Press "Enter" to skip to content

The future of urban living and how we can change it | Amelie Salameh | TEDxFrankfurt


[Applause]

[Applause] two years ago I traveled through Bali

two years ago I traveled through Bali

two years ago I traveled through Bali for a month and before the trip I wanted

for a month and before the trip I wanted

for a month and before the trip I wanted to have a very small backpack fitting

to have a very small backpack fitting

to have a very small backpack fitting only necessary things I don’t have to

only necessary things I don’t have to

only necessary things I don’t have to carry heavy stuff around me all the time

carry heavy stuff around me all the time

carry heavy stuff around me all the time so I get this one and before I also

so I get this one and before I also

so I get this one and before I also started this packing list where edit and

started this packing list where edit and

started this packing list where edit and removed items all the time and I

removed items all the time and I

removed items all the time and I reviewed it over and over again and

reviewed it over and over again and

reviewed it over and over again and during the trip I stayed at these

during the trip I stayed at these

during the trip I stayed at these bungalows and huts with you know like

bungalows and huts with you know like

bungalows and huts with you know like bedroom bathroom kitchen towels all I

bedroom bathroom kitchen towels all I

bedroom bathroom kitchen towels all I needed

needed

needed and one was actually my favorite

and one was actually my favorite

and one was actually my favorite recommendation where the host called

recommendation where the host called

recommendation where the host called themselves Papa mama Jarrow they

themselves Papa mama Jarrow they

themselves Papa mama Jarrow they literally had parents for a week and

literally had parents for a week and

literally had parents for a week and after the trip I looked very carefully

after the trip I looked very carefully

after the trip I looked very carefully at my backpack while I was unpacking and

at my backpack while I was unpacking and

at my backpack while I was unpacking and even though I had this list I found

even though I had this list I found

even though I had this list I found items where I was like okay I know the

items where I was like okay I know the

items where I was like okay I know the medical kit is very important even

medical kit is very important even

medical kit is very important even though I didn’t use it but why the heck

though I didn’t use it but why the heck

though I didn’t use it but why the heck did I pack this I was so convinced

did I pack this I was so convinced

did I pack this I was so convinced before the trip that I gonna need to

before the trip that I gonna need to

before the trip that I gonna need to wear this dress for a party or something

wear this dress for a party or something

wear this dress for a party or something to dress up but actually I didn’t end up

to dress up but actually I didn’t end up

to dress up but actually I didn’t end up wearing it because I’m not a big fan of

wearing it because I’m not a big fan of

wearing it because I’m not a big fan of wearing dresses and for me it feels like

wearing dresses and for me it feels like

wearing dresses and for me it feels like a symbol of an individual being trapped

a symbol of an individual being trapped

a symbol of an individual being trapped in thinking patterns and doesn’t really

in thinking patterns and doesn’t really

in thinking patterns and doesn’t really know what a person needs so I asked

know what a person needs so I asked

know what a person needs so I asked myself over and over again what do I

myself over and over again what do I

myself over and over again what do I really need and back in my apartment I

really need and back in my apartment I

really need and back in my apartment I felt very cramped and I wanted to get

felt very cramped and I wanted to get

felt very cramped and I wanted to get rid of things there’s actually a simple

rid of things there’s actually a simple

rid of things there’s actually a simple method where you can look at something

method where you can look at something

method where you can look at something and ask yourself does that bring me joy

and ask yourself does that bring me joy

and ask yourself does that bring me joy and you’re like nope and during the time

and you’re like nope and during the time

and you’re like nope and during the time I also watch a lot of YouTube

I also watch a lot of YouTube

I also watch a lot of YouTube documentaries about tiny houses a tiny

documentaries about tiny houses a tiny

documentaries about tiny houses a tiny house is literally just a small self bit

house is literally just a small self bit

house is literally just a small self bit house on a trailer and therefore movable

house on a trailer and therefore movable

house on a trailer and therefore movable like this one

like this one

like this one this girl traveled around the whole

this girl traveled around the whole

this girl traveled around the whole world with the tiny house and I was so

world with the tiny house and I was so

world with the tiny house and I was so impressed by these little room oneness

impressed by these little room oneness

impressed by these little room oneness where you can slide things up like this

where you can slide things up like this

where you can slide things up like this and then you move it around like this

and then you move it around like this

and then you move it around like this and then actually at the end of kind of

and then actually at the end of kind of

and then actually at the end of kind of transforms into a table and there are

transforms into a table and there are

transforms into a table and there are these videos of people being like

these videos of people being like

these videos of people being like welcome to my crib but it were way

welcome to my crib but it were way

welcome to my crib but it were way cooler than the ones I’m empty

cooler than the ones I’m empty

cooler than the ones I’m empty to me I found videos of people building

to me I found videos of people building

to me I found videos of people building tiny houses that cost around five

tiny houses that cost around five

tiny houses that cost around five thousand to ten thousand euros so I

thousand to ten thousand euros so I

thousand to ten thousand euros so I started calculating I was like ah this

started calculating I was like ah this

started calculating I was like ah this is actually the amount of money I pay

is actually the amount of money I pay

is actually the amount of money I pay for rent each year but you know the

for rent each year but you know the

for rent each year but you know the thing with an apartment or a house or

thing with an apartment or a house or

thing with an apartment or a house or something is that as soon as you get

something is that as soon as you get

something is that as soon as you get kicked out or you stop paying your rent

kicked out or you stop paying your rent

kicked out or you stop paying your rent every month you actually end up with

every month you actually end up with

every month you actually end up with nothing and instead of taking on a

nothing and instead of taking on a

nothing and instead of taking on a lifelong bank credit to buy my own house

lifelong bank credit to buy my own house

lifelong bank credit to buy my own house or apartment or keep on paying rent each

or apartment or keep on paying rent each

or apartment or keep on paying rent each month

month

month I thought I can just save some money

I thought I can just save some money

I thought I can just save some money build a tiny house and call him my own

build a tiny house and call him my own

build a tiny house and call him my own and with that dream already in my head

and with that dream already in my head

and with that dream already in my head big dream of building a tiny house I

big dream of building a tiny house I

big dream of building a tiny house I moved to Berlin and I found this event

moved to Berlin and I found this event

moved to Berlin and I found this event by the Tanyard University the tiniest

by the Tanyard University the tiniest

by the Tanyard University the tiniest university is an association founded in

university is an association founded in

university is an association founded in 2016 by very well-known architects some

2016 by very well-known architects some

2016 by very well-known architects some of you might know of unbeli Mensa and

of you might know of unbeli Mensa and

of you might know of unbeli Mensa and other architects designers education

other architects designers education

other architects designers education activists as well as refugees and it

activists as well as refugees and it

activists as well as refugees and it started as a collective of people being

started as a collective of people being

started as a collective of people being interested in tiny houses and

interested in tiny houses and

interested in tiny houses and minimalistic living and also in homeless

minimalistic living and also in homeless

minimalistic living and also in homeless shelters and refugee shelters and how to

shelters and refugee shelters and how to

shelters and refugee shelters and how to build them easily and make them creative

build them easily and make them creative

build them easily and make them creative and I was so pumped to meet these people

and I was so pumped to meet these people

and I was so pumped to meet these people so I joined one of their first meetings

so I joined one of their first meetings

so I joined one of their first meetings in a cafe in Berlin and vevo gave me a

in a cafe in Berlin and vevo gave me a

in a cafe in Berlin and vevo gave me a pen and a paper and he said draw your

pen and a paper and he said draw your

pen and a paper and he said draw your dream house it shouldn’t be bigger than

dream house it shouldn’t be bigger than

dream house it shouldn’t be bigger than 10 square meters very simple

10 square meters very simple

10 square meters very simple instructions I was like no no no I can’t

instructions I was like no no no I can’t

instructions I was like no no no I can’t I don’t know how to draw fluffin but he

I don’t know how to draw fluffin but he

I don’t know how to draw fluffin but he pushed me and pushed me and eventually I

pushed me and pushed me and eventually I

pushed me and pushed me and eventually I found out that my fear wasn’t about

found out that my fear wasn’t about

found out that my fear wasn’t about drawing a floor plan now I know how to

drawing a floor plan now I know how to

drawing a floor plan now I know how to do it it’s actually easy but at that

do it it’s actually easy but at that

do it it’s actually easy but at that time it was more about not being

time it was more about not being

time it was more about not being creative enough not knowing what I

creative enough not knowing what I

creative enough not knowing what I should have in this house not knowing

should have in this house not knowing

should have in this house not knowing how big or small things should be and I

how big or small things should be and I

how big or small things should be and I looked at all he’s telling the people

looked at all he’s telling the people

looked at all he’s telling the people around me having perfect solutions for

around me having perfect solutions for

around me having perfect solutions for their individual needs and let me

their individual needs and let me

their individual needs and let me overthink my own situation where it was

overthink my own situation where it was

overthink my own situation where it was usually very satisfied and you know

usually very satisfied and you know

usually very satisfied and you know contend with the circumstances I found

contend with the circumstances I found

contend with the circumstances I found in my old apartments and I kind of

in my old apartments and I kind of

in my old apartments and I kind of adapted to it but this time it was in my

adapted to it but this time it was in my

adapted to it but this time it was in my hands to create my personal very

hands to create my personal very

hands to create my personal very individualized living space for myself

individualized living space for myself

individualized living space for myself it’s not just a

it’s not just a

it’s not just a it’s a bathroom it’s a kitchen you know

it’s a bathroom it’s a kitchen you know

it’s a bathroom it’s a kitchen you know why I was only thinking of my own

why I was only thinking of my own

why I was only thinking of my own consumption in terms of stuff I buy I

consumption in terms of stuff I buy I

consumption in terms of stuff I buy I switch my focus to resources I consume

switch my focus to resources I consume

switch my focus to resources I consume every day and now I want to talk about

every day and now I want to talk about

every day and now I want to talk about something no one likes to talk about

something no one likes to talk about

something no one likes to talk about it’s actually about the product we

it’s actually about the product we

it’s actually about the product we humans produce after we eat I found this

humans produce after we eat I found this

humans produce after we eat I found this interesting University study where they

interesting University study where they

interesting University study where they calculated that the amount of feces a

calculated that the amount of feces a

calculated that the amount of feces a person produces each year is around 50

person produces each year is around 50

person produces each year is around 50 liters you can see in a brown bucket and

liters you can see in a brown bucket and

liters you can see in a brown bucket and the amount of urine a person produces

the amount of urine a person produces

the amount of urine a person produces each year is around 500 liters you can

each year is around 500 liters you can

each year is around 500 liters you can see in the green bucket and we use 6000

see in the green bucket and we use 6000

see in the green bucket and we use 6000 to 25,000 litres of fresh water to flush

to 25,000 litres of fresh water to flush

to 25,000 litres of fresh water to flush it away and that is in the same ways of

it away and that is in the same ways of

it away and that is in the same ways of resources because actually as soon as

resources because actually as soon as

resources because actually as soon as you separate the feces from the urine

you separate the feces from the urine

you separate the feces from the urine you can create fertilizers for

you can create fertilizers for

you can create fertilizers for agriculture various oils for plants as

agriculture various oils for plants as

agriculture various oils for plants as well as biogas but instead we produce

well as biogas but instead we produce

well as biogas but instead we produce grey water makes sense right so these

grey water makes sense right so these

grey water makes sense right so these are all things you kind of have to take

are all things you kind of have to take

are all things you kind of have to take into account when constructing your

into account when constructing your

into account when constructing your house you have to think about how do I

house you have to think about how do I

house you have to think about how do I want to design these systems what

want to design these systems what

want to design these systems what materials are we going to use how much

materials are we going to use how much

materials are we going to use how much energy or water do we need so I want to

energy or water do we need so I want to

energy or water do we need so I want to show you some of my early floor plans

show you some of my early floor plans

show you some of my early floor plans because one year later I found myself in

because one year later I found myself in

because one year later I found myself in a team where we were all inspired by the

a team where we were all inspired by the

a team where we were all inspired by the crater to create a philosophy it’s

crater to create a philosophy it’s

crater to create a philosophy it’s actually just about that every product

actually just about that every product

actually just about that every product we produce should have its own life

we produce should have its own life

we produce should have its own life cycle and if we put it out there we kind

cycle and if we put it out there we kind

cycle and if we put it out there we kind of have to see how can we get it back

of have to see how can we get it back

of have to see how can we get it back into that cycle and we were inspired by

into that cycle and we were inspired by

into that cycle and we were inspired by that philosophy and ending up building a

that philosophy and ending up building a

that philosophy and ending up building a house for people building the holy Foods

house for people building the holy Foods

house for people building the holy Foods house the holy food sales is a

house the holy food sales is a

house the holy food sales is a self-sufficient tiny home with a public

self-sufficient tiny home with a public

self-sufficient tiny home with a public food chain shelf affair Tyler it’s a

food chain shelf affair Tyler it’s a

food chain shelf affair Tyler it’s a community hub to share food because

community hub to share food because

community hub to share food because actually in Germany each year 50% of

actually in Germany each year 50% of

actually in Germany each year 50% of edible food gets thrown away due to

edible food gets thrown away due to

edible food gets thrown away due to aesthetic policies and marketing reasons

aesthetic policies and marketing reasons

aesthetic policies and marketing reasons and we wanted to bring awareness to

and we wanted to bring awareness to

and we wanted to bring awareness to these issues so on one side we created

these issues so on one side we created

these issues so on one side we created an organized weekly public dinners where

an organized weekly public dinners where

an organized weekly public dinners where we cooked with that food coming from

we cooked with that food coming from

we cooked with that food coming from supermarkets and bakeries and volunteers

supermarkets and bakeries and volunteers

supermarkets and bakeries and volunteers picking them up and bringing it to our

picking them up and bringing it to our

picking them up and bringing it to our little shelf outside and then on the

little shelf outside and then on the

little shelf outside and then on the other hand we created that house being a

other hand we created that house being a

other hand we created that house being a whole sustainable cycle a close one we

whole sustainable cycle a close one we

whole sustainable cycle a close one we we implemented systems like solar panels

we implemented systems like solar panels

we implemented systems like solar panels you can see on the outside and infrared

you can see on the outside and infrared

you can see on the outside and infrared heating and the shower loop system which

heating and the shower loop system which

heating and the shower loop system which uses 90 percent less water than a

uses 90 percent less water than a

uses 90 percent less water than a conventional shower and while

conventional shower and while

conventional shower and while experiencing how people can easily

experiencing how people can easily

experiencing how people can easily create their own living space within

create their own living space within

create their own living space within like three months I also learned a lot

like three months I also learned a lot

like three months I also learned a lot about how conventional houses are

about how conventional houses are

about how conventional houses are designed how we use materials that

designed how we use materials that

designed how we use materials that cannot be recycled that actually are

cannot be recycled that actually are

cannot be recycled that actually are unhealthy make us sick like carpets or

unhealthy make us sick like carpets or

unhealthy make us sick like carpets or other things and also I learned a lot

other things and also I learned a lot

other things and also I learned a lot about how neighborhoods and cities are

about how neighborhoods and cities are

about how neighborhoods and cities are designed and please don’t get me wrong I

designed and please don’t get me wrong I

designed and please don’t get me wrong I really love cities I mean I live in

really love cities I mean I live in

really love cities I mean I live in Berlin and I just love the vibrant

Berlin and I just love the vibrant

Berlin and I just love the vibrant lifestyle people coming to get a good

lifestyle people coming to get a good

lifestyle people coming to get a good food good parties great enthusiasm

food good parties great enthusiasm

food good parties great enthusiasm motivation especially in Berlin where

motivation especially in Berlin where

motivation especially in Berlin where all the startup seen us and still we

all the startup seen us and still we

all the startup seen us and still we have so many problems if you live in a

have so many problems if you live in a

have so many problems if you live in a city you can experience all of them are

city you can experience all of them are

city you can experience all of them are closed you see people living on the

closed you see people living on the

closed you see people living on the streets people living in apartments that

streets people living in apartments that

streets people living in apartments that almost fall apart people getting kicked

almost fall apart people getting kicked

almost fall apart people getting kicked out of their apartments because they

out of their apartments because they

out of their apartments because they can’t afford them anymore

can’t afford them anymore

can’t afford them anymore due to gentrification and other reasons

due to gentrification and other reasons

due to gentrification and other reasons friends searching for apartments for

friends searching for apartments for

friends searching for apartments for ages news shops every 100 meter with

ages news shops every 100 meter with

ages news shops every 100 meter with stuff we apparently need and

stuff we apparently need and

stuff we apparently need and neighborhoods that get totally wiped out

neighborhoods that get totally wiped out

neighborhoods that get totally wiped out to make space for new hotels and

to make space for new hotels and

to make space for new hotels and shopping centers and big properties

shopping centers and big properties

shopping centers and big properties being completely left alone in nice

being completely left alone in nice

being completely left alone in nice areas totally unused just because

areas totally unused just because

areas totally unused just because investors sit on them and it’s said I

investors sit on them and it’s said I

investors sit on them and it’s said I know it’s actually all these needs of of

know it’s actually all these needs of of

know it’s actually all these needs of of people and the challenges we are facing

people and the challenges we are facing

people and the challenges we are facing kind of scene that they don’t matter too

kind of scene that they don’t matter too

kind of scene that they don’t matter too much millenials nowadays pay up to 50%

much millenials nowadays pay up to 50%

much millenials nowadays pay up to 50% of the income for housing and it’s not

of the income for housing and it’s not

of the income for housing and it’s not about the city playing in politics is

about the city playing in politics is

about the city playing in politics is kind of not about creating affordable

kind of not about creating affordable

kind of not about creating affordable healthy beautiful space it’s not about a

healthy beautiful space it’s not about a

healthy beautiful space it’s not about a city that gets you makes you creative

city that gets you makes you creative

city that gets you makes you creative that you take over space and meet your

that you take over space and meet your

that you take over space and meet your neighbors the city planning and politics

neighbors the city planning and politics

neighbors the city planning and politics is pretty much in the hands of a few and

is pretty much in the hands of a few and

is pretty much in the hands of a few and small see about money and it kind of

small see about money and it kind of

small see about money and it kind of seems like there’s nothing we can do but

seems like there’s nothing we can do but

seems like there’s nothing we can do but I think the key is to come up with

I think the key is to come up with

I think the key is to come up with answers and solutions ourselves to be

answers and solutions ourselves to be

answers and solutions ourselves to be prepared as soon as we get the chance

prepared as soon as we get the chance

prepared as soon as we get the chance and someone asks us

and someone asks us

and someone asks us and we know how we want to live and what

and we know how we want to live and what

and we know how we want to live and what we need so the tiny-house university did

we need so the tiny-house university did

we need so the tiny-house university did some research on that because we believe

some research on that because we believe

some research on that because we believe that housing can be way more than the

that housing can be way more than the

that housing can be way more than the options we have at the moment and we

options we have at the moment and we

options we have at the moment and we wanted to challenge existing

wanted to challenge existing

wanted to challenge existing neighborhood concepts so we came up with

neighborhood concepts so we came up with

neighborhood concepts so we came up with our own actually the Bauhaus Museum

our own actually the Bauhaus Museum

our own actually the Bauhaus Museum Berlin gave up the space in front of the

Berlin gave up the space in front of the

Berlin gave up the space in front of the museum to create a new social

museum to create a new social

museum to create a new social neighborhood and we called the Bauhaus

neighborhood and we called the Bauhaus

neighborhood and we called the Bauhaus campus it’s an experiment ground for

campus it’s an experiment ground for

campus it’s an experiment ground for innovative social research and we wanted

innovative social research and we wanted

innovative social research and we wanted to challenge existing neighborhood

to challenge existing neighborhood

to challenge existing neighborhood concepts as I said and come up with new

concepts as I said and come up with new

concepts as I said and come up with new ideas our goal was to have these new

ideas our goal was to have these new

ideas our goal was to have these new concepts where our only tools were

concepts where our only tools were

concepts where our only tools were architecture and a simple belief that

architecture and a simple belief that

architecture and a simple belief that diversity makes a village stronger than

diversity makes a village stronger than

diversity makes a village stronger than common sense so far we’ve got 13 tiny

common sense so far we’ve got 13 tiny

common sense so far we’ve got 13 tiny houses on that ground and they all

houses on that ground and they all

houses on that ground and they all address different problems within

address different problems within

address different problems within societies and cities and we fought it’s

societies and cities and we fought it’s

societies and cities and we fought it’s the easiest to do it in a small space

the easiest to do it in a small space

the easiest to do it in a small space because actually a tiny house gives you

because actually a tiny house gives you

because actually a tiny house gives you the opportunity to take your personal

the opportunity to take your personal

the opportunity to take your personal interest into account like to create to

interest into account like to create to

interest into account like to create to create a philosophy and no the tiny

create a philosophy and no the tiny

create a philosophy and no the tiny houses are still not perfect but what

houses are still not perfect but what

houses are still not perfect but what the tiniest university really taught me

the tiniest university really taught me

the tiniest university really taught me was that we the people can actually

was that we the people can actually

was that we the people can actually change the city and can actually change

change the city and can actually change

change the city and can actually change how we want to interact and how we want

how we want to interact and how we want

how we want to interact and how we want to you know see our neighbors and

to you know see our neighbors and

to you know see our neighbors and interact with our neighbors and also

interact with our neighbors and also

interact with our neighbors and also that cities are going to change so for

that cities are going to change so for

that cities are going to change so for example we invented the 100 year

example we invented the 100 year

example we invented the 100 year apartment which is an model of an

apartment which is an model of an

apartment which is an model of an affordable apartment in a big house with

affordable apartment in a big house with

affordable apartment in a big house with a lot of community area and shared space

a lot of community area and shared space

a lot of community area and shared space the cafe Glyndon come invented a new

the cafe Glyndon come invented a new

the cafe Glyndon come invented a new stable digital currency based on

stable digital currency based on

stable digital currency based on blockchain technology and paired with

blockchain technology and paired with

blockchain technology and paired with the universal basic income and we’re

the universal basic income and we’re

the universal basic income and we’re testing that right now on the campus we

testing that right now on the campus we

testing that right now on the campus we invented tiny town houses and they can

invented tiny town houses and they can

invented tiny town houses and they can be placed next to each other like in a

be placed next to each other like in a

be placed next to each other like in a street or once it can be stacked on top

street or once it can be stacked on top

street or once it can be stacked on top of each other and we also working on

of each other and we also working on

of each other and we also working on other concepts of new urban housing a

other concepts of new urban housing a

other concepts of new urban housing a startup found a potential of a new space

startup found a potential of a new space

startup found a potential of a new space on top of the city Berlin alone has

on top of the city Berlin alone has

on top of the city Berlin alone has space for 55,000 apartments on top of

space for 55,000 apartments on top of

space for 55,000 apartments on top of its roofs and Kevin Spacey wants to

its roofs and Kevin Spacey wants to

its roofs and Kevin Spacey wants to conquer these roofs and put small

conquer these roofs and put small

conquer these roofs and put small sustainable smart cabins on top of them

sustainable smart cabins on top of them

sustainable smart cabins on top of them to create new living space that is

to create new living space that is

to create new living space that is flexible and

flexible and

flexible and easily accessible for technology and we

easily accessible for technology and we

easily accessible for technology and we got a lot of press for these projects

got a lot of press for these projects

got a lot of press for these projects journalists asking me so it’s just a

journalists asking me so it’s just a

journalists asking me so it’s just a solution for everyone I was like thank

solution for everyone I was like thank

solution for everyone I was like thank you so much I feel so honored did you

you so much I feel so honored did you

you so much I feel so honored did you think I just found a solution for four

think I just found a solution for four

think I just found a solution for four billion people but no actually I don’t

billion people but no actually I don’t

billion people but no actually I don’t think there’s a one-size-fits-all

think there’s a one-size-fits-all

think there’s a one-size-fits-all I think people will still have different

I think people will still have different

I think people will still have different needs and interests and you know society

needs and interests and you know society

needs and interests and you know society puts all these thinking patterns on us

puts all these thinking patterns on us

puts all these thinking patterns on us why should we even think in square

why should we even think in square

why should we even think in square meters is this really important to us

meters is this really important to us

meters is this really important to us why don’t we calculate the price per

why don’t we calculate the price per

why don’t we calculate the price per light stream or air flow but actually I

light stream or air flow but actually I

light stream or air flow but actually I think there’s just one big question

think there’s just one big question

think there’s just one big question which is how do we want to live in the

which is how do we want to live in the

which is how do we want to live in the future

future

future and I want to leave this question with

and I want to leave this question with

and I want to leave this question with you as an inspiration because also up to

you as an inspiration because also up to

you as an inspiration because also up to you if you want to change the picture of

you if you want to change the picture of

you if you want to change the picture of the city we have to start doing it

the city we have to start doing it

the city we have to start doing it starting with us because cities or what

starting with us because cities or what

starting with us because cities or what we make out of them thank you

we make out of them thank you

we make out of them thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *