Press "Enter" to skip to content

Astrophysics or the interplay of scales | Marta Reina-Campos | TEDxUniHeidelberg


it is a lark winter night and the city

it is a lark winter night and the city is getting ready to go to sleep in a big

is getting ready to go to sleep in a big

is getting ready to go to sleep in a big apartment building a kitchen window is

apartment building a kitchen window is

apartment building a kitchen window is lit on the other side a young woman and

lit on the other side a young woman and

lit on the other side a young woman and her daughter are looking into the

her daughter are looking into the

her daughter are looking into the darkness and pointing at the Stars

darkness and pointing at the Stars

darkness and pointing at the Stars the woman is telling stories feeding the

the woman is telling stories feeding the

the woman is telling stories feeding the growing curiosity of her daughter but

growing curiosity of her daughter but

growing curiosity of her daughter but questions keep coming if I had to look

questions keep coming if I had to look

questions keep coming if I had to look back that would be the first time I

back that would be the first time I

back that would be the first time I recall looking up at the sky we all

recall looking up at the sky we all

recall looking up at the sky we all share similar memories stargazing nights

share similar memories stargazing nights

share similar memories stargazing nights with family or friends

with family or friends

with family or friends hoping to see a shooting star to make a

hoping to see a shooting star to make a

hoping to see a shooting star to make a wish and I wonder how many of you tried

wish and I wonder how many of you tried

wish and I wonder how many of you tried to count stars how many of you felt

to count stars how many of you felt

to count stars how many of you felt intimidated by the size of the universe

intimidated by the size of the universe

intimidated by the size of the universe and how many of you have fallen asleep

and how many of you have fallen asleep

and how many of you have fallen asleep while stargazing over time I managed to

while stargazing over time I managed to

while stargazing over time I managed to answer some of the questions that

answer some of the questions that

answer some of the questions that intrigued me back then but I’m still

intrigued me back then but I’m still

intrigued me back then but I’m still working on others this is a bit

working on others this is a bit

working on others this is a bit embarrassing but up until I was four or

embarrassing but up until I was four or

embarrassing but up until I was four or five I was convinced at the sky with the

five I was convinced at the sky with the

five I was convinced at the sky with the Sun during the day and the moon and the

Sun during the day and the moon and the

Sun during the day and the moon and the stars during the night were just theater

stars during the night were just theater

stars during the night were just theater curtains that someone was in charge of

curtains that someone was in charge of

curtains that someone was in charge of changing I was not sad though when I

changing I was not sad though when I

changing I was not sad though when I learned the truth because it opened me

learned the truth because it opened me

learned the truth because it opened me the door to all of possibilities

the door to all of possibilities

the door to all of possibilities according to the oxford dictionary

according to the oxford dictionary

according to the oxford dictionary astronomy is the scientist Sally’s

astronomy is the scientist Sally’s

astronomy is the scientist Sally’s celestial objects the space and the

celestial objects the space and the

celestial objects the space and the universe as a whole is that clear

universe as a whole is that clear

universe as a whole is that clear perhaps not much what do we understand a

perhaps not much what do we understand a

perhaps not much what do we understand a celestial objects the definition can be

celestial objects the definition can be

celestial objects the definition can be used all the way from meteorites which

used all the way from meteorites which

used all the way from meteorites which can be as small as a grain of Sun up to

can be as small as a grain of Sun up to

can be as small as a grain of Sun up to planets or stars or even whole galaxies

planets or stars or even whole galaxies

planets or stars or even whole galaxies so pretty much everything that lies

so pretty much everything that lies

so pretty much everything that lies beyond our atmosphere

beyond our atmosphere

beyond our atmosphere nowadays we the astronomers prefer to be

nowadays we the astronomers prefer to be

nowadays we the astronomers prefer to be called astrophysicists in order to

called astrophysicists in order to

called astrophysicists in order to respect the professional feel of the

respect the professional feel of the

respect the professional feel of the astrologist trust me

astrologist trust me

astrologist trust me I’ve lost count of the number of times

I’ve lost count of the number of times

I’ve lost count of the number of times that I’ve been asked to read a hand or

that I’ve been asked to read a hand or

that I’ve been asked to read a hand or to do a horoscope

to do a horoscope

to do a horoscope yes we study the Stars no we don’t

yes we study the Stars no we don’t

yes we study the Stars no we don’t predict people’s fortunes and what does

predict people’s fortunes and what does

predict people’s fortunes and what does astronomy have in particular that has

astronomy have in particular that has

astronomy have in particular that has made us wonder for generations questions

made us wonder for generations questions

made us wonder for generations questions about where we come from or whether we

about where we come from or whether we

about where we come from or whether we are alone in the universe have filled

are alone in the universe have filled

are alone in the universe have filled our imaginations for centuries producing

our imaginations for centuries producing

our imaginations for centuries producing cultures rich in myth but that’s not

cultures rich in myth but that’s not

cultures rich in myth but that’s not what Falls mine don’t get me wrong we

what Falls mine don’t get me wrong we

what Falls mine don’t get me wrong we all like a bit of alien debate over a

all like a bit of alien debate over a

all like a bit of alien debate over a veer from time to time but that’s not my

veer from time to time but that’s not my

veer from time to time but that’s not my thing

thing

thing what makes me wonder are the scales or

what makes me wonder are the scales or

what makes me wonder are the scales or the sizes I remember a visit I did to

the sizes I remember a visit I did to

the sizes I remember a visit I did to the Sequoia National Park a couple of

the Sequoia National Park a couple of

the Sequoia National Park a couple of years ago I was walking through the

years ago I was walking through the

years ago I was walking through the forest and I saw the sign that said how

forest and I saw the sign that said how

forest and I saw the sign that said how big is big and I was extending next to

big is big and I was extending next to

big is big and I was extending next to the sign which was already taller than

the sign which was already taller than

the sign which was already taller than me next to one of those immense sequoias

me next to one of those immense sequoias

me next to one of those immense sequoias and it made me feel small and

and it made me feel small and

and it made me feel small and insignificant and I had the same feeling

insignificant and I had the same feeling

insignificant and I had the same feeling in astronomy the time over which

in astronomy the time over which

in astronomy the time over which processes happened the masses of the

processes happened the masses of the

processes happened the masses of the objects and the distances between them

objects and the distances between them

objects and the distances between them there are all in normal skills and

there are all in normal skills and

there are all in normal skills and they’re almost impossible to imagine I

they’re almost impossible to imagine I

they’re almost impossible to imagine I know you’ve heard comparisons to

know you’ve heard comparisons to

know you’ve heard comparisons to thousands of millions of stadiums but I

thousands of millions of stadiums but I

thousands of millions of stadiums but I know that doing those comparisons with

know that doing those comparisons with

know that doing those comparisons with everyday objects does not help to better

everyday objects does not help to better

everyday objects does not help to better understand the concepts so the question

understand the concepts so the question

understand the concepts so the question is how big is weak even in astronomy

is how big is weak even in astronomy

is how big is weak even in astronomy that is a tough question what we call a

that is a tough question what we call a

that is a tough question what we call a small and large will depend on our fill

small and large will depend on our fill

small and large will depend on our fill of a study if you are someone that is

of a study if you are someone that is

of a study if you are someone that is working with planets they will tell you

working with planets they will tell you

working with planets they will tell you that a star is quite large but if you

that a star is quite large but if you

that a star is quite large but if you are someone that is working with the

are someone that is working with the

are someone that is working with the structure of the universe they will tell

structure of the universe they will tell

structure of the universe they will tell you the rest are is like me next to the

you the rest are is like me next to the

you the rest are is like me next to the Sequoia just insignificant but it is not

Sequoia just insignificant but it is not

Sequoia just insignificant but it is not all about the size or so they say

all about the size or so they say

all about the size or so they say what really makes me wonder is the

what really makes me wonder is the

what really makes me wonder is the interplay between those scales how the

interplay between those scales how the

interplay between those scales how the large scales determine what the small

large scales determine what the small

large scales determine what the small ones can do how the small scale

ones can do how the small scale

ones can do how the small scale processes work together to shape the big

processes work together to shape the big

processes work together to shape the big picture here is an image of the

picture here is an image of the

picture here is an image of the Andromeda galaxy also known as an 31

Andromeda galaxy also known as an 31

Andromeda galaxy also known as an 31 among the galaxies that surround us this

among the galaxies that surround us this

among the galaxies that surround us this is a brightest one to the extent that it

is a brightest one to the extent that it

is a brightest one to the extent that it can be seen with a clear with your naked

can be seen with a clear with your naked

can be seen with a clear with your naked eye on a clear night do you see it’s

eye on a clear night do you see it’s

eye on a clear night do you see it’s this cloud shape by developing an

this cloud shape by developing an

this cloud shape by developing an observational II testing theories of

observational II testing theories of

observational II testing theories of galaxy formation we have learned that

galaxy formation we have learned that

galaxy formation we have learned that galaxies form from the contraction of a

galaxies form from the contraction of a

galaxies form from the contraction of a big halo of gas and the only reason why

big halo of gas and the only reason why

big halo of gas and the only reason why this gas can collapse is because it can

this gas can collapse is because it can

this gas can collapse is because it can lose energy thanks to the interactions

lose energy thanks to the interactions

lose energy thanks to the interactions among the atomic on the atomic level so

among the atomic on the atomic level so

among the atomic on the atomic level so it is those interactions among the atoms

it is those interactions among the atoms

it is those interactions among the atoms that compose the gas where allows the

that compose the gas where allows the

that compose the gas where allows the gas to collapse and settle into the disk

gas to collapse and settle into the disk

gas to collapse and settle into the disk of the galaxy this constant interplay of

of the galaxy this constant interplay of

of the galaxy this constant interplay of scales might seem difficult to

scales might seem difficult to

scales might seem difficult to understand at first but we have a tool

understand at first but we have a tool

understand at first but we have a tool to shed light on it and it’s called the

to shed light on it and it’s called the

to shed light on it and it’s called the scientific method this method allows us

scientific method this method allows us

scientific method this method allows us to learn from nature with just five

to learn from nature with just five

to learn from nature with just five steps first one formulation of a

steps first one formulation of a

steps first one formulation of a question we observe a phenomena in

question we observe a phenomena in

question we observe a phenomena in nature

nature

nature that we want to learn about and so we

that we want to learn about and so we

that we want to learn about and so we formulate a simple question about it

formulate a simple question about it

formulate a simple question about it second hypothesis from what we already

second hypothesis from what we already

second hypothesis from what we already know we can touch her what the answer

know we can touch her what the answer

know we can touch her what the answer can be third prediction this one is

can be third prediction this one is

can be third prediction this one is especially relevant scientific models

especially relevant scientific models

especially relevant scientific models and theories not only are capable of

and theories not only are capable of

and theories not only are capable of describing nature but they’re also

describing nature but they’re also

describing nature but they’re also capable of predicting events for the

capable of predicting events for the

capable of predicting events for the testing this is the most well known

testing this is the most well known

testing this is the most well known because here is where the actual

because here is where the actual

because here is where the actual experiments are being performed and five

experiments are being performed and five

experiments are being performed and five analysis with this we can evaluate

analysis with this we can evaluate

analysis with this we can evaluate whether our hypothesis is correct or not

whether our hypothesis is correct or not

whether our hypothesis is correct or not different Sciences may refer on the way

different Sciences may refer on the way

different Sciences may refer on the way they do the testing a step but they are

they do the testing a step but they are

they do the testing a step but they are all use the scientific method to bill

all use the scientific method to bill

all use the scientific method to bill knowledge

knowledge

knowledge for example if you ask biologists how do

for example if you ask biologists how do

for example if you ask biologists how do they face research that will tell you

they face research that will tell you

they face research that will tell you how the most important thing is to be

how the most important thing is to be

how the most important thing is to be able to control all the variables that

able to control all the variables that

able to control all the variables that may play a role in whatever it is that

may play a role in whatever it is that

may play a role in whatever it is that you want to study and then they will

you want to study and then they will

you want to study and then they will start talking about also experiments

start talking about also experiments

start talking about also experiments that can be done in which they can

that can be done in which they can

that can be done in which they can replicate over and over the exact same

replicate over and over the exact same

replicate over and over the exact same conditions in order to investigate what

conditions in order to investigate what

conditions in order to investigate what are the most relevant variables in

are the most relevant variables in

are the most relevant variables in astronomy we cannot do that imagine you

astronomy we cannot do that imagine you

astronomy we cannot do that imagine you want to study how a galaxy like

want to study how a galaxy like

want to study how a galaxy like Andromeda here forms what can we do in

Andromeda here forms what can we do in

Andromeda here forms what can we do in the same way that paleontologists can

the same way that paleontologists can

the same way that paleontologists can reconstruct the evolutionary trajectory

reconstruct the evolutionary trajectory

reconstruct the evolutionary trajectory of a given species using only fossils

of a given species using only fossils

of a given species using only fossils which are fragments of that history we

which are fragments of that history we

which are fragments of that history we must construct the formation history of

must construct the formation history of

must construct the formation history of OVA galaxies using only examples similar

OVA galaxies using only examples similar

OVA galaxies using only examples similar to that galaxy and sometimes actual

to that galaxy and sometimes actual

to that galaxy and sometimes actual glimpses into the past with that we can

glimpses into the past with that we can

glimpses into the past with that we can put forward theories to try to explain

put forward theories to try to explain

put forward theories to try to explain these processes and then we try to prove

these processes and then we try to prove

these processes and then we try to prove those theories wrong once we’ve proven

those theories wrong once we’ve proven

those theories wrong once we’ve proven them wrong because that will happen you

them wrong because that will happen you

them wrong because that will happen you have to test the theory and try again

have to test the theory and try again

have to test the theory and try again these theories are never set in stone

these theories are never set in stone

these theories are never set in stone but they are constantly developing to

but they are constantly developing to

but they are constantly developing to better describe what we observe there’s

better describe what we observe there’s

better describe what we observe there’s another solution and that is to put all

another solution and that is to put all

another solution and that is to put all our knowledge into a computer to create

our knowledge into a computer to create

our knowledge into a computer to create a beautiful galaxy in a simulation to

a beautiful galaxy in a simulation to

a beautiful galaxy in a simulation to actually replicate how the birth of that

actually replicate how the birth of that

actually replicate how the birth of that galaxy has been numerical simulations

galaxy has been numerical simulations

galaxy has been numerical simulations are very important in astronomy because

are very important in astronomy because

are very important in astronomy because they allows us to change the properties

they allows us to change the properties

they allows us to change the properties of the universe and so to build a bridge

of the universe and so to build a bridge

of the universe and so to build a bridge between observations and the models like

between observations and the models like

between observations and the models like in the real universe our simulated

in the real universe our simulated

in the real universe our simulated galaxies are made of particles but

galaxies are made of particles but

galaxies are made of particles but because we do not have the computational

because we do not have the computational

because we do not have the computational power available to treat each star in

power available to treat each star in

power available to treat each star in your galaxy individually what we call

your galaxy individually what we call

your galaxy individually what we call particles actually correspond to chunks

particles actually correspond to chunks

particles actually correspond to chunks of mass that can correspond up to

of mass that can correspond up to

of mass that can correspond up to several millions of stars like the Sun

several millions of stars like the Sun

several millions of stars like the Sun there is not what one things by the word

there is not what one things by the word

there is not what one things by the word particle right

particle right

particle right to design these big numerical

to design these big numerical

to design these big numerical simulations we first need to think how

simulations we first need to think how

simulations we first need to think how different physical processes will affect

different physical processes will affect

different physical processes will affect one of our particles and then we grow a

one of our particles and then we grow a

one of our particles and then we grow a code in which we simulate all those

code in which we simulate all those

code in which we simulate all those different physical processes for several

different physical processes for several

different physical processes for several millions of particles once we’ve run the

millions of particles once we’ve run the

millions of particles once we’ve run the simulation we can compare the results

simulation we can compare the results

simulation we can compare the results with the observations to see whether the

with the observations to see whether the

with the observations to see whether the physical ingredients that we have

physical ingredients that we have

physical ingredients that we have implemented in our simulation correctly

implemented in our simulation correctly

implemented in our simulation correctly describe the observed properties of the

describe the observed properties of the

describe the observed properties of the galaxies or not designing one of these

galaxies or not designing one of these

galaxies or not designing one of these big numerical simulations is not a

big numerical simulations is not a

big numerical simulations is not a trivial problem because there’s many

trivial problem because there’s many

trivial problem because there’s many many physical mechanisms and need to be

many physical mechanisms and need to be

many physical mechanisms and need to be accounted for another very important

accounted for another very important

accounted for another very important issue is the number of particles that we

issue is the number of particles that we

issue is the number of particles that we use to describe these galaxies the

use to describe these galaxies the

use to describe these galaxies the smaller the number of particles the

smaller the number of particles the

smaller the number of particles the faster we can run our simulation but the

faster we can run our simulation but the

faster we can run our simulation but the less information we’re going to obtain

less information we’re going to obtain

less information we’re going to obtain out of it so we have to constantly

out of it so we have to constantly

out of it so we have to constantly trade-off between computational speed

trade-off between computational speed

trade-off between computational speed and precision I am a PhD student at the

and precision I am a PhD student at the

and precision I am a PhD student at the University of Heidelberg and I’m not

University of Heidelberg and I’m not

University of Heidelberg and I’m not interested interested as much in these

interested interested as much in these

interested interested as much in these objects but actually in these dollars

objects but actually in these dollars

objects but actually in these dollars which are called stellar clusters a

which are called stellar clusters a

which are called stellar clusters a stellar cluster is a group of stars that

stellar cluster is a group of stars that

stellar cluster is a group of stars that has formed at the same time in the same

has formed at the same time in the same

has formed at the same time in the same place of the galaxy and there is held

place of the galaxy and there is held

place of the galaxy and there is held together by the gravitational

together by the gravitational

together by the gravitational interaction among each other here is

interaction among each other here is

interaction among each other here is another image of the Andromeda galaxy do

another image of the Andromeda galaxy do

another image of the Andromeda galaxy do you see that in the bottom right corner

you see that in the bottom right corner

you see that in the bottom right corner there is a blue circle that circle

there is a blue circle that circle

there is a blue circle that circle corresponds to its brightest a stellar

corresponds to its brightest a stellar

corresponds to its brightest a stellar cluster in that galaxy and you can see

cluster in that galaxy and you can see

cluster in that galaxy and you can see that there’s quite a difference between

that there’s quite a difference between

that there’s quite a difference between a stellar cluster and a galaxy my field

a stellar cluster and a galaxy my field

a stellar cluster and a galaxy my field has developed mainly from observations

has developed mainly from observations

has developed mainly from observations and over the years people have found

and over the years people have found

and over the years people have found many different types of a stellar

many different types of a stellar

many different types of a stellar clusters being the two most well-known

clusters being the two most well-known

clusters being the two most well-known these two which are called

these two which are called

these two which are called open clusters or globular clusters the

open clusters or globular clusters the

open clusters or globular clusters the first time they’re heard about these

first time they’re heard about these

first time they’re heard about these objects I was on my second year of uni

objects I was on my second year of uni

objects I was on my second year of uni back in Barcelona and the finger I most

back in Barcelona and the finger I most

back in Barcelona and the finger I most clearly remember about that lecture is

clearly remember about that lecture is

clearly remember about that lecture is how much they emphasized on the

how much they emphasized on the

how much they emphasized on the differences between them open clusters

differences between them open clusters

differences between them open clusters are young the

are young the

are young the have very few stars and some diffuse gas

have very few stars and some diffuse gas

have very few stars and some diffuse gas whereas chloral clusters are old they

whereas chloral clusters are old they

whereas chloral clusters are old they have up to several thousands of a stars

have up to several thousands of a stars

have up to several thousands of a stars and they have no guys at all

and they have no guys at all

and they have no guys at all so the question is how did these objects

so the question is how did these objects

so the question is how did these objects form here there’s a bit of debate as

form here there’s a bit of debate as

form here there’s a bit of debate as usual seeing how different the

usual seeing how different the

usual seeing how different the properties are some people suggest that

properties are some people suggest that

properties are some people suggest that these objects form following two

these objects form following two

these objects form following two complete different physical processes

complete different physical processes

complete different physical processes and that you cannot compare them in any

and that you cannot compare them in any

and that you cannot compare them in any way on the other hand there are some

way on the other hand there are some

way on the other hand there are some other people who suggest that these

other people who suggest that these

other people who suggest that these objects form following the same physical

objects form following the same physical

objects form following the same physical process but because these objects are

process but because these objects are

process but because these objects are orbiting in the galaxies and so they’re

orbiting in the galaxies and so they’re

orbiting in the galaxies and so they’re evolving inside of that galaxy what

evolving inside of that galaxy what

evolving inside of that galaxy what happens throughout the life will modify

happens throughout the life will modify

happens throughout the life will modify their aspect and so will change how we

their aspect and so will change how we

their aspect and so will change how we see them nowadays I’m working with that

see them nowadays I’m working with that

see them nowadays I’m working with that second hypothesis and it is not a

second hypothesis and it is not a

second hypothesis and it is not a trivial problem because we have to work

trivial problem because we have to work

trivial problem because we have to work from the largest scales of how does the

from the largest scales of how does the

from the largest scales of how does the galaxies form and evolve through cosmic

galaxies form and evolve through cosmic

galaxies form and evolve through cosmic time down to the smaller scales of how

time down to the smaller scales of how

time down to the smaller scales of how the the clusters form from the gas

the the clusters form from the gas

the the clusters form from the gas sitting in the galaxies and how they

sitting in the galaxies and how they

sitting in the galaxies and how they evolve inside of that galaxy and how

evolve inside of that galaxy and how

evolve inside of that galaxy and how they keep interacting with that gas

they keep interacting with that gas

they keep interacting with that gas throughout their lifetimes in order to

throughout their lifetimes in order to

throughout their lifetimes in order to work with certain interplay of scales I

work with certain interplay of scales I

work with certain interplay of scales I have to use numerical simulations which

have to use numerical simulations which

have to use numerical simulations which allow me to replicate how galaxies and

allow me to replicate how galaxies and

allow me to replicate how galaxies and clusters form evolve and interact

clusters form evolve and interact

clusters form evolve and interact through our LED throughout their

through our LED throughout their

through our LED throughout their lifetimes

lifetimes

lifetimes I will end up comparing my simulations

I will end up comparing my simulations

I will end up comparing my simulations with observations those are which will

with observations those are which will

with observations those are which will allow me to evaluate our hypothesis on

allow me to evaluate our hypothesis on

allow me to evaluate our hypothesis on the stellar cluster formation thus

the stellar cluster formation thus

the stellar cluster formation thus fulfilling the last step of the

fulfilling the last step of the

fulfilling the last step of the scientific method the complexity of

scientific method the complexity of

scientific method the complexity of interplays of scales may obscure the way

interplays of scales may obscure the way

interplays of scales may obscure the way to the truth behind it but armed with a

to the truth behind it but armed with a

to the truth behind it but armed with a scientific method and some Efrain

scientific method and some Efrain

scientific method and some Efrain dedication I know I can light my way out

dedication I know I can light my way out

dedication I know I can light my way out from the darkness thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *