an awful lot about these animals
but there is a lot more waiting to be revealed.
There lies endless potential for discovery
and maybe for enlightenment.
( applause )
These are, arguably,
the most intelligent animals in the ocean.
And with this story I’ve worked with five different species
of dolphins in nine locations
around the world and I wanted to make photos
that would allow us to see into the dolphins’ world.
You know, just parts of the dolphin world.
There is so much that we don’t know.
After spending probably two years on this subject,
I’ve come to the conclusion that there is far more
that we don’t know about these dolphin minds than we do.
But we have seen ways that they can be smart.
So that’s what I wanted to show you tonight is
a look at some of the ways dolphins are smart.
And I have a small video, a short video here,
that frames this subject sort of nicely.
It’s narrated by Dr. Diana Reese,
who is a dolphin researcher and especially articulate
on this subject.
( music )
Dr. Diana Reiss: The challenge is to understand
this kind of intelligence.
I talk about dolphins as a non-terrestrial intelligence.
These are totally aquatic mammals with big brains.
And I think we often get stuck with
looking for intelligence through our human lens.
We see it the way we expect it to be
rather than thinking about
what are the sensory systems of these animals,
what are the environmental and social pressures
that they face in their daily lives
and thinking about their intelligence like that.
Interestingly, they show so many things
that are similar to what we do,
like mirror self-recognition.
Like being able to learn vocally.
Their vocal behavior.
We learn different things
by studying animals out here in the wild
and in aquaria.
And it’s the marriage of those two approaches
that gives us the richest picture
of what’s going on in the minds of these animals,
in the lives of these animals.
These are societies in the sea.
What are these big beautiful minds doing?
These are highly complex, they are packed with neurons.
They’ve got brains second to ours in size.
What are they doing out here with them?
And how do they use them?
The researcher and the species
that has been studied the longest
is the spotted dolphin that we see here.
And they’ve been studied by a researcher
named Dr. Denise Herzing
who for, about 30 years now
has been collecting data on the spotted dolphins
of the Bahamas.
This is Denise right here.
She has, sort of, been called the Jane Goodall of the sea
for her three decades of work getting to know
over three generations of dolphins.
And during that time, she’s correlated,
among the research she’s done,
she’s correlated dolphin sounds
with behaviors to try to unlock
the mysteries of their communication.
Very exciting stuff.
In this photo, that’s Denise on the right of the frame there,
she is wearing something that she developed
called the CHAT. C-H-A-T.
Which stands for Cetacean Hearing and Telemetry.
It’s essentially a computer that she can wear underwater
that’s capable of both transmitting
and receiving dolphin vocalizations.
When that CHAT box recognizes
one of the pre-programmed sounds
that she has put in there after decades of research,
a human voice translates the sound into Denise’s headset.
So she’s got certain words
that she knows the dolphin has said,
you know, so, sargassum seed or if she brings a rope
or a scarf into the water,
she tries to do that. And she can also
type on a keyboard words out to the dolphin.
So signature whistles
and different dialects that she has, sort of, identified.
So, this is really the only…
only the very beginning but what she’s hoping for, in time,
is to develop true
two-way communication with dolphins.
You know, kind of a dolphin Rosetta Stone
is what she has developed here.
There’s only three of these in existence.
And, as I said, she is just getting started.
Dolphin research in the wild is very difficult.
And because of this,
a number of researchers study captive animals.
Now there is certainly no shortage of
controversy when it comes to the subject of captive dolphins.
None of the researches that we worked with,
that I worked with on this story, would support,
you know, catching wild dolphins these days for aquariums.
This was a very old bottle-nose dolphin
that I photographed in Vallejo, California at Six Flags.
He was playing with his Batman basketball here,
a little cognitive stimulation.
But it was in that facility
that a researcher named Dr. Stan Kuczaj
from the University of Mississippi
had an experiment.
He created a maze out of PVC pipe.
It was similar to finger mazes
that chimpanzees have been used with
over the years. And the way this worked is
he made a gelatin ball…
That’s the yellow gelatin ball.
…and he would drop in the top of the PVC pipe at the top.
And then the dolphin had to figure out
how to get it out the bottom.
It would use its rostrum to, sort of, poke it
and prod it along and then get it out.
Well, the dolphin figured this out
in about a second and a half. It took no time at all.
And then once it came out the bottom
the dolphin could eat it.
So it was a little bit of a reward.
So, Stan then created another experiment
with dolphins that he works with in Key Largo, Florida.
He took another piece of PVC,
a PVC tube and he glued an end cap to it.
And on the other end cap it wasn’t glued.
It would just, sort of, fit snugly on the other end.
And he put fish inside.
He showed the dolphins that there were fish inside.
And he had ropes on either end.
And the theory here was that
the dolphins would have to communicate.
They’d have to not only problem solve,
but they’d have to communicate and work cooperatively
in tandem to figure this out.
So, he showed it to them and threw it in the water.
And as you can see the dolphins, again, really…
It maybe took a minute and half this time.
But once again nailed it.
One would hold it while the other one pulled the rope.
And then they had the fish,
they popped out and they could sort of
enjoy the spoils of their victory here.
So, very, very smart.
He, as a cognitive biologist,
has worked with many different animals.
He was quite surprised at just how quickly
they would figure this stuff out.
Um… Another place that Stan
is working with captive dolphins
is in Honduras. On the island of Roatán.
Because it’s so large and because there’s 30 dolphins,
and there are so many dolphins,
that scientists can observe, sort of, natural alliances
that are formed. Social behaviors.
But, you know, groups would form little cliques,
males fighting with each other, mating groups and so forth.
Quite interesting.
You know, the way they raise revenue at this place,
or places like this, is through these dolphin experiences,
where tourists can come down mostly off cruise ships,
and have these, sort of, little interactions with dolphins.
It’s not my cup of tea, not the kind of thing that
I would really advocate.
But the interesting experiment beyond the social stuff
that Stan is doing down there
is something he calls the Dolphin Reading Program,
where he has a series of symbols,
black symbols on white slates,
that are supposed to indicate individual behaviors.
And he shows the dolphin the slate,
and then using hand signals,
tells the dolphin what they are supposed to do.
So, in this case,
the down arrow just very simply means
the dolphin is supposed to submerge.
Well, that’s how it begins
but then he stops doing the hand signal.
So, weeks later, he will come back
and just show the two-dimensional slate
to the dolphin and it has to be able to read.
And, you know, in terms of science,
I guess that’s a rather big deal.
That a dolphin can read a symbol,
remember it off a two-dimensional slate,
not a trainer telling them what to do,
and then perform that action.
Well, again the dolphins did it quite well.
Some better than others. I mean, it seems like,
you know, the juveniles were a little more
playful or whatever. But if you get the right animal
it really understood this.
And here we see the dolphin nailing it one more time.
I, on the other hand, had a hell of a time
trying to get that line straight
as I was trying to shoot this split-shot here
and not have water drops on Stan’s face
that made him look like he was melting from acid but…
Anyway, well the captive stuff was interesting
but, as always, I just wanted to get out into the wild.
Because this is, you know, where it happens for me…
One of those species I photographed
was the spinner dolphins in Hawaii.
These are animals that are known for their aerobatic,
you know, leaps and spins. Probably to shake parasites.
I think they do it just because they can but…
These are some of the most social of all dolphin species.
You almost never see a single animal out there,
or even a group of three or four.
They’re always in these very big groups.
It’s also the only, well, one of the few dolphins,
that has never successfully been kept in captivity
because they need that social stimulation.
They need to be with big pods as we see here.
One of the behaviors that I was really hoping to photograph
but didn’t know if I was gonna be successful,
was game play with dolphins.
Particularly with the spinner dolphins.
I had heard that sometimes you can see them
playing games with leaves that fall into the water.
They’ll pick up a leaf, as we saw in the video,
on their pectoral fin or their tail
or their dorsal fin and then they swim through the water
and then they pass it to one another in this,
you know, morning game of catch.
So this one particular morning,
most of the times I was working off of boats,
but this one morning I went in from a little cove off
the island of Kona, the big island,
and I swam out. It was early in the morning
and I was just blown away.
I saw these three spinner dolphins
that were just adorned with leaves.
They were playing with these leaves.
One on its dorsal, tail and pectoral.
And light levels were very low, so I, sort of, boosted the ISO
and was able to make this picture of them playing catch.
Well, one of the other things that I wanted to focus on
with this story about how dolphins are smart
was to look at feeding strategies.
Because unlike many other animals,
dolphins have developed unique feeding strategies
depending where in the world they’re located geographically.
They have invented these ways of feeding
that are quite interesting.
In the Bahamas,
bottle-nose dolphins have developed a strategy
known as crater-feeding.
They use their echo location, their sonar, to find little fish
that are hiding under the sand and when they find a fish,
they position their body vertically
and, sort of, dig with their rostrum
down into the sand, creating this crater.
It’s like seeing a dolphin growing out of
the bottom of the ocean here when you swim down like this.
So, again, this is all free diving
down about 30 feet trying to be stealthy
to get close enough to get a picture like this.
In Florida, bottle-nose dolphins have developed
a completely different feeding strategy.
This is in Florida Bay, near the Everglades,
where these dolphins have developed something
called mud-ring feeding.
And the way this works is
a single dolphin will make a perfect mud ring
around a school of fish and he does that by,
it’s in very shallow water
and he’ll swim around using his tail
to disturb the mud, making little plumes of mud,
eventually encircling the fish.
And the fish will freak out
but they won’t swim through the mud ring
they actually leap over.
So his buddies who are waiting out there, with their…
with their mouths open and then he comes around too.
And you know, the fish literally jump right into their mouths.
This stuff had never been photographed before.
I was able to do this from a helicopter
with a 500 millimeter lens
and I used this steadying device called the glide-cam
that actually allowed me to shoot
with that one lens from a moving helicopter.
Pretty interesting stuff.
In Patagonia, Argentina,
I wanted to work with dusky dolphins
because I knew that dusky dolphins
have a strategy where they use communication
in a cooperative feeding event,
where they will use the sound
to create bait-balls of anchovies.
There is lot of anchovies in the Gulf of Nuevo here.
And they also do this leaping behavior,
not unlike the spinners,
but they’ll leap out of the water.
Scientists tell us that that’s for two reasons.
One, is to create a splash
that scares the fish into these tight balls.
But it also evidently calls
dolphins from across the bay to come and help
in this feast.
So the water here is temperate water.
It’s quite cold. And when I was there,
it was really thick with plankton and algae.
The visibility wasn’t that good.
Very tricky to photograph these highly contrasted dolphins
but that was the behavior I wanted to photograph,
This cooperative feeding.
So, I spent three weeks in Patagonia
and I didn’t see anything until the very last day.
It was literally the last ten minutes of the last day.
I way out in the Gulf in a small boat
and was pretty much ready to give up and surrender,
and we saw birds working.
And the captain of the boat said
“I think something must be happening, Brian.”
So, with a little 30 foot cubic bottle on my back, I dove down.
And I came upon this scene where we had six dusky dolphins
feeding cooperatively. I got there sort of at the tail end.
But you still see a little ball of anchovies here.
And the dolphin at the bottom was just about to pick off
one of the anchovies. All the white particles there…
Those are fish scales.
And, there is a penguin, a magellanic penguin
that had an anchovy in his mouth that was down there.
And even a sheer water bird that was diving down.
Everything joins in on this feast.
So sometimes things do go right.
A bit of serendipity here. But all… all good.
Well, the last species of dolphins
that I wanted to share with you tonight,
and the last feeding strategy actually,
occurs with the biggest and most intelligent
species of dolphin and that is the orca.
So to photograph this unique strategy,
I returned to Patagonia a year later,
at a different part of Patagonia,
this was Punta Norte in the Valdes Peninsula.
And it was a strategy known as a stranding behavior for orcas.
This is the object of their desire:
The little sea lion pups that are born in January
and about by April,
they begin testing the waters
and going in and sea lion pup is what’s for dinner.
This is the only place in the world
where these orcas have developed this strategy
where they will actually come up on the beach.
And almost strand themselves
to try and catch one of these sea lion pups.
It was amazing to see this.
They have to be very resourceful to do it because
it can only happen when the tide is high.
They don’t want to get stranded at low tide.
It can only happen in places where
there’s, sort of, a natural channel
where they can do that.
The pups have to be there, and sort of in the surf zone.
They can’t expend a lot of energy,
you know, wasted energy to do this.
But here you see one of those orcas very close to shore
in this jade colored sea here,
just sort of cruising along.
And when the moment is right,
that orca will just turn on a dime
and just come racing in.
And the pups, you know, are just clueless.
They have no idea what’s happening.
It’s like, “Oh, are you my friend?”
You know, and this thing is just waiting under the waves here.
And this is the next frame
in the sequence a millisecond later.
By that time the pups usually figure it out but it’s–
it’s usually too late
and they will just kind of race right in and grab them.
And sometimes the females, this is largely done by females,
and they’ll take the pup out while it’s still alive
and they actually play with it off shore.
It’s, kind of, this gruesome game
where they’ll flip it up with their tail.
That little pup is actually screaming,
you can see the mouth is open.
And it’s teaching, the orca is teaching it’s calf,
it’s a calf on the left of the frame there.
So, this is all learned behavior.
You know, this is what dolphins do.
It’s not inherent in their DNA.
It’s moms teaching calves and sort of this culture,
if we can use that word, where they’re passing this on
to the next generation.
But you know, sometimes they are not successful
and I guess nature gives and takes.
And we see, one of the pups here getting away
and the orca has to wiggle its way back into the ocean
and try for another day.
A happy ending for the seal–
seal pup fans in the audience here. So…
In closing, we slip back beneath the surface
looking into the eyes of dolphins
and can’t help but wonder how much more do they know.
What are they really thinking?
Researchers have told us
an awful lot about these animals and
about the entire ocean for that matter.
But there’s a lot more waiting to be revealed.
Within the sea,
there lies endless potential for discovery
and, maybe, for enlightenment.
Thanks very much.
( applause )
”
Be First to Comment