Press "Enter" to skip to content

A commercial block that changed China | Benjamin T. Wood | TEDxXiguan


I grew up on a farm in rural America and

I grew up on a farm in rural America and my brother and I used to spend hours and

my brother and I used to spend hours and

my brother and I used to spend hours and hours in our backyard digging in the

hours in our backyard digging in the

hours in our backyard digging in the sand my mother would come out and she

sand my mother would come out and she

sand my mother would come out and she would say if you just dig deep enough

would say if you just dig deep enough

would say if you just dig deep enough you’ll end up in China and fortunately I

you’ll end up in China and fortunately I

you’ll end up in China and fortunately I did get to China to do a project 18

did get to China to do a project 18

did get to China to do a project 18 years ago and I didn’t have to tear up

years ago and I didn’t have to tear up

years ago and I didn’t have to tear up my mother’s yard to do it so I’m glad to

my mother’s yard to do it so I’m glad to

my mother’s yard to do it so I’m glad to be here I’m here to talk about shenton d

be here I’m here to talk about shenton d

be here I’m here to talk about shenton d the project that brought me here and I

the project that brought me here and I

the project that brought me here and I think everybody knows that chintan d is

think everybody knows that chintan d is

think everybody knows that chintan d is an extraordinary commercial success and

an extraordinary commercial success and

an extraordinary commercial success and for that reason I’m not going to talk

for that reason I’m not going to talk

for that reason I’m not going to talk about why it’s a success because those

about why it’s a success because those

about why it’s a success because those of you that have been there and those

of you that have been there and those

of you that have been there and those that will go there we’ll see why its

that will go there we’ll see why its

that will go there we’ll see why its success at least on a commercial level

success at least on a commercial level

success at least on a commercial level I’m much more interested in another

I’m much more interested in another

I’m much more interested in another level and that’s why I think chinden d

level and that’s why I think chinden d

level and that’s why I think chinden d is not only commercially important but

is not only commercially important but

is not only commercially important but culturally important when I was five

culturally important when I was five

culturally important when I was five years old my mother and I waited on a

years old my mother and I waited on a

years old my mother and I waited on a school bus and that school bus was to

school bus and that school bus was to

school bus and that school bus was to take me to my first day in public school

take me to my first day in public school

take me to my first day in public school and she told me she said Ben you will

and she told me she said Ben you will

and she told me she said Ben you will ride the school bus with friends of

ride the school bus with friends of

ride the school bus with friends of yours from our neighborhood but not all

yours from our neighborhood but not all

yours from our neighborhood but not all your friends will be on that bus not the

your friends will be on that bus not the

your friends will be on that bus not the colored ones so it was my first lesson

colored ones so it was my first lesson

colored ones so it was my first lesson in humanity and chintan d was created

in humanity and chintan d was created

in humanity and chintan d was created for a rising middle class

for a rising middle class

for a rising middle class post-revolutionary shanghai population

post-revolutionary shanghai population

post-revolutionary shanghai population and what we gave them was exactly what

and what we gave them was exactly what

and what we gave them was exactly what they didn’t know they needed it needed

they didn’t know they needed it needed

they didn’t know they needed it needed at the time when

at the time when

at the time when needed the most we gave the people of

needed the most we gave the people of

needed the most we gave the people of Shanghai a place where they could enjoy

Shanghai a place where they could enjoy

Shanghai a place where they could enjoy life and the dignity and Haren and

life and the dignity and Haren and

life and the dignity and Haren and social equality 45 years later I was in

social equality 45 years later I was in

social equality 45 years later I was in my Boston studio working on a two

my Boston studio working on a two

my Boston studio working on a two billion dollar renovation of a home for

billion dollar renovation of a home for

billion dollar renovation of a home for the Chicago Bears 65,000 seats and then

the Chicago Bears 65,000 seats and then

the Chicago Bears 65,000 seats and then I got a call that made a big turn in my

I got a call that made a big turn in my

I got a call that made a big turn in my career the call was from Vincent low

career the call was from Vincent low

career the call was from Vincent low Hong Kong developer and he said he had a

Hong Kong developer and he said he had a

Hong Kong developer and he said he had a project in the heart of Shanghai and he

project in the heart of Shanghai and he

project in the heart of Shanghai and he wanted to create a world-class

wanted to create a world-class

wanted to create a world-class destination for dining and shopping and

destination for dining and shopping and

destination for dining and shopping and entertainment and he said he wanted to

entertainment and he said he wanted to

entertainment and he said he wanted to do something unique something that would

do something unique something that would

do something unique something that would call attention to the historical

call attention to the historical

call attention to the historical importance of that neighborhood he said

importance of that neighborhood he said

importance of that neighborhood he said he had an airline ticket for me leaving

he had an airline ticket for me leaving

he had an airline ticket for me leaving the next day and I said yes I’m coming

the next day and I said yes I’m coming

the next day and I said yes I’m coming I’m never one to turn down a great

I’m never one to turn down a great

I’m never one to turn down a great adventure so I two days later I find

adventure so I two days later I find

adventure so I two days later I find myself in this place chintan d this is

myself in this place chintan d this is

myself in this place chintan d this is what it looked like in 1998 and I walk

what it looked like in 1998 and I walk

what it looked like in 1998 and I walk 10 blocks from my hotel room to this

10 blocks from my hotel room to this

10 blocks from my hotel room to this neighborhood and as I approached the

neighborhood and as I approached the

neighborhood and as I approached the neighborhood other than noticing some

neighborhood other than noticing some

neighborhood other than noticing some terribly rundown overcrowded buildings I

terribly rundown overcrowded buildings I

terribly rundown overcrowded buildings I smell something it turns out it was the

smell something it turns out it was the

smell something it turns out it was the smell of sewage these people were living

smell of sewage these people were living

smell of sewage these people were living without indoor plumbing and I noticed

without indoor plumbing and I noticed

without indoor plumbing and I noticed behind the door to every residential

behind the door to every residential

behind the door to every residential apartment there was a pot and I later

apartment there was a pot and I later

apartment there was a pot and I later found out it was four nights oil and

found out it was four nights oil and

found out it was four nights oil and then I had to be told what night soil

then I had to be told what night soil

then I had to be told what night soil was so that was really my cultural

was so that was really my cultural

was so that was really my cultural introduction to China in 1998 it’s come

introduction to China in 1998 it’s come

introduction to China in 1998 it’s come a long way of course but back then there

a long way of course but back then there

a long way of course but back then there were sixteen hundred families living on

were sixteen hundred families living on

were sixteen hundred families living on this block and when someone didn’t move

this block and when someone didn’t move

this block and when someone didn’t move the government took their roof off and

the government took their roof off and

the government took their roof off and they moved anyway the other thing that I

they moved anyway the other thing that I

they moved anyway the other thing that I found amusing was that and by the way

found amusing was that and by the way

found amusing was that and by the way didn’t find the

didn’t find the

didn’t find the getting the roof off i’m using it all

getting the roof off i’m using it all

getting the roof off i’m using it all but i do i did notice that behind the

but i do i did notice that behind the

but i do i did notice that behind the next to the night soil was a wash basin

next to the night soil was a wash basin

next to the night soil was a wash basin every apartment had one so they didn’t

every apartment had one so they didn’t

every apartment had one so they didn’t have their handles on the cold water

have their handles on the cold water

have their handles on the cold water didn’t have any hot water but had cold

didn’t have any hot water but had cold

didn’t have any hot water but had cold water and there were no handles and i

water and there were no handles and i

water and there were no handles and i asked my god i said where the handles it

asked my god i said where the handles it

asked my god i said where the handles it so they’re there in the pocket of the

so they’re there in the pocket of the

so they’re there in the pocket of the people that live there you can you can

people that live there you can you can

people that live there you can you can tell where somebody lives by what

tell where somebody lives by what

tell where somebody lives by what they’re handled on their faucet looks

they’re handled on their faucet looks

they’re handled on their faucet looks like you know what changed my start well

like you know what changed my start well

like you know what changed my start well at least it started me to think was that

at least it started me to think was that

at least it started me to think was that there was life everywhere there were

there was life everywhere there were

there was life everywhere there were children playing in the lanes this is

children playing in the lanes this is

children playing in the lanes this is seven o’clock in the morning and the

seven o’clock in the morning and the

seven o’clock in the morning and the children the small children who weren’t

children the small children who weren’t

children the small children who weren’t old enough to go to school were playing

old enough to go to school were playing

old enough to go to school were playing in the lanes and the alleyways and their

in the lanes and the alleyways and their

in the lanes and the alleyways and their grandparents were up to watch them and

grandparents were up to watch them and

grandparents were up to watch them and then the parents were leaving the these

then the parents were leaving the these

then the parents were leaving the these humble actually decaying relics but they

humble actually decaying relics but they

humble actually decaying relics but they were well dressed they were clean I

were well dressed they were clean I

were well dressed they were clean I looked at the buildings and I looked

looked at the buildings and I looked

looked at the buildings and I looked underneath all the layers of the ad hoc

underneath all the layers of the ad hoc

underneath all the layers of the ad hoc editions in all the ways they had tried

editions in all the ways they had tried

editions in all the ways they had tried to eat more spaced out of these

to eat more spaced out of these

to eat more spaced out of these dwellings and those are some very

dwellings and those are some very

dwellings and those are some very elegant brick buildings and I know this

elegant brick buildings and I know this

elegant brick buildings and I know this beautiful stone details beautiful wood

beautiful stone details beautiful wood

beautiful stone details beautiful wood windows beautiful wood doors and I said

windows beautiful wood doors and I said

windows beautiful wood doors and I said at that moment I need to find a way to

at that moment I need to find a way to

at that moment I need to find a way to save these buildings the next day I went

save these buildings the next day I went

save these buildings the next day I went to see Vincent low and his Board of

to see Vincent low and his Board of

to see Vincent low and his Board of Directors in Hong Kong it was a day of

Directors in Hong Kong it was a day of

Directors in Hong Kong it was a day of interviews and at the end of the day I’m

interviews and at the end of the day I’m

interviews and at the end of the day I’m sitting there with four other architects

sitting there with four other architects

sitting there with four other architects in a little conference room and a call

in a little conference room and a call

in a little conference room and a call comes down and they said Mr would mr.

comes down and they said Mr would mr.

comes down and they said Mr would mr. Lowe wants to see you in his penthouse

Lowe wants to see you in his penthouse

Lowe wants to see you in his penthouse office I go up to see Vincent he said

office I go up to see Vincent he said

office I go up to see Vincent he said Ben you got the job and he said but she

Ben you got the job and he said but she

Ben you got the job and he said but she only got one vote was my vote and he

only got one vote was my vote and he

only got one vote was my vote and he said you got my vote because you wanted

said you got my vote because you wanted

said you got my vote because you wanted to save the buildings in 1996 that since

to save the buildings in 1996 that since

to save the buildings in 1996 that since company had been awarded a contract to

company had been awarded a contract to

company had been awarded a contract to redevelop 22 blocks in Shanghai and it

redevelop 22 blocks in Shanghai and it

redevelop 22 blocks in Shanghai and it was on two of those blocks that was the

was on two of those blocks that was the

was on two of those blocks that was the site of what would become one day tient

site of what would become one day tient

site of what would become one day tient indie and on one of those blocks was a

indie and on one of those blocks was a

indie and on one of those blocks was a first Congress Hall of the Communist

first Congress Hall of the Communist

first Congress Hall of the Communist Party in 1921 Chairman Mao and 11 other

Party in 1921 Chairman Mao and 11 other

Party in 1921 Chairman Mao and 11 other people had the first meeting of the

people had the first meeting of the

people had the first meeting of the Communist Party in China and they did it

Communist Party in China and they did it

Communist Party in China and they did it here because it was in the French

here because it was in the French

here because it was in the French Concession and it was a safe haven from

Concession and it was a safe haven from

Concession and it was a safe haven from the rest of Shanghai which was where

the rest of Shanghai which was where

the rest of Shanghai which was where Chairman Mao was would have been

Chairman Mao was would have been

Chairman Mao was would have been arrested had he been found so there was

arrested had he been found so there was

arrested had he been found so there was some historical significance to the site

some historical significance to the site

some historical significance to the site that went beyond just the buildings it

that went beyond just the buildings it

that went beyond just the buildings it was a there was political ideological

was a there was political ideological

was a there was political ideological significance to this neighborhood so the

significance to this neighborhood so the

significance to this neighborhood so the next task after having arrived in

next task after having arrived in

next task after having arrived in Shanghai was what did you how to take

Shanghai was what did you how to take

Shanghai was what did you how to take that neighborhood and turn it into a

that neighborhood and turn it into a

that neighborhood and turn it into a world-class entertainment destination I

world-class entertainment destination I

world-class entertainment destination I have to admit it was a struggle mean I

have to admit it was a struggle mean I

have to admit it was a struggle mean I was an American I knew I didn’t know the

was an American I knew I didn’t know the

was an American I knew I didn’t know the language I’d never been to China there

language I’d never been to China there

language I’d never been to China there was no really but no one really I could

was no really but no one really I could

was no really but no one really I could talk to so I started to I po and we

talk to so I started to I po and we

talk to so I started to I po and we didn’t have drawings we didn’t have

didn’t have drawings we didn’t have

didn’t have drawings we didn’t have drawings of any of the buildings we

drawings of any of the buildings we

drawings of any of the buildings we didn’t have time to do the drawings so

didn’t have time to do the drawings so

didn’t have time to do the drawings so the first thing we did was we took

the first thing we did was we took

the first thing we did was we took thousands of photographs and we were

thousands of photographs and we were

thousands of photographs and we were able to get an aerial view and this is

able to get an aerial view and this is

able to get an aerial view and this is the view of the North Block and one of

the view of the North Block and one of

the view of the North Block and one of the most difficult decisions was what’s

the most difficult decisions was what’s

the most difficult decisions was what’s buildings to remove because I knew we

buildings to remove because I knew we

buildings to remove because I knew we had to make some public space see

had to make some public space see

had to make some public space see normally when an architect has a site

normally when an architect has a site

normally when an architect has a site it’s blank and they they build public

it’s blank and they they build public

it’s blank and they they build public space by building buildings in this case

space by building buildings in this case

space by building buildings in this case I had to build public space by taking

I had to build public space by taking

I had to build public space by taking away buildings and it was very difficult

away buildings and it was very difficult

away buildings and it was very difficult to decide which buildings to leave and

to decide which buildings to leave and

to decide which buildings to leave and which buildings to demolish in which

which buildings to demolish in which

which buildings to demolish in which buildings to change to make them

buildings to change to make them

buildings to change to make them commercially successful but in the end

commercially successful but in the end

commercially successful but in the end this is the diagram I came up with and

this is the diagram I came up with and

this is the diagram I came up with and if you go the shinden do recognize this

if you go the shinden do recognize this

if you go the shinden do recognize this as the main promenade I also came up

as the main promenade I also came up

as the main promenade I also came up with a concept plan of how the place

with a concept plan of how the place

with a concept plan of how the place which was to be used and so I did more

which was to be used and so I did more

which was to be used and so I did more than just the architecture I had to

than just the architecture I had to

than just the architecture I had to recruit tenants I had to find the

recruit tenants I had to find the

recruit tenants I had to find the restaurants I went around went to every

restaurants I went around went to every

restaurants I went around went to every bar and nightclub in Shanghai and I said

bar and nightclub in Shanghai and I said

bar and nightclub in Shanghai and I said I’ve got a great project please come

and then we did these photo this is

and then we did these photo this is before we had Sketchup and a lot of

before we had Sketchup and a lot of

before we had Sketchup and a lot of these very sophisticated 3d modeling

these very sophisticated 3d modeling

these very sophisticated 3d modeling programs so my team made all these photo

programs so my team made all these photo

programs so my team made all these photo collages and we would overlay over their

collages and we would overlay over their

collages and we would overlay over their photo collage what we thought the place

photo collage what we thought the place

photo collage what we thought the place might look like when we were finished

might look like when we were finished

might look like when we were finished and we did several of these we take an

and we did several of these we take an

and we did several of these we take an old photograph that we took and we would

old photograph that we took and we would

old photograph that we took and we would overlay commercial didn’t use and faces

overlay commercial didn’t use and faces

overlay commercial didn’t use and faces the sip and landscaping and this way we

the sip and landscaping and this way we

the sip and landscaping and this way we were able to convince the government of

were able to convince the government of

were able to convince the government of Shanghai to let us go ahead with a

Shanghai to let us go ahead with a

Shanghai to let us go ahead with a project and then there were some very

project and then there were some very

project and then there were some very dark days I mean it was a day when I

dark days I mean it was a day when I

dark days I mean it was a day when I walked out and I said to myself how are

walked out and I said to myself how are

walked out and I said to myself how are we ever going to get this place put back

we ever going to get this place put back

we ever going to get this place put back together I mean we had we ended up

together I mean we had we ended up

together I mean we had we ended up having demolished almost all the walls

having demolished almost all the walls

having demolished almost all the walls because of earthquake requirements but

because of earthquake requirements but

because of earthquake requirements but every wall went back exactly where we

every wall went back exactly where we

every wall went back exactly where we tore it down so when you go to Shipton Z

tore it down so when you go to Shipton Z

tore it down so when you go to Shipton Z today the alleyways the lanes are

today the alleyways the lanes are

today the alleyways the lanes are exactly the width in exactly the same

exactly the width in exactly the same

exactly the width in exactly the same place as they were when I went there in

place as they were when I went there in

place as they were when I went there in 1998 and then my partner from the car

1998 and then my partner from the car

1998 and then my partner from the car look from Shanghai arrives he’s in this

look from Shanghai arrives he’s in this

look from Shanghai arrives he’s in this picture he’s standing on three feet of

picture he’s standing on three feet of

picture he’s standing on three feet of rubble and he said Ben I’m from Ecuador

rubble and he said Ben I’m from Ecuador

rubble and he said Ben I’m from Ecuador I got out of a third world country why

I got out of a third world country why

I got out of a third world country why are you in one and i said i’m here

are you in one and i said i’m here

are you in one and i said i’m here because China won’t always be a third

because China won’t always be a third

because China won’t always be a third world country and he went he got on the

world country and he went he got on the

world country and he went he got on the next plane and went home never to come

next plane and went home never to come

next plane and went home never to come back he never forgave me for using our

back he never forgave me for using our

back he never forgave me for using our resources on this project and then as we

resources on this project and then as we

resources on this project and then as we approached our first opening which was

approached our first opening which was

approached our first opening which was in the late the year 2001 we got to the

in the late the year 2001 we got to the

in the late the year 2001 we got to the point where we could open the North ally

point where we could open the North ally

point where we could open the North ally when it went in D opened I wouldn’t say

when it went in D opened I wouldn’t say

when it went in D opened I wouldn’t say it was a instant success but it was more

it was a instant success but it was more

it was a instant success but it was more like it wasn’t an instant failure but

like it wasn’t an instant failure but

like it wasn’t an instant failure but over the next few months as we open more

over the next few months as we open more

over the next few months as we open more and more shops or restaurants or cafes

and more shops or restaurants or cafes

and more shops or restaurants or cafes more nightclubs more bars

more nightclubs more bars

more nightclubs more bars people by the thousands started to come

people by the thousands started to come

people by the thousands started to come to Shenton d and i think they came there

to Shenton d and i think they came there

to Shenton d and i think they came there not because we had restored old

not because we had restored old

not because we had restored old buildings I think they came there

buildings I think they came there

buildings I think they came there because it was part of their city and

because it was part of their city and

because it was part of their city and they remembered when it was something

they remembered when it was something

they remembered when it was something else and these old buildings in this

else and these old buildings in this

else and these old buildings in this neighborhood had stories to tell and

neighborhood had stories to tell and

neighborhood had stories to tell and they could bring their friends from out

they could bring their friends from out

they could bring their friends from out of town and tell them the stories of

of town and tell them the stories of

of town and tell them the stories of what it was and now look at what it is

what it was and now look at what it is

what it was and now look at what it is so they took ownership of this place the

so they took ownership of this place the

so they took ownership of this place the other reason they liked this place is it

other reason they liked this place is it

other reason they liked this place is it wasn’t a shopping mall today when you go

wasn’t a shopping mall today when you go

wasn’t a shopping mall today when you go to a big shopping mall you have to the

to a big shopping mall you have to the

to a big shopping mall you have to the first thing you see is a what I call a

first thing you see is a what I call a

first thing you see is a what I call a phalanx of luxury brand flagship stores

phalanx of luxury brand flagship stores

phalanx of luxury brand flagship stores and you have to navigate your way by

and you have to navigate your way by

and you have to navigate your way by Gucci and Versace all these famous

Gucci and Versace all these famous

Gucci and Versace all these famous brands just to get to a shop where you

brands just to get to a shop where you

brands just to get to a shop where you want to buy a simple pair of shoes and

want to buy a simple pair of shoes and

want to buy a simple pair of shoes and so what distinguished chintan d was it

so what distinguished chintan d was it

so what distinguished chintan d was it was a collection of ordinary buildings

was a collection of ordinary buildings

was a collection of ordinary buildings for ordinary people and I think people

for ordinary people and I think people

for ordinary people and I think people appreciated that and it was a glass

appreciated that and it was a glass

appreciated that and it was a glass curtain walls framed in fifty shades of

curtain walls framed in fifty shades of

curtain walls framed in fifty shades of grey which is what every high-rise is

grey which is what every high-rise is

grey which is what every high-rise is they’re all gray they’re all glass they

they’re all gray they’re all glass they

they’re all gray they’re all glass they have no character the other thing I

have no character the other thing I

have no character the other thing I think Shenton d achieved was it it

think Shenton d achieved was it it

think Shenton d achieved was it it demonstrated that no building should

demonstrated that no building should

demonstrated that no building should ever make you feel humble so it opened

ever make you feel humble so it opened

ever make you feel humble so it opened and it was it was a place that was

and it was it was a place that was

and it was it was a place that was architectural e distinguished it had a

architectural e distinguished it had a

architectural e distinguished it had a history and it had a texture and it had

history and it had a texture and it had

history and it had a texture and it had stories and it wasn’t used as a symbol

stories and it wasn’t used as a symbol

stories and it wasn’t used as a symbol of power when you use it like the

of power when you use it like the

of power when you use it like the government every building they built is

government every building they built is

government every building they built is a symbol of power and when you use a

a symbol of power and when you use a

a symbol of power and when you use a building to symbolize power you the

building to symbolize power you the

building to symbolize power you the architecture corrupts and in

architecture corrupts and in

architecture corrupts and in turn the architecture itself is

turn the architecture itself is

turn the architecture itself is corrupted so when I gathered my

corrupted so when I gathered my

corrupted so when I gathered my colleagues around the studio to talk

colleagues around the studio to talk

colleagues around the studio to talk about how you would design a beautiful

about how you would design a beautiful

about how you would design a beautiful romantic alfresco dining area in

romantic alfresco dining area in

romantic alfresco dining area in Shenzhen d they looked at me like what

Shenzhen d they looked at me like what

Shenzhen d they looked at me like what what are you talking about the only

what are you talking about the only

what are you talking about the only public space in my hometown was a

public space in my hometown was a

public space in my hometown was a treeless Plaza used to celebrate

treeless Plaza used to celebrate

treeless Plaza used to celebrate government sponsored events and at the

government sponsored events and at the

government sponsored events and at the apex of that plaza was a great anja

apex of that plaza was a great anja

apex of that plaza was a great anja mental government building if you’ve

mental government building if you’ve

mental government building if you’ve ever studied music you may know that

ever studied music you may know that

ever studied music you may know that sometimes it’s harder to play the space

sometimes it’s harder to play the space

sometimes it’s harder to play the space between the notes than the notes

between the notes than the notes

between the notes than the notes themselves and I think for me who did

themselves and I think for me who did

themselves and I think for me who did study music the notes of their music and

study music the notes of their music and

study music the notes of their music and the sound of the music and the space

the sound of the music and the space

the sound of the music and the space between them are the architecture of

between them are the architecture of

between them are the architecture of music so I think chintan d was the first

music so I think chintan d was the first

music so I think chintan d was the first place in a post Cultural Revolution

place in a post Cultural Revolution

place in a post Cultural Revolution Society of a rising middle class for

Society of a rising middle class for

Society of a rising middle class for people in China I could go and here NC a

people in China I could go and here NC a

people in China I could go and here NC a place they could wander in and out and

place they could wander in and out and

place they could wander in and out and they could shout in the street they

they could shout in the street they

they could shout in the street they could shout by making a parent what

could shout by making a parent what

could shout by making a parent what choices they made about how they lived

choices they made about how they lived

choices they made about how they lived they were literally creating culture at

they were literally creating culture at

they were literally creating culture at the same time they were consuming it and

the same time they were consuming it and

the same time they were consuming it and they did all this without permission

they did all this without permission

they did all this without permission from the cultural Bureau or the Ministry

from the cultural Bureau or the Ministry

from the cultural Bureau or the Ministry of propaganda or the licensing Bureau

of propaganda or the licensing Bureau

of propaganda or the licensing Bureau they did it themselves and that’s why

they did it themselves and that’s why

they did it themselves and that’s why I’m enlightened to see all these people

I’m enlightened to see all these people

I’m enlightened to see all these people here because you’re going to change the

here because you’re going to change the

here because you’re going to change the culture of China and it’s not up to the

culture of China and it’s not up to the

culture of China and it’s not up to the government it’s up to you I asked Vince

government it’s up to you I asked Vince

government it’s up to you I asked Vince at once he has these wings on his logo I

at once he has these wings on his logo I

at once he has these wings on his logo I said what Vince is what inspired you to

said what Vince is what inspired you to

said what Vince is what inspired you to put wings on your company logo and he

put wings on your company logo and he

put wings on your company logo and he said it was a book about a seagull it

said it was a book about a seagull it

said it was a book about a seagull it was not contempt sitting around eating

was not contempt sitting around eating

was not contempt sitting around eating fish heads it was a seagull who believed

fish heads it was a seagull who believed

fish heads it was a seagull who believed that he who flies highest sees the

that he who flies highest sees the

that he who flies highest sees the furthest

furthest

furthest for me that recalcitrant disruptor of a

for me that recalcitrant disruptor of a

for me that recalcitrant disruptor of a seagull named Jonathan Livingston

seagull named Jonathan Livingston

seagull named Jonathan Livingston signified that no bird soars in a calm

signified that no bird soars in a calm

signified that no bird soars in a calm and the Wright brothers right about this

and the Wright brothers right about this

and the Wright brothers right about this phenomena it was to be a pioneer in

phenomena it was to be a pioneer in

phenomena it was to be a pioneer in aviation was incredibly difficult and to

aviation was incredibly difficult and to

aviation was incredibly difficult and to actually design chintan d at least for

actually design chintan d at least for

actually design chintan d at least for me was extraordinarily difficult and so

me was extraordinarily difficult and so

me was extraordinarily difficult and so we had to use whatever we could do we

we had to use whatever we could do we

we had to use whatever we could do we begged we borrowed and we stole ideas

begged we borrowed and we stole ideas

begged we borrowed and we stole ideas you know Steve Jobs said his best ideas

you know Steve Jobs said his best ideas

you know Steve Jobs said his best ideas are the one he stole from somebody so I

are the one he stole from somebody so I

are the one he stole from somebody so I think that you can be a critical

think that you can be a critical

think that you can be a critical identification of Shanghai you can be a

identification of Shanghai you can be a

identification of Shanghai you can be a critic of the commercialization of a

critic of the commercialization of a

critic of the commercialization of a historic neighborhood but Schwindt

historic neighborhood but Schwindt

historic neighborhood but Schwindt indeed did change China and it changed

indeed did change China and it changed

indeed did change China and it changed it by holding out a promise of a better

it by holding out a promise of a better

it by holding out a promise of a better life in a better city and I think for me

life in a better city and I think for me

life in a better city and I think for me no one should have to wait for social

no one should have to wait for social

no one should have to wait for social and justice disguised as a school bus to

and justice disguised as a school bus to

and justice disguised as a school bus to steal away their opportunity to discover

steal away their opportunity to discover

steal away their opportunity to discover the beauty and joy inherent in humane

the beauty and joy inherent in humane

the beauty and joy inherent in humane architecture you know a city is like a

architecture you know a city is like a

architecture you know a city is like a bar or a great cities like a great bar

bar or a great cities like a great bar

bar or a great cities like a great bar it was hemming away who said I go to a

it was hemming away who said I go to a

it was hemming away who said I go to a bar not to get drunk I go to a bar to

bar not to get drunk I go to a bar to

bar not to get drunk I go to a bar to stay drunk and when I was in Cuba a

stay drunk and when I was in Cuba a

stay drunk and when I was in Cuba a couple of weeks ago I went to every bar

couple of weeks ago I went to every bar

couple of weeks ago I went to every bar that I knew that Hemingway had visited

that I knew that Hemingway had visited

that I knew that Hemingway had visited and the one thing all these bars had in

and the one thing all these bars had in

and the one thing all these bars had in common where they were a full of

common where they were a full of

common where they were a full of characters who told great stories about

characters who told great stories about

characters who told great stories about their city it reminds me that that we

their city it reminds me that that we

their city it reminds me that that we who live in cities those same cities

who live in cities those same cities

who live in cities those same cities live in us they are us and so if you

live in us they are us and so if you

live in us they are us and so if you visit chintan d I hope you will visit my

visit chintan d I hope you will visit my

visit chintan d I hope you will visit my bar and I’ll tell you one of my stories

bar and I’ll tell you one of my stories

bar and I’ll tell you one of my stories about being here for 18 years and I hope

about being here for 18 years and I hope

about being here for 18 years and I hope you will share one of your stories with

you will share one of your stories with

you will share one of your stories with me for its those stories and those ideas

me for its those stories and those ideas

me for its those stories and those ideas that I get from other people

that I get from other people

that I get from other people it gives me new ideas for what I do

it gives me new ideas for what I do

it gives me new ideas for what I do thank you very much

thank you very much

thank you very much [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *