Press "Enter" to skip to content

How to make the world better without volunteering harder. | Karen Chan | TEDxYouth@AISHK


[Applause]

[Applause] everyone so sometime last year I was

everyone so sometime last year I was

everyone so sometime last year I was applying for the student award one

applying for the student award one

applying for the student award one section of the application form was

section of the application form was

section of the application form was titled community service so I wrote

titled community service so I wrote

titled community service so I wrote about my work in helping to organize

about my work in helping to organize

about my work in helping to organize this you summit that gathers young

this you summit that gathers young

this you summit that gathers young people passionate about the environment

people passionate about the environment

people passionate about the environment and empowers them to take on

and empowers them to take on

and empowers them to take on environmental projects in their local

environmental projects in their local

environmental projects in their local community three days later after I

community three days later after I

community three days later after I handed in this application form I got a

handed in this application form I got a

handed in this application form I got a call from the organization that

call from the organization that

call from the organization that coordinates the award the lady on the

coordinates the award the lady on the

coordinates the award the lady on the line told me that her organization was

line told me that her organization was

line told me that her organization was looking for real community service

looking for real community service

looking for real community service experiences I was confused it wasn’t

experiences I was confused it wasn’t

experiences I was confused it wasn’t that what I wrote on my application form

that what I wrote on my application form

that what I wrote on my application form so I asked for a clarification and she

so I asked for a clarification and she

so I asked for a clarification and she told me we are looking for real

told me we are looking for real

told me we are looking for real instances of helping people things like

instances of helping people things like

instances of helping people things like tutoring children building houses or

tutoring children building houses or

tutoring children building houses or visiting elderly homes have you done any

visiting elderly homes have you done any

visiting elderly homes have you done any of these things I realized after this

of these things I realized after this

of these things I realized after this phone call that some people believe

phone call that some people believe

phone call that some people believe charity work means visiting a remote

charity work means visiting a remote

charity work means visiting a remote orphanage halfway across the world and

orphanage halfway across the world and

orphanage halfway across the world and handing out brand-new stationery in fact

handing out brand-new stationery in fact

handing out brand-new stationery in fact that was what a few of my friends try to

that was what a few of my friends try to

that was what a few of my friends try to do so a few weeks back a few months back

do so a few weeks back a few months back

do so a few weeks back a few months back actually some of my friends signed up

actually some of my friends signed up

actually some of my friends signed up for the service trip to Nepal to work in

for the service trip to Nepal to work in

for the service trip to Nepal to work in a local school when they came back I

a local school when they came back I

a local school when they came back I asked him how are they went and they

asked him how are they went and they

asked him how are they went and they told me the most constructive thing they

told me the most constructive thing they

told me the most constructive thing they did in Nepal was actually shopping in

did in Nepal was actually shopping in

did in Nepal was actually shopping in their words it was stimulating the

their words it was stimulating the

their words it was stimulating the Nepalese economy apparently there seven

Nepalese economy apparently there seven

Nepalese economy apparently there seven days service trip was actually a six day

days service trip was actually a six day

days service trip was actually a six day scenic tour across Nepal accompanied by

scenic tour across Nepal accompanied by

scenic tour across Nepal accompanied by half a day of actually visiting a school

half a day of actually visiting a school

half a day of actually visiting a school so for the first six days of their trip

so for the first six days of their trip

so for the first six days of their trip they dined on buffalo meat and splurge

they dined on buffalo meat and splurge

they dined on buffalo meat and splurge on expensive coffee on the last day of

on expensive coffee on the last day of

on expensive coffee on the last day of the trip when they actually went to

the trip when they actually went to

the trip when they actually went to visit a local school they discovered

visit a local school they discovered

visit a local school they discovered that the school they were sent to was

that the school they were sent to was

that the school they were sent to was actually frequently visited by

actually frequently visited by

actually frequently visited by volunteers and as a result the children

volunteers and as a result the children

volunteers and as a result the children in that school were doing quite well and

in that school were doing quite well and

in that school were doing quite well and they didn’t need any help

they didn’t need any help

they didn’t need any help not all trips end up like this and

not all trips end up like this and

not all trips end up like this and sometimes volunteers think they can

sometimes volunteers think they can

sometimes volunteers think they can actually bring on a positive change a

actually bring on a positive change a

actually bring on a positive change a group of boarding school girls went to

group of boarding school girls went to

group of boarding school girls went to Tanzania to help build a library now

Tanzania to help build a library now

Tanzania to help build a library now they did their best at putting bricks

they did their best at putting bricks

they did their best at putting bricks and cement together and two weeks later

and cement together and two weeks later

and cement together and two weeks later voila the children had a new library

voila the children had a new library

voila the children had a new library sounds great right well that’s only part

sounds great right well that’s only part

sounds great right well that’s only part of the story you see every night after

of the story you see every night after

of the story you see every night after these girls went to bed the local men

these girls went to bed the local men

these girls went to bed the local men would sneak out and they would demolish

would sneak out and they would demolish

would sneak out and they would demolish whatever structure the girls had built

whatever structure the girls had built

whatever structure the girls had built during the day because it was about to

during the day because it was about to

during the day because it was about to collapse they would rebuild it and in

collapse they would rebuild it and in

collapse they would rebuild it and in the morning the girls would get up and

the morning the girls would get up and

the morning the girls would get up and believe what was in front of them was

believe what was in front of them was

believe what was in front of them was actually their work so what did these

actually their work so what did these

actually their work so what did these people contribute during this two weeks

people contribute during this two weeks

people contribute during this two weeks not much they effectively failed a

not much they effectively failed a

not much they effectively failed a single task they were doing they were

single task they were doing they were

single task they were doing they were there to do sometimes volunteering

there to do sometimes volunteering

there to do sometimes volunteering doesn’t just fail to bring much good it

doesn’t just fail to bring much good it

doesn’t just fail to bring much good it actually brings more harm than good

actually brings more harm than good

actually brings more harm than good overwhelming international volunteering

overwhelming international volunteering

overwhelming international volunteering has spurred whole new industries in

has spurred whole new industries in

has spurred whole new industries in certain countries in Cambodia the number

certain countries in Cambodia the number

certain countries in Cambodia the number of volunteering are the number of

of volunteering are the number of

of volunteering are the number of orphanages increased by 75% over a five

orphanages increased by 75% over a five

orphanages increased by 75% over a five year period these orphanages are there

year period these orphanages are there

year period these orphanages are there to cater for the number of tourists who

to cater for the number of tourists who

to cater for the number of tourists who are just so enthusiastically trying to

are just so enthusiastically trying to

are just so enthusiastically trying to vine a ball up to find an orphanage to

vine a ball up to find an orphanage to

vine a ball up to find an orphanage to village to visit and the problem is

village to visit and the problem is

village to visit and the problem is there actually aren’t that many orphans

there actually aren’t that many orphans

there actually aren’t that many orphans in Cambodia to fodeez orphanages so what

in Cambodia to fodeez orphanages so what

in Cambodia to fodeez orphanages so what the operators of these orphanages do is

the operators of these orphanages do is

the operators of these orphanages do is that they go visit parents and lure them

that they go visit parents and lure them

that they go visit parents and lure them to send their own children into an

to send their own children into an

to send their own children into an orphanage by promising that they’ll be

orphanage by promising that they’ll be

orphanage by promising that they’ll be better educated better house better fed

better educated better house better fed

better educated better house better fed a study by Columbia University showed

a study by Columbia University showed

a study by Columbia University showed that three out of four children in

that three out of four children in

that three out of four children in Cambodian orphanages actually have one

Cambodian orphanages actually have one

Cambodian orphanages actually have one or more living parent and if you think

or more living parent and if you think

or more living parent and if you think about it the operators of these

about it the operators of these

about it the operators of these orphanages have no incentive to treat

orphanages have no incentive to treat

orphanages have no incentive to treat these kids well they are a profit-making

these kids well they are a profit-making

these kids well they are a profit-making firm and how old forests donate money to

firm and how old forests donate money to

firm and how old forests donate money to orphanages if they see how these

orphanages if they see how these

orphanages if they see how these children

children

children living happily so they manufacture

living happily so they manufacture

living happily so they manufacture appalling living conditions for these

appalling living conditions for these

appalling living conditions for these children just to evoke sympathy in

children just to evoke sympathy in

children just to evoke sympathy in tourists this is not to say that any act

tourists this is not to say that any act

tourists this is not to say that any act of altruism would end up in a disaster

of altruism would end up in a disaster

of altruism would end up in a disaster but these experiences invite the

but these experiences invite the

but these experiences invite the question why why does it sometimes go

question why why does it sometimes go

question why why does it sometimes go wrong when people simply try to help

wrong when people simply try to help

wrong when people simply try to help other people the problem isn’t with the

other people the problem isn’t with the

other people the problem isn’t with the work these people were doing the work

work these people were doing the work

work these people were doing the work these volunteers and millions across the

these volunteers and millions across the

these volunteers and millions across the world are doing was great a lot of you

world are doing was great a lot of you

world are doing was great a lot of you in the audience can probably teach

in the audience can probably teach

in the audience can probably teach English better than someone qualified

English better than someone qualified

English better than someone qualified teachers in rural China libraries if

teachers in rural China libraries if

teachers in rural China libraries if they are well built give kids a refuge

they are well built give kids a refuge

they are well built give kids a refuge and a source for knowledge orphanages

and a source for knowledge orphanages

and a source for knowledge orphanages are often short staffed and having

are often short staffed and having

are often short staffed and having volunteers to visit making these field

volunteers to visit making these field

volunteers to visit making these field children making these children feel

children making these children feel

children making these children feel cared for it does do good for them

cared for it does do good for them

cared for it does do good for them it wasn’t the work that was bad it

it wasn’t the work that was bad it

it wasn’t the work that was bad it wasn’t the volunteering that was bad it

wasn’t the volunteering that was bad it

wasn’t the volunteering that was bad it was a people being there look at me I am

was a people being there look at me I am

was a people being there look at me I am not half a doctor or engineer a teacher

not half a doctor or engineer a teacher

not half a doctor or engineer a teacher or any other profession that would allow

or any other profession that would allow

or any other profession that would allow me to design and implement long-term

me to design and implement long-term

me to design and implement long-term sustainable solutions tailored to

sustainable solutions tailored to

sustainable solutions tailored to communities in developing countries I am

communities in developing countries I am

communities in developing countries I am a person who isn’t really good at

a person who isn’t really good at

a person who isn’t really good at teaching English to a kid who doesn’t

teaching English to a kid who doesn’t

teaching English to a kid who doesn’t speak any of my languages I am not very

speak any of my languages I am not very

speak any of my languages I am not very good at singing songs that are four

good at singing songs that are four

good at singing songs that are four times as old as I am to people in

times as old as I am to people in

times as old as I am to people in retirement homes I can’t really build a

retirement homes I can’t really build a

retirement homes I can’t really build a brick water doesn’t collapse and neither

brick water doesn’t collapse and neither

brick water doesn’t collapse and neither can I paint the wall of a school neatly

can I paint the wall of a school neatly

can I paint the wall of a school neatly imagine if you could spend the money you

imagine if you could spend the money you

imagine if you could spend the money you used on that five day English teaching

used on that five day English teaching

used on that five day English teaching trip to hire local qualified teachers

trip to hire local qualified teachers

trip to hire local qualified teachers whose monthly salary is a third of the

whose monthly salary is a third of the

whose monthly salary is a third of the cost of your trip these teachers could

cost of your trip these teachers could

cost of your trip these teachers could actually implement structured

actually implement structured

actually implement structured curriculums that allow these students to

curriculums that allow these students to

curriculums that allow these students to develop language abilities as opposed to

develop language abilities as opposed to

develop language abilities as opposed to having them learn how to count to ten

having them learn how to count to ten

having them learn how to count to ten again every time a new volunteering

again every time a new volunteering

again every time a new volunteering group arrives

group arrives

group arrives imagine that these kind-hearted people

imagine that these kind-hearted people

imagine that these kind-hearted people use the money they spent the flattest

use the money they spent the flattest

use the money they spent the flattest Hanson area to hire experienced local

Hanson area to hire experienced local

Hanson area to hire experienced local contractors to build that library they

contractors to build that library they

contractors to build that library they would do it so much faster safer better

would do it so much faster safer better

would do it so much faster safer better and of course the income of these

and of course the income of these

and of course the income of these workers would as my friend said

workers would as my friend said

workers would as my friend said stimulate the economy imagine if you

stimulate the economy imagine if you

stimulate the economy imagine if you gave monetary support to organizations

gave monetary support to organizations

gave monetary support to organizations that supported struggling families in in

that supported struggling families in in

that supported struggling families in in Cambodia who are contemplating whether

Cambodia who are contemplating whether

Cambodia who are contemplating whether or not to send their children to an

or not to send their children to an

or not to send their children to an orphanage the parents of these children

orphanage the parents of these children

orphanage the parents of these children could take care of their own kids so

could take care of their own kids so

could take care of their own kids so much more better than a group of

much more better than a group of

much more better than a group of volunteers who only come for three days

volunteers who only come for three days

volunteers who only come for three days ever could people are qualified at

ever could people are qualified at

ever could people are qualified at different things I a 16 year old girl

different things I a 16 year old girl

different things I a 16 year old girl I’m gonna have many things I can

I’m gonna have many things I can

I’m gonna have many things I can persuade an audience how a story maybe

persuade an audience how a story maybe

persuade an audience how a story maybe even start a social media sensation

even start a social media sensation

even start a social media sensation I am insightful about my own community

I am insightful about my own community

I am insightful about my own community as a student I understand how some

as a student I understand how some

as a student I understand how some students in Hong Kong face the problem

students in Hong Kong face the problem

students in Hong Kong face the problem that of a lack in educational tools I

that of a lack in educational tools I

that of a lack in educational tools I would see that when they face a

would see that when they face a

would see that when they face a schoolwork problem they wouldn’t seek

schoolwork problem they wouldn’t seek

schoolwork problem they wouldn’t seek out help from the internet but they

out help from the internet but they

out help from the internet but they might just give up instead I also see

might just give up instead I also see

might just give up instead I also see that whenever I taught these people how

that whenever I taught these people how

that whenever I taught these people how a particular online tool could help them

a particular online tool could help them

a particular online tool could help them clarify a math concept they would use it

clarify a math concept they would use it

clarify a math concept they would use it the next time they had a problem these

the next time they had a problem these

the next time they had a problem these experiences made me realize that the

experiences made me realize that the

experiences made me realize that the problem with educational inequality

problem with educational inequality

problem with educational inequality isn’t that there is a lack of resources

isn’t that there is a lack of resources

isn’t that there is a lack of resources because there are so many of them free

because there are so many of them free

because there are so many of them free and existing and high-quality online it

and existing and high-quality online it

and existing and high-quality online it is that there is a lack of awareness and

is that there is a lack of awareness and

is that there is a lack of awareness and sometimes even the ability to access

sometimes even the ability to access

sometimes even the ability to access these resources which is why I a few

these resources which is why I a few

these resources which is why I a few friends a few friends and I started this

friends a few friends and I started this

friends a few friends and I started this organization called educate that helps

organization called educate that helps

organization called educate that helps young people learn about how they can

young people learn about how they can

young people learn about how they can use these free educational resources

use these free educational resources

use these free educational resources online serving the community and

online serving the community and

online serving the community and contributing to a better world comes in

contributing to a better world comes in

contributing to a better world comes in many forms there are people who work at

many forms there are people who work at

many forms there are people who work at the forefront but there are also people

the forefront but there are also people

the forefront but there are also people who

who

who behind-the-scenes service doesn’t mean

behind-the-scenes service doesn’t mean

behind-the-scenes service doesn’t mean that everyone needs to kid at teach a

that everyone needs to kid at teach a

that everyone needs to kid at teach a kid English or build a library do what

kid English or build a library do what

kid English or build a library do what you’re good at

you’re good at

you’re good at because that is exactly when you will be

because that is exactly when you will be

because that is exactly when you will be able to make the biggest and best impact

able to make the biggest and best impact

able to make the biggest and best impact you can on your community thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *