Press "Enter" to skip to content

Most Eaten, Least Heard: The Inner Lives of Fishes | Jonathan Balcombe | TEDxHeidelberg


thank you we mostly think of

thank you we mostly think of in one of two contexts either as a

in one of two contexts either as a

in one of two contexts either as a source of food or a source of recreation

source of food or a source of recreation

source of food or a source of recreation my own fishing career was brief when it

my own fishing career was brief when it

my own fishing career was brief when it came time to impale worms on hooks and

came time to impale worms on hooks and

came time to impale worms on hooks and to twist them out of fish’s mouths I

to twist them out of fish’s mouths I

to twist them out of fish’s mouths I lost interest I just couldn’t help

lost interest I just couldn’t help

lost interest I just couldn’t help seeing it from their perspective at that

seeing it from their perspective at that

seeing it from their perspective at that time my family and I would make

time my family and I would make

time my family and I would make occasional trips to McDonald’s and I

occasional trips to McDonald’s and I

occasional trips to McDonald’s and I made it no association with those fishes

made it no association with those fishes

made it no association with those fishes on my hook on my line with the anonymous

on my hook on my line with the anonymous

on my hook on my line with the anonymous ones who ended up in the filet-o-fish

ones who ended up in the filet-o-fish

ones who ended up in the filet-o-fish sandwiches I used to have at that time

sandwiches I used to have at that time

sandwiches I used to have at that time McDonald’s was boasting 1 billion served

McDonald’s was boasting 1 billion served

McDonald’s was boasting 1 billion served they were speaking of customers but they

they were speaking of customers but they

they were speaking of customers but they could have been speaking about chickens

could have been speaking about chickens

could have been speaking about chickens or fishes

or fishes

or fishes I also remember dolphin-safe tuna

I also remember dolphin-safe tuna

I also remember dolphin-safe tuna campaigns I’m wondering why they were no

campaigns I’m wondering why they were no

campaigns I’m wondering why they were no tuna safe tuna campaigns the fact is

tuna safe tuna campaigns the fact is

tuna safe tuna campaigns the fact is we’ve been alienated from fishes we can

we’ve been alienated from fishes we can

we’ve been alienated from fishes we can look out over water and there may be

look out over water and there may be

look out over water and there may be thousands just below the surface but we

thousands just below the surface but we

thousands just below the surface but we cannot see any of them it’s only in the

cannot see any of them it’s only in the

cannot see any of them it’s only in the last 50 years where we’ve had scuba

last 50 years where we’ve had scuba

last 50 years where we’ve had scuba technology and underwater cinematography

technology and underwater cinematography

technology and underwater cinematography that allow us to see them in their own

that allow us to see them in their own

that allow us to see them in their own environment those unblinking eyes

environment those unblinking eyes

environment those unblinking eyes consider those unblinking eyes

consider those unblinking eyes

consider those unblinking eyes permanently bathed in water and

permanently bathed in water and

permanently bathed in water and therefore in no need of eyelids and the

therefore in no need of eyelids and the

therefore in no need of eyelids and the sounds they make fishes actually make

sounds they make fishes actually make

sounds they make fishes actually make lots of sounds but we can’t hear them

lots of sounds but we can’t hear them

lots of sounds but we can’t hear them because again they’re below the surface

because again they’re below the surface

because again they’re below the surface it’s very hard to be an active listener

it’s very hard to be an active listener

it’s very hard to be an active listener when you can’t hear anything today I

when you can’t hear anything today I

when you can’t hear anything today I want to invite you to see fishes through

want to invite you to see fishes through

want to invite you to see fishes through a different lens

a different lens

a different lens I’ve spent the last five years swimming

I’ve spent the last five years swimming

I’ve spent the last five years swimming among researching and writing about

among researching and writing about

among researching and writing about fishes culminating in this book what a

fishes culminating in this book what a

fishes culminating in this book what a fish knows which I’m happy to say is

fish knows which I’m happy to say is

fish knows which I’m happy to say is soon available in a German translation

soon available in a German translation

soon available in a German translation not sure about Russian yet

not sure about Russian yet

not sure about Russian yet so let me start with a few superlatives

so let me start with a few superlatives

so let me start with a few superlatives about fishes the longest fish name

about fishes the longest fish name

about fishes the longest fish name belongs to the Hawaiian reef triggerfish

belongs to the Hawaiian reef triggerfish

belongs to the Hawaiian reef triggerfish known to the locals as the

known to the locals as the

known to the locals as the humuhumunukunukuapua’a which stands for

humuhumunukunukuapua’a which stands for

humuhumunukunukuapua’a which stands for the fish who shows with a needle and

the fish who shows with a needle and

the fish who shows with a needle and grunts like a pig for me the prettiest

grunts like a pig for me the prettiest

grunts like a pig for me the prettiest fish name belongs to the diagonal banded

fish name belongs to the diagonal banded

fish name belongs to the diagonal banded sweetlips I don’t know about you when I

sweetlips I don’t know about you when I

sweetlips I don’t know about you when I see those lips I just want to give them

see those lips I just want to give them

see those lips I just want to give them a kiss perhaps the smallest vertebrate

a kiss perhaps the smallest vertebrate

a kiss perhaps the smallest vertebrate on earth is this little fish of

on earth is this little fish of

on earth is this little fish of philippine lakes you could put 300

philippine lakes you could put 300

philippine lakes you could put 300 adults on one side of a scale and a

adults on one side of a scale and a

adults on one side of a scale and a penny on the other and the penny will go

penny on the other and the penny will go

penny on the other and the penny will go down the new record holder for longevity

down the new record holder for longevity

down the new record holder for longevity among vertebrates goes to the Greenland

among vertebrates goes to the Greenland

among vertebrates goes to the Greenland shark when scientists analyze the

shark when scientists analyze the

shark when scientists analyze the corneal layers laid down each year on

corneal layers laid down each year on

corneal layers laid down each year on the I just like the rings of a tree one

the I just like the rings of a tree one

the I just like the rings of a tree one of the females in this study had 392

of the females in this study had 392

of the females in this study had 392 layers

layers

layers she was approaching her 400th birthday

she was approaching her 400th birthday

she was approaching her 400th birthday when she was caught apparently healthy

when she was caught apparently healthy

when she was caught apparently healthy by fishermen my nomination for the

by fishermen my nomination for the

by fishermen my nomination for the kinkiest mating system goes to the

kinkiest mating system goes to the

kinkiest mating system goes to the deep-sea anglerfish ‘as there’s about a

deep-sea anglerfish ‘as there’s about a

deep-sea anglerfish ‘as there’s about a hundred and sixty known species these

hundred and sixty known species these

hundred and sixty known species these animals it’s very hard to find the right

animals it’s very hard to find the right

animals it’s very hard to find the right mate if you are a male living in the

mate if you are a male living in the

mate if you are a male living in the darkest biggest habitat on earth so you

darkest biggest habitat on earth so you

darkest biggest habitat on earth so you want to make good if you do find the

want to make good if you do find the

want to make good if you do find the right female and how do males make good

right female and how do males make good

right female and how do males make good they bite her and it’s the last bite

they bite her and it’s the last bite

they bite her and it’s the last bite they ever take

the way it works is scientists often

the way it works is scientists often call it parasitic sexuality and

call it parasitic sexuality and

call it parasitic sexuality and parasitic mating system and in the sense

parasitic mating system and in the sense

parasitic mating system and in the sense that the male is attached as a parasite

that the male is attached as a parasite

that the male is attached as a parasite we can see that and she provides all the

we can see that and she provides all the

we can see that and she provides all the food she does all the nourishment we can

food she does all the nourishment we can

food she does all the nourishment we can see how it is sort of parasitic but when

see how it is sort of parasitic but when

see how it is sort of parasitic but when you consider that a female’s life

you consider that a female’s life

you consider that a female’s life history is nothing it doesn’t come it

history is nothing it doesn’t come it

history is nothing it doesn’t come it comes to an end if there’s no male then

comes to an end if there’s no male then

comes to an end if there’s no male then it’s not fully parasitic so for but for

it’s not fully parasitic so for but for

it’s not fully parasitic so for but for any radical feminists in the audience

any radical feminists in the audience

any radical feminists in the audience you may take some grim pleasure in the

you may take some grim pleasure in the

you may take some grim pleasure in the knowledge that some males never do

knowledge that some males never do

knowledge that some males never do amount to anything more than an

amount to anything more than an

amount to anything more than an appendage but let’s go beyond

appendage but let’s go beyond

appendage but let’s go beyond superlatives and think about fish minds

superlatives and think about fish minds

superlatives and think about fish minds and fish feelings what fishes are

and fish feelings what fishes are

and fish feelings what fishes are capable of consider this little five

capable of consider this little five

capable of consider this little five inch long fish the friend goby lives in

inch long fish the friend goby lives in

inch long fish the friend goby lives in intertidal zones this is their habitat

intertidal zones this is their habitat

intertidal zones this is their habitat and we’ve wondered for a while why they

and we’ve wondered for a while why they

and we’ve wondered for a while why they can jump accurately from one tide pool

can jump accurately from one tide pool

can jump accurately from one tide pool to another and work their way out to the

to another and work their way out to the

to another and work their way out to the ocean they can do that how do they do

ocean they can do that how do they do

ocean they can do that how do they do that a series of experiments was done

that a series of experiments was done

that a series of experiments was done that showed that they actually memorized

that showed that they actually memorized

that showed that they actually memorized the tide pool zone by swimming down

the tide pool zone by swimming down

the tide pool zone by swimming down among it at high tide so when the waters

among it at high tide so when the waters

among it at high tide so when the waters in they can swim down among the rocks

in they can swim down among the rocks

in they can swim down among the rocks and remember where things are it’s very

and remember where things are it’s very

and remember where things are it’s very useful if an octopus or a heron comes

useful if an octopus or a heron comes

useful if an octopus or a heron comes along and trying trying to catch you and

along and trying trying to catch you and

along and trying trying to catch you and it’s saves having to make a leap of

it’s saves having to make a leap of

it’s saves having to make a leap of faith and end up stranded on the rocks

faith and end up stranded on the rocks

faith and end up stranded on the rocks what about tool use and observational

what about tool use and observational

what about tool use and observational learning in fishes can they do that yes

learning in fishes can they do that yes

learning in fishes can they do that yes Archer fishes use water as a tool by

Archer fishes use water as a tool by

Archer fishes use water as a tool by squirting it at insects who may be

squirting it at insects who may be

squirting it at insects who may be perched or flying by over the water and

perched or flying by over the water and

perched or flying by over the water and they don’t this doesn’t just come innate

they don’t this doesn’t just come innate

they don’t this doesn’t just come innate they have to learn it from other fishes

they have to learn it from other fishes

they have to learn it from other fishes they can learn this by watching other in

they can learn this by watching other in

they can learn this by watching other in the

the

the practice their skill they also are

practice their skill they also are

practice their skill they also are flexible in how they do this if the

flexible in how they do this if the

flexible in how they do this if the insect is flying close to the water they

insect is flying close to the water they

insect is flying close to the water they squirt it directly at the at the insect

squirt it directly at the at the insect

squirt it directly at the at the insect so they and they rotate their body at

so they and they rotate their body at

so they and they rotate their body at the same time if however the insect is

the same time if however the insect is

the same time if however the insect is further away they they squirt a head of

further away they they squirt a head of

further away they they squirt a head of the insect like passing a football or in

the insect like passing a football or in

the insect like passing a football or in America a football because Archer fishes

America a football because Archer fishes

America a football because Archer fishes squirt water they’re really good

squirt water they’re really good

squirt water they’re really good subjects for studies to test preferences

subjects for studies to test preferences

subjects for studies to test preferences or test ability to recognize things for

or test ability to recognize things for

or test ability to recognize things for a long time people who keep fishes in

a long time people who keep fishes in

a long time people who keep fishes in aquariums have said that the fish

aquariums have said that the fish

aquariums have said that the fish recognized me recognizes me they know

recognized me recognizes me they know

recognized me recognizes me they know it’s me and now we have the science to

it’s me and now we have the science to

it’s me and now we have the science to back that up you can train Archer fishes

back that up you can train Archer fishes

back that up you can train Archer fishes with familiar faces and then present

with familiar faces and then present

with familiar faces and then present them with one familiar face among 30 or

them with one familiar face among 30 or

them with one familiar face among 30 or more 40 or more even unfamiliar faces

more 40 or more even unfamiliar faces

more 40 or more even unfamiliar faces and they will squirt water at the one

and they will squirt water at the one

and they will squirt water at the one familiar face in the crowd

fishes also have the face inversion

fishes also have the face inversion effect a face that’s familiar to them

effect a face that’s familiar to them

effect a face that’s familiar to them the right way up if you turn it upside

the right way up if you turn it upside

the right way up if you turn it upside down they can’t recognize it we also

down they can’t recognize it we also

down they can’t recognize it we also have the face inversion effect

have the face inversion effect

have the face inversion effect chimpanzees do not and if you consider

chimpanzees do not and if you consider

chimpanzees do not and if you consider their behavior you can see why fishes

their behavior you can see why fishes

their behavior you can see why fishes actually referential communication is

actually referential communication is

actually referential communication is rare in nature and it’s vanishingly rare

rare in nature and it’s vanishingly rare

rare in nature and it’s vanishingly rare across species and yet we have an

across species and yet we have an

across species and yet we have an example here of among fishes who can do

example here of among fishes who can do

example here of among fishes who can do this the fish on top is a grouper and

this the fish on top is a grouper and

this the fish on top is a grouper and the one on the bottom is a moray eel

the one on the bottom is a moray eel

the one on the bottom is a moray eel groupers invite moray eels to hunt

groupers invite moray eels to hunt

groupers invite moray eels to hunt cooperatively with them by a gesture

cooperatively with them by a gesture

cooperatively with them by a gesture they make a head shake or a full body

they make a head shake or a full body

they make a head shake or a full body shimmy and the grouper knows what it

shimmy and the grouper knows what it

shimmy and the grouper knows what it means it means will you come hunting

means it means will you come hunting

means it means will you come hunting with me and if the grouper is hungry and

with me and if the grouper is hungry and

with me and if the grouper is hungry and in the mood off they swim over the reef

in the mood off they swim over the reef

in the mood off they swim over the reef together and they’re hunting styles are

together and they’re hunting styles are

together and they’re hunting styles are complementary the moray eel is like a

complementary the moray eel is like a

complementary the moray eel is like a little ferret and can go into the nooks

little ferret and can go into the nooks

little ferret and can go into the nooks and crannies so if a fish flees into the

and crannies so if a fish flees into the

and crannies so if a fish flees into the reef the Moray Eel can go after

reef the Moray Eel can go after

reef the Moray Eel can go after and if the Moray Eel is unable to catch

and if the Moray Eel is unable to catch

and if the Moray Eel is unable to catch the fish because the fish swims into

the fish because the fish swims into

the fish because the fish swims into open water

open water

open water you know who’s waiting the grouper

you know who’s waiting the grouper

you know who’s waiting the grouper sometimes groupers will point to a prey

sometimes groupers will point to a prey

sometimes groupers will point to a prey for 20 minutes or more to try to get the

for 20 minutes or more to try to get the

for 20 minutes or more to try to get the moray eel to come over to to catch this

moray eel to come over to to catch this

moray eel to come over to to catch this and in fact observational studies show

and in fact observational studies show

and in fact observational studies show that they by working together there they

that they by working together there they

that they by working together there they can be as much as five times more

can be as much as five times more

can be as much as five times more successful at catching fish than if they

successful at catching fish than if they

successful at catching fish than if they work alone English science writer Edie

work alone English science writer Edie

work alone English science writer Edie Young sums it up with a familiar jingle

Young sums it up with a familiar jingle

Young sums it up with a familiar jingle if your praise in a hole then you don’t

if your praise in a hole then you don’t

if your praise in a hole then you don’t have a pulse that’s amore captive

have a pulse that’s amore captive

have a pulse that’s amore captive studies find that groupers recognize a

studies find that groupers recognize a

studies find that groupers recognize a cooperative moray eel versus an

cooperative moray eel versus an

cooperative moray eel versus an uncooperative one and they will choose

uncooperative one and they will choose

uncooperative one and they will choose the cooperative one the next day

the cooperative one the next day

the cooperative one the next day you may notice this is a laminated eel

you may notice this is a laminated eel

you may notice this is a laminated eel not a real one it allows scientists who

not a real one it allows scientists who

not a real one it allows scientists who use police to control the eels and make

use police to control the eels and make

use police to control the eels and make some of them cooperative and some of

some of them cooperative and some of

some of them cooperative and some of them uncooperative can we find Mackay

them uncooperative can we find Mackay

them uncooperative can we find Mackay Yale Machiavellian intelligence and

Yale Machiavellian intelligence and

Yale Machiavellian intelligence and fishes yes we can on reefs one of the

fishes yes we can on reefs one of the

fishes yes we can on reefs one of the most sophisticated mutualisms in nature

most sophisticated mutualisms in nature

most sophisticated mutualisms in nature happens on reefs

happens on reefs

happens on reefs it’s the cleaner client mutualism it’s

it’s the cleaner client mutualism it’s

it’s the cleaner client mutualism it’s very well studied there are probably

very well studied there are probably

very well studied there are probably more than 150 published studies on this

more than 150 published studies on this

more than 150 published studies on this relationship and it works what by having

relationship and it works what by having

relationship and it works what by having cleaners these two cleaners here you can

cleaners these two cleaners here you can

cleaners these two cleaners here you can see and they offer a cleaning service to

see and they offer a cleaning service to

see and they offer a cleaning service to client fishes of more than a hundred

client fishes of more than a hundred

client fishes of more than a hundred different kinds who will line up to wait

different kinds who will line up to wait

different kinds who will line up to wait their turn to be serviced by the

their turn to be serviced by the

their turn to be serviced by the cleaners the cleaners pluck parasites

cleaners the cleaners pluck parasites

cleaners the cleaners pluck parasites off the off the clients so they get food

off the off the clients so they get food

off the off the clients so they get food and the clients get a parasite removal

and the clients get a parasite removal

and the clients get a parasite removal service and a spa treatment and you can

service and a spa treatment and you can

service and a spa treatment and you can see the client is cooperative opening

see the client is cooperative opening

see the client is cooperative opening the mouth and opening the gills gill

the mouth and opening the gills gill

the mouth and opening the gills gill covers and nobody has ever seen a client

covers and nobody has ever seen a client

covers and nobody has ever seen a client fish eat the cleaner fish even though

fish eat the cleaner fish even though

fish eat the cleaner fish even though they easily could do that

they easily could do that

they easily could do that it just doesn’t sustain good basic good

it just doesn’t sustain good basic good

it just doesn’t sustain good basic good business relationships to eat your

business relationships to eat your

business relationships to eat your partner

now for the Machiavellian part sometimes

now for the Machiavellian part sometimes cleaners don’t do such a good job if

cleaners don’t do such a good job if

cleaners don’t do such a good job if there’s cleaners can do what’s called

there’s cleaners can do what’s called

there’s cleaners can do what’s called mucus nipping where they bite a little

mucus nipping where they bite a little

mucus nipping where they bite a little mote of mucus off the skin of the client

mote of mucus off the skin of the client

mote of mucus off the skin of the client and that makes the client jolt often and

and that makes the client jolt often and

and that makes the client jolt often and that probably signals to other clients

that probably signals to other clients

that probably signals to other clients in the queue that maybe these cleaners

in the queue that maybe these cleaners

in the queue that maybe these cleaners aren’t doing a very good job what about

aren’t doing a very good job what about

aren’t doing a very good job what about stress relief oh one other point I

stress relief oh one other point I

stress relief oh one other point I forgot to make to curry favor with

forgot to make to curry favor with

forgot to make to curry favor with unhappy clients cleaners will sometimes

unhappy clients cleaners will sometimes

unhappy clients cleaners will sometimes do what’s called a caressing they will

do what’s called a caressing they will

do what’s called a caressing they will stroke the client fish with their

stroke the client fish with their

stroke the client fish with their pectoral fins which leads me to a study

pectoral fins which leads me to a study

pectoral fins which leads me to a study of stress relief a study from the

of stress relief a study from the

of stress relief a study from the university of lisbon scientists

university of lisbon scientists

university of lisbon scientists collected surgeon fish’s striated

collected surgeon fish’s striated

collected surgeon fish’s striated surgeon fishes and then they stressed

surgeon fishes and then they stressed

surgeon fishes and then they stressed them even more being caught is stressful

them even more being caught is stressful

them even more being caught is stressful but being put into a bucket of water for

but being put into a bucket of water for

but being put into a bucket of water for 30 minutes is very stressful and you can

30 minutes is very stressful and you can

30 minutes is very stressful and you can measure stress in a fish by taking a

measure stress in a fish by taking a

measure stress in a fish by taking a little blood sample from the tail vein

little blood sample from the tail vein

little blood sample from the tail vein and seeing that the cortisol level a

and seeing that the cortisol level a

and seeing that the cortisol level a stress hormone goes up and what they

stress hormone goes up and what they

stress hormone goes up and what they found was curious if a stressed fish was

found was curious if a stressed fish was

found was curious if a stressed fish was put in a tank with a model of a cleaner

put in a tank with a model of a cleaner

put in a tank with a model of a cleaner fish which you just met the cleaner

fish which you just met the cleaner

fish which you just met the cleaner wrasse in which case in which the

wrasse in which case in which the

wrasse in which case in which the cleaner model was attached to a motor

cleaner model was attached to a motor

cleaner model was attached to a motor and that would sweep back and forth like

and that would sweep back and forth like

and that would sweep back and forth like that in a waving motion the one on top

that in a waving motion the one on top

that in a waving motion the one on top it has a different different outcome

it has a different different outcome

it has a different different outcome than if it’s put in a tank with a

than if it’s put in a tank with a

than if it’s put in a tank with a stationary cleaner fish the model

stationary cleaner fish the model

stationary cleaner fish the model doesn’t move in the top one the fishes

doesn’t move in the top one the fishes

doesn’t move in the top one the fishes would visit that moving cleaner fish an

would visit that moving cleaner fish an

would visit that moving cleaner fish an average of 15 times per hour in the

average of 15 times per hour in the

average of 15 times per hour in the bottom one

bottom one

bottom one they didn’t visit it at all the top one

they didn’t visit it at all the top one

they didn’t visit it at all the top one could give them strokes they could get

could give them strokes they could get

could give them strokes they could get stress relief and the stress levels

stress relief and the stress levels

stress relief and the stress levels cortisol came down not so in the bottom

cortisol came down not so in the bottom

cortisol came down not so in the bottom one so we see evidence here for fishes

one so we see evidence here for fishes

one so we see evidence here for fishes being stress but also being able to seek

being stress but also being able to seek

being stress but also being able to seek out stress relief when

out stress relief when

out stress relief when given the opportunity if fishes can be

given the opportunity if fishes can be

given the opportunity if fishes can be cooperative and Machiavellian and if

cooperative and Machiavellian and if

cooperative and Machiavellian and if they can get stressed and they can get

they can get stressed and they can get

they can get stressed and they can get stress relief maybe they can be virtuous

stress relief maybe they can be virtuous

stress relief maybe they can be virtuous too is it true here’s one example rabbet

too is it true here’s one example rabbet

too is it true here’s one example rabbet fishes of various species we see four

fishes of various species we see four

fishes of various species we see four here in each quadrant they forage as a

here in each quadrant they forage as a

here in each quadrant they forage as a team

team

team kind of like morays and groupers except

kind of like morays and groupers except

kind of like morays and groupers except they don’t catch other fish they eat

they don’t catch other fish they eat

they don’t catch other fish they eat algae off the coral reef and you can see

algae off the coral reef and you can see

algae off the coral reef and you can see that while one individual is down in the

that while one individual is down in the

that while one individual is down in the reef with the head down feeding on algae

reef with the head down feeding on algae

reef with the head down feeding on algae the other of the pair is head up playing

the other of the pair is head up playing

the other of the pair is head up playing look out this is virtuous because it’s

look out this is virtuous because it’s

look out this is virtuous because it’s foregoing gratification the one who’s

foregoing gratification the one who’s

foregoing gratification the one who’s playing look out is not getting any food

playing look out is not getting any food

playing look out is not getting any food and if he or she sees danger a moray in

and if he or she sees danger a moray in

and if he or she sees danger a moray in a group or perhaps they can signal that

a group or perhaps they can signal that

a group or perhaps they can signal that danger and the two fishes can swim off

danger and the two fishes can swim off

danger and the two fishes can swim off quickly to get safe of course they

quickly to get safe of course they

quickly to get safe of course they switch places after a few minutes the

switch places after a few minutes the

switch places after a few minutes the one on the bottom comes up and the one

one on the bottom comes up and the one

one on the bottom comes up and the one goes down so both of them get to be fed

goes down so both of them get to be fed

goes down so both of them get to be fed in a safer way in our relations with

in a safer way in our relations with

in a safer way in our relations with fishes we could be more virtuous than we

fishes we could be more virtuous than we

fishes we could be more virtuous than we have been it’s unknown how many fishes

have been it’s unknown how many fishes

have been it’s unknown how many fishes we kill every year but it estimates

we kill every year but it estimates

we kill every year but it estimates range anywhere from 200 billion to

range anywhere from 200 billion to

range anywhere from 200 billion to perhaps a trillion or more and fish

perhaps a trillion or more and fish

perhaps a trillion or more and fish farming aquaculture also consumes

farming aquaculture also consumes

farming aquaculture also consumes billions of fishes and it’s a very

billions of fishes and it’s a very

billions of fishes and it’s a very stressful difficult environment on a

stressful difficult environment on a

stressful difficult environment on a fish farm the crowding the concentrated

fish farm the crowding the concentrated

fish farm the crowding the concentrated number of fishes in one place the

number of fishes in one place the

number of fishes in one place the parasites that thrive in these

parasites that thrive in these

parasites that thrive in these environments the chemicals used to try

environments the chemicals used to try

environments the chemicals used to try to get rid of the parasites the

to get rid of the parasites the

to get rid of the parasites the concentrated wastes of the fishes the

concentrated wastes of the fishes the

concentrated wastes of the fishes the frustration of natural behaviors all of

frustration of natural behaviors all of

frustration of natural behaviors all of these things are very difficult for

these things are very difficult for

these things are very difficult for these fishes to cope with and many of

these fishes to cope with and many of

these fishes to cope with and many of them just simply can’t manage the salmon

them just simply can’t manage the salmon

them just simply can’t manage the salmon on the bottom the farmed salmon is the

on the bottom the farmed salmon is the

on the bottom the farmed salmon is the same age as the one on top and the

same age as the one on top and the

same age as the one on top and the industry term for the one on the bottom

industry term for the one on the bottom

industry term for the one on the bottom is a dropout this individual simply

is a dropout this individual simply

is a dropout this individual simply couldn’t cope with the stresses of

couldn’t cope with the stresses of

couldn’t cope with the stresses of captivity he or she stopped eating the

captivity he or she stopped eating the

captivity he or she stopped eating the stress levels go very high

stress levels go very high

stress levels go very high the fish floats to the surface and dies

the fish floats to the surface and dies

the fish floats to the surface and dies and the oceans and freshwater habitats

and the oceans and freshwater habitats

and the oceans and freshwater habitats around the world are beleaguered by a

around the world are beleaguered by a

around the world are beleaguered by a number of terrible problems facing them

number of terrible problems facing them

number of terrible problems facing them growing problems climate change warming

growing problems climate change warming

growing problems climate change warming oceans you’ve heard of that ocean

oceans you’ve heard of that ocean

oceans you’ve heard of that ocean acidification or acid levels are rising

acidification or acid levels are rising

acidification or acid levels are rising slowly

slowly

slowly well more quickly caryl bleaching is a

well more quickly caryl bleaching is a

well more quickly caryl bleaching is a result of some of these problems plastic

result of some of these problems plastic

result of some of these problems plastic pollution the manufacture of plastics

pollution the manufacture of plastics

pollution the manufacture of plastics produces huge numbers of little plastic

produces huge numbers of little plastic

produces huge numbers of little plastic beads which are ingested by little

beads which are ingested by little

beads which are ingested by little fishes who feed on fish eggs they look

fishes who feed on fish eggs they look

fishes who feed on fish eggs they look just like plastic beads they’re very

just like plastic beads they’re very

just like plastic beads they’re very similar leading their stomachs to

similar leading their stomachs to

similar leading their stomachs to rupture because they cannot digest them

rupture because they cannot digest them

rupture because they cannot digest them and of course that kills them speaking

and of course that kills them speaking

and of course that kills them speaking of plastics we leave discard or lose

of plastics we leave discard or lose

of plastics we leave discard or lose approximately six hundred and forty

approximately six hundred and forty

approximately six hundred and forty thousand tons of fishing gear in the

thousand tons of fishing gear in the

thousand tons of fishing gear in the oceans every year you may have heard of

oceans every year you may have heard of

oceans every year you may have heard of bycatch of which about 200 million

bycatch of which about 200 million

bycatch of which about 200 million pounds a day of dead or dying sea

pounds a day of dead or dying sea

pounds a day of dead or dying sea creatures who we don’t that fishermen

creatures who we don’t that fishermen

creatures who we don’t that fishermen are not trying to catch they’re tossed

are not trying to catch they’re tossed

are not trying to catch they’re tossed back in the ocean ninety-eight percent

back in the ocean ninety-eight percent

back in the ocean ninety-eight percent of all the animals we take are to be

of all the animals we take are to be

of all the animals we take are to be eaten and we’ve been eating a lot such

eaten and we’ve been eating a lot such

eaten and we’ve been eating a lot such that we’ve lost about half of all marine

that we’ve lost about half of all marine

that we’ve lost about half of all marine life in the last half century

are there any other ways we can eat of

are there any other ways we can eat of course there are we can choose other

course there are we can choose other

course there are we can choose other things and probably the most immediate

things and probably the most immediate

things and probably the most immediate way we can help fishes is to refrain

way we can help fishes is to refrain

way we can help fishes is to refrain from eating them however technological

from eating them however technological

from eating them however technological advances are leading to other choices

advances are leading to other choices

advances are leading to other choices companies like New Wave foods and

companies like New Wave foods and

companies like New Wave foods and finless foods are developing plant-based

finless foods are developing plant-based

finless foods are developing plant-based and in-vitro alternatives to fish as

and in-vitro alternatives to fish as

and in-vitro alternatives to fish as food many products are already available

food many products are already available

food many products are already available now so in closing science has shown us

now so in closing science has shown us

now so in closing science has shown us that fishes are intelligent that they

that fishes are intelligent that they

that fishes are intelligent that they think they feel they have emotions they

think they feel they have emotions they

think they feel they have emotions they can get stressed they can feel stress

can get stressed they can feel stress

can get stressed they can feel stress relief they can be upset they can be

relief they can be upset they can be

relief they can be upset they can be annoyed they have a lot of

annoyed they have a lot of

annoyed they have a lot of characteristics that make them very

characteristics that make them very

characteristics that make them very special creatures and I think we would

special creatures and I think we would

special creatures and I think we would do better to treat them better and I

do better to treat them better and I

do better to treat them better and I believe in karma that a better world is

believe in karma that a better world is

believe in karma that a better world is for them if we have more respectful and

for them if we have more respectful and

for them if we have more respectful and compassionate towards them we will be

compassionate towards them we will be

compassionate towards them we will be more respectful and compassionate toward

more respectful and compassionate toward

more respectful and compassionate toward each other that’s the kind of world I’d

each other that’s the kind of world I’d

each other that’s the kind of world I’d like to live in thank you

like to live in thank you

like to live in thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *