Press "Enter" to skip to content

If Darwin had been a woman | Inge Schröder | TEDxKielUniversity


if someone asks me Inga what is your

if someone asks me Inga what is your profession

profession

profession I find it very difficult to answer

I find it very difficult to answer

I find it very difficult to answer because I’ve done so many different jobs

because I’ve done so many different jobs

because I’ve done so many different jobs you know I was a project manager a

you know I was a project manager a

you know I was a project manager a product manager a researcher an R&D

product manager a researcher an R&D

product manager a researcher an R&D coordinator co-founder of open campus

coordinator co-founder of open campus

coordinator co-founder of open campus and managing director of a company and

and managing director of a company and

and managing director of a company and all these tasks these jobs were

all these tasks these jobs were

all these tasks these jobs were intriguing demanding and fulfilling at

intriguing demanding and fulfilling at

intriguing demanding and fulfilling at the same time and provided new insights

the same time and provided new insights

the same time and provided new insights and tremendous knowledge that

and tremendous knowledge that

and tremendous knowledge that accompanied all my life today I want to

accompanied all my life today I want to

accompanied all my life today I want to go back into my time as a researcher and

go back into my time as a researcher and

go back into my time as a researcher and share one important process of

share one important process of

share one important process of understanding with you back in the 1990s

understanding with you back in the 1990s

understanding with you back in the 1990s I was a junior professor of anthropology

I was a junior professor of anthropology

I was a junior professor of anthropology and I studied human evolution and it had

and I studied human evolution and it had

and I studied human evolution and it had occurred to me that the natural history

occurred to me that the natural history

occurred to me that the natural history of humans has mostly been reconstructed

of humans has mostly been reconstructed

of humans has mostly been reconstructed as a natural history of men women didn’t

as a natural history of men women didn’t

as a natural history of men women didn’t come into it very much and I had just

come into it very much and I had just

come into it very much and I had just started to develop some ideas to solve

started to develop some ideas to solve

started to develop some ideas to solve the problem when a colleague from

the problem when a colleague from

the problem when a colleague from Austria called and asked me to give a

Austria called and asked me to give a

Austria called and asked me to give a lecture at a summer school what is the

lecture at a summer school what is the

lecture at a summer school what is the general theme I asked beautiful new

general theme I asked beautiful new

general theme I asked beautiful new woman’s world he said with the question

woman’s world he said with the question

woman’s world he said with the question mark oh that sounds interesting and what

mark oh that sounds interesting and what

mark oh that sounds interesting and what topic you want me to talk about I

topic you want me to talk about I

topic you want me to talk about I thought of if Darwin had been a woman

thought of if Darwin had been a woman

thought of if Darwin had been a woman Matt sounded interesting and I

Matt sounded interesting and I

Matt sounded interesting and I spontaneously agreed but you know at

spontaneously agreed but you know at

spontaneously agreed but you know at that time I had not the slightest idea

that time I had not the slightest idea

that time I had not the slightest idea that this task would turn out to be one

that this task would turn out to be one

that this task would turn out to be one of the most interesting and precious

of the most interesting and precious

of the most interesting and precious processes of understanding for me to be

processes of understanding for me to be

processes of understanding for me to be honest at first I had no clue how to

honest at first I had no clue how to

honest at first I had no clue how to tackle the topic I consulted Darwin’s

tackle the topic I consulted Darwin’s

tackle the topic I consulted Darwin’s biography start simple I thought and

biography start simple I thought and

biography start simple I thought and then I decided to literally change

then I decided to literally change

then I decided to literally change Darwin’s gender identity so what the

Darwin’s gender identity so what the

Darwin’s gender identity so what the crucial events in child TV be compatible

crucial events in child TV be compatible

crucial events in child TV be compatible with the life of my fictitious Charlotte

with the life of my fictitious Charlotte

with the life of my fictitious Charlotte child studied in Edinburgh and Cambridge

child studied in Edinburgh and Cambridge

child studied in Edinburgh and Cambridge between 1825 and 1831 and Charlotte no

between 1825 and 1831 and Charlotte no

between 1825 and 1831 and Charlotte no women were not admitted to universities

women were not admitted to universities

women were not admitted to universities in those days chards graduated in 1831

in those days chards graduated in 1831

in those days chards graduated in 1831 in Cambridge and Charlotte again no for

in Cambridge and Charlotte again no for

in Cambridge and Charlotte again no for the same reason the first women students

the same reason the first women students

the same reason the first women students in Cambridge were examined in 1882 more

in Cambridge were examined in 1882 more

in Cambridge were examined in 1882 more than 50 years later the most important

than 50 years later the most important

than 50 years later the most important event in Charles professional life was

event in Charles professional life was

event in Charles professional life was the voyage on the Beagle from 1831 to

the voyage on the Beagle from 1831 to

the voyage on the Beagle from 1831 to 1836 he sailed around the world

1836 he sailed around the world

1836 he sailed around the world he endured storms he suffered from

he endured storms he suffered from

he endured storms he suffered from seasickness he experienced too heavy

seasickness he experienced too heavy

seasickness he experienced too heavy earthquake he collected fossils in rough

earthquake he collected fossils in rough

earthquake he collected fossils in rough Patagonia and studied flora and fauna in

Patagonia and studied flora and fauna in

Patagonia and studied flora and fauna in the lush rainforest before his departure

the lush rainforest before his departure

the lush rainforest before his departure that 22 year old Charles had lots of

that 22 year old Charles had lots of

that 22 year old Charles had lots of difficulties to get his father’s consent

difficulties to get his father’s consent

difficulties to get his father’s consent and Charlotte what do you think would

and Charlotte what do you think would

and Charlotte what do you think would her father have given her permission to

her father have given her permission to

her father have given her permission to sail around the world

sail around the world

sail around the world visit all those places and share the

visit all those places and share the

visit all those places and share the cabin with a man-child well was a

cabin with a man-child well was a

cabin with a man-child well was a relatively wealthy man and spend most of

relatively wealthy man and spend most of

relatively wealthy man and spend most of his life as a private scholar a

his life as a private scholar a

his life as a private scholar a self-funded gentleman scientist and the

self-funded gentleman scientist and the

self-funded gentleman scientist and the lap of his family cared for by his wife

lap of his family cared for by his wife

lap of his family cared for by his wife Emma he did a lot of research and

Emma he did a lot of research and

Emma he did a lot of research and publishing and permanently elaborated

publishing and permanently elaborated

publishing and permanently elaborated his theory of evolution which he finally

his theory of evolution which he finally

his theory of evolution which he finally published in 1859

published in 1859

published in 1859 so please note the full title on the

so please note the full title on the

so please note the full title on the Origin of Species by means of natural

Origin of Species by means of natural

Origin of Species by means of natural selection or he offers a different title

selection or he offers a different title

selection or he offers a different title the preservation of favoured races in

the preservation of favoured races in

the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life his findings were

the struggle for life his findings were

the struggle for life his findings were discussed extremely controversially

discussed extremely controversially

discussed extremely controversially among his contemporaries and caused a

among his contemporaries and caused a

among his contemporaries and caused a lot of hostilities in 1871 he published

lot of hostilities in 1871 he published

lot of hostilities in 1871 he published his no less controversial book The

his no less controversial book The

his no less controversial book The Descent of Man and selection in relation

Descent of Man and selection in relation

Descent of Man and selection in relation to sex and Charlotte which he have been

to sex and Charlotte which he have been

to sex and Charlotte which he have been able to discover develop publish and

able to discover develop publish and

able to discover develop publish and defend a theory that has in retrospect

defend a theory that has in retrospect

defend a theory that has in retrospect changed a paradigm I came to the

changed a paradigm I came to the

changed a paradigm I came to the conclusion that a woman in those days

conclusion that a woman in those days

conclusion that a woman in those days had no chance to develop the theory of

had no chance to develop the theory of

had no chance to develop the theory of evolution and at this point I decided to

evolution and at this point I decided to

evolution and at this point I decided to end Charlotte’s story but I had the

end Charlotte’s story but I had the

end Charlotte’s story but I had the feeling that my story my task was not

feeling that my story my task was not

feeling that my story my task was not yet at an

yet at an

yet at an and so again I consulted the literature

and so again I consulted the literature

and so again I consulted the literature dived into many books and articles you

dived into many books and articles you

dived into many books and articles you know scientists always feel comfortable

know scientists always feel comfortable

know scientists always feel comfortable if they can refer to literature suddenly

if they can refer to literature suddenly

if they can refer to literature suddenly I came across a sentence of John Maynard

I came across a sentence of John Maynard

I came across a sentence of John Maynard Smith a very influential of illusionary

Smith a very influential of illusionary

Smith a very influential of illusionary biologist in the last quarter of the

biologist in the last quarter of the

biologist in the last quarter of the 20th century science is a social

20th century science is a social

20th century science is a social construct this is what he wrote science

construct this is what he wrote science

construct this is what he wrote science is a social construct this is very

is a social construct this is very

is a social construct this is very disturbing for a scientist who tries to

disturbing for a scientist who tries to

disturbing for a scientist who tries to explore and explain natural phenomena in

explore and explain natural phenomena in

explore and explain natural phenomena in order to approach and as yet unknown

order to approach and as yet unknown

order to approach and as yet unknown truth is this truth influenced by my

truth is this truth influenced by my

truth is this truth influenced by my worldviews my values my prejudices and

worldviews my values my prejudices and

worldviews my values my prejudices and even my gender identity and can we

even my gender identity and can we

even my gender identity and can we identify such influences and Charles

identify such influences and Charles

identify such influences and Charles Darwin’s evolutionary theory so how did

Darwin’s evolutionary theory so how did

Darwin’s evolutionary theory so how did the man Charles Darwin look at mother

the man Charles Darwin look at mother

the man Charles Darwin look at mother nature well unquestionably Darwin was he

nature well unquestionably Darwin was he

nature well unquestionably Darwin was he was rethinking nature he discovered the

was rethinking nature he discovered the

was rethinking nature he discovered the principle of selection of evolution

principle of selection of evolution

principle of selection of evolution driven by two different processes

driven by two different processes

driven by two different processes natural selection and sexual selection

natural selection and sexual selection

natural selection and sexual selection today almost every child in school is

today almost every child in school is

today almost every child in school is familiar with the concept of natural

familiar with the concept of natural

familiar with the concept of natural selection which has many different

selection which has many different

selection which has many different aspects for example a relatively higher

aspects for example a relatively higher

aspects for example a relatively higher reproduction rate or the ability to

reproduction rate or the ability to

reproduction rate or the ability to collect and monopolize more food than

collect and monopolize more food than

collect and monopolize more food than competitors or to be better camouflage

competitors or to be better camouflage

competitors or to be better camouflage than conspecifics

than conspecifics

than conspecifics or to pretend being dangerous to prevent

or to pretend being dangerous to prevent

or to pretend being dangerous to prevent being

being

being all these examples demonstrate what

all these examples demonstrate what

all these examples demonstrate what Fitness in an evolutionary sense means

Fitness in an evolutionary sense means

Fitness in an evolutionary sense means best adaptation to specific environments

best adaptation to specific environments

best adaptation to specific environments but Darwin used the language of his time

but Darwin used the language of his time

but Darwin used the language of his time to describe natural selection

to describe natural selection

to describe natural selection therefore he provoked mental images

therefore he provoked mental images

therefore he provoked mental images telling a different story the survival

telling a different story the survival

telling a different story the survival of the fittest turned into survival of

of the fittest turned into survival of

of the fittest turned into survival of the strongest the struggle for life

the strongest the struggle for life

the strongest the struggle for life appeared to be a battlefield of life and

appeared to be a battlefield of life and

appeared to be a battlefield of life and competition

competition

competition turned into combat so that was the

turned into combat so that was the

turned into combat so that was the description of a man’s world in the 19th

description of a man’s world in the 19th

description of a man’s world in the 19th century in addition it was part of the

century in addition it was part of the

century in addition it was part of the zeitgeist of industrialization to have a

zeitgeist of industrialization to have a

zeitgeist of industrialization to have a strong belief in the blessings of

strong belief in the blessings of

strong belief in the blessings of technology and therefore Darwin

technology and therefore Darwin

technology and therefore Darwin associated human evolution with

associated human evolution with

associated human evolution with technology tools became very important

technology tools became very important

technology tools became very important driving force and tools were quickly

driving force and tools were quickly

driving force and tools were quickly equated with weapons Darwin did not he

equated with weapons Darwin did not he

equated with weapons Darwin did not he well he was a he was a very open-minded

well he was a he was a very open-minded

well he was a he was a very open-minded man but he did not question the he did

man but he did not question the he did

man but he did not question the he did not question racism and sexism that were

not question racism and sexism that were

not question racism and sexism that were widely spread and generally accepted

widely spread and generally accepted

widely spread and generally accepted among his contemporaries so in this

among his contemporaries so in this

among his contemporaries so in this respect he was a child of his time and

respect he was a child of his time and

respect he was a child of his time and he even – he thought women were inferior

he even – he thought women were inferior

he even – he thought women were inferior and he even developed a novel ooh

and he even developed a novel ooh

and he even developed a novel ooh Minori explanation for this this was men

Minori explanation for this this was men

Minori explanation for this this was men had to defend their families in the

had to defend their families in the

had to defend their families in the struggle for life and they also had to

struggle for life and they also had to

struggle for life and they also had to invent all these splendid tools and by

invent all these splendid tools and by

invent all these splendid tools and by this way he paved the way for an

this way he paved the way for an

this way he paved the way for an evolutionary scenario of man the hunter

evolutionary scenario of man the hunter

evolutionary scenario of man the hunter which dominated for more than 100 years

which dominated for more than 100 years

which dominated for more than 100 years women were just supernumerary actors or

women were just supernumerary actors or

women were just supernumerary actors or should I say actresses in the background

should I say actresses in the background

should I say actresses in the background well Darwin he changed paradigm but he

well Darwin he changed paradigm but he

well Darwin he changed paradigm but he did not question racism and sexism so I

did not question racism and sexism so I

did not question racism and sexism so I want now to know is there at this point

want now to know is there at this point

want now to know is there at this point I only noticed that John Maynard Smith

I only noticed that John Maynard Smith

I only noticed that John Maynard Smith was really right science is a social

was really right science is a social

was really right science is a social construct but you know at this point I

construct but you know at this point I

construct but you know at this point I still had the feeling that my story my

still had the feeling that my story my

still had the feeling that my story my task was not yet at an end as yet I had

task was not yet at an end as yet I had

task was not yet at an end as yet I had analyzed the past the history of the

analyzed the past the history of the

analyzed the past the history of the theory but is it possible that Darwin’s

theory but is it possible that Darwin’s

theory but is it possible that Darwin’s prejudice perpetuates until today in the

prejudice perpetuates until today in the

prejudice perpetuates until today in the last 25 years

last 25 years

last 25 years there has been a lot of research around

there has been a lot of research around

there has been a lot of research around the concept of sexual selection and this

the concept of sexual selection and this

the concept of sexual selection and this concept deals with reproductive

concept deals with reproductive

concept deals with reproductive competition and reproductive choices or

competition and reproductive choices or

competition and reproductive choices or to phrase it simpler how do individuals

to phrase it simpler how do individuals

to phrase it simpler how do individuals find their mating partners and how does

find their mating partners and how does

find their mating partners and how does this influence evolution let me give you

this influence evolution let me give you

this influence evolution let me give you an example of the 1990s a group of

an example of the 1990s a group of

an example of the 1990s a group of researchers were studying

researchers were studying

researchers were studying piñon J’s a species of birds in

piñon J’s a species of birds in

piñon J’s a species of birds in California that live and breed in

California that live and breed in

California that live and breed in colonies the researchers observed the

colonies the researchers observed the

colonies the researchers observed the birds and noticed a lack of competitive

birds and noticed a lack of competitive

birds and noticed a lack of competitive and aggressive behavior which made it

and aggressive behavior which made it

and aggressive behavior which made it very difficult to identify a ranking

very difficult to identify a ranking

very difficult to identify a ranking order but finally the researchers were

order but finally the researchers were

order but finally the researchers were confident of having found the alpha male

confident of having found the alpha male

confident of having found the alpha male after a while this specific bird

after a while this specific bird

after a while this specific bird disappeared for unknown reasons again

disappeared for unknown reasons again

disappeared for unknown reasons again the researchers had to identify the new

the researchers had to identify the new

the researchers had to identify the new alpha male it took some time before they

alpha male it took some time before they

alpha male it took some time before they announced the new number one in their

announced the new number one in their

announced the new number one in their colony and then they speculated a lot

colony and then they speculated a lot

colony and then they speculated a lot about one amazing fact the new alpha

about one amazing fact the new alpha

about one amazing fact the new alpha male was bonded to the same female bird

male was bonded to the same female bird

male was bonded to the same female bird as his predecessor what characteristics

as his predecessor what characteristics

as his predecessor what characteristics made this female so attractive to an

made this female so attractive to an

made this female so attractive to an alpha male any idea the researchers

alpha male any idea the researchers

alpha male any idea the researchers didn’t see what was right before their

didn’t see what was right before their

didn’t see what was right before their eyes

eyes

eyes the Alpha individual never disappeared

the Alpha individual never disappeared

the Alpha individual never disappeared she was always there but Darwin’s or are

she was always there but Darwin’s or are

she was always there but Darwin’s or are they this the image of biological image

they this the image of biological image

they this the image of biological image of male dominance it goes back to

of male dominance it goes back to

of male dominance it goes back to Charles Darwin was so strong that it

Charles Darwin was so strong that it

Charles Darwin was so strong that it blocked the simple explanation of a

blocked the simple explanation of a

blocked the simple explanation of a female hierarchy in the colony and at

female hierarchy in the colony and at

female hierarchy in the colony and at this point I and I really understood the

this point I and I really understood the

this point I and I really understood the power of a bias and ever since my

power of a bias and ever since my

power of a bias and ever since my concept of science is more complete good

concept of science is more complete good

concept of science is more complete good science requires

science requires

science requires Christian’s in order to find new answers

Christian’s in order to find new answers

Christian’s in order to find new answers and new solutions but good good science

and new solutions but good good science

and new solutions but good good science also requires the readiness to change

also requires the readiness to change

also requires the readiness to change one’s perspective again and again in

one’s perspective again and again in

one’s perspective again and again in order to get a wider view you see this

order to get a wider view you see this

order to get a wider view you see this this leopard I took this photo some

this leopard I took this photo some

this leopard I took this photo some years ago in Kenya and I hope you can

years ago in Kenya and I hope you can

years ago in Kenya and I hope you can see that the leopard is alert

see that the leopard is alert

see that the leopard is alert he’s obviously staring at something but

he’s obviously staring at something but

he’s obviously staring at something but from my point of view I couldn’t see

from my point of view I couldn’t see

from my point of view I couldn’t see anything I wanted to know so I started

anything I wanted to know so I started

anything I wanted to know so I started circling around changed my position and

circling around changed my position and

circling around changed my position and then came across this little antelope

then came across this little antelope

then came across this little antelope but I could see that the leopard was not

but I could see that the leopard was not

but I could see that the leopard was not staring in its direction so I had to go

staring in its direction so I had to go

staring in its direction so I had to go on again circle around find a new

on again circle around find a new

on again circle around find a new position a new angle found this bunch of

position a new angle found this bunch of

position a new angle found this bunch of tourist cars and you know although all

tourist cars and you know although all

tourist cars and you know although all these intrusive observers were watching

these intrusive observers were watching

these intrusive observers were watching the leopard the leopard was not

the leopard the leopard was not

the leopard the leopard was not interested in them he looked into a

interested in them he looked into a

interested in them he looked into a different direction so again I had to

different direction so again I had to

different direction so again I had to circle around find another position a

circle around find another position a

circle around find another position a new perspective came across this lioness

new perspective came across this lioness

new perspective came across this lioness and now I could see that the leopard was

and now I could see that the leopard was

and now I could see that the leopard was directly staring at this lioness in the

directly staring at this lioness in the

directly staring at this lioness in the beginning when I first saw the leopard I

beginning when I first saw the leopard I

beginning when I first saw the leopard I could only speculate about the reason

could only speculate about the reason

could only speculate about the reason for his behavior but after circling

for his behavior but after circling

for his behavior but after circling around changing my position my

around changing my position my

around changing my position my perspective again and again I could

perspective again and again I could

perspective again and again I could derive that it was neither hunger nor

derive that it was neither hunger nor

derive that it was neither hunger nor annoyance he was simply afraid of a

annoyance he was simply afraid of a

annoyance he was simply afraid of a dangerous competitor let me return to

dangerous competitor let me return to

dangerous competitor let me return to Charles Darwin Charles Darwin did not

Charles Darwin Charles Darwin did not

Charles Darwin Charles Darwin did not question the alleged inferiority of

question the alleged inferiority of

question the alleged inferiority of women but he successfully overcame the

women but he successfully overcame the

women but he successfully overcame the idea of a special position

idea of a special position

idea of a special position of humans in nature he had a new

of humans in nature he had a new

of humans in nature he had a new viewpoint instead of a top-down

viewpoint instead of a top-down

viewpoint instead of a top-down standpoint he had a bottom-up view at

standpoint he had a bottom-up view at

standpoint he had a bottom-up view at the origin of species he changed a

the origin of species he changed a

the origin of species he changed a paradigm because he changed his

paradigm because he changed his

paradigm because he changed his perspective and this approach is not

perspective and this approach is not

perspective and this approach is not restricted to science everyone can use

restricted to science everyone can use

restricted to science everyone can use it in day-to-day life I am out of

it in day-to-day life I am out of

it in day-to-day life I am out of research business for 14 years now but I

research business for 14 years now but I

research business for 14 years now but I never forgot my lesson learned I had to

never forgot my lesson learned I had to

never forgot my lesson learned I had to face many new challenges and I found

face many new challenges and I found

face many new challenges and I found many new solutions new Answers I was

many new solutions new Answers I was

many new solutions new Answers I was successful because I changed my

successful because I changed my

successful because I changed my perspective I always look at problems

perspective I always look at problems

perspective I always look at problems from different perspectives and I

from different perspectives and I

from different perspectives and I personally particularly love

personally particularly love

personally particularly love perspectives that appear to be a little

perspectives that appear to be a little

perspectives that appear to be a little bit crazy a little bit weird like the

bit crazy a little bit weird like the

bit crazy a little bit weird like the idea that Darwin had been a woman thank

idea that Darwin had been a woman thank

idea that Darwin had been a woman thank you

you

you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *