
[Applause] every one so how do you know what’s real
every one so how do you know what’s real
every one so how do you know what’s real does that seem like a pretty obvious
does that seem like a pretty obvious
does that seem like a pretty obvious question and given the title of my talk
question and given the title of my talk
question and given the title of my talk do you think I’m just gonna say science
do you think I’m just gonna say science
do you think I’m just gonna say science well I would argue that it’s less
well I would argue that it’s less
well I would argue that it’s less important to know all the facts then
important to know all the facts then
important to know all the facts then this is to be able to share ideas the
this is to be able to share ideas the
this is to be able to share ideas the facts will come along with that process
facts will come along with that process
facts will come along with that process in order to ignite a movement a
in order to ignite a movement a
in order to ignite a movement a scientific idea sharing millions of
scientific idea sharing millions of
scientific idea sharing millions of others n I decided to march for science
others n I decided to march for science
others n I decided to march for science but also often asked the question why
but also often asked the question why
but also often asked the question why would you march for science I do think a
would you march for science I do think a
would you march for science I do think a lot about this because it was a good
lot about this because it was a good
lot about this because it was a good question
question
question what kind of March for science bring us
what kind of March for science bring us
what kind of March for science bring us marching for social issues makes more
marching for social issues makes more
marching for social issues makes more immediate sense because the direct
immediate sense because the direct
immediate sense because the direct impact that social problems have on
impact that social problems have on
impact that social problems have on people’s lives scientists themselves
people’s lives scientists themselves
people’s lives scientists themselves worried that this March might politicize
worried that this March might politicize
worried that this March might politicize science but here’s the thing science has
science but here’s the thing science has
science but here’s the thing science has never really been free from
never really been free from
never really been free from politicization because of the power
politicization because of the power
politicization because of the power provides one of our first champions of
provides one of our first champions of
provides one of our first champions of evidence-based reason Galileo was
evidence-based reason Galileo was
evidence-based reason Galileo was himself a victim of political
himself a victim of political
himself a victim of political suppression he was sharing ideas of the
suppression he was sharing ideas of the
suppression he was sharing ideas of the universe that the reigning power saw
universe that the reigning power saw
universe that the reigning power saw threatening at the time he was punished
threatening at the time he was punished
threatening at the time he was punished dearly for it controlling our
dearly for it controlling our
dearly for it controlling our perceptions of reality is very
perceptions of reality is very
perceptions of reality is very convenient for political groups to
convenient for political groups to
convenient for political groups to manipulate our opinions in order to
manipulate our opinions in order to
manipulate our opinions in order to achieve their agenda in fact if you can
achieve their agenda in fact if you can
achieve their agenda in fact if you can think of any oppressive political regime
think of any oppressive political regime
think of any oppressive political regime or social structure in history you can
or social structure in history you can
or social structure in history you can always find some manipulation of facts
always find some manipulation of facts
always find some manipulation of facts within it and if you need to ask
within it and if you need to ask
within it and if you need to ask yourself who has the power just answer
yourself who has the power just answer
yourself who has the power just answer the question who controls the knowledge
the question who controls the knowledge
the question who controls the knowledge the only way to resist this gradual
the only way to resist this gradual
the only way to resist this gradual creep of mass delusion is to be properly
creep of mass delusion is to be properly
creep of mass delusion is to be properly armed with tools to figure out nonsense
armed with tools to figure out nonsense
armed with tools to figure out nonsense we could be headed off a metaphorical
we could be headed off a metaphorical
we could be headed off a metaphorical cliff whether we choose to believe in it
cliff whether we choose to believe in it
cliff whether we choose to believe in it or not and science provides us an
or not and science provides us an
or not and science provides us an efficient method of discovering facts in
efficient method of discovering facts in
efficient method of discovering facts in order to learn how to avoid the cliff
order to learn how to avoid the cliff
order to learn how to avoid the cliff but it doesn’t necessarily help us with
but it doesn’t necessarily help us with
but it doesn’t necessarily help us with that
that
that central component of communicating the
central component of communicating the
central component of communicating the facts so that everyone can avoid the
facts so that everyone can avoid the
facts so that everyone can avoid the cliff the most powerful tools we can
cliff the most powerful tools we can
cliff the most powerful tools we can imagine our meaningless if no one knows
imagine our meaningless if no one knows
imagine our meaningless if no one knows how to use them those same tools could
how to use them those same tools could
how to use them those same tools could be weapons only if you know how to use
be weapons only if you know how to use
be weapons only if you know how to use them you want an example don’t Eve you
them you want an example don’t Eve you
them you want an example don’t Eve you know how to code with computers so not
know how to code with computers so not
know how to code with computers so not only is it good to advocate for science
only is it good to advocate for science
only is it good to advocate for science it’s morally necessary for a
it’s morally necessary for a
it’s morally necessary for a well-functioning society and yet we shy
well-functioning society and yet we shy
well-functioning society and yet we shy away from these conversations because
away from these conversations because
away from these conversations because some are on the along the progression of
some are on the along the progression of
some are on the along the progression of the internet more people than ever have
the internet more people than ever have
the internet more people than ever have wrapped up their understanding of the
wrapped up their understanding of the
wrapped up their understanding of the world into their personal identities
world into their personal identities
world into their personal identities verifying evidence on the Internet is
verifying evidence on the Internet is
verifying evidence on the Internet is actually extremely difficult because you
actually extremely difficult because you
actually extremely difficult because you can find false or conflicting
can find false or conflicting
can find false or conflicting information about anything to verify
information about anything to verify
information about anything to verify your preconceived notions finding
your preconceived notions finding
your preconceived notions finding company who never challenge your beliefs
company who never challenge your beliefs
company who never challenge your beliefs is also easy online and tribalism is
is also easy online and tribalism is
is also easy online and tribalism is rampant you can imagine your real
rampant you can imagine your real
rampant you can imagine your real community with a diversity of opinions
community with a diversity of opinions
community with a diversity of opinions 8bd all going onto the internet and
8bd all going onto the internet and
8bd all going onto the internet and segregating into similar opinions and
segregating into similar opinions and
segregating into similar opinions and digital communities as an older
digital communities as an older
digital communities as an older millennial I grew up watching these
millennial I grew up watching these
millennial I grew up watching these dynamics developed getting my first
dynamics developed getting my first
dynamics developed getting my first computer and middle school and having my
computer and middle school and having my
computer and middle school and having my first conversations online shortly after
first conversations online shortly after
first conversations online shortly after it turns out for most of my life I was
it turns out for most of my life I was
it turns out for most of my life I was not good at this I came from blue-collar
not good at this I came from blue-collar
not good at this I came from blue-collar roots and I can’t say that understanding
roots and I can’t say that understanding
roots and I can’t say that understanding the world was a major topic of
the world was a major topic of
the world was a major topic of conversation in my family growing up
conversation in my family growing up
conversation in my family growing up like most families it didn’t make sense
like most families it didn’t make sense
like most families it didn’t make sense to do because getting by and enjoying
to do because getting by and enjoying
to do because getting by and enjoying what we had in front of us was most
what we had in front of us was most
what we had in front of us was most important my parents got their nightly
important my parents got their nightly
important my parents got their nightly news from the television and that was
news from the television and that was
news from the television and that was enough I was lucky that they encouraged
enough I was lucky that they encouraged
enough I was lucky that they encouraged my passions they exposed me to science
my passions they exposed me to science
my passions they exposed me to science as a kid and I took it in like a sponge
as a kid and I took it in like a sponge
as a kid and I took it in like a sponge zoos museums Magic School Bus Discovery
zoos museums Magic School Bus Discovery
zoos museums Magic School Bus Discovery World I remember growing up thinking
World I remember growing up thinking
World I remember growing up thinking this is the good stuff that everyone
this is the good stuff that everyone
this is the good stuff that everyone would want to know I mean why wouldn’t
would want to know I mean why wouldn’t
would want to know I mean why wouldn’t they as we speak as we speak stars are
they as we speak as we speak stars are
they as we speak as we speak stars are exploding and their guts are being
exploding and their guts are being
exploding and their guts are being condensed into planets containing the
condensed into planets containing the
condensed into planets containing the elements that make up your bodies your
elements that make up your bodies your
elements that make up your bodies your very bodies oh just happened again and
very bodies oh just happened again and
very bodies oh just happened again and if you can tell science education became
if you can tell science education became
if you can tell science education became a huge passion for me
a huge passion for me
a huge passion for me and I spent a lot of time in college
and I spent a lot of time in college
and I spent a lot of time in college doing science education and then I
doing science education and then I
doing science education and then I learned a lot about sharing facts but if
learned a lot about sharing facts but if
learned a lot about sharing facts but if I’m being honest with you I never got
I’m being honest with you I never got
I’m being honest with you I never got much beyond simply sharing the facts
much beyond simply sharing the facts
much beyond simply sharing the facts direct education is extremely important
direct education is extremely important
direct education is extremely important but it only reaches those who are
but it only reaches those who are
but it only reaches those who are interested in listening to you I never
interested in listening to you I never
interested in listening to you I never asked questions about why people should
asked questions about why people should
asked questions about why people should listen to me or what I could learn from
listen to me or what I could learn from
listen to me or what I could learn from them even coming from a family who
them even coming from a family who
them even coming from a family who doesn’t have too much of a scientific
doesn’t have too much of a scientific
doesn’t have too much of a scientific background I didn’t think too much about
background I didn’t think too much about
background I didn’t think too much about how someone might perceive someone
how someone might perceive someone
how someone might perceive someone telling them what should be important to
telling them what should be important to
telling them what should be important to them so what I would chime in was
them so what I would chime in was
them so what I would chime in was something like well actually I shouldn’t
something like well actually I shouldn’t
something like well actually I shouldn’t have been surprised when my comments
have been surprised when my comments
have been surprised when my comments weren’t exactly appreciated as an adult
weren’t exactly appreciated as an adult
weren’t exactly appreciated as an adult I saw my own lecture in attitude clash
I saw my own lecture in attitude clash
I saw my own lecture in attitude clash with my family during those classic
with my family during those classic
with my family during those classic social media comments and dinner table
social media comments and dinner table
social media comments and dinner table conversations we’ve all had that
conversations we’ve all had that
conversations we’ve all had that Thanksgiving to this day I have a family
Thanksgiving to this day I have a family
Thanksgiving to this day I have a family member who grew up two doors away from
member who grew up two doors away from
member who grew up two doors away from me who helped raise me who fed me
me who helped raise me who fed me
me who helped raise me who fed me biscuits and gravy on Saturday mornings
biscuits and gravy on Saturday mornings
biscuits and gravy on Saturday mornings who probably wouldn’t talk to me today
who probably wouldn’t talk to me today
who probably wouldn’t talk to me today because of words I’ve used to them I’ll
because of words I’ve used to them I’ll
because of words I’ve used to them I’ll forever got saying you don’t know what
forever got saying you don’t know what
forever got saying you don’t know what you’re talking about to someone that I
you’re talking about to someone that I
you’re talking about to someone that I loved because it really happened is we
loved because it really happened is we
loved because it really happened is we don’t know how to talk with each other I
don’t know how to talk with each other I
don’t know how to talk with each other I didn’t get too much of this reality
didn’t get too much of this reality
didn’t get too much of this reality check in academia either I spent eight
check in academia either I spent eight
check in academia either I spent eight years in research institutions during my
years in research institutions during my
years in research institutions during my master’s degree and afterwards as a
master’s degree and afterwards as a
master’s degree and afterwards as a research specialist and I was hard
research specialist and I was hard
research specialist and I was hard pressed to find people who disagreed
pressed to find people who disagreed
pressed to find people who disagreed with me on any of the hot-button
with me on any of the hot-button
with me on any of the hot-button scientific issues I mean sure the
scientific issues I mean sure the
scientific issues I mean sure the science community argues over various
science community argues over various
science community argues over various hypotheses and the interpretation of
hypotheses and the interpretation of
hypotheses and the interpretation of results but overall people in scientific
results but overall people in scientific
results but overall people in scientific circles share similar values and take
circles share similar values and take
circles share similar values and take for granted the process of knowing
for granted the process of knowing
for granted the process of knowing what’s real we just share the facts and
what’s real we just share the facts and
what’s real we just share the facts and hope people appreciate them because
hope people appreciate them because
hope people appreciate them because we’ve done the work they haven’t let’s
we’ve done the work they haven’t let’s
we’ve done the work they haven’t let’s also be frank feeling like you have all
also be frank feeling like you have all
also be frank feeling like you have all the answers can make you unwilling to
the answers can make you unwilling to
the answers can make you unwilling to engage with someone who’s challenging
engage with someone who’s challenging
engage with someone who’s challenging you that you think knows less than you
you that you think knows less than you
you that you think knows less than you if you don’t think it’s worth your time
if you don’t think it’s worth your time
if you don’t think it’s worth your time it’s important for me to say there are
it’s important for me to say there are
it’s important for me to say there are those in academia who are actively
those in academia who are actively
those in academia who are actively challenging this commute
challenging this commute
challenging this commute an issue in fact I think we could learn
an issue in fact I think we could learn
an issue in fact I think we could learn a lot from people who study culture in
a lot from people who study culture in
a lot from people who study culture in communication but let’s recap the state
communication but let’s recap the state
communication but let’s recap the state of things the science community has a
of things the science community has a
of things the science community has a communication challenge in front of us
communication challenge in front of us
communication challenge in front of us we want to discuss reality but aren’t
we want to discuss reality but aren’t
we want to discuss reality but aren’t effectively doing so outside of the
effectively doing so outside of the
effectively doing so outside of the choir then you have those who don’t have
choir then you have those who don’t have
choir then you have those who don’t have time or aren’t interested in
time or aren’t interested in
time or aren’t interested in communicating at all and finally there
communicating at all and finally there
communicating at all and finally there are those who have political motives to
are those who have political motives to
are those who have political motives to the way they treat scientific facts as
the way they treat scientific facts as
the way they treat scientific facts as societal rifts grew and grew through the
societal rifts grew and grew through the
societal rifts grew and grew through the echo chambers of the internet over the
echo chambers of the internet over the
echo chambers of the internet over the last presidential election something
last presidential election something
last presidential election something just felt necessary about this moment to
just felt necessary about this moment to
just felt necessary about this moment to finally say enough is enough we need to
finally say enough is enough we need to
finally say enough is enough we need to re-energize the public conversation
re-energize the public conversation
re-energize the public conversation about science that we saw when we landed
about science that we saw when we landed
about science that we saw when we landed people on the moon because if we lose
people on the moon because if we lose
people on the moon because if we lose those fundamental principles of knowing
those fundamental principles of knowing
those fundamental principles of knowing that our founding fathers valued so
that our founding fathers valued so
that our founding fathers valued so highly we lose our foundation of
highly we lose our foundation of
highly we lose our foundation of democracy the science community may not
democracy the science community may not
democracy the science community may not have caused this problem we’re gonna
have caused this problem we’re gonna
have caused this problem we’re gonna need to seriously re-evaluate our
need to seriously re-evaluate our
need to seriously re-evaluate our approach if we’re gonna help solve it
approach if we’re gonna help solve it
approach if we’re gonna help solve it this is why it was time to march for
this is why it was time to march for
this is why it was time to march for science with the fire of all these
science with the fire of all these
science with the fire of all these thoughts in my mind I joined the March
thoughts in my mind I joined the March
thoughts in my mind I joined the March for science organization team in
for science organization team in
for science organization team in Milwaukee found them online actually I
Milwaukee found them online actually I
Milwaukee found them online actually I was excited to see that they were hoping
was excited to see that they were hoping
was excited to see that they were hoping to tackle these very issues that I’d
to tackle these very issues that I’d
to tackle these very issues that I’d been struggling with we had a lot of
been struggling with we had a lot of
been struggling with we had a lot of conversations about what a march for
conversations about what a march for
conversations about what a march for science would look like whether we
science would look like whether we
science would look like whether we realized it or not we decided to
realized it or not we decided to
realized it or not we decided to implement ideas that scholars of
implement ideas that scholars of
implement ideas that scholars of communication have known about for a
communication have known about for a
communication have known about for a long time we were going to tell people
long time we were going to tell people
long time we were going to tell people what to think or why our way was better
what to think or why our way was better
what to think or why our way was better we were simply going to welcome everyone
we were simply going to welcome everyone
we were simply going to welcome everyone to celebrate science and encourage
to celebrate science and encourage
to celebrate science and encourage people from all backgrounds to find a
people from all backgrounds to find a
people from all backgrounds to find a piece of science that belongs to them
piece of science that belongs to them
piece of science that belongs to them something we can agree upon is a
something we can agree upon is a
something we can agree upon is a starting point to get our conversations
starting point to get our conversations
starting point to get our conversations going again this would be a welcoming
going again this would be a welcoming
going again this would be a welcoming celebration because we all stand a
celebration because we all stand a
celebration because we all stand a benefit from scientific achievements
benefit from scientific achievements
benefit from scientific achievements knowledge is empowering and we can all
knowledge is empowering and we can all
knowledge is empowering and we can all unite around that fact we had no enemies
unite around that fact we had no enemies
unite around that fact we had no enemies we weren’t against any institution we
we weren’t against any institution we
we weren’t against any institution we sought to be the movement of PRO we just
sought to be the movement of PRO we just
sought to be the movement of PRO we just wanted to stand together be nerds and
wanted to stand together be nerds and
wanted to stand together be nerds and get excited about science and we had a
get excited about science and we had a
get excited about science and we had a few approaches to achieve these goals we
few approaches to achieve these goals we
few approaches to achieve these goals we wrote articles to feature local
wrote articles to feature local
wrote articles to feature local scientists to try and break through the
scientists to try and break through the
scientists to try and break through the jargon and make their work more
jargon and make their work more
jargon and make their work more approachable we invited speakers to the
approachable we invited speakers to the
approachable we invited speakers to the march from a diverse background of life
march from a diverse background of life
march from a diverse background of life experiences in science to a lot of the
experiences in science to a lot of the
experiences in science to a lot of the public to better relate with them to
public to better relate with them to
public to better relate with them to show that scientists are part of our
show that scientists are part of our
show that scientists are part of our community they’re our neighbors and
community they’re our neighbors and
community they’re our neighbors and since many of them are paid with tax
since many of them are paid with tax
since many of them are paid with tax dollars they serve the public and the
dollars they serve the public and the
dollars they serve the public and the work contributes towards the greater
work contributes towards the greater
work contributes towards the greater good we also strategize ways we could
good we also strategize ways we could
good we also strategize ways we could bring people from every ideological
bring people from every ideological
bring people from every ideological background into the fold and reach out
background into the fold and reach out
background into the fold and reach out to those who might see us as threatening
to those who might see us as threatening
to those who might see us as threatening we networked with the outer suburbs and
we networked with the outer suburbs and
we networked with the outer suburbs and the inner cities we made a painstaking
the inner cities we made a painstaking
the inner cities we made a painstaking effort for inclusivity to make a
effort for inclusivity to make a
effort for inclusivity to make a political statement without having a
political statement without having a
political statement without having a partisan one in our messaging we made
partisan one in our messaging we made
partisan one in our messaging we made clear that partisan identities are
clear that partisan identities are
clear that partisan identities are irrelevant to the fact that science
irrelevant to the fact that science
irrelevant to the fact that science moves this planet forward it’s all
moves this planet forward it’s all
moves this planet forward it’s all around us it’s this it’s everything that
around us it’s this it’s everything that
around us it’s this it’s everything that you can look at in this room right now
you can look at in this room right now
you can look at in this room right now there are scientific achievements
there are scientific achievements
there are scientific achievements everywhere and finally we had a policy
everywhere and finally we had a policy
everywhere and finally we had a policy not to shy away from people who
not to shy away from people who
not to shy away from people who challenged us in doing this I learned a
challenged us in doing this I learned a
challenged us in doing this I learned a lot about navigating these conversations
lot about navigating these conversations
lot about navigating these conversations and it was one of my most reflective
and it was one of my most reflective
and it was one of my most reflective experiences we had one particular
experiences we had one particular
experiences we had one particular challenger leading up to the March that
challenger leading up to the March that
challenger leading up to the March that I’ll call Tim and Tim was not happy with
I’ll call Tim and Tim was not happy with
I’ll call Tim and Tim was not happy with us use some colorful language on social
us use some colorful language on social
us use some colorful language on social media she had to let us know Tim made
media she had to let us know Tim made
media she had to let us know Tim made clear that he saw what we were doing is
clear that he saw what we were doing is
clear that he saw what we were doing is threatening what he believed in we
threatening what he believed in we
threatening what he believed in we thought about ignoring Tim but we
thought about ignoring Tim but we
thought about ignoring Tim but we decided to engage him we asked questions
decided to engage him we asked questions
decided to engage him we asked questions like okay why are you feeling that way
like okay why are you feeling that way
like okay why are you feeling that way what matters to you and how can we
what matters to you and how can we
what matters to you and how can we address your concerns we wanted to let
address your concerns we wanted to let
address your concerns we wanted to let him know that not only did we have
him know that not only did we have
him know that not only did we have nothing against him we wanted to welcome
nothing against him we wanted to welcome
nothing against him we wanted to welcome him to the March and try to find
him to the March and try to find
him to the March and try to find something we both agreed upon in science
something we both agreed upon in science
something we both agreed upon in science and we could celebrate together I don’t
and we could celebrate together I don’t
and we could celebrate together I don’t think he expected that he stopped
think he expected that he stopped
think he expected that he stopped replying after too long but then on the
replying after too long but then on the
replying after too long but then on the day of the March there was Tim he
day of the March there was Tim he
day of the March there was Tim he approached our team as the guy we’d been
approached our team as the guy we’d been
approached our team as the guy we’d been interacting with on social media and he
interacting with on social media and he
interacting with on social media and he told us I really do support science I
told us I really do support science I
told us I really do support science I just thought you’d be biased
just thought you’d be biased
just thought you’d be biased Thanks drop being biased Tim marched
Thanks drop being biased Tim marched
Thanks drop being biased Tim marched alongside us and thousands of other
alongside us and thousands of other
alongside us and thousands of other people that day
people that day
people that day for him at least a common denominator
for him at least a common denominator
for him at least a common denominator was found between Tim and a bunch of
was found between Tim and a bunch of
was found between Tim and a bunch of nerds he’d have no interest in speaking
nerds he’d have no interest in speaking
nerds he’d have no interest in speaking to otherwise and I get what you’re
to otherwise and I get what you’re
to otherwise and I get what you’re thinking right now it may seem a little
thinking right now it may seem a little
thinking right now it may seem a little unbelievable but this really did happen
unbelievable but this really did happen
unbelievable but this really did happen but no no no no no this is not the magic
but no no no no no this is not the magic
but no no no no no this is not the magic bullet to solve all of society’s
bullet to solve all of society’s
bullet to solve all of society’s problems it’s true some people will
problems it’s true some people will
problems it’s true some people will never talk to you and plenty of people
never talk to you and plenty of people
never talk to you and plenty of people didn’t but by at least leaving the table
didn’t but by at least leaving the table
didn’t but by at least leaving the table open we engaged more people than we
open we engaged more people than we
open we engaged more people than we would have ever otherwise wouldn’t have
would have ever otherwise wouldn’t have
would have ever otherwise wouldn’t have reached him if we didn’t try through
reached him if we didn’t try through
reached him if we didn’t try through continuing that effort we can pull the
continuing that effort we can pull the
continuing that effort we can pull the average of society towards more
average of society towards more
average of society towards more reasonable and approachable discourse
reasonable and approachable discourse
reasonable and approachable discourse more people interested in discussing
more people interested in discussing
more people interested in discussing facts we founded the Milwaukee area
facts we founded the Milwaukee area
facts we founded the Milwaukee area science advocates to be that continuing
science advocates to be that continuing
science advocates to be that continuing force to help keep these important
force to help keep these important
force to help keep these important conversations about science alive and
conversations about science alive and
conversations about science alive and well and we’ve drawn some lessons for
well and we’ve drawn some lessons for
well and we’ve drawn some lessons for ourselves from the March and for this
ourselves from the March and for this
ourselves from the March and for this science move it as we continue forward
science move it as we continue forward
science move it as we continue forward the most important lesson is not for
the most important lesson is not for
the most important lesson is not for those who have unscientific beliefs
those who have unscientific beliefs
those who have unscientific beliefs people like me who are interested in
people like me who are interested in
people like me who are interested in sharing scientific ideas most critical
sharing scientific ideas most critical
sharing scientific ideas most critical is that the science community has to
is that the science community has to
is that the science community has to start getting themselves out there you
start getting themselves out there you
start getting themselves out there you have to and have the difficult
have to and have the difficult
have to and have the difficult conversations with the public not just
conversations with the public not just
conversations with the public not just at the annual symposium or the usual
at the annual symposium or the usual
at the annual symposium or the usual science venues but at the local Town
science venues but at the local Town
science venues but at the local Town Hall in the newspaper with elected
Hall in the newspaper with elected
Hall in the newspaper with elected officials and just out with your
officials and just out with your
officials and just out with your neighbors in the community I know it’s
neighbors in the community I know it’s
neighbors in the community I know it’s tough I know it’s a thick barrier to
tough I know it’s a thick barrier to
tough I know it’s a thick barrier to break and it may not always end well and
break and it may not always end well and
break and it may not always end well and maybe you don’t think it’s your job to
maybe you don’t think it’s your job to
maybe you don’t think it’s your job to be your own advocate but in a society
be your own advocate but in a society
be your own advocate but in a society where the public appreciation of science
where the public appreciation of science
where the public appreciation of science is dwindling those who think it’s not
is dwindling those who think it’s not
is dwindling those who think it’s not their job may soon be out of one they
their job may soon be out of one they
their job may soon be out of one they don’t speak out and we need you so
don’t speak out and we need you so
don’t speak out and we need you so please get on to the public share ideas
please get on to the public share ideas
please get on to the public share ideas when you do this it must be done with
when you do this it must be done with
when you do this it must be done with compassion the scientific process
compassion the scientific process
compassion the scientific process doesn’t have a heart but scientists have
doesn’t have a heart but scientists have
doesn’t have a heart but scientists have a heart so science communication needs a
a heart so science communication needs a
a heart so science communication needs a heart we have to have the humility that
heart we have to have the humility that
heart we have to have the humility that none of us are above taking the time to
none of us are above taking the time to
none of us are above taking the time to truly understand someone who disagrees
truly understand someone who disagrees
truly understand someone who disagrees with us let’s give less lectures and ask
with us let’s give less lectures and ask
with us let’s give less lectures and ask more questions let’s always have
more questions let’s always have
more questions let’s always have something to learn
something to learn
something to learn what matters to them as a person what
what matters to them as a person what
what matters to them as a person what are they perceiving about me or what am
are they perceiving about me or what am
are they perceiving about me or what am i perceiving about them that could be
i perceiving about them that could be
i perceiving about them that could be totally wrong remember that no one is
totally wrong remember that no one is
totally wrong remember that no one is there lists of facts and beliefs ideas
there lists of facts and beliefs ideas
there lists of facts and beliefs ideas exist outside of an individual and you
exist outside of an individual and you
exist outside of an individual and you might be right but you can be right in
might be right but you can be right in
might be right but you can be right in the wrong ways avoid ignorant straw
the wrong ways avoid ignorant straw
the wrong ways avoid ignorant straw man’s and leave the insults at home that
man’s and leave the insults at home that
man’s and leave the insults at home that gets us nowhere
gets us nowhere
gets us nowhere Alan Watts said if a person believes the
Alan Watts said if a person believes the
Alan Watts said if a person believes the earth is flat you’re not gonna talk him
earth is flat you’re not gonna talk him
earth is flat you’re not gonna talk him out of that he can look out the window
out of that he can look out the window
out of that he can look out the window and see that it’s flat the only way
and see that it’s flat the only way
and see that it’s flat the only way you’re gonna convince him that it isn’t
you’re gonna convince him that it isn’t
you’re gonna convince him that it isn’t is to say okay let’s go and find the
is to say okay let’s go and find the
is to say okay let’s go and find the edge so practice something that I’ve
edge so practice something that I’ve
edge so practice something that I’ve learned is called steel Manning you
learned is called steel Manning you
learned is called steel Manning you heard of this instead of the classic
heard of this instead of the classic
heard of this instead of the classic straw man where you mischaracterize an
straw man where you mischaracterize an
straw man where you mischaracterize an argument in order to make it easy to win
argument in order to make it easy to win
argument in order to make it easy to win maybe talk past each other maybe you
maybe talk past each other maybe you
maybe talk past each other maybe you make things up but you don’t realize
make things up but you don’t realize
make things up but you don’t realize you’re making things up try to form the
you’re making things up try to form the
you’re making things up try to form the best version the most reasonable version
best version the most reasonable version
best version the most reasonable version of an argument you disagree with state
of an argument you disagree with state
of an argument you disagree with state it back to the person you disagree with
it back to the person you disagree with
it back to the person you disagree with and see if they agree with your summary
and see if they agree with your summary
and see if they agree with your summary of their idea if not ask genuine
of their idea if not ask genuine
of their idea if not ask genuine questions try to get it right in their
questions try to get it right in their
questions try to get it right in their eyes see how well your ideas hold up
eyes see how well your ideas hold up
eyes see how well your ideas hold up against that version it’s crazy but you
against that version it’s crazy but you
against that version it’s crazy but you might even find you were wrong and why
might even find you were wrong and why
might even find you were wrong and why should we do this we need to find ways
should we do this we need to find ways
should we do this we need to find ways to have discussions without assuming bad
to have discussions without assuming bad
to have discussions without assuming bad intentions and work through
intentions and work through
intentions and work through disagreements with a spirit of goodwill
disagreements with a spirit of goodwill
disagreements with a spirit of goodwill or how are we gonna mend these ribs
or how are we gonna mend these ribs
or how are we gonna mend these ribs we have to talk to each other so how do
we have to talk to each other so how do
we have to talk to each other so how do you know what’s real you don’t really we
you know what’s real you don’t really we
you know what’s real you don’t really we only have tools to discover what’s true
only have tools to discover what’s true
only have tools to discover what’s true and methods of communicating what we’ve
and methods of communicating what we’ve
and methods of communicating what we’ve learned we can make that joint discovery
learned we can make that joint discovery
learned we can make that joint discovery beautiful instead of uncomfortable
beautiful instead of uncomfortable
beautiful instead of uncomfortable because science is humbling it exposes
because science is humbling it exposes
because science is humbling it exposes us to what we don’t know it makes idiots
us to what we don’t know it makes idiots
us to what we don’t know it makes idiots of us all being comfortable with that
of us all being comfortable with that
of us all being comfortable with that fact can be our d polarizer and our
fact can be our d polarizer and our
fact can be our d polarizer and our unifying force as we join together
unifying force as we join together
unifying force as we join together towards further knowing this needs to be
towards further knowing this needs to be
towards further knowing this needs to be the movement of science so let’s find
the movement of science so let’s find
the movement of science so let’s find the edge together thank you
the edge together thank you
the edge together thank you [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment