Press "Enter" to skip to content

Errar non nuoce | Andrea De Benedetti | TEDxBari


[Music]

good evening I’m not the kind of

linguist that you expect and not

I will tell you what a linguist

normally he usually says I’m not here

to celebrate the funeral together with you

the umpteenth of the Italian language

I’m not here to intone the de

profundis of the subjunctive and the past

remote also because I give you news

exclusive the subjunctive is fine

I’m not here to tell you my lady where

our fine Italian will end

vilipeso trampled and sullied by

no young people are not here to explain

how they have become ignorant indeed

when they became ignorant the

others because the ignorant are always

the others never are not here to give

confirm our prejudices and respect

to the functioning of the language in short

I’m not here to sell the three goods

that not only among fans of

language have more market

nostalgia indignation and fear

I ‘m not here to do this I’m not

here not even to do necessary things

that as a teacher I do all

the other many others do and do it

even better than me that is to explain that

what is right and what is wrong to draw up

catalogs of things not to say about mistakes

not to do

I’m not here to give bonton advice

language to illustrate symptoms

diagnosis and therapy of what is coming

considered is represented with one

illness and I am not a doctor

less a medical examiner I am here for

to celebrate linguistic disorder and with

it if not the beauty at least

the inevitability of democracy

utility and even rationality

of the error the possibility of making mistakes

it is not only the main one

guarantee of our freedom and also

and above all the main indicator

of the vitality of an idiom

it exists perhaps in ours in any

other language

something more intimately grammatical

of the error no there is no error is the

quintessence of grammar because it does not

it’s a simple violation of a rule

but it is a violation based on a hypothesis

alternative operation of the

tongue

in short, it is an infringement of the rule that

in other words, it presupposes another norm

another grammar

yet the temptation of trenitalia le

rules to put it to the sedan of

feel better than others for the

just done you had maybe

a better education is so strong

strong enough to make us forget a series of

a series of elements that the first

element is this and that is that all

mistakes have a motive for the heart

heart written with care I do not know if if

if you have ever had an experience of the

kind of maybe there’s one in the kitchen

tile slightly raised you there

go but regularly stumble over

and you know it’s there

tile slightly raised

compared to the treading floor from

kitchen, however, despite this we end up

always to stumble because there

stumble because of you

sure but maybe also because of the

tiler who in his time has

placed has placed the tile badly

we translate this discourse to the language of

who is the true king

whose fault is the fault of is the fault of

whoever commits it certainly

in the long run it is his fault, but it is also his fault

the language’s fault if you think about it

here we have an image you notice that the

power point of the linguists

tends to be a little more

ugly linguists are more credible

how much worse are their power points

then you are able to make yourself more

credible here we have an image of the

of our former premier and current

secretary of the democratic party

and it was he who wrote these words

he was one of his collaborators the most

foiled who wrote to the word

scientist wrote it without her or error

we will see many of us

yet yet it is a mistake that everyone all

how many we have committed for

describe science or consciousness without her

as a child and because that i do not

it is utterly useless

in the system of our language e

we do not need it there

spelling the spelling of the language e

against intuitive and purple itself the

rule that the Italian language has been given

has codified therefore to be wrong

certainly it is that form and scientist

written without her but being wrong

also the language

think about writing breakfast with the

double z instead of a single z

or say the eggs do not get eggs

or it seems to me if instead it seemed to me or

those who say themselves I believe of

say it when maybe I’m a bit

disregard a miss instead of a brand

by analogy with adipe avido arido donkey

soul a breath acino to acid that is

most words say 90

percent of the words that begin

with has composed of three syllables in

Italian are they are slippery to brand is

the only exception, in short, us

we make mistakes because the

language itself leads us to commit them

because the language itself

every now and then you raise the tile

ethics makes the mistakes of today stumble

it may not be tomorrow anymore

I want our destinies to be lost

in the infinity you I of course here either

I’ll show you a let’s say a summary one

synthesis of florilegi much wider than

mistakes you can find

doing any online research

in what sense today’s error could

it may not be tomorrow anymore

see here another example I do not have

nothing personal naturally against

against our former premier and not even

with against his faithful collaborator

which one writes what is written

naturally without without the apostrophe

naturally up to a certain point

of course it is not

the right adverb because because in

reality

of course we are told to write it down

with the apostrophe which by analogy with

the series of questions we say of

questioning particles followed by dal

verb to be

where with the apostrophe it ‘s like when

etc

the only exception is what then is certain

we can remember someone we know

that effectively such as a particle

that has something of an autonomous life

in which case, etc.

but there’s nothing for us to do

which is part of that series there and me

I myself realize it when I think so

are there are some that I write

thoughtful I was made to write

that apostrofo is not made of

write it only to me but to one

majority I would say wide enough of the

ours of our fellow citizens if it is true

that if you go to google the forms

which is written with the apostrophe and which

it is written without you will find more results

or less equivalent indeed as they

time passes and thanks to the fact that then

google is a huge blender that

keep everything inside you will discover that man

hand which is written with the apostrophe sta

taking more and more foot

means that correct no in this

moment it probably is not it

it will still be

again for the next ten fifteen

twenty years will come one day but this is it

a prediction that I then make

possibly test the between 10 15 20

years

there will come a day when you probably will

grammars ourselves and ours

our habits ours

sensitivity will have to surrender e

will have to take note that which

it is written with the apostrophe it has become

just like maybe a little with the accent

maybe but this has already happened

rather than rather than script with

value with rather disjunctive value

that with the meaning of or that one

of the horrors one that the linguists

to which linguists have dedicated even

even books have titled gods

books rather than this

it was enough to change it

destiny and to make this form

regretted vituperated both disappeared

in reality he lives and is increasingly healthier

strong and unstoppable or week

next week without without

the article is bad we all have the

right to consider certain bad

forms and to take in the distance myself

I find and make from my point of view

staff week next week

last without without the article though

fate

the story star goes into a certain one

direction and we can also do the

barricades but most of the time not

we manage to stop the error that well

you’re correcting something else that often

we forget it may not be the

more serious

we in Italy there is still an injury

positive towards spelling

the spelling is considered the thing

more beautiful than the language

in fact, the spelling is better or better

misspellings are bad if I

I see a spelling mistake and how to see

a person around with a stain of

sauce on the shirt with a sock

unpaired and yet spelling

yes for charity it’s ugly but

tends to not affect the

communication between people

the spelling mistake does not affect the

communication between people

if I write because with the acute accent

with the grave accent or I write

provinces without or with the self as well

scientist that one without a live person understands

what I mean, you understand what

I want to write very often instead

most important errors are of the

mistakes that are even harder to

classify and much more difficult to

correct and those that do damage

the convocation, however, the spelling no

the spelling is considered as one

sort of of say of something sacred in the

in our language in all languages ​​e

the spelling is a bit like violating the

constitution how to commit a sin

mortal for charity is a sin

and it is a pity that it must be sanctioned

etcetera but here maybe you give it gives a

a little more important than

that which are its actuals

merit well the languages ​​are born and die

with accidentals if if the languages

they would not change if they did not commit themselves

mistakes this is a seems a triviality

but it is not

we will still talk about it in Latin, indeed a work

while we will speak again the proto

Indo-European that is that mythical language

from which they would all derive

Neolatine languages ​​like ours

here is a document that maybe someone

of you know and a document of a

dramatic dramatic of the IV century after

Christ who was called Probe who had

drawn up a series of a list of words

as we were saying they were written and

as they should have been written

there is the former there is not the former throw a spear

auris not die face if it does

etc. well etc. we see in

this series of words speculum not

speculum that in the censored versions

we already see the traces of an outcome

which then the outcome of the Italian language

the speculum become in the mirror the

veto luz which then became bay cruz

he has become our old man, and so on

etcetera, in other words, he had already

identified a number of errors and li them

he pointed out that he was censored or point

nor did he dream of elimination except for later

obviously having to make it too

he is faced with a phenomenon that he then has

brought as a result to the Italian language

some forms that we consider the installments

I’m not candy I do not want any more

alberto lupo and mine

no it is a form that is called

dislocation on the left that thing for

which I anticipate an element of

communication then I resume it shortly thereafter

with a pronoun is the same thing to say

I like it or I read the book

how many times have we heard that

those things do not make themselves beautiful you do not

they do but we do we all do it

let’s all do when we talk

and also when we write and if it is

we do because somehow we are

saying something different than

I simply do not want any more sweets

we are saying something different and we are

adding also information and lo

same speech that applies to Rome

sentence start does not start a sentence with

a conjunction can not be started one

sentence as I comma etc. this does not

I know if you recognize the image of one

beautiful at night also called jasmine

night as the jasmine begins

night and will know in the first round joined

a poem begins and it is not only

poetic license think

think, for example, of a phrase from

this one of this kind

marco a shy and boring boy or

Marco is a shy guy point is boring

they mean the same thing no not

they mean the same thing

in the second case, Marco is a boy more

boring that shy in the first case more or

minus the two the two defects are

equivalent to the second case instead of the

boredom weighs much more too

make mistakes even you too

you too, we too are fantozzi and

filini

we continually make mistakes

let’s say reboans instead of bombastic

instead say bonante let’s say decade

instead of decades rather than instead

di or Marco and Andrea instead of

macro andrea and if we do not make mistakes

at least we make some kind of mistakes

this type that of daniela santanchè

who writes if the newspaper succeeded in

to do with h what we are not

succeeded in twenty years

now we can think of all the evil

possible daniela santanchè me a little

I think

but I do not think it’s his fault I think

is rather the fault of his concealer a

sometimes mistakes are not mistakes

our fault

they are also the fault of the technology that

we have invented to spare them

above all we remember this we remember

that the error is systematic while it is

mistake is accidental if the error

systematic if something that precisely

falls into a dynamic of a compulsion

to repeat and why

evidently it is the language itself a

facilitate it and therefore to conclude

this intervention

what I invite to do and what if

we just have to take it with

someone if we really must criticize

the mistakes well let’s do it with the

people who for the role they occupy

for the work they do have some

particular responsibilities towards

of the language I think of teachers I think of

TV personalities to politicians

people who occupy key positions

in the culture we leave instead

hindrance children leave in peace

foreigners leave all those in peace

so the inaccessibility of the word in

some way constitutes one

inaccessibility to the world here to be furious

against them raging with theirs

mistakes

it is an act from my point of view

cowardice and it is something that I invite you to

do not thank you

[Applause]

[Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *