Press "Enter" to skip to content

A fair go for self-determination | Vincent Redhouse | TEDxFulbrightCanberra


yeah they shake it oh she done it

yeah they shake it oh she done it Vince red house Anisha Irish you surely

Vince red house Anisha Irish you surely

Vince red house Anisha Irish you surely Filipino Bachchan German de chelly arrow

Filipino Bachchan German de chelly arrow

Filipino Bachchan German de chelly arrow kiss Jimmy – lolly I gotta go you know

kiss Jimmy – lolly I gotta go you know

kiss Jimmy – lolly I gotta go you know initially I hear as a Navajo man I’d

initially I hear as a Navajo man I’d

initially I hear as a Navajo man I’d like to pay my respects to the

like to pay my respects to the

like to pay my respects to the traditional owners of this land and not

traditional owners of this land and not

traditional owners of this land and not a wall people and their elders past

a wall people and their elders past

a wall people and their elders past present and future night I’m going to

present and future night I’m going to

present and future night I’m going to talk about self-determination I’ll talk

talk about self-determination I’ll talk

talk about self-determination I’ll talk a little bit about my own personal

a little bit about my own personal

a little bit about my own personal experiences with it and a little bit

experiences with it and a little bit

experiences with it and a little bit about the experiences of Native

about the experiences of Native

about the experiences of Native Americans in general you know we’re also

Americans in general you know we’re also

Americans in general you know we’re also going to talk a little bit about

going to talk a little bit about

going to talk a little bit about self-determination in Australia so about

self-determination in Australia so about

self-determination in Australia so about me I grew up like a lot of Native

me I grew up like a lot of Native

me I grew up like a lot of Native Americans very poor I grew up in a

Americans very poor I grew up in a

Americans very poor I grew up in a neighborhood and then a family that had

neighborhood and then a family that had

neighborhood and then a family that had issues with drugs and alcohol

issues with drugs and alcohol

issues with drugs and alcohol growing up education was not very

growing up education was not very

growing up education was not very important to me I was the youngest of

important to me I was the youngest of

important to me I was the youngest of four siblings and I was the first to

four siblings and I was the first to

four siblings and I was the first to complete high school on time however

complete high school on time however

complete high school on time however that came with a caveat when I graduated

that came with a caveat when I graduated

that came with a caveat when I graduated high school I graduated with the most

high school I graduated with the most

high school I graduated with the most unexcused absences of anyone ever

unexcused absences of anyone ever

unexcused absences of anyone ever graduate from that school it’s been

graduate from that school it’s been

graduate from that school it’s been around since the 1960s as a teenager and

around since the 1960s as a teenager and

around since the 1960s as a teenager and a young adult I had my own issues with

a young adult I had my own issues with

a young adult I had my own issues with drugs and alcohol being arrested for

drugs and alcohol being arrested for

drugs and alcohol being arrested for both and as a young adult I also found

both and as a young adult I also found

both and as a young adult I also found myself homeless for a brief period of

myself homeless for a brief period of

myself homeless for a brief period of time

with the help of some truly amazing

with the help of some truly amazing friends I was I would get my life back

friends I was I would get my life back

friends I was I would get my life back on track to find work to create some

on track to find work to create some

on track to find work to create some stability and after a while what I

stability and after a while what I

stability and after a while what I realized is that I wanted to give back I

realized is that I wanted to give back I

realized is that I wanted to give back I wanted to provide opportunities for

wanted to provide opportunities for

wanted to provide opportunities for people who grew up like me and if I

people who grew up like me and if I

people who grew up like me and if I could I wanted to help future

could I wanted to help future

could I wanted to help future generations so they didn’t have to grow

generations so they didn’t have to grow

generations so they didn’t have to grow up like me now in order to achieve those

up like me now in order to achieve those

up like me now in order to achieve those goals I figured I should probably get an

goals I figured I should probably get an

goals I figured I should probably get an education

getting an education in the United

getting an education in the United States is not the cheapest thing and as

States is not the cheapest thing and as

States is not the cheapest thing and as you can imagine I’m not the wealthiest

you can imagine I’m not the wealthiest

you can imagine I’m not the wealthiest guy around but nonetheless I was able to

guy around but nonetheless I was able to

guy around but nonetheless I was able to get an education and I was able to do

get an education and I was able to do

get an education and I was able to do that because my tribe the Navajo Nation

that because my tribe the Navajo Nation

that because my tribe the Navajo Nation was able to provide me with scholarships

was able to provide me with scholarships

was able to provide me with scholarships to pay for my tuition and even more when

to pay for my tuition and even more when

to pay for my tuition and even more when I arrived at the University campus as a

I arrived at the University campus as a

I arrived at the University campus as a first-generation college student I found

first-generation college student I found

first-generation college student I found there was a resource center there just

there was a resource center there just

there was a resource center there just for Native American students ran by

for Native American students ran by

for Native American students ran by Native Americans

Native Americans

Native Americans this Resource Center gave me a place

this Resource Center gave me a place

this Resource Center gave me a place where I could feel at home a place where

where I could feel at home a place where

where I could feel at home a place where I could be myself a place where I could

I could be myself a place where I could

I could be myself a place where I could get support

get support

get support now that Center was not there simply out

now that Center was not there simply out

now that Center was not there simply out of the decency of my University it was

of the decency of my University it was

of the decency of my University it was there because my tribe as well as other

there because my tribe as well as other

there because my tribe as well as other tribes across the country have donated

tribes across the country have donated

tribes across the country have donated millions of dollars to universities to

millions of dollars to universities to

millions of dollars to universities to get them to build these centers to

get them to build these centers to

get them to build these centers to support us to provide their children our

support us to provide their children our

support us to provide their children our future generations with opportunities to

future generations with opportunities to

future generations with opportunities to succeed my tribe would not have been in

succeed my tribe would not have been in

succeed my tribe would not have been in that position had it not been through

that position had it not been through

that position had it not been through the United States Congress passing the

the United States Congress passing the

the United States Congress passing the Indian self-determination and Education

Indian self-determination and Education

Indian self-determination and Education Act in 1975 now in 1970 President

Act in 1975 now in 1970 President

Act in 1975 now in 1970 President Richard M Nixon delivered a message to

Richard M Nixon delivered a message to

Richard M Nixon delivered a message to the US Congress on Indian Affairs since

the US Congress on Indian Affairs since

the US Congress on Indian Affairs since assuming his presidency Nixon had been

assuming his presidency Nixon had been

assuming his presidency Nixon had been meeting with tribal leaders from all

meeting with tribal leaders from all

meeting with tribal leaders from all over the country he wanted to understand

over the country he wanted to understand

over the country he wanted to understand what was happening it’s a Native

what was happening it’s a Native

what was happening it’s a Native Americans what was happening on these

Americans what was happening on these

Americans what was happening on these reservations in the previous decades

reservations in the previous decades

reservations in the previous decades US policy for Indians had been mostly

US policy for Indians had been mostly

US policy for Indians had been mostly paternalistic the federal government had

paternalistic the federal government had

paternalistic the federal government had assumed almost near complete control of

assumed almost near complete control of

assumed almost near complete control of all the affairs happening on

all the affairs happening on

all the affairs happening on reservations and when Nixon noticed is

reservations and when Nixon noticed is

reservations and when Nixon noticed is that this wasn’t working outcomes for

that this wasn’t working outcomes for

that this wasn’t working outcomes for Native Americans where the remaining

Native Americans where the remaining

Native Americans where the remaining stagnant or getting worse in his message

stagnant or getting worse in his message

stagnant or getting worse in his message Nixon identified three areas and

Nixon identified three areas and

Nixon identified three areas and particularly

particularly

particularly that needed to be addressed economic

that needed to be addressed economic

that needed to be addressed economic outcomes health outcomes and education

outcomes health outcomes and education

outcomes health outcomes and education outcomes terms of account economics the

outcomes terms of account economics the

outcomes terms of account economics the average unemployment rate for Native

average unemployment rate for Native

average unemployment rate for Native Americans in 1970 he said was ten times

Americans in 1970 he said was ten times

Americans in 1970 he said was ten times higher than the national average with

higher than the national average with

higher than the national average with some reservations experiencing

some reservations experiencing

some reservations experiencing unemployment of up to eighty percent the

unemployment of up to eighty percent the

unemployment of up to eighty percent the average life expectancy for Native

average life expectancy for Native

average life expectancy for Native Americans he said was 44 years old

Americans he said was 44 years old

Americans he said was 44 years old infant mortality rates were 50 percent

infant mortality rates were 50 percent

infant mortality rates were 50 percent higher than the rest of the population

higher than the rest of the population

higher than the rest of the population and suicide rates were nearly double the

and suicide rates were nearly double the

and suicide rates were nearly double the rest of the population the average

rest of the population the average

rest of the population the average education level for Native Americans was

education level for Native Americans was

education level for Native Americans was er6 in order to address those poor

er6 in order to address those poor

er6 in order to address those poor outcomes Nixon working together closely

outcomes Nixon working together closely

outcomes Nixon working together closely with tribal leaders developed a policy

with tribal leaders developed a policy

with tribal leaders developed a policy of self-determination they wanted the

of self-determination they wanted the

of self-determination they wanted the shift away from the paternalistic

shift away from the paternalistic

shift away from the paternalistic policies the government had towards

policies the government had towards

policies the government had towards tribal self-determination in his

tribal self-determination in his

tribal self-determination in his proposal

proposal

proposal Nixon listed five key elements to

Nixon listed five key elements to

Nixon listed five key elements to achieving self-determination for tribes

achieving self-determination for tribes

achieving self-determination for tribes first the federal government needs to

first the federal government needs to

first the federal government needs to provide training and supports so tribes

provide training and supports so tribes

provide training and supports so tribes could learn how to take advantage of

could learn how to take advantage of

could learn how to take advantage of self-determination could learn how to

self-determination could learn how to

self-determination could learn how to administer their own programs and govern

administer their own programs and govern

administer their own programs and govern themselves second special subcommittees

themselves second special subcommittees

themselves second special subcommittees and councils should be created by Native

and councils should be created by Native

and councils should be created by Native Americans and for Native Americans to

Americans and for Native Americans to

Americans and for Native Americans to assist the United States Congress in

assist the United States Congress in

assist the United States Congress in creating federal Indian policies third

creating federal Indian policies third

creating federal Indian policies third that none of that should be taken as

that none of that should be taken as

that none of that should be taken as diminishing or mitigating the special

diminishing or mitigating the special

diminishing or mitigating the special relationship between the United States

relationship between the United States

relationship between the United States and its tribes a nation-to-nation

and its tribes a nation-to-nation

and its tribes a nation-to-nation relationship fourth that this needed to

relationship fourth that this needed to

relationship fourth that this needed to become the norm we could not simply have

become the norm we could not simply have

become the norm we could not simply have self-determination as an experiment 5 10

self-determination as an experiment 5 10

self-determination as an experiment 5 10 15 years but it needed to be the thing

15 years but it needed to be the thing

15 years but it needed to be the thing that was done now and always and lastly

that was done now and always and lastly

that was done now and always and lastly he told

he told

he told Congress that they needed to raise the

Congress that they needed to raise the

Congress that they needed to raise the budget on Indian Affairs so the

budget on Indian Affairs so the

budget on Indian Affairs so the self-determination could actually take

self-determination could actually take

self-determination could actually take hold in five years later in 1975 the

hold in five years later in 1975 the

hold in five years later in 1975 the united states congress took those words

united states congress took those words

united states congress took those words and turned them into action for the most

and turned them into action for the most

and turned them into action for the most part they passed the Indian

part they passed the Indian

part they passed the Indian self-determination and Education Act and

self-determination and Education Act and

self-determination and Education Act and that realized four of the elements Nixon

that realized four of the elements Nixon

that realized four of the elements Nixon was talking about where it failed was it

was talking about where it failed was it

was talking about where it failed was it didn’t provide additional funding for

didn’t provide additional funding for

didn’t provide additional funding for tribes and in fact over the next 10

tribes and in fact over the next 10

tribes and in fact over the next 10 years funding for tribes was reduced by

years funding for tribes was reduced by

years funding for tribes was reduced by over half and has continued to fall this

over half and has continued to fall this

over half and has continued to fall this day to the point in which Native

day to the point in which Native

day to the point in which Native Americans per capita received less

Americans per capita received less

Americans per capita received less federal funding than any other group in

federal funding than any other group in

federal funding than any other group in the United States despite the lack of

the United States despite the lack of

the United States despite the lack of funding however tribes beginning

funding however tribes beginning

funding however tribes beginning primarily in the 1990s started enrolling

primarily in the 1990s started enrolling

primarily in the 1990s started enrolling in self-determination programs and today

in self-determination programs and today

in self-determination programs and today over half of the 567 federally

over half of the 567 federally

over half of the 567 federally recognized tribes from Arizona where I’m

recognized tribes from Arizona where I’m

recognized tribes from Arizona where I’m from all the way up to Alaska are able

from all the way up to Alaska are able

from all the way up to Alaska are able to exercise some form of

to exercise some form of

to exercise some form of self-determination so what have the

self-determination so what have the

self-determination so what have the results been well obviously they’ve been

results been well obviously they’ve been

results been well obviously they’ve been good or else I wouldn’t be up here

good or else I wouldn’t be up here

good or else I wouldn’t be up here unemployment for Native Americans on

unemployment for Native Americans on

unemployment for Native Americans on reservations is just about above 11

reservations is just about above 11

reservations is just about above 11 percent average life expectancy for

percent average life expectancy for

percent average life expectancy for Native Americans whose primary health

Native Americans whose primary health

Native Americans whose primary health care comes from their tribe is 73 years

infant mortality rates and suicide rates

infant mortality rates and suicide rates had decreased dramatically and have also

had decreased dramatically and have also

had decreased dramatically and have also decreased relative to the rest of the

decreased relative to the rest of the

decreased relative to the rest of the population and over 80 percent of Native

population and over 80 percent of Native

population and over 80 percent of Native Americans under the age of 25 have high

Americans under the age of 25 have high

Americans under the age of 25 have high school diplomas or equivalent and over

school diplomas or equivalent and over

school diplomas or equivalent and over 30 percent have college degrees like

30 percent have college degrees like

30 percent have college degrees like myself now it took a long time for these

myself now it took a long time for these

myself now it took a long time for these results to come about almost twenty

results to come about almost twenty

results to come about almost twenty years until you started seeing them pop

years until you started seeing them pop

years until you started seeing them pop up much of that had to do with the fact

up much of that had to do with the fact

up much of that had to do with the fact that the government did not properly

that the government did not properly

that the government did not properly fund self-determination much of it also

fund self-determination much of it also

fund self-determination much of it also had to do with the situation

had to do with the situation

had to do with the situation the indigenous people were in at the

the indigenous people were in at the

the indigenous people were in at the time it’s not easy to dig yourself out

time it’s not easy to dig yourself out

time it’s not easy to dig yourself out of a hole like that much of it likely

of a hole like that much of it likely

of a hole like that much of it likely also had to do with the attitudes of

also had to do with the attitudes of

also had to do with the attitudes of American citizens who by and large have

American citizens who by and large have

American citizens who by and large have often view Native Americans as being

often view Native Americans as being

often view Native Americans as being savage antiquated unfit to govern but

savage antiquated unfit to govern but

savage antiquated unfit to govern but despite all of those obstacles

despite all of those obstacles

despite all of those obstacles self-determination has been a success

self-determination has been a success

self-determination has been a success things are not perfect in the United

things are not perfect in the United

things are not perfect in the United States the numbers are still acceptable

States the numbers are still acceptable

States the numbers are still acceptable but self-determination has worked and it

but self-determination has worked and it

but self-determination has worked and it continues to work to this day so why

continues to work to this day so why

continues to work to this day so why hasn’t it worked here in Australia when

hasn’t it worked here in Australia when

hasn’t it worked here in Australia when I present those results to Australians

I present those results to Australians

I present those results to Australians the reply usually get us something like

the reply usually get us something like

the reply usually get us something like mate listen we tried that it failed and

mate listen we tried that it failed and

mate listen we tried that it failed and I think really you guys really tried

I think really you guys really tried

I think really you guys really tried that and I looked at it and sure enough

that and I looked at it and sure enough

that and I looked at it and sure enough in the 1960s beginning and then

in the 1960s beginning and then

in the 1960s beginning and then Australia started to talk about

Australia started to talk about

Australia started to talk about self-determination you had voting in

self-determination you had voting in

self-determination you had voting in 1962 for Indigenous Australians the

1962 for Indigenous Australians the

1962 for Indigenous Australians the census in 67 and so on and so forth some

census in 67 and so on and so forth some

census in 67 and so on and so forth some really great things happened here but

really great things happened here but

really great things happened here but none of those things were

none of those things were

none of those things were self-determination as I’ve described it

self-determination as I’ve described it

self-determination as I’ve described it there are positive steps they weren’t

there are positive steps they weren’t

there are positive steps they weren’t self-determination the closest perhaps

self-determination the closest perhaps

self-determination the closest perhaps the Australia has come to

the Australia has come to

the Australia has come to self-determination was at Sikh the

self-determination was at Sikh the

self-determination was at Sikh the Australian tourist area under commission

Australian tourist area under commission

Australian tourist area under commission now from anyone’s perspective at SiC was

now from anyone’s perspective at SiC was

now from anyone’s perspective at SiC was not perfect it was a bit of a mess

not perfect it was a bit of a mess

not perfect it was a bit of a mess nonetheless it was a step in the right

nonetheless it was a step in the right

nonetheless it was a step in the right direction towards self-determination

direction towards self-determination

direction towards self-determination unfortunately after only lasting roughly

unfortunately after only lasting roughly

unfortunately after only lasting roughly 10 years it was abolished and when it

10 years it was abolished and when it

10 years it was abolished and when it was abolished the assailing government

was abolished the assailing government

was abolished the assailing government claimed that self-determination as an

claimed that self-determination as an

claimed that self-determination as an experiment had failed and since then

experiment had failed and since then

experiment had failed and since then Australia’s policies towards indigenous

Australia’s policies towards indigenous

Australia’s policies towards indigenous people have primarily been paternalistic

now I shared my story with you in the

now I shared my story with you in the story of self-determination in the US

story of self-determination in the US

story of self-determination in the US because I wanted you to see the success

because I wanted you to see the success

because I wanted you to see the success that can happen when you really give

that can happen when you really give

that can happen when you really give self-determination a chance when you

self-determination a chance when you

self-determination a chance when you give it as Australians would say a fair

give it as Australians would say a fair

give it as Australians would say a fair go you haven’t done that yet now I do

go you haven’t done that yet now I do

go you haven’t done that yet now I do believe they can work here

believe they can work here

believe they can work here I know Australia in America they’re not

I know Australia in America they’re not

I know Australia in America they’re not the same places obviously but there’s no

the same places obviously but there’s no

the same places obviously but there’s no reason to think that you’re indigenous

reason to think that you’re indigenous

reason to think that you’re indigenous people can’t govern themselves and

people can’t govern themselves and

people can’t govern themselves and you’ve heard the success now of what

you’ve heard the success now of what

you’ve heard the success now of what happens in the u.s. despite the beliefs

happens in the u.s. despite the beliefs

happens in the u.s. despite the beliefs that people have despite the conditions

that people have despite the conditions

that people have despite the conditions the tribes are in it can work and if you

the tribes are in it can work and if you

the tribes are in it can work and if you listen to what your indigenous people

listen to what your indigenous people

listen to what your indigenous people are saying if you work with them and you

are saying if you work with them and you

are saying if you work with them and you give them the time you give them the

give them the time you give them the

give them the time you give them the space you give them the resources they

space you give them the resources they

space you give them the resources they will create that transformation they

will create that transformation they

will create that transformation they will create success

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *