Press "Enter" to skip to content

Імітація успішної держави чи ідея суспільного блага? | Андрій Баумейстер | TEDxKyiv


[music]

we all live

states are among the

their successful others

losers in the third

it is simply dangerous to live and

so some

citizens flee from

their countries

the country successfully and those

are forced to pay

a high price for

success but somehow

today the state

nobody canceled and

sooner or later

Every one of us asks

question and why

exist

the state

in what

main objectives

that she personally gives me

if we feel that

Our state does not

successful what you need

to make

change the situation

the answer seems

clear need

mimic successful

samples

you need to mimic that

what works for example

look at Europe and

watch it like this

occurs at them but

the fact is that exactly

European

politic system

today and in general

west system

is very

deep crisis itself

deep since 1945

Imagine

an eye

Europeans in

the fifteenth year

border of Europe

crossed over

million people in

This year, more and

this situation is Europe

faces

whose challenges

before she did not know and

many experts

they say that Europe

risks losing his

let out

let’s imagine

some district of kyiv

for example, shells

differences

where is compact

people from

the Middle East and

africa

several thousand of them

most of them do not

can find

work or does not want

seek work and

contain them and

public

structures and urban

must pay

high enough

finance

also imagine that

your children this school and

they are told to be

be restrained be

are attentive because

what is this other

culture is not

mention that

may be when

some signs

your cultural

identity

for example, do not talk

about christmas

Christmas

gifts at that time

how are these people

quite clearly

religiously

identified

they are with suspicion

are put to secular

culture it is clear that

migration is only

one of the

manifestations of the crisis

but it’s much

Deeper is more

Deep causes of business

in that the system itself

which formed

70th years of the last century

it is this system

now they are not stalling

triggered the

system that can

call the state

manager she

generates several

pathologies I will say 2 2

of them is the economy

exceptions and this

policy exception

what is the economy

Exceptions we

produce products

more than

can be consumed at

this every year from

hunger dies 9

million people this

two holocausts

annually 800 million

people suffer from

hunger about it

recently wrote a book

Argentinian

writer martin

kaparos is his

he was the first to

surprised by this terrible

paradox of the economy

exceptions

it means that

global economy

today serve

interests

billion people

which are traditionally

called sometimes

golden billion

media billion 200

millions of us

today 7 billion

people live on

they are like

thrown out of this

systems are their talents

their efforts are their work

no one needs

for example, if we take

African

continent for

excluding his pf then

what they deliver

African countries

to another world it is in

first priority

raw is oil it

precious metals and

precious stones

more than from these

countries would not

required

here we can ask

question about ourselves what we are

we can give peace but this

slightly different topic

second important point

it’s politics

except that this

means it means

that even successful

countries

distrust of

political elites to

political

institutions

feel that they are not

they hear politicians they

feel that themes

which excite them

very acute topics

which you need

discuss

are hushed up and

politicians and the press

as a result of

strengthen their

position right

radicals and we are now

we see the last year and

it still remains

watch in the future

as right-radical

force gradually

captures sympathy

of their citizens

that they are better

respond to those needs

who are now

arise and now

when we ask

why this system

fails if we

we will try

analyze this

structure literally

in two minutes I would

said so this

system

was formed on

the last

three hundred years and its

the main trend was

harmonization and

bureaucratization

states when

arises

state monster

as he called this a

brain terrible

monster levy

he who must

to pacify and conquer

recalcitrant were three

stages of this development

the first of which is

Westphalian

system of 1648 is

result

religious wars

when arise

sovereign states

when the first time

there is a new map

Europe from the scrappy

diverse

pluralistic

Europe is emerging

monolithic

large state

the second moment is

emergence of

nationalism of early 19

century when

state

is becoming

incarnation

national idea and

finally the third stage

the experience of the twentieth century

when arise

totalitarian regimes and

humanity

going through a terrible

experience of two world

wars as a result of

this 60-ies of the 20th

century occurs on

west idea

very

cautious

value difference

very cautious

complex problems

arises

state

focused on

market standards

where all

formally where all

value neutral

where everyone

a citizen

is provided

opportunity to seek

your happiness and be

happy but exactly

this system

and it fails and when we

today we ask

what should be

we will start the economy

small

reasoning for this

topic with such a metaphor

if the last three hundred

s state

lined up as

rigid vertical

from the horizontal

policy, now we

we need a policy

the network I call it

general

Benefits if in history

similar examples I

call

very important 2 first

of which this is an example

Aristotle, he teaches about

Tom

in its policy that

state

is not simply

for life from to

a good life for

full-fledged life

what he calls

beautiful

activities and it

arises only in

the moment when

arises

unifying idea

general interest

rising above

individual

groups of clans and even

he says of the ethnoses

this she calls

common good

will try

project

this idea in Ukraine we

25 years trying

build

the state but so far

we could not

work out

the idea of ​​the common good before

now the state

substitutes

interests of those or

other clans who

imitate

state

structure is imitated

state

institutions and

as a result, a large

part of citizens

is unnecessary

thrown out of

state

life

Some of us feel

that this state

not for them

Some of them feel

that they are superfluous that they

second-rate people

and therefore if we

talking about our

future near us

should develop this

the idea of ​​a common eye

good that she

connected us

united in a certain

general project two

important important example

it’s medieval

the city is unique

political

structure that

grew from below it and

there is a very

bright this network

policies from below

The fact is that

analogues to this city

was not in either

antiquity is not in

Islamic world and

medieval

the city grows

modern europe and

since the time of the

medieval

cities are growing

university

European science and

here we are talking about

this system when

the vertical should

change

the horizontal is the one

example from which we

now we will draw

own strength that

was a

this city was

alliance of guilds

brotherhoods

called themselves

University of this commune

I and they together

created their

political life

it was very

complex network

religious

political

economic and

legal relations

take an example

some of the guilds

let it be

tanners or suits

the tips you are in front of

you see two

famous portrait

left portrait of the guild

holy bows this

Guild of Artists

architects and

sculptors

it was formed in

In the 15th century, do not call the Rein and

Netherlands

and on the right you see

a portrait of the clothers

what makes a guild in

city children appoint

their representatives

ogidy I

determines the quality

products and methods

its distribution form

organizes schools

hospital shelters

Build Your Temples

bury their dead

eventually

guild merging into

certain common networks

rule the city

remember

centers of European

cities that this is

market that is surrounded by

houses of guilds we

see rathaus town hall we

see the temple and if we

we will go further than we

we can see except

temples and synagogue is

a separate area and all

this demonstrates

some new structure

which then

originated from

network structure

policies among other things

and we in Kiev have

signs and presence

this

full

political life

if we go

now on the Dnieper

We will see the embankment

there is a column

erected

return to Kiev

magdeburg law

really then this

not for very long

existed

signs and such

culture we find

so also in lviv

these are the signs

government and

now ask yourself

how do you like

this structure

would act now

we will take

for example, not a guild

tanners

but the guild of IT specialists

IT people are very

serious people

which can

reside in a separate

district of Kiev for example

on the limes of the hem and

shell

they establish their own

schools they

are in charge of

polyclinic they

organize

cultural and scientific

activities they

take care of patients

take care of the elderly

and they receive from

cities

medieval

terminology charter

or legal

document on

they

think about cleanliness

its streets and

serviceability of houses

about the work of the intro

infrastructure

go further in our

example

let us imagine that

other children begin

cooperate with them

they begin

create a city

self management

they decide the most

important things in life

city and ask ourselves

and then if necessary

policies with their

unrealizable

promises

Russian

doubtful

biographies

with a very tough

hierarchical

structure between

other this problem

our future we

see how much

active talented

of people

manifested itself in

civil and

how hard it is for them

political

structures when

politics eats them

energy does not give them

prove oneself

forcing them to play

by its rules here

this image

medieval

city ​​and ours with you

area of ​​IT and

other areas between

other here on

do you know what

there is a kozhemyakin area

here you are

guild of tanners

near where the streets are

Voloshskaya there and closer

to the hills lived

compact professor

university

Theological Academy

who by the way

contained gardens

fruit contained

scott medics were

family doctors

many friends

there was some

who does not have

community and here to me

it seems that here

first important sign

so the idea of ​​a common

good and idea

corporate idea

mutual support idea

activity

when the policy

emerges from his

hard

prescriptions and

principles and

become something

new what I call

network policy

in this case we

should ask themselves

as we are with you to this

come in

advantage

general welfare policy

imagine two

case one of them you

wage earners you

come to

certain

the collective is not you

determine the rules

behavior in this

you

feel like

if you do not quit at home

any

initiative of you

forced to live on

rules that you

incomprehensible and

are unacceptable to you and

it is clear that your

your talents

creativity then dreams there

nobody cares

you

are interested in these

people as a certain

functions that

carry out those or

Other skills like this

current

state

bureaucracy and now

Imagine that you

are

participants in the general

business

you feel that from

your efforts from your

initiatives from your

talent

the success of this

common cause then in

this situation will

your

your talents

self-fulfillment

each of us then

is a part

general project is that

I call

common good to be

part of the overall project

I think I hope

what do we go for

direction to

To these samples I

now must

ask how is this

achieve what should

Change and here I am

would say of the three

important first steps

should change

the nature of politics

successful countries

Western countries

many citizens already

feel that the old

political parties

do not match their

interests

frankly ask

ourselves each of us

do we find today

in Ukrainian

political Olympus

those political forces

which represented

would our interests here

this is our feeling

is similar to ours

European

neighbors

people educated

proactive

active feel

that in politics they

no one to represent

so often

political parties

traditional seem

old things in

unnecessary

with their

old rubbish

certain ideas and

political show

political

carnivals in which

We are invited

participate

instead should

a new

politics policy

general dialogue

when we are together

solve difficult

social

political

economic life

but this requires that

do something about it

you need to change more

in this direction

should change

nature of the media

because in

lately

in Western countries

experts say

mass media

information is not

can resist

temptation to

manipulate

public opinion

on the one hand this

commercial

structures that

extract

economic success with

the other side is

certain

impact on

Most people

for example albert mountains

once wrote

book attack on the mind

where you showed how

the US

TV affects

Americans and influenced

as long as they do not

recognized the

legitimacy

intrusion

US forces in

Iraq, he says

Unfortunately

television is still

pores of influence in

America despite

then what is society

Complex is more complicated than

us and the connection with this

should change

the nature of the media in which

direction

development direction

developing programs

educational

programs

They have to

contribute

development of culture

dialogue in

hearing another

position because

today in the world except

gap between

rich and poor

the gap is widening

between educated and

uneducated

people and this is still

more threat if in

the world is increasing

quantity

uneducated people

very hard

democratic

structure

These values ​​are

are considered

traditional

European and

finally nature

entities deal in

that we are with you

we understand that

human

education

knowledge information

now limitless and

now the school is

passive perception

the whole flow of knowledge

but the school

they say about it

many spectrum experts

should develop

us culture

analytical

thinking

critical

thinking the ability to lead

discussion skills

create their own

position skill

listen to another

person should be taught

culture and

tolerance and

situation of this

change in nature

policy change

nature of the media focus on

education

change in nature

secondary education

and there should be something

what can we call

broad class

educated

free and

responsible people

sprouts already exist

for example connected

states 8 to 17

percent of people

yourself

presents himself in

courts have their own interests

using lawyers as

consultants I think

what is it good

initiative and behind it

business of the future and here we are

ask ourselves

do we want

change and the second

very important question

which state do we

want to build

Thank you

[applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *