Press "Enter" to skip to content

Learning from History | Dr. Sayed Irfan Habib | TEDxStEdmundsSchool


yeah good evening and thank you for for

yeah good evening and thank you for for this introduction unfortunately I didn’t

this introduction unfortunately I didn’t

this introduction unfortunately I didn’t decide to actually go into all this past

decide to actually go into all this past

decide to actually go into all this past of Indian science because that is not

of Indian science because that is not

of Indian science because that is not exactly what I planned I thought I will

exactly what I planned I thought I will

exactly what I planned I thought I will talk talk to you about learning from

talk talk to you about learning from

talk talk to you about learning from history that’s what the pain told me and

history that’s what the pain told me and

history that’s what the pain told me and I will touch upon science as well and

I will touch upon science as well and

I will touch upon science as well and the idea was to do in present context

the idea was to do in present context

the idea was to do in present context particularly in India where past is

particularly in India where past is

particularly in India where past is always with us all the time and all of

always with us all the time and all of

always with us all the time and all of us claim to be great experts in

us claim to be great experts in

us claim to be great experts in understanding what our past is which

understanding what our past is which

understanding what our past is which leads to all sorts of problems for us so

leads to all sorts of problems for us so

leads to all sorts of problems for us so I thought let me let me reflect upon

I thought let me let me reflect upon

I thought let me let me reflect upon that in this brief little time we have

that in this brief little time we have

that in this brief little time we have first what exactly is history history

first what exactly is history history

first what exactly is history history for us today is not really the history

for us today is not really the history

for us today is not really the history which we used to learn couple of decades

which we used to learn couple of decades

which we used to learn couple of decades ago which was a biography of kings and

ago which was a biography of kings and

ago which was a biography of kings and queens and we never bothered to actually

queens and we never bothered to actually

queens and we never bothered to actually have a look at the past in terms of what

have a look at the past in terms of what

have a look at the past in terms of what what were the production techniques what

what were the production techniques what

what were the production techniques what was science what was our culture and

was science what was our culture and

was science what was our culture and what was the sort of life which people

what was the sort of life which people

what was the sort of life which people used to lead now that aspect of our

used to lead now that aspect of our

used to lead now that aspect of our history was totally untouched so it was

history was totally untouched so it was

history was totally untouched so it was a very very very enclaved a sort of

a very very very enclaved a sort of

a very very very enclaved a sort of understanding of our past now all that

understanding of our past now all that

understanding of our past now all that is behind us we have gone much beyond

is behind us we have gone much beyond

is behind us we have gone much beyond that and today as the little girls just

that and today as the little girls just

that and today as the little girls just told you are and then understanding of

told you are and then understanding of

told you are and then understanding of history and my own concern one concern

history and my own concern one concern

history and my own concern one concern you know I do a couple of things but one

you know I do a couple of things but one

you know I do a couple of things but one of them is my understanding of of

of them is my understanding of of

of them is my understanding of of science in India

science in India

science in India I don’t do ancient science what exactly

I don’t do ancient science what exactly

I don’t do ancient science what exactly happened in India in the 19th century

happened in India in the 19th century

happened in India in the 19th century onwards how did we engage with with

onwards how did we engage with with

onwards how did we engage with with modernity with modern science etcetera

modernity with modern science etcetera

modernity with modern science etcetera without traditional knowledge base

without traditional knowledge base

without traditional knowledge base in tact and that was that was the the

in tact and that was that was the the

in tact and that was that was the the main challenge because India is a

main challenge because India is a

main challenge because India is a civilization which which is not actually

civilization which which is not actually

civilization which which is not actually actually like like it’s not a tabula

actually like like it’s not a tabula

actually like like it’s not a tabula rasa now it is it is a civilization

rasa now it is it is a civilization

rasa now it is it is a civilization which is rich which contributes to be

which is rich which contributes to be

which is rich which contributes to be rich no country not even the British

rich no country not even the British

rich no country not even the British could come here and impose things

could come here and impose things

could come here and impose things without facing a challenge from what

without facing a challenge from what

without facing a challenge from what India actually was so there was a very

India actually was so there was a very

India actually was so there was a very very active sort of interaction between

very active sort of interaction between

very active sort of interaction between between India Indian civilization and

between India Indian civilization and

between India Indian civilization and what the British got got to got to India

what the British got got to got to India

what the British got got to got to India with them in the 19th century so this

with them in the 19th century so this

with them in the 19th century so this interaction I have tried to understand

interaction I have tried to understand

interaction I have tried to understand all my work is around that what we did

all my work is around that what we did

all my work is around that what we did to mathematics what we did to to science

to mathematics what we did to to science

to mathematics what we did to to science in general what we did to modern

in general what we did to modern

in general what we did to modern scientific ideas in general so all that

scientific ideas in general so all that

scientific ideas in general so all that gives us and gives us an idea how our

gives us and gives us an idea how our

gives us and gives us an idea how our knowledge can be understood can be read

knowledge can be understood can be read

knowledge can be understood can be read in a broad perspective that teaches us

in a broad perspective that teaches us

in a broad perspective that teaches us that is actually the understanding of

that is actually the understanding of

that is actually the understanding of history which I have that teaches us

history which I have that teaches us

history which I have that teaches us that the world is porous all of us

that the world is porous all of us

that the world is porous all of us cannot claim and nobody can claim

cannot claim and nobody can claim

cannot claim and nobody can claim exclusive rights over over knowledge

exclusive rights over over knowledge

exclusive rights over over knowledge scientific knowledge particularly we

scientific knowledge particularly we

scientific knowledge particularly we have learnt and this is something which

have learnt and this is something which

have learnt and this is something which I which I keep saying that we cannot

I which I keep saying that we cannot

I which I keep saying that we cannot claim as as some people do that we are

claim as as some people do that we are

claim as as some people do that we are masters of the world we are masters of

masters of the world we are masters of

masters of the world we are masters of the world of course in some areas but we

the world of course in some areas but we

the world of course in some areas but we have also learned a lot from others and

have also learned a lot from others and

have also learned a lot from others and that is something which I try to

that is something which I try to

that is something which I try to emphasize that we should get out of that

emphasize that we should get out of that

emphasize that we should get out of that mode when we learn about the past when

mode when we learn about the past when

mode when we learn about the past when you talk about the past when I talk

you talk about the past when I talk

you talk about the past when I talk about the history of our civilization we

about the history of our civilization we

about the history of our civilization we have given to the world but we have in

have given to the world but we have in

have given to the world but we have in the process understood a lot from others

the process understood a lot from others

the process understood a lot from others and that is how that is how the the

and that is how that is how the the

and that is how that is how the the knowledge grows in this in this process

knowledge grows in this in this process

knowledge grows in this in this process we

we

we we actually try to try to grapple with

we actually try to try to grapple with

we actually try to try to grapple with with civilizations elsewhere and there

with civilizations elsewhere and there

with civilizations elsewhere and there are so many instances one can one can

are so many instances one can one can

are so many instances one can one can give but there is no time for that if we

give but there is no time for that if we

give but there is no time for that if we move from from this to the political

move from from this to the political

move from from this to the political history part of it which is my another

history part of it which is my another

history part of it which is my another area and I want to talk about it because

area and I want to talk about it because

area and I want to talk about it because that is very very important in the

that is very very important in the

that is very very important in the context we are living in today in India

context we are living in today in India

context we are living in today in India when we learn from history like for

when we learn from history like for

when we learn from history like for example I give you an example of a

example I give you an example of a

example I give you an example of a guessing Bhagat Singh is somebody which

guessing Bhagat Singh is somebody which

guessing Bhagat Singh is somebody which everybody who everybody loves and

everybody who everybody loves and

everybody who everybody loves and everybody can relate to especially the

everybody can relate to especially the

everybody can relate to especially the young when we read about him we just

young when we read about him we just

young when we read about him we just don’t care what progressing actually

don’t care what progressing actually

don’t care what progressing actually stood for you know that is that is how

stood for you know that is that is how

stood for you know that is that is how history is being he history is being

history is being he history is being

history is being he history is being being read we just remember him as a

being read we just remember him as a

being read we just remember him as a martyr as a great nationalist we don’t

martyr as a great nationalist we don’t

martyr as a great nationalist we don’t care to understand what exactly he stood

care to understand what exactly he stood

care to understand what exactly he stood for what were his ideas and in his case

for what were his ideas and in his case

for what were his ideas and in his case it is so easy because he left behind the

it is so easy because he left behind the

it is so easy because he left behind the intellectual legacy in the form of

intellectual legacy in the form of

intellectual legacy in the form of written word he wrote so much so we can

written word he wrote so much so we can

written word he wrote so much so we can we can straightaway go and understand

we can straightaway go and understand

we can straightaway go and understand try to understand what exactly he left

try to understand what exactly he left

try to understand what exactly he left behind unfortunately in our context

behind unfortunately in our context

behind unfortunately in our context today for the last several years we

today for the last several years we

today for the last several years we don’t bother to understand our past in a

don’t bother to understand our past in a

don’t bother to understand our past in a manner in which we should do in a

manner in which we should do in a

manner in which we should do in a holistic way we do that very

holistic way we do that very

holistic way we do that very conveniently that’s what we suits us

conveniently that’s what we suits us

conveniently that’s what we suits us because amatis legacy is very convenient

because amatis legacy is very convenient

because amatis legacy is very convenient on 20th March you’ve organized a

on 20th March you’ve organized a

on 20th March you’ve organized a function garland is photo and finish his

function garland is photo and finish his

function garland is photo and finish his intellectual legacy is very difficult to

intellectual legacy is very difficult to

intellectual legacy is very difficult to follow because he is a man who talked

follow because he is a man who talked

follow because he is a man who talked off and these are all relevant things

off and these are all relevant things

off and these are all relevant things unfortunately even today against cast

unfortunately even today against cast

unfortunately even today against cast against communalism the role of students

against communalism the role of students

against communalism the role of students in politics and international universal

in politics and international universal

in politics and international universal brotherhood well these are all important

brotherhood well these are all important

brotherhood well these are all important subjects

subjects

subjects she touched upon as a young man of 23 so

she touched upon as a young man of 23 so

she touched upon as a young man of 23 so if you try to grapple with these ideas

if you try to grapple with these ideas

if you try to grapple with these ideas of s then it will take lot of energy lot

of s then it will take lot of energy lot

of s then it will take lot of energy lot of time lot of difficult exercise

of time lot of difficult exercise

of time lot of difficult exercise because you just can’t do that by God

because you just can’t do that by God

because you just can’t do that by God Landingham so these are issues which

Landingham so these are issues which

Landingham so these are issues which need to be kept in mind when we talk of

need to be kept in mind when we talk of

need to be kept in mind when we talk of learning from history and these are

learning from history and these are

learning from history and these are examples have tried to give to you

examples have tried to give to you

examples have tried to give to you similarly there are so many other

similarly there are so many other

similarly there are so many other instances the one can talk about

instances the one can talk about

instances the one can talk about unfortunately what is happening with

unfortunately what is happening with

unfortunately what is happening with with our past is that in India

with our past is that in India

with our past is that in India particularly I have not seen it in

particularly I have not seen it in

particularly I have not seen it in elsewhere in other countries among

elsewhere in other countries among

elsewhere in other countries among students or even the adult population

students or even the adult population

students or even the adult population people don’t relate to the past in a

people don’t relate to the past in a

people don’t relate to the past in a manner in a passionate way as as we do

manner in a passionate way as as we do

manner in a passionate way as as we do and that is across caste communities

and that is across caste communities

and that is across caste communities religion or age groups every everybody

religion or age groups every everybody

religion or age groups every everybody in India and I try to use this process

in India and I try to use this process

in India and I try to use this process again panikker actually used this

again panikker actually used this

again panikker actually used this expression once long back that history

expression once long back that history

expression once long back that history is it like cricket anybody can can make

is it like cricket anybody can can make

is it like cricket anybody can can make a comment sitting outside and whether

a comment sitting outside and whether

a comment sitting outside and whether you have held a bat in your life or not

you have held a bat in your life or not

you have held a bat in your life or not but you will make a comment on it on a

but you will make a comment on it on a

but you will make a comment on it on a batsman’s style of betting similarly in

batsman’s style of betting similarly in

batsman’s style of betting similarly in history without understanding without

history without understanding without

history without understanding without reading without knowing anything we

reading without knowing anything we

reading without knowing anything we can’t you can’t do that in economics in

can’t you can’t do that in economics in

can’t you can’t do that in economics in sociology science is not possible at all

sociology science is not possible at all

sociology science is not possible at all history is only subject where everybody

history is only subject where everybody

history is only subject where everybody is an expert and that is the reason why

is an expert and that is the reason why

is an expert and that is the reason why we are actually facing all sorts of

we are actually facing all sorts of

we are actually facing all sorts of problems because history has a method

problems because history has a method

problems because history has a method history has a method of understanding

history has a method of understanding

history has a method of understanding the past the tools of understanding in

the past the tools of understanding in

the past the tools of understanding in the past which most of the people don’t

the past which most of the people don’t

the past which most of the people don’t don’t really comprehend you know they

don’t really comprehend you know they

don’t really comprehend you know they don’t they and we don’t expect anybody

don’t they and we don’t expect anybody

don’t they and we don’t expect anybody doesn’t expect everyone to be an expert

doesn’t expect everyone to be an expert

doesn’t expect everyone to be an expert in history but everybody wants to relate

in history but everybody wants to relate

in history but everybody wants to relate to the past whether it is in terms of

to the past whether it is in terms of

to the past whether it is in terms of religion caste community I don’t want to

religion caste community I don’t want to

religion caste community I don’t want to name but there are so many problems we

name but there are so many problems we

name but there are so many problems we are facing today and all that involves a

are facing today and all that involves a

are facing today and all that involves a large number of people with the past

large number of people with the past

large number of people with the past unfortunately instead of learning

unfortunately instead of learning

unfortunately instead of learning learning from the past we have started

learning from the past we have started

learning from the past we have started some of us haven’t started living in the

some of us haven’t started living in the

some of us haven’t started living in the past now that that causes most of the

past now that that causes most of the

past now that that causes most of the trouble because past you can only relate

trouble because past you can only relate

trouble because past you can only relate to the past in the context of what you

to the past in the context of what you

to the past in the context of what you want to plan for your future you should

want to plan for your future you should

want to plan for your future you should learn but you can’t actually start

learn but you can’t actually start

learn but you can’t actually start living in the past that that causes most

living in the past that that causes most

living in the past that that causes most of the trouble because if you do that

of the trouble because if you do that

of the trouble because if you do that then you are going to confront because

then you are going to confront because

then you are going to confront because most of your present cannot cannot

most of your present cannot cannot

most of your present cannot cannot reconcile with the with the medieval

reconcile with the with the medieval

reconcile with the with the medieval past of the ancient past because those

past of the ancient past because those

past of the ancient past because those were different worlds those were

were different worlds those were

were different worlds those were different times you can only talk about

different times you can only talk about

different times you can only talk about them and learn whatever is is retrieve

them and learn whatever is is retrieve

them and learn whatever is is retrieve whatever is retrievable salvage water

whatever is retrievable salvage water

whatever is retrievable salvage water whatever is salvageable not everything

whatever is salvageable not everything

whatever is salvageable not everything unfortunately we are not making that

unfortunately we are not making that

unfortunately we are not making that sort of distinction which we need to

sort of distinction which we need to

sort of distinction which we need to make and so learning from the past

make and so learning from the past

make and so learning from the past learning from history is important only

learning from history is important only

learning from history is important only when you try to rationally understand

when you try to rationally understand

when you try to rationally understand what exactly how you exactly you want to

what exactly how you exactly you want to

what exactly how you exactly you want to learn you just can’t emotionally engage

learn you just can’t emotionally engage

learn you just can’t emotionally engage with the past or you can’t look for

with the past or you can’t look for

with the past or you can’t look for heroes and heroines in the past because

heroes and heroines in the past because

heroes and heroines in the past because today that is another serious problem

today that is another serious problem

today that is another serious problem that we want to look for heroes in

that we want to look for heroes in

that we want to look for heroes in medieval India in ancient India we don’t

medieval India in ancient India we don’t

medieval India in ancient India we don’t understand though these people will come

understand though these people will come

understand though these people will come with their baggage with their weaknesses

with their baggage with their weaknesses

with their baggage with their weaknesses and strengths because they belong to a

and strengths because they belong to a

and strengths because they belong to a different period know which which will

different period know which which will

different period know which which will not really go along your 21st century

not really go along your 21st century

not really go along your 21st century life type lifestyle or values but some

life type lifestyle or values but some

life type lifestyle or values but some people want to do that and that is the

people want to do that and that is the

people want to do that and that is the issue which is leading to all sorts of

issue which is leading to all sorts of

issue which is leading to all sorts of trouble which we are facing in our lives

trouble which we are facing in our lives

trouble which we are facing in our lives almost every day and unfortunately

almost every day and unfortunately

almost every day and unfortunately history has become more important

history has become more important

history has become more important subject than then even economic

subject than then even economic

subject than then even economic condition of the country you know

condition of the country you know

condition of the country you know because we are more passionate about

because we are more passionate about

because we are more passionate about what happened in the past then what is

what happened in the past then what is

what happened in the past then what is happening today or what is going to

happening today or what is going to

happening today or what is going to happen in future so that is that is

happen in future so that is that is

happen in future so that is that is something which is I believe is a future

something which is I believe is a future

something which is I believe is a future either is a

either is a

either is a is a misunderstanding of the past not

is a misunderstanding of the past not

is a misunderstanding of the past not really the understanding of the past

really the understanding of the past

really the understanding of the past thank you

thank you

thank you [Music]

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *