Press "Enter" to skip to content

All the single ladies: Impact of job promotions on divorce | Johanna Rickne | TEDxUppsalaUniversity


hello everyone it’s really really nice

hello everyone it’s really really nice to meet y’all my name is Johanna and I’m

to meet y’all my name is Johanna and I’m

to meet y’all my name is Johanna and I’m a researcher in economics and one

a researcher in economics and one

a researcher in economics and one question that I’m very interested in in

question that I’m very interested in in

question that I’m very interested in in my work is the opportunities that people

my work is the opportunities that people

my work is the opportunities that people have to pursue their goals and dreams in

have to pursue their goals and dreams in

have to pursue their goals and dreams in their lives so if you all take a second

their lives so if you all take a second

their lives so if you all take a second and like quickly try to picture in your

and like quickly try to picture in your

and like quickly try to picture in your minds

minds

minds what your own goals are for your own

what your own goals are for your own

what your own goals are for your own future okay so some of you might picture

future okay so some of you might picture

future okay so some of you might picture that dream job that great career and

that dream job that great career and

that dream job that great career and then others you may think of family

then others you may think of family

then others you may think of family loving relationship maybe children at

loving relationship maybe children at

loving relationship maybe children at least those are part of what I think of

least those are part of what I think of

least those are part of what I think of when I think of these things and the

when I think of these things and the

when I think of these things and the research that I’m going to talk about

research that I’m going to talk about

research that I’m going to talk about today shows that even today in Sweden

today shows that even today in Sweden

today shows that even today in Sweden women are substantially less likely to

women are substantially less likely to

women are substantially less likely to be able to achieve those goals than men

be able to achieve those goals than men

be able to achieve those goals than men are and as a background I’d like to tell

are and as a background I’d like to tell

are and as a background I’d like to tell you a story that happened when I was out

you a story that happened when I was out

you a story that happened when I was out presenting my work because when I am out

presenting my work because when I am out

presenting my work because when I am out talking about family and career people

talking about family and career people

talking about family and career people tend to come up afterwards and we want

tend to come up afterwards and we want

tend to come up afterwards and we want to discuss their own experiences and

to discuss their own experiences and

to discuss their own experiences and that’s great because you find out lots

that’s great because you find out lots

that’s great because you find out lots of stuff about people and in this

of stuff about people and in this

of stuff about people and in this particular case a woman was talking

particular case a woman was talking

particular case a woman was talking about some friends of hers this friend

about some friends of hers this friend

about some friends of hers this friend that was pursuing the position of mayor

that was pursuing the position of mayor

that was pursuing the position of mayor in Italy and it was really this woman’s

in Italy and it was really this woman’s

in Italy and it was really this woman’s dream to become a mayor and she was

dream to become a mayor and she was

dream to become a mayor and she was campaigning really hard and her husband

campaigning really hard and her husband

campaigning really hard and her husband was helping her to become a mayor he was

was helping her to become a mayor he was

was helping her to become a mayor he was out on the campaign trail with her but

out on the campaign trail with her but

out on the campaign trail with her but then after a very close election it

then after a very close election it

then after a very close election it ended up that she lost unfortunately and

ended up that she lost unfortunately and

ended up that she lost unfortunately and the husband was sad but then he confided

the husband was sad but then he confided

the husband was sad but then he confided in this friend that actually he wasn’t

in this friend that actually he wasn’t

in this friend that actually he wasn’t that sad he was actually can be relieved

that sad he was actually can be relieved

that sad he was actually can be relieved that she didn’t get this position after

that she didn’t get this position after

that she didn’t get this position after all so she would still be in her less

all so she would still be in her less

all so she would still be in her less demanding job and so what this story

demanding job and so what this story

demanding job and so what this story highlights is that there can be these

highlights is that there can be these

highlights is that there can be these conflicts between your career goals in

conflicts between your career goals in

conflicts between your career goals in life and your family situation and in

life and your family situation and in

life and your family situation and in our research me and my colleagues what

our research me and my colleagues what

our research me and my colleagues what we researched was in Sweden what the

we researched was in Sweden what the

we researched was in Sweden what the impacts are on women’s and men’s

impacts are on women’s and men’s

impacts are on women’s and men’s relationships from getting to these top

relationships from getting to these top

relationships from getting to these top jobs in politics and also in business so

jobs in politics and also in business so

jobs in politics and also in business so I’m going to tell you first how we

I’m going to tell you first how we

I’m going to tell you first how we analyze politics and we picked two jobs

analyze politics and we picked two jobs

analyze politics and we picked two jobs top jobs in Swedish politics in

top jobs in Swedish politics in

top jobs in Swedish politics in Parliament in Sweden in every electoral

Parliament in Sweden in every electoral

Parliament in Sweden in every electoral districts parties offer electoral

districts parties offer electoral

districts parties offer electoral ballots and so say your party wins five

ballots and so say your party wins five

ballots and so say your party wins five seats you count those five seats from

seats you count those five seats from

seats you count those five seats from the top of the ballot so for twenty year

the top of the ballot so for twenty year

the top of the ballot so for twenty year period in nine elections we could find

period in nine elections we could find

period in nine elections we could find in Swedish data all the marginal

in Swedish data all the marginal

in Swedish data all the marginal candidates on those lists in this case

candidates on those lists in this case

candidates on those lists in this case the fifth person that barely got into

the fifth person that barely got into

the fifth person that barely got into Parliament and the sixth person that

Parliament and the sixth person that

Parliament and the sixth person that wanted to be a parliamentarian but in

wanted to be a parliamentarian but in

wanted to be a parliamentarian but in the end couldn’t get in so we selected

the end couldn’t get in so we selected

the end couldn’t get in so we selected from Swedish data all those close

from Swedish data all those close

from Swedish data all those close contestants for Parliament and another

contestants for Parliament and another

contestants for Parliament and another point of data where we could find good

point of data where we could find good

point of data where we could find good data on promotions and people who lost

data on promotions and people who lost

data on promotions and people who lost promotions is for mayor in Sweden we

promotions is for mayor in Sweden we

promotions is for mayor in Sweden we have 300 municipalities and in each

have 300 municipalities and in each

have 300 municipalities and in each municipality you have a right bloc of

municipality you have a right bloc of

municipality you have a right bloc of parties right-wing bloc competing

parties right-wing bloc competing

parties right-wing bloc competing against the left-wing bloc and each one

against the left-wing bloc and each one

against the left-wing bloc and each one has a candidate for mayor so suppose

has a candidate for mayor so suppose

has a candidate for mayor so suppose that you guys on this side are the

that you guys on this side are the

that you guys on this side are the left-wing parties and you guys are the

left-wing parties and you guys are the

left-wing parties and you guys are the right-wing parties if you guys win 50

right-wing parties if you guys win 50

right-wing parties if you guys win 50 percent of the council seats your

percent of the council seats your

percent of the council seats your candidate for mayor becomes mayor and

candidate for mayor becomes mayor and

candidate for mayor becomes mayor and unfortunately for this side your

unfortunately for this side your

unfortunately for this side your candidate becomes opposition leader so

candidate becomes opposition leader so

candidate becomes opposition leader so they’re like the Italian woman that

they’re like the Italian woman that

they’re like the Italian woman that ended up not becoming mayor after all

ended up not becoming mayor after all

ended up not becoming mayor after all and so for these nine election periods

and so for these nine election periods

and so for these nine election periods and every one of the 300 municipalities

and every one of the 300 municipalities

and every one of the 300 municipalities we pick out in the data all these rivals

we pick out in the data all these rivals

we pick out in the data all these rivals people who wanted to become mayor and

people who wanted to become mayor and

people who wanted to become mayor and we’re of some people ended up getting

we’re of some people ended up getting

we’re of some people ended up getting the position and in Sweden thanks to

the position and in Sweden thanks to

the position and in Sweden thanks to personal identity sure numbers we have

personal identity sure numbers we have

personal identity sure numbers we have very good data and we know for everyone

very good data and we know for everyone

very good data and we know for everyone in this data set precisely if they were

in this data set precisely if they were

in this data set precisely if they were married or divorced in each individual

married or divorced in each individual

married or divorced in each individual year and we also know many other

year and we also know many other

year and we also know many other background variables about these people

background variables about these people

background variables about these people so using this data we can go for years

so using this data we can go for years

so using this data we can go for years prior in time to when this election

prior in time to when this election

prior in time to when this election happened and we can compare the women

happened and we can compare the women

happened and we can compare the women who lost to the women who

who lost to the women who

who lost to the women who and we can compare many variables and

and we can compare many variables and

and we can compare many variables and here is just an example the women who

here is just an example the women who

here is just an example the women who were promoted are very similar in these

were promoted are very similar in these

were promoted are very similar in these variables to the women who were not

variables to the women who were not

variables to the women who were not promoted they are similar age they’re

promoted they are similar age they’re

promoted they are similar age they’re similarly likely to have children they

similarly likely to have children they

similarly likely to have children they have been married for similar lengths of

have been married for similar lengths of

have been married for similar lengths of time and make similar amount of money

time and make similar amount of money

time and make similar amount of money and the same thing happens in the data

and the same thing happens in the data

and the same thing happens in the data for men the men who win and lose are

for men the men who win and lose are

for men the men who win and lose are also very similar to each other on these

also very similar to each other on these

also very similar to each other on these observable characteristics

observable characteristics

observable characteristics okay so keeping in mind that these

okay so keeping in mind that these

okay so keeping in mind that these people are very similar to each other

people are very similar to each other

people are very similar to each other the winner and the losers we can then go

the winner and the losers we can then go

the winner and the losers we can then go for years back in time before each one

for years back in time before each one

for years back in time before each one of these elections and we can plot in

of these elections and we can plot in

of these elections and we can plot in the graph and the probability to remain

the graph and the probability to remain

the graph and the probability to remain married so we take all these candidates

married so we take all these candidates

married so we take all these candidates and we restrict the data to the people

and we restrict the data to the people

and we restrict the data to the people who are married four years prior to the

who are married four years prior to the

who are married four years prior to the election this is 70 percent of the men

election this is 70 percent of the men

election this is 70 percent of the men and 60 percent of the women so this

and 60 percent of the women so this

and 60 percent of the women so this figure starts it starts to count down on

figure starts it starts to count down on

figure starts it starts to count down on the horizontal axis to the election –

the horizontal axis to the election –

the horizontal axis to the election – four years – three years and the line

four years – three years and the line

four years – three years and the line starts at one because by construction

starts at one because by construction

starts at one because by construction 100 percent of the people in the data

100 percent of the people in the data

100 percent of the people in the data are married and then each year a certain

are married and then each year a certain

are married and then each year a certain number of relationships fall apart so we

number of relationships fall apart so we

number of relationships fall apart so we see a declining trend in the proportion

see a declining trend in the proportion

see a declining trend in the proportion that remained married to their partner

that remained married to their partner

that remained married to their partner and in this figure these gray lines

and in this figure these gray lines

and in this figure these gray lines right now they show the development in

right now they show the development in

right now they show the development in the probability remain married for

the probability remain married for

the probability remain married for people who did not get the promotion and

people who did not get the promotion and

people who did not get the promotion and the promotion happened here happens here

the promotion happened here happens here

the promotion happened here happens here at this black line and then year one is

at this black line and then year one is

at this black line and then year one is the first year on the job etc okay so

the first year on the job etc okay so

the first year on the job etc okay so now we’re going to look at the

now we’re going to look at the

now we’re going to look at the development for men who did get the

development for men who did get the

development for men who did get the promotion okay so when I add the line

promotion okay so when I add the line

promotion okay so when I add the line for men you can hardly see it because it

for men you can hardly see it because it

for men you can hardly see it because it perfectly overlaps with the line for men

perfectly overlaps with the line for men

perfectly overlaps with the line for men who lost the promotion so there’s really

who lost the promotion so there’s really

who lost the promotion so there’s really no difference here the probability to

no difference here the probability to

no difference here the probability to remain married for men but when we

remain married for men but when we

remain married for men but when we examined women who got the promotion it

examined women who got the promotion it

examined women who got the promotion it was clear that leading up to the

was clear that leading up to the

was clear that leading up to the election there was no difference between

election there was no difference between

election there was no difference between the winning and losing candidates

the winning and losing candidates

the winning and losing candidates but immediately once the women who make

but immediately once the women who make

but immediately once the women who make up the black line who were promoted to

up the black line who were promoted to

up the black line who were promoted to these top jobs in politics once they get

these top jobs in politics once they get

these top jobs in politics once they get promoted they start divorcing at a much

promoted they start divorcing at a much

promoted they start divorcing at a much faster rate

faster rate

faster rate they actually divorced twice as fast as

they actually divorced twice as fast as

they actually divorced twice as fast as the control group and four years into

the control group and four years into

the control group and four years into the job when were at time point four

the job when were at time point four

the job when were at time point four there’s a seven percentage point

there’s a seven percentage point

there’s a seven percentage point difference in the divorce rate of these

difference in the divorce rate of these

difference in the divorce rate of these two groups okay so here we have women

two groups okay so here we have women

two groups okay so here we have women who on average have invested about like

who on average have invested about like

who on average have invested about like 20 years in this relationship and it

20 years in this relationship and it

20 years in this relationship and it seems like they are giving it up as they

seems like they are giving it up as they

seems like they are giving it up as they get this promotion hmm so another sector

get this promotion hmm so another sector

get this promotion hmm so another sector that we looked at whilst the private

that we looked at whilst the private

that we looked at whilst the private sector promotions to CEO in private

sector promotions to CEO in private

sector promotions to CEO in private firms and in private firms we

firms and in private firms we

firms and in private firms we unfortunately don’t know who applied for

unfortunately don’t know who applied for

unfortunately don’t know who applied for the position but lost so we can only

the position but lost so we can only

the position but lost so we can only compare men and women who were promoted

compare men and women who were promoted

compare men and women who were promoted so this graph here shows the probability

so this graph here shows the probability

so this graph here shows the probability to remain married for people who became

to remain married for people who became

to remain married for people who became CEO in Swedish firms with more than 100

CEO in Swedish firms with more than 100

CEO in Swedish firms with more than 100 employees and who were previously an

employees and who were previously an

employees and who were previously an employee in that firm so they were

employee in that firm so they were

employee in that firm so they were promoted from working in the firm to

promoted from working in the firm to

promoted from working in the firm to being the leader of the firm and this is

being the leader of the firm and this is

being the leader of the firm and this is a development over time for men and if

a development over time for men and if

a development over time for men and if we compare it to women who started this

we compare it to women who started this

we compare it to women who started this position in time point one again we saw

position in time point one again we saw

position in time point one again we saw the same pattern that once women get

the same pattern that once women get

the same pattern that once women get this promotion they start divorcing at a

this promotion they start divorcing at a

this promotion they start divorcing at a much faster rate than the men who got

much faster rate than the men who got

much faster rate than the men who got this promotion hmm

this promotion hmm

this promotion hmm so this could seem like I’m delivering

so this could seem like I’m delivering

so this could seem like I’m delivering some bad news here and when we saw these

some bad news here and when we saw these

some bad news here and when we saw these results – we were quite surprised that

results – we were quite surprised that

results – we were quite surprised that we wanted to know what was causing this

we wanted to know what was causing this

we wanted to know what was causing this divorce effect among women so a first

divorce effect among women so a first

divorce effect among women so a first thing that we looked into was that

thing that we looked into was that

thing that we looked into was that perhaps these women find new partners

perhaps these women find new partners

perhaps these women find new partners when they promoted they might find more

when they promoted they might find more

when they promoted they might find more attractive new matches and maybe that’s

attractive new matches and maybe that’s

attractive new matches and maybe that’s why and we could immediately reject that

why and we could immediately reject that

why and we could immediately reject that that was the case since we know who

that was the case since we know who

that was the case since we know who finds a new partner in each year we

finds a new partner in each year we

finds a new partner in each year we could see that when we looked six years

could see that when we looked six years

could see that when we looked six years after these people became promoted

after these people became promoted

after these people became promoted the women who were promoted and divorced

the women who were promoted and divorced

the women who were promoted and divorced were actually the least likely out of

were actually the least likely out of

were actually the least likely out of any group to have remarried or found a

any group to have remarried or found a

any group to have remarried or found a new cohabitant so clearly didn’t seem

new cohabitant so clearly didn’t seem

new cohabitant so clearly didn’t seem like they were divorcing because they

like they were divorcing because they

like they were divorcing because they were finding new and better men around

were finding new and better men around

were finding new and better men around so what could it be then that is causing

so what could it be then that is causing

so what could it be then that is causing this we looked into different types of

this we looked into different types of

this we looked into different types of characteristics of these couples and

characteristics of these couples and

characteristics of these couples and something that was very apparent in the

something that was very apparent in the

something that was very apparent in the data was that these women despite

data was that these women despite

data was that these women despite reaching the top of the income

reaching the top of the income

reaching the top of the income distribution many of them are still in

distribution many of them are still in

distribution many of them are still in very traditional marriages so even in

very traditional marriages so even in

very traditional marriages so even in Sweden if our labour market has become

Sweden if our labour market has become

Sweden if our labour market has become much more gender equal over time when we

much more gender equal over time when we

much more gender equal over time when we are working women are reaching the top

are working women are reaching the top

are working women are reaching the top if you look at who marries who that

if you look at who marries who that

if you look at who marries who that pattern is still very traditional and it

pattern is still very traditional and it

pattern is still very traditional and it hasn’t changed very much in the last

hasn’t changed very much in the last

hasn’t changed very much in the last decades so by a gender traditional

decades so by a gender traditional

decades so by a gender traditional couple formation you have the woman

couple formation you have the woman

couple formation you have the woman being younger doing more work in the

being younger doing more work in the

being younger doing more work in the household the relationship really

household the relationship really

household the relationship really focusing around the career of the

focusing around the career of the

focusing around the career of the husband and this is true even for women

husband and this is true even for women

husband and this is true even for women who reached the top of hierarchies they

who reached the top of hierarchies they

who reached the top of hierarchies they are usually married to someone where the

are usually married to someone where the

are usually married to someone where the relationship focuses on his career so

relationship focuses on his career so

relationship focuses on his career so looking at the politicians one good

looking at the politicians one good

looking at the politicians one good measure of the gender equality in the

measure of the gender equality in the

measure of the gender equality in the couple is to look at the age gap between

couple is to look at the age gap between

couple is to look at the age gap between the two people because when people are

the two people because when people are

the two people because when people are married to someone who is more equal to

married to someone who is more equal to

married to someone who is more equal to their own age usually they split other

their own age usually they split other

their own age usually they split other things more equal as well so this shows

things more equal as well so this shows

things more equal as well so this shows the distribution of those age gaps for

the distribution of those age gaps for

the distribution of those age gaps for politicians and for women I’ve marked

politicians and for women I’ve marked

politicians and for women I’ve marked the pink bars are the women politicians

the pink bars are the women politicians

the pink bars are the women politicians in this data set who are married like

in this data set who are married like

in this data set who are married like where the woman politician is younger so

where the woman politician is younger so

where the woman politician is younger so traditional couples and the blue bars

traditional couples and the blue bars

traditional couples and the blue bars are the men who are older than their

are the men who are older than their

are the men who are older than their spouse so clearly here women are the

spouse so clearly here women are the

spouse so clearly here women are the younger person in the couple and men are

younger person in the couple and men are

younger person in the couple and men are the older person but for women we can

the older person but for women we can

the older person but for women we can split these couples into more or less

split these couples into more or less

split these couples into more or less equal so we redid our entire divorce

equal so we redid our entire divorce

equal so we redid our entire divorce analysis on couples that are closer in

analysis on couples that are closer in

analysis on couples that are closer in age and those that are where she is more

age and those that are where she is more

age and those that are where she is more like younger than him by a greater

like younger than him by a greater

like younger than him by a greater margin so what we found was clearly

margin so what we found was clearly

margin so what we found was clearly when the couple is more equal with a

when the couple is more equal with a

when the couple is more equal with a smaller age gap we didn’t see in a

smaller age gap we didn’t see in a

smaller age gap we didn’t see in a divorce effect we’re very small divorce

divorce effect we’re very small divorce

divorce effect we’re very small divorce effect at least but in these couples

effect at least but in these couples

effect at least but in these couples where the woman was much younger than

where the woman was much younger than

where the woman was much younger than the husband that’s where we could see an

the husband that’s where we could see an

the husband that’s where we could see an even larger divorce effect than the

even larger divorce effect than the

even larger divorce effect than the baseline and we can divide the data into

baseline and we can divide the data into

baseline and we can divide the data into more measures of an equal couple for

more measures of an equal couple for

more measures of an equal couple for example how you split parental leave so

example how you split parental leave so

example how you split parental leave so here this politician meant they didn’t

here this politician meant they didn’t

here this politician meant they didn’t take that much parental leave so we had

take that much parental leave so we had

take that much parental leave so we had to be generous with our definition of a

to be generous with our definition of a

to be generous with our definition of a gender equal couple and so the finding a

gender equal couple and so the finding a

gender equal couple and so the finding a gender equal couple as the husband doing

gender equal couple as the husband doing

gender equal couple as the husband doing 10% or more of parental leave even so in

10% or more of parental leave even so in

10% or more of parental leave even so in those couples where you were splitting

those couples where you were splitting

those couples where you were splitting more equally we didn’t see any divorce

more equally we didn’t see any divorce

more equally we didn’t see any divorce impact for women who were promoted

impact for women who were promoted

impact for women who were promoted compared to women who were not promoted

compared to women who were not promoted

compared to women who were not promoted there was just a point 2% margin instead

there was just a point 2% margin instead

there was just a point 2% margin instead of a 7% percentage point margin that I

of a 7% percentage point margin that I

of a 7% percentage point margin that I talked about before but in the way in

talked about before but in the way in

talked about before but in the way in the relationships that were more unequal

the relationships that were more unequal

the relationships that were more unequal were women did the most of the parental

were women did the most of the parental

were women did the most of the parental leave there was again that big impact of

leave there was again that big impact of

leave there was again that big impact of the promotion on divorce so even if we

the promotion on divorce so even if we

the promotion on divorce so even if we think of like when people form their

think of like when people form their

think of like when people form their couple of course they’re in love and

couple of course they’re in love and

couple of course they’re in love and everything and this is the match that

everything and this is the match that

everything and this is the match that they want but people might be or

they want but people might be or

they want but people might be or especially women they might be unaware

especially women they might be unaware

especially women they might be unaware that the formation the way they marry

that the formation the way they marry

that the formation the way they marry especially if they marry someone who’s

especially if they marry someone who’s

especially if they marry someone who’s more their superior than their equal

more their superior than their equal

more their superior than their equal that this could have this ripple effect

that this could have this ripple effect

that this could have this ripple effect into their future likelihood of keeping

into their future likelihood of keeping

into their future likelihood of keeping that relationship if they also want to

that relationship if they also want to

that relationship if they also want to realize their career goals hmm so what

realize their career goals hmm so what

realize their career goals hmm so what can women and what can men do to get out

can women and what can men do to get out

can women and what can men do to get out of this problem and get give people more

of this problem and get give people more

of this problem and get give people more equal chances to pursue both their goals

equal chances to pursue both their goals

equal chances to pursue both their goals of the career and the goals of the

of the career and the goals of the

of the career and the goals of the loving relationship I think that as

loving relationship I think that as

loving relationship I think that as women we can kind of set our dating apps

women we can kind of set our dating apps

women we can kind of set our dating apps and our mindsets more into finding our

and our mindsets more into finding our

and our mindsets more into finding our equal partner in life rather than

equal partner in life rather than

equal partner in life rather than looking for the superior man where the

looking for the superior man where the

looking for the superior man where the relationship is more revolving around

relationship is more revolving around

relationship is more revolving around his career than around both people’s

his career than around both people’s

his career than around both people’s careers

careers

careers as a society allowing more women headed

as a society allowing more women headed

as a society allowing more women headed households more men headed household and

households more men headed household and

households more men headed household and more equal households to coexist we can

more equal households to coexist we can

more equal households to coexist we can get to this society where both men and

get to this society where both men and

get to this society where both men and women have equal opportunities of

women have equal opportunities of

women have equal opportunities of reaching goals of both career and family

reaching goals of both career and family

reaching goals of both career and family thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *