Press "Enter" to skip to content

Beautiful Babies Need No Design | Maria Sole Franceschi | TEDxYouth@ISF


I can’t wait to have a baby now I know

I can’t wait to have a baby now I know we’re all thinking she’s just a kid but

we’re all thinking she’s just a kid but

we’re all thinking she’s just a kid but I’ve got it all figured out

I’ve got it all figured out

I’ve got it all figured out first I’ll attend my dream college then

first I’ll attend my dream college then

first I’ll attend my dream college then start my dream job

start my dream job

start my dream job of course marry my dream husband and

of course marry my dream husband and

of course marry my dream husband and together we’ll design our dream baby

together we’ll design our dream baby

together we’ll design our dream baby I’ve always wanted a baby with blue eyes

I’ve always wanted a baby with blue eyes

I’ve always wanted a baby with blue eyes and dark hair maybe a little bit of a

and dark hair maybe a little bit of a

and dark hair maybe a little bit of a stigmatism because babies with glasses

stigmatism because babies with glasses

stigmatism because babies with glasses are cute really

are cute really

are cute really by the time I’m gonna be able to have

by the time I’m gonna be able to have

by the time I’m gonna be able to have children I’m gonna be able to decide the

children I’m gonna be able to decide the

children I’m gonna be able to decide the height the intelligence and any desired

height the intelligence and any desired

height the intelligence and any desired trait this sounds like a dream doesn’t

trait this sounds like a dream doesn’t

trait this sounds like a dream doesn’t it being able to design your perfect

it being able to design your perfect

it being able to design your perfect child actually being able to design

child actually being able to design

child actually being able to design generations and generations but who is

generations and generations but who is

generations and generations but who is giving consent to this

giving consent to this

giving consent to this certainly not the unborn baby I mean who

certainly not the unborn baby I mean who

certainly not the unborn baby I mean who are we to alter millions of years of

are we to alter millions of years of

are we to alter millions of years of evolution just for a baby with blue eyes

evolution just for a baby with blue eyes

evolution just for a baby with blue eyes a high IQ end world-class speed we have

a high IQ end world-class speed we have

a high IQ end world-class speed we have the technology to play God to mess with

the technology to play God to mess with

the technology to play God to mess with nature

nature

nature it’s called CRISPR put a funny name with

it’s called CRISPR put a funny name with

it’s called CRISPR put a funny name with CRISPR we can cut out undesired parts of

CRISPR we can cut out undesired parts of

CRISPR we can cut out undesired parts of DNA and replace them with arbitrarily

DNA and replace them with arbitrarily

DNA and replace them with arbitrarily generated desirable traits does it still

generated desirable traits does it still

generated desirable traits does it still sound like a dream picture this in 15

sound like a dream picture this in 15

sound like a dream picture this in 15 years you and your partner have a normal

years you and your partner have a normal

years you and your partner have a normal child which means that she’s not

child which means that she’s not

child which means that she’s not genetically modified let’s say her name

genetically modified let’s say her name

genetically modified let’s say her name is Maya your neighbors on the other hand

is Maya your neighbors on the other hand

is Maya your neighbors on the other hand decided to go down a different path and

decided to go down a different path and

decided to go down a different path and named their genetically modified

named their genetically modified

named their genetically modified daughter Emma now emma is smarter

daughter Emma now emma is smarter

daughter Emma now emma is smarter prettier more talented and

prettier more talented and

prettier more talented and scientifically proven to be better than

scientifically proven to be better than

scientifically proven to be better than your child she’s the perfect child

your child she’s the perfect child

your child she’s the perfect child perfectly designed but there has always

perfectly designed but there has always

perfectly designed but there has always been something off about her she has to

been something off about her she has to

been something off about her she has to go to a different school

go to a different school

go to a different school lead a different life life which is very

lead a different life life which is very

lead a different life life which is very different from that of your child I mean

different from that of your child I mean

different from that of your child I mean after all she’s a designer baby

after all she’s a designer baby

after all she’s a designer baby perhaps a trophy child Emma lives just

perhaps a trophy child Emma lives just

perhaps a trophy child Emma lives just next door and somehow you know that she

next door and somehow you know that she

next door and somehow you know that she never gets sick she never gets hurt or

never gets sick she never gets hurt or

never gets sick she never gets hurt or trips lately she’s definitely an asset

trips lately she’s definitely an asset

trips lately she’s definitely an asset to the government who will most likely

to the government who will most likely

to the government who will most likely never have to spend large sums of money

never have to spend large sums of money

never have to spend large sums of money for her health care

for her health care

for her health care well then maybe even the government

well then maybe even the government

well then maybe even the government might start to promote the production of

might start to promote the production of

might start to promote the production of designer babies and your little Maya

designer babies and your little Maya

designer babies and your little Maya will find herself alone filled in a

will find herself alone filled in a

will find herself alone filled in a world with perfect humans it wouldn’t be

world with perfect humans it wouldn’t be

world with perfect humans it wouldn’t be the first time that the government

the first time that the government

the first time that the government controlled or tried to control child

controlled or tried to control child

controlled or tried to control child birth whether the number the mental or

birth whether the number the mental or

birth whether the number the mental or the physical qualities of the offspring

the physical qualities of the offspring

the physical qualities of the offspring a modern example could be China’s

a modern example could be China’s

a modern example could be China’s one-child policy but I think that the

one-child policy but I think that the

one-child policy but I think that the most frightening example of eugenics was

most frightening example of eugenics was

most frightening example of eugenics was during the Nazi period Hitler wanted a

during the Nazi period Hitler wanted a

during the Nazi period Hitler wanted a superior race the Aryan race he went

superior race the Aryan race he went

superior race the Aryan race he went through great lengths to achieve this

through great lengths to achieve this

through great lengths to achieve this firstly by concentration camps and then

firstly by concentration camps and then

firstly by concentration camps and then by sterilizing for executing individuals

by sterilizing for executing individuals

by sterilizing for executing individuals which he judged to be handicapped or

which he judged to be handicapped or

which he judged to be handicapped or credence is this the world that you want

credence is this the world that you want

credence is this the world that you want your children to inherit is this what

your children to inherit is this what

your children to inherit is this what you want our race to become oh and Maya

you want our race to become oh and Maya

you want our race to become oh and Maya you’ll love her just as much with her

you’ll love her just as much with her

you’ll love her just as much with her messy hair slightly asymmetrical nose

messy hair slightly asymmetrical nose

messy hair slightly asymmetrical nose and that little cough which never seems

and that little cough which never seems

and that little cough which never seems to go away but maybe just maybe you

to go away but maybe just maybe you

to go away but maybe just maybe you won’t be able to stop yourself from

won’t be able to stop yourself from

won’t be able to stop yourself from comparing her to her friend Emma and

comparing her to her friend Emma and

comparing her to her friend Emma and trust me when I say that you won’t be

trust me when I say that you won’t be

trust me when I say that you won’t be the only one so will colleges employers

the only one so will colleges employers

the only one so will colleges employers potential mates and what if one day she

potential mates and what if one day she

potential mates and what if one day she comes back crying asking why am I not

comes back crying asking why am I not

comes back crying asking why am I not like Emma all you know is that society

like Emma all you know is that society

like Emma all you know is that society has changed between your child and Emma

has changed between your child and Emma

has changed between your child and Emma there’s an abyss a superior race has

there’s an abyss a superior race has

there’s an abyss a superior race has been born and your child does not belong

been born and your child does not belong

been born and your child does not belong to it it’s time to ask ourselves really

to it it’s time to ask ourselves really

to it it’s time to ask ourselves really important questions like who are we what

important questions like who are we what

important questions like who are we what will be become and who will decide IVF

will be become and who will decide IVF

will be become and who will decide IVF is a modern example of designer Bay

is a modern example of designer Bay

is a modern example of designer Bay selective breeding which is a type of

selective breeding which is a type of

selective breeding which is a type of baby designing has been around for

baby designing has been around for

baby designing has been around for thousands of years IVF is already an

thousands of years IVF is already an

thousands of years IVF is already an accepted way of reproducing for

accepted way of reproducing for

accepted way of reproducing for infertile parents or those who run the

infertile parents or those who run the

infertile parents or those who run the risk of passing on dangerous genetic

risk of passing on dangerous genetic

risk of passing on dangerous genetic diseases in other words it’s already a

diseases in other words it’s already a

diseases in other words it’s already a method of bypassing natural evolution

method of bypassing natural evolution

method of bypassing natural evolution now imagine being a parent who decided

now imagine being a parent who decided

now imagine being a parent who decided to reproduce using IVF and the doctor

to reproduce using IVF and the doctor

to reproduce using IVF and the doctor mentions that for an extra $1,000 he can

mentions that for an extra $1,000 he can

mentions that for an extra $1,000 he can eliminate the risk for your child of

eliminate the risk for your child of

eliminate the risk for your child of ever getting Alzheimer’s now I’m pretty

ever getting Alzheimer’s now I’m pretty

ever getting Alzheimer’s now I’m pretty sure that each and every one of you

sure that each and every one of you

sure that each and every one of you would accept his offer because as a

would accept his offer because as a

would accept his offer because as a parent everyone wants the best for his

parent everyone wants the best for his

parent everyone wants the best for his or her child whether the best job best

or her child whether the best job best

or her child whether the best job best education or the best genetic trait

education or the best genetic trait

education or the best genetic trait parents are already influencing their

parents are already influencing their

parents are already influencing their child’s life so much by imposing a

child’s life so much by imposing a

child’s life so much by imposing a religion and education sometimes even a

religion and education sometimes even a

religion and education sometimes even a hobby so why not give them the best

hobby so why not give them the best

hobby so why not give them the best traits they need to thrive in the

traits they need to thrive in the

traits they need to thrive in the society they live in in other words a

society they live in in other words a

society they live in in other words a virtual guarantee of success

virtual guarantee of success

virtual guarantee of success now this reality seems far away almost

now this reality seems far away almost

now this reality seems far away almost as if it was a post-apocalyptic movie

as if it was a post-apocalyptic movie

as if it was a post-apocalyptic movie but but it’s actually closer than what

but but it’s actually closer than what

but but it’s actually closer than what you might imagine experimenters in China

you might imagine experimenters in China

you might imagine experimenters in China have already tested this technology on

have already tested this technology on

have already tested this technology on human embryos now I do not go too well

human embryos now I do not go too well

human embryos now I do not go too well but these are only the early stages of

but these are only the early stages of

but these are only the early stages of the trial the good news is that we have

the trial the good news is that we have

the trial the good news is that we have an excuse to avoid the production of

an excuse to avoid the production of

an excuse to avoid the production of designer babies they are simply too

designer babies they are simply too

designer babies they are simply too dangerous but what about when this is

dangerous but what about when this is

dangerous but what about when this is not an excuse anymore the first child

not an excuse anymore the first child

not an excuse anymore the first child born from IVF came to light a little

born from IVF came to light a little

born from IVF came to light a little over 40 years ago and since then 5

over 40 years ago and since then 5

over 40 years ago and since then 5 million children have been born through

million children have been born through

million children have been born through that technology 5 million and 4 decades

that technology 5 million and 4 decades

that technology 5 million and 4 decades that’s a lot now a tire like Emma may

that’s a lot now a tire like Emma may

that’s a lot now a tire like Emma may not be too far away and the choices

not be too far away and the choices

not be too far away and the choices scientists make will define and maybe

scientists make will define and maybe

scientists make will define and maybe tear apart society as we know it but

tear apart society as we know it but

tear apart society as we know it but then again where do you draw the line

then again where do you draw the line

then again where do you draw the line the

the

the between saving a life and creating a

between saving a life and creating a

between saving a life and creating a trophy child and most importantly who

trophy child and most importantly who

trophy child and most importantly who will draw that line think about your own

will draw that line think about your own

will draw that line think about your own children for a second is there anything

children for a second is there anything

children for a second is there anything you would change about us except that

you would change about us except that

you would change about us except that we’re always asking you for money and if

we’re always asking you for money and if

we’re always asking you for money and if that answer is yes do you still want a

that answer is yes do you still want a

that answer is yes do you still want a perfect child now about the baby I can

perfect child now about the baby I can

perfect child now about the baby I can wait thank you

wait thank you

wait thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *