Press "Enter" to skip to content

Inclusion: for pity’s sake? | Joanna Grace & Chloe Salfield | TEDxTruro


Chloe and I are here to share with you

Chloe and I are here to share with you why we believe arguments for inclusion

why we believe arguments for inclusion

why we believe arguments for inclusion should be based on gain not pity I am a

should be based on gain not pity I am a

should be based on gain not pity I am a linguistic being and my halving of

linguistic being and my halving of

linguistic being and my halving of language bias is my view of the world

language bias is my view of the world

language bias is my view of the world I’ll be presenting verbally Chloe is a

I’ll be presenting verbally Chloe is a

I’ll be presenting verbally Chloe is a sensory being her view of the world is

sensory being her view of the world is

sensory being her view of the world is just as bias as my own and she will be

just as bias as my own and she will be

just as bias as my own and she will be presenting through her expression and

presenting through her expression and

presenting through her expression and presence here today and a linguistic

presence here today and a linguistic

presence here today and a linguistic being is just somebody who has acquired

being is just somebody who has acquired

being is just somebody who has acquired and uses language to experience and

and uses language to experience and

and uses language to experience and frame meaning and a sensory being is a

frame meaning and a sensory being is a

frame meaning and a sensory being is a person whose primary experience of the

person whose primary experience of the

person whose primary experience of the world and meaning within it is sensory

world and meaning within it is sensory

world and meaning within it is sensory and Chloe and I are each just one

and Chloe and I are each just one

and Chloe and I are each just one example of two very diverse groups so I

believe that pity erodes life

believe that pity erodes life that’s how I signed off my first letter

that’s how I signed off my first letter

that’s how I signed off my first letter of application to teach children with

of application to teach children with

of application to teach children with severe and profound special educational

severe and profound special educational

severe and profound special educational needs and disabilities and when I was

needs and disabilities and when I was

needs and disabilities and when I was cool to interview I was told that I had

cool to interview I was told that I had

cool to interview I was told that I had been invited there not because of my

been invited there not because of my

been invited there not because of my professional qualifications or personal

professional qualifications or personal

professional qualifications or personal experience but because they’d wanted to

experience but because they’d wanted to

experience but because they’d wanted to see if I had really written that letter

see if I had really written that letter

see if I had really written that letter my lack of pity for the people I work on

my lack of pity for the people I work on

my lack of pity for the people I work on behalf of at the sensory projects does

behalf of at the sensory projects does

behalf of at the sensory projects does not stem from a lack of understanding I

not stem from a lack of understanding I

not stem from a lack of understanding I regularly meet children who lead

regularly meet children who lead

regularly meet children who lead foreshortened lives

foreshortened lives

foreshortened lives I witnessed the struggles they face and

I witnessed the struggles they face and

I witnessed the struggles they face and through the window of Facebook once

through the window of Facebook once

through the window of Facebook once those lives are over I watched their

those lives are over I watched their

those lives are over I watched their families and I see their parents snapped

families and I see their parents snapped

families and I see their parents snapped smiling by friends at parties the light

smiling by friends at parties the light

smiling by friends at parties the light in their eyes is gone

in their eyes is gone

in their eyes is gone I watched the color drain out of though

I watched the color drain out of though

I watched the color drain out of though world’s and people ask them how they

world’s and people ask them how they

world’s and people ask them how they cope people say they couldn’t cope if it

cope people say they couldn’t cope if it

cope people say they couldn’t cope if it happened to them they couldn’t even

happened to them they couldn’t even

happened to them they couldn’t even imagine it and for the record I’ve known

imagine it and for the record I’ve known

imagine it and for the record I’ve known enough of these families now to know

enough of these families now to know

enough of these families now to know that coping isn’t a thing they do coping

that coping isn’t a thing they do coping

that coping isn’t a thing they do coping is a thing that is done to them by the

is a thing that is done to them by the

is a thing that is done to them by the continuation of life beyond that first

continuation of life beyond that first

continuation of life beyond that first decision not to follow your child into

decision not to follow your child into

decision not to follow your child into the grave and that’s no small one beyond

the grave and that’s no small one beyond

the grave and that’s no small one beyond that there is no doing coping happens

that there is no doing coping happens

that there is no doing coping happens life happens and so no my lack of pity

life happens and so no my lack of pity

life happens and so no my lack of pity does not stem from naivety have a naive

does not stem from naivety have a naive

does not stem from naivety have a naive I’m a look my lack of pity is down to

I’m a look my lack of pity is down to

I’m a look my lack of pity is down to its lack of utility it certainly has no

its lack of utility it certainly has no

its lack of utility it certainly has no use in breaking down the barriers to

use in breaking down the barriers to

use in breaking down the barriers to inclusion and we’re going to explain why

inclusion and we’re going to explain why

inclusion and we’re going to explain why everyone lives their lives on a scale of

everyone lives their lives on a scale of

everyone lives their lives on a scale of one to ten good to bad and our scale

one to ten good to bad and our scale

one to ten good to bad and our scale stretches according to our experience

stretches according to our experience

stretches according to our experience it’s a bit like when medics attending

it’s a bit like when medics attending

it’s a bit like when medics attending trauma victims asked them to rate their

trauma victims asked them to rate their

trauma victims asked them to rate their pain from 1 to 10 and then medicate

pain from 1 to 10 and then medicate

pain from 1 to 10 and then medicate accordingly it’s very subjective but

accordingly it’s very subjective but

accordingly it’s very subjective but it’s very real and when we ask someone

it’s very real and when we ask someone

it’s very real and when we ask someone who currently believes their life to be

who currently believes their life to be

who currently believes their life to be running at a stress level 8 – pity

running at a stress level 8 – pity

running at a stress level 8 – pity we’re asking them to give some think

we’re asking them to give some think

we’re asking them to give some think they do not believe they have and sure

they do not believe they have and sure

they do not believe they have and sure you know a gift is being given here

you know a gift is being given here

you know a gift is being given here we’re great who wouldn’t want to hang

we’re great who wouldn’t want to hang

we’re great who wouldn’t want to hang out with us it’s best not to check that

out with us it’s best not to check that

out with us it’s best not to check that part of the argument too closely if the

part of the argument too closely if the

part of the argument too closely if the gift goes both ways

gift goes both ways

gift goes both ways how much more open with those ears

how much more open with those ears

how much more open with those ears beyond that stress level 8 person if

beyond that stress level 8 person if

beyond that stress level 8 person if instead of asking them to give we were

instead of asking them to give we were

instead of asking them to give we were offering them a gift we tend to think

offering them a gift we tend to think

offering them a gift we tend to think about the barriers to inclusion as being

about the barriers to inclusion as being

about the barriers to inclusion as being physical things like ramp access and

physical things like ramp access and

physical things like ramp access and specialist wheelchairs or hearing aids

specialist wheelchairs or hearing aids

specialist wheelchairs or hearing aids or funky pieces of equipment and these

or funky pieces of equipment and these

or funky pieces of equipment and these things are important changing places for

things are important changing places for

things are important changing places for example a disabled toilet is

example a disabled toilet is

example a disabled toilet is accessible to those who can shift

accessible to those who can shift

accessible to those who can shift themselves from chair to toilet and if

themselves from chair to toilet and if

themselves from chair to toilet and if you can’t then super Josh on my slide is

you can’t then super Josh on my slide is

you can’t then super Josh on my slide is showing you what a disabled toilet means

showing you what a disabled toilet means

showing you what a disabled toilet means to you how can it be that in 2017 in a

to you how can it be that in 2017 in a

to you how can it be that in 2017 in a country like ours we are still asking

country like ours we are still asking

country like ours we are still asking for toilets for some members of our

for toilets for some members of our

for toilets for some members of our society just you know just imagine if

society just you know just imagine if

society just you know just imagine if you’d been invited here today and told

you’d been invited here today and told

you’d been invited here today and told how fantastic the event is gonna be just

how fantastic the event is gonna be just

how fantastic the event is gonna be just one thing to take note of before you

one thing to take note of before you

one thing to take note of before you come the toilets will be out of action

come the toilets will be out of action

come the toilets will be out of action but don’t worry because we will be

but don’t worry because we will be

but don’t worry because we will be handing out nappy pads on the door and

handing out nappy pads on the door and

handing out nappy pads on the door and if you want to change you can go and lie

if you want to change you can go and lie

if you want to change you can go and lie on the toilet floor to do it you’d have

on the toilet floor to do it you’d have

on the toilet floor to do it you’d have still come right that would be fine no

still come right that would be fine no

still come right that would be fine no if it’s not okay for you why is it okay

if it’s not okay for you why is it okay

if it’s not okay for you why is it okay for somebody who uses a wheelchair these

for somebody who uses a wheelchair these

for somebody who uses a wheelchair these things are important but if we had all

things are important but if we had all

things are important but if we had all of these things would that be inclusion

of these things would that be inclusion

of these things would that be inclusion acheived know the real barriers to

acheived know the real barriers to

acheived know the real barriers to inclusion are those of understanding and

inclusion are those of understanding and

inclusion are those of understanding and awareness it’s not a lack of ability in

awareness it’s not a lack of ability in

awareness it’s not a lack of ability in them it’s a lack of insight in us and

them it’s a lack of insight in us and

them it’s a lack of insight in us and the argument for inclusion should be

the argument for inclusion should be

the argument for inclusion should be made based on the extraordinariness of

made based on the extraordinariness of

made based on the extraordinariness of these lives

these lives

these lives the brilliance to the moment shared the

the brilliance to the moment shared the

the brilliance to the moment shared the unique perspective they bring you’ve met

unique perspective they bring you’ve met

unique perspective they bring you’ve met Larry we’d like to introduce you to some

Larry we’d like to introduce you to some

Larry we’d like to introduce you to some of her friends this is Shannon Shannon

of her friends this is Shannon Shannon

of her friends this is Shannon Shannon can teach you about joy and connection

can teach you about joy and connection

can teach you about joy and connection and the present moment this is Hannah

and the present moment this is Hannah

and the present moment this is Hannah Hannah can teach you wonder curiosity

Hannah can teach you wonder curiosity

Hannah can teach you wonder curiosity and persistence and this was Harry Harry

and persistence and this was Harry Harry

and persistence and this was Harry Harry was a super skilled communicator who

was a super skilled communicator who

was a super skilled communicator who used the limited set of resources he was

used the limited set of resources he was

used the limited set of resources he was given to communicate a thousand things

given to communicate a thousand things

given to communicate a thousand things in his short life and I’m devastated

in his short life and I’m devastated

in his short life and I’m devastated that I won’t get to

that I won’t get to

that I won’t get to from Harry anymore I’m not saying these

from Harry anymore I’m not saying these

from Harry anymore I’m not saying these things to be nice these talents are real

things to be nice these talents are real

things to be nice these talents are real when we first planned this presentation

when we first planned this presentation

when we first planned this presentation we plan to present you with a list of

we plan to present you with a list of

we plan to present you with a list of reasons based on gain not pity why

reasons based on gain not pity why

reasons based on gain not pity why people like Chloe and her friends should

people like Chloe and her friends should

people like Chloe and her friends should be included but we’ve decided not to

be included but we’ve decided not to

be included but we’ve decided not to we’re gonna start the list and we want

we’re gonna start the list and we want

we’re gonna start the list and we want you to continue it and together we will

you to continue it and together we will

you to continue it and together we will create a petition for inclusion a

create a petition for inclusion a

create a petition for inclusion a thousand ideas long so here’s one to get

thousand ideas long so here’s one to get

thousand ideas long so here’s one to get you going our society goes through

you going our society goes through

you going our society goes through emotional phases just like a person does

emotional phases just like a person does

emotional phases just like a person does and currently we are living through an

and currently we are living through an

and currently we are living through an age of anxiety with nearly a quarter of

age of anxiety with nearly a quarter of

age of anxiety with nearly a quarter of the UK population reporting feeling

the UK population reporting feeling

the UK population reporting feeling anxious all the time

anxious all the time

anxious all the time corresponding to this rise in anxiety

corresponding to this rise in anxiety

corresponding to this rise in anxiety we’re seeing increased interest in

we’re seeing increased interest in

we’re seeing increased interest in mindfulness practice with places as

mindfulness practice with places as

mindfulness practice with places as prestigious as Oxford University

prestigious as Oxford University

prestigious as Oxford University dedicating time to its study mindfulness

dedicating time to its study mindfulness

dedicating time to its study mindfulness has been shown to be a tonic for anxiety

has been shown to be a tonic for anxiety

has been shown to be a tonic for anxiety mindfulness is the nun judgemental

mindfulness is the nun judgemental

mindfulness is the nun judgemental attention to the present and in the

attention to the present and in the

attention to the present and in the population of people who are sensory

population of people who are sensory

population of people who are sensory beings we meet a great many people who

beings we meet a great many people who

beings we meet a great many people who lead lives of constant non-judgmental

lead lives of constant non-judgmental

lead lives of constant non-judgmental attention to the present and who often

attention to the present and who often

attention to the present and who often find those lives joyful thinking in this

find those lives joyful thinking in this

find those lives joyful thinking in this way you quickly come up with ideas of

way you quickly come up with ideas of

way you quickly come up with ideas of what we all gain from inclusion and you

what we all gain from inclusion and you

what we all gain from inclusion and you also realize that the line between those

also realize that the line between those

also realize that the line between those doing the including and those being

doing the including and those being

doing the including and those being included is distinctly blurry which side

included is distinctly blurry which side

included is distinctly blurry which side of the line do you fall on will you

of the line do you fall on will you

of the line do you fall on will you always fall on that side which side of

always fall on that side which side of

always fall on that side which side of the line do I fall on have you assumed

the line do I fall on have you assumed

the line do I fall on have you assumed that I’m neurotypical I’m not I’m

that I’m neurotypical I’m not I’m

that I’m neurotypical I’m not I’m autistic do we want a world where

autistic do we want a world where

autistic do we want a world where everyone is the same

everyone is the same

everyone is the same a world without people with Down

a world without people with Down

a world without people with Down syndrome without people with autism

syndrome without people with autism

syndrome without people with autism without people with Tourette’s without

without people with Tourette’s without

without people with Tourette’s without without without you know the assumption

without without you know the assumption

without without you know the assumption that is made when trying to eliminate

that is made when trying to eliminate

that is made when trying to eliminate diversity is one of hierarchy we assume

diversity is one of hierarchy we assume

diversity is one of hierarchy we assume that because some lives are different

that because some lives are different

that because some lives are different they are necessarily better or worse

they are necessarily better or worse

they are necessarily better or worse than our own in the idea that some lives

than our own in the idea that some lives

than our own in the idea that some lives for their own good should not be lived

for their own good should not be lived

for their own good should not be lived is just shocking the arrogant you know

is just shocking the arrogant you know

is just shocking the arrogant you know our lives is your life so good that you

our lives is your life so good that you

our lives is your life so good that you think one’s different – it should be

think one’s different – it should be

think one’s different – it should be prevented Chloe’s life is hers to live

prevented Chloe’s life is hers to live

prevented Chloe’s life is hers to live not yours hers to judge she’s living it

not yours hers to judge she’s living it

not yours hers to judge she’s living it and getting every ounce of life out of

and getting every ounce of life out of

and getting every ounce of life out of it are you doing the same with yours

it are you doing the same with yours

it are you doing the same with yours could you learn a thing or two from

could you learn a thing or two from

could you learn a thing or two from hanging out with Chloe I bet no one who

hanging out with Chloe I bet no one who

hanging out with Chloe I bet no one who had knows Chloe has a bad hair day and

had knows Chloe has a bad hair day and

had knows Chloe has a bad hair day and ranks her innate treat her pain saw out

ranks her innate treat her pain saw out

ranks her innate treat her pain saw out her seizures tackle medical difficulties

her seizures tackle medical difficulties

her seizures tackle medical difficulties sure but eliminate difference is that

sure but eliminate difference is that

sure but eliminate difference is that really what we want to do acknowledging

really what we want to do acknowledging

really what we want to do acknowledging difference does not necessarily mean the

difference does not necessarily mean the

difference does not necessarily mean the creation of a hierarchy difference

creation of a hierarchy difference

creation of a hierarchy difference brings gifts as a linguistic being I see

brings gifts as a linguistic being I see

brings gifts as a linguistic being I see my life in this way and as a sensory

my life in this way and as a sensory

my life in this way and as a sensory being Chloe views her life in this way

being Chloe views her life in this way

being Chloe views her life in this way and when we work together to share our

and when we work together to share our

and when we work together to share our views we each see more if we try and

views we each see more if we try and

views we each see more if we try and make everyone’s view the same or try and

make everyone’s view the same or try and

make everyone’s view the same or try and shut people out from our way of seeing

shut people out from our way of seeing

shut people out from our way of seeing we see less different and included we

we see less different and included we

we see less different and included we gained different and excluded we lose

gained different and excluded we lose

gained different and excluded we lose here’s one more for the list this one I

here’s one more for the list this one I

here’s one more for the list this one I hear a lot from people who care directly

hear a lot from people who care directly

hear a lot from people who care directly for individuals with profound

for individuals with profound

for individuals with profound disabilities complex needs autism Down

disabilities complex needs autism Down

disabilities complex needs autism Down syndrome fragile X Noonan syndrome

syndrome fragile X Noonan syndrome

syndrome fragile X Noonan syndrome charge

charge

charge Rhett’s you know on and on into this

Rhett’s you know on and on into this

Rhett’s you know on and on into this one’s this is what they say I have

one’s this is what they say I have

one’s this is what they say I have learned so much from them and people

learned so much from them and people

learned so much from them and people find it hard to articulate this learning

find it hard to articulate this learning

find it hard to articulate this learning but it is a stretching of the ha

but it is a stretching of the ha

but it is a stretching of the ha an extension to one’s limits a depth of

an extension to one’s limits a depth of

an extension to one’s limits a depth of experience unanticipated an ability to

experience unanticipated an ability to

experience unanticipated an ability to function without sleep people give out

function without sleep people give out

function without sleep people give out free phorus worries and selfish

free phorus worries and selfish

free phorus worries and selfish preoccupations and focus on a bigger

preoccupations and focus on a bigger

preoccupations and focus on a bigger picture and time runs out for insecurity

picture and time runs out for insecurity

picture and time runs out for insecurity and bad hair days I believe when we

and bad hair days I believe when we

and bad hair days I believe when we think about inclusion we should consider

think about inclusion we should consider

think about inclusion we should consider evolution and how we want progress to be

evolution and how we want progress to be

evolution and how we want progress to be measured you have body survival of the

measured you have body survival of the

measured you have body survival of the fittest and as a species we’re living

fittest and as a species we’re living

fittest and as a species we’re living into our 80s and 90s it’s done for us so

into our 80s and 90s it’s done for us so

into our 80s and 90s it’s done for us so then you have mind commentators talk

then you have mind commentators talk

then you have mind commentators talk about horizontal evolution about

about horizontal evolution about

about horizontal evolution about promoting survival through the

promoting survival through the

promoting survival through the horizontal exchange of knowledge and we

horizontal exchange of knowledge and we

horizontal exchange of knowledge and we have the World Wide Web so perhaps it’s

have the World Wide Web so perhaps it’s

have the World Wide Web so perhaps it’s time for a third as society diversifies

time for a third as society diversifies

time for a third as society diversifies does it not call for an evolution of the

does it not call for an evolution of the

does it not call for an evolution of the soul for an increased capacious honest

soul for an increased capacious honest

soul for an increased capacious honest at the heart for more caring for more

at the heart for more caring for more

at the heart for more caring for more awareness and understanding think about

awareness and understanding think about

awareness and understanding think about how you want progress to be measured you

how you want progress to be measured you

how you want progress to be measured you want to see us becoming ever stronger

want to see us becoming ever stronger

want to see us becoming ever stronger and more symmetrical or knowing more and

and more symmetrical or knowing more and

and more symmetrical or knowing more and more stuff what about more understanding

more stuff what about more understanding

more stuff what about more understanding more empathetic more loving when we seek

more empathetic more loving when we seek

more empathetic more loving when we seek to include those who are different to

to include those who are different to

to include those who are different to ourselves no matter what that difference

ourselves no matter what that difference

ourselves no matter what that difference might be this is the future we all gain

might be this is the future we all gain

might be this is the future we all gain our future for ourselves and for our

our future for ourselves and for our

our future for ourselves and for our children be those children neurotypical

children be those children neurotypical

children be those children neurotypical physically typical or otherwise

inclusion is for everyone thank you for

inclusion is for everyone thank you for your attention

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *