today I’d like to invite you in a journey to show you not judgmentally but
journey to show you not judgmentally but
journey to show you not judgmentally but why we shouldn’t keep wild animals from
why we shouldn’t keep wild animals from
why we shouldn’t keep wild animals from wild species as pets wildlife
wild species as pets wildlife
wild species as pets wildlife trafficking globally encompasses many
trafficking globally encompasses many
trafficking globally encompasses many many ways of exploiting my life as it
many ways of exploiting my life as it
many ways of exploiting my life as it was very well shown here from the
was very well shown here from the
was very well shown here from the production of souvenirs to decoration
production of souvenirs to decoration
production of souvenirs to decoration and food items like religious charms
and food items like religious charms
and food items like religious charms fashion accessories substances you
fashion accessories substances you
fashion accessories substances you supplied the drug industry or cosmetic
supplied the drug industry or cosmetic
supplied the drug industry or cosmetic industry rare animals should supply the
industry rare animals should supply the
industry rare animals should supply the International pet trade for collectors
International pet trade for collectors
International pet trade for collectors in zoos and they legal wild pet trade
in zoos and they legal wild pet trade
in zoos and they legal wild pet trade Brazilians have a strong connection to
Brazilians have a strong connection to
Brazilians have a strong connection to nature and as such they love to have
nature and as such they love to have
nature and as such they love to have wild animals with them in their houses
wild animals with them in their houses
wild animals with them in their houses as an accepted cultural trait so
as an accepted cultural trait so
as an accepted cultural trait so throughout my country from urban centers
throughout my country from urban centers
throughout my country from urban centers to the most remote rural areas the sight
to the most remote rural areas the sight
to the most remote rural areas the sight the bucolic sight of a house displaying
the bucolic sight of a house displaying
the bucolic sight of a house displaying cages without wild animals is very
cages without wild animals is very
cages without wild animals is very common and house owners display their
common and house owners display their
common and house owners display their cages with pride as they show their love
cages with pride as they show their love
cages with pride as they show their love and admiration for nature and the
and admiration for nature and the
and admiration for nature and the animals they usually buy these animals
animals they usually buy these animals
animals they usually buy these animals from normal Street markets and they have
from normal Street markets and they have
from normal Street markets and they have no idea about the relationship with
no idea about the relationship with
no idea about the relationship with buying their dear animals with the
buying their dear animals with the
buying their dear animals with the poaching and wildlife trafficking and
poaching and wildlife trafficking and
poaching and wildlife trafficking and that’s a good Brazilian myself I too
that’s a good Brazilian myself I too
that’s a good Brazilian myself I too have a strong connection to nature and
have a strong connection to nature and
have a strong connection to nature and since my early years I learned from my
since my early years I learned from my
since my early years I learned from my parents a deep love respect and
parents a deep love respect and
parents a deep love respect and admiration for all living things
admiration for all living things
admiration for all living things and I still miss my pet Han today I
and I still miss my pet Han today I
and I still miss my pet Han today I began learning about wildlife
began learning about wildlife
began learning about wildlife trafficking in Brazil when I met
trafficking in Brazil when I met
trafficking in Brazil when I met Organization SOS fauna and their work I
Organization SOS fauna and their work I
Organization SOS fauna and their work I could not get over of the ridiculous
could not get over of the ridiculous
could not get over of the ridiculous volume of animals being illegally
volume of animals being illegally
volume of animals being illegally collected transported sewed and kept
collected transported sewed and kept
collected transported sewed and kept just so that some people could have
just so that some people could have
just so that some people could have their wild pets
their wild pets
their wild pets and as a good example as you see here
and as a good example as you see here
and as a good example as you see here this cargo it was in just one truck and
this cargo it was in just one truck and
this cargo it was in just one truck and it was carrying more than four thousand
it was carrying more than four thousand
it was carrying more than four thousand poached animals to supply the pet trade
poached animals to supply the pet trade
poached animals to supply the pet trade so I had to do something I just could
so I had to do something I just could
so I had to do something I just could not go home and put my head to rest in
not go home and put my head to rest in
not go home and put my head to rest in the pillow at night and I started
the pillow at night and I started
the pillow at night and I started volunteering for the organization so we
volunteering for the organization so we
volunteering for the organization so we don’t have one estimate for from the
don’t have one estimate for from the
don’t have one estimate for from the government and numbers are very hard to
government and numbers are very hard to
government and numbers are very hard to come by
come by
come by but let’s try to choose to make the
but let’s try to choose to make the
but let’s try to choose to make the picture a little bit clearer from 2002
picture a little bit clearer from 2002
picture a little bit clearer from 2002 to 2009 federal triage facilities
to 2009 federal triage facilities
to 2009 federal triage facilities received from collections deliveries and
received from collections deliveries and
received from collections deliveries and seizures more than three hundred and
seizures more than three hundred and
seizures more than three hundred and seven thousand animals all together with
seven thousand animals all together with
seven thousand animals all together with a mean of 38,000 per year however these
a mean of 38,000 per year however these
a mean of 38,000 per year however these numbers may be even bigger as just the
numbers may be even bigger as just the
numbers may be even bigger as just the state of Sao Paulo alone in 2006 seized
state of Sao Paulo alone in 2006 seized
state of Sao Paulo alone in 2006 seized more than 3000 animals also trying to
more than 3000 animals also trying to
more than 3000 animals also trying to use scientific methodology to try to
use scientific methodology to try to
use scientific methodology to try to estimate these numbers two researchers
estimate these numbers two researchers
estimate these numbers two researchers from Brazil analyzed eighth Street
from Brazil analyzed eighth Street
from Brazil analyzed eighth Street markets and they concluded that these
markets and they concluded that these
markets and they concluded that these markets alone could be legally trading
markets alone could be legally trading
markets alone could be legally trading per year more than 50,000 poached birds
per year more than 50,000 poached birds
per year more than 50,000 poached birds valued at six hundred and thirty
valued at six hundred and thirty
valued at six hundred and thirty thousand dollars per year if we remember
thousand dollars per year if we remember
thousand dollars per year if we remember that Brazil has over five thousand
that Brazil has over five thousand
that Brazil has over five thousand cities and each one has at least one of
cities and each one has at least one of
cities and each one has at least one of those markets then we start to be able
those markets then we start to be able
those markets then we start to be able to grasp about the volume we are talking
to grasp about the volume we are talking
to grasp about the volume we are talking about
about
about so withdrawing numerous animals from a
so withdrawing numerous animals from a
so withdrawing numerous animals from a couple of species from nature in a
couple of species from nature in a
couple of species from nature in a regular basis has many consequences and
regular basis has many consequences and
regular basis has many consequences and the most obvious is the lack of animal
the most obvious is the lack of animal
the most obvious is the lack of animal welfare these creatures endure so much
welfare these creatures endure so much
welfare these creatures endure so much suffering through violent collection
suffering through violent collection
suffering through violent collection transportation methods and then enjoy a
transportation methods and then enjoy a
transportation methods and then enjoy a lifetime in captivity without social
lifetime in captivity without social
lifetime in captivity without social interaction or exercise and most times
interaction or exercise and most times
interaction or exercise and most times in places which are humid hot and
in places which are humid hot and
in places which are humid hot and without adequate food sources but there
without adequate food sources but there
without adequate food sources but there are more profound consequences and I’m
are more profound consequences and I’m
are more profound consequences and I’m risking a little bit of an
risking a little bit of an
risking a little bit of an oversimplification here but let’s try to
oversimplification here but let’s try to
oversimplification here but let’s try to understand what this have what happens
understand what this have what happens
understand what this have what happens to the environment when we take animals
to the environment when we take animals
to the environment when we take animals and species that have unique ecological
and species that have unique ecological
and species that have unique ecological roles
roles
roles types of plants growing in the ecosystem
types of plants growing in the ecosystem
types of plants growing in the ecosystem will be altered if seed predation rates
will be altered if seed predation rates
will be altered if seed predation rates change
change
change also if trees depend on any specific
also if trees depend on any specific
also if trees depend on any specific species to disperse their seeds they
species to disperse their seeds they
species to disperse their seeds they will have reduced dispersal capacity and
will have reduced dispersal capacity and
will have reduced dispersal capacity and also the echo system will have decreased
also the echo system will have decreased
also the echo system will have decreased regeneration ability if predators are
regeneration ability if predators are
regeneration ability if predators are missing prey species may experience
missing prey species may experience
missing prey species may experience explosion in populations which can even
explosion in populations which can even
explosion in populations which can even become pasture agriculture on the other
become pasture agriculture on the other
become pasture agriculture on the other hand when prey species are missing
hand when prey species are missing
hand when prey species are missing predators may experience decrease in
predators may experience decrease in
predators may experience decrease in their population sizes which can affect
their population sizes which can affect
their population sizes which can affect all connected species lastly when less
all connected species lastly when less
all connected species lastly when less individuals are left to reproduce this
individuals are left to reproduce this
individuals are left to reproduce this can lead to more genetically similar
can lead to more genetically similar
can lead to more genetically similar populations which in extreme cases can
populations which in extreme cases can
populations which in extreme cases can even contribute to the populations are
even contribute to the populations are
even contribute to the populations are the species extinction some people some
the species extinction some people some
the species extinction some people some among them some researchers who I
among them some researchers who I
among them some researchers who I respect very much have proposed that we
respect very much have proposed that we
respect very much have proposed that we do commercial captive breeding of wild
do commercial captive breeding of wild
do commercial captive breeding of wild species in order to supply demand
species in order to supply demand
species in order to supply demand without exploit nature this obviously
without exploit nature this obviously
without exploit nature this obviously has many advantages as yes in theory it
has many advantages as yes in theory it
has many advantages as yes in theory it could supply demand for wild animals as
could supply demand for wild animals as
could supply demand for wild animals as pets we could learn and acquire precious
pets we could learn and acquire precious
pets we could learn and acquire precious knowledge on how to maintain this
knowledge on how to maintain this
knowledge on how to maintain this species in captivity which could be used
species in captivity which could be used
species in captivity which could be used in future conservation efforts and we
in future conservation efforts and we
in future conservation efforts and we could create an industry with lots of
could create an industry with lots of
could create an industry with lots of jobs however there are disadvantages
jobs however there are disadvantages
jobs however there are disadvantages keeping wild animals in captivity is per
keeping wild animals in captivity is per
keeping wild animals in captivity is per se a source of suffering also being a
se a source of suffering also being a
se a source of suffering also being a relevant business it could also bring
relevant business it could also bring
relevant business it could also bring about many political interests and this
about many political interests and this
about many political interests and this would probably shaped our ultimate goal
would probably shaped our ultimate goal
would probably shaped our ultimate goal of conserving wild species lastly when
of conserving wild species lastly when
of conserving wild species lastly when we do captive breeding of wild animals
we do captive breeding of wild animals
we do captive breeding of wild animals with commercial purposes it becomes very
with commercial purposes it becomes very
with commercial purposes it becomes very difficult to promote effective control
difficult to promote effective control
difficult to promote effective control and law enforcement of this activity
and law enforcement of this activity
and law enforcement of this activity making it very easy and profitable to
making it very easy and profitable to
making it very easy and profitable to make poached animals look like they’re
make poached animals look like they’re
make poached animals look like they’re bred in captivity what we call bird
bred in captivity what we call bird
bred in captivity what we call bird laundering so there is an even worse
laundering so there is an even worse
laundering so there is an even worse problem
problem
problem honest breeders invest great deals of
honest breeders invest great deals of
honest breeders invest great deals of time money and resources to obtain a
time money and resources to obtain a
time money and resources to obtain a limited number of animals for example a
limited number of animals for example a
limited number of animals for example a captive bred blue fronted Amazon can
captive bred blue fronted Amazon can
captive bred blue fronted Amazon can cost around one thousand US dollars in
cost around one thousand US dollars in
cost around one thousand US dollars in Brazil
Brazil
Brazil whereas a poached animal from nature
whereas a poached animal from nature
whereas a poached animal from nature will cost $40 or less so there are way
will cost $40 or less so there are way
will cost $40 or less so there are way fewer people willing to pay so much more
fewer people willing to pay so much more
fewer people willing to pay so much more and what happens is that the bigger
and what happens is that the bigger
and what happens is that the bigger consumer market will not buy the most
consumer market will not buy the most
consumer market will not buy the most expensive animal so these animals with
expensive animal so these animals with
expensive animal so these animals with very different origins and very
very different origins and very
very different origins and very different prices will supply very
different prices will supply very
different prices will supply very different consumer markets so in my
different consumer markets so in my
different consumer markets so in my opinion commercial captive breeding of
opinion commercial captive breeding of
opinion commercial captive breeding of wild species will not have not the
wild species will not have not the
wild species will not have not the ability to supply the big demand and
ability to supply the big demand and
ability to supply the big demand and another problem and let me start with
another problem and let me start with
another problem and let me start with the solutions when animals which were
the solutions when animals which were
the solutions when animals which were illegally traded or kept are seized they
illegally traded or kept are seized they
illegally traded or kept are seized they have to go through very complicated
have to go through very complicated
have to go through very complicated rehabilitation process and absolutely
rehabilitation process and absolutely
rehabilitation process and absolutely cannot be released anywhere or we will
cannot be released anywhere or we will
cannot be released anywhere or we will cause more bad impacts than good ones we
cause more bad impacts than good ones we
cause more bad impacts than good ones we have to make sure they are healthy we
have to make sure they are healthy we
have to make sure they are healthy we have to make sure they exhibit wild
have to make sure they exhibit wild
have to make sure they exhibit wild behaviors we have to make sure that the
behaviors we have to make sure that the
behaviors we have to make sure that the place where releasing them is safe we
place where releasing them is safe we
place where releasing them is safe we don’t want them to be recollected and
don’t want them to be recollected and
don’t want them to be recollected and back in the black market but it has to
back in the black market but it has to
back in the black market but it has to be able to maintain the new individuals
be able to maintain the new individuals
be able to maintain the new individuals as well as the natural populations they
as well as the natural populations they
as well as the natural populations they have to be released in the same biome
have to be released in the same biome
have to be released in the same biome they are collected in for adaptive
they are collected in for adaptive
they are collected in for adaptive reasons and depending on the existence
reasons and depending on the existence
reasons and depending on the existence of different genetic populations within
of different genetic populations within
of different genetic populations within each species they must be released to as
each species they must be released to as
each species they must be released to as close as possible to their true
close as possible to their true
close as possible to their true population of origin or we can cause a
population of origin or we can cause a
population of origin or we can cause a severe decrease in the offsprings
severe decrease in the offsprings
severe decrease in the offsprings adaptive potential following mating with
adaptive potential following mating with
adaptive potential following mating with the local population so I was fortunate
the local population so I was fortunate
the local population so I was fortunate enough to find mentors that fully
enough to find mentors that fully
enough to find mentors that fully supported my ideas after so many knows
supported my ideas after so many knows
supported my ideas after so many knows and you were crazy we decided to I just
and you were crazy we decided to I just
and you were crazy we decided to I just had to do more and we decided that
had to do more and we decided that
had to do more and we decided that together we would develop my PhD
together we would develop my PhD
together we would develop my PhD research in population genetics of some
research in population genetics of some
research in population genetics of some wild birds that are severely exploited
wild birds that are severely exploited
wild birds that are severely exploited in Brazil for the world pet trade so
in Brazil for the world pet trade so
in Brazil for the world pet trade so thank you guys I’ll just show you a
thank you guys I’ll just show you a
thank you guys I’ll just show you a couple of my results among all the piles
couple of my results among all the piles
couple of my results among all the piles of data that we generated so meet the
of data that we generated so meet the
of data that we generated so meet the red card Cardinal
they are very appreciated for their
they are very appreciated for their beauty and their songs so I decided to
beauty and their songs so I decided to
beauty and their songs so I decided to study the species to see if we could
study the species to see if we could
study the species to see if we could find different genetic populations
find different genetic populations
find different genetic populations within each one and see the level of
within each one and see the level of
within each one and see the level of threat or if we could pinpoint the
threat or if we could pinpoint the
threat or if we could pinpoint the origin of animal see with a known origin
origin of animal see with a known origin
origin of animal see with a known origin ironically enough we found a different
ironically enough we found a different
ironically enough we found a different populations in the species we did not
populations in the species we did not
populations in the species we did not expect to find but we did not find them
expect to find but we did not find them
expect to find but we did not find them in these species we expect to find them
in these species we expect to find them
in these species we expect to find them so it changed a little bit the way we
so it changed a little bit the way we
so it changed a little bit the way we solve these species
this has complicated implications but
this has complicated implications but broadly it means that releasing the
broadly it means that releasing the
broadly it means that releasing the south patters back in the wild should be
south patters back in the wild should be
south patters back in the wild should be respirable problematic concerning the
respirable problematic concerning the
respirable problematic concerning the genetics criterion I just mentioned then
genetics criterion I just mentioned then
genetics criterion I just mentioned then releasing the red card Cardinals here
releasing the red card Cardinals here
releasing the red card Cardinals here the three populations of Cardinals that
the three populations of Cardinals that
the three populations of Cardinals that we were able to describe and we would
we were able to describe and we would
we were able to describe and we would like to know if we could infer the most
like to know if we could infer the most
like to know if we could infer the most likely origin of some animals seized in
likely origin of some animals seized in
likely origin of some animals seized in some problem this test still need to be
some problem this test still need to be
some problem this test still need to be refined but they indicate that these
refined but they indicate that these
refined but they indicate that these animals are probably most likely from a
animals are probably most likely from a
animals are probably most likely from a population the Northeast that is known
population the Northeast that is known
population the Northeast that is known to be a collection hotspot so data like
to be a collection hotspot so data like
to be a collection hotspot so data like this alone will not provide a final
this alone will not provide a final
this alone will not provide a final answer but along with other sources of
answer but along with other sources of
answer but along with other sources of information may provide a good
information may provide a good
information may provide a good indication and a good help for the
indication and a good help for the
indication and a good help for the decision making process not only for
decision making process not only for
decision making process not only for privation prevention efforts but for
privation prevention efforts but for
privation prevention efforts but for releasing in a technique technically
releasing in a technique technically
releasing in a technique technically responsible way but towards the end of
responsible way but towards the end of
responsible way but towards the end of my PhD I wanted to do everything but
my PhD I wanted to do everything but
my PhD I wanted to do everything but writing the thesis too much the despair
writing the thesis too much the despair
writing the thesis too much the despair of my advisors so I was still not happy
of my advisors so I was still not happy
of my advisors so I was still not happy because I felt my work was really
because I felt my work was really
because I felt my work was really localized and still small so I went on
localized and still small so I went on
localized and still small so I went on and along with Freeland Foundation from
and along with Freeland Foundation from
and along with Freeland Foundation from Southeast Asia
Southeast Asia
Southeast Asia I started Freeland Brasil trying to
I started Freeland Brasil trying to
I started Freeland Brasil trying to organize the work I was doing and
organize the work I was doing and
organize the work I was doing and broaden the impact so we work now with
broaden the impact so we work now with
broaden the impact so we work now with three pillars trying to accomplish a
three pillars trying to accomplish a
three pillars trying to accomplish a comprehensive set of actions against
comprehensive set of actions against
comprehensive set of actions against wildlife trafficking in Brazil so the
wildlife trafficking in Brazil so the
wildlife trafficking in Brazil so the first one education and awareness ow
first one education and awareness ow
first one education and awareness ow amazing the brick of our civilization
amazing the brick of our civilization
amazing the brick of our civilization but a little bit too long term for us
but a little bit too long term for us
but a little bit too long term for us but in this component among other
but in this component among other
but in this component among other projects we are Co producing a feature
projects we are Co producing a feature
projects we are Co producing a feature film documentary on wild animal
film documentary on wild animal
film documentary on wild animal trafficking in Brazil Kiki Nemo –
trafficking in Brazil Kiki Nemo –
trafficking in Brazil Kiki Nemo – masseur Tufano Trasolini allegorical
masseur Tufano Trasolini allegorical
masseur Tufano Trasolini allegorical stonagal
les pasado por todas aquellas Eva’s
les pasado por todas aquellas Eva’s Portola kita prisons en cap rezones low
Portola kita prisons en cap rezones low
Portola kita prisons en cap rezones low as possible
as possible
as possible SB twice Christmas are you Victor
so this should launch a beginning of
so this should launch a beginning of next year
next year
next year also that was not enough yet so off we
also that was not enough yet so off we
also that was not enough yet so off we went to launch research a mitigation of
went to launch research a mitigation of
went to launch research a mitigation of impact where a student is analyzing the
impact where a student is analyzing the
impact where a student is analyzing the mitochondrial DNA of the cell cottage to
mitochondrial DNA of the cell cottage to
mitochondrial DNA of the cell cottage to see if my results can be corroborated
see if my results can be corroborated
see if my results can be corroborated and I hope to start my post PhD next
and I hope to start my post PhD next
and I hope to start my post PhD next semester developing paternity tests
semester developing paternity tests
semester developing paternity tests which will be able to be used in
which will be able to be used in
which will be able to be used in commercial bird breeders to help law
commercial bird breeders to help law
commercial bird breeders to help law enforcement detect poached animals we
enforcement detect poached animals we
enforcement detect poached animals we also collaborate in responsible releases
also collaborate in responsible releases
also collaborate in responsible releases such as this done by the organization as
such as this done by the organization as
such as this done by the organization as well as found in which ad blue frontier
well as found in which ad blue frontier
well as found in which ad blue frontier Amazon’s were returned to nature
Amazon’s were returned to nature
Amazon’s were returned to nature following most of all those criteria I
following most of all those criteria I
following most of all those criteria I just showed you this was only a couple
just showed you this was only a couple
just showed you this was only a couple of years ago
that’s me almost crying behind so if
that’s me almost crying behind so if you’re asking yourself how well that
you’re asking yourself how well that
you’re asking yourself how well that went
went
went how about this and this but that was not
how about this and this but that was not
how about this and this but that was not enough see not enough so off we went
enough see not enough so off we went
enough see not enough so off we went to capacity enhancement and articulation
to capacity enhancement and articulation
to capacity enhancement and articulation where we work with agents involved in
where we work with agents involved in
where we work with agents involved in combating wildlife trafficking and
combating wildlife trafficking and
combating wildlife trafficking and provide training courses and workshops
provide training courses and workshops
provide training courses and workshops the next ones all aligned is one with
the next ones all aligned is one with
the next ones all aligned is one with the prosecutor’s office from San Paolo
the prosecutor’s office from San Paolo
the prosecutor’s office from San Paolo where they will launch a national
where they will launch a national
where they will launch a national prosecutors Task Force against wildlife
prosecutors Task Force against wildlife
prosecutors Task Force against wildlife trafficking in Brazil and we will bring
trafficking in Brazil and we will bring
trafficking in Brazil and we will bring South American prosecutors to develop
South American prosecutors to develop
South American prosecutors to develop international agreements on how we can
international agreements on how we can
international agreements on how we can better cooperate against wildlife
better cooperate against wildlife
better cooperate against wildlife trafficking regionally and how we can
trafficking regionally and how we can
trafficking regionally and how we can join the global efforts we also have an
join the global efforts we also have an
join the global efforts we also have an aligned workshop with the Brazilian
aligned workshop with the Brazilian
aligned workshop with the Brazilian Federal Police on wildlife forensics and
Federal Police on wildlife forensics and
Federal Police on wildlife forensics and best practices lastly we are producing
best practices lastly we are producing
best practices lastly we are producing with SOS fauna post-seizure procedures
with SOS fauna post-seizure procedures
with SOS fauna post-seizure procedures guides on how to radically decrease the
guides on how to radically decrease the
guides on how to radically decrease the death rate both after the animals are
death rate both after the animals are
death rate both after the animals are seized by law enforcement by taking very
seized by law enforcement by taking very
seized by law enforcement by taking very simple and cheap measures just like this
simple and cheap measures just like this
simple and cheap measures just like this animal likes cold this animal hates heat
animal likes cold this animal hates heat
animal likes cold this animal hates heat and etc but that’s not enough so my next
and etc but that’s not enough so my next
and etc but that’s not enough so my next goal is to get involved with efforts to
goal is to get involved with efforts to
goal is to get involved with efforts to change the Brazilian environmental
change the Brazilian environmental
change the Brazilian environmental legislation and try to encompass
legislation and try to encompass
legislation and try to encompass wildlife trafficking as a full crime
wildlife trafficking as a full crime
wildlife trafficking as a full crime because believe it or not it doesn’t so
because believe it or not it doesn’t so
because believe it or not it doesn’t so if your country legislation is anything
if your country legislation is anything
if your country legislation is anything like ours tell your lawmakers you want
like ours tell your lawmakers you want
like ours tell your lawmakers you want to change it and encompass wildlife
to change it and encompass wildlife
to change it and encompass wildlife trafficking as a full crime as it is a
trafficking as a full crime as it is a
trafficking as a full crime as it is a crime against humanity these animals are
crime against humanity these animals are
crime against humanity these animals are being withdrawn from the environment in
being withdrawn from the environment in
being withdrawn from the environment in a regular basis to be people’s pets
a regular basis to be people’s pets
a regular basis to be people’s pets should we maintain the so called
should we maintain the so called
should we maintain the so called cultural habit just because we’re used
cultural habit just because we’re used
cultural habit just because we’re used to it is this
to it is this
to it is this if commercial captive breeding of wild
if commercial captive breeding of wild
if commercial captive breeding of wild animals makes law enforcement and
animals makes law enforcement and
animals makes law enforcement and protecting our biodiversity more
protecting our biodiversity more
protecting our biodiversity more difficult should we do this just because
difficult should we do this just because
difficult should we do this just because so just so that some people can fulfill
so just so that some people can fulfill
so just so that some people can fulfill their desire of owning a wild animal
their desire of owning a wild animal
their desire of owning a wild animal if we fail consequences may be Savior
if we fail consequences may be Savior
if we fail consequences may be Savior and even not fixable
and even not fixable
and even not fixable cultures are dynamic and can and must
cultures are dynamic and can and must
cultures are dynamic and can and must evolve so I’d say no these animals and
evolve so I’d say no these animals and
evolve so I’d say no these animals and all endless forms most beautiful and
all endless forms most beautiful and
all endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful should be out in a
most wonderful should be out in a
most wonderful should be out in a healthy and dynamic environment
healthy and dynamic environment
healthy and dynamic environment fulfilling their ecological roles and
fulfilling their ecological roles and
fulfilling their ecological roles and their evolutionary roles as species that
their evolutionary roles as species that
their evolutionary roles as species that evolved over time thank
”
Be First to Comment