
[Music] [Applause]
[Applause]
[Applause] we’re going to talk about whales and we
we’re going to talk about whales and we
we’re going to talk about whales and we have known for a long time that we’ve
have known for a long time that we’ve
have known for a long time that we’ve had an economic dependence on whales and
had an economic dependence on whales and
had an economic dependence on whales and that goes from whaling which was a huge
that goes from whaling which was a huge
that goes from whaling which was a huge economic impact in this country for a
economic impact in this country for a
economic impact in this country for a long time and in fact we killed nearly 3
long time and in fact we killed nearly 3
long time and in fact we killed nearly 3 million whales just in the 20th century
million whales just in the 20th century
million whales just in the 20th century alone
alone
alone – now whale watching and whale watching
– now whale watching and whale watching
– now whale watching and whale watching is so important now that it’s valued at
is so important now that it’s valued at
is so important now that it’s valued at over 2 billion dollars as a global
over 2 billion dollars as a global
over 2 billion dollars as a global industry but something happened in 1972
industry but something happened in 1972
industry but something happened in 1972 where at least in the United States we
where at least in the United States we
where at least in the United States we decided that whales weren’t just
decided that whales weren’t just
decided that whales weren’t just important to us economically but that
important to us economically but that
important to us economically but that they also had value to us aesthetically
they also had value to us aesthetically
they also had value to us aesthetically and recreationally and that’s when the
and recreationally and that’s when the
and recreationally and that’s when the US Congress passed something called the
US Congress passed something called the
US Congress passed something called the Marine Mammal Protection Act it was
Marine Mammal Protection Act it was
Marine Mammal Protection Act it was groundbreaking legislation because it
groundbreaking legislation because it
groundbreaking legislation because it protect all marine mammals in the u.s.
protect all marine mammals in the u.s.
protect all marine mammals in the u.s. regardless of their status it did
regardless of their status it did
regardless of their status it did something that no other country had ever
something that no other country had ever
something that no other country had ever done before and it valued whales in a
done before and it valued whales in a
done before and it valued whales in a very different way it made sure that we
very different way it made sure that we
very different way it made sure that we weren’t just killing them on purpose
weren’t just killing them on purpose
weren’t just killing them on purpose anymore but something else that was
anymore but something else that was
anymore but something else that was really amazing about this is it actually
really amazing about this is it actually
really amazing about this is it actually made sure we weren’t killing them by
made sure we weren’t killing them by
made sure we weren’t killing them by accident or at least not too many of
accident or at least not too many of
accident or at least not too many of them and when I say by accident what I’m
them and when I say by accident what I’m
them and when I say by accident what I’m talking about is when they accidentally
talking about is when they accidentally
talking about is when they accidentally get caught in fishing gear or when
get caught in fishing gear or when
get caught in fishing gear or when they’re accidentally run over by passing
they’re accidentally run over by passing
they’re accidentally run over by passing vessels in fact the Marine Mammal
vessels in fact the Marine Mammal
vessels in fact the Marine Mammal Protection Act includes a mathematical
Protection Act includes a mathematical
Protection Act includes a mathematical formula and I’m sure know we told you
formula and I’m sure know we told you
formula and I’m sure know we told you there was gonna be math but there is um
there was gonna be math but there is um
there was gonna be math but there is um it’s called PBR and it’s a threshold and
it’s called PBR and it’s a threshold and
it’s called PBR and it’s a threshold and it makes sure that we’re not killing too
it makes sure that we’re not killing too
it makes sure that we’re not killing too many whales of a species women a
many whales of a species women a
many whales of a species women a particular population by accident if we
particular population by accident if we
particular population by accident if we exceed this threshold the Marie millet
exceed this threshold the Marie millet
exceed this threshold the Marie millet Protection Act says that we’re supposed
Protection Act says that we’re supposed
Protection Act says that we’re supposed to do something about it we’re supposed
to do something about it we’re supposed
to do something about it we’re supposed to intervene and help and that’s a
to intervene and help and that’s a
to intervene and help and that’s a really really cool amazing thing what
really really cool amazing thing what
really really cool amazing thing what I’m gonna tell you though is that maybe
I’m gonna tell you though is that maybe
I’m gonna tell you though is that maybe it doesn’t go quite far enough because
it doesn’t go quite far enough because
it doesn’t go quite far enough because what this mathematical formula doesn’t
what this mathematical formula doesn’t
what this mathematical formula doesn’t do is it doesn’t tell you if the whale
do is it doesn’t tell you if the whale
do is it doesn’t tell you if the whale that was killed was male or female it
that was killed was male or female it
that was killed was male or female it doesn’t tell you if it was an adult or
doesn’t tell you if it was an adult or
doesn’t tell you if it was an adult or if it was a juvenile and perhaps even
if it was a juvenile and perhaps even
if it was a juvenile and perhaps even more importantly
more importantly
more importantly it doesn’t tell you who it was this
it doesn’t tell you who it was this
it doesn’t tell you who it was this particular formula treats whales is
particular formula treats whales is
particular formula treats whales is interchangeable says that all the whales
interchangeable says that all the whales
interchangeable says that all the whales that are in that population of that
that are in that population of that
that are in that population of that species are pretty much all of equal
species are pretty much all of equal
species are pretty much all of equal value that they’re all the same but is
value that they’re all the same but is
value that they’re all the same but is we look more and more we kind of go a
we look more and more we kind of go a
we look more and more we kind of go a little bit more in depth into looking at
little bit more in depth into looking at
little bit more in depth into looking at whales what we’re finding is that
whales what we’re finding is that
whales what we’re finding is that they’re not all interchangeable the
they’re not all interchangeable the
they’re not all interchangeable the different whales play unique roles
different whales play unique roles
different whales play unique roles within their societies that they have
within their societies that they have
within their societies that they have they have societies and that they have
they have societies and that they have
they have societies and that they have culture this is salt she’s probably one
culture this is salt she’s probably one
culture this is salt she’s probably one of the most famous whales in the North
of the most famous whales in the North
of the most famous whales in the North Atlantic she was the first whale named
Atlantic she was the first whale named
Atlantic she was the first whale named on the gulf of mean should we know her
on the gulf of mean should we know her
on the gulf of mean should we know her because of these unique markings on her
because of these unique markings on her
because of these unique markings on her fluke she’s top researchers lots and
fluke she’s top researchers lots and
fluke she’s top researchers lots and lots and lots of things about humpback
lots and lots of things about humpback
lots and lots of things about humpback whales she taught us where they migrate
whales she taught us where they migrate
whales she taught us where they migrate to from this population she’s taught us
to from this population she’s taught us
to from this population she’s taught us how many calves they can have or she’s
how many calves they can have or she’s
how many calves they can have or she’s continuing to teach us that she’s taught
continuing to teach us that she’s taught
continuing to teach us that she’s taught us how frequently they can have calves
us how frequently they can have calves
us how frequently they can have calves eventually she might help us figure out
eventually she might help us figure out
eventually she might help us figure out how old they can live to me and one of
how old they can live to me and one of
how old they can live to me and one of the things she’s doing right now is
the things she’s doing right now is
the things she’s doing right now is she’s teaching us about Whale culture
she’s teaching us about Whale culture
she’s teaching us about Whale culture and not because of something she’s doing
and not because of something she’s doing
and not because of something she’s doing but actually because of something she
but actually because of something she
but actually because of something she doesn’t do salt was born over 40 years
doesn’t do salt was born over 40 years
doesn’t do salt was born over 40 years ago in the Caribbean and now a mama 14
ago in the Caribbean and now a mama 14
ago in the Caribbean and now a mama 14 grandmother were 14 great-grandmother to
grandmother were 14 great-grandmother to
grandmother were 14 great-grandmother to sue she’s still having calves of her own
sue she’s still having calves of her own
sue she’s still having calves of her own she returns to the waters off New
she returns to the waters off New
she returns to the waters off New England each spring and she feeds there
England each spring and she feeds there
England each spring and she feeds there in the spring summer and fall because
in the spring summer and fall because
in the spring summer and fall because that’s where her mom brought her and
that’s where her mom brought her and
that’s where her mom brought her and that’s where she brought her children
that’s where she brought her children
that’s where she brought her children and that’s now where her children come
and that’s now where her children come
and that’s now where her children come up every year that’s where her
up every year that’s where her
up every year that’s where her grandchildren her great-grandchildren
grandchildren her great-grandchildren
grandchildren her great-grandchildren I’ll come up to feed she taught her
I’ll come up to feed she taught her
I’ll come up to feed she taught her children how to get there she taught her
children how to get there she taught her
children how to get there she taught her children how to find food once they were
children how to find food once they were
children how to find food once they were there she taught them what to eat and
there she taught them what to eat and
there she taught them what to eat and she even taught them perhaps how to
she even taught them perhaps how to
she even taught them perhaps how to collect that food but something she did
collect that food but something she did
collect that food but something she did not teach them was a very specific
not teach them was a very specific
not teach them was a very specific behavior called kick feeding and it’s a
behavior called kick feeding and it’s a
behavior called kick feeding and it’s a behavior that’s only found in this one
behavior that’s only found in this one
behavior that’s only found in this one particular tribe this one particular
particular tribe this one particular
particular tribe this one particular Society of humpback whales in the world
Society of humpback whales in the world
Society of humpback whales in the world it’s the only place that you can see it
it’s the only place that you can see it
it’s the only place that you can see it sea salt is a baleen whale
sea salt is a baleen whale
sea salt is a baleen whale she’s a humpback whale and if we can get
she’s a humpback whale and if we can get
she’s a humpback whale and if we can get this to her come back well
this to her come back well
this to her come back well have teeth they have this baleen that
have teeth they have this baleen that
have teeth they have this baleen that hangs out from their upper jaw she’s
hangs out from their upper jaw she’s
hangs out from their upper jaw she’s probably between 40 and 50 feet long and
probably between 40 and 50 feet long and
probably between 40 and 50 feet long and she weighs around 80,000 pounds she does
she weighs around 80,000 pounds she does
she weighs around 80,000 pounds she does not eat one fish at a time large baleen
not eat one fish at a time large baleen
not eat one fish at a time large baleen whales need to eat lots and lots and
whales need to eat lots and lots and
whales need to eat lots and lots and lots of fish at once they have to eat
lots of fish at once they have to eat
lots of fish at once they have to eat about a ton of food a day what she eats
about a ton of food a day what she eats
about a ton of food a day what she eats is a tiny little fish tiny small
is a tiny little fish tiny small
is a tiny little fish tiny small schooling fish and the southern Gulf of
schooling fish and the southern Gulf of
schooling fish and the southern Gulf of Maine she usually feeds on this kind of
Maine she usually feeds on this kind of
Maine she usually feeds on this kind of fish it’s called a sandy loris and lands
fish it’s called a sandy loris and lands
fish it’s called a sandy loris and lands so she learned how to collect it and she
so she learned how to collect it and she
so she learned how to collect it and she taught her kids how to do that what she
taught her kids how to do that what she
taught her kids how to do that what she did though is she’s super old-school she
did though is she’s super old-school she
did though is she’s super old-school she does something called the bubble cloud
does something called the bubble cloud
does something called the bubble cloud or a bubble net and so what you’ll see
or a bubble net and so what you’ll see
or a bubble net and so what you’ll see is the water turn a little bit green and
is the water turn a little bit green and
is the water turn a little bit green and it’s turning kind of green because a
it’s turning kind of green because a
it’s turning kind of green because a phytoplankton which we’ll talk about in
phytoplankton which we’ll talk about in
phytoplankton which we’ll talk about in a little while and you can see her come
a little while and you can see her come
a little while and you can see her come up here so the thought is is the fish
up here so the thought is is the fish
up here so the thought is is the fish perceive that bubble basically those
perceive that bubble basically those
perceive that bubble basically those bubbles is a barrier that can’t get
bubbles is a barrier that can’t get
bubbles is a barrier that can’t get through and see what schools the fish
through and see what schools the fish
through and see what schools the fish into a night Tice place she can get more
into a night Tice place she can get more
into a night Tice place she can get more for a mouthful it’s a great technique
for a mouthful it’s a great technique
for a mouthful it’s a great technique that’s what she does this is kind of
that’s what she does this is kind of
that’s what she does this is kind of collecting sand lance 101 so this is 1.0
collecting sand lance 101 so this is 1.0
collecting sand lance 101 so this is 1.0 but some whales have taken this to a new
but some whales have taken this to a new
but some whales have taken this to a new level and there’s feeding on sand lance
level and there’s feeding on sand lance
level and there’s feeding on sand lance 2.0 and feeding on sand lance 2.0 is a
2.0 and feeding on sand lance 2.0 is a
2.0 and feeding on sand lance 2.0 is a behavior called kick feeding salt does
behavior called kick feeding salt does
behavior called kick feeding salt does not kick feed so some whales in the
not kick feed so some whales in the
not kick feed so some whales in the 1980s figured out that if you kick the
1980s figured out that if you kick the
1980s figured out that if you kick the water surface first before you form that
water surface first before you form that
water surface first before you form that bubble cloud you can stun the fish and
bubble cloud you can stun the fish and
bubble cloud you can stun the fish and really kind of concentrate them there
really kind of concentrate them there
really kind of concentrate them there was an innovator in the society
was an innovator in the society
was an innovator in the society researchers in 1980 said that they
researchers in 1980 said that they
researchers in 1980 said that they didn’t see any whales doing this by 1990
didn’t see any whales doing this by 1990
didn’t see any whales doing this by 1990 half the whales that they were watching
half the whales that they were watching
half the whales that they were watching out there did it but what was kind of
out there did it but what was kind of
out there did it but what was kind of cool and remarkable is that the moms of
cool and remarkable is that the moms of
cool and remarkable is that the moms of the kick feeders didn’t kick feed they
the kick feeders didn’t kick feed they
the kick feeders didn’t kick feed they didn’t learn this from their mothers
didn’t learn this from their mothers
didn’t learn this from their mothers they learned it from their friends it
they learned it from their friends it
they learned it from their friends it was shared and culturally transmitted
was shared and culturally transmitted
was shared and culturally transmitted through a peer group so some whale was
through a peer group so some whale was
through a peer group so some whale was an innovator enough to have tried this
an innovator enough to have tried this
an innovator enough to have tried this and figure it out in other whales there
and figure it out in other whales there
and figure it out in other whales there was the trendsetter and then there were
was the trendsetter and then there were
was the trendsetter and then there were the trend followers who picked up on it
the trend followers who picked up on it
the trend followers who picked up on it and then shared it throughout the
and then shared it throughout the
and then shared it throughout the population so this is kind of feeding on
population so this is kind of feeding on
population so this is kind of feeding on sand lance 2.0 salt however like I said
sand lance 2.0 salt however like I said
sand lance 2.0 salt however like I said this is her family tree here with her 14
this is her family tree here with her 14
this is her family tree here with her 14 kids and her 14 grandkids and
kids and her 14 grandkids and
kids and her 14 grandkids and the two grand cabs that we know of right
the two grand cabs that we know of right
the two grand cabs that we know of right now she doesn’t kick feed but her son
now she doesn’t kick feed but her son
now she doesn’t kick feed but her son crystalline I know it’s a girl’s name
crystalline I know it’s a girl’s name
crystalline I know it’s a girl’s name but it’s her son so her son crystal her
but it’s her son so her son crystal her
but it’s her son so her son crystal her daughter Thalassa her granddaughter at
daughter Thalassa her granddaughter at
daughter Thalassa her granddaughter at your sketch they’re all kick feeders
your sketch they’re all kick feeders
your sketch they’re all kick feeders whale namings a whole nother talk but
whale namings a whole nother talk but
whale namings a whole nother talk but but they kick feed they didn’t learn
but they kick feed they didn’t learn
but they kick feed they didn’t learn that from salt they learned it from each
that from salt they learned it from each
that from salt they learned it from each other they learned it from their friends
other they learned it from their friends
other they learned it from their friends that’s a way that we think of where we
that’s a way that we think of where we
that’s a way that we think of where we can think of culture when you want to
can think of culture when you want to
can think of culture when you want to think of cultural transmission is
think of cultural transmission is
think of cultural transmission is learning things from your friends not
learning things from your friends not
learning things from your friends not just from your parents that you’re
just from your parents that you’re
just from your parents that you’re sharing those those ideas kind of kind
sharing those those ideas kind of kind
sharing those those ideas kind of kind of like doing these talks you share
of like doing these talks you share
of like doing these talks you share ideas with with a peer group think of it
ideas with with a peer group think of it
ideas with with a peer group think of it from musical perspectives so the
from musical perspectives so the
from musical perspectives so the generational changes we heard some music
generational changes we heard some music
generational changes we heard some music this morning there’s generational
this morning there’s generational
this morning there’s generational changes that happen in music the musical
changes that happen in music the musical
changes that happen in music the musical tastes of my parents did not necessarily
tastes of my parents did not necessarily
tastes of my parents did not necessarily become my own and my misspent youth
become my own and my misspent youth
become my own and my misspent youth listening to rock groups and I learned
listening to rock groups and I learned
listening to rock groups and I learned that from my friends and what the latest
that from my friends and what the latest
that from my friends and what the latest bands were out there that I wanted to
bands were out there that I wanted to
bands were out there that I wanted to listen to that was something that I
listen to that was something that I
listen to that was something that I shared with my friends I promise you
shared with my friends I promise you
shared with my friends I promise you that I did not an impart a love of
that I did not an impart a love of
that I did not an impart a love of country music on my children they got
country music on my children they got
country music on my children they got that from their friends and that’s
that from their friends and that’s
that from their friends and that’s cultural transmission that’s
cultural transmission that’s
cultural transmission that’s generational changes that happen when
generational changes that happen when
generational changes that happen when you have peer groups share ideas that
you have peer groups share ideas that
you have peer groups share ideas that happens in whale behavior so this is
happens in whale behavior so this is
happens in whale behavior so this is Samara and she’s a pretty standard kick
Samara and she’s a pretty standard kick
Samara and she’s a pretty standard kick feeder she’s gonna kick twice can watch
feeder she’s gonna kick twice can watch
feeder she’s gonna kick twice can watch her get ready there and there’s the
her get ready there and there’s the
her get ready there and there’s the first kick that’s her calf with her so
first kick that’s her calf with her so
first kick that’s her calf with her so her calf might learn this technique but
her calf might learn this technique but
her calf might learn this technique but might also change it and there’s the
might also change it and there’s the
might also change it and there’s the second kick she’ll then dive down and
second kick she’ll then dive down and
second kick she’ll then dive down and she’ll form her bubbles that’s pretty
she’ll form her bubbles that’s pretty
she’ll form her bubbles that’s pretty typical standard 2.0 kick feeding but as
typical standard 2.0 kick feeding but as
typical standard 2.0 kick feeding but as we dig a little bit deeper what we’re
we dig a little bit deeper what we’re
we dig a little bit deeper what we’re seeing is that 3.0 might be around the
seeing is that 3.0 might be around the
seeing is that 3.0 might be around the corner and that this behavior itself is
corner and that this behavior itself is
corner and that this behavior itself is changing and that whales are kind of
changing and that whales are kind of
changing and that whales are kind of testing out new ways of doing it and so
testing out new ways of doing it and so
testing out new ways of doing it and so as we’re starting to dig into this a
as we’re starting to dig into this a
as we’re starting to dig into this a little bit more we’re trying to figure
little bit more we’re trying to figure
little bit more we’re trying to figure out which of these techniques is going
out which of these techniques is going
out which of these techniques is going to take off who is the next innovator
to take off who is the next innovator
to take off who is the next innovator who are the who are the next group of
who are the who are the next group of
who are the who are the next group of trend followers that are brave enough to
trend followers that are brave enough to
trend followers that are brave enough to try it and share it throughout the
try it and share it throughout the
try it and share it throughout the population
population
population is fulcrum she’s gonna kick three times
is fulcrum she’s gonna kick three times
is fulcrum she’s gonna kick three times now that’s not so typical most of them
now that’s not so typical most of them
now that’s not so typical most of them will do two but you’ve got three kicks
will do two but you’ve got three kicks
will do two but you’ve got three kicks here so right before she goes down she’s
here so right before she goes down she’s
here so right before she goes down she’s gonna give a little extra kick and there
gonna give a little extra kick and there
gonna give a little extra kick and there it is that’s more energetically
it is that’s more energetically
it is that’s more energetically expensive it takes more energy to do
expensive it takes more energy to do
expensive it takes more energy to do that but is that better
that but is that better
that but is that better does that help to stun the fish a little
does that help to stun the fish a little
does that help to stun the fish a little bit more is this the new technique that
bit more is this the new technique that
bit more is this the new technique that we’re gonna start to see taking off or
we’re gonna start to see taking off or
we’re gonna start to see taking off or is it gonna be a reflection reflection
is it gonna be a reflection reflection
is it gonna be a reflection reflection does something called a chin slap breach
does something called a chin slap breach
does something called a chin slap breach before she kicked she does the two kicks
before she kicked she does the two kicks
before she kicked she does the two kicks but if we watch it again she’s gonna
but if we watch it again she’s gonna
but if we watch it again she’s gonna stick her face out of the water and
stick her face out of the water and
stick her face out of the water and she’s actually gonna slap her chin down
she’s actually gonna slap her chin down
she’s actually gonna slap her chin down on the water and then she’s gonna do her
on the water and then she’s gonna do her
on the water and then she’s gonna do her two kicks is that gonna be the technique
two kicks is that gonna be the technique
two kicks is that gonna be the technique that takes off is this an Lance feeding
that takes off is this an Lance feeding
that takes off is this an Lance feeding 3.0 it’s possible that that chin slap
3.0 it’s possible that that chin slap
3.0 it’s possible that that chin slap might bring the fish toward her tail and
might bring the fish toward her tail and
might bring the fish toward her tail and might make that a more effective way of
might make that a more effective way of
might make that a more effective way of feeding it’s something that we’re trying
feeding it’s something that we’re trying
feeding it’s something that we’re trying to look at now it’s gonna take a while
to look at now it’s gonna take a while
to look at now it’s gonna take a while to figure this out but certainly we’re
to figure this out but certainly we’re
to figure this out but certainly we’re starting to see these changes a tornado
starting to see these changes a tornado
starting to see these changes a tornado tornadoes a little bit trickier because
tornadoes a little bit trickier because
tornadoes a little bit trickier because she does this chin slap breach but
she does this chin slap breach but
she does this chin slap breach but really quickly you can see her flipper
really quickly you can see her flipper
really quickly you can see her flipper stick out of the water first so we’ll
stick out of the water first so we’ll
stick out of the water first so we’ll watch it again and just watch right here
watch it again and just watch right here
watch it again and just watch right here there’s her flipper and so she sticks
there’s her flipper and so she sticks
there’s her flipper and so she sticks her flippers out before she does that
her flippers out before she does that
her flippers out before she does that chin slap breach so is this the three
chin slap breach so is this the three
chin slap breach so is this the three point out technique of feeding because
point out technique of feeding because
point out technique of feeding because we do know that the flippers have the
we do know that the flippers have the
we do know that the flippers have the white unto the side and they can also
white unto the side and they can also
white unto the side and they can also work as a startle mechanism for the fish
work as a startle mechanism for the fish
work as a startle mechanism for the fish so was she helping to school the fish
so was she helping to school the fish
so was she helping to school the fish even in a better way to bring him
even in a better way to bring him
even in a better way to bring him underneath her move him down with her
underneath her move him down with her
underneath her move him down with her head then slap him with her tail or or
head then slap him with her tail or or
head then slap him with her tail or or is she just like me and has a little bit
is she just like me and has a little bit
is she just like me and has a little bit balanced problem and she might need that
balanced problem and she might need that
balanced problem and she might need that extra help we don’t know but we’re gonna
extra help we don’t know but we’re gonna
extra help we don’t know but we’re gonna look to see if this behavior starts to
look to see if this behavior starts to
look to see if this behavior starts to kind of take off is this something a
kind of take off is this something a
kind of take off is this something a little bit better maybe then bubble
little bit better maybe then bubble
little bit better maybe then bubble clouds maybe then just regular kick
clouds maybe then just regular kick
clouds maybe then just regular kick feeding this is ventus KO I have no
feeding this is ventus KO I have no
feeding this is ventus KO I have no doubt she’s an innovator but I don’t
doubt she’s an innovator but I don’t
doubt she’s an innovator but I don’t think she’s a trend setter her little
think she’s a trend setter her little
think she’s a trend setter her little bit of a sloppy floppy kind of way of
bit of a sloppy floppy kind of way of
bit of a sloppy floppy kind of way of kicking that I’m not guessing that’s
kicking that I’m not guessing that’s
kicking that I’m not guessing that’s gonna take off but the fact that she’s
gonna take off but the fact that she’s
gonna take off but the fact that she’s trying something different it’s kind of
trying something different it’s kind of
trying something different it’s kind of cool that they’re kind of taking these
cool that they’re kind of taking these
cool that they’re kind of taking these different ways of figuring stuff out
different ways of figuring stuff out
different ways of figuring stuff out that there’s thought put into it
that there’s thought put into it
that there’s thought put into it that there’s innovation and that they’re
that there’s innovation and that they’re
that there’s innovation and that they’re sharing that and then the friends are
sharing that and then the friends are
sharing that and then the friends are picking it up and it’s transmitting
picking it up and it’s transmitting
picking it up and it’s transmitting throughout the population we don’t know
throughout the population we don’t know
throughout the population we don’t know who the innovators are we don’t always
who the innovators are we don’t always
who the innovators are we don’t always know who the trendsetters are we don’t
know who the trendsetters are we don’t
know who the trendsetters are we don’t necessarily know who the trend followers
necessarily know who the trend followers
necessarily know who the trend followers are those brave group who kind of take
are those brave group who kind of take
are those brave group who kind of take and we’ll try that like the first people
and we’ll try that like the first people
and we’ll try that like the first people that maybe we’re like trying Netflix and
that maybe we’re like trying Netflix and
that maybe we’re like trying Netflix and then it took off it’s it’s that kind of
then it took off it’s it’s that kind of
then it took off it’s it’s that kind of thing we don’t know who’s doing that but
thing we don’t know who’s doing that but
thing we don’t know who’s doing that but we know that they’re important we know
we know that they’re important we know
we know that they’re important we know that they serve this incredibly
that they serve this incredibly
that they serve this incredibly important role within these societies
important role within these societies
important role within these societies and the reason that it’s important is
and the reason that it’s important is
and the reason that it’s important is because this behavior of kick feeding
because this behavior of kick feeding
because this behavior of kick feeding seem to coincide with a shift in prey it
seem to coincide with a shift in prey it
seem to coincide with a shift in prey it went from herring which were largely
went from herring which were largely
went from herring which were largely being overfished to these sand lands
being overfished to these sand lands
being overfished to these sand lands which aren’t so commercially valuable so
which aren’t so commercially valuable so
which aren’t so commercially valuable so some whales figured out this was an
some whales figured out this was an
some whales figured out this was an alternate prey source some whales
alternate prey source some whales
alternate prey source some whales figured out that this was a better way
figured out that this was a better way
figured out that this was a better way to collect it in an environment where we
to collect it in an environment where we
to collect it in an environment where we have whales facing a rapidly changing
have whales facing a rapidly changing
have whales facing a rapidly changing climate potentially having to exploit
climate potentially having to exploit
climate potentially having to exploit any prey sources we need those
any prey sources we need those
any prey sources we need those innovators we need those risk takers to
innovators we need those risk takers to
innovators we need those risk takers to go out there and figure something out we
go out there and figure something out we
go out there and figure something out we need those trend followers to share it
need those trend followers to share it
need those trend followers to share it with the rest of the population because
with the rest of the population because
with the rest of the population because that’s what’s gonna keep these
that’s what’s gonna keep these
that’s what’s gonna keep these populations healthy and so why do you
populations healthy and so why do you
populations healthy and so why do you care about this you care about it
care about this you care about it
care about this you care about it because not only do we know whales are
because not only do we know whales are
because not only do we know whales are aesthetically pleasing that they are
aesthetically pleasing that they are
aesthetically pleasing that they are economically important that they’re
economically important that they’re
economically important that they’re recreationally important we’re starting
recreationally important we’re starting
recreationally important we’re starting to understand now that they are
to understand now that they are
to understand now that they are ecologically important we need them for
ecologically important we need them for
ecologically important we need them for our own survival whales play an
our own survival whales play an
our own survival whales play an incredibly important key role in the
incredibly important key role in the
incredibly important key role in the ecosystem that we’re just starting to
ecosystem that we’re just starting to
ecosystem that we’re just starting to understand and it all comes back to a
understand and it all comes back to a
understand and it all comes back to a small tiny microscopic organism that
small tiny microscopic organism that
small tiny microscopic organism that most of you will never see and it’s
most of you will never see and it’s
most of you will never see and it’s called phytoplankton and that’s kind of
called phytoplankton and that’s kind of
called phytoplankton and that’s kind of what made those green bubble clouds look
what made those green bubble clouds look
what made those green bubble clouds look kind of greenish phytoplankton forms a
kind of greenish phytoplankton forms a
kind of greenish phytoplankton forms a free-floating ocean forest and the
free-floating ocean forest and the
free-floating ocean forest and the sunlit waters it floats around into
sunlit waters it floats around into
sunlit waters it floats around into photosynthesizes just like plants on
photosynthesizes just like plants on
photosynthesizes just like plants on land it uses the sun’s energy and some
land it uses the sun’s energy and some
land it uses the sun’s energy and some nutrients it takes in carbon dioxide
nutrients it takes in carbon dioxide
nutrients it takes in carbon dioxide from the atmosphere it gives off oxygen
from the atmosphere it gives off oxygen
from the atmosphere it gives off oxygen it makes food for itself it actually
it makes food for itself it actually
it makes food for itself it actually makes at least half of air that you
makes at least half of air that you
makes at least half of air that you breathe
it is the very base of the marine food
it is the very base of the marine food web sustainable fish stocks depend on
web sustainable fish stocks depend on
web sustainable fish stocks depend on lots of phytoplankton and healthy
lots of phytoplankton and healthy
lots of phytoplankton and healthy phytoplankton stocks because it takes
phytoplankton stocks because it takes
phytoplankton stocks because it takes the carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere
the carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere
the carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere and it gives off the oxygen it keeps a
and it gives off the oxygen it keeps a
and it gives off the oxygen it keeps a carbon with them the phytoplankton have
carbon with them the phytoplankton have
carbon with them the phytoplankton have a very short but very fulfilling life
a very short but very fulfilling life
a very short but very fulfilling life they live about two days and they are
they live about two days and they are
they live about two days and they are literally carbon sinks they take that
literally carbon sinks they take that
literally carbon sinks they take that carbon with them and they sink to the
carbon with them and they sink to the
carbon with them and they sink to the ocean bottom so they are helping to
ocean bottom so they are helping to
ocean bottom so they are helping to regulate this climate we need them to
regulate this climate we need them to
regulate this climate we need them to help to fight climate change we need
help to fight climate change we need
help to fight climate change we need phytoplankton what phytoplankton need
phytoplankton what phytoplankton need
phytoplankton what phytoplankton need are whales you see phytoplankton can’t
are whales you see phytoplankton can’t
are whales you see phytoplankton can’t root into the soil the way that plants
root into the soil the way that plants
root into the soil the way that plants on land can so they have to have their
on land can so they have to have their
on land can so they have to have their nutrients brought to them and that’s
nutrients brought to them and that’s
nutrients brought to them and that’s where whales come into the picture
where whales come into the picture
where whales come into the picture whales literally serve this incredibly
whales literally serve this incredibly
whales literally serve this incredibly important role as the ocean gardeners
important role as the ocean gardeners
important role as the ocean gardeners and they tend that forest of
and they tend that forest of
and they tend that forest of phytoplankton and the way they do it is
phytoplankton and the way they do it is
phytoplankton and the way they do it is maybe not the best dinner talk but the
maybe not the best dinner talk but the
maybe not the best dinner talk but the way they do it is because they can’t
way they do it is because they can’t
way they do it is because they can’t poop under pressure and it’s not the
poop under pressure and it’s not the
poop under pressure and it’s not the pressure of like maybe somebody’s
pressure of like maybe somebody’s
pressure of like maybe somebody’s waiting outside the bathroom door it’s
waiting outside the bathroom door it’s
waiting outside the bathroom door it’s the physical atmospheric pressure of
the physical atmospheric pressure of
the physical atmospheric pressure of being at depth so bathroom breaks happen
being at depth so bathroom breaks happen
being at depth so bathroom breaks happen at the surface those bathroom breaks are
at the surface those bathroom breaks are
at the surface those bathroom breaks are full of nitrogen and iron and these
full of nitrogen and iron and these
full of nitrogen and iron and these amazing nutrients at the phytoplankton
amazing nutrients at the phytoplankton
amazing nutrients at the phytoplankton need they tend met ocean forests when
need they tend met ocean forests when
need they tend met ocean forests when they come up to the surface and they
they come up to the surface and they
they come up to the surface and they feed and they’re coming up and they’re
feed and they’re coming up and they’re
feed and they’re coming up and they’re using those bathroom breaks
using those bathroom breaks
using those bathroom breaks phytoplankton need whales they need the
phytoplankton need whales they need the
phytoplankton need whales they need the nutrients if we want to fight climate
nutrients if we want to fight climate
nutrients if we want to fight climate change if you want sustainable fish
change if you want sustainable fish
change if you want sustainable fish stocks if we want to breathe we want
stocks if we want to breathe we want
stocks if we want to breathe we want whales to be healthy healthy populations
whales to be healthy healthy populations
whales to be healthy healthy populations of whales need a healthy society they
of whales need a healthy society they
of whales need a healthy society they need to consider the individuals that
need to consider the individuals that
need to consider the individuals that live within that society and that the
live within that society and that the
live within that society and that the roles that they play the way that we’re
roles that they play the way that we’re
roles that they play the way that we’re managing whales now doesn’t do that it
managing whales now doesn’t do that it
managing whales now doesn’t do that it treats whales as interchangeable so we
treats whales as interchangeable so we
treats whales as interchangeable so we have a threshold a mathematical formula
have a threshold a mathematical formula
have a threshold a mathematical formula that looks at whales and says well maybe
that looks at whales and says well maybe
that looks at whales and says well maybe there’s too many in this population that
there’s too many in this population that
there’s too many in this population that are being killed but I’m telling you
are being killed but I’m telling you
are being killed but I’m telling you that we need to think about who they are
that we need to think about who they are
that we need to think about who they are and that there really can’t be a
and that there really can’t be a
and that there really can’t be a threshold we need a healthy society of
threshold we need a healthy society of
threshold we need a healthy society of whales because we depend on them
whales because we depend on them
whales because we depend on them the way that we are doing things now is
the way that we are doing things now is
the way that we are doing things now is that we’re managing things in a way for
that we’re managing things in a way for
that we’re managing things in a way for whales to survive which is great but we
whales to survive which is great but we
whales to survive which is great but we need whale populations to thrive not
need whale populations to thrive not
need whale populations to thrive not just survive and to thrive we need to
just survive and to thrive we need to
just survive and to thrive we need to protect their cultures because our very
protect their cultures because our very
protect their cultures because our very future and our survival may depend on it
future and our survival may depend on it
future and our survival may depend on it thank you
”
Be First to Comment