
I’d like to share with you today a thought experiment that was first
thought experiment that was first
thought experiment that was first proposed to me by my PhD advisor at
proposed to me by my PhD advisor at
proposed to me by my PhD advisor at Northern Illinois University his name
Northern Illinois University his name
Northern Illinois University his name was dr. Reed Shearer Reed would always
was dr. Reed Shearer Reed would always
was dr. Reed Shearer Reed would always throw these problems at his students as
throw these problems at his students as
throw these problems at his students as a way of getting us not just to think
a way of getting us not just to think
a way of getting us not just to think about scientific facts and memorize them
about scientific facts and memorize them
about scientific facts and memorize them but to think about scientific questions
but to think about scientific questions
but to think about scientific questions one particular time I was taking this
one particular time I was taking this
one particular time I was taking this really stressful exam by myself in a
really stressful exam by myself in a
really stressful exam by myself in a conference room and towards the end Reed
conference room and towards the end Reed
conference room and towards the end Reed came running in with a box and he set it
came running in with a box and he set it
came running in with a box and he set it down in front of me and inside was this
down in front of me and inside was this
down in front of me and inside was this large rock with a big woolly mammoth
large rock with a big woolly mammoth
large rock with a big woolly mammoth tooth sticking out of it and he said
tooth sticking out of it and he said
tooth sticking out of it and he said this was just found here in the county
this was just found here in the county
this was just found here in the county the other day what can you tell me about
the other day what can you tell me about
the other day what can you tell me about this and he stored it towards the door
this and he stored it towards the door
this and he stored it towards the door and then he stopped it by the way this
and then he stopped it by the way this
and then he stopped it by the way this is on your exam and he walked out so I
is on your exam and he walked out so I
is on your exam and he walked out so I be remiss not to credit Reed with this
be remiss not to credit Reed with this
be remiss not to credit Reed with this because like everything in science from
because like everything in science from
because like everything in science from simply standing on the shoulders of
simply standing on the shoulders of
simply standing on the shoulders of giants
giants
giants but biological evolution evolution its
but biological evolution evolution its
but biological evolution evolution its defined as the change in the frequency
defined as the change in the frequency
defined as the change in the frequency of alleles in a population over time
of alleles in a population over time
of alleles in a population over time it’s a complex theory built upon
it’s a complex theory built upon
it’s a complex theory built upon hundreds of tested hypotheses it’s
hundreds of tested hypotheses it’s
hundreds of tested hypotheses it’s driven by random mutation and natural
driven by random mutation and natural
driven by random mutation and natural selection and today it’s the central
selection and today it’s the central
selection and today it’s the central tenet of all biology and paleontology
tenet of all biology and paleontology
tenet of all biology and paleontology it’s a really nice definition but how
it’s a really nice definition but how
it’s a really nice definition but how many of us actually really know what
many of us actually really know what
many of us actually really know what that means after teaching historical
that means after teaching historical
that means after teaching historical geology and paleontology for over ten
geology and paleontology for over ten
geology and paleontology for over ten years now I can tell you that students
years now I can tell you that students
years now I can tell you that students will not along when you talk about
will not along when you talk about
will not along when you talk about evolution but when you ask them to
evolution but when you ask them to
evolution but when you ask them to define it blank stares it’s kind of like
define it blank stares it’s kind of like
define it blank stares it’s kind of like art they know it when they see it but
art they know it when they see it but
art they know it when they see it but they can’t really explain it but you
they can’t really explain it but you
they can’t really explain it but you know we use the word evolution to
know we use the word evolution to
know we use the word evolution to describe the changes in things around us
describe the changes in things around us
describe the changes in things around us all the time non-biological things like
all the time non-biological things like
all the time non-biological things like technological advancement cars and
technological advancement cars and
technological advancement cars and computers in fact we’re probably more
computers in fact we’re probably more
computers in fact we’re probably more familiar with the evolution of
familiar with the evolution of
familiar with the evolution of smartphones and cars than we are with
smartphones and cars than we are with
smartphones and cars than we are with biological lineages over millions and
biological lineages over millions and
biological lineages over millions and millions of years so the idea is can we
millions of years so the idea is can we
millions of years so the idea is can we use our familiarity with technological
use our familiarity with technological
use our familiarity with technological evolution like cars to help us
evolution like cars to help us
evolution like cars to help us understand and identify patterns in
understand and identify patterns in
understand and identify patterns in biological evolution through deep time
biological evolution through deep time
biological evolution through deep time on our planets history
on our planets history
on our planets history now before we get too far along here
now before we get too far along here
now before we get too far along here there are some inherent differences
there are some inherent differences
there are some inherent differences between technological evolution and
between technological evolution and
between technological evolution and biological evolution that we need to
biological evolution that we need to
biological evolution that we need to address first complexity when a new car
address first complexity when a new car
address first complexity when a new car model rolls off the line it’s usually
model rolls off the line it’s usually
model rolls off the line it’s usually more complex at least slightly than the
more complex at least slightly than the
more complex at least slightly than the previous model it’s got heated seats or
previous model it’s got heated seats or
previous model it’s got heated seats or Wi-Fi capability or or some kind of GPS
Wi-Fi capability or or some kind of GPS
Wi-Fi capability or or some kind of GPS signal that’s not necessarily true for
signal that’s not necessarily true for
signal that’s not necessarily true for organisms though they don’t necessarily
organisms though they don’t necessarily
organisms though they don’t necessarily become more complex over time take for
become more complex over time take for
become more complex over time take for example the hummingbird okay some of the
example the hummingbird okay some of the
example the hummingbird okay some of the smallest birds alive on the planet today
smallest birds alive on the planet today
smallest birds alive on the planet today yet they share a long evolutionary
yet they share a long evolutionary
yet they share a long evolutionary lineage with some of the largest most
lineage with some of the largest most
lineage with some of the largest most ferocious carnivores ever to walk the
ferocious carnivores ever to walk the
ferocious carnivores ever to walk the earth like Tyrannosaurus Rex but one
earth like Tyrannosaurus Rex but one
earth like Tyrannosaurus Rex but one isn’t more complex than the other ones
isn’t more complex than the other ones
isn’t more complex than the other ones just a lot more intimidating than the
just a lot more intimidating than the
just a lot more intimidating than the other the other big difference of course
other the other big difference of course
other the other big difference of course is how we get new organisms and how we
is how we get new organisms and how we
is how we get new organisms and how we get new technology life by definition is
get new technology life by definition is
get new technology life by definition is self-propagating I won’t go into that
self-propagating I won’t go into that
self-propagating I won’t go into that too much more that’s a talk for another
too much more that’s a talk for another
too much more that’s a talk for another time but we get new technology by new
time but we get new technology by new
time but we get new technology by new ideas and skill and know-how and being
ideas and skill and know-how and being
ideas and skill and know-how and being able to craft something and produce
able to craft something and produce
able to craft something and produce something new so despite these
something new so despite these
something new so despite these differences there’s quite a lot that
differences there’s quite a lot that
differences there’s quite a lot that technological evolution of biological
technological evolution of biological
technological evolution of biological evolution have in common both are driven
evolution have in common both are driven
evolution have in common both are driven by comparable forces in the evolution of
by comparable forces in the evolution of
by comparable forces in the evolution of a new technology whether it succeeds or
a new technology whether it succeeds or
a new technology whether it succeeds or fails is controlled by the economy by
fails is controlled by the economy by
fails is controlled by the economy by market forces in biology that’s natural
market forces in biology that’s natural
market forces in biology that’s natural selection where success is passing your
selection where success is passing your
selection where success is passing your genes on to the next generation and
genes on to the next generation and
genes on to the next generation and failure is ultimately extinction and
failure is ultimately extinction and
failure is ultimately extinction and like I said before new technology comes
like I said before new technology comes
like I said before new technology comes from an idea and it may not be random
from an idea and it may not be random
from an idea and it may not be random like random mutation and evolution for
like random mutation and evolution for
like random mutation and evolution for organisms but it’s an innovation an idea
organisms but it’s an innovation an idea
organisms but it’s an innovation an idea that maybe isn’t random but maybe
that maybe isn’t random but maybe
that maybe isn’t random but maybe inspired so what else can we look at
inspired so what else can we look at
inspired so what else can we look at looking maybe the evolution of cars and
looking maybe the evolution of cars and
looking maybe the evolution of cars and learn something about the evolution of
learn something about the evolution of
learn something about the evolution of life well let’s start with something
life well let’s start with something
life well let’s start with something like the rates of evolution starting
like the rates of evolution starting
like the rates of evolution starting with cars
with cars
with cars these are Cadillac DeVille supposed to
these are Cadillac DeVille supposed to
these are Cadillac DeVille supposed to have a 1956 Cadillac deville and a 1960
have a 1956 Cadillac deville and a 1960
have a 1956 Cadillac deville and a 1960 in the four years in between these two
in the four years in between these two
in the four years in between these two vehicles being produced lots of physical
vehicles being produced lots of physical
vehicles being produced lots of physical changes happen to these species
changes happen to these species
changes happen to these species headlights the grille styling the hood
headlights the grille styling the hood
headlights the grille styling the hood styling the wheelbase when these cars
styling the wheelbase when these cars
styling the wheelbase when these cars are driving down the road you can tell
are driving down the road you can tell
are driving down the road you can tell them apart in biology we’d say these
them apart in biology we’d say these
them apart in biology we’d say these have high disparity the physical
have high disparity the physical
have high disparity the physical differences are extreme and notable now
differences are extreme and notable now
differences are extreme and notable now there weren’t a lot of sedans being
there weren’t a lot of sedans being
there weren’t a lot of sedans being produced at this time so we’d say that
produced at this time so we’d say that
produced at this time so we’d say that the diversity was quite low but they
the diversity was quite low but they
the diversity was quite low but they were very very successful now what about
were very very successful now what about
were very very successful now what about our more modern sedans these are also
our more modern sedans these are also
our more modern sedans these are also Cadillac deville 1995 2000 and 2004
Cadillac deville 1995 2000 and 2004
Cadillac deville 1995 2000 and 2004 twice the amount of time not nearly as
twice the amount of time not nearly as
twice the amount of time not nearly as many physical changes in these species
many physical changes in these species
many physical changes in these species in fact what do we hear about modern
in fact what do we hear about modern
in fact what do we hear about modern cars all the time they all look alike
cars all the time they all look alike
cars all the time they all look alike well why is that is it just because we
well why is that is it just because we
well why is that is it just because we like this style maybe that’s part of it
like this style maybe that’s part of it
like this style maybe that’s part of it but there’s also safety standards
but there’s also safety standards
but there’s also safety standards there’s efficiency it comes down to that
there’s efficiency it comes down to that
there’s efficiency it comes down to that this form works so there’s no need to
this form works so there’s no need to
this form works so there’s no need to change it and when we have a long
change it and when we have a long
change it and when we have a long lineage of an organism or a group of
lineage of an organism or a group of
lineage of an organism or a group of organisms with very few changes in
organisms with very few changes in
organisms with very few changes in biology would call that stasis and
biology would call that stasis and
biology would call that stasis and stasis works because the form works for
stasis works because the form works for
stasis works because the form works for the environment now if we want to talk
the environment now if we want to talk
the environment now if we want to talk about stasis in the evolution of
about stasis in the evolution of
about stasis in the evolution of automobiles there is no better example
automobiles there is no better example
automobiles there is no better example than the type one air cooled beetle from
than the type one air cooled beetle from
than the type one air cooled beetle from Volkswagen originally produced in the
Volkswagen originally produced in the
Volkswagen originally produced in the 1930s in Germany it was the flagship
1930s in Germany it was the flagship
1930s in Germany it was the flagship vehicle of Volkswagen the people’s car
vehicle of Volkswagen the people’s car
vehicle of Volkswagen the people’s car and this was a very very efficient
and this was a very very efficient
and this was a very very efficient species it was easy to maintain it was
species it was easy to maintain it was
species it was easy to maintain it was pretty cheap to fix it was very
pretty cheap to fix it was very
pretty cheap to fix it was very affordable pretty good mileage today of
affordable pretty good mileage today of
affordable pretty good mileage today of course we look at the type one and it’s
course we look at the type one and it’s
course we look at the type one and it’s a it produces a mental image of a long
a it produces a mental image of a long
a it produces a mental image of a long foregone heir it’s a fossil essentially
foregone heir it’s a fossil essentially
foregone heir it’s a fossil essentially if you will from the 1960s but actually
if you will from the 1960s but actually
if you will from the 1960s but actually these continued production until 2003 in
these continued production until 2003 in
these continued production until 2003 in Mexico the last of the type ones were
Mexico the last of the type ones were
Mexico the last of the type ones were produced in Mexico in 2003 virtually no
produced in Mexico in 2003 virtually no
produced in Mexico in 2003 virtually no changes because it worked very well in
changes because it worked very well in
changes because it worked very well in its ecosystem there was nothing to drive
its ecosystem there was nothing to drive
its ecosystem there was nothing to drive that change now do we see examples of
that change now do we see examples of
that change now do we see examples of this
this
this stream stasis in the fossil record
stream stasis in the fossil record
stream stasis in the fossil record certainly we also see it with living
certainly we also see it with living
certainly we also see it with living organisms today if you go walking along
organisms today if you go walking along
organisms today if you go walking along the beaches of the world it’s very
the beaches of the world it’s very
the beaches of the world it’s very likely you’ll come across one of these a
likely you’ll come across one of these a
likely you’ll come across one of these a horseshoe crab an arthropod of the clade
horseshoe crab an arthropod of the clade
horseshoe crab an arthropod of the clade zyphus era horseshoe crabs are amazing
zyphus era horseshoe crabs are amazing
zyphus era horseshoe crabs are amazing survivors they have a hard exoskeleton
survivors they have a hard exoskeleton
survivors they have a hard exoskeleton complex eyes light sensing organs they
complex eyes light sensing organs they
complex eyes light sensing organs they have a very diet of worms and
have a very diet of worms and
have a very diet of worms and crustaceans and molluscs but this is a
crustaceans and molluscs but this is a
crustaceans and molluscs but this is a 200 million year old horseshoe crab in
200 million year old horseshoe crab in
200 million year old horseshoe crab in fact horseshoe crabs have a fossil
fact horseshoe crabs have a fossil
fact horseshoe crabs have a fossil record that goes back to 350 million
record that goes back to 350 million
record that goes back to 350 million years virtually unchanged why because
years virtually unchanged why because
years virtually unchanged why because the form fits very well in the ecosystem
the form fits very well in the ecosystem
the form fits very well in the ecosystem this is the type 1 air cooled beetle of
this is the type 1 air cooled beetle of
this is the type 1 air cooled beetle of arthropods if the car is not broke you
arthropods if the car is not broke you
arthropods if the car is not broke you don’t need to fix it but we’re not done
don’t need to fix it but we’re not done
don’t need to fix it but we’re not done with Volkswagens yet turns out they’re
with Volkswagens yet turns out they’re
with Volkswagens yet turns out they’re really really useful for understanding
really really useful for understanding
really really useful for understanding evolution because after the type 1 was
evolution because after the type 1 was
evolution because after the type 1 was so successful in the 60s
so successful in the 60s
so successful in the 60s Volkswagen diversified rapid
Volkswagen diversified rapid
Volkswagen diversified rapid diversification where you have one
diversification where you have one
diversification where you have one lineage and it splits into numerous ones
lineage and it splits into numerous ones
lineage and it splits into numerous ones if you want something a little faster
if you want something a little faster
if you want something a little faster try the Karmann Ghia it’s their sports
try the Karmann Ghia it’s their sports
try the Karmann Ghia it’s their sports car about the type 3 fastback or
car about the type 3 fastback or
car about the type 3 fastback or squareback the thing whatever that was
squareback the thing whatever that was
squareback the thing whatever that was the microbus and of course still the
the microbus and of course still the
the microbus and of course still the beetle in fact in the late 1970s
beetle in fact in the late 1970s
beetle in fact in the late 1970s Volkswagens were at their peak diversity
Volkswagens were at their peak diversity
Volkswagens were at their peak diversity and abundance similar to what we see
and abundance similar to what we see
and abundance similar to what we see with some groups of organisms after
with some groups of organisms after
with some groups of organisms after rapid diversification unfortunately in
rapid diversification unfortunately in
rapid diversification unfortunately in the later 1970’s and early 80’s they
the later 1970’s and early 80’s they
the later 1970’s and early 80’s they suffered a mass extinction and this is
suffered a mass extinction and this is
suffered a mass extinction and this is very common in biology and in the fossil
very common in biology and in the fossil
very common in biology and in the fossil record after peak diversity and
record after peak diversity and
record after peak diversity and abundance you have a fossil you have a
abundance you have a fossil you have a
abundance you have a fossil you have a major mass extinction event and we also
major mass extinction event and we also
major mass extinction event and we also see this in the fossil record with
see this in the fossil record with
see this in the fossil record with things called trilobite s’ these were a
things called trilobite s’ these were a
things called trilobite s’ these were a very successful group of arthropods not
very successful group of arthropods not
very successful group of arthropods not really that similar to horseshoe crabs
really that similar to horseshoe crabs
really that similar to horseshoe crabs but somewhat comparable and throughout
but somewhat comparable and throughout
but somewhat comparable and throughout the Paleozoic era from around 550 to 250
the Paleozoic era from around 550 to 250
the Paleozoic era from around 550 to 250 million years ago they were quite
million years ago they were quite
million years ago they were quite abundant however their peak abundance
abundant however their peak abundance
abundant however their peak abundance was in the late Cambrian period through
was in the late Cambrian period through
was in the late Cambrian period through the Ordovician so about 490 million
the Ordovician so about 490 million
the Ordovician so about 490 million years ago and then they repeated they
years ago and then they repeated they
years ago and then they repeated they said they went through several mass
said they went through several mass
said they went through several mass extinctions one right after the other
extinctions one right after the other
extinctions one right after the other throughout the rest of the Paleozoic in
throughout the rest of the Paleozoic in
throughout the rest of the Paleozoic in the beginning they had
the beginning they had
the beginning they had diversity low disparity they all looked
diversity low disparity they all looked
diversity low disparity they all looked alike but we had hundreds of species and
alike but we had hundreds of species and
alike but we had hundreds of species and the later Paleozoic we had fewer species
the later Paleozoic we had fewer species
the later Paleozoic we had fewer species but high disparity they evolved spines
but high disparity they evolved spines
but high disparity they evolved spines and the ability to roll up into a ball
and the ability to roll up into a ball
and the ability to roll up into a ball they were much more specialized now what
they were much more specialized now what
they were much more specialized now what caused these extinctions and trilobite
caused these extinctions and trilobite
caused these extinctions and trilobite s– notably changes in their environment
s– notably changes in their environment
s– notably changes in their environment changes in the climate changes in the
changes in the climate changes in the
changes in the climate changes in the chemistry of the ocean the addition of
chemistry of the ocean the addition of
chemistry of the ocean the addition of new predators and the addition of new
new predators and the addition of new
new predators and the addition of new competition they couldn’t all keep up
competition they couldn’t all keep up
competition they couldn’t all keep up so let’s look back at our Volkswagens
so let’s look back at our Volkswagens
so let’s look back at our Volkswagens what caused this mass extinction very
what caused this mass extinction very
what caused this mass extinction very similar to our trilobite s– the
similar to our trilobite s– the
similar to our trilobite s– the extinction of most of our Volkswagens
extinction of most of our Volkswagens
extinction of most of our Volkswagens was caused from an invasive species
was caused from an invasive species
was caused from an invasive species because in the late 1970s another car
because in the late 1970s another car
because in the late 1970s another car came out to rival the type one it was
came out to rival the type one it was
came out to rival the type one it was easy to repair it was very good on gas
easy to repair it was very good on gas
easy to repair it was very good on gas and it was very cheap and this was the
and it was very cheap and this was the
and it was very cheap and this was the 1978 Toyota Corolla the Japanese beetle
well while all this was happening with
well while all this was happening with Volkswagen that was yet another trend
Volkswagen that was yet another trend
Volkswagen that was yet another trend that was happening in for hobbyists in
that was happening in for hobbyists in
that was happening in for hobbyists in the United States with cars this was the
the United States with cars this was the
the United States with cars this was the muscle car whether you got it off the
muscle car whether you got it off the
muscle car whether you got it off the line or built it from a kit the goal is
line or built it from a kit the goal is
line or built it from a kit the goal is to make it faster louder and stronger
to make it faster louder and stronger
to make it faster louder and stronger unfortunately they had a very specific
unfortunately they had a very specific
unfortunately they had a very specific food source and that was that they
food source and that was that they
food source and that was that they weren’t very good on gas and these were
weren’t very good on gas and these were
weren’t very good on gas and these were only popular for about 10 years now why
only popular for about 10 years now why
only popular for about 10 years now why is that well if we look at their food
is that well if we look at their food
is that well if we look at their food source during this time we find that the
source during this time we find that the
source during this time we find that the muscle cars were popular when oil was at
muscle cars were popular when oil was at
muscle cars were popular when oil was at an all-time low and when suddenly the
an all-time low and when suddenly the
an all-time low and when suddenly the OPEC oil embargo happened followed by
OPEC oil embargo happened followed by
OPEC oil embargo happened followed by the iran-iraq war they didn’t fully go
the iran-iraq war they didn’t fully go
the iran-iraq war they didn’t fully go extinct but they never really recovered
extinct but they never really recovered
extinct but they never really recovered to where they once were and in fact we
to where they once were and in fact we
to where they once were and in fact we actually saw this again relatively
actually saw this again relatively
actually saw this again relatively recently that some of the younger of us
recently that some of the younger of us
recently that some of the younger of us can remember a little bit more and
can remember a little bit more and
can remember a little bit more and that’s with the SUV this originally
that’s with the SUV this originally
that’s with the SUV this originally started in the 1920s as a military truck
started in the 1920s as a military truck
started in the 1920s as a military truck and then from the 30s through the 80s
and then from the 30s through the 80s
and then from the 30s through the 80s it was predominantly a farm truck or
it was predominantly a farm truck or
it was predominantly a farm truck or something you’d take off-road but then
something you’d take off-road but then
something you’d take off-road but then in the early 1990s there was a new
in the early 1990s there was a new
in the early 1990s there was a new diversification event with one single
diversification event with one single
diversification event with one single species of SUVs where it found a new
species of SUVs where it found a new
species of SUVs where it found a new niche in a new habitat inside the
niche in a new habitat inside the
niche in a new habitat inside the suburban driveway and that was the 1991
suburban driveway and that was the 1991
suburban driveway and that was the 1991 Ford Explorer and what happened after
Ford Explorer and what happened after
Ford Explorer and what happened after the Ford Explorer every auto
the Ford Explorer every auto
the Ford Explorer every auto manufacturer started making SUVs we had
manufacturer started making SUVs we had
manufacturer started making SUVs we had very rapid diversification and very high
very rapid diversification and very high
very rapid diversification and very high diversity and we also started to see
diversity and we also started to see
diversity and we also started to see high disparity because they became
high disparity because they became
high disparity because they became larger and larger and larger and as they
larger and larger and larger and as they
larger and larger and larger and as they became larger they became less efficient
became larger they became less efficient
became larger they became less efficient and they over exceeded the carrying
and they over exceeded the carrying
and they over exceeded the carrying capacity of their ecosystem now have we
capacity of their ecosystem now have we
capacity of their ecosystem now have we seen this in the fossil record numerous
seen this in the fossil record numerous
seen this in the fossil record numerous times and so numerous we have a name for
times and so numerous we have a name for
times and so numerous we have a name for it and that’s called copse rule from
it and that’s called copse rule from
it and that’s called copse rule from 1887 and this is that as a lineage
1887 and this is that as a lineage
1887 and this is that as a lineage evolves they tend to increase in size
evolves they tend to increase in size
evolves they tend to increase in size sometimes becoming less efficient and we
sometimes becoming less efficient and we
sometimes becoming less efficient and we see with horses with whales with
see with horses with whales with
see with horses with whales with dinosaurs and numerous other taxa
dinosaurs and numerous other taxa
dinosaurs and numerous other taxa ultimately when you have increased size
ultimately when you have increased size
ultimately when you have increased size and increase needs and you’re exceeding
and increase needs and you’re exceeding
and increase needs and you’re exceeding the carrying capacity of your land
the carrying capacity of your land
the carrying capacity of your land that’s a high risk for extinction and
that’s a high risk for extinction and
that’s a high risk for extinction and while our SUVs haven’t necessarily gone
while our SUVs haven’t necessarily gone
while our SUVs haven’t necessarily gone extinct we can definitely call them
extinct we can definitely call them
extinct we can definitely call them endangered
endangered
endangered because we don’t see as many of them
because we don’t see as many of them
because we don’t see as many of them around today as we used to so what have
around today as we used to so what have
around today as we used to so what have we learned so far we’ve learned that
we learned so far we’ve learned that
we learned so far we’ve learned that some of the forces that control the
some of the forces that control the
some of the forces that control the evolution of life also control the
evolution of life also control the
evolution of life also control the evolution of cars or various other forms
evolution of cars or various other forms
evolution of cars or various other forms of Technology whether you’re looking at
of Technology whether you’re looking at
of Technology whether you’re looking at the economy or looking at ecology it’s
the economy or looking at ecology it’s
the economy or looking at ecology it’s the same controls whether you’re looking
the same controls whether you’re looking
the same controls whether you’re looking at Pleistocene wolves from the La Brea
at Pleistocene wolves from the La Brea
at Pleistocene wolves from the La Brea Tar Pits or the Wolves of Wall Street’s
Tar Pits or the Wolves of Wall Street’s
Tar Pits or the Wolves of Wall Street’s we’re all controlled by the same factors
we’re all controlled by the same factors
we’re all controlled by the same factors now before we finish up though I do need
now before we finish up though I do need
now before we finish up though I do need to address the elephant during this case
to address the elephant during this case
to address the elephant during this case the mammoth in the room and that’s that
the mammoth in the room and that’s that
the mammoth in the room and that’s that cars are not animals as we said before
cars are not animals as we said before
cars are not animals as we said before they don’t self propagate they’re not
they don’t self propagate they’re not
they don’t self propagate they’re not living things they don’t come about on
living things they don’t come about on
living things they don’t come about on their own they are designed they’re
their own they are designed they’re
their own they are designed they’re manufactured with skill and precision
manufactured with skill and precision
manufactured with skill and precision they come from an idea but like
they come from an idea but like
they come from an idea but like evolution all cars have a single common
evolution all cars have a single common
evolution all cars have a single common ancestor a single idea and that was the
ancestor a single idea and that was the
ancestor a single idea and that was the wheel and that wheel has driven us
wheel and that wheel has driven us
wheel and that wheel has driven us pretty far so if you take nothing else
pretty far so if you take nothing else
pretty far so if you take nothing else from this when you’re out walking along
from this when you’re out walking along
from this when you’re out walking along in the street and you see the new model
in the street and you see the new model
in the street and you see the new model of car roll by or you see the latest
of car roll by or you see the latest
of car roll by or you see the latest smartphone ad on TV think about what
smartphone ad on TV think about what
smartphone ad on TV think about what kind of broader changes that reflects of
kind of broader changes that reflects of
kind of broader changes that reflects of our planet over deep time and ask that
our planet over deep time and ask that
our planet over deep time and ask that change that you see something that reads
change that you see something that reads
change that you see something that reads Scherer would say well can you tell me
Scherer would say well can you tell me
Scherer would say well can you tell me about this thank you
”
Be First to Comment