beautiful historic life history of this animal the

historic life history of this animal the

historic life history of this animal the path of the pronghorn today has

path of the pronghorn today has

path of the pronghorn today has protection it’s the only animal movement

protection it’s the only animal movement

protection it’s the only animal movement that has protection in the lower 48 and

that has protection in the lower 48 and

that has protection in the lower 48 and we have to do that a lot more now here

we have to do that a lot more now here

we have to do that a lot more now here we have a tool for doing it a lot more

we have a tool for doing it a lot more

we have a tool for doing it a lot more this is a screenshot from my naturalist

this is a screenshot from my naturalist

this is a screenshot from my naturalist this is one of my favorite citizen

this is one of my favorite citizen

this is one of my favorite citizen science platforms you can it’s free you

science platforms you can it’s free you

science platforms you can it’s free you put it on your phone I suggest you all

put it on your phone I suggest you all

put it on your phone I suggest you all get onto I naturalist today it’s easier

get onto I naturalist today it’s easier

get onto I naturalist today it’s easier to do it on a desktop or a laptop and

to do it on a desktop or a laptop and

to do it on a desktop or a laptop and then to put it on your phone as the app

then to put it on your phone as the app

then to put it on your phone as the app so all of those blue dots represent

so all of those blue dots represent

so all of those blue dots represent people seeing pronghorn antelope taking

people seeing pronghorn antelope taking

people seeing pronghorn antelope taking a photograph of what they see the app

a photograph of what they see the app

a photograph of what they see the app assigns the photographic observation the

assigns the photographic observation the

assigns the photographic observation the date the time the latitude and the

date the time the latitude and the

date the time the latitude and the longitude of the photograph so you’ll

longitude of the photograph so you’ll

longitude of the photograph so you’ll hear people tell you citizens can’t take

hear people tell you citizens can’t take

hear people tell you citizens can’t take data the same way that professionals can

data the same way that professionals can

data the same way that professionals can well first of all there’s a lot of

well first of all there’s a lot of

well first of all there’s a lot of studies that show the opposite in many

studies that show the opposite in many

studies that show the opposite in many cases citizens are better at it but in

cases citizens are better at it but in

cases citizens are better at it but in any case with I naturalist all that’s

any case with I naturalist all that’s

any case with I naturalist all that’s out of there because it’s GPS it’s the

out of there because it’s GPS it’s the

out of there because it’s GPS it’s the atomic clock it’s date time latitude

atomic clock it’s date time latitude

atomic clock it’s date time latitude longitude it is that that observation in

longitude it is that that observation in

longitude it is that that observation in time there’s lots of different ways to

time there’s lots of different ways to

time there’s lots of different ways to get involved with citizen science if you

get involved with citizen science if you

get involved with citizen science if you don’t want to do it technologically

don’t want to do it technologically

don’t want to do it technologically there’s lots of other ways to do it the

there’s lots of other ways to do it the

there’s lots of other ways to do it the important thing is I want you to know

important thing is I want you to know

important thing is I want you to know that we need to save nature and that we

that we need to save nature and that we

that we need to save nature and that we it’s a mob sourced thing

it’s a mob sourced thing

it’s a mob sourced thing the only way to do it what we want to do

the only way to do it what we want to do

the only way to do it what we want to do with something like I naturalist is

with something like I naturalist is

with something like I naturalist is create this big biodiversity observation

create this big biodiversity observation

create this big biodiversity observation network there’s an instrument for that

network there’s an instrument for that

network there’s an instrument for that it’s our eyes as we do it together when

it’s our eyes as we do it together when

it’s our eyes as we do it together when we get this we get data for all these

we get this we get data for all these

we get this we get data for all these kinds of species that you can see on I

kinds of species that you can see on I

kinds of species that you can see on I naturalist and things like uber dat

naturalist and things like uber dat

naturalist and things like uber dat nature’s notebook you can see these

nature’s notebook you can see these

nature’s notebook you can see these patterns of how life is unfolding get

patterns of how life is unfolding get

patterns of how life is unfolding get predictions of where extinctions are

predictions of where extinctions are

predictions of where extinctions are happening and then make surgical strikes

happening and then make surgical strikes

happening and then make surgical strikes like protections like the path of the

like protections like the path of the

like protections like the path of the pronghorn to help those animals and

pronghorn to help those animals and

pronghorn to help those animals and plants now I will tell you one more

plants now I will tell you one more

plants now I will tell you one more story about citizen science it is not

story about citizen science it is not

story about citizen science it is not just about collecting data citizen

just about collecting data citizen

just about collecting data citizen science is also a practice a practice

science is also a practice a practice

science is also a practice a practice that can help us do something that is

that can help us do something that is

that can help us do something that is very important which is to get in better

very important which is to get in better

very important which is to get in better healthier alignment with our own place

healthier alignment with our own place

healthier alignment with our own place in the cycle of life about five years

in the cycle of life about five years

in the cycle of life about five years ago I took my father up to Hawk Hill in

ago I took my father up to Hawk Hill in

ago I took my father up to Hawk Hill in Sausalito where I participate in a hawk

Sausalito where I participate in a hawk

Sausalito where I participate in a hawk watch this is a 20 picture from 2012 at

watch this is a 20 picture from 2012 at

watch this is a 20 picture from 2012 at where we had this huge surge a

where we had this huge surge a

where we had this huge surge a broad-winged hawk so those are all

broad-winged hawk so those are all

broad-winged hawk so those are all broad-winged Hawks in that photograph

broad-winged Hawks in that photograph

broad-winged Hawks in that photograph and it’s at this pattern that’s an

and it’s at this pattern that’s an

and it’s at this pattern that’s an anomalous year has actually been

anomalous year has actually been

anomalous year has actually been associated with a greater a quicker

associated with a greater a quicker

associated with a greater a quicker melting of sea-level ice which changed

melting of sea-level ice which changed

melting of sea-level ice which changed the currents the air currents that the

the currents the air currents that the

the currents the air currents that the birds fly on and actually brought birds

birds fly on and actually brought birds

birds fly on and actually brought birds from the east coast to the west coast so

from the east coast to the west coast so

from the east coast to the west coast so this is where you start to see that you

this is where you start to see that you

this is where you start to see that you see a pattern from the citizen science

see a pattern from the citizen science

see a pattern from the citizen science data that scientists can use to

data that scientists can use to

data that scientists can use to correlate with other things going on to

correlate with other things going on to

correlate with other things going on to figure out what’s happening so my father

figure out what’s happening so my father

figure out what’s happening so my father says to me this is what you do you are

says to me this is what you do you are

says to me this is what you do you are looking through your binoculars up at

looking through your binoculars up at

looking through your binoculars up at the sky and you are watching one

the sky and you are watching one

the sky and you are watching one instance of life go from one point to

instance of life go from one point to

instance of life go from one point to another because the birds seem to come

another because the birds seem to come

another because the birds seem to come out of nowhere and then they fly across

out of nowhere and then they fly across

out of nowhere and then they fly across and we watch them this is a northern

and we watch them this is a northern

and we watch them this is a northern Harrier and I said yes that’s what we do

Harrier and I said yes that’s what we do

Harrier and I said yes that’s what we do we watch one instance of life and we

we watch one instance of life and we

we watch one instance of life and we take note of it

take note of it

take note of it he said that’s spiritual so I knew what

he said that’s spiritual so I knew what

he said that’s spiritual so I knew what he meant because really the wisdom

he meant because really the wisdom

he meant because really the wisdom traditions I’ll ask us if you want to

traditions I’ll ask us if you want to

traditions I’ll ask us if you want to deepen your experience of life the first

deepen your experience of life the first

deepen your experience of life the first thing to do is to start observing

thing to do is to start observing

thing to do is to start observing observe your own breath observe your own

observe your own breath observe your own

observe your own breath observe your own thoughts going by why wouldn’t we

thoughts going by why wouldn’t we

thoughts going by why wouldn’t we actually add this to our spiritual

actually add this to our spiritual

actually add this to our spiritual practice to actually keep biodiversity

practice to actually keep biodiversity

practice to actually keep biodiversity going so two years ago my father died he

going so two years ago my father died he

going so two years ago my father died he died of lung cancer and as he

died of lung cancer and as he

died of lung cancer and as he was dying I was sitting by his bedside

was dying I was sitting by his bedside

was dying I was sitting by his bedside watching him and he was watching me and

watching him and he was watching me and

watching him and he was watching me and I realized I am watching an instance of

I realized I am watching an instance of

I realized I am watching an instance of life go from here to who-knows-where

life go from here to who-knows-where

life go from here to who-knows-where so then in the subsequent years after

so then in the subsequent years after

so then in the subsequent years after his death of course I’ve thought about

his death of course I’ve thought about

his death of course I’ve thought about him up there on Hawk Hill now the Hawks

him up there on Hawk Hill now the Hawks

him up there on Hawk Hill now the Hawks that we see on the West Coast are almost

that we see on the West Coast are almost

that we see on the West Coast are almost all juvenile hawks their fledgling year

all juvenile hawks their fledgling year

all juvenile hawks their fledgling year Hawks nobody knows why because on the

Hawks nobody knows why because on the

Hawks nobody knows why because on the East Coast the Hawks they see and

East Coast the Hawks they see and

East Coast the Hawks they see and they’re Hawk migration are mostly adults

they’re Hawk migration are mostly adults

they’re Hawk migration are mostly adults they’re mostly two-year-old birds are

they’re mostly two-year-old birds are

they’re mostly two-year-old birds are older it is thought that perhaps the

older it is thought that perhaps the

older it is thought that perhaps the passage over the Golden Gate Way is

passage over the Golden Gate Way is

passage over the Golden Gate Way is harrowing for the Hawks and that they

harrowing for the Hawks and that they

harrowing for the Hawks and that they learn a better way south when they’re

learn a better way south when they’re

learn a better way south when they’re older so I’m watching these juvenile

older so I’m watching these juvenile

older so I’m watching these juvenile hawks and I’m thinking the reason this

hawks and I’m thinking the reason this

hawks and I’m thinking the reason this generation is here is because of

generation is here is because of

generation is here is because of thousands of years of generations that

thousands of years of generations that

thousands of years of generations that have gone before that have brought these

have gone before that have brought these

have gone before that have brought these Hawks here you know it’s fine my father

Hawks here you know it’s fine my father

Hawks here you know it’s fine my father was old enough to die it was in the

was old enough to die it was in the

was old enough to die it was in the natural order of things but I think

natural order of things but I think

natural order of things but I think about my children right their fledgling

about my children right their fledgling

about my children right their fledgling my daughter is about to graduate from

my daughter is about to graduate from

my daughter is about to graduate from college this year she’s about to go on

college this year she’s about to go on

college this year she’s about to go on her first migration into the world what

her first migration into the world what

her first migration into the world what kind of world are we sending the next

kind of world are we sending the next

kind of world are we sending the next generation into Darwin called life that

generation into Darwin called life that

generation into Darwin called life that vast tree of life endless forms most

vast tree of life endless forms most

vast tree of life endless forms most beautiful this is the story we can tell

beautiful this is the story we can tell

beautiful this is the story we can tell only together using citizen science

only together using citizen science

only together using citizen science thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *