Press "Enter" to skip to content

Is Academic Knowledge a Public Good? | Professor Steve Fuller | TEDxUniversityofBolton


let me start by saying that the question

let me start by saying that the question that I’m going to be addressing here is

that I’m going to be addressing here is

that I’m going to be addressing here is one that might either seem very obvious

one that might either seem very obvious

one that might either seem very obvious or in fact very difficult and I want to

or in fact very difficult and I want to

or in fact very difficult and I want to say that in fact it’s a very difficult

say that in fact it’s a very difficult

say that in fact it’s a very difficult question to answer because if you ask

question to answer because if you ask

question to answer because if you ask academics whether they think the

academics whether they think the

academics whether they think the knowledge that they produce is a public

knowledge that they produce is a public

knowledge that they produce is a public good I think the answer that they would

good I think the answer that they would

good I think the answer that they would give you is that self-evidently yes okay

give you is that self-evidently yes okay

give you is that self-evidently yes okay and this has something to do with the

and this has something to do with the

and this has something to do with the way in which they think about the nature

way in which they think about the nature

way in which they think about the nature of the knowledge that they produce

of the knowledge that they produce

of the knowledge that they produce namely it’s something that in principle

namely it’s something that in principle

namely it’s something that in principle is meant for everyone

is meant for everyone

is meant for everyone and all you need to have is the right

and all you need to have is the right

and all you need to have is the right credentials and background knowledge and

credentials and background knowledge and

credentials and background knowledge and oh all of a sudden things start to get

oh all of a sudden things start to get

oh all of a sudden things start to get tricky because of course the background

tricky because of course the background

tricky because of course the background knowledge that you actually need to have

knowledge that you actually need to have

knowledge that you actually need to have in order to access academic knowledge is

in order to access academic knowledge is

in order to access academic knowledge is one that typically requires that you go

one that typically requires that you go

one that typically requires that you go under academic training and so to give

under academic training and so to give

under academic training and so to give you a sense of how this is a kind of

you a sense of how this is a kind of

you a sense of how this is a kind of complicated issue I want you to think

complicated issue I want you to think

complicated issue I want you to think about what two phrases mean that are

about what two phrases mean that are

about what two phrases mean that are very much part of the popular culture in

very much part of the popular culture in

very much part of the popular culture in which we live one is the idea of

which we live one is the idea of

which we live one is the idea of knowledge being open access okay and

knowledge being open access okay and

knowledge being open access okay and when we talk about that in the academic

when we talk about that in the academic

when we talk about that in the academic world what we usually mean is that there

world what we usually mean is that there

world what we usually mean is that there are journals that the University perhaps

are journals that the University perhaps

are journals that the University perhaps has paid a subscription to and so forth

has paid a subscription to and so forth

has paid a subscription to and so forth but one of the consequences of it is

but one of the consequences of it is

but one of the consequences of it is that anyone can have access anywhere on

that anyone can have access anywhere on

that anyone can have access anywhere on the internet if they can just access it

the internet if they can just access it

the internet if they can just access it however that idea doesn’t necessarily

however that idea doesn’t necessarily

however that idea doesn’t necessarily enable anyone to be able to make sense

enable anyone to be able to make sense

enable anyone to be able to make sense of the content of the knowledge that’s

of the content of the knowledge that’s

of the content of the knowledge that’s located in those journals okay because

located in those journals okay because

located in those journals okay because basically you need to be educated in

basically you need to be educated in

basically you need to be educated in exactly the same way as the people who

exactly the same way as the people who

exactly the same way as the people who wrote the articles who are in those

wrote the articles who are in those

wrote the articles who are in those journals so in this respect open access

journals so in this respect open access

journals so in this respect open access in terms of providing free access that’s

in terms of providing free access that’s

in terms of providing free access that’s to say free from a purely financial

to say free from a purely financial

to say free from a purely financial standpoint the academic knowledge only

standpoint the academic knowledge only

standpoint the academic knowledge only benefits those who are already

benefits those who are already

benefits those who are already academically trained

academically trained

academically trained okay that’s open access there’s another

okay that’s open access there’s another

okay that’s open access there’s another phrase that we also use as well and it’s

phrase that we also use as well and it’s

phrase that we also use as well and it’s called open source okay open source is

called open source okay open source is

called open source okay open source is where you can actually intervene in the

where you can actually intervene in the

where you can actually intervene in the knowledge that is being produced so we

knowledge that is being produced so we

knowledge that is being produced so we talked about open source very often in

talked about open source very often in

talked about open source very often in the context of computer codes and things

the context of computer codes and things

the context of computer codes and things like this where there’s a sense in which

like this where there’s a sense in which

like this where there’s a sense in which there’s already a kind of body of

there’s already a kind of body of

there’s already a kind of body of knowledge you might say that it’s

knowledge you might say that it’s

knowledge you might say that it’s already there but the the the issue here

already there but the the the issue here

already there but the the the issue here is who can actually intervene and change

is who can actually intervene and change

is who can actually intervene and change and contribute to it in some fashion

and contribute to it in some fashion

and contribute to it in some fashion when we talk about knowledge being open

when we talk about knowledge being open

when we talk about knowledge being open source we’re operating on the assumption

source we’re operating on the assumption

source we’re operating on the assumption that the people who are consuming the

that the people who are consuming the

that the people who are consuming the knowledge are potential producers of the

knowledge are potential producers of the

knowledge are potential producers of the knowledge right there isn’t this kind of

knowledge right there isn’t this kind of

knowledge right there isn’t this kind of asymmetry right and what I would like to

asymmetry right and what I would like to

asymmetry right and what I would like to argue in this context is that academic

argue in this context is that academic

argue in this context is that academic knowledge normally speaking is open

knowledge normally speaking is open

knowledge normally speaking is open access perhaps but not open source okay

access perhaps but not open source okay

access perhaps but not open source okay and in order for academic knowledge to

and in order for academic knowledge to

and in order for academic knowledge to be a public good in the proper sense it

be a public good in the proper sense it

be a public good in the proper sense it has to be open source just as much as

has to be open source just as much as

has to be open source just as much as it’s open access okay and that is the

it’s open access okay and that is the

it’s open access okay and that is the proposition that I want to sort of put

proposition that I want to sort of put

proposition that I want to sort of put on the table for you to think about now

on the table for you to think about now

on the table for you to think about now when we talk about something as being a

when we talk about something as being a

when we talk about something as being a public good in economics because that’s

public good in economics because that’s

public good in economics because that’s where the phrase comes from public good

where the phrase comes from public good

where the phrase comes from public good it’s an it’s a phrase from economics and

it’s an it’s a phrase from economics and

it’s an it’s a phrase from economics and the idea here is that it would actually

the idea here is that it would actually

the idea here is that it would actually cost more to restrict access to the good

cost more to restrict access to the good

cost more to restrict access to the good than it would to allow the good to be

than it would to allow the good to be

than it would to allow the good to be freely available okay so it’s a it’s

freely available okay so it’s a it’s

freely available okay so it’s a it’s really about the issue of the cost of

really about the issue of the cost of

really about the issue of the cost of access that’s kind of what the public

access that’s kind of what the public

access that’s kind of what the public good idea is about and so you know so

good idea is about and so you know so

good idea is about and so you know so when this idea was first put forward the

when this idea was first put forward the

when this idea was first put forward the the point was that actually there’s

the point was that actually there’s

the point was that actually there’s certain if you’re you know what is the

certain if you’re you know what is the

certain if you’re you know what is the goal that we’re thinking about when

goal that we’re thinking about when

goal that we’re thinking about when we’re talking about goods in general

we’re talking about goods in general

we’re talking about goods in general well the idea generally speaking is that

well the idea generally speaking is that

well the idea generally speaking is that we’re talking about something that can

we’re talking about something that can

we’re talking about something that can benefit the well-being or welfare of an

benefit the well-being or welfare of an

benefit the well-being or welfare of an entire society or group or community or

entire society or group or community or

entire society or group or community or market in other words make them more

market in other words make them more

market in other words make them more productive to put it in the real

productive to put it in the real

productive to put it in the real economists terms and there are going to

economists terms and there are going to

economists terms and there are going to be certain kinds of goods that if you

be certain kinds of goods that if you

be certain kinds of goods that if you restrict access to them they actually

restrict access to them they actually

restrict access to them they actually inhibit the overall capacity of the

inhibit the overall capacity of the

inhibit the overall capacity of the society to be able to be productive in

society to be able to be productive in

society to be able to be productive in the way that would benefit everyone okay

the way that would benefit everyone okay

the way that would benefit everyone okay and so there is actually something to be

and so there is actually something to be

and so there is actually something to be said for making those kinds of Goods

said for making those kinds of Goods

said for making those kinds of Goods freely available now academic knowledge

freely available now academic knowledge

freely available now academic knowledge actually doesn’t have this character

actually doesn’t have this character

actually doesn’t have this character this is the point it doesn’t have this

this is the point it doesn’t have this

this is the point it doesn’t have this character in its current form and why is

character in its current form and why is

character in its current form and why is that because there are actually access

that because there are actually access

that because there are actually access costs to academic knowledge and that is

costs to academic knowledge and that is

costs to academic knowledge and that is because the only way typically in which

because the only way typically in which

because the only way typically in which anyone outside of academia can get

anyone outside of academia can get

anyone outside of academia can get access to this knowledge is by being

access to this knowledge is by being

access to this knowledge is by being trained at academia academically right

trained at academia academically right

trained at academia academically right if you want to read a scientific journal

if you want to read a scientific journal

if you want to read a scientific journal article if you want to make sense of

article if you want to make sense of

article if you want to make sense of what’s going on in all these

what’s going on in all these

what’s going on in all these professional journals and things like

professional journals and things like

professional journals and things like this you typically need to have some

this you typically need to have some

this you typically need to have some kind of academic training so even if the

kind of academic training so even if the

kind of academic training so even if the knowledge is out there available for

knowledge is out there available for

knowledge is out there available for free on the internet

free on the internet

free on the internet if you have not been trained properly

if you have not been trained properly

if you have not been trained properly you cannot make sense of what’s going on

you cannot make sense of what’s going on

you cannot make sense of what’s going on okay that is still an access cost just

okay that is still an access cost just

okay that is still an access cost just because it’s not a financial cost

because it’s not a financial cost

because it’s not a financial cost doesn’t mean it’s not an access cost and

doesn’t mean it’s not an access cost and

doesn’t mean it’s not an access cost and this is where academic knowledge rather

this is where academic knowledge rather

this is where academic knowledge rather than being a public good is normally

than being a public good is normally

than being a public good is normally speaking a club good that is to say it

speaking a club good that is to say it

speaking a club good that is to say it is kind of good that in a sense the

is kind of good that in a sense the

is kind of good that in a sense the value of it has a lot to do with already

value of it has a lot to do with already

value of it has a lot to do with already being an insider okay think about clubs

being an insider okay think about clubs

being an insider okay think about clubs right you get certain benefits by virtue

right you get certain benefits by virtue

right you get certain benefits by virtue of paying a subscription and you often

of paying a subscription and you often

of paying a subscription and you often need to pay you know when you pay the

need to pay you know when you pay the

need to pay you know when you pay the subscription part of it has to do with

subscription part of it has to do with

subscription part of it has to do with your having gone through some kind of

your having gone through some kind of

your having gone through some kind of vetting procedure in advance and so

vetting procedure in advance and so

vetting procedure in advance and so forth and then you become member of the

forth and then you become member of the

forth and then you become member of the club and you can do certain things and

club and you can do certain things and

club and you can do certain things and know certain things that people outside

know certain things that people outside

know certain things that people outside the club cannot know okay academic

the club cannot know okay academic

the club cannot know okay academic knowledge de facto regardless of all the

knowledge de facto regardless of all the

knowledge de facto regardless of all the rhetoric and

rhetoric and

rhetoric and hype surrounding it is for the most part

hype surrounding it is for the most part

hype surrounding it is for the most part a club good okay and it’s a club good if

a club good okay and it’s a club good if

a club good okay and it’s a club good if we’re understanding academic knowledge

we’re understanding academic knowledge

we’re understanding academic knowledge primarily at the level of the research

primarily at the level of the research

primarily at the level of the research publication okay because so far

publication okay because so far

publication okay because so far everything I’ve been talking about with

everything I’ve been talking about with

everything I’ve been talking about with regard to academic knowledge has been

regard to academic knowledge has been

regard to academic knowledge has been about journal articles and the writings

about journal articles and the writings

about journal articles and the writings and publications of academics and so

and publications of academics and so

and publications of academics and so that is the thing that often claims to

that is the thing that often claims to

that is the thing that often claims to be a public good but as in fact I would

be a public good but as in fact I would

be a public good but as in fact I would argue a club good so the question then

argue a club good so the question then

argue a club good so the question then becomes well then where do we get this

becomes well then where do we get this

becomes well then where do we get this idea of academic knowledge being a

idea of academic knowledge being a

idea of academic knowledge being a public good in the first place given

public good in the first place given

public good in the first place given that in fact if you want to make sense

that in fact if you want to make sense

that in fact if you want to make sense of anything that academics are doing you

of anything that academics are doing you

of anything that academics are doing you have to already have some academic

have to already have some academic

have to already have some academic training so there’s an enormous amount

training so there’s an enormous amount

training so there’s an enormous amount of access cost to it how do we even get

of access cost to it how do we even get

of access cost to it how do we even get this idea that academic knowledge is a

this idea that academic knowledge is a

this idea that academic knowledge is a public good and here I think this goes

public good and here I think this goes

public good and here I think this goes to the heart of what a university is

to the heart of what a university is

to the heart of what a university is supposed to be okay so here what I want

supposed to be okay so here what I want

supposed to be okay so here what I want to race is that when we think about this

to race is that when we think about this

to race is that when we think about this problem if we think that this idea of

problem if we think that this idea of

problem if we think that this idea of academic knowledge is a public good is

academic knowledge is a public good is

academic knowledge is a public good is not really you know doesn’t really live

not really you know doesn’t really live

not really you know doesn’t really live up to its hype the reason probably is

up to its hype the reason probably is

up to its hype the reason probably is because universities aren’t quite doing

because universities aren’t quite doing

because universities aren’t quite doing what they’re doing

what they’re doing

what they’re doing in other words universities ought to be

in other words universities ought to be

in other words universities ought to be in the business in fact they ought to be

in the business in fact they ought to be

in the business in fact they ought to be in the unique business of manufacturing

in the unique business of manufacturing

in the unique business of manufacturing knowledge as a public good okay and let

knowledge as a public good okay and let

knowledge as a public good okay and let me explain what I mean by that and this

me explain what I mean by that and this

me explain what I mean by that and this has a lot to do with how we should be

has a lot to do with how we should be

has a lot to do with how we should be thinking about the relationship between

thinking about the relationship between

thinking about the relationship between research and teaching because I haven’t

research and teaching because I haven’t

research and teaching because I haven’t said anything about teaching yet but

said anything about teaching yet but

said anything about teaching yet but it’s through the teaching process that

it’s through the teaching process that

it’s through the teaching process that actually knowledge gets academic

actually knowledge gets academic

actually knowledge gets academic knowledge gets turned into a public good

knowledge gets turned into a public good

knowledge gets turned into a public good and without the teaching process being

and without the teaching process being

and without the teaching process being seen as integral to what happens to

seen as integral to what happens to

seen as integral to what happens to research once it’s done you are never

research once it’s done you are never

research once it’s done you are never going to make academic knowledge a

going to make academic knowledge a

going to make academic knowledge a public good okay so let me explain where

public good okay so let me explain where

public good okay so let me explain where I’m coming from here I mean there’s one

I’m coming from here I mean there’s one

I’m coming from here I mean there’s one level at which I’m coming from which I’m

level at which I’m coming from which I’m

level at which I’m coming from which I’m coming from and that

coming from and that

coming from and that has to do with the kind of classical

has to do with the kind of classical

has to do with the kind of classical definition of the University of Vilhelm

definition of the University of Vilhelm

definition of the University of Vilhelm von Humboldt in the beginning of the

von Humboldt in the beginning of the

von Humboldt in the beginning of the 19th century who came up with this idea

19th century who came up with this idea

19th century who came up with this idea that what the university was about was

that what the university was about was

that what the university was about was about this kind of integration or unity

about this kind of integration or unity

about this kind of integration or unity or synthesis of research and teaching

or synthesis of research and teaching

or synthesis of research and teaching and the academic as a professional

and the academic as a professional

and the academic as a professional vocation right embodied that combination

vocation right embodied that combination

vocation right embodied that combination right and that was the unique thing

right and that was the unique thing

right and that was the unique thing about being in academic that was the

about being in academic that was the

about being in academic that was the thing that academics did that nobody

thing that academics did that nobody

thing that academics did that nobody else did is they did both research and

else did is they did both research and

else did is they did both research and teaching right because we’ve had people

teaching right because we’ve had people

teaching right because we’ve had people doing research you know for eons and

doing research you know for eons and

doing research you know for eons and many of them didn’t really have much to

many of them didn’t really have much to

many of them didn’t really have much to do with teaching especially if we teach

do with teaching especially if we teach

do with teaching especially if we teach if we think about teaching from the

if we think about teaching from the

if we think about teaching from the standpoint of trying to bestow knowledge

standpoint of trying to bestow knowledge

standpoint of trying to bestow knowledge on people who don’t already have the

on people who don’t already have the

on people who don’t already have the background and in some sense need to be

background and in some sense need to be

background and in some sense need to be introduced to the background and who may

introduced to the background and who may

introduced to the background and who may in fact once they get the knowledge may

in fact once they get the knowledge may

in fact once they get the knowledge may not be taking it in the direction of the

not be taking it in the direction of the

not be taking it in the direction of the people who produce the knowledge right

people who produce the knowledge right

people who produce the knowledge right for me this is the kind of robust

for me this is the kind of robust

for me this is the kind of robust understanding of teaching that I think

understanding of teaching that I think

understanding of teaching that I think one needs to have to see teaching is

one needs to have to see teaching is

one needs to have to see teaching is different from research teaching is

different from research teaching is

different from research teaching is something more than just reproducing the

something more than just reproducing the

something more than just reproducing the research culture on a small scale ok

research culture on a small scale ok

research culture on a small scale ok teaching is a really different thing

teaching is a really different thing

teaching is a really different thing from research and unless you have the

from research and unless you have the

from research and unless you have the two things combined together you are not

two things combined together you are not

two things combined together you are not going to be able to make academic

going to be able to make academic

going to be able to make academic knowledge into a public good ok so this

knowledge into a public good ok so this

knowledge into a public good ok so this is the point and this was very much part

is the point and this was very much part

is the point and this was very much part of the founding of the modern University

of the founding of the modern University

of the founding of the modern University with Vilhelm von Humboldt it’s a very

with Vilhelm von Humboldt it’s a very

with Vilhelm von Humboldt it’s a very classical ideal and what I’m just the

classical ideal and what I’m just the

classical ideal and what I’m just the way I’m expressing it here is trying to

way I’m expressing it here is trying to

way I’m expressing it here is trying to be bring this ideal up-to-date in a

be bring this ideal up-to-date in a

be bring this ideal up-to-date in a period where I think across the world we

period where I think across the world we

period where I think across the world we see the research culture going in one

see the research culture going in one

see the research culture going in one direction and the teaching culture going

direction and the teaching culture going

direction and the teaching culture going in another direction and in fact being

in another direction and in fact being

in another direction and in fact being rewarded differently being subsidized

rewarded differently being subsidized

rewarded differently being subsidized differently I mean anyone who is

differently I mean anyone who is

differently I mean anyone who is familiar with higher education and

familiar with higher education and

familiar with higher education and not only in the UK but across the world

not only in the UK but across the world

not only in the UK but across the world know exactly what I’m talking about

know exactly what I’m talking about

know exactly what I’m talking about there is a sense in which the Humboldt

there is a sense in which the Humboldt

there is a sense in which the Humboldt Ian mission of the modern University is

Ian mission of the modern University is

Ian mission of the modern University is being torn apart everyday okay but if

being torn apart everyday okay but if

being torn apart everyday okay but if you don’t if you allow this to be torn

you don’t if you allow this to be torn

you don’t if you allow this to be torn apart if you allow the research and

apart if you allow the research and

apart if you allow the research and teaching functions to be torn apart you

teaching functions to be torn apart you

teaching functions to be torn apart you will not have academic knowledge

will not have academic knowledge

will not have academic knowledge produced as a public good it will be a

produced as a public good it will be a

produced as a public good it will be a club good it will be the preserve of the

club good it will be the preserve of the

club good it will be the preserve of the people who are able to go through the

people who are able to go through the

people who are able to go through the training in the terms that the

training in the terms that the

training in the terms that the researchers think about it there will be

researchers think about it there will be

researchers think about it there will be no obligation actually to translate or

no obligation actually to translate or

no obligation actually to translate or transfer that elite form of knowledge

transfer that elite form of knowledge

transfer that elite form of knowledge into a knowledge that a larger

into a knowledge that a larger

into a knowledge that a larger population can understand and do

population can understand and do

population can understand and do something which with which is exactly

something which with which is exactly

something which with which is exactly what is important about the idea of

what is important about the idea of

what is important about the idea of public it is to remove the access costs

public it is to remove the access costs

public it is to remove the access costs to entry right again going back to the

to entry right again going back to the

to entry right again going back to the economist definition of what a public

economist definition of what a public

economist definition of what a public good is it is to remove the access costs

good is it is to remove the access costs

good is it is to remove the access costs to entry and where does that happen in

to entry and where does that happen in

to entry and where does that happen in academia it doesn’t happen in the

academia it doesn’t happen in the

academia it doesn’t happen in the graduate programs where where you end up

graduate programs where where you end up

graduate programs where where you end up getting knowledge reproduced at the

getting knowledge reproduced at the

getting knowledge reproduced at the elite level for purposes of primarily

elite level for purposes of primarily

elite level for purposes of primarily publishing in elite journals but rather

publishing in elite journals but rather

publishing in elite journals but rather you get it at the teaching level and

you get it at the teaching level and

you get it at the teaching level and primarily at the undergraduate level

primarily at the undergraduate level

primarily at the undergraduate level okay that is the way in which academic

okay that is the way in which academic

okay that is the way in which academic knowledge becomes part of something that

knowledge becomes part of something that

knowledge becomes part of something that can be seriously called a public good

can be seriously called a public good

can be seriously called a public good now how to think about this matter in

now how to think about this matter in

now how to think about this matter in contemporary terms I have a certain way

contemporary terms I have a certain way

contemporary terms I have a certain way of thinking about this which I’ve been

of thinking about this which I’ve been

of thinking about this which I’ve been promoting now for for many years and I

promoting now for for many years and I

promoting now for for many years and I really think we need to think about

really think we need to think about

really think we need to think about teaching as engaged in an activity

teaching as engaged in an activity

teaching as engaged in an activity that’s quite like what the great

that’s quite like what the great

that’s quite like what the great economist Joseph Schumpeter talked about

economist Joseph Schumpeter talked about

economist Joseph Schumpeter talked about as creative destruction okay for those

as creative destruction okay for those

as creative destruction okay for those of you who know something about the

of you who know something about the

of you who know something about the history of Technology and maybe the

history of Technology and maybe the

history of Technology and maybe the history of capitalism more generally you

history of capitalism more generally you

history of capitalism more generally you will know that

will know that

will know that Schumpeter introduced this concept of

Schumpeter introduced this concept of

Schumpeter introduced this concept of creative destruction to describe the

creative destruction to describe the

creative destruction to describe the innovative character

innovative character

innovative character capitalism and the question that becomes

capitalism and the question that becomes

capitalism and the question that becomes what is so innovative about capitalism

what is so innovative about capitalism

what is so innovative about capitalism isn’t just about producing greater

isn’t just about producing greater

isn’t just about producing greater wealth but it’s kind of the way it does

wealth but it’s kind of the way it does

wealth but it’s kind of the way it does it and the way it does it is by

it and the way it does it is by

it and the way it does it is by disrupting markets in a very radical way

disrupting markets in a very radical way

disrupting markets in a very radical way so Schumpeter’s own example was Henry

so Schumpeter’s own example was Henry

so Schumpeter’s own example was Henry Ford Henry Ford introduces the motor car

Ford Henry Ford introduces the motor car

Ford Henry Ford introduces the motor car into an environment where people up to

into an environment where people up to

into an environment where people up to that point thought about personal

that point thought about personal

that point thought about personal transport primarily in terms of riding

transport primarily in terms of riding

transport primarily in terms of riding on horseback and that had its own kind

on horseback and that had its own kind

on horseback and that had its own kind of market its own kind of values

of market its own kind of values

of market its own kind of values attached to it and people were dealing

attached to it and people were dealing

attached to it and people were dealing in that Henry Ford basically transformed

in that Henry Ford basically transformed

in that Henry Ford basically transformed the market by reconceptualizing the

the market by reconceptualizing the

the market by reconceptualizing the fundamental values of personal transport

fundamental values of personal transport

fundamental values of personal transport into a new form and a new form that made

into a new form and a new form that made

into a new form and a new form that made it more available to more people less

it more available to more people less

it more available to more people less expensively that is the creative

expensively that is the creative

expensively that is the creative destruction of the market okay that is

destruction of the market okay that is

destruction of the market okay that is Schumpeter’s primary example now

Schumpeter’s primary example now

Schumpeter’s primary example now teaching in general can do exactly this

teaching in general can do exactly this

teaching in general can do exactly this kind of innovative function okay because

kind of innovative function okay because

kind of innovative function okay because the idea here is that the teacher knows

the idea here is that the teacher knows

the idea here is that the teacher knows the esoteric knowledge knows the

the esoteric knowledge knows the

the esoteric knowledge knows the restricted not markets in which it plays

restricted not markets in which it plays

restricted not markets in which it plays but then realizes ah there’s actually a

but then realizes ah there’s actually a

but then realizes ah there’s actually a way of presenting pretty much the same

way of presenting pretty much the same

way of presenting pretty much the same content in a way that can better enable

content in a way that can better enable

content in a way that can better enable more people to have access to it and

more people to have access to it and

more people to have access to it and take this knowledge in farther and

take this knowledge in farther and

take this knowledge in farther and farther in greater directions than would

farther in greater directions than would

farther in greater directions than would normally be the case if we just let it

normally be the case if we just let it

normally be the case if we just let it sit in the current markets where it

sit in the current markets where it

sit in the current markets where it normally flourishes okay and so in other

normally flourishes okay and so in other

normally flourishes okay and so in other words part of what teaching does you

words part of what teaching does you

words part of what teaching does you might say is to undermine the inherently

might say is to undermine the inherently

might say is to undermine the inherently elite standing that any kind of research

elite standing that any kind of research

elite standing that any kind of research knowledge has because look at the end of

knowledge has because look at the end of

knowledge has because look at the end of the day we have to admit it as academics

the day we have to admit it as academics

the day we have to admit it as academics that the first landfall you might say of

that the first landfall you might say of

that the first landfall you might say of new research if it’s going to be

new research if it’s going to be

new research if it’s going to be recognized by academics is in elite

recognized by academics is in elite

recognized by academics is in elite academic journals so it starts off being

academic journals so it starts off being

academic journals so it starts off being esoteric it starts off as being the kind

esoteric it starts off as being the kind

esoteric it starts off as being the kind of knowledge only relic

of knowledge only relic

of knowledge only relic few people will know and so then the

few people will know and so then the

few people will know and so then the question becomes what does the

question becomes what does the

question becomes what does the university do about this does it just

university do about this does it just

university do about this does it just encourage more of the same behavior

encourage more of the same behavior

encourage more of the same behavior right or does it in fact try to provide

right or does it in fact try to provide

right or does it in fact try to provide incentives whereby one tries you know in

incentives whereby one tries you know in

incentives whereby one tries you know in a regular basis with the large numbers

a regular basis with the large numbers

a regular basis with the large numbers of students that academics are exposed

of students that academics are exposed

of students that academics are exposed to in the classroom to try to translate

to in the classroom to try to translate

to in the classroom to try to translate even perhaps reduce god-forbid

even perhaps reduce god-forbid

even perhaps reduce god-forbid vulgarized

vulgarized

vulgarized this kind of elite form of knowledge in

this kind of elite form of knowledge in

this kind of elite form of knowledge in a way that actually enables more and

a way that actually enables more and

a way that actually enables more and more people to be empowered by it okay

more people to be empowered by it okay

more people to be empowered by it okay this is what I’m talking about here this

this is what I’m talking about here this

this is what I’m talking about here this is the the if we buy into this idea that

is the the if we buy into this idea that

is the the if we buy into this idea that in a sense what one needs to do is to

in a sense what one needs to do is to

in a sense what one needs to do is to make academic research more available

make academic research more available

make academic research more available more accessible in the classroom to

more accessible in the classroom to

more accessible in the classroom to people who do not come from the same

people who do not come from the same

people who do not come from the same backgrounds as the original researchers

backgrounds as the original researchers

backgrounds as the original researchers and who will not take that knowledge in

and who will not take that knowledge in

and who will not take that knowledge in the same directions necessarily as the

the same directions necessarily as the

the same directions necessarily as the original researchers then we will have

original researchers then we will have

original researchers then we will have produced academic knowledge as a public

produced academic knowledge as a public

produced academic knowledge as a public good and so this to me becomes a

good and so this to me becomes a

good and so this to me becomes a contemporary argument an argument for

contemporary argument an argument for

contemporary argument an argument for our own times about why we should have

our own times about why we should have

our own times about why we should have the unity of research and teaching in

the unity of research and teaching in

the unity of research and teaching in the university and that when we are

the university and that when we are

the university and that when we are hiring academic staff we should think

hiring academic staff we should think

hiring academic staff we should think about the qualifications of people who

about the qualifications of people who

about the qualifications of people who can do both in one person thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *