Press "Enter" to skip to content

Fiction in a Dangerous Age | Omar El Akkad | TEDxSonomaCounty


in the summer of 2014 I started writing

in the summer of 2014 I started writing what would would become my debut novel a

what would would become my debut novel a

what would would become my debut novel a book called American War American War is

book called American War American War is

book called American War American War is the story of essentially a second

the story of essentially a second

the story of essentially a second American Civil War takes place a few

American Civil War takes place a few

American Civil War takes place a few decades from now the America of that

decades from now the America of that

decades from now the America of that future world is a very different place

future world is a very different place

future world is a very different place it’s rising sea levels have wiped out

it’s rising sea levels have wiped out

it’s rising sea levels have wiped out the eastern seaboard

the eastern seaboard

the eastern seaboard Florida’s gone the capital has been

Florida’s gone the capital has been

Florida’s gone the capital has been moved inland from Washington DC to

moved inland from Washington DC to

moved inland from Washington DC to Columbus Ohio and long after would do

Columbus Ohio and long after would do

Columbus Ohio and long after would do any good at all the federal government

any good at all the federal government

any good at all the federal government decides to impose a prohibition on

decides to impose a prohibition on

decides to impose a prohibition on fossil fuels as a way to to combat all

fossil fuels as a way to to combat all

fossil fuels as a way to to combat all of this by this point in time pretty

of this by this point in time pretty

of this by this point in time pretty well all the world has moved on to other

well all the world has moved on to other

well all the world has moved on to other sources of a fuel nonetheless a number

sources of a fuel nonetheless a number

sources of a fuel nonetheless a number of southern states decide that they

of southern states decide that they

of southern states decide that they would rather secede than go along with

would rather secede than go along with

would rather secede than go along with this what follows is a second civil war

this what follows is a second civil war

this what follows is a second civil war the kinetic part of which is over very

the kinetic part of which is over very

the kinetic part of which is over very quickly the South loses again and what

quickly the South loses again and what

quickly the South loses again and what follows that as a sort of years long

follows that as a sort of years long

follows that as a sort of years long insurgency I’ve been on the road now for

insurgency I’ve been on the road now for

insurgency I’ve been on the road now for six months promoting the book and the

six months promoting the book and the

six months promoting the book and the question I get excuse me the question I

question I get excuse me the question I

question I get excuse me the question I get more often than any is why did you

get more often than any is why did you

get more often than any is why did you decide to write this and the closest

decide to write this and the closest

decide to write this and the closest thing I can think of in terms of a

thing I can think of in terms of a

thing I can think of in terms of a Genesis moment is a vague recollection I

Genesis moment is a vague recollection I

Genesis moment is a vague recollection I have from many many years ago now of

have from many many years ago now of

have from many many years ago now of watching an interview with a foreign

watching an interview with a foreign

watching an interview with a foreign affairs expert one of these talking

affairs expert one of these talking

affairs expert one of these talking heads that they periodically bring in to

heads that they periodically bring in to

heads that they periodically bring in to to explain the world and the interview

to explain the world and the interview

to explain the world and the interview is taking place in the immediate

is taking place in the immediate

is taking place in the immediate aftermath of a set of protests that had

aftermath of a set of protests that had

aftermath of a set of protests that had happened in Afghanistan local villagers

happened in Afghanistan local villagers

happened in Afghanistan local villagers were protesting against the US military

were protesting against the US military

were protesting against the US military presence there and the question that was

presence there and the question that was

presence there and the question that was put to this gentleman was something

put to this gentleman was something

put to this gentleman was something along the lines of why do they hate us

along the lines of why do they hate us

along the lines of why do they hate us and as part of his answer he noted that

and as part of his answer he noted that

and as part of his answer he noted that sometimes the Special Forces have to go

sometimes the Special Forces have to go

sometimes the Special Forces have to go into these villages and conduct

into these villages and conduct

into these villages and conduct nighttime raids looking for insurgents

nighttime raids looking for insurgents

nighttime raids looking for insurgents and when they do this they will often

and when they do this they will often

and when they do this they will often ransack the houses or hold the women and

ransack the houses or hold the women and

ransack the houses or hold the women and children at gunpoint and then he

children at gunpoint and then he

children at gunpoint and then he helpfully added and you know in Afghan

helpfully added and you know in Afghan

helpfully added and you know in Afghan culture that sort of thing is considered

culture that sort of thing is considered

culture that sort of thing is considered very offensive

very offensive

very offensive I remember thinking you name me one

I remember thinking you name me one

I remember thinking you name me one culture on earth I would not consider

culture on earth I would not consider

culture on earth I would not consider this sort of thing offensive and that’s

this sort of thing offensive and that’s

this sort of thing offensive and that’s when I first started thinking about this

when I first started thinking about this

when I first started thinking about this idea of taking the conflicts that have

idea of taking the conflicts that have

idea of taking the conflicts that have defined the world in my lifetime and

defined the world in my lifetime and

defined the world in my lifetime and effectively these are conflicts in which

effectively these are conflicts in which

effectively these are conflicts in which US involvement has been from a great

US involvement has been from a great

US involvement has been from a great distance and recasting them as elements

distance and recasting them as elements

distance and recasting them as elements of something close to home and I

of something close to home and I

of something close to home and I couldn’t think of anything more close to

couldn’t think of anything more close to

couldn’t think of anything more close to home than a second civil civil war the

home than a second civil civil war the

home than a second civil civil war the point of this being to explore the idea

point of this being to explore the idea

point of this being to explore the idea that there is no such thing as a foreign

that there is no such thing as a foreign

that there is no such thing as a foreign kind of suffering that we all react in

kind of suffering that we all react in

kind of suffering that we all react in justice the same way some of us just

justice the same way some of us just

justice the same way some of us just have the privilege to believe otherwise

have the privilege to believe otherwise

have the privilege to believe otherwise I started writing the book in the summer

I started writing the book in the summer

I started writing the book in the summer of 2014 I finished the first draft

of 2014 I finished the first draft

of 2014 I finished the first draft almost exactly a year later two or three

almost exactly a year later two or three

almost exactly a year later two or three weeks after that Donald Trump announced

weeks after that Donald Trump announced

weeks after that Donald Trump announced he was running for president the book

he was running for president the book

he was running for president the book came out in April and ever since then

came out in April and ever since then

came out in April and ever since then it’s been seen in a very different

it’s been seen in a very different

it’s been seen in a very different context than what I intended this book I

context than what I intended this book I

context than what I intended this book I intended as being a sort of allegory or

intended as being a sort of allegory or

intended as being a sort of allegory or analogous novel has instead been seen as

analogous novel has instead been seen as

analogous novel has instead been seen as a kind of road map you know this is what

a kind of road map you know this is what

a kind of road map you know this is what could happen which is strange to me

could happen which is strange to me

could happen which is strange to me because almost everything in the book is

because almost everything in the book is

because almost everything in the book is based on something that did happen it

based on something that did happen it

based on something that did happen it just happened to somebody very far away

just happened to somebody very far away

just happened to somebody very far away and so what I’d like to do is tell you a

and so what I’d like to do is tell you a

and so what I’d like to do is tell you a little bit about some of the experiences

little bit about some of the experiences

little bit about some of the experiences I had as a journalist over the last 10

I had as a journalist over the last 10

I had as a journalist over the last 10 years that contributed to to the novel

years that contributed to to the novel

years that contributed to to the novel these are experiences from places like

these are experiences from places like

these are experiences from places like Afghanistan and Guantanamo Bay where I

Afghanistan and Guantanamo Bay where I

Afghanistan and Guantanamo Bay where I went to cover the war on terror

went to cover the war on terror

went to cover the war on terror and I’m not sharing these experiences

and I’m not sharing these experiences

and I’m not sharing these experiences with you because they constitute a

with you because they constitute a

with you because they constitute a holistic understanding of the entire

holistic understanding of the entire

holistic understanding of the entire conflict

conflict

conflict but rather because I think they

but rather because I think they

but rather because I think they represent snapshots of the reality of

represent snapshots of the reality of

represent snapshots of the reality of the last decade and a half and to live

the last decade and a half and to live

the last decade and a half and to live in the United States in 2017 often to me

in the United States in 2017 often to me

in the United States in 2017 often to me feels like living in a country that’s at

feels like living in a country that’s at

feels like living in a country that’s at constant war with reality I was 25 years

constant war with reality I was 25 years

constant war with reality I was 25 years old when I got my first assignment to

old when I got my first assignment to

old when I got my first assignment to Afghanistan at the time I was working

Afghanistan at the time I was working

Afghanistan at the time I was working for a Canadian newspaper and the

for a Canadian newspaper and the

for a Canadian newspaper and the Canadian presence was was heavy in the

Canadian presence was was heavy in the

Canadian presence was was heavy in the South of Afghanistan

South of Afghanistan

South of Afghanistan so I ended up spending quite a bit of

so I ended up spending quite a bit of

so I ended up spending quite a bit of time in the NATO Airfield in Kandahar

time in the NATO Airfield in Kandahar

time in the NATO Airfield in Kandahar which is this sprawling mass of tents

which is this sprawling mass of tents

which is this sprawling mass of tents and repurposed shipping containers and a

and repurposed shipping containers and a

and repurposed shipping containers and a lot of the scenery in my in my novel is

lot of the scenery in my in my novel is

lot of the scenery in my in my novel is based on that kind of infrastructure

based on that kind of infrastructure

based on that kind of infrastructure when I first showed up I was young I had

when I first showed up I was young I had

when I first showed up I was young I had read far too much Hemingway and I had a

read far too much Hemingway and I had a

read far too much Hemingway and I had a very romanticized vision of the

very romanticized vision of the

very romanticized vision of the swashbuckling a foreign reporter who you

swashbuckling a foreign reporter who you

swashbuckling a foreign reporter who you know dodges the bullets and and all of

know dodges the bullets and and all of

know dodges the bullets and and all of that nonsense which turned out to be

that nonsense which turned out to be

that nonsense which turned out to be complete garbage none of that is true

complete garbage none of that is true

complete garbage none of that is true the very first experience I had in

the very first experience I had in

the very first experience I had in Afghanistan that stuck with me and

Afghanistan that stuck with me and

Afghanistan that stuck with me and actually formed the basis for a couple

actually formed the basis for a couple

actually formed the basis for a couple of scenes in in the novel had to do with

of scenes in in the novel had to do with

of scenes in in the novel had to do with an assignment I had walking around with

an assignment I had walking around with

an assignment I had walking around with a polio vaccination team I was working

a polio vaccination team I was working

a polio vaccination team I was working on the outskirts of the city being on

on the outskirts of the city being on

on the outskirts of the city being on the losing end of a war is akin to

the losing end of a war is akin to

the losing end of a war is akin to moving backwards in time diseases that

moving backwards in time diseases that

moving backwards in time diseases that might otherwise have been eradicated

might otherwise have been eradicated

might otherwise have been eradicated suddenly come back to life and so this

suddenly come back to life and so this

suddenly come back to life and so this was my first trip outside of Kandahar

was my first trip outside of Kandahar

was my first trip outside of Kandahar Airfield I’d arrived a few days earlier

Airfield I’d arrived a few days earlier

Airfield I’d arrived a few days earlier to get out of Kandahar Airfield you have

to get out of Kandahar Airfield you have

to get out of Kandahar Airfield you have to leave the inner wire and then the

to leave the inner wire and then the

to leave the inner wire and then the outer wire the inner wire is a cordoned

outer wire the inner wire is a cordoned

outer wire the inner wire is a cordoned off area surrounding the base proper and

off area surrounding the base proper and

off area surrounding the base proper and it’s guarded by NATO troops the outer

it’s guarded by NATO troops the outer

it’s guarded by NATO troops the outer wire is right by the highway and it’s

wire is right by the highway and it’s

wire is right by the highway and it’s guarded by Afghan soldiers the NATO

guarded by Afghan soldiers the NATO

guarded by Afghan soldiers the NATO troops have state-of-the-art equipment

troops have state-of-the-art equipment

troops have state-of-the-art equipment the Afghan soldiers have flimsy

the Afghan soldiers have flimsy

the Afghan soldiers have flimsy hand-me-downs but if ever there’s an

hand-me-downs but if ever there’s an

hand-me-downs but if ever there’s an attack 90% of the time it’s going to

attack 90% of the time it’s going to

attack 90% of the time it’s going to happen at the outer wire and it was my

happen at the outer wire and it was my

happen at the outer wire and it was my first experience of this sort of

first experience of this sort of

first experience of this sort of hierarchy that exists in many many

hierarchy that exists in many many

hierarchy that exists in many many systems but in in wartime was

systems but in in wartime was

systems but in in wartime was particularly enlightening

particularly enlightening

particularly enlightening which is the sense that yeah we’re all

which is the sense that yeah we’re all

which is the sense that yeah we’re all on the same team but some lives are more

on the same team but some lives are more

on the same team but some lives are more dispensable than others there were of

dispensable than others there were of

dispensable than others there were of course the the sort of the the kinetic

course the the sort of the the kinetic

course the the sort of the the kinetic experiences experiences of being hit by

experiences experiences of being hit by

experiences experiences of being hit by RPGs or that sort of the violence that’s

RPGs or that sort of the violence that’s

RPGs or that sort of the violence that’s associated with covering warfare and

associated with covering warfare and

associated with covering warfare and that I thought would make up the bulk of

that I thought would make up the bulk of

that I thought would make up the bulk of my experiences most of it happened in

my experiences most of it happened in

my experiences most of it happened in places called forward operating bases or

places called forward operating bases or

places called forward operating bases or fobs unlike Kandahar Airfield which is

fobs unlike Kandahar Airfield which is

fobs unlike Kandahar Airfield which is this massive small City and of itself

this massive small City and of itself

this massive small City and of itself these tend to be very very small and in

these tend to be very very small and in

these tend to be very very small and in very remote locations which means that

very remote locations which means that

very remote locations which means that they get attacked much more often at

they get attacked much more often at

they get attacked much more often at this particular fob we had shown up that

this particular fob we had shown up that

this particular fob we had shown up that night we were walking back from the mess

night we were walking back from the mess

night we were walking back from the mess hall pitch-black we hear whistling in

hall pitch-black we hear whistling in

hall pitch-black we hear whistling in the air and months earlier for insurance

the air and months earlier for insurance

the air and months earlier for insurance reasons my newspaper had sent me to war

reasons my newspaper had sent me to war

reasons my newspaper had sent me to war correspondent training which basically

correspondent training which basically

correspondent training which basically boils down to if you hear a whistling

boils down to if you hear a whistling

boils down to if you hear a whistling sound drop to the ground so of course

sound drop to the ground so of course

sound drop to the ground so of course that’s what we do we drop to the ground

that’s what we do we drop to the ground

that’s what we do we drop to the ground and what followed was a process of

and what followed was a process of

and what followed was a process of entirely dumb luck even the person

entirely dumb luck even the person

entirely dumb luck even the person firing this RPG has no idea where it’s

firing this RPG has no idea where it’s

firing this RPG has no idea where it’s gonna land it happened to land over

gonna land it happened to land over

gonna land it happened to land over there instead of over here and that’s

there instead of over here and that’s

there instead of over here and that’s why we were safe and for a while I

why we were safe and for a while I

why we were safe and for a while I thought this would be the kind of

thought this would be the kind of

thought this would be the kind of experience that’s stuck with me

experience that’s stuck with me

experience that’s stuck with me afterwards but that didn’t turn out to

afterwards but that didn’t turn out to

afterwards but that didn’t turn out to be the case this is a ramp ceremony in

be the case this is a ramp ceremony in

be the case this is a ramp ceremony in this particular case it was for two

this particular case it was for two

this particular case it was for two Canadian soldiers who had died when they

Canadian soldiers who had died when they

Canadian soldiers who had died when they stepped on an IAD while on patrol

stepped on an IAD while on patrol

stepped on an IAD while on patrol customarily when there is a ramp

customarily when there is a ramp

customarily when there is a ramp ceremony at Kandahar Airfield soldiers

ceremony at Kandahar Airfield soldiers

ceremony at Kandahar Airfield soldiers political representatives from the other

political representatives from the other

political representatives from the other NATO countries will come and pay their

NATO countries will come and pay their

NATO countries will come and pay their respects and so what you’re seeing here

respects and so what you’re seeing here

respects and so what you’re seeing here is a very small sliver of the number of

is a very small sliver of the number of

is a very small sliver of the number of people who showed up that day the

people who showed up that day the

people who showed up that day the reporters on that day were stationed

reporters on that day were stationed

reporters on that day were stationed right next to the ramp

right next to the ramp

right next to the ramp we saw the caskets go up into the plane

we saw the caskets go up into the plane

we saw the caskets go up into the plane and for very obvious physical and

and for very obvious physical and

and for very obvious physical and emotional reasons the people carrying

emotional reasons the people carrying

emotional reasons the people carrying these caskets look to be an obvious

these caskets look to be an obvious

these caskets look to be an obvious distress and at the time I thought I

distress and at the time I thought I

distress and at the time I thought I understood why I thought I understood

understood why I thought I understood

understood why I thought I understood all of the reasons why but there was one

all of the reasons why but there was one

all of the reasons why but there was one one detail that I only found out when

one detail that I only found out when

one detail that I only found out when talking to an officer later on but I

talking to an officer later on but I

talking to an officer later on but I hadn’t realized before and it has to do

hadn’t realized before and it has to do

hadn’t realized before and it has to do with that casket

with that casket

with that casket which is much much heavier than it would

which is much much heavier than it would

which is much much heavier than it would otherwise be this was a very hot day it

otherwise be this was a very hot day it

otherwise be this was a very hot day it was 100-plus degrees a couple of people

was 100-plus degrees a couple of people

was 100-plus degrees a couple of people had fainted while standing and the ramp

had fainted while standing and the ramp

had fainted while standing and the ramp ceremony and that casket in order to

ceremony and that casket in order to

ceremony and that casket in order to preserve the body for the long journey

preserve the body for the long journey

preserve the body for the long journey home is also filled with pounds and

home is also filled with pounds and

home is also filled with pounds and pounds of ice it’s been almost exactly

pounds of ice it’s been almost exactly

pounds of ice it’s been almost exactly 10 years to the day I took that photo I

10 years to the day I took that photo I

10 years to the day I took that photo I don’t remember much about the caliber of

don’t remember much about the caliber of

don’t remember much about the caliber of the bullets which regiment was based

the bullets which regiment was based

the bullets which regiment was based where all of that stuff escapes me but I

where all of that stuff escapes me but I

where all of that stuff escapes me but I will never forget the detail about the

will never forget the detail about the

will never forget the detail about the ice in the casket a year after my first

ice in the casket a year after my first

ice in the casket a year after my first Afghan assignment I was offered the

Afghan assignment I was offered the

Afghan assignment I was offered the chance to go to a very different outpost

chance to go to a very different outpost

chance to go to a very different outpost in the war on terror the Guantanamo Bay

in the war on terror the Guantanamo Bay

in the war on terror the Guantanamo Bay detention camps are obviously very

detention camps are obviously very

detention camps are obviously very infamous but they also represent the

infamous but they also represent the

infamous but they also represent the only place I have ever been during my

only place I have ever been during my

only place I have ever been during my journalistic career that can truly be

journalistic career that can truly be

journalistic career that can truly be described as calf cask

every single reporter in the history of

every single reporter in the history of Guantanamo Bay has gone to take a

Guantanamo Bay has gone to take a

Guantanamo Bay has gone to take a picture of this sign the thing to know

picture of this sign the thing to know

picture of this sign the thing to know about gonna move a is it was built very

about gonna move a is it was built very

about gonna move a is it was built very very quickly not just the detention

very quickly not just the detention

very quickly not just the detention camps themselves but the entire legal

camps themselves but the entire legal

camps themselves but the entire legal and bureaucratic system around them were

and bureaucratic system around them were

and bureaucratic system around them were built in a hurry and you can see this in

built in a hurry and you can see this in

built in a hurry and you can see this in almost every aspect of this place

almost every aspect of this place

almost every aspect of this place especially in the language so my first

especially in the language so my first

especially in the language so my first my first trip there I was asking one of

my first trip there I was asking one of

my first trip there I was asking one of the soldiers a question and I made the

the soldiers a question and I made the

the soldiers a question and I made the mistake of referring to the people who

mistake of referring to the people who

mistake of referring to the people who are kept in this place as prisoners and

are kept in this place as prisoners and

are kept in this place as prisoners and immediately I was corrected we don’t

immediately I was corrected we don’t

immediately I was corrected we don’t have prisoners here sir we have

have prisoners here sir we have

have prisoners here sir we have detainees and there’s a very real reason

detainees and there’s a very real reason

detainees and there’s a very real reason for this prisoner implies a prison

for this prisoner implies a prison

for this prisoner implies a prison sentence which is a finite thing

sentence which is a finite thing

sentence which is a finite thing detainees especially so-called enemy

detainees especially so-called enemy

detainees especially so-called enemy combatants can be held indefinitely when

combatants can be held indefinitely when

combatants can be held indefinitely when I went there and I suspect this is still

I went there and I suspect this is still

I went there and I suspect this is still the case today most of the prisoners

the case today most of the prisoners

the case today most of the prisoners were kept in three camps excuse me camp

were kept in three camps excuse me camp

were kept in three camps excuse me camp 4 camp 5 camp 6 camp 4 was modeled after

4 camp 5 camp 6 camp 4 was modeled after

4 camp 5 camp 6 camp 4 was modeled after a medium-security facility which meant

a medium-security facility which meant

a medium-security facility which meant that for lack of a better word the

that for lack of a better word the

that for lack of a better word the prisoners had lots of perks that the

prisoners had lots of perks that the

prisoners had lots of perks that the others in camp 5 and 6 would not

others in camp 5 and 6 would not

others in camp 5 and 6 would not these include communal living you get to

these include communal living you get to

these include communal living you get to spend time with other people you get to

spend time with other people you get to

spend time with other people you get to do your own laundry you get what are

do your own laundry you get what are

do your own laundry you get what are called comfort items which include

called comfort items which include

called comfort items which include things like prayer beads pens that are

things like prayer beads pens that are

things like prayer beads pens that are specially designed so that you can’t use

specially designed so that you can’t use

specially designed so that you can’t use them to stab someone

them to stab someone

them to stab someone i shade x’ because the lights never go

i shade x’ because the lights never go

i shade x’ because the lights never go off in camp for toiletries that come in

off in camp for toiletries that come in

off in camp for toiletries that come in these little condiment packets that look

these little condiment packets that look

these little condiment packets that look like McDonald’s ketchup packets these

like McDonald’s ketchup packets these

like McDonald’s ketchup packets these are the perks of living in camp 4 in

are the perks of living in camp 4 in

are the perks of living in camp 4 in addition to that out in the rec yard

addition to that out in the rec yard

addition to that out in the rec yard there was this sort of bulletin board

there was this sort of bulletin board

there was this sort of bulletin board where the soldiers would sometimes place

where the soldiers would sometimes place

where the soldiers would sometimes place heavily vetted copies of news articles

heavily vetted copies of news articles

heavily vetted copies of news articles from the BBC and other sources and for

from the BBC and other sources and for

from the BBC and other sources and for reasons I still don’t quite understand a

reasons I still don’t quite understand a

reasons I still don’t quite understand a copy of the Geneva Conventions this is

copy of the Geneva Conventions this is

copy of the Geneva Conventions this is camp 5 camp 5 and camp 6 our Supermax

camp 5 camp 5 and camp 6 our Supermax

camp 5 camp 5 and camp 6 our Supermax facilities where the

facilities where the

facilities where the on compliant prisoners are kept this

on compliant prisoners are kept this

on compliant prisoners are kept this means that for the vast majority of them

means that for the vast majority of them

means that for the vast majority of them it is 23 hours or more a day of

it is 23 hours or more a day of

it is 23 hours or more a day of isolation in a Cell not much bigger than

isolation in a Cell not much bigger than

isolation in a Cell not much bigger than this red circle I’m standing in when you

this red circle I’m standing in when you

this red circle I’m standing in when you do get to go outside you are in a rec

do get to go outside you are in a rec

do get to go outside you are in a rec yard that’s fenced in you are alone and

yard that’s fenced in you are alone and

yard that’s fenced in you are alone and you’re monitored the whole time

you’re monitored the whole time

you’re monitored the whole time camps five and six also happened to be

camps five and six also happened to be

camps five and six also happened to be the places where the the government kept

the places where the the government kept

the places where the the government kept the prisoners who are effectively too

the prisoners who are effectively too

the prisoners who are effectively too innocent to charge and too guilty to let

innocent to charge and too guilty to let

innocent to charge and too guilty to let go which constitute the bulk of the

go which constitute the bulk of the

go which constitute the bulk of the remaining prisoners in Guantanamo Bay

remaining prisoners in Guantanamo Bay

remaining prisoners in Guantanamo Bay Carole Rosenberg who’s a reporter for

Carole Rosenberg who’s a reporter for

Carole Rosenberg who’s a reporter for the Miami Herald and who knows this

the Miami Herald and who knows this

the Miami Herald and who knows this place better than anyone else on earth

place better than anyone else on earth

place better than anyone else on earth has referred to these people as forever

has referred to these people as forever

has referred to these people as forever prisoners and that’s what this place is

prisoners and that’s what this place is

prisoners and that’s what this place is and that’s what a lot of places in this

and that’s what a lot of places in this

and that’s what a lot of places in this age of the war on terror are this is a

age of the war on terror are this is a

age of the war on terror are this is a place that neither exists on US soil nor

place that neither exists on US soil nor

place that neither exists on US soil nor outside US soil it’s not subject to US

outside US soil it’s not subject to US

outside US soil it’s not subject to US law nor is it not subject to US law it’s

law nor is it not subject to US law it’s

law nor is it not subject to US law it’s a forever place and it seems in many

a forever place and it seems in many

a forever place and it seems in many ways sort of violently immune to the

ways sort of violently immune to the

ways sort of violently immune to the passage of time and that’s why I spend a

passage of time and that’s why I spend a

passage of time and that’s why I spend a lot of time talking about about these

lot of time talking about about these

lot of time talking about about these places you know I moved to the US a few

places you know I moved to the US a few

places you know I moved to the US a few years ago I live here now my daughter

years ago I live here now my daughter

years ago I live here now my daughter was born here I’m invested in this place

was born here I’m invested in this place

was born here I’m invested in this place and I think that living in America today

and I think that living in America today

and I think that living in America today in in in a time when almost daily there

in in in a time when almost daily there

in in in a time when almost daily there seems to be some new outrage some new

seems to be some new outrage some new

seems to be some new outrage some new unbelievable thing happening this era

unbelievable thing happening this era

unbelievable thing happening this era and what happened during this era is

and what happened during this era is

and what happened during this era is going to be very easy to forget it is

going to be very easy to forget it is

going to be very easy to forget it is astounding to me today to see someone

astounding to me today to see someone

astounding to me today to see someone like george w bush referred to as a

like george w bush referred to as a

like george w bush referred to as a promising amateur artist and a newfound

promising amateur artist and a newfound

promising amateur artist and a newfound member of the resistance as opposed to

member of the resistance as opposed to

member of the resistance as opposed to somebody who started an unnecessary war

somebody who started an unnecessary war

somebody who started an unnecessary war that killed half a million people that

that killed half a million people that

that killed half a million people that is bizarre to me because i think

is bizarre to me because i think

is bizarre to me because i think forgetting is a form of violence it’s

forgetting is a form of violence it’s

forgetting is a form of violence it’s it’s a violence against reality and any

it’s a violence against reality and any

it’s a violence against reality and any place that commits violence against

place that commits violence against

place that commits violence against reality

reality

reality inevitably commits violence against

inevitably commits violence against

inevitably commits violence against itself thank you so much

itself thank you so much

itself thank you so much [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *