
well thanks for the opportunity to share my alarm at the decrease that the
my alarm at the decrease that the
my alarm at the decrease that the shortage of rural surgeons in America so
shortage of rural surgeons in America so
shortage of rural surgeons in America so when I introduced you to George and
when I introduced you to George and
when I introduced you to George and chicky Watkins they’re my neighbors this
chicky Watkins they’re my neighbors this
chicky Watkins they’re my neighbors this picture is taken just a couple weeks ago
picture is taken just a couple weeks ago
picture is taken just a couple weeks ago in their backyard but two years ago
in their backyard but two years ago
in their backyard but two years ago chicky nearly died from septic shock
chicky nearly died from septic shock
chicky nearly died from septic shock from a perforated colon and she had to
from a perforated colon and she had to
from a perforated colon and she had to undergo life-saving emergency surgery in
undergo life-saving emergency surgery in
undergo life-saving emergency surgery in our little Hospital in Henderson North
our little Hospital in Henderson North
our little Hospital in Henderson North Carolina where we lived she spent a
Carolina where we lived she spent a
Carolina where we lived she spent a couple weeks in the hospital and then
couple weeks in the hospital and then
couple weeks in the hospital and then several months Richert recovering from
several months Richert recovering from
several months Richert recovering from that but she’s back to her feisty self
that but she’s back to her feisty self
that but she’s back to her feisty self and if you knew chickie you’d know
and if you knew chickie you’d know
and if you knew chickie you’d know exactly what I mean
exactly what I mean
exactly what I mean what makes chickies story I’m sorry
what makes chickies story I’m sorry
what makes chickies story I’m sorry what makes chickies story I’ll more
what makes chickies story I’ll more
what makes chickies story I’ll more important most important to me is not
important most important to me is not
important most important to me is not that just that she’s my neighbor and
that just that she’s my neighbor and
that just that she’s my neighbor and good friends of the family or that it’s
good friends of the family or that it’s
good friends of the family or that it’s hot this was done in our local hospital
hot this was done in our local hospital
hot this was done in our local hospital and that her surgeon is a really good
and that her surgeon is a really good
and that her surgeon is a really good friend of mine that I actually went to
friend of mine that I actually went to
friend of mine that I actually went to medical school with but what’s really
medical school with but what’s really
medical school with but what’s really important to me is that chickies success
important to me is that chickies success
important to me is that chickies success story is becoming increasingly more
story is becoming increasingly more
story is becoming increasingly more difficult to achieve in smaller
difficult to achieve in smaller
difficult to achieve in smaller communities in rural areas because we
communities in rural areas because we
communities in rural areas because we have a significant shortage of rural
have a significant shortage of rural
have a significant shortage of rural surgeons and it’s a problem that’s gonna
surgeons and it’s a problem that’s gonna
surgeons and it’s a problem that’s gonna last for at least a generation or two
last for at least a generation or two
last for at least a generation or two until we get it under control now
full disclosure I got a dog in this
full disclosure I got a dog in this fight I am a general surgeon
fight I am a general surgeon
fight I am a general surgeon we have been described as the Marines of
we have been described as the Marines of
we have been described as the Marines of the healthcare system
the healthcare system
the healthcare system affectionately I’m sure I’m also an
affectionately I’m sure I’m also an
affectionately I’m sure I’m also an advocate for small-town quality
advocate for small-town quality
advocate for small-town quality healthcare just like what I grew up with
healthcare just like what I grew up with
healthcare just like what I grew up with and what I’ve been involved in
and what I’ve been involved in
and what I’ve been involved in professionally I come by it honestly
professionally I come by it honestly
professionally I come by it honestly my grandfather among other things was a
my grandfather among other things was a
my grandfather among other things was a Norman Rockwell type country general
Norman Rockwell type country general
Norman Rockwell type country general practitioner who practiced 50 years in
practitioner who practiced 50 years in
practitioner who practiced 50 years in the town he was born in
the town he was born in
the town he was born in and lived and raised in my father my
and lived and raised in my father my
and lived and raised in my father my uncle and my sister are all
uncle and my sister are all
uncle and my sister are all obstetricians they all grew up in small
obstetricians they all grew up in small
obstetricians they all grew up in small towns and actually work in small towns
towns and actually work in small towns
towns and actually work in small towns I’ve had a fairly colorful career it’s
I’ve had a fairly colorful career it’s
I’ve had a fairly colorful career it’s been described to me the first 12 years
been described to me the first 12 years
been described to me the first 12 years I was actually a country general surgeon
I was actually a country general surgeon
I was actually a country general surgeon first in northern Idaho and then the
first in northern Idaho and then the
first in northern Idaho and then the last part of that was in rural North
last part of that was in rural North
last part of that was in rural North Carolina
Carolina
Carolina I then trance transitioned and became a
I then trance transitioned and became a
I then trance transitioned and became a trauma surgeon in an urban environment
trauma surgeon in an urban environment
trauma surgeon in an urban environment where I was teaching residents but you
where I was teaching residents but you
where I was teaching residents but you know that was that was really a lot of
know that was that was really a lot of
know that was that was really a lot of fun to but that I really missed the
fun to but that I really missed the
fun to but that I really missed the rural setting so the last four years
rural setting so the last four years
rural setting so the last four years I’ve been working for a LifePoint health
I’ve been working for a LifePoint health
I’ve been working for a LifePoint health now that they’re a giant corporation
now that they’re a giant corporation
now that they’re a giant corporation publicly traded they own and operate 70
publicly traded they own and operate 70
publicly traded they own and operate 70 hospitals across the United States most
hospitals across the United States most
hospitals across the United States most of them are in small communities in
of them are in small communities in
of them are in small communities in rural settings their mission statement
rural settings their mission statement
rural settings their mission statement is making communities healthier and
is making communities healthier and
is making communities healthier and they’re one of their main tenants is
they’re one of their main tenants is
they’re one of their main tenants is keeping care close to home and that’s
keeping care close to home and that’s
keeping care close to home and that’s that’s why I took this job and while I’m
that’s why I took this job and while I’m
that’s why I took this job and while I’m really interested in these guys they
really interested in these guys they
really interested in these guys they hired me to go out and hire and create a
hired me to go out and hire and create a
hired me to go out and hire and create a group of seasoned experienced general
group of seasoned experienced general
group of seasoned experienced general and trauma surgeons and our mission we
and trauma surgeons and our mission we
and trauma surgeons and our mission we call ourselves a surgical Special Forces
call ourselves a surgical Special Forces
call ourselves a surgical Special Forces team and our mission was to go into all
team and our mission was to go into all
team and our mission was to go into all these hospitals and help the doctors and
these hospitals and help the doctors and
these hospitals and help the doctors and the and the hospitals when they needed
the and the hospitals when they needed
the and the hospitals when they needed it in other words if they had a shortage
it in other words if they had a shortage
it in other words if they had a shortage or there’s a problem so as a result of
or there’s a problem so as a result of
or there’s a problem so as a result of this really cool job I’ve had the
this really cool job I’ve had the
this really cool job I’ve had the opportunity to operate in at least 25
opportunity to operate in at least 25
opportunity to operate in at least 25 hospitals in the United States and I
hospitals in the United States and I
hospitals in the United States and I keep adding more and more each year in
keep adding more and more each year in
keep adding more and more each year in addition I’ve done some medical mission
addition I’ve done some medical mission
addition I’ve done some medical mission work and operated in the third world in
work and operated in the third world in
work and operated in the third world in Madagascar and Kenya and Nicaragua and
Madagascar and Kenya and Nicaragua and
Madagascar and Kenya and Nicaragua and as a result of this kind of broad
as a result of this kind of broad
as a result of this kind of broad experience I have I really have a lot of
experience I have I really have a lot of
experience I have I really have a lot of tools to do what I do in my job which is
tools to do what I do in my job which is
tools to do what I do in my job which is to really ensure high quality surgical
to really ensure high quality surgical
to really ensure high quality surgical care and smaller communities and
care and smaller communities and
care and smaller communities and hospitals now it goes without saying I
hospitals now it goes without saying I
hospitals now it goes without saying I think that health care has got some
think that health care has got some
think that health care has got some problems in America and you know that
problems in America and you know that
problems in America and you know that the news is full of it you just you
the news is full of it you just you
the news is full of it you just you can’t get away from it and it just seems
can’t get away from it and it just seems
can’t get away from it and it just seems like every time you turn around
like every time you turn around
like every time you turn around somebody’s either criticizing or wanting
somebody’s either criticizing or wanting
somebody’s either criticizing or wanting a piece of that three point four
a piece of that three point four
a piece of that three point four trillion dollar health care pie which
trillion dollar health care pie which
trillion dollar health care pie which represents 18% of our GNP now the
represents 18% of our GNP now the
represents 18% of our GNP now the current debate that we see on CNN and
current debate that we see on CNN and
current debate that we see on CNN and everywhere is really framed as an
everywhere is really framed as an
everywhere is really framed as an actuarial math problem you know how are
actuarial math problem you know how are
actuarial math problem you know how are we gonna pay for health care for all of
we gonna pay for health care for all of
we gonna pay for health care for all of our citizens and I’m gonna I’m gonna
our citizens and I’m gonna I’m gonna
our citizens and I’m gonna I’m gonna suggest that it’s way more complicated
suggest that it’s way more complicated
suggest that it’s way more complicated than that that we’ve had decades of
than that that we’ve had decades of
than that that we’ve had decades of perverted and misaligned incentives in
perverted and misaligned incentives in
perverted and misaligned incentives in our system and I’m gonna also suggest
our system and I’m gonna also suggest
our system and I’m gonna also suggest that the biggest problem we have in
that the biggest problem we have in
that the biggest problem we have in health care is actually taking care of
health care is actually taking care of
health care is actually taking care of patients and that is way more
patients and that is way more
patients and that is way more complicated than just trying to figure
complicated than just trying to figure
complicated than just trying to figure out at the end of the month how much
out at the end of the month how much
out at the end of the month how much money I your paycheck is gonna go to pay
money I your paycheck is gonna go to pay
money I your paycheck is gonna go to pay for your insurance premiums so I’m just
for your insurance premiums so I’m just
for your insurance premiums so I’m just going to talk about one of those
going to talk about one of those
going to talk about one of those problems today and so we really have
problems today and so we really have
problems today and so we really have time for but it but it’s I’m going to
time for but it but it’s I’m going to
time for but it but it’s I’m going to concentrate on the shortage of general
concentrate on the shortage of general
concentrate on the shortage of general surgeons and rural communities and why
surgeons and rural communities and why
surgeons and rural communities and why it’s it’s a big deal because it’s going
it’s it’s a big deal because it’s going
it’s it’s a big deal because it’s going to really affect how we can optimally
to really affect how we can optimally
to really affect how we can optimally take care of patients in these settings
take care of patients in these settings
take care of patients in these settings and whether or not even these hospitals
and whether or not even these hospitals
and whether or not even these hospitals are gonna be able to stay open and it’s
are gonna be able to stay open and it’s
are gonna be able to stay open and it’s a problem it’s going to take at least a
a problem it’s going to take at least a
a problem it’s going to take at least a generation to fix if we can even get
generation to fix if we can even get
generation to fix if we can even get there so rural communities are really at
there so rural communities are really at
there so rural communities are really at risk for the perturbations in these
risk for the perturbations in these
risk for the perturbations in these health care changes you know some more
health care changes you know some more
health care changes you know some more full disclosure that’s actually my son’s
full disclosure that’s actually my son’s
full disclosure that’s actually my son’s car and he and he drove it across our
car and he and he drove it across our
car and he and he drove it across our country on a big trip but um rural
country on a big trip but um rural
country on a big trip but um rural populations when compared to urban
populations when compared to urban
populations when compared to urban populations there there tend to be older
populations there there tend to be older
populations there there tend to be older or under 18 poor uninsured more likely
or under 18 poor uninsured more likely
or under 18 poor uninsured more likely to be disabled or chronically ill and
to be disabled or chronically ill and
to be disabled or chronically ill and you know rural
you know rural
you know rural communities have problems with financial
communities have problems with financial
communities have problems with financial issues that I have unemployment and
issues that I have unemployment and
issues that I have unemployment and other issues and they’re often are under
other issues and they’re often are under
other issues and they’re often are under represented in their legislation our
represented in their legislation our
represented in their legislation our legislators and there’s plenty of
legislators and there’s plenty of
legislators and there’s plenty of evidence that rural hospitals are
evidence that rural hospitals are
evidence that rural hospitals are already taking it on the chin in the
already taking it on the chin in the
already taking it on the chin in the last 10 years 200 maternity wards have
last 10 years 200 maternity wards have
last 10 years 200 maternity wards have closed in rural areas nationwide leaving
closed in rural areas nationwide leaving
closed in rural areas nationwide leaving 54% of all rural counties without any
54% of all rural counties without any
54% of all rural counties without any Hospital based obstetrics in that same
Hospital based obstetrics in that same
Hospital based obstetrics in that same time frame 60 hospitals have closed in
time frame 60 hospitals have closed in
time frame 60 hospitals have closed in 22 states rural hospital hospitals and
22 states rural hospital hospitals and
22 states rural hospital hospitals and it’s estimated that about 700 more in 42
it’s estimated that about 700 more in 42
it’s estimated that about 700 more in 42 states are vulnerable or at risk for
states are vulnerable or at risk for
states are vulnerable or at risk for closure hot rural hospitals are really
closure hot rural hospitals are really
closure hot rural hospitals are really important to their communities and some
important to their communities and some
important to their communities and some of you already know this but you know
of you already know this but you know
of you already know this but you know they serve as the organizational core
they serve as the organizational core
they serve as the organizational core not just for health care but for social
not just for health care but for social
not just for health care but for social services they’re often the largest
services they’re often the largest
services they’re often the largest employer and one thing is for certain if
employer and one thing is for certain if
employer and one thing is for certain if you don’t have a decent hospital if you
you don’t have a decent hospital if you
you don’t have a decent hospital if you lose your hospital you’re never going to
lose your hospital you’re never going to
lose your hospital you’re never going to recruit any more business to your
recruit any more business to your
recruit any more business to your community or you’re not going to you
community or you’re not going to you
community or you’re not going to you know have trouble recruiting businesses
know have trouble recruiting businesses
know have trouble recruiting businesses to your community and the other thing
to your community and the other thing
to your community and the other thing this is for sure is that if these rural
this is for sure is that if these rural
this is for sure is that if these rural hospitals can’t offer key specialty care
hospitals can’t offer key specialty care
hospitals can’t offer key specialty care they’re not going to survive and we we
they’re not going to survive and we we
they’re not going to survive and we we know about what these important
know about what these important
know about what these important specialties are in general surgery is
specialties are in general surgery is
specialties are in general surgery is one of the well-known specialties that
one of the well-known specialties that
one of the well-known specialties that keeps these rural hospitals open now
keeps these rural hospitals open now
keeps these rural hospitals open now there’s plenty of history press
there’s plenty of history press
there’s plenty of history press historical precedents that supports us
historical precedents that supports us
historical precedents that supports us you know every rural hospital from for
you know every rural hospital from for
you know every rural hospital from for 30 or 40 years has had a surgeon and
30 or 40 years has had a surgeon and
30 or 40 years has had a surgeon and they did all the surgical work and
they did all the surgical work and
they did all the surgical work and surgeons you know well trained surgeons
surgeons you know well trained surgeons
surgeons you know well trained surgeons can do almost every single general
can do almost every single general
can do almost every single general surgery case in any Hospital you don’t
surgery case in any Hospital you don’t
surgery case in any Hospital you don’t need helicopters and you know TV screens
need helicopters and you know TV screens
need helicopters and you know TV screens and all that kind of stuff to do
and all that kind of stuff to do
and all that kind of stuff to do most life-saving surgery and and most of
most life-saving surgery and and most of
most life-saving surgery and and most of the guys in my group know that for a
the guys in my group know that for a
the guys in my group know that for a fact because we’ve operated in third
fact because we’ve operated in third
fact because we’ve operated in third world done major operations in a tent so
world done major operations in a tent so
world done major operations in a tent so we know general surgery is important you
we know general surgery is important you
we know general surgery is important you know we’re on the front line of medical
know we’re on the front line of medical
know we’re on the front line of medical emergencies and surgical emergencies and
emergencies and surgical emergencies and
emergencies and surgical emergencies and there’s some studies that have come out
there’s some studies that have come out
there’s some studies that have come out comparing rural surgeons
comparing rural surgeons
comparing rural surgeons two urban surgeons and their caseloads
two urban surgeons and their caseloads
two urban surgeons and their caseloads and they know that rural surgeons do a
and they know that rural surgeons do a
and they know that rural surgeons do a wider variety of cases when compared to
wider variety of cases when compared to
wider variety of cases when compared to urban surgeons and they do a higher
urban surgeons and they do a higher
urban surgeons and they do a higher percentage of cases in those hospitals
percentage of cases in those hospitals
percentage of cases in those hospitals now this is pretty can you explain it if
now this is pretty can you explain it if
now this is pretty can you explain it if you’re the only guy in town then you got
you’re the only guy in town then you got
you’re the only guy in town then you got to do what walks in the door and you and
to do what walks in the door and you and
to do what walks in the door and you and you’re going to so real surgeons need a
you’re going to so real surgeons need a
you’re going to so real surgeons need a bigger bra a broader skill set than
bigger bra a broader skill set than
bigger bra a broader skill set than their their urban patients there’s also
their their urban patients there’s also
their their urban patients there’s also some intriguing studies that have come
some intriguing studies that have come
some intriguing studies that have come out that have shown that rural surgery
out that have shown that rural surgery
out that have shown that rural surgery patients actually do better than the
patients actually do better than the
patients actually do better than the urban patients they have shorter
urban patients they have shorter
urban patients they have shorter hospital stays less morbidity surgical
hospital stays less morbidity surgical
hospital stays less morbidity surgical complications less mortality and there
complications less mortality and there
complications less mortality and there and their costs are cheaper and it
and their costs are cheaper and it
and their costs are cheaper and it doesn’t mean that real surgeons are
doesn’t mean that real surgeons are
doesn’t mean that real surgeons are better than urban surgeons necessarily
better than urban surgeons necessarily
better than urban surgeons necessarily they put it probably means that the
they put it probably means that the
they put it probably means that the rural surgeons are choosing their
rural surgeons are choosing their
rural surgeons are choosing their patients correctly and probably sending
patients correctly and probably sending
patients correctly and probably sending the more complex patients down the line
the more complex patients down the line
the more complex patients down the line there’s some more other intriguing
there’s some more other intriguing
there’s some more other intriguing studies that are out there a study out
studies that are out there a study out
studies that are out there a study out of Maryland looked at nearly a half a
of Maryland looked at nearly a half a
of Maryland looked at nearly a half a million patients that either that had
million patients that either that had
million patients that either that had emergency surgery either in a smaller
emergency surgery either in a smaller
emergency surgery either in a smaller community or a big city urban tertiary
community or a big city urban tertiary
community or a big city urban tertiary Hospital and what they found was that
Hospital and what they found was that
Hospital and what they found was that the cost of care and the tertiary
the cost of care and the tertiary
the cost of care and the tertiary centers were significantly higher than
centers were significantly higher than
centers were significantly higher than the innocent community hospitals and if
the innocent community hospitals and if
the innocent community hospitals and if they had to be admitted into the ICU
they had to be admitted into the ICU
they had to be admitted into the ICU then their costs were twice as much and
then their costs were twice as much and
then their costs were twice as much and these studies just looked at medical
these studies just looked at medical
these studies just looked at medical cost it didn’t even go into the
cost it didn’t even go into the
cost it didn’t even go into the inconvenience of care or the opportunity
inconvenience of care or the opportunity
inconvenience of care or the opportunity cost that people from small communities
cost that people from small communities
cost that people from small communities had to incur when they travel to it to a
had to incur when they travel to it to a
had to incur when they travel to it to a barrier committee and there’s one more
barrier committee and there’s one more
barrier committee and there’s one more study I just want to mention we already
study I just want to mention we already
study I just want to mention we already have a shortage of rural surgeons a
have a shortage of rural surgeons a
have a shortage of rural surgeons a study just came out of a teaching
study just came out of a teaching
study just came out of a teaching institution in Maine when they looked at
institution in Maine when they looked at
institution in Maine when they looked at transfers of surgery patients from rural
transfers of surgery patients from rural
transfers of surgery patients from rural communities and what they were surprised
communities and what they were surprised
communities and what they were surprised to find was that 50% of the patients
to find was that 50% of the patients
to find was that 50% of the patients that were transferred to their
that were transferred to their
that were transferred to their institution came because there wasn’t a
institution came because there wasn’t a
institution came because there wasn’t a surgeon at that transferring hospital to
surgeon at that transferring hospital to
surgeon at that transferring hospital to take care of them
take care of them
take care of them when they needed it
there have been unintended consequences
there have been unintended consequences that have led to this shortage of
that have led to this shortage of
that have led to this shortage of surgeons I trained under the old surgery
surgeons I trained under the old surgery
surgeons I trained under the old surgery paradigm back in 1990 I don’t know if
paradigm back in 1990 I don’t know if
paradigm back in 1990 I don’t know if y’all heard anything about that but the
y’all heard anything about that but the
y’all heard anything about that but the best people could say about it was that
best people could say about it was that
best people could say about it was that it was inhumane and the worst is that it
it was inhumane and the worst is that it
it was inhumane and the worst is that it was dangerous I don’t really remember
was dangerous I don’t really remember
was dangerous I don’t really remember that but we we were trained in a way to
that but we we were trained in a way to
that but we we were trained in a way to maximize output with minimal resources
maximize output with minimal resources
maximize output with minimal resources and just for an example when I finished
and just for an example when I finished
and just for an example when I finished my residency I went to work as a rural
my residency I went to work as a rural
my residency I went to work as a rural surgeon and I worked pretty much every
surgeon and I worked pretty much every
surgeon and I worked pretty much every day every other weekend every other
day every other weekend every other
day every other weekend every other night for about 12 years and it didn’t
night for about 12 years and it didn’t
night for about 12 years and it didn’t even seem odd I mean that’s just what we
even seem odd I mean that’s just what we
even seem odd I mean that’s just what we did and in fact it was actually written
did and in fact it was actually written
did and in fact it was actually written in the hospital by law so that’s what
in the hospital by law so that’s what
in the hospital by law so that’s what our schedule and what we were required
our schedule and what we were required
our schedule and what we were required to do well times have certainly changed
to do well times have certainly changed
to do well times have certainly changed in 2003 the the committee that governs
in 2003 the the committee that governs
in 2003 the the committee that governs residency education so all the residents
residency education so all the residents
residency education so all the residents imposed mandatory maximum work hours
imposed mandatory maximum work hours
imposed mandatory maximum work hours whether this was good or bad is being
whether this was good or bad is being
whether this was good or bad is being vigorously debated now because the
vigorously debated now because the
vigorously debated now because the safety and quality data is really
safety and quality data is really
safety and quality data is really inconclusive
inconclusive
inconclusive but one thing is absolutely certain that
but one thing is absolutely certain that
but one thing is absolutely certain that change has has changed the way surgeons
change has has changed the way surgeons
change has has changed the way surgeons think about their job when if you look
think about their job when if you look
think about their job when if you look at millennial medical resident graduates
at millennial medical resident graduates
at millennial medical resident graduates that are under the age of 35 they are
that are under the age of 35 they are
that are under the age of 35 they are being projected to work 13% fewer hours
being projected to work 13% fewer hours
being projected to work 13% fewer hours than their older cohorts which comes out
than their older cohorts which comes out
than their older cohorts which comes out to be two or three days per month and
to be two or three days per month and
to be two or three days per month and understandably the new grads won’t a
understandably the new grads won’t a
understandably the new grads won’t a more balanced work-life balance a more
more balanced work-life balance a more
more balanced work-life balance a more favorable work-life balance they want to
favorable work-life balance they want to
favorable work-life balance they want to work fewer hours have more family time
work fewer hours have more family time
work fewer hours have more family time not and not being on call as much and
not and not being on call as much and
not and not being on call as much and I’ll tell you the older surgeons have
I’ll tell you the older surgeons have
I’ll tell you the older surgeons have heard this and they they agree and and
heard this and they they agree and and
heard this and they they agree and and we all want better work-life balance as
we all want better work-life balance as
we all want better work-life balance as well but what’s happened is
well but what’s happened is
well but what’s happened is the current workforce is refusing to
the current workforce is refusing to
the current workforce is refusing to adhere to the old delivery of care model
adhere to the old delivery of care model
adhere to the old delivery of care model and delivery systems hospitals are
and delivery systems hospitals are
and delivery systems hospitals are having a hard time coming up with viable
having a hard time coming up with viable
having a hard time coming up with viable plans to fill the team on a regular
plans to fill the team on a regular
plans to fill the team on a regular basis so the numbers the numbers are out
basis so the numbers the numbers are out
basis so the numbers the numbers are out and and we don’t just have unintended
and and we don’t just have unintended
and and we don’t just have unintended consequences we actually have a shortage
consequences we actually have a shortage
consequences we actually have a shortage so so if you look at the numbers of
so so if you look at the numbers of
so so if you look at the numbers of surgeons surgeons between the ages of 55
surgeons surgeons between the ages of 55
surgeons surgeons between the ages of 55 and 75 which unfortunately is my age
and 75 which unfortunately is my age
and 75 which unfortunately is my age cohort make up right at about 37% of all
cohort make up right at about 37% of all
cohort make up right at about 37% of all active surgeons now these are you know
active surgeons now these are you know
active surgeons now these are you know we’re we should be thinking about retire
we’re we should be thinking about retire
we’re we should be thinking about retire or maybe even be retired at that age
or maybe even be retired at that age
or maybe even be retired at that age doing surgery rural surgeons are older
doing surgery rural surgeons are older
doing surgery rural surgeons are older than the mean in every category
than the mean in every category
than the mean in every category including general surgeons general
including general surgeons general
including general surgeons general surgeons that are retiring in rural
surgeons that are retiring in rural
surgeons that are retiring in rural areas are not being replaced and we
areas are not being replaced and we
areas are not being replaced and we already have a geographic male
already have a geographic male
already have a geographic male distribution of a work of the workforce
distribution of a work of the workforce
distribution of a work of the workforce and then if you look at demand which is
and then if you look at demand which is
and then if you look at demand which is really driving this this this is all
really driving this this this is all
really driving this this this is all demographics the baby but it’s and it’s
demographics the baby but it’s and it’s
demographics the baby but it’s and it’s all about the baby boomers surprise
all about the baby boomers surprise
all about the baby boomers surprise right so the baby boomers have come of
right so the baby boomers have come of
right so the baby boomers have come of age they’re now hitting the age of 65
age they’re now hitting the age of 65
age they’re now hitting the age of 65 and in the next ten years that
and in the next ten years that
and in the next ten years that population is going to increase by at
population is going to increase by at
population is going to increase by at least 40 to 50 percent and you know who
least 40 to 50 percent and you know who
least 40 to 50 percent and you know who uses healthcare it’s the older people so
uses healthcare it’s the older people so
uses healthcare it’s the older people so what we have now is a perfect storm
what we have now is a perfect storm
what we have now is a perfect storm we have decreasing volume of care that
we have decreasing volume of care that
we have decreasing volume of care that we can we can give and we have a surge
we can we can give and we have a surge
we can we can give and we have a surge and demand so we have an aging physician
and demand so we have an aging physician
and demand so we have an aging physician population in 2016 more physicians
population in 2016 more physicians
population in 2016 more physicians retired then then went into practice
retired then then went into practice
retired then then went into practice it’s the first time that’s happened we
it’s the first time that’s happened we
it’s the first time that’s happened we have fewer surgeons work in fewer hours
have fewer surgeons work in fewer hours
have fewer surgeons work in fewer hours when it really takes more surgeons to do
when it really takes more surgeons to do
when it really takes more surgeons to do the same amount of work and we have more
the same amount of work and we have more
the same amount of work and we have more work to do so where are the surgeons now
work to do so where are the surgeons now
work to do so where are the surgeons now anybody who’s looked at demographics
anybody who’s looked at demographics
anybody who’s looked at demographics knew this should have been coming and
knew this should have been coming and
knew this should have been coming and some people did but I mean it’s as if
some people did but I mean it’s as if
some people did but I mean it’s as if things really haven’t changed
things really haven’t changed
things really haven’t changed until it’s a crisis point and that’s
until it’s a crisis point and that’s
until it’s a crisis point and that’s common in many portions of healthcare
common in many portions of healthcare
common in many portions of healthcare why don’t we just train more surgeons I
why don’t we just train more surgeons I
why don’t we just train more surgeons I mean that’s you know just train just
mean that’s you know just train just
mean that’s you know just train just train more well it’s not quite that
train more well it’s not quite that
train more well it’s not quite that simple it’s extremely expensive it’s
simple it’s extremely expensive it’s
simple it’s extremely expensive it’s complicated you know Americans don’t
complicated you know Americans don’t
complicated you know Americans don’t really like mediocre surgeons so you got
really like mediocre surgeons so you got
really like mediocre surgeons so you got to be thoughtful about it they actually
to be thoughtful about it they actually
to be thoughtful about it they actually have started they’ve been trying to
have started they’ve been trying to
have started they’ve been trying to train more surgeons for the past ten
train more surgeons for the past ten
train more surgeons for the past ten years they’ve made a conscious effort to
years they’ve made a conscious effort to
years they’ve made a conscious effort to improve to increase the number of
improve to increase the number of
improve to increase the number of surgery residents and they have actually
surgery residents and they have actually
surgery residents and they have actually increased it by 100 in the last 10 years
increased it by 100 in the last 10 years
increased it by 100 in the last 10 years so right now approximately 1,100 chief
so right now approximately 1,100 chief
so right now approximately 1,100 chief residents graduate every every year it
residents graduate every every year it
residents graduate every every year it takes a minimum of five years to finish
takes a minimum of five years to finish
takes a minimum of five years to finish a general surgery residency a minimum
a general surgery residency a minimum
a general surgery residency a minimum most people take longer and then it gets
most people take longer and then it gets
most people take longer and then it gets really complicated of that 1,100 people
really complicated of that 1,100 people
really complicated of that 1,100 people that finish 90 percent of them go on for
that finish 90 percent of them go on for
that finish 90 percent of them go on for subspecialty training and but what’s
subspecialty training and but what’s
subspecialty training and but what’s when it’s all said and done you end up
when it’s all said and done you end up
when it’s all said and done you end up with fewer than 200 general surgeons who
with fewer than 200 general surgeons who
with fewer than 200 general surgeons who are coming out to join fewer than 200
are coming out to join fewer than 200
are coming out to join fewer than 200 chief residents who come out to join the
chief residents who come out to join the
chief residents who come out to join the pool of general surgeons who are out
pool of general surgeons who are out
pool of general surgeons who are out taking care of hospital emergencies and
taking care of hospital emergencies and
taking care of hospital emergencies and doing all the elective surgery it has to
doing all the elective surgery it has to
doing all the elective surgery it has to be done and then when you finish you
be done and then when you finish you
be done and then when you finish you still got to go do the job and general
still got to go do the job and general
still got to go do the job and general surgery is still intense it’s stressful
surgery is still intense it’s stressful
surgery is still intense it’s stressful it’s physically and mentally challenging
it’s physically and mentally challenging
it’s physically and mentally challenging remember we’re the Marines right it’s
remember we’re the Marines right it’s
remember we’re the Marines right it’s getting harder to get the younger
getting harder to get the younger
getting harder to get the younger surgeons to sign up what you still need
surgeons to sign up what you still need
surgeons to sign up what you still need a broader skill set in the rural
a broader skill set in the rural
a broader skill set in the rural communities which is intimidating just
communities which is intimidating just
communities which is intimidating just to the younger surgeons the rural
to the younger surgeons the rural
to the younger surgeons the rural markets are smaller and have a harder
markets are smaller and have a harder
markets are smaller and have a harder time supporting a large number of
time supporting a large number of
time supporting a large number of surgeons to share the burden of call so
surgeons to share the burden of call so
surgeons to share the burden of call so the fewer surgeons you have the worst of
the fewer surgeons you have the worst of
the fewer surgeons you have the worst of the lifestyle we have an increasingly
the lifestyle we have an increasingly
the lifestyle we have an increasingly negative feedback loop
negative feedback loop
negative feedback loop it’s that play in rural communities and
it’s that play in rural communities and
it’s that play in rural communities and it’s really making hard for the for the
it’s really making hard for the for the
it’s really making hard for the for the hospitals to feel the team to cover
hospitals to feel the team to cover
hospitals to feel the team to cover the entire process now Congress has
the entire process now Congress has
the entire process now Congress has noticed in June of this year they said
noticed in June of this year they said
noticed in June of this year they said they introduced a bill both both the
they introduced a bill both both the
they introduced a bill both both the House and the Senate it’s the same bill
House and the Senate it’s the same bill
House and the Senate it’s the same bill where they acknowledge that there is a
where they acknowledge that there is a
where they acknowledge that there is a shortage of general surgeons and this
shortage of general surgeons and this
shortage of general surgeons and this bill suggested that we develop a
bill suggested that we develop a
bill suggested that we develop a methodology to study it and undecide
methodology to study it and undecide
methodology to study it and undecide which populations are going to be at
which populations are going to be at
which populations are going to be at risk I’d submit it’s probably a little
risk I’d submit it’s probably a little
risk I’d submit it’s probably a little bit it’s a little too little and a
bit it’s a little too little and a
bit it’s a little too little and a little too late to help us in the near
little too late to help us in the near
little too late to help us in the near future anyway so I’ve told you what’s
future anyway so I’ve told you what’s
future anyway so I’ve told you what’s bad and now I’m going to kind of tell
bad and now I’m going to kind of tell
bad and now I’m going to kind of tell you what what the bridge is at life
you what what the bridge is at life
you what what the bridge is at life point so what we’re trying to do to
point so what we’re trying to do to
point so what we’re trying to do to mitigate these shortages was has
mitigate these shortages was has
mitigate these shortages was has developed strategies to help the
developed strategies to help the
developed strategies to help the surgeons in the community and and my
surgeons in the community and and my
surgeons in the community and and my group how many point surgeries was the
group how many point surgeries was the
group how many point surgeries was the first step that LifePoint Wentz who they
first step that LifePoint Wentz who they
first step that LifePoint Wentz who they hired me in late 2013 to put this group
hired me in late 2013 to put this group
hired me in late 2013 to put this group together and this is part of our guys
together and this is part of our guys
together and this is part of our guys and they don’t much look like a Special
and they don’t much look like a Special
and they don’t much look like a Special Forces team but they’re really really
Forces team but they’re really really
Forces team but they’re really really talented good guys and so what we do is
talented good guys and so what we do is
talented good guys and so what we do is we we go into these communities and we
we we go into these communities and we
we we go into these communities and we add just help just a body first off but
add just help just a body first off but
add just help just a body first off but what we have intellectual expertise and
what we have intellectual expertise and
what we have intellectual expertise and resources and leadership skills and
resources and leadership skills and
resources and leadership skills and we’ve had a very significant success in
we’ve had a very significant success in
we’ve had a very significant success in the short term and well but what we
the short term and well but what we
the short term and well but what we found is when we left you give that a
found is when we left you give that a
found is when we left you give that a little bit of time then these hospitals
little bit of time then these hospitals
little bit of time then these hospitals would kind of fall back in their same
would kind of fall back in their same
would kind of fall back in their same pattern where things were kind of
pattern where things were kind of
pattern where things were kind of falling off the rack again so we had to
falling off the rack again so we had to
falling off the rack again so we had to come up with another strategy so about
come up with another strategy so about
come up with another strategy so about two years ago we started working on
two years ago we started working on
two years ago we started working on developing about three years ago
developing about three years ago
developing about three years ago developing structured acute care surgery
developing structured acute care surgery
developing structured acute care surgery programs now if you know anything about
programs now if you know anything about
programs now if you know anything about the about the business we’ve been
the about the business we’ve been
the about the business we’ve been putting these in larger institutions
putting these in larger institutions
putting these in larger institutions that have high volumes for several years
that have high volumes for several years
that have high volumes for several years now but there really has been no
now but there really has been no
now but there really has been no experience in the smaller Hospital so we
experience in the smaller Hospital so we
experience in the smaller Hospital so we we’ve been putting these in where you’d
we’ve been putting these in where you’d
we’ve been putting these in where you’d actually develop a team approach for
actually develop a team approach for
actually develop a team approach for taking care of acutely ill surgical
taking care of acutely ill surgical
taking care of acutely ill surgical patients in the hospital and you do it
patients in the hospital and you do it
patients in the hospital and you do it by having a shift approach to hospital
by having a shift approach to hospital
by having a shift approach to hospital care and what that does is it allows the
care and what that does is it allows the
care and what that does is it allows the surgeons to compartmentalize their
surgeons to compartmentalize their
surgeons to compartmentalize their workload they can avoid long stretches
workload they can avoid long stretches
workload they can avoid long stretches of call but but the other important part
of call but but the other important part
of call but but the other important part is it separates their
is it separates their
is it separates their elective practice from the emerging care
elective practice from the emerging care
elective practice from the emerging care now what it’s really stressful when
now what it’s really stressful when
now what it’s really stressful when you’re running a clinic seeing patients
you’re running a clinic seeing patients
you’re running a clinic seeing patients and they call you the emergency room or
and they call you the emergency room or
and they call you the emergency room or to the floor for some kind of a consult
to the floor for some kind of a consult
to the floor for some kind of a consult it happens all the time it’s incredibly
it happens all the time it’s incredibly
it happens all the time it’s incredibly disruptive it inconveniences the
disruptive it inconveniences the
disruptive it inconveniences the patients is stressful as the surgeons
patients is stressful as the surgeons
patients is stressful as the surgeons have a hard time getting back on track
have a hard time getting back on track
have a hard time getting back on track so this these programs separate all that
so this these programs separate all that
so this these programs separate all that and it and it makes their the surgeons
and it and it makes their the surgeons
and it and it makes their the surgeons lives more predictable less stressed
lives more predictable less stressed
lives more predictable less stressed better lifestyle and in fact we have a
better lifestyle and in fact we have a
better lifestyle and in fact we have a program that’s been in fact for about
program that’s been in fact for about
program that’s been in fact for about eighteen 18 months just down the road at
eighteen 18 months just down the road at
eighteen 18 months just down the road at Wilson Regional Medical Center and it’s
Wilson Regional Medical Center and it’s
Wilson Regional Medical Center and it’s been extremely effective by all accounts
been extremely effective by all accounts
been extremely effective by all accounts and it’s allowed them to recruit younger
and it’s allowed them to recruit younger
and it’s allowed them to recruit younger surgeons into their practice in the last
surgeons into their practice in the last
surgeons into their practice in the last year and a half which they they were
year and a half which they they were
year and a half which they they were unable to do before this program was put
unable to do before this program was put
unable to do before this program was put into effect now other strategies aren’t
into effect now other strategies aren’t
into effect now other strategies aren’t far as far down the line and they’re in
far as far down the line and they’re in
far as far down the line and they’re in their kind of longer place we are
their kind of longer place we are
their kind of longer place we are partnering with university residency
partnering with university residency
partnering with university residency programs because we know there are
programs because we know there are
programs because we know there are general surgeon residents out there who
general surgeon residents out there who
general surgeon residents out there who want to work in rural communities and
want to work in rural communities and
want to work in rural communities and we’re trying to identify give these the
we’re trying to identify give these the
we’re trying to identify give these the university some resources we want to
university some resources we want to
university some resources we want to identify them first support them and
identify them first support them and
identify them first support them and then recruit them into our hospitals
then recruit them into our hospitals
then recruit them into our hospitals before somebody else stalks them out of
before somebody else stalks them out of
before somebody else stalks them out of it which is really what’s going on in a
it which is really what’s going on in a
it which is really what’s going on in a lot of these a lot of these training
lot of these a lot of these training
lot of these a lot of these training programs we only have a few programs and
programs we only have a few programs and
programs we only have a few programs and it’s just it’s one our list to get done
it’s just it’s one our list to get done
it’s just it’s one our list to get done in the next year so and longer the last
in the next year so and longer the last
in the next year so and longer the last two really are just kind of idea is that
two really are just kind of idea is that
two really are just kind of idea is that we hadn’t gotten much much traction with
we hadn’t gotten much much traction with
we hadn’t gotten much much traction with with with my leadership probably because
with with my leadership probably because
with with my leadership probably because they really cost a lot of money but you
they really cost a lot of money but you
they really cost a lot of money but you know robotic surgery and advanced
know robotic surgery and advanced
know robotic surgery and advanced laparoscopic surgery are kind of the
laparoscopic surgery are kind of the
laparoscopic surgery are kind of the next thing and again
next thing and again
next thing and again there’s almost no general surgery cases
there’s almost no general surgery cases
there’s almost no general surgery cases that we can’t do in a rural hospital
that we can’t do in a rural hospital
that we can’t do in a rural hospital aisle yet if you got a power source you
aisle yet if you got a power source you
aisle yet if you got a power source you can plug up your computers and and you
can plug up your computers and and you
can plug up your computers and and you can do this robotic surgery it’s just
can do this robotic surgery it’s just
can do this robotic surgery it’s just incredibly expensive I mean each robot
incredibly expensive I mean each robot
incredibly expensive I mean each robot costs a million dollars but we know
costs a million dollars but we know
costs a million dollars but we know we’re not going to be able to recruit
we’re not going to be able to recruit
we’re not going to be able to recruit the the younger generation of highly
the the younger generation of highly
the the younger generation of highly technically trained robotic surgeons
technically trained robotic surgeons
technically trained robotic surgeons unless we get this but there’s no reason
unless we get this but there’s no reason
unless we get this but there’s no reason we couldn’t get it so that’s that’s
we couldn’t get it so that’s that’s
we couldn’t get it so that’s that’s that’s the next time my gender that
that’s the next time my gender that
that’s the next time my gender that we’re working with and then there’s got
we’re working with and then there’s got
we’re working with and then there’s got to be some government
to be some government
to be some government in intervention here there is some
in intervention here there is some
in intervention here there is some precedence with you know loan repayment
precedence with you know loan repayment
precedence with you know loan repayment for rural commitment and then the j-1
for rural commitment and then the j-1
for rural commitment and then the j-1 visa program which which is really kind
visa program which which is really kind
visa program which which is really kind of off the off the agenda at this point
of off the off the agenda at this point
of off the off the agenda at this point with this certain with this current
with this certain with this current
with this certain with this current administration but there’s really
administration but there’s really
administration but there’s really nothing going on in this field right now
nothing going on in this field right now
nothing going on in this field right now and it’s not going to be until the
and it’s not going to be until the
and it’s not going to be until the electorate really starts to complain so
electorate really starts to complain so
electorate really starts to complain so just to review the takeaways there is a
just to review the takeaways there is a
just to review the takeaways there is a surge a shortage of surgeons in rural
surge a shortage of surgeons in rural
surge a shortage of surgeons in rural America and in ten years it’s gonna be
America and in ten years it’s gonna be
America and in ten years it’s gonna be all over America except for the nicest
all over America except for the nicest
all over America except for the nicest cities it’s a big deal
cities it’s a big deal
cities it’s a big deal it’s gonna affect all the constituents
it’s gonna affect all the constituents
it’s gonna affect all the constituents there are some practical short-term
there are some practical short-term
there are some practical short-term solutions but the long term is going to
solutions but the long term is going to
solutions but the long term is going to be a problem
be a problem
be a problem you can’t help support your local
you can’t help support your local
you can’t help support your local hospital when it’s possible you can tell
hospital when it’s possible you can tell
hospital when it’s possible you can tell your friends you can contact your
your friends you can contact your
your friends you can contact your elected officials but this is what it’s
elected officials but this is what it’s
elected officials but this is what it’s about
Thanks
Thanks [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment