Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Spiral of Anxiety in Education Competition | Tai Lok Lui | TEDxEdUHK


so let me start with the very beginning

so let me start with the very beginning of the education process here in Hong

of the education process here in Hong

of the education process here in Hong Kong most of the children who start some

Kong most of the children who start some

Kong most of the children who start some form of organised and formal education

form of organised and formal education

form of organised and formal education around the age of two so it’s basically

around the age of two so it’s basically

around the age of two so it’s basically a case where most of the kids barely

a case where most of the kids barely

a case where most of the kids barely know how to stand up for a long period

know how to stand up for a long period

know how to stand up for a long period of time walk and run and then they will

of time walk and run and then they will

of time walk and run and then they will be sent to school to learn which is okay

be sent to school to learn which is okay

be sent to school to learn which is okay and in the context of Hong Kong

and in the context of Hong Kong

and in the context of Hong Kong theoretically preschool education is not

theoretically preschool education is not

theoretically preschool education is not mandatory so basically the to the

mandatory so basically the to the

mandatory so basically the to the parents can choose to go or not to go

parents can choose to go or not to go

parents can choose to go or not to go but increasingly we know that more and

but increasingly we know that more and

but increasingly we know that more and more parents will send the kids to

more parents will send the kids to

more parents will send the kids to school at a very early stage two and two

school at a very early stage two and two

school at a very early stage two and two plus most of the time and sometimes you

plus most of the time and sometimes you

plus most of the time and sometimes you also find some of the kids would go to

also find some of the kids would go to

also find some of the kids would go to school before the age of two and because

school before the age of two and because

school before the age of two and because of the growing numbers of parents

of the growing numbers of parents

of the growing numbers of parents sending their kids to school at an early

sending their kids to school at an early

sending their kids to school at an early stage so this creates certain impacts on

stage so this creates certain impacts on

stage so this creates certain impacts on our system first of all it intensified

our system first of all it intensified

our system first of all it intensified the process of preparation for going to

the process of preparation for going to

the process of preparation for going to school at such an early stage for

school at such an early stage for

school at such an early stage for instance for many parents they think

instance for many parents they think

instance for many parents they think that you know they make backup plans

that you know they make backup plans

that you know they make backup plans they need to make sure that you know

they need to make sure that you know

they need to make sure that you know they will be able to send their kids to

they will be able to send their kids to

they will be able to send their kids to school right at the age of two twenty

school right at the age of two twenty

school right at the age of two twenty years ago when I send my eldest son to

years ago when I send my eldest son to

years ago when I send my eldest son to pre nursery well basically I apply for

pre nursery well basically I apply for

pre nursery well basically I apply for two schools and at that time I think

two schools and at that time I think

two schools and at that time I think that actually I’m quite crazy because

that actually I’m quite crazy because

that actually I’m quite crazy because actually we can afford not to go to

actually we can afford not to go to

actually we can afford not to go to school at the age of two so if I apply

school at the age of two so if I apply

school at the age of two so if I apply and fail so what but I did apply for two

and fail so what but I did apply for two

and fail so what but I did apply for two schools and then we have a backup and it

schools and then we have a backup and it

schools and then we have a backup and it works out perfectly twenty years later

works out perfectly twenty years later

works out perfectly twenty years later when I asked most of the younger parents

when I asked most of the younger parents

when I asked most of the younger parents so what have you done normally the

so what have you done normally the

so what have you done normally the answer is that they have applied for

answer is that they have applied for

answer is that they have applied for something like ten some even twelve

something like ten some even twelve

something like ten some even twelve nurseries preschools so that you know

nurseries preschools so that you know

nurseries preschools so that you know they would be very sure that there would

they would be very sure that there would

they would be very sure that there would be a plan that would be a backup and so

be a plan that would be a backup and so

be a plan that would be a backup and so by the time of all

by the time of all

by the time of all is after some holiday there kids would

is after some holiday there kids would

is after some holiday there kids would go to school and as a result of that is

go to school and as a result of that is

go to school and as a result of that is create a very interesting situation

create a very interesting situation

create a very interesting situation because every parent would apply for

because every parent would apply for

because every parent would apply for something like 12 schools so originally

something like 12 schools so originally

something like 12 schools so originally probably there would be enough positions

probably there would be enough positions

probably there would be enough positions for accommodating the kids but because

for accommodating the kids but because

for accommodating the kids but because everyone is holding 12 so there will be

everyone is holding 12 so there will be

everyone is holding 12 so there will be a shortage and because of shortage

a shortage and because of shortage

a shortage and because of shortage people get nervous and the more nervous

people get nervous and the more nervous

people get nervous and the more nervous you are you apply for more so people

you are you apply for more so people

you are you apply for more so people starting from 12 14 16 and so on of

starting from 12 14 16 and so on of

starting from 12 14 16 and so on of course you will ask the parents that why

course you will ask the parents that why

course you will ask the parents that why don’t ever you need to do that and then

don’t ever you need to do that and then

don’t ever you need to do that and then they start cooking up new narratives is

they start cooking up new narratives is

they start cooking up new narratives is not just about backup it’s actually

not just about backup it’s actually

not just about backup it’s actually quite a good training for kids learning

quite a good training for kids learning

quite a good training for kids learning how to go through interviews so the

how to go through interviews so the

how to go through interviews so the first eight is just for warming up from

first eight is just for warming up from

first eight is just for warming up from 9 to 12 these are the serious stuff and

9 to 12 these are the serious stuff and

9 to 12 these are the serious stuff and for the 13 through 16

for the 13 through 16

for the 13 through 16 it’s just cooling down so it’s like very

it’s just cooling down so it’s like very

it’s just cooling down so it’s like very much like sports so as a result of that

much like sports so as a result of that

much like sports so as a result of that people get a lot more nervous because

people get a lot more nervous because

people get a lot more nervous because everyone is holding 16 of option and in

everyone is holding 16 of option and in

everyone is holding 16 of option and in only 3 days before the beginning of the

only 3 days before the beginning of the

only 3 days before the beginning of the semester they were said ok I’m not

semester they were said ok I’m not

semester they were said ok I’m not coming so people get nervous and the

coming so people get nervous and the

coming so people get nervous and the more nervous you are you start

more nervous you are you start

more nervous you are you start perceiving entrance into nursery

perceiving entrance into nursery

perceiving entrance into nursery preschools in a different way because

preschools in a different way because

preschools in a different way because you think that this is a competition and

you think that this is a competition and

you think that this is a competition and it is a competition that you need to win

it is a competition that you need to win

it is a competition that you need to win as a result of that they start

as a result of that they start

as a result of that they start preparation and schools also started to

preparation and schools also started to

preparation and schools also started to organise interviews interviewing a kid

organise interviews interviewing a kid

organise interviews interviewing a kid about to enter school at the age of two

about to enter school at the age of two

about to enter school at the age of two so at the time of interview he or she

so at the time of interview he or she

so at the time of interview he or she would be around well 18 months 20 months

would be around well 18 months 20 months

would be around well 18 months 20 months barely able to walk to us the desk and

barely able to walk to us the desk and

barely able to walk to us the desk and be interviewed I never quite sure about

be interviewed I never quite sure about

be interviewed I never quite sure about the contents of the interview but I know

the contents of the interview but I know

the contents of the interview but I know from knowing from some of my response

from knowing from some of my response

from knowing from some of my response and saying that you know that would be

and saying that you know that would be

and saying that you know that would be questions about names of parents address

questions about names of parents address

questions about names of parents address how do you come to this place and so on

how do you come to this place and so on

how do you come to this place and so on and so forth

and so forth

and so forth but this would be easy nowadays

but this would be easy nowadays

but this would be easy nowadays increasingly you have more and more

increasingly you have more and more

increasingly you have more and more sophisticated interviews

sophisticated interviews

sophisticated interviews including I’ve seen a case where there

including I’ve seen a case where there

including I’ve seen a case where there will be teachers in another classroom to

will be teachers in another classroom to

will be teachers in another classroom to give instructions in English so that

give instructions in English so that

give instructions in English so that they make sure that the kids know how to

they make sure that the kids know how to

they make sure that the kids know how to respond like you need to jump three

respond like you need to jump three

respond like you need to jump three times and then there will be a principal

times and then there will be a principal

times and then there will be a principal observing what is happening there and

observing what is happening there and

observing what is happening there and then there will be a second session of

then there will be a second session of

then there will be a second session of interview to make sure that you know you

interview to make sure that you know you

interview to make sure that you know you know how to respond to further

know how to respond to further

know how to respond to further questioning so as a result of that

questioning so as a result of that

questioning so as a result of that people get nervous and also you started

people get nervous and also you started

people get nervous and also you started to have new business of preparing

to have new business of preparing

to have new business of preparing one-year-old kids for future interview

one-year-old kids for future interview

one-year-old kids for future interview before the age of two this is the

before the age of two this is the

before the age of two this is the beginning of the process but mind you

beginning of the process but mind you

beginning of the process but mind you this is barely the beginning for most of

this is barely the beginning for most of

this is barely the beginning for most of our children they need to go through

our children they need to go through

our children they need to go through something like fifteen twenty two years

something like fifteen twenty two years

something like fifteen twenty two years of all this kind of competition

of all this kind of competition

of all this kind of competition throughout their education career and

throughout their education career and

throughout their education career and the interesting part of it is that once

the interesting part of it is that once

the interesting part of it is that once you start to be competitive at the age

you start to be competitive at the age

you start to be competitive at the age of two then you start worrying about

of two then you start worrying about

of two then you start worrying about entrance to kindergarten you becoming

entrance to kindergarten you becoming

entrance to kindergarten you becoming more wearing about entrance in the

more wearing about entrance in the

more wearing about entrance in the primary school and the big challenge

primary school and the big challenge

primary school and the big challenge will be getting in the secondary school

will be getting in the secondary school

will be getting in the secondary school and then university and then

and then university and then

and then university and then postgraduate studies so first of all the

postgraduate studies so first of all the

postgraduate studies so first of all the pressure is never-ending and society is

pressure is never-ending and society is

pressure is never-ending and society is growing and more interesting is despite

growing and more interesting is despite

growing and more interesting is despite the government telling you that you know

the government telling you that you know

the government telling you that you know education and including higher education

education and including higher education

education and including higher education is going to becoming more and more

is going to becoming more and more

is going to becoming more and more popular inaccessible quota has been

popular inaccessible quota has been

popular inaccessible quota has been expanded so you should come down but

expanded so you should come down but

expanded so you should come down but this come to the first point I want to

this come to the first point I want to

this come to the first point I want to make this is the first irony that I

make this is the first irony that I

make this is the first irony that I would like to state here is despite the

would like to state here is despite the

would like to state here is despite the fact of the popularization of higher

fact of the popularization of higher

fact of the popularization of higher education pressure on education

education pressure on education

education pressure on education competition has not been reduced in fact

competition has not been reduced in fact

competition has not been reduced in fact because of the popularization of higher

because of the popularization of higher

because of the popularization of higher education this creates another most

education this creates another most

education this creates another most intriguing situation more and more

intriguing situation more and more

intriguing situation more and more parents things that you know getting a

parents things that you know getting a

parents things that you know getting a universe

universe

universe the degree is not enough you need more

the degree is not enough you need more

the degree is not enough you need more and in the context of Hong Kong this is

and in the context of Hong Kong this is

and in the context of Hong Kong this is becoming even more challenging because

becoming even more challenging because

becoming even more challenging because our economy have shift from a more

our economy have shift from a more

our economy have shift from a more diversified economy with manufacturing

diversified economy with manufacturing

diversified economy with manufacturing and other economic activities towards

and other economic activities towards

and other economic activities towards highly concentrating on surfaces and for

highly concentrating on surfaces and for

highly concentrating on surfaces and for high finance for business service you

high finance for business service you

high finance for business service you require credentials in order to enter

require credentials in order to enter

require credentials in order to enter the job market so for a lot of parents

the job market so for a lot of parents

the job market so for a lot of parents they became very nervous because how to

they became very nervous because how to

they became very nervous because how to prepare my children to have all this

prepare my children to have all this

prepare my children to have all this qualification to be qualified for what

qualification to be qualified for what

qualification to be qualified for what they call these and jobs this will be

they call these and jobs this will be

they call these and jobs this will be important so to get a university that’s

important so to get a university that’s

important so to get a university that’s become something basic and more

become something basic and more

become something basic and more interestingly is that you know education

interestingly is that you know education

interestingly is that you know education qualification is something what I call

qualification is something what I call

qualification is something what I call positional goods by this I mean these

positional goods by this I mean these

positional goods by this I mean these are the kinds of goods that not

are the kinds of goods that not

are the kinds of goods that not depending on his own quality it depends

depending on his own quality it depends

depending on his own quality it depends on the consumption of the same good by

on the consumption of the same good by

on the consumption of the same good by other people meaning that if you have an

other people meaning that if you have an

other people meaning that if you have an undergraduate degree by itself of course

undergraduate degree by itself of course

undergraduate degree by itself of course it’s okay but once you find from your

it’s okay but once you find from your

it’s okay but once you find from your peers that they all have ma ma even PhD

peers that they all have ma ma even PhD

peers that they all have ma ma even PhD then you start to worry you start to

then you start to worry you start to

then you start to worry you start to think that you know probably you have

think that you know probably you have

think that you know probably you have not enough so it’s relative and it’s

not enough so it’s relative and it’s

not enough so it’s relative and it’s also positional because you keep on

also positional because you keep on

also positional because you keep on comparing with other people and so as a

comparing with other people and so as a

comparing with other people and so as a result of popularization of higher

result of popularization of higher

result of popularization of higher education it actually creates a very

education it actually creates a very

education it actually creates a very interesting situation where increasingly

interesting situation where increasingly

interesting situation where increasingly we think is not enough to have a

we think is not enough to have a

we think is not enough to have a university degree in fact we need to

university degree in fact we need to

university degree in fact we need to have a degree from a prestigious

have a degree from a prestigious

have a degree from a prestigious university or from a prestigious program

university or from a prestigious program

university or from a prestigious program those most difficult to enter would be

those most difficult to enter would be

those most difficult to enter would be better so as a result most of the

better so as a result most of the

better so as a result most of the parents will start thinking that you

parents will start thinking that you

parents will start thinking that you know not only did I need to prepare my

know not only did I need to prepare my

know not only did I need to prepare my children to get into university in fact

children to get into university in fact

children to get into university in fact I want them to enter only certain

I want them to enter only certain

I want them to enter only certain universities so I need to prepare them

universities so I need to prepare them

universities so I need to prepare them for that so this is irony to saying that

for that so this is irony to saying that

for that so this is irony to saying that you know the popularization of higher

you know the popularization of higher

you know the popularization of higher education not only have not read

education not only have not read

education not only have not read use pressure on education competition in

use pressure on education competition in

use pressure on education competition in fact intensified it it makes people even

fact intensified it it makes people even

fact intensified it it makes people even more nervous because you never get

more nervous because you never get

more nervous because you never get enough you always look across the

enough you always look across the

enough you always look across the shoulder and find out what other people

shoulder and find out what other people

shoulder and find out what other people have and make sure that you know you are

have and make sure that you know you are

have and make sure that you know you are ahead of them so pressure intensified

ahead of them so pressure intensified

ahead of them so pressure intensified competition is becoming more competitive

competition is becoming more competitive

competition is becoming more competitive well but in many other countries in many

well but in many other countries in many

well but in many other countries in many other places the intensification the

other places the intensification the

other places the intensification the competition probably would be just

competition probably would be just

competition probably would be just adding there you think that okay I work

adding there you think that okay I work

adding there you think that okay I work hard I study hard I try to do my best in

hard I study hard I try to do my best in

hard I study hard I try to do my best in the public examination and then I would

the public examination and then I would

the public examination and then I would get to the university that I desired

get to the university that I desired

get to the university that I desired that would be alright

that would be alright

that would be alright but in Hong Kong we have a very strange

but in Hong Kong we have a very strange

but in Hong Kong we have a very strange situation this is a society putting a

situation this is a society putting a

situation this is a society putting a lot of emphasis on achievement and in a

lot of emphasis on achievement and in a

lot of emphasis on achievement and in a way I would say that you know most of us

way I would say that you know most of us

way I would say that you know most of us are very motivated however being hyper

are very motivated however being hyper

are very motivated however being hyper little motivated hyper Li

little motivated hyper Li

little motivated hyper Li achievement-oriented again bring us into

achievement-oriented again bring us into

achievement-oriented again bring us into a very strange position increasingly

a very strange position increasingly

a very strange position increasingly parents think that not only I need to

parents think that not only I need to

parents think that not only I need to start early at the age of two and in

start early at the age of two and in

start early at the age of two and in fact in the process of entering primary

fact in the process of entering primary

fact in the process of entering primary school secondary school I need them need

school secondary school I need them need

school secondary school I need them need to prepare them for the best so what

to prepare them for the best so what

to prepare them for the best so what should I do

should I do

should I do I should ensure that you know they would

I should ensure that you know they would

I should ensure that you know they would be able to distinguish themselves from

be able to distinguish themselves from

be able to distinguish themselves from the others I should ensure that they

the others I should ensure that they

the others I should ensure that they would have the kind of quality to send

would have the kind of quality to send

would have the kind of quality to send out signals to the teachers to the

out signals to the teachers to the

out signals to the teachers to the school system for people who are

school system for people who are

school system for people who are assessing entrance to university knowing

assessing entrance to university knowing

assessing entrance to university knowing that my children are the best so what

that my children are the best so what

that my children are the best so what should you do ok you start thinking

should you do ok you start thinking

should you do ok you start thinking about doing a little extras on top of

about doing a little extras on top of

about doing a little extras on top of curriculum on top of schooling on top of

curriculum on top of schooling on top of

curriculum on top of schooling on top of which school you go to

which school you go to

which school you go to you think probably we need more let’s

you think probably we need more let’s

you think probably we need more let’s start with sports so in the old days

start with sports so in the old days

start with sports so in the old days when I was a secondary school student

when I was a secondary school student

when I was a secondary school student it’s perfectly okay for you just focus

it’s perfectly okay for you just focus

it’s perfectly okay for you just focus on soccer

on soccer

on soccer and I can’t even play basketball quite

and I can’t even play basketball quite

and I can’t even play basketball quite honestly but being a member of the

honestly but being a member of the

honestly but being a member of the school team of the soccer team in the

school team of the soccer team in the

school team of the soccer team in the old days in the 1970s that’s very decent

old days in the 1970s that’s very decent

old days in the 1970s that’s very decent very respectable your classmates love

very respectable your classmates love

very respectable your classmates love you good enough nowadays if you tell

you good enough nowadays if you tell

you good enough nowadays if you tell people that you know I happen to be a

people that you know I happen to be a

people that you know I happen to be a member of the school team for soccer

member of the school team for soccer

member of the school team for soccer then people were expected to say and

then people were expected to say and

then people were expected to say and then and and then you would say that

then and and then you would say that

then and and then you would say that okay I need some other things as well

okay I need some other things as well

okay I need some other things as well but basically soccer player don’t swim

but basically soccer player don’t swim

but basically soccer player don’t swim so what do you expect from me

so what do you expect from me

so what do you expect from me okay then you start saying okay why not

okay then you start saying okay why not

okay then you start saying okay why not other things like music okay then we

other things like music okay then we

other things like music okay then we start musical instrument in Hong Kong we

start musical instrument in Hong Kong we

start musical instrument in Hong Kong we know that you know in terms of the

know that you know in terms of the

know that you know in terms of the examination of your you know performance

examination of your you know performance

examination of your you know performance in musical instruments you have

in musical instruments you have

in musical instruments you have different layers of certificates and

different layers of certificates and

different layers of certificates and most of us would do very well in those

most of us would do very well in those

most of us would do very well in those kinds of examination and so as a result

kinds of examination and so as a result

kinds of examination and so as a result more and more of us start learning to

more and more of us start learning to

more and more of us start learning to play musical instruments and as a result

play musical instruments and as a result

play musical instruments and as a result of that nowadays some of the secondary

of that nowadays some of the secondary

of that nowadays some of the secondary schools would say that all students

schools would say that all students

schools would say that all students would be required to learn how to play

would be required to learn how to play

would be required to learn how to play one musical instrument but in that

one musical instrument but in that

one musical instrument but in that notice to parents they have a bracket

notice to parents they have a bracket

notice to parents they have a bracket piano would not be counted

piano would not be counted

piano would not be counted so if piano is not a musical instrument

so if piano is not a musical instrument

so if piano is not a musical instrument what do you mean by that

what do you mean by that

what do you mean by that well that’s a matter because it’s saying

well that’s a matter because it’s saying

well that’s a matter because it’s saying that you know just knowing to play one

that you know just knowing to play one

that you know just knowing to play one piece of musical instrument this would

piece of musical instrument this would

piece of musical instrument this would not be good enough so we have a

not be good enough so we have a

not be good enough so we have a proliferation of all these extras

proliferation of all these extras

proliferation of all these extras nowadays musical instrument that’s

nowadays musical instrument that’s

nowadays musical instrument that’s ordinary soccer well below ordinary you

ordinary soccer well below ordinary you

ordinary soccer well below ordinary you need non-local learning experience you

need non-local learning experience you

need non-local learning experience you need summer school you need internship

need summer school you need internship

need summer school you need internship you need this you need that and so on

you need this you need that and so on

you need this you need that and so on and so forth so as a result it’s a

and so forth so as a result it’s a

and so forth so as a result it’s a proliferation of all kinds of activities

proliferation of all kinds of activities

proliferation of all kinds of activities and some of them of course are very

and some of them of course are very

and some of them of course are very useful some of them I’m not so sure the

useful some of them I’m not so sure the

useful some of them I’m not so sure the other day I was observing a school that

other day I was observing a school that

other day I was observing a school that teach children to do those do those all

teach children to do those do those all

teach children to do those do those all all calculations in their own minds very

all calculations in their own minds very

all calculations in their own minds very very quickly and of course all the kids

very quickly and of course all the kids

very quickly and of course all the kids perform very well but then

perform very well but then

perform very well but then then you know we have calculators

then you know we have calculators

then you know we have calculators nowadays and it’s very cheap so why do

nowadays and it’s very cheap so why do

nowadays and it’s very cheap so why do we need to do that do we need to do that

we need to do that do we need to do that

we need to do that do we need to do that anymore well doesn’t matter because it’s

anymore well doesn’t matter because it’s

anymore well doesn’t matter because it’s again something extra so in the context

again something extra so in the context

again something extra so in the context of Hong Kong we come to a very strange

of Hong Kong we come to a very strange

of Hong Kong we come to a very strange situation the very fact that we are very

situation the very fact that we are very

situation the very fact that we are very motivated we are very much in

motivated we are very much in

motivated we are very much in achievement oriented it pushes us toward

achievement oriented it pushes us toward

achievement oriented it pushes us toward a situation where we keep on doing the

a situation where we keep on doing the

a situation where we keep on doing the extras even though that we know that is

extras even though that we know that is

extras even though that we know that is doesn’t serve a purpose it is non

doesn’t serve a purpose it is non

doesn’t serve a purpose it is non educational it is becoming too much but

educational it is becoming too much but

educational it is becoming too much but it’s unstoppable this is the iron iron

it’s unstoppable this is the iron iron

it’s unstoppable this is the iron iron III that I want to make saying that you

III that I want to make saying that you

III that I want to make saying that you know this is not only a situation where

know this is not only a situation where

know this is not only a situation where we keep on comparing ourselves with the

we keep on comparing ourselves with the

we keep on comparing ourselves with the others in fact because of all these

others in fact because of all these

others in fact because of all these credentials are all positional we keep

credentials are all positional we keep

credentials are all positional we keep on doing it even though that we think

on doing it even though that we think

on doing it even though that we think that you know this is not a way to do it

that you know this is not a way to do it

that you know this is not a way to do it but we will keep on doing it because we

but we will keep on doing it because we

but we will keep on doing it because we need to stay ahead of competition so we

need to stay ahead of competition so we

need to stay ahead of competition so we end up in a situation where the whole

end up in a situation where the whole

end up in a situation where the whole competition is unstoppable

competition is unstoppable

competition is unstoppable even though that you know this is not a

even though that you know this is not a

even though that you know this is not a way that I should push my children but

way that I should push my children but

way that I should push my children but when I look across the shoulder and I

when I look across the shoulder and I

when I look across the shoulder and I find out what the other parents are

find out what the other parents are

find out what the other parents are doing

doing

doing I will ask my child to do this and that

I will ask my child to do this and that

I will ask my child to do this and that and in fact on top of this I have a

and in fact on top of this I have a

and in fact on top of this I have a taller list of things that you need to

taller list of things that you need to

taller list of things that you need to do is it a good idea no can this be

do is it a good idea no can this be

do is it a good idea no can this be changed probably the title of our theme

changed probably the title of our theme

changed probably the title of our theme today is about going beyond the status

today is about going beyond the status

today is about going beyond the status code what I do think Hong Kong people

code what I do think Hong Kong people

code what I do think Hong Kong people need to do is sit back think and going

need to do is sit back think and going

need to do is sit back think and going back to the basics and we think about

back to the basics and we think about

back to the basics and we think about something very simple what is the

something very simple what is the

something very simple what is the purpose of Education thank you very much

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *