Press "Enter" to skip to content

In Defense of Darkness | Scott Butner | TEDxRichland


you know it’s been a long time since I

you know it’s been a long time since I was there but it’s dark in the womb at

was there but it’s dark in the womb at

was there but it’s dark in the womb at least so I’ve been told

least so I’ve been told

least so I’ve been told and so in darkness were all born and yet

and so in darkness were all born and yet

and so in darkness were all born and yet most of us seem to spend the rest of our

most of us seem to spend the rest of our

most of us seem to spend the rest of our lives trying to avoid the dark we seek

lives trying to avoid the dark we seek

lives trying to avoid the dark we seek out the light and we banish the darkness

out the light and we banish the darkness

out the light and we banish the darkness to the closets and the cellars of our

to the closets and the cellars of our

to the closets and the cellars of our emotional and our physical life I’m in a

emotional and our physical life I’m in a

emotional and our physical life I’m in a dark space right now we might tell a

dark space right now we might tell a

dark space right now we might tell a friend if we’re feeling kind of low kind

friend if we’re feeling kind of low kind

friend if we’re feeling kind of low kind of in a dark place I wouldn’t want to

of in a dark place I wouldn’t want to

of in a dark place I wouldn’t want to meet up with him in a dark alley conveys

meet up with him in a dark alley conveys

meet up with him in a dark alley conveys a threat and not a promise we fear the

a threat and not a promise we fear the

a threat and not a promise we fear the darkness for those unseen things that go

darkness for those unseen things that go

darkness for those unseen things that go bump we fear the darkness for what it

bump we fear the darkness for what it

bump we fear the darkness for what it hides from our sight and yet when we

hides from our sight and yet when we

hides from our sight and yet when we turn out the lights when we turn out the

turn out the lights when we turn out the

turn out the lights when we turn out the lights something wonderful happens we

lights something wonderful happens we

lights something wonderful happens we can often see things that we haven’t

can often see things that we haven’t

can often see things that we haven’t seen before look around you as your eyes

seen before look around you as your eyes

seen before look around you as your eyes get used to the darkness and as they

get used to the darkness and as they

get used to the darkness and as they adjust what can you see that you didn’t

adjust what can you see that you didn’t

adjust what can you see that you didn’t see before maybe you see the glow from

see before maybe you see the glow from

see before maybe you see the glow from the door over here I’m really quite

the door over here I’m really quite

the door over here I’m really quite impressed I was expecting that I’d see

impressed I was expecting that I’d see

impressed I was expecting that I’d see the glow of a few cellphones in the

the glow of a few cellphones in the

the glow of a few cellphones in the audience but I don’t see nary a one and

audience but I don’t see nary a one and

audience but I don’t see nary a one and the magical thing is the longer we stay

the magical thing is the longer we stay

the magical thing is the longer we stay here in the dark the more our eyes adapt

here in the dark the more our eyes adapt

here in the dark the more our eyes adapt and the more that we can see and the

and the more that we can see and the

and the more that we can see and the really neat thing is that when we go

really neat thing is that when we go

really neat thing is that when we go outside into the wilderness and we let

outside into the wilderness and we let

outside into the wilderness and we let we go out on a clear moonless night

we go out on a clear moonless night

we go out on a clear moonless night something similar happens in the dark

something similar happens in the dark

something similar happens in the dark except they’re much more wonderful

unfortunately for most of us we really

unfortunately for most of us we really don’t get views they’re that spectacular

don’t get views they’re that spectacular

don’t get views they’re that spectacular satellite surveys of the night sky

satellite surveys of the night sky

satellite surveys of the night sky indicate that about 80% of the people

indicate that about 80% of the people

indicate that about 80% of the people living in the United States can’t see

living in the United States can’t see

living in the United States can’t see the Milky Way at night

the Milky Way at night

the Milky Way at night where they live light pollution has soul

where they live light pollution has soul

where they live light pollution has soul in the night from us and made it

in the night from us and made it

in the night from us and made it impossible to see those faint objects

impossible to see those faint objects

impossible to see those faint objects that once we’re a part of everyone’s

that once we’re a part of everyone’s

that once we’re a part of everyone’s experience and it doesn’t take very much

experience and it doesn’t take very much

experience and it doesn’t take very much light drive 40 miles from the tri-cities

light drive 40 miles from the tri-cities

light drive 40 miles from the tri-cities you will still see the glow of the

you will still see the glow of the

you will still see the glow of the tri-cities on the horizon but let’s

tri-cities on the horizon but let’s

tri-cities on the horizon but let’s imagine for a moment that we could go

imagine for a moment that we could go

imagine for a moment that we could go out into the wheat fields and on a clear

out into the wheat fields and on a clear

out into the wheat fields and on a clear moonless night what would we see out

moonless night what would we see out

moonless night what would we see out there well the first thing we might

there well the first thing we might

there well the first thing we might notice is that we see a lot more stars

notice is that we see a lot more stars

notice is that we see a lot more stars than we imagine there were when I take

than we imagine there were when I take

than we imagine there were when I take my dog Maddie out for our nightly walk

my dog Maddie out for our nightly walk

my dog Maddie out for our nightly walk just a couple blocks from this theater

just a couple blocks from this theater

just a couple blocks from this theater we’re in town and and I might see

we’re in town and and I might see

we’re in town and and I might see perhaps two dozen stars on a moonless

perhaps two dozen stars on a moonless

perhaps two dozen stars on a moonless night if I’ve been looking at my cell

night if I’ve been looking at my cell

night if I’ve been looking at my cell phone then I’ll probably see a couple

phone then I’ll probably see a couple

phone then I’ll probably see a couple fewer I’m standing in the shadows of a

fewer I’m standing in the shadows of a

fewer I’m standing in the shadows of a maple tree or Sycamore under and and

maple tree or Sycamore under and and

maple tree or Sycamore under and and away from the streetlight I might see a

away from the streetlight I might see a

away from the streetlight I might see a couple dozen more if I go out into the

couple dozen more if I go out into the

couple dozen more if I go out into the suburbs away from the city lights way

suburbs away from the city lights way

suburbs away from the city lights way from commercial buildings and stoplights

from commercial buildings and stoplights

from commercial buildings and stoplights and street lights I might see perhaps

and street lights I might see perhaps

and street lights I might see perhaps two hundred stars in the night sky if I

two hundred stars in the night sky if I

two hundred stars in the night sky if I go out into the wheat fields forty miles

go out into the wheat fields forty miles

go out into the wheat fields forty miles from town away from almost all lights on

from town away from almost all lights on

from town away from almost all lights on a clear moonless night I can see as many

a clear moonless night I can see as many

a clear moonless night I can see as many as forty five hundred stars these are

as forty five hundred stars these are

as forty five hundred stars these are what astronomers call the local

what astronomers call the local

what astronomers call the local neighborhood a turn the only astronomers

neighborhood a turn the only astronomers

neighborhood a turn the only astronomers could get away with using four stars

could get away with using four stars

could get away with using four stars that are still tens to thousands of

that are still tens to thousands of

that are still tens to thousands of light-years away that means the light

light-years away that means the light

light-years away that means the light that left those stars isn’t isn’t what

that left those stars isn’t isn’t what

that left those stars isn’t isn’t what we’re seeing isn’t the light that left

we’re seeing isn’t the light that left

we’re seeing isn’t the light that left those stars right now that’s the light

those stars right now that’s the light

those stars right now that’s the light that left years and years ago in the

that left years and years ago in the

that left years and years ago in the case of our Sun that was eight and a

case of our Sun that was eight and a

case of our Sun that was eight and a half minutes ago in the case of the

half minutes ago in the case of the

half minutes ago in the case of the bright star Sirius which is the dog star

bright star Sirius which is the dog star

bright star Sirius which is the dog star the brightest star we can see in the in

the brightest star we can see in the in

the brightest star we can see in the in the sky that light left eight and a half

the sky that light left eight and a half

the sky that light left eight and a half years ago about the time of the fir

years ago about the time of the fir

years ago about the time of the fir tedtalk actually and if we look at the

tedtalk actually and if we look at the

tedtalk actually and if we look at the star Deneb in the constellation the Swan

star Deneb in the constellation the Swan

star Deneb in the constellation the Swan that light left 1700 years ago when

that light left 1700 years ago when

that light left 1700 years ago when Attila the Hun was still roaming around

Attila the Hun was still roaming around

Attila the Hun was still roaming around Asia but what if we let our eyes adapt

Asia but what if we let our eyes adapt

Asia but what if we let our eyes adapt even further how far can we see well if

even further how far can we see well if

even further how far can we see well if you are out on a summer night in

you are out on a summer night in

you are out on a summer night in particular and you look up to the sky

particular and you look up to the sky

particular and you look up to the sky after your eyes have adapted you’ll see

after your eyes have adapted you’ll see

after your eyes have adapted you’ll see the Milky Way milky way’s of this river

the Milky Way milky way’s of this river

the Milky Way milky way’s of this river of light that crosses the sky roughly

of light that crosses the sky roughly

of light that crosses the sky roughly north to south and the neat thing about

north to south and the neat thing about

north to south and the neat thing about looking at the Milky Way is that we’re

looking at the Milky Way is that we’re

looking at the Milky Way is that we’re looking at the edge of our universe

looking at the edge of our universe

looking at the edge of our universe we’re looking sort of edge on right

we’re looking sort of edge on right

we’re looking sort of edge on right through our universe we’re seeing not

through our universe we’re seeing not

through our universe we’re seeing not tens of stars not hundreds of stars not

tens of stars not hundreds of stars not

tens of stars not hundreds of stars not even millions of stars but hundreds of

even millions of stars but hundreds of

even millions of stars but hundreds of billions of stars and we’re looking very

billions of stars and we’re looking very

billions of stars and we’re looking very far back in time in fact when we look to

far back in time in fact when we look to

far back in time in fact when we look to the southern part of the Milky Way the

the southern part of the Milky Way the

the southern part of the Milky Way the bright part of the Milky Way in the

bright part of the Milky Way in the

bright part of the Milky Way in the summertime we’re seeing light that left

summertime we’re seeing light that left

summertime we’re seeing light that left over 20,000 years ago think about that

over 20,000 years ago think about that

over 20,000 years ago think about that when the light that this picture was

when the light that this picture was

when the light that this picture was taken with let first left the the stars

taken with let first left the the stars

taken with let first left the the stars that originated from this theater and

that originated from this theater and

that originated from this theater and everyone in it would have been under

everyone in it would have been under

everyone in it would have been under about six hundred feet of water because

about six hundred feet of water because

about six hundred feet of water because it would been during the Ice Age floods

it would been during the Ice Age floods

it would been during the Ice Age floods but let’s keep watching for a while what

but let’s keep watching for a while what

but let’s keep watching for a while what else do we see well eventually we’re

else do we see well eventually we’re

else do we see well eventually we’re going to see some shooting stars we’ll

going to see some shooting stars we’ll

going to see some shooting stars we’ll see them streak across the sky and every

see them streak across the sky and every

see them streak across the sky and every one of them is a fiery reminder that

one of them is a fiery reminder that

one of them is a fiery reminder that Joni Mitchell was right when she said

Joni Mitchell was right when she said

Joni Mitchell was right when she said that we are Stardust we were golden

that we are Stardust we were golden

that we are Stardust we were golden because these are the ashes of dead

because these are the ashes of dead

because these are the ashes of dead stars falling to earth to become part of

stars falling to earth to become part of

stars falling to earth to become part of our living planet

let’s look up to the north part of the

let’s look up to the north part of the sky if you look to the north and if

sky if you look to the north and if

sky if you look to the north and if you’re lucky enough and if you’re

you’re lucky enough and if you’re

you’re lucky enough and if you’re patient enough and it’s dark enough you

patient enough and it’s dark enough you

patient enough and it’s dark enough you may just see a great green fog along the

may just see a great green fog along the

may just see a great green fog along the horizon you may even imagine that you

horizon you may even imagine that you

horizon you may even imagine that you see it moving but that’s not your

see it moving but that’s not your

see it moving but that’s not your imagination those are the Northern

imagination those are the Northern

imagination those are the Northern Lights and believe it or not even down

Lights and believe it or not even down

Lights and believe it or not even down here at 47 degrees latitude

here at 47 degrees latitude

here at 47 degrees latitude we still get the Northern Light several

we still get the Northern Light several

we still get the Northern Light several times a year well what does all this

times a year well what does all this

times a year well what does all this matter well I suppose I could tell you

matter well I suppose I could tell you

matter well I suppose I could tell you that this is important because being

that this is important because being

that this is important because being able to see the night sky will inspire

able to see the night sky will inspire

able to see the night sky will inspire our kids to want to be part of these

our kids to want to be part of these

our kids to want to be part of these STEM careers they’re so vaunted it’ll

STEM careers they’re so vaunted it’ll

STEM careers they’re so vaunted it’ll spark their love of science and they’ll

spark their love of science and they’ll

spark their love of science and they’ll want to all grow up to be scientists but

want to all grow up to be scientists but

want to all grow up to be scientists but you know Neil deGrasse Tyson grew up in

you know Neil deGrasse Tyson grew up in

you know Neil deGrasse Tyson grew up in Brooklyn he could see maybe a dozen

Brooklyn he could see maybe a dozen

Brooklyn he could see maybe a dozen stars at night at best and he seems to

stars at night at best and he seems to

stars at night at best and he seems to have done pretty well so I could tell

have done pretty well so I could tell

have done pretty well so I could tell you instead that you know the universe

you instead that you know the universe

you instead that you know the universe and the stars the night sky is inspired

and the stars the night sky is inspired

and the stars the night sky is inspired artists from the ancients through van

artists from the ancients through van

artists from the ancients through van Gogh to Paul Simon and and and even

Gogh to Paul Simon and and and even

Gogh to Paul Simon and and and even contemporary artists and I wouldn’t be

contemporary artists and I wouldn’t be

contemporary artists and I wouldn’t be lying if I said that but I don’t think

lying if I said that but I don’t think

lying if I said that but I don’t think it’s the most important thing and it’s

it’s the most important thing and it’s

it’s the most important thing and it’s certainly not the only thing I could

certainly not the only thing I could

certainly not the only thing I could tell you instead that you have to

tell you instead that you have to

tell you instead that you have to experience it if you lay out on a

experience it if you lay out on a

experience it if you lay out on a blanket at night in the summer that

blanket at night in the summer that

blanket at night in the summer that sense of awe is what’s important that’s

sense of awe is what’s important that’s

sense of awe is what’s important that’s why it’s important but if you’ve done

why it’s important but if you’ve done

why it’s important but if you’ve done that you already understand that and if

that you already understand that and if

that you already understand that and if you haven’t you probably can’t be

you haven’t you probably can’t be

you haven’t you probably can’t be convinced so I’m going to suggest

convinced so I’m going to suggest

convinced so I’m going to suggest instead that what’s important about the

instead that what’s important about the

instead that what’s important about the night sky and our ability to see it is

night sky and our ability to see it is

night sky and our ability to see it is all of these things and more I’m going

all of these things and more I’m going

all of these things and more I’m going to suggest the night sky instead is is a

to suggest the night sky instead is is a

to suggest the night sky instead is is a thread that links us across cultures and

thread that links us across cultures and

thread that links us across cultures and across the ages because it’s the one

across the ages because it’s the one

across the ages because it’s the one thing that hasn’t changed about our

thing that hasn’t changed about our

thing that hasn’t changed about our human experience

human experience

human experience it’s a thread that weaves throughout the

it’s a thread that weaves throughout the

it’s a thread that weaves throughout the human the entire fabric of what it means

human the entire fabric of what it means

human the entire fabric of what it means to be human you know it’s not like the

to be human you know it’s not like the

to be human you know it’s not like the night sky doesn’t change ever but it

night sky doesn’t change ever but it

night sky doesn’t change ever but it changes very slowly across the millennia

changes very slowly across the millennia

changes very slowly across the millennia supernovae here slow drifting a part of

supernovae here slow drifting a part of

supernovae here slow drifting a part of stars over there but for the most part

stars over there but for the most part

stars over there but for the most part things stay pretty constant up in space

things stay pretty constant up in space

things stay pretty constant up in space fact if we were to be standing here with

fact if we were to be standing here with

fact if we were to be standing here with Kennewick Man and walk him down to the

Kennewick Man and walk him down to the

Kennewick Man and walk him down to the river he probably wouldn’t recognize the

river he probably wouldn’t recognize the

river he probably wouldn’t recognize the river not after 6,000 years

river not after 6,000 years

river not after 6,000 years I think the Columbia’s changed a bit

I think the Columbia’s changed a bit

I think the Columbia’s changed a bit since his time he could look up into the

since his time he could look up into the

since his time he could look up into the hills and he would be totally confused

hills and he would be totally confused

hills and he would be totally confused by all these buildings and man-made

by all these buildings and man-made

by all these buildings and man-made structures up there he’d certainly be a

structures up there he’d certainly be a

structures up there he’d certainly be a gasps I think the roar of cars and

gasps I think the roar of cars and

gasps I think the roar of cars and airplanes flying past in every direction

airplanes flying past in every direction

airplanes flying past in every direction but we could take him out into the night

but we could take him out into the night

but we could take him out into the night sky and have him look up and then take

sky and have him look up and then take

sky and have him look up and then take comfort and seeing the arc of the Milky

comfort and seeing the arc of the Milky

comfort and seeing the arc of the Milky Way he could foretell the coming of the

Way he could foretell the coming of the

Way he could foretell the coming of the winter from the three bright stars of

winter from the three bright stars of

winter from the three bright stars of Orion’s belt although he’d know it by a

Orion’s belt although he’d know it by a

Orion’s belt although he’d know it by a different name he would know those stars

different name he would know those stars

different name he would know those stars and he would know that that means when

and he would know that that means when

and he would know that that means when he sees that in the early morning hours

he sees that in the early morning hours

he sees that in the early morning hours that winter’s coming even before the

that winter’s coming even before the

that winter’s coming even before the first frost those stars tell what’s

first frost those stars tell what’s

first frost those stars tell what’s happening he would foresee his fate and

happening he would foresee his fate and

happening he would foresee his fate and ours written in the stars so what can we

ours written in the stars so what can we

ours written in the stars so what can we do about it

do about it

do about it well these talks are supposed to be

well these talks are supposed to be

well these talks are supposed to be about big ideas and so here’s mine I

about big ideas and so here’s mine I

about big ideas and so here’s mine I want to propose that we have a unique

want to propose that we have a unique

want to propose that we have a unique opportunity here in our community

opportunity here in our community

opportunity here in our community something that very community and very

something that very community and very

something that very community and very few communities have in fact and that is

few communities have in fact and that is

few communities have in fact and that is the opportunity to take back some of the

the opportunity to take back some of the

the opportunity to take back some of the night sky these are pictures of the

night sky these are pictures of the

night sky these are pictures of the Hanford reservation at night the first

Hanford reservation at night the first

Hanford reservation at night the first couple were pictures looking south

couple were pictures looking south

couple were pictures looking south towards rattlesnake mountain from the

towards rattlesnake mountain from the

towards rattlesnake mountain from the highway as you notice the mountain has

highway as you notice the mountain has

highway as you notice the mountain has no lights on it from the highway all the

no lights on it from the highway all the

no lights on it from the highway all the way to the top of the mountain looking

way to the top of the mountain looking

way to the top of the mountain looking north the views not quite as as rosy we

north the views not quite as as rosy we

north the views not quite as as rosy we see light spreading from the end reactor

see light spreading from the end reactor

see light spreading from the end reactor to the north to the tri-cities off to

to the north to the tri-cities off to

to the north to the tri-cities off to the east and these islands of light

the east and these islands of light

the east and these islands of light basically obscure the the night sky all

basically obscure the the night sky all

basically obscure the the night sky all along the horizon looking further beyond

along the horizon looking further beyond

along the horizon looking further beyond Hanford though we see very few lights

Hanford though we see very few lights

Hanford though we see very few lights between the river and the town of a

between the river and the town of a

between the river and the town of a thilo just a few scattered farms so we

thilo just a few scattered farms so we

thilo just a few scattered farms so we have a stretch of about 35 miles from

have a stretch of about 35 miles from

have a stretch of about 35 miles from north to south

north to south

north to south and yes right now they’re obscured by

and yes right now they’re obscured by

and yes right now they’re obscured by lights from the construction projects

lights from the construction projects

lights from the construction projects and the end the cleanup projects but

and the end the cleanup projects but

and the end the cleanup projects but what if we were to set about deciding

what if we were to set about deciding

what if we were to set about deciding that we were going to clean up not only

that we were going to clean up not only

that we were going to clean up not only the soil and the water at Hanford but

the soil and the water at Hanford but

the soil and the water at Hanford but the night sky as well call me naive or

the night sky as well call me naive or

the night sky as well call me naive or call me an optimist I like to prefer an

call me an optimist I like to prefer an

call me an optimist I like to prefer an optimist but I think at some point that

optimist but I think at some point that

optimist but I think at some point that cleanup project will be done and the

cleanup project will be done and the

cleanup project will be done and the need for those lights will slowly fade

need for those lights will slowly fade

need for those lights will slowly fade away what if we could bring back that

away what if we could bring back that

away what if we could bring back that that ability to go out into the Hanford

that ability to go out into the Hanford

that ability to go out into the Hanford Site and see the night sky in its

Site and see the night sky in its

Site and see the night sky in its richness it can be done

richness it can be done

richness it can be done communities all around the United States

communities all around the United States

communities all around the United States have especially here in the West where

have especially here in the West where

have especially here in the West where where it’s not too late

where it’s not too late

where it’s not too late have elected to try to save some of the

have elected to try to save some of the

have elected to try to save some of the night sky there’s an organization called

night sky there’s an organization called

night sky there’s an organization called the International dark-sky Association

the International dark-sky Association

the International dark-sky Association that actually has put together a model

that actually has put together a model

that actually has put together a model ordinance that helps to protect both

ordinance that helps to protect both

ordinance that helps to protect both personal property and personal safety

personal property and personal safety

personal property and personal safety while still preserving the night by

while still preserving the night by

while still preserving the night by minimizing the amount of light that

minimizing the amount of light that

minimizing the amount of light that spills over from lighting fixtures and

spills over from lighting fixtures and

spills over from lighting fixtures and homes and businesses communities like

homes and businesses communities like

homes and businesses communities like Malibu California and Sedona Arizona and

Malibu California and Sedona Arizona and

Malibu California and Sedona Arizona and Moab Utah have all adopted these

Moab Utah have all adopted these

Moab Utah have all adopted these standards and found ways to preserve the

standards and found ways to preserve the

standards and found ways to preserve the night sky in fact what they found is

night sky in fact what they found is

night sky in fact what they found is that it actually increases the amount of

that it actually increases the amount of

that it actually increases the amount of time that tourists spend in their

time that tourists spend in their

time that tourists spend in their communities we already know that people

communities we already know that people

communities we already know that people come to the tri-cities for our abundant

come to the tri-cities for our abundant

come to the tri-cities for our abundant sunshine what if we could offer them

sunshine what if we could offer them

sunshine what if we could offer them starlight as well that would be pretty

starlight as well that would be pretty

starlight as well that would be pretty cool so if you share that vision if you

cool so if you share that vision if you

cool so if you share that vision if you believe that something that’s worthwhile

believe that something that’s worthwhile

believe that something that’s worthwhile I encourage you to do at least one thing

I encourage you to do at least one thing

I encourage you to do at least one thing tonight today and that is to go to the

tonight today and that is to go to the

tonight today and that is to go to the Facebook page in defense of darkness

Facebook page in defense of darkness

Facebook page in defense of darkness that’s the site that we’ve set up

that’s the site that we’ve set up

that’s the site that we’ve set up specifically as a rallying point for

specifically as a rallying point for

specifically as a rallying point for people who believe as I do that the

people who believe as I do that the

people who believe as I do that the night sky ties us across time and across

night sky ties us across time and across

night sky ties us across time and across space to the rest of the universe and

space to the rest of the universe and

space to the rest of the universe and who want to try to find a way to

who want to try to find a way to

who want to try to find a way to preserve that

preserve that

preserve that we have a choice we can preserve that

we have a choice we can preserve that

we have a choice we can preserve that darkness we can reclaim the night for

darkness we can reclaim the night for

darkness we can reclaim the night for our children and for ourselves or we can

our children and for ourselves or we can

our children and for ourselves or we can let it vanish into a bright glow it’s up

let it vanish into a bright glow it’s up

let it vanish into a bright glow it’s up to us thank you very much

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *