Press "Enter" to skip to content

Designing good urbanism | Lucas Boyd | TEDxYale


[Music]

[Music] with the unprecedented migration of the

with the unprecedented migration of the

with the unprecedented migration of the world’s population into cities we have

world’s population into cities we have

world’s population into cities we have the opportunity to rethink a variety of

the opportunity to rethink a variety of

the opportunity to rethink a variety of urban issues among the most pressing of

urban issues among the most pressing of

urban issues among the most pressing of these is the provision of affordable

these is the provision of affordable

these is the provision of affordable housing

housing

housing now communities around the world have

now communities around the world have

now communities around the world have responded with both inventive topologies

responded with both inventive topologies

responded with both inventive topologies and inspiring public action but what

and inspiring public action but what

and inspiring public action but what continues to be proven as the most

continues to be proven as the most

continues to be proven as the most critical factor is the way in which

critical factor is the way in which

critical factor is the way in which these two interact

these two interact

these two interact now housing or the home is a cultural

now housing or the home is a cultural

now housing or the home is a cultural concept and it’s one that differs

concept and it’s one that differs

concept and it’s one that differs greatly from place to place in the

greatly from place to place in the

greatly from place to place in the United States property ownership or the

United States property ownership or the

United States property ownership or the asset that is one’s home carries with it

asset that is one’s home carries with it

asset that is one’s home carries with it immense historical significance the

immense historical significance the

immense historical significance the house and the land that it sits on is a

house and the land that it sits on is a

house and the land that it sits on is a primary symbol of the American Dream and

primary symbol of the American Dream and

primary symbol of the American Dream and the obtaining of it is the most

the obtaining of it is the most

the obtaining of it is the most prominent rite of passage into the

prominent rite of passage into the

prominent rite of passage into the middle class for the better part of a

middle class for the better part of a

middle class for the better part of a century this has represented the

century this has represented the

century this has represented the majority of American households while

majority of American households while

majority of American households while various forms of subsidized means have

various forms of subsidized means have

various forms of subsidized means have been used to house the less fortunate

been used to house the less fortunate

been used to house the less fortunate the gap in between these two initially

the gap in between these two initially

the gap in between these two initially intended to be quite modest and occupied

intended to be quite modest and occupied

intended to be quite modest and occupied by things like market rent was to

by things like market rent was to

by things like market rent was to operate as a bridge allowing movement

operate as a bridge allowing movement

operate as a bridge allowing movement from one side to the other but as home

from one side to the other but as home

from one side to the other but as home prices have risen on one side and the

prices have risen on one side and the

prices have risen on one side and the means available for subsidy have

means available for subsidy have

means available for subsidy have decreased on the other that gap has

decreased on the other that gap has

decreased on the other that gap has grown far too large and any opportunity

grown far too large and any opportunity

grown far too large and any opportunity for lateral movement has all but

for lateral movement has all but

for lateral movement has all but disappeared what exactly do we mean when

disappeared what exactly do we mean when

disappeared what exactly do we mean when we say affordable housing

to provide a little context this is

to provide a little context this is Jeffrey he makes thirty thirty two

Jeffrey he makes thirty thirty two

Jeffrey he makes thirty thirty two thousand dollars a year which places him

thousand dollars a year which places him

thousand dollars a year which places him roughly right in the middle of the

roughly right in the middle of the

roughly right in the middle of the second quintile for decades housing the

second quintile for decades housing the

second quintile for decades housing the least affluent forty percent of

least affluent forty percent of

least affluent forty percent of Americans like Jeffrey has primarily

Americans like Jeffrey has primarily

Americans like Jeffrey has primarily been the responsibility of government

been the responsibility of government

been the responsibility of government agencies such as municipal housing

agencies such as municipal housing

agencies such as municipal housing organizations these groups generally

organizations these groups generally

organizations these groups generally speaking defined affordability as

speaking defined affordability as

speaking defined affordability as spending less than thirty percent of a

spending less than thirty percent of a

spending less than thirty percent of a household’s income on accommodations

household’s income on accommodations

household’s income on accommodations this is often surprising because by that

this is often surprising because by that

this is often surprising because by that definition that’s a lot of people not

definition that’s a lot of people not

definition that’s a lot of people not just the poorest of the poor so further

just the poorest of the poor so further

just the poorest of the poor so further dependent on income spending more than

dependent on income spending more than

dependent on income spending more than this can qualify a family for any number

this can qualify a family for any number

this can qualify a family for any number of programs whether it be subsidized

of programs whether it be subsidized

of programs whether it be subsidized rents tax credits housing vouchers all

rents tax credits housing vouchers all

rents tax credits housing vouchers all of which are administered by these

of which are administered by these

of which are administered by these groups now the physical infrastructure

groups now the physical infrastructure

groups now the physical infrastructure that a system like this can afford is

that a system like this can afford is

that a system like this can afford is often quite poor for on top of

often quite poor for on top of

often quite poor for on top of allocating and distributing these

allocating and distributing these

allocating and distributing these subsidies they have to act as real

subsidies they have to act as real

subsidies they have to act as real estate agents developers landlords and

estate agents developers landlords and

estate agents developers landlords and all the other roles that go into mass

all the other roles that go into mass

all the other roles that go into mass housing on the other hand the

housing on the other hand the

housing on the other hand the overwhelming majority of owner-occupied

overwhelming majority of owner-occupied

overwhelming majority of owner-occupied housing in the United States has been

housing in the United States has been

housing in the United States has been produced by merchant builders who by way

produced by merchant builders who by way

produced by merchant builders who by way of consolidating all aspects of

of consolidating all aspects of

of consolidating all aspects of development and simple economies of

development and simple economies of

development and simple economies of scale are able to produce a lot of

scale are able to produce a lot of

scale are able to produce a lot of housing very efficiently not

housing very efficiently not

housing very efficiently not surprisingly with the onset of the home

surprisingly with the onset of the home

surprisingly with the onset of the home as an asset the bulk of innovation

as an asset the bulk of innovation

as an asset the bulk of innovation that’s available in the industry has

that’s available in the industry has

that’s available in the industry has been concentrated on the production and

been concentrated on the production and

been concentrated on the production and marketing of housing to those that can

marketing of housing to those that can

marketing of housing to those that can afford it inexpensive housing is simply

afford it inexpensive housing is simply

afford it inexpensive housing is simply not as lucrative as luxury apartments

not as lucrative as luxury apartments

not as lucrative as luxury apartments and housing built for sale even at its

and housing built for sale even at its

and housing built for sale even at its cheapest it’s still far too expensive

cheapest it’s still far too expensive

cheapest it’s still far too expensive for people like Jeffrey but what if it

for people like Jeffrey but what if it

for people like Jeffrey but what if it wasn’t what if we could develop

wasn’t what if we could develop

wasn’t what if we could develop affordable housing models that take

affordable housing models that take

affordable housing models that take advantage of the commodification of the

advantage of the commodification of the

advantage of the commodification of the home in ways that not only generate

home in ways that not only generate

home in ways that not only generate wealth but

wealth but

wealth but produce healthier cities I think this is

produce healthier cities I think this is

produce healthier cities I think this is possible and I think at the root of it

possible and I think at the root of it

possible and I think at the root of it is building design in its capacity to

is building design in its capacity to

is building design in its capacity to respond to both the social and economic

respond to both the social and economic

respond to both the social and economic realities of the 21st century home in

realities of the 21st century home in

realities of the 21st century home in other words rather than continuing to

other words rather than continuing to

other words rather than continuing to value engineer buildings that reflect an

value engineer buildings that reflect an

value engineer buildings that reflect an increasingly antiquated view of

increasingly antiquated view of

increasingly antiquated view of domesticity we could begin leveraging

domesticity we could begin leveraging

domesticity we could begin leveraging contemporary lifestyles and tailoring

contemporary lifestyles and tailoring

contemporary lifestyles and tailoring our buildings to the new emerging more

our buildings to the new emerging more

our buildings to the new emerging more affordable ways of living so what would

affordable ways of living so what would

affordable ways of living so what would this actually look like I’d like to

this actually look like I’d like to

this actually look like I’d like to suggest three levels at which changes

suggest three levels at which changes

suggest three levels at which changes could be made first policy public

could be made first policy public

could be made first policy public efforts have gradually recognized the

efforts have gradually recognized the

efforts have gradually recognized the advantages of the private sector and we

advantages of the private sector and we

advantages of the private sector and we need to continue to promote affordable

need to continue to promote affordable

need to continue to promote affordable housing as a developer friendly endeavor

housing as a developer friendly endeavor

housing as a developer friendly endeavor not just an obligatory afterthought this

not just an obligatory afterthought this

not just an obligatory afterthought this means rather than simply helping Jeffrey

means rather than simply helping Jeffrey

means rather than simply helping Jeffrey pay his rent we incentivize the building

pay his rent we incentivize the building

pay his rent we incentivize the building of homes that target a price that he can

of homes that target a price that he can

of homes that target a price that he can afford but we also need to be open to

afford but we also need to be open to

afford but we also need to be open to new potentially more accessible forms of

new potentially more accessible forms of

new potentially more accessible forms of this rather established method for

this rather established method for

this rather established method for example collective private commissioning

example collective private commissioning

example collective private commissioning is an embraced and encouraged project

is an embraced and encouraged project

is an embraced and encouraged project delivery model in other parts of the

delivery model in other parts of the

delivery model in other parts of the world

world

world it sees the bypassing of many of the

it sees the bypassing of many of the

it sees the bypassing of many of the development related costs by way of the

development related costs by way of the

development related costs by way of the direct funding and building of housing

direct funding and building of housing

direct funding and building of housing buys future residents so in other words

buys future residents so in other words

buys future residents so in other words Jeffrey and his friends while they may

Jeffrey and his friends while they may

Jeffrey and his friends while they may not be able to afford the building of

not be able to afford the building of

not be able to afford the building of their individual homes can pool their

their individual homes can pool their

their individual homes can pool their resources and develop their own building

resources and develop their own building

resources and develop their own building it’s a model that’s seen tremendous

it’s a model that’s seen tremendous

it’s a model that’s seen tremendous success in other countries not only by

success in other countries not only by

success in other countries not only by way of cost savings but also with

way of cost savings but also with

way of cost savings but also with respect to certain social benefits

respect to certain social benefits

respect to certain social benefits things like having a say in who your

things like having a say in who your

things like having a say in who your neighbors are

neighbors are

neighbors are second planning unlocking land into and

second planning unlocking land into and

second planning unlocking land into and its value is potentially the most

its value is potentially the most

its value is potentially the most significant way to create affordability

significant way to create affordability

significant way to create affordability current development trends heavily favor

current development trends heavily favor

current development trends heavily favor two ends of a spectrum on one side you

two ends of a spectrum on one side you

two ends of a spectrum on one side you have a house built on a parcel of land

have a house built on a parcel of land

have a house built on a parcel of land that goes largely unused and on the

that goes largely unused and on the

that goes largely unused and on the other a unit within a build

other a unit within a build

other a unit within a build with no individual parcel simply

with no individual parcel simply

with no individual parcel simply shrinking the parcel significantly

shrinking the parcel significantly

shrinking the parcel significantly reduces costs and in suburban context

reduces costs and in suburban context

reduces costs and in suburban context where the developer is producing a

where the developer is producing a

where the developer is producing a higher building footprint to land ratio

higher building footprint to land ratio

higher building footprint to land ratio the added revenue can be passed on to

the added revenue can be passed on to

the added revenue can be passed on to Jeffrey a savings in their proven ways

Jeffrey a savings in their proven ways

Jeffrey a savings in their proven ways of consolidating the what would be

of consolidating the what would be

of consolidating the what would be private open space into public parks and

private open space into public parks and

private open space into public parks and amenities that have the same

amenities that have the same

amenities that have the same compensatory qualities with respect to

compensatory qualities with respect to

compensatory qualities with respect to residential density but municipalities

residential density but municipalities

residential density but municipalities need to be promoting the same type of

need to be promoting the same type of

need to be promoting the same type of thinking within existing urban fabrics

thinking within existing urban fabrics

thinking within existing urban fabrics because as cities grow and layers are

because as cities grow and layers are

because as cities grow and layers are added a host of leftover earth in

added a host of leftover earth in

added a host of leftover earth in between pockets of land appear there

between pockets of land appear there

between pockets of land appear there often oddly shaped or considered too

often oddly shaped or considered too

often oddly shaped or considered too small for traditional topologies and go

small for traditional topologies and go

small for traditional topologies and go largely unused for any number of reasons

largely unused for any number of reasons

largely unused for any number of reasons for example it’s often very

for example it’s often very

for example it’s often very time-consuming and expensive to harvest

time-consuming and expensive to harvest

time-consuming and expensive to harvest these valuable urban resources making

these valuable urban resources making

these valuable urban resources making their development exclusive to designer

their development exclusive to designer

their development exclusive to designer or bespoke custom homes but if we

or bespoke custom homes but if we

or bespoke custom homes but if we eliminated the red tape and lift lifted

eliminated the red tape and lift lifted

eliminated the red tape and lift lifted the fees and municipalities began

the fees and municipalities began

the fees and municipalities began incentivizing this type of incremental

incentivizing this type of incremental

incentivizing this type of incremental urbanism people like Jeffrey could use

urbanism people like Jeffrey could use

urbanism people like Jeffrey could use them as a means to affordability but

them as a means to affordability but

them as a means to affordability but it’s also common that these increasingly

it’s also common that these increasingly

it’s also common that these increasingly rare urban sites

rare urban sites

rare urban sites despite their proximity to urban centers

despite their proximity to urban centers

despite their proximity to urban centers have some sort of undesirable

have some sort of undesirable

have some sort of undesirable characteristic to them whether if their

characteristic to them whether if their

characteristic to them whether if their shape is simply too weird or they have a

shape is simply too weird or they have a

shape is simply too weird or they have a noisy neighbor or any number of things

noisy neighbor or any number of things

noisy neighbor or any number of things that keep them from being developed

that keep them from being developed

that keep them from being developed however these seemingly negative

however these seemingly negative

however these seemingly negative qualities can almost always be mitigated

qualities can almost always be mitigated

qualities can almost always be mitigated by way of building design and we need to

by way of building design and we need to

by way of building design and we need to realize that the connectivity that these

realize that the connectivity that these

realize that the connectivity that these sites often offer is far more important

sites often offer is far more important

sites often offer is far more important in terms of the long term health of any

in terms of the long term health of any

in terms of the long term health of any housing development especially those

housing development especially those

housing development especially those that target lower earning households so

that target lower earning households so

that target lower earning households so by prioritizing access to food education

by prioritizing access to food education

by prioritizing access to food education employment we can significantly increase

employment we can significantly increase

employment we can significantly increase the success of not only a

the success of not only a

the success of not only a durable housing but our cities in

durable housing but our cities in

durable housing but our cities in general in thirdly building design not

general in thirdly building design not

general in thirdly building design not surprisingly the most significant

surprisingly the most significant

surprisingly the most significant expense when it comes to the production

expense when it comes to the production

expense when it comes to the production of mass housing is construction this

of mass housing is construction this

of mass housing is construction this creates a tremendous opportunity for

creates a tremendous opportunity for

creates a tremendous opportunity for designers everywhere to explore cost

designers everywhere to explore cost

designers everywhere to explore cost saving strategies through critically

saving strategies through critically

saving strategies through critically examining that house home relationship

examining that house home relationship

examining that house home relationship this can be really simple things like

this can be really simple things like

this can be really simple things like using standardized materials in sizes

using standardized materials in sizes

using standardized materials in sizes this 2,000 square foot home for example

this 2,000 square foot home for example

this 2,000 square foot home for example uses 205 for buy sheets of plywood for

uses 205 for buy sheets of plywood for

uses 205 for buy sheets of plywood for its schita and this 2,000 square foot

its schita and this 2,000 square foot

its schita and this 2,000 square foot home uses 132 but the cost of

home uses 132 but the cost of

home uses 132 but the cost of construction can be thought of as half

construction can be thought of as half

construction can be thought of as half materials in half labor so while there’s

materials in half labor so while there’s

materials in half labor so while there’s a reduction in materials here there’s an

a reduction in materials here there’s an

a reduction in materials here there’s an even bigger savings from the fact that

even bigger savings from the fact that

even bigger savings from the fact that on that first house 44 percent of those

on that first house 44 percent of those

on that first house 44 percent of those pieces of plywood need to be cut on site

pieces of plywood need to be cut on site

pieces of plywood need to be cut on site and on the second just 13 percent when

and on the second just 13 percent when

and on the second just 13 percent when this reasoning is applied throughout the

this reasoning is applied throughout the

this reasoning is applied throughout the construction process that savings is

construction process that savings is

construction process that savings is compounded in the use of generic

compounded in the use of generic

compounded in the use of generic components doesn’t need to imply generic

components doesn’t need to imply generic

components doesn’t need to imply generic assemblies but can in fact produce more

assemblies but can in fact produce more

assemblies but can in fact produce more exciting results based on the thoughtful

exciting results based on the thoughtful

exciting results based on the thoughtful invention that’s required

invention that’s required

invention that’s required or how about typological considerations

or how about typological considerations

or how about typological considerations the back to back row house is an

the back to back row house is an

the back to back row house is an extremely cost effective way to build

extremely cost effective way to build

extremely cost effective way to build housing it’s got a relatively small

housing it’s got a relatively small

housing it’s got a relatively small footprint plenty of shared walls and a

footprint plenty of shared walls and a

footprint plenty of shared walls and a single foundation however it’s a fairly

single foundation however it’s a fairly

single foundation however it’s a fairly unpleasant arrangement in terms of

unpleasant arrangement in terms of

unpleasant arrangement in terms of exposure to light and air being a single

exposure to light and air being a single

exposure to light and air being a single orientation unit but by simple simply

orientation unit but by simple simply

orientation unit but by simple simply swapping one of those levels you get the

swapping one of those levels you get the

swapping one of those levels you get the same unit on the same parcel but with

same unit on the same parcel but with

same unit on the same parcel but with two orientations and that much desired

two orientations and that much desired

two orientations and that much desired cross ventilation

cross ventilation

cross ventilation this produces a far more comfortable in

this produces a far more comfortable in

this produces a far more comfortable in quality living environment within a very

quality living environment within a very

quality living environment within a very inexpensive building type and can also

inexpensive building type and can also

inexpensive building type and can also reduce costs associated with energy

reduce costs associated with energy

reduce costs associated with energy consumption or perhaps we can design

consumption or perhaps we can design

consumption or perhaps we can design flexible homes that reflect the changing

flexible homes that reflect the changing

flexible homes that reflect the changing nature of the standard household an

nature of the standard household an

nature of the standard household an increasingly popular strategy that’s

increasingly popular strategy that’s

increasingly popular strategy that’s used as a means to affordability is

used as a means to affordability is

used as a means to affordability is multi-generational living

multi-generational living

multi-generational living typically speaking people have a very

typically speaking people have a very

typically speaking people have a very similar trajectory in terms of what

similar trajectory in terms of what

similar trajectory in terms of what stages of life are for owning and what

stages of life are for owning and what

stages of life are for owning and what stages of life are for renting during

stages of life are for renting during

stages of life are for renting during those times of ownership there is

those times of ownership there is

those times of ownership there is usually just one generation contributing

usually just one generation contributing

usually just one generation contributing to the cost of living but if we can

to the cost of living but if we can

to the cost of living but if we can consolidate some of those stages that

consolidate some of those stages that

consolidate some of those stages that cost can be spread out so Geoffrey’s now

cost can be spread out so Geoffrey’s now

cost can be spread out so Geoffrey’s now young adult son or daughter fresh out of

young adult son or daughter fresh out of

young adult son or daughter fresh out of college rather than renting an apartment

college rather than renting an apartment

college rather than renting an apartment could be helping out with the mortgage

could be helping out with the mortgage

could be helping out with the mortgage payment or Geoffrey’s parents rather

payment or Geoffrey’s parents rather

payment or Geoffrey’s parents rather than moving into a retirement community

than moving into a retirement community

than moving into a retirement community or an assisted living facility they

or an assisted living facility they

or an assisted living facility they could pitch in – the problem is Jeffrey

could pitch in – the problem is Jeffrey

could pitch in – the problem is Jeffrey like most of us doesn’t want live with

like most of us doesn’t want live with

like most of us doesn’t want live with his parents but by reconfiguring the

his parents but by reconfiguring the

his parents but by reconfiguring the basic programs of the home we can create

basic programs of the home we can create

basic programs of the home we can create a hierarchy of accessibility and more

a hierarchy of accessibility and more

a hierarchy of accessibility and more importantly autonomy

importantly autonomy

importantly autonomy amongst the private spaces of the basic

amongst the private spaces of the basic

amongst the private spaces of the basic house this creates a far more

house this creates a far more

house this creates a far more accommodating environment for more than

accommodating environment for more than

accommodating environment for more than one contributing generation or perhaps

one contributing generation or perhaps

one contributing generation or perhaps we could reconsider the degree to which

we could reconsider the degree to which

we could reconsider the degree to which new homes are finished new home owners

new homes are finished new home owners

new homes are finished new home owners spend four times more than established

spend four times more than established

spend four times more than established established residents on related

established residents on related

established residents on related products and services we usually fit out

products and services we usually fit out

products and services we usually fit out new homes as a means to marketing them

new homes as a means to marketing them

new homes as a means to marketing them just to have them immediately modified

just to have them immediately modified

just to have them immediately modified but what if we could design and build

but what if we could design and build

but what if we could design and build homes to a degree of only what is

homes to a degree of only what is

homes to a degree of only what is essential to utility the resident can

essential to utility the resident can

essential to utility the resident can then move in and fit them out at their

then move in and fit them out at their

then move in and fit them out at their own pace into their own desires this not

own pace into their own desires this not

own pace into their own desires this not only has the potential to drastically

only has the potential to drastically

only has the potential to drastically reduce entry-level costs but also to

reduce entry-level costs but also to

reduce entry-level costs but also to create more diverse and eclectic

create more diverse and eclectic

create more diverse and eclectic neighborhoods in combat the homogeneity

neighborhoods in combat the homogeneity

neighborhoods in combat the homogeneity that plagues so many traditional

that plagues so many traditional

that plagues so many traditional affordable housing models now this is

affordable housing models now this is

affordable housing models now this is far from an exhaustive list but it’s

far from an exhaustive list but it’s

far from an exhaustive list but it’s just meant to demonstrate the role that

just meant to demonstrate the role that

just meant to demonstrate the role that design can have in promoting

design can have in promoting

design can have in promoting affordability and while there’s clear

affordability and while there’s clear

affordability and while there’s clear social and economic implications here I

social and economic implications here I

social and economic implications here I believe the real benefit to such

believe the real benefit to such

believe the real benefit to such strategies is that it’s good urban ISM

strategies is that it’s good urban ISM

strategies is that it’s good urban ISM creating access to affordable housing is

creating access to affordable housing is

creating access to affordable housing is absolutely critical for generating

absolutely critical for generating

absolutely critical for generating healthy community

healthy community

healthy community reducing financial strain as it relates

reducing financial strain as it relates

reducing financial strain as it relates to housing costs allows residents to

to housing costs allows residents to

to housing costs allows residents to establish a genuine stake in the

establish a genuine stake in the

establish a genuine stake in the neighborhood

neighborhood

neighborhood the benefits range from better health

the benefits range from better health

the benefits range from better health and school outcomes increased civic

and school outcomes increased civic

and school outcomes increased civic engagement and volunteerism reduced

engagement and volunteerism reduced

engagement and volunteerism reduced crime and a higher lifetime law the key

crime and a higher lifetime law the key

crime and a higher lifetime law the key is tapping into design as not something

is tapping into design as not something

is tapping into design as not something to be afforded but as a means to

to be afforded but as a means to

to be afforded but as a means to affordability thank you

affordability thank you

affordability thank you [Applause]

you

you [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *