Press "Enter" to skip to content

Modern Progressivism and Religion: Are They Incompatible? | Reuben D’Silva | TEDxPershingSq


Thank You stool for that a great

Thank You stool for that a great gracious introduction so I guess I’m the

gracious introduction so I guess I’m the

gracious introduction so I guess I’m the last speaker today so I try to be as

last speaker today so I try to be as

last speaker today so I try to be as perky and as uplifting as possible I’m a

perky and as uplifting as possible I’m a

perky and as uplifting as possible I’m a public school teacher so this is

public school teacher so this is

public school teacher so this is something that I had to kind of do for a

something that I had to kind of do for a

something that I had to kind of do for a living so I’ll try to be as a brief and

living so I’ll try to be as a brief and

living so I’ll try to be as a brief and there’s a perky as a possible so I’m

there’s a perky as a possible so I’m

there’s a perky as a possible so I’m talking today about religion and

talking today about religion and

talking today about religion and politics and I’m already looking out

politics and I’m already looking out

politics and I’m already looking out into this audience and some of you guys

into this audience and some of you guys

into this audience and some of you guys are like for real seriously I didn’t

are like for real seriously I didn’t

are like for real seriously I didn’t come here for that those are the two

come here for that those are the two

come here for that those are the two things that you just don’t talk about in

things that you just don’t talk about in

things that you just don’t talk about in good company or at the dinner table but

good company or at the dinner table but

good company or at the dinner table but they the fact that it matter is that

they the fact that it matter is that

they the fact that it matter is that these two things religion and politics

these two things religion and politics

these two things religion and politics are really the fundamental way in which

are really the fundamental way in which

are really the fundamental way in which throughout human history we as human

throughout human history we as human

throughout human history we as human beings have come to identify the world

beings have come to identify the world

beings have come to identify the world around us view of the world around us

around us view of the world around us

around us view of the world around us and understand the peoples around us and

and understand the peoples around us and

and understand the peoples around us and ourselves

ourselves

ourselves indeed ourselves so religion and

indeed ourselves so religion and

indeed ourselves so religion and politics may be something that you don’t

politics may be something that you don’t

politics may be something that you don’t talk about at the kitchen table or

talk about at the kitchen table or

talk about at the kitchen table or around good company but it is

around good company but it is

around good company but it is fundamentally important to understand

fundamentally important to understand

fundamentally important to understand that our societies are shaped and

that our societies are shaped and

that our societies are shaped and extremely extremely big and influential

extremely extremely big and influential

extremely extremely big and influential ways by these two things so this isn’t

ways by these two things so this isn’t

ways by these two things so this isn’t really matter but my politics I’ll just

really matter but my politics I’ll just

really matter but my politics I’ll just go ahead and just throw them out there

go ahead and just throw them out there

go ahead and just throw them out there real quick I are progressive I believe

real quick I are progressive I believe

real quick I are progressive I believe in a in raising the minimum wage I

in a in raising the minimum wage I

in a in raising the minimum wage I believe in a upholding and protecting

believe in a upholding and protecting

believe in a upholding and protecting the rights of the lgbtqia+ community to

the rights of the lgbtqia+ community to

the rights of the lgbtqia+ community to marry I believe that a Planned

marry I believe that a Planned

marry I believe that a Planned Parenthood is a good thing and we need

Parenthood is a good thing and we need

Parenthood is a good thing and we need to promote a funding for a Planned

to promote a funding for a Planned

to promote a funding for a Planned Parenthood as a great health resource in

Parenthood as a great health resource in

Parenthood as a great health resource in our communities I believe in a

our communities I believe in a

our communities I believe in a single-payer health care system and

single-payer health care system and

single-payer health care system and universal health care and on the same

universal health care and on the same

universal health care and on the same token of my religion I’m a committed

token of my religion I’m a committed

token of my religion I’m a committed Christian I believe in the Ten

Christian I believe in the Ten

Christian I believe in the Ten Commandments I believe that the God of

Commandments I believe that the God of

Commandments I believe that the God of Abraham revealed himself to Abraham in

Abraham revealed himself to Abraham in

Abraham revealed himself to Abraham in in the deserts out there somewhere in

in the deserts out there somewhere in

in the deserts out there somewhere in Mesopotamia

Mesopotamia

Mesopotamia I believe that Jesus Saves so that

I believe that Jesus Saves so that

I believe that Jesus Saves so that really often times becomes a a sort a

really often times becomes a a sort a

really often times becomes a a sort a reason for conflict how can you

reason for conflict how can you

reason for conflict how can you reconcile these two things because I

reconcile these two things because I

reconcile these two things because I also understand that religion has

also understand that religion has

also understand that religion has throughout the entire course of the

throughout the entire course of the

throughout the entire course of the human narrative the court the entire

human narrative the court the entire

human narrative the court the entire scope of human history when used to

scope of human history when used to

scope of human history when used to marginalized communities it’s been used

marginalized communities it’s been used

marginalized communities it’s been used it’s been used to oppress entire

it’s been used to oppress entire

it’s been used to oppress entire categories of people’s religion has been

categories of people’s religion has been

categories of people’s religion has been used to divide commune

used to divide commune

used to divide commune and yes to to install all kinds of acts

and yes to to install all kinds of acts

and yes to to install all kinds of acts of violence and war itself those of you

of violence and war itself those of you

of violence and war itself those of you who study history will understand some

who study history will understand some

who study history will understand some of the most brutal of brutal of wars

of the most brutal of brutal of wars

of the most brutal of brutal of wars were fought along religious lines

were fought along religious lines

were fought along religious lines whether you look at the Wars of the

whether you look at the Wars of the

whether you look at the Wars of the Reformation in Europe or even what’s

Reformation in Europe or even what’s

Reformation in Europe or even what’s going on the Middle East today a war

going on the Middle East today a war

going on the Middle East today a war that I served in you know I remember

that I served in you know I remember

that I served in you know I remember just how important religion was in that

just how important religion was in that

just how important religion was in that conflict in the war in Iraq

conflict in the war in Iraq

conflict in the war in Iraq so that baguettes the question and it’s

so that baguettes the question and it’s

so that baguettes the question and it’s an important question to ask ourselves

an important question to ask ourselves

an important question to ask ourselves as a global humanity as a global mankind

as a global humanity as a global mankind

as a global humanity as a global mankind how can you be somebody who espouses

how can you be somebody who espouses

how can you be somebody who espouses progressivism because those things I

progressivism because those things I

progressivism because those things I just mentioned all right

just mentioned all right

just mentioned all right war marginalization oppression so on and

war marginalization oppression so on and

war marginalization oppression so on and so forth are not progressive values how

so forth are not progressive values how

so forth are not progressive values how can you be and identify yourself as a

can you be and identify yourself as a

can you be and identify yourself as a progressive and be a good Jew how can

progressive and be a good Jew how can

progressive and be a good Jew how can you identify yourself as a progressive

you identify yourself as a progressive

you identify yourself as a progressive and be a good Hindu or a Buddhist how

and be a good Hindu or a Buddhist how

and be a good Hindu or a Buddhist how can you identify yourself as a

can you identify yourself as a

can you identify yourself as a progressive and be a committed Christian

progressive and be a committed Christian

progressive and be a committed Christian how can you identify yourself as a

how can you identify yourself as a

how can you identify yourself as a progressive and be a Muslim how can that

progressive and be a Muslim how can that

progressive and be a Muslim how can that be and again this is a question that an

be and again this is a question that an

be and again this is a question that an encyclopedia is you really answer this

encyclopedia is you really answer this

encyclopedia is you really answer this question but the argument that I want to

question but the argument that I want to

question but the argument that I want to make today here today to you all and my

make today here today to you all and my

make today here today to you all and my real idea that I just want to promote is

real idea that I just want to promote is

real idea that I just want to promote is that in many regards progressivism

that in many regards progressivism

that in many regards progressivism modern progressivism and religion are

modern progressivism and religion are

modern progressivism and religion are not in two separate spheres they don’t

not in two separate spheres they don’t

not in two separate spheres they don’t exist in two separate categories and

exist in two separate categories and

exist in two separate categories and indeed there are significant ways in

indeed there are significant ways in

indeed there are significant ways in which these two arenas actually do

which these two arenas actually do

which these two arenas actually do overlap and there’s a multitude of

overlap and there’s a multitude of

overlap and there’s a multitude of different ways of approaching this and

different ways of approaching this and

different ways of approaching this and again as a history teacher I teach high

again as a history teacher I teach high

again as a history teacher I teach high school history so let’s look at some of

school history so let’s look at some of

school history so let’s look at some of the some of the key terms now all right

the some of the key terms now all right

the some of the key terms now all right some of the buzzwords the key terms and

some of the buzzwords the key terms and

some of the buzzwords the key terms and definitions all right when you think of

definitions all right when you think of

definitions all right when you think of the modern-day progressive movement all

the modern-day progressive movement all

the modern-day progressive movement all right some of the buzz words are

right some of the buzz words are

right some of the buzz words are economic justice all right social

economic justice all right social

economic justice all right social justice climate justice gender justice

justice climate justice gender justice

justice climate justice gender justice racial justice justice is at the heart

racial justice justice is at the heart

racial justice justice is at the heart and at the soul really of modern

and at the soul really of modern

and at the soul really of modern progressivism now if you look at

progressivism now if you look at

progressivism now if you look at the organized face of the world and I do

the organized face of the world and I do

the organized face of the world and I do worry folks on organized religion

worry folks on organized religion

worry folks on organized religion Christianity Buddhism Judaism Islam and

Christianity Buddhism Judaism Islam and

Christianity Buddhism Judaism Islam and if you look at this concept justice it

if you look at this concept justice it

if you look at this concept justice it is also at the very heart and soul of

is also at the very heart and soul of

is also at the very heart and soul of each one of those faiths the with the

each one of those faiths the with the

each one of those faiths the with the judeo-christian imagery of justice

judeo-christian imagery of justice

judeo-christian imagery of justice rolling down the the rocks and mountains

rolling down the the rocks and mountains

rolling down the the rocks and mountains like a roaring stream like waters that

like a roaring stream like waters that

like a roaring stream like waters that are going to free people is a very vivid

are going to free people is a very vivid

are going to free people is a very vivid one in Christianity there was actually

one in Christianity there was actually

one in Christianity there was actually and judeo-christianity I should say that

and judeo-christianity I should say that

and judeo-christianity I should say that was embraced by people like dr. Martin

was embraced by people like dr. Martin

was embraced by people like dr. Martin Luther King Bernie Sanders if you look

Luther King Bernie Sanders if you look

Luther King Bernie Sanders if you look at the idea of the word Allah in Arabic

at the idea of the word Allah in Arabic

at the idea of the word Allah in Arabic this is the this is the name for God and

this is the this is the name for God and

this is the this is the name for God and the word is translated to utter justice

the word is translated to utter justice

the word is translated to utter justice it is a name of Allah Himself if you

it is a name of Allah Himself if you

it is a name of Allah Himself if you look at the first indo-aryan language

look at the first indo-aryan language

look at the first indo-aryan language that was written down in a script in a

that was written down in a script in a

that was written down in a script in a form of writing and when the first the

form of writing and when the first the

form of writing and when the first the symbols that was actually made of vivid

symbols that was actually made of vivid

symbols that was actually made of vivid really I was written down in the ancient

really I was written down in the ancient

really I was written down in the ancient language of Sanskrit it was a word

language of Sanskrit it was a word

language of Sanskrit it was a word knee knee eye which means what do you

knee knee eye which means what do you

knee knee eye which means what do you think justice and again do you know the

think justice and again do you know the

think justice and again do you know the dharmic religions are huge on this

dharmic religions are huge on this

dharmic religions are huge on this concept of me high justice in the world

concept of me high justice in the world

concept of me high justice in the world so when you understand this notion now

so when you understand this notion now

so when you understand this notion now that justice is at the core of both the

that justice is at the core of both the

that justice is at the core of both the modern progressive movement and religion

modern progressive movement and religion

modern progressive movement and religion you can start seeing if there’s some

you can start seeing if there’s some

you can start seeing if there’s some important overlaps and again I don’t

important overlaps and again I don’t

important overlaps and again I don’t take too much time but I was told that

take too much time but I was told that

take too much time but I was told that we have to wrap this up quickly because

we have to wrap this up quickly because

we have to wrap this up quickly because you guys have been sitting here since

you guys have been sitting here since

you guys have been sitting here since 9:00 o’clock in the morning I want to

9:00 o’clock in the morning I want to

9:00 o’clock in the morning I want to make this argument a this big idea and

make this argument a this big idea and

make this argument a this big idea and that is that the two communities are at

that is that the two communities are at

that is that the two communities are at modern progressive warriors out there

modern progressive warriors out there

modern progressive warriors out there and religious communities shouldn’t be

and religious communities shouldn’t be

and religious communities shouldn’t be in separate spheres and that the two

in separate spheres and that the two

in separate spheres and that the two groups should find each other and work

groups should find each other and work

groups should find each other and work together on common causes whether it is

together on common causes whether it is

together on common causes whether it is racial justice whether it is a health

racial justice whether it is a health

racial justice whether it is a health care rights whether it is that bringing

care rights whether it is that bringing

care rights whether it is that bringing together and fighting for poor people

together and fighting for poor people

together and fighting for poor people it’s a powerful thing

it’s a powerful thing

it’s a powerful thing this

this

this say to way up to a Muslim that that

say to way up to a Muslim that that

say to way up to a Muslim that that Allah mandates you to work and push your

Allah mandates you to work and push your

Allah mandates you to work and push your society to take care of the poor it is

society to take care of the poor it is

society to take care of the poor it is mandated for you as a Muslim to do this

mandated for you as a Muslim to do this

mandated for you as a Muslim to do this it’s important too it’s a powerful thing

it’s important too it’s a powerful thing

it’s important too it’s a powerful thing to understand that in Judaism if you’re

to understand that in Judaism if you’re

to understand that in Judaism if you’re Jewish that Yahweh mandates you commands

Jewish that Yahweh mandates you commands

Jewish that Yahweh mandates you commands you if you’re a a landowner or a

you if you’re a a landowner or a

you if you’re a a landowner or a landlord that you must pay a just wage

landlord that you must pay a just wage

landlord that you must pay a just wage to your Labor’s or if you have

to your Labor’s or if you have

to your Labor’s or if you have foreigners at your door that they must

foreigners at your door that they must

foreigners at your door that they must be welcomed in if you have strangers at

be welcomed in if you have strangers at

be welcomed in if you have strangers at your door whether they be migrants

your door whether they be migrants

your door whether they be migrants whether it be immigrants or whether they

whether it be immigrants or whether they

whether it be immigrants or whether they be refugees it’s a powerful thing to say

be refugees it’s a powerful thing to say

be refugees it’s a powerful thing to say to a Christian that Jesus never asked

to a Christian that Jesus never asked

to a Christian that Jesus never asked for a deductible or a copay when He

for a deductible or a copay when He

for a deductible or a copay when He healed the sickest of the sick and

healed the sickest of the sick and

healed the sickest of the sick and raised people from the dead there’s a

raised people from the dead there’s a

raised people from the dead there’s a progressive values those are religious

progressive values those are religious

progressive values those are religious values so and when I add well upon is

values so and when I add well upon is

values so and when I add well upon is and this is again the history teacher in

and this is again the history teacher in

and this is again the history teacher in me when I think about the great icons of

me when I think about the great icons of

me when I think about the great icons of progress throughout the scope of human

progress throughout the scope of human

progress throughout the scope of human history you can see that many of them I

history you can see that many of them I

history you can see that many of them I would even argue and say most of them

would even argue and say most of them

would even argue and say most of them were driven by religious fervor the

were driven by religious fervor the

were driven by religious fervor the abolitionists who embraced the story of

abolitionists who embraced the story of

abolitionists who embraced the story of Exodus from the Hebrew Scriptures as

Exodus from the Hebrew Scriptures as

Exodus from the Hebrew Scriptures as they fought vehemently tirelessly to

they fought vehemently tirelessly to

they fought vehemently tirelessly to eradicate slavery in this country I

eradicate slavery in this country I

eradicate slavery in this country I think of Mahatma Gandhi who embraced the

think of Mahatma Gandhi who embraced the

think of Mahatma Gandhi who embraced the concepts of ahimsa who embraced the

concepts of ahimsa who embraced the

concepts of ahimsa who embraced the concept of satyagraha him submitting

concept of satyagraha him submitting

concept of satyagraha him submitting non-violence satyagraha means soul force

non-violence satyagraha means soul force

non-violence satyagraha means soul force and embracing those notions and those

and embracing those notions and those

and embracing those notions and those ideas to free an entire subcontinent

ideas to free an entire subcontinent

ideas to free an entire subcontinent from imperial rule in a non-violent

from imperial rule in a non-violent

from imperial rule in a non-violent manner largely that is an extremely

manner largely that is an extremely

manner largely that is an extremely amazing thing that was accomplished in

amazing thing that was accomplished in

amazing thing that was accomplished in human history where the most amazing

human history where the most amazing

human history where the most amazing things I will say to free 300 million

things I will say to free 300 million

things I will say to free 300 million people in a non-violent way a largely

people in a non-violent way a largely

people in a non-violent way a largely nonviolent fashion I think that the

nonviolent fashion I think that the

nonviolent fashion I think that the great icon one of my personal heroes dr.

great icon one of my personal heroes dr.

great icon one of my personal heroes dr. King who used his Christianity as an

King who used his Christianity as an

King who used his Christianity as an inspiration to fight for the civil

inspiration to fight for the civil

inspiration to fight for the civil liberties and a civil right

liberties and a civil right

liberties and a civil right of this country’s african-american

of this country’s african-american

of this country’s african-american community and through that successful

community and through that successful

community and through that successful movement was able to garner civil rights

movement was able to garner civil rights

movement was able to garner civil rights for many different marginalized

for many different marginalized

for many different marginalized communities I think of Cesar Chavez who

communities I think of Cesar Chavez who

communities I think of Cesar Chavez who in this very state embraced his Catholic

in this very state embraced his Catholic

in this very state embraced his Catholic identity and said that God is the

identity and said that God is the

identity and said that God is the protector of the laborers that workers

protector of the laborers that workers

protector of the laborers that workers rights are divine rights and it is up to

rights are divine rights and it is up to

rights are divine rights and it is up to society to make sure that they are

society to make sure that they are

society to make sure that they are getting paid a living wage that they

getting paid a living wage that they

getting paid a living wage that they have equitable living conditions and

have equitable living conditions and

have equitable living conditions and that they’re safe when they work I think

that they’re safe when they work I think

that they’re safe when they work I think of modern day heroes like milena Yousef

of modern day heroes like milena Yousef

of modern day heroes like milena Yousef side or Desmond Tutu who again garnered

side or Desmond Tutu who again garnered

side or Desmond Tutu who again garnered their religious faith both of them

their religious faith both of them

their religious faith both of them identify themselves as being very

identify themselves as being very

identify themselves as being very religious and both of them embraced the

religious and both of them embraced the

religious and both of them embraced the notion of reconciliation in in terms of

notion of reconciliation in in terms of

notion of reconciliation in in terms of moving their societies forward Desmond

moving their societies forward Desmond

moving their societies forward Desmond Tutu was a second second-class citizen

Tutu was a second second-class citizen

Tutu was a second second-class citizen in his country South Africa during

in his country South Africa during

in his country South Africa during apartheid and we know what happened to

apartheid and we know what happened to

apartheid and we know what happened to Malala Malala yousufzai shot in the head

Malala Malala yousufzai shot in the head

Malala Malala yousufzai shot in the head by the Taliban survived spoke out and

by the Taliban survived spoke out and

by the Taliban survived spoke out and said that it is it is though it is a a

said that it is it is though it is a a

said that it is it is though it is a a sin that the Taliban is saying that I

sin that the Taliban is saying that I

sin that the Taliban is saying that I cannot be participating in my own

cannot be participating in my own

cannot be participating in my own society my own community because I’m a

society my own community because I’m a

society my own community because I’m a woman and she embraced religion and

woman and she embraced religion and

woman and she embraced religion and argued against another religious idea

argued against another religious idea

argued against another religious idea the Taliban was espousing to her own

the Taliban was espousing to her own

the Taliban was espousing to her own faith so again there’s just a couple of

faith so again there’s just a couple of

faith so again there’s just a couple of historical examples that I want to give

historical examples that I want to give

historical examples that I want to give but I really want to end on this one

but I really want to end on this one

but I really want to end on this one note that if we can again as in days

note that if we can again as in days

note that if we can again as in days past connect the tool that the modern

past connect the tool that the modern

past connect the tool that the modern progressive progressive movement and

progressive progressive movement and

progressive progressive movement and religious organized religion are not in

religious organized religion are not in

religious organized religion are not in separate arenas they’re not in separate

separate arenas they’re not in separate

separate arenas they’re not in separate worlds if we can start building those

worlds if we can start building those

worlds if we can start building those divides if we can start working together

divides if we can start working together

divides if we can start working together and again I know that there are certain

and again I know that there are certain

and again I know that there are certain things that are going to be perennial

things that are going to be perennial

things that are going to be perennial issues that may never be rectified I

issues that may never be rectified I

issues that may never be rectified I understand that they would never be in

understand that they would never be in

understand that they would never be in any sort of congruence but there is a

any sort of congruence but there is a

any sort of congruence but there is a great degree of overlap and if we can

great degree of overlap and if we can

great degree of overlap and if we can once again our generation make this

once again our generation make this

once again our generation make this happen

happen

happen we can truly bring transformative

we can truly bring transformative

we can truly bring transformative globally transformative change to this

globally transformative change to this

globally transformative change to this world in the right direction thank you

world in the right direction thank you

world in the right direction thank you again everybody

again everybody

again everybody [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *