Press "Enter" to skip to content

Redefining excellence | Josh Hill | TEDxKitchenerED


[Applause]

[Applause] well it was spring 2014 and I just taken

well it was spring 2014 and I just taken

well it was spring 2014 and I just taken my senior Wind Ensemble to the local

my senior Wind Ensemble to the local

my senior Wind Ensemble to the local music festival competition and my

music festival competition and my

music festival competition and my seniors had played a nearly flawless

seniors had played a nearly flawless

seniors had played a nearly flawless performance of some very advanced level

performance of some very advanced level

performance of some very advanced level high school repertoire and as a result

high school repertoire and as a result

high school repertoire and as a result the adjudicator had awarded them the top

the adjudicator had awarded them the top

the adjudicator had awarded them the top prize given out by the festival the

prize given out by the festival the

prize given out by the festival the award for the best ensemble and in that

award for the best ensemble and in that

award for the best ensemble and in that moment I was undoubtedly proud of my

moment I was undoubtedly proud of my

moment I was undoubtedly proud of my students but unexpectedly there was also

students but unexpectedly there was also

students but unexpectedly there was also the sense of emptiness that followed and

the sense of emptiness that followed and

the sense of emptiness that followed and I recall thinking on the bus ride back

I recall thinking on the bus ride back

I recall thinking on the bus ride back to the school that night that if this

to the school that night that if this

to the school that night that if this was everything we had worked towards if

was everything we had worked towards if

was everything we had worked towards if this was it then I was missing something

this was it then I was missing something

this was it then I was missing something I believe we live in a society and that

I believe we live in a society and that

I believe we live in a society and that I teach in an educational system that

I teach in an educational system that

I teach in an educational system that has an unhealthy infatuation with

has an unhealthy infatuation with

has an unhealthy infatuation with competition and the pursuit of

competition and the pursuit of

competition and the pursuit of individualized excellence and you don’t

individualized excellence and you don’t

individualized excellence and you don’t need it and you don’t need to look very

need it and you don’t need to look very

need it and you don’t need to look very far in the high school system to see how

far in the high school system to see how

far in the high school system to see how this plays out we give our highest

this plays out we give our highest

this plays out we give our highest scholarships to our top academic

scholarships to our top academic

scholarships to our top academic achievers we push our athletes our

achievers we push our athletes our

achievers we push our athletes our musicians our Chess Club players our

musicians our Chess Club players our

musicians our Chess Club players our deca Club participants to be the best

deca Club participants to be the best

deca Club participants to be the best and we even design competitions where we

and we even design competitions where we

and we even design competitions where we can show our students without a shadow

can show our students without a shadow

can show our students without a shadow of a doubt who is first and who was last

of a doubt who is first and who was last

of a doubt who is first and who was last who was best and who was worst and all

who was best and who was worst and all

who was best and who was worst and all the while I believe we ignore the

the while I believe we ignore the

the while I believe we ignore the tremendous amount of stress anxiety and

tremendous amount of stress anxiety and

tremendous amount of stress anxiety and pressure that we heap on to our students

pressure that we heap on to our students

pressure that we heap on to our students and I believe we ignore the resulting

and I believe we ignore the resulting

and I believe we ignore the resulting system where countless high school

system where countless high school

system where countless high school students walked the hallways of our

students walked the hallways of our

students walked the hallways of our buildings every single day feeling a

buildings every single day feeling a

buildings every single day feeling a profound sense of disconnection

profound sense of disconnection

profound sense of disconnection isolation and loneliness they choose to

isolation and loneliness they choose to

isolation and loneliness they choose to function on the margins of the community

function on the margins of the community

function on the margins of the community afraid to engage because they’re

afraid to engage because they’re

afraid to engage because they’re terrified that they just won’t measure

terrified that they just won’t measure

terrified that they just won’t measure up but I believe our society functions

up but I believe our society functions

up but I believe our society functions in a similar way so let me ask you the

in a similar way so let me ask you the

in a similar way so let me ask you the question when’s the last time you

question when’s the last time you

question when’s the last time you declined the opportunity to participate

declined the opportunity to participate

declined the opportunity to participate in an activity with others because you

in an activity with others because you

in an activity with others because you were afraid you would measure up that

were afraid you would measure up that

were afraid you would measure up that you might be judge

you might be judge

you might be judge by those around you and we developed

by those around you and we developed

by those around you and we developed these great little catchphrases like you

these great little catchphrases like you

these great little catchphrases like you know what I’d love to sing but I’m

know what I’d love to sing but I’m

know what I’d love to sing but I’m actually tone-deaf or I could you said

actually tone-deaf or I could you said

actually tone-deaf or I could you said that before I or I don’t have an

that before I or I don’t have an

that before I or I don’t have an athletic bone in my body and another

athletic bone in my body and another

athletic bone in my body and another common whenever it is you know I’d help

common whenever it is you know I’d help

common whenever it is you know I’d help but I don’t even know which end of the

but I don’t even know which end of the

but I don’t even know which end of the hammer to pick up and these catchphrases

hammer to pick up and these catchphrases

hammer to pick up and these catchphrases are highly effective in keeping us on

are highly effective in keeping us on

are highly effective in keeping us on the sidelines away from the judgment of

the sidelines away from the judgment of

the sidelines away from the judgment of others but sadly they also prevent us

others but sadly they also prevent us

others but sadly they also prevent us from experiencing the deep sense of

from experiencing the deep sense of

from experiencing the deep sense of belonging that comes when we know that

belonging that comes when we know that

belonging that comes when we know that we belong to others and I think it’s

we belong to others and I think it’s

we belong to others and I think it’s actually a byproduct of a society that

actually a byproduct of a society that

actually a byproduct of a society that at its core doesn’t really value the

at its core doesn’t really value the

at its core doesn’t really value the communal expressions of participation we

communal expressions of participation we

communal expressions of participation we seem to say that the quality of the

seem to say that the quality of the

seem to say that the quality of the activity or the level of the participant

activity or the level of the participant

activity or the level of the participant matters more than the relational

matters more than the relational

matters more than the relational belonging that’s formed when we

belonging that’s formed when we

belonging that’s formed when we participate together and I think it

participate together and I think it

participate together and I think it helps to explain a little bit at least

helps to explain a little bit at least

helps to explain a little bit at least in part the feeling that something was

in part the feeling that something was

in part the feeling that something was missing when I left that festival in

missing when I left that festival in

missing when I left that festival in 2014 because if I’m really honest with

2014 because if I’m really honest with

2014 because if I’m really honest with myself along the way I had started to

myself along the way I had started to

myself along the way I had started to buy into that traditional model of

buy into that traditional model of

buy into that traditional model of excellence and to push my students hard

excellence and to push my students hard

excellence and to push my students hard towards the competition and in so doing

towards the competition and in so doing

towards the competition and in so doing I started to use my students as a

I started to use my students as a

I started to use my students as a vehicle to pursue a musical goal versus

vehicle to pursue a musical goal versus

vehicle to pursue a musical goal versus using music as the vehicle to create

using music as the vehicle to create

using music as the vehicle to create inclusive spaces of belonging for my

inclusive spaces of belonging for my

inclusive spaces of belonging for my students and the one elevates the

students and the one elevates the

students and the one elevates the quality of the activity and the other

quality of the activity and the other

quality of the activity and the other elevates the individual their well-being

elevates the individual their well-being

elevates the individual their well-being their belonging and ultimately their

their belonging and ultimately their

their belonging and ultimately their sense of empowerment that matters most

sense of empowerment that matters most

sense of empowerment that matters most and I want to see a movement in

and I want to see a movement in

and I want to see a movement in education where we leave behind those

education where we leave behind those

education where we leave behind those traditional models of excellence and

traditional models of excellence and

traditional models of excellence and instead forge a courageous new path

instead forge a courageous new path

instead forge a courageous new path towards excellence as defined by shared

towards excellence as defined by shared

towards excellence as defined by shared engagement relational connectedness

engagement relational connectedness

engagement relational connectedness community collaboration where ultimately

community collaboration where ultimately

community collaboration where ultimately our success is determined by the quality

our success is determined by the quality

our success is determined by the quality and the impact of the human interaction

and the impact of the human interaction

and the impact of the human interaction and our ability to be of service to each

and our ability to be of service to each

and our ability to be of service to each other now maybe you think this sounds a

other now maybe you think this sounds a

other now maybe you think this sounds a bit wishy-washy or touchy-feely or maybe

bit wishy-washy or touchy-feely or maybe

bit wishy-washy or touchy-feely or maybe you’re wondering about what this

you’re wondering about what this

you’re wondering about what this actually looks like in practice and in

actually looks like in practice and in

actually looks like in practice and in part I hope to answer that last question

part I hope to answer that last question

part I hope to answer that last question through the illustration of one of the

through the illustration of one of the

through the illustration of one of the projects of our music program but before

projects of our music program but before

projects of our music program but before I get there let me first help to set the

I get there let me first help to set the

I get there let me first help to set the context a little bit for our journey

context a little bit for our journey

context a little bit for our journey because it was when my colleagues and I

because it was when my colleagues and I

because it was when my colleagues and I in our department began to think more

in our department began to think more

in our department began to think more mystically about our role as educators

mystically about our role as educators

mystically about our role as educators when we began to consider the human need

when we began to consider the human need

when we began to consider the human need for belonging to know others and be

for belonging to know others and be

for belonging to know others and be known in return when we began to tackle

known in return when we began to tackle

known in return when we began to tackle the tough question of what it might look

the tough question of what it might look

the tough question of what it might look like for high school music program to

like for high school music program to

like for high school music program to have something to say about social

have something to say about social

have something to say about social justice in our community and when we

justice in our community and when we

justice in our community and when we began to dream of creating inclusive

began to dream of creating inclusive

began to dream of creating inclusive spaces of belonging for students where

spaces of belonging for students where

spaces of belonging for students where they would be empowered to live lives of

they would be empowered to live lives of

they would be empowered to live lives of significance in the world it’s then that

significance in the world it’s then that

significance in the world it’s then that we realized we needed to leave behind

we realized we needed to leave behind

we realized we needed to leave behind those traditional models of excellence

those traditional models of excellence

those traditional models of excellence and instead to shift our purpose towards

and instead to shift our purpose towards

and instead to shift our purpose towards excellence that’s measured through

excellence that’s measured through

excellence that’s measured through relational belonging and one of the

relational belonging and one of the

relational belonging and one of the projects in our music program that’s

projects in our music program that’s

projects in our music program that’s helping us to live these values is

helping us to live these values is

helping us to live these values is called the circle of music and this is a

called the circle of music and this is a

called the circle of music and this is a project where we bring together youth

project where we bring together youth

project where we bring together youth from our music program and we pair them

from our music program and we pair them

from our music program and we pair them with the senior and her community who’s

with the senior and her community who’s

with the senior and her community who’s living with dementia and along with

living with dementia and along with

living with dementia and along with their caregiver they meet each week and

their caregiver they meet each week and

their caregiver they meet each week and over juice and cookies they dig into

over juice and cookies they dig into

over juice and cookies they dig into each other’s lives they get caught up on

each other’s lives they get caught up on

each other’s lives they get caught up on the week and they just build

the week and they just build

the week and they just build relationships and then that’s followed

relationships and then that’s followed

relationships and then that’s followed by a large group time of singing where

by a large group time of singing where

by a large group time of singing where community is fostered through the

community is fostered through the

community is fostered through the creation of art and then again before

creation of art and then again before

creation of art and then again before the time finishes is the opportunity for

the time finishes is the opportunity for

the time finishes is the opportunity for their participants to socialize and this

their participants to socialize and this

their participants to socialize and this is a project that’s a joint project

is a project that’s a joint project

is a project that’s a joint project between the Cameron Heights music

between the Cameron Heights music

between the Cameron Heights music program the kW Alzheimer’s Society merit

program the kW Alzheimer’s Society merit

program the kW Alzheimer’s Society merit a masters and community music graduate

a masters and community music graduate

a masters and community music graduate from Wilfrid Laurier University and st.

from Wilfrid Laurier University and st.

from Wilfrid Laurier University and st. Peter’s Lutheran Church which hosts the

Peter’s Lutheran Church which hosts the

Peter’s Lutheran Church which hosts the event each week but before I say too

event each week but before I say too

event each week but before I say too much more about how the circle of music

much more about how the circle of music

much more about how the circle of music is helping us to redefine excellence I

is helping us to redefine excellence I

is helping us to redefine excellence I want us to experience the circle of

want us to experience the circle of

want us to experience the circle of music at least a little taste of the

music at least a little taste of the

music at least a little taste of the circle of music here tonight so as I

circle of music here tonight so as I

circle of music here tonight so as I invite my friends to come and join us on

invite my friends to come and join us on

invite my friends to come and join us on stage I just want to be clear with you

stage I just want to be clear with you

stage I just want to be clear with you that what’s about to unfold tonight is

that what’s about to unfold tonight is

that what’s about to unfold tonight is not a performance this is not intended

not a performance this is not intended

not a performance this is not intended for you to sit in your chairs and to

for you to sit in your chairs and to

for you to sit in your chairs and to passively consume but rather this is an

passively consume but rather this is an

passively consume but rather this is an open invitation to each of you to be an

open invitation to each of you to be an

open invitation to each of you to be an active engaged participant with us as we

active engaged participant with us as we

active engaged participant with us as we sing so I’m gonna need you to turn off

sing so I’m gonna need you to turn off

sing so I’m gonna need you to turn off that voice in your head that’s used to

that voice in your head that’s used to

that voice in your head that’s used to saying that you’re tone-deaf and you

saying that you’re tone-deaf and you

saying that you’re tone-deaf and you can’t sing and I’m going to need you to

can’t sing and I’m going to need you to

can’t sing and I’m going to need you to society voice that says that you

society voice that says that you

society voice that says that you shouldn’t sing because the people around

shouldn’t sing because the people around

shouldn’t sing because the people around you are going to judge you and instead I

you are going to judge you and instead I

you are going to judge you and instead I want you to take a risk I want you to

want you to take a risk I want you to

want you to take a risk I want you to imagine that you’re sitting on stage

imagine that you’re sitting on stage

imagine that you’re sitting on stage next to one of these seniors or one of

next to one of these seniors or one of

next to one of these seniors or one of these youth experiencing the deep sense

these youth experiencing the deep sense

these youth experiencing the deep sense of joy that comes when we know that we

of joy that comes when we know that we

of joy that comes when we know that we belong and so before I turn it over to

belong and so before I turn it over to

belong and so before I turn it over to Sasha doodles and Kelly who is our

Sasha doodles and Kelly who is our

Sasha doodles and Kelly who is our projects coordinator for the circle of

projects coordinator for the circle of

projects coordinator for the circle of music I just want to say that when we

music I just want to say that when we

music I just want to say that when we finished singing tonight you are welcome

finished singing tonight you are welcome

finished singing tonight you are welcome to applaud but please don’t applaud as

to applaud but please don’t applaud as

to applaud but please don’t applaud as if this was some performance that you

if this was some performance that you

if this was some performance that you watched applaud rather in celebration of

watched applaud rather in celebration of

watched applaud rather in celebration of the moment that were about to share

the moment that were about to share

the moment that were about to share together or applaud in celebration of

together or applaud in celebration of

together or applaud in celebration of the relationships that have formed

the relationships that have formed

the relationships that have formed between these seniors in these youths

between these seniors in these youths

between these seniors in these youths over the last year of the the circle of

over the last year of the the circle of

over the last year of the the circle of music project are you ready

music project are you ready

music project are you ready great let’s sing together tonight

great let’s sing together tonight

great let’s sing together tonight [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

the earth is our mother we must take

the earth is our mother we must take care of her

care of her

care of her the earth is our mother

the earth is our mother

the earth is our mother we must take care of her

hey I know you’re not a Unipol hey I

hey I know you’re not a Unipol hey I know

the rebels are our sisters we must take

the rebels are our sisters we must take care open the rivers are our sisters we

care open the rivers are our sisters we

care open the rivers are our sisters we must take care oh hey Jana

must take care oh hey Jana

must take care oh hey Jana [Music]

the trees are our brothers we must take

the trees are our brothers we must take care we must take care hey hey hey these

care we must take care hey hey hey these

care we must take care hey hey hey these are mother she will take care of our

are mother she will take care of our

are mother she will take care of our face are my teeth will take care

face are my teeth will take care

face are my teeth will take care [Music]

[Music]

[Music] hey hey hey hey

hey hey hey hey

hey hey hey hey Oh

the circle of music is an experience

the circle of music is an experience that just simply wouldn’t exist in our

that just simply wouldn’t exist in our

that just simply wouldn’t exist in our program if we were following those

program if we were following those

program if we were following those traditional models of excellence and we

traditional models of excellence and we

traditional models of excellence and we would lose out on the opportunity to

would lose out on the opportunity to

would lose out on the opportunity to create community between diverse groups

create community between diverse groups

create community between diverse groups of people at its core I believe that

of people at its core I believe that

of people at its core I believe that competition in the pursuit of

competition in the pursuit of

competition in the pursuit of individualized excellence actually

individualized excellence actually

individualized excellence actually fractures relationships and when we

fractures relationships and when we

fractures relationships and when we prioritize technical prescribed outcomes

prioritize technical prescribed outcomes

prioritize technical prescribed outcomes we disempower community stakeholders and

we disempower community stakeholders and

we disempower community stakeholders and the circle of music it’s the kind of

the circle of music it’s the kind of

the circle of music it’s the kind of experience where regardless of whether

experience where regardless of whether

experience where regardless of whether the singing is excellent or not on a

the singing is excellent or not on a

the singing is excellent or not on a given Thursday music remains the

given Thursday music remains the

given Thursday music remains the facilitator of something that’s so much

facilitator of something that’s so much

facilitator of something that’s so much greater for intergenerational

greater for intergenerational

greater for intergenerational communities to be forged for spaces of

communities to be forged for spaces of

communities to be forged for spaces of mentorship and support to flourish and

mentorship and support to flourish and

mentorship and support to flourish and for the hearts and minds of our students

for the hearts and minds of our students

for the hearts and minds of our students to be opened up to the possibility of

to be opened up to the possibility of

to be opened up to the possibility of creating relationships with people that

creating relationships with people that

creating relationships with people that are vastly different than them

are vastly different than them

are vastly different than them relationships that are founded on the

relationships that are founded on the

relationships that are founded on the values of empathy kindness and respect

values of empathy kindness and respect

values of empathy kindness and respect values I believe we can all agree our

values I believe we can all agree our

values I believe we can all agree our world desperately needs more of right

world desperately needs more of right

world desperately needs more of right now in our culture at Cameron Heights we

now in our culture at Cameron Heights we

now in our culture at Cameron Heights we resist the notion that we need to foster

resist the notion that we need to foster

resist the notion that we need to foster the culture of competition and

the culture of competition and

the culture of competition and individualize excellence for the sake of

individualize excellence for the sake of

individualize excellence for the sake of preparing our students for a tough and

preparing our students for a tough and

preparing our students for a tough and competitive world rather I believe it is

competitive world rather I believe it is

competitive world rather I believe it is our responsibility as educators to

our responsibility as educators to

our responsibility as educators to create spaces of inclusion and belonging

create spaces of inclusion and belonging

create spaces of inclusion and belonging for students where they can ultimately

for students where they can ultimately

for students where they can ultimately be empowered to be difference makers in

be empowered to be difference makers in

be empowered to be difference makers in the world shaping the world into a place

the world shaping the world into a place

the world shaping the world into a place where the norm becomes seniors living

where the norm becomes seniors living

where the norm becomes seniors living with dementia meeting to build

with dementia meeting to build

with dementia meeting to build relationships with youth in our program

relationships with youth in our program

relationships with youth in our program we use music as the vehicle to push

we use music as the vehicle to push

we use music as the vehicle to push after this kind of social change in the

after this kind of social change in the

after this kind of social change in the world and the stories of hope and life

world and the stories of hope and life

world and the stories of hope and life transformation that are emerging are

transformation that are emerging are

transformation that are emerging are beautiful and deeply inspiring but I

beautiful and deeply inspiring but I

beautiful and deeply inspiring but I believe that the concepts I’m sharing

believe that the concepts I’m sharing

believe that the concepts I’m sharing with you tonight are broad and I

with you tonight are broad and I

with you tonight are broad and I actually get shivers thinking about what

actually get shivers thinking about what

actually get shivers thinking about what it would look like for each one of you

it would look like for each one of you

it would look like for each one of you gathered here tonight in your own ways

gathered here tonight in your own ways

gathered here tonight in your own ways to begin to implement these ideas in the

to begin to implement these ideas in the

to begin to implement these ideas in the communities that you belong to because

communities that you belong to because

communities that you belong to because the reality is this there are too many

the reality is this there are too many

the reality is this there are too many people in our society who live on the

people in our society who live on the

people in our society who live on the sidelines who feel relegated to the

sidelines who feel relegated to the

sidelines who feel relegated to the margins and they desperately want and

margins and they desperately want and

margins and they desperately want and need a space where they can belong but

need a space where they can belong but

need a space where they can belong but they are terrified that they just don’t

they are terrified that they just don’t

they are terrified that they just don’t match

match

match and they believe that who they are isn’t

and they believe that who they are isn’t

and they believe that who they are isn’t good enough they need a connector

good enough they need a connector

good enough they need a connector someone like you or someone like me

someone like you or someone like me

someone like you or someone like me who’s going to be willing to invite them

who’s going to be willing to invite them

who’s going to be willing to invite them off of the sidelines to pull them from

off of the sidelines to pull them from

off of the sidelines to pull them from their spaces on the margins and welcome

their spaces on the margins and welcome

their spaces on the margins and welcome them into communities where excellence

them into communities where excellence

them into communities where excellence is defined by the quality and the impact

is defined by the quality and the impact

is defined by the quality and the impact of the human interaction and our ability

of the human interaction and our ability

of the human interaction and our ability to be of service to each other

to be of service to each other

to be of service to each other I believe our society needs connectors

I believe our society needs connectors

I believe our society needs connectors now more than it ever has before and so

now more than it ever has before and so

now more than it ever has before and so tonight I leave you with one final

tonight I leave you with one final

tonight I leave you with one final question will you join me in the

question will you join me in the

question will you join me in the difficult but rewarding work of

difficult but rewarding work of

difficult but rewarding work of redefining excellence in our community

redefining excellence in our community

redefining excellence in our community thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *