Press "Enter" to skip to content

Justice That Heals: A Response to Prostitution | Hannah Estabrook | TEDxColumbus


[Music]

[Music] when I was a senior in college I had a

when I was a senior in college I had a

when I was a senior in college I had a professor in a particular class that

professor in a particular class that

professor in a particular class that asked us to go around the room and share

asked us to go around the room and share

asked us to go around the room and share where we wanted to be in 10 years so I

where we wanted to be in 10 years so I

where we wanted to be in 10 years so I listened to my classmates say things

listened to my classmates say things

listened to my classmates say things like I want to be married and have a

like I want to be married and have a

like I want to be married and have a couple of children maybe open up a

couple of children maybe open up a

couple of children maybe open up a private practice things you would expect

private practice things you would expect

private practice things you would expect and when it came to me I simply said as

and when it came to me I simply said as

and when it came to me I simply said as if it was the most natural thing for me

if it was the most natural thing for me

if it was the most natural thing for me to say I want to work with prostitutes

now my short asian male professor I

now my short asian male professor I think didn’t quite know what I meant by

think didn’t quite know what I meant by

think didn’t quite know what I meant by work with prostitutes

work with prostitutes

work with prostitutes he began blushing pretty badly it felt

he began blushing pretty badly it felt

he began blushing pretty badly it felt really awkward and we just moved on from

really awkward and we just moved on from

really awkward and we just moved on from there I know what you’re thinking what

there I know what you’re thinking what

there I know what you’re thinking what causes a person to want to work with

causes a person to want to work with

causes a person to want to work with prostitutes

prostitutes

prostitutes well the unfortunately common but

well the unfortunately common but

well the unfortunately common but derogatory words that we use to describe

derogatory words that we use to describe

derogatory words that we use to describe prostitutes today words like whore slut

prostitutes today words like whore slut

prostitutes today words like whore slut temptress these are the words that I

temptress these are the words that I

temptress these are the words that I felt as a child and a young teenager

felt as a child and a young teenager

felt as a child and a young teenager described me not because I had been

described me not because I had been

described me not because I had been involved in prostitution but because I

involved in prostitution but because I

involved in prostitution but because I had experienced several doses of sexual

had experienced several doses of sexual

had experienced several doses of sexual abuse between ages five and ten many

abuse between ages five and ten many

abuse between ages five and ten many sexual abuse survivors feel that they’re

sexual abuse survivors feel that they’re

sexual abuse survivors feel that they’re to blame for their abuse they feel like

to blame for their abuse they feel like

to blame for their abuse they feel like there’s something wrong with them I felt

there’s something wrong with them I felt

there’s something wrong with them I felt like there was something wrong with me I

like there was something wrong with me I

like there was something wrong with me I felt like I was some kind of

felt like I was some kind of

felt like I was some kind of eight-year-old temptress now fortunately

eight-year-old temptress now fortunately

eight-year-old temptress now fortunately I had an amazing family and came from a

I had an amazing family and came from a

I had an amazing family and came from a privileged background I had access to

privileged background I had access to

privileged background I had access to all the resources and therapy that I

all the resources and therapy that I

all the resources and therapy that I needed to heal from my trauma and that

needed to heal from my trauma and that

needed to heal from my trauma and that dream I had as a senior in college it

dream I had as a senior in college it

dream I had as a senior in college it came true almost ten years exactly later

came true almost ten years exactly later

came true almost ten years exactly later I was hired by the Franklin County

I was hired by the Franklin County

I was hired by the Franklin County Municipal Court to work with prostitutes

Municipal Court to work with prostitutes

Municipal Court to work with prostitutes I have the privilege of coordinating a

I have the privilege of coordinating a

I have the privilege of coordinating a program called catch court for survivors

program called catch court for survivors

program called catch court for survivors of prostitution and human trafficking

of prostitution and human trafficking

of prostitution and human trafficking it’s a problem-solving court or a

it’s a problem-solving court or a

it’s a problem-solving court or a specialized docket and these kinds of

specialized docket and these kinds of

specialized docket and these kinds of courts have been around in our country

courts have been around in our country

courts have been around in our country since 1989 you may be familiar with

since 1989 you may be familiar with

since 1989 you may be familiar with things like mental health courts or drug

things like mental health courts or drug

things like mental health courts or drug courts and they all follow this

courts and they all follow this

courts and they all follow this restorative justice philosophy that says

restorative justice philosophy that says

restorative justice philosophy that says because crime hurts justice should heal

because crime hurts justice should heal

because crime hurts justice should heal so catch which is just specifically for

so catch which is just specifically for

so catch which is just specifically for survivors of prostitution and

survivors of prostitution and

survivors of prostitution and trafficking stands for changing actions

trafficking stands for changing actions

trafficking stands for changing actions to change habits it does not stand for

to change habits it does not stand for

to change habits it does not stand for caught at the corner hooking remember

caught at the corner hooking remember

caught at the corner hooking remember that so in 2007 what happened was there

that so in 2007 what happened was there

that so in 2007 what happened was there was a shift in a policy and this shift

was a shift in a policy and this shift

was a shift in a policy and this shift brought a lot more attention to domestic

brought a lot more attention to domestic

brought a lot more attention to domestic violence cases and what was what would

violence cases and what was what would

violence cases and what was what would happen is that many more facts and

happen is that many more facts and

happen is that many more facts and images photographs of domestic violence

images photographs of domestic violence

images photographs of domestic violence victims were presented to judges who

victims were presented to judges who

victims were presented to judges who were presiding over these cases so one

were presiding over these cases so one

were presiding over these cases so one day in 2007 Judge Paul Herbert was

day in 2007 Judge Paul Herbert was

day in 2007 Judge Paul Herbert was presiding an arraignment court here in

presiding an arraignment court here in

presiding an arraignment court here in Franklin County and he had 37 domestic

Franklin County and he had 37 domestic

Franklin County and he had 37 domestic violence cases which meant that he spent

violence cases which meant that he spent

violence cases which meant that he spent a big chunk of his morning looking at

a big chunk of his morning looking at

a big chunk of his morning looking at images like this domestic violence

images like this domestic violence

images like this domestic violence victim after victim and after these

victim after victim and after these

victim after victim and after these cases were done

cases were done

cases were done his next offend inque min to the

his next offend inque min to the

his next offend inque min to the courtroom and the case file said

courtroom and the case file said

courtroom and the case file said prostitute and he looked up at her and

prostitute and he looked up at her and

prostitute and he looked up at her and he describes that for a split second he

he describes that for a split second he

he describes that for a split second he saw all the images he had been looking

saw all the images he had been looking

saw all the images he had been looking at all morning he saw a domestic

at all morning he saw a domestic

at all morning he saw a domestic violence victim he was really curious

violence victim he was really curious

violence victim he was really curious about that it took a wise judge to be

about that it took a wise judge to be

about that it took a wise judge to be curious not just about the crime and

curious not just about the crime and

curious not just about the crime and what she had done but about what had

what she had done but about what had

what she had done but about what had happened to her so you know he literally

happened to her so you know he literally

happened to her so you know he literally like goes back to his office and

like goes back to his office and

like goes back to his office and Google’s Criminology of prostitution to

Google’s Criminology of prostitution to

Google’s Criminology of prostitution to try to learn about the background of

try to learn about the background of

try to learn about the background of these women and I want to tell you a

these women and I want to tell you a

these women and I want to tell you a little bit about the backgrounds of

little bit about the backgrounds of

little bit about the backgrounds of these women this is based on about a

these women this is based on about a

these women this is based on about a sampling of about 95 women who’ve come

sampling of about 95 women who’ve come

sampling of about 95 women who’ve come through our program so generally

through our program so generally

through our program so generally speaking they come from a low

speaking they come from a low

speaking they come from a low socioeconomic status generally they

socioeconomic status generally they

socioeconomic status generally they haven’t even completed high school and

haven’t even completed high school and

haven’t even completed high school and no one to this point has been a college

no one to this point has been a college

no one to this point has been a college grad

grad

grad do it most of them are moms many of them

do it most of them are moms many of them

do it most of them are moms many of them have already been involved in the mental

have already been involved in the mental

have already been involved in the mental health system in our community many of

health system in our community many of

health system in our community many of them began using drugs at a very young

them began using drugs at a very young

them began using drugs at a very young age

age

age somewhere between al ages ages 11 and 14

somewhere between al ages ages 11 and 14

somewhere between al ages ages 11 and 14 typically but all of them by the time

typically but all of them by the time

typically but all of them by the time they get to us have been diagnosed with

they get to us have been diagnosed with

they get to us have been diagnosed with a substance use disorder without a doubt

a substance use disorder without a doubt

a substance use disorder without a doubt these are women who have extensive

these are women who have extensive

these are women who have extensive trauma in their background again out of

trauma in their background again out of

trauma in their background again out of 95 89 of them report having experienced

95 89 of them report having experienced

95 89 of them report having experienced sexual violence the same number it’s

sexual violence the same number it’s

sexual violence the same number it’s meant partner violence and 88 the

meant partner violence and 88 the

meant partner violence and 88 the unexpected loss or death of a loved one

unexpected loss or death of a loved one

unexpected loss or death of a loved one so you tell me is this woman a criminal

so you tell me is this woman a criminal

so you tell me is this woman a criminal is she a victim what I can tell you from

is she a victim what I can tell you from

is she a victim what I can tell you from working with these women is that there

working with these women is that there

working with these women is that there are threads of both in their stories

are threads of both in their stories

are threads of both in their stories there are threads of trauma and

there are threads of trauma and

there are threads of trauma and victimization and also threads of

victimization and also threads of

victimization and also threads of criminal thinking and so we need a sort

criminal thinking and so we need a sort

criminal thinking and so we need a sort of trauma-informed justice to respond so

of trauma-informed justice to respond so

of trauma-informed justice to respond so catch court seeks to provide both

catch court seeks to provide both

catch court seeks to provide both trauma-informed care and also

trauma-informed care and also

trauma-informed care and also accountability because both are needed

accountability because both are needed

accountability because both are needed this is me the little girl the little

this is me the little girl the little

this is me the little girl the little girl who was sexually abused as a child

girl who was sexually abused as a child

girl who was sexually abused as a child and again I’m very aware that if I

and again I’m very aware that if I

and again I’m very aware that if I didn’t come from privileged and having

didn’t come from privileged and having

didn’t come from privileged and having had access to resources that my story it

had access to resources that my story it

had access to resources that my story it could have ended up a lot different it

could have ended up a lot different it

could have ended up a lot different it could have ended up a lot like Mandy’s

could have ended up a lot like Mandy’s

could have ended up a lot like Mandy’s this is Mandy Mandy grew up in an

this is Mandy Mandy grew up in an

this is Mandy Mandy grew up in an addicted household she was verbally

addicted household she was verbally

addicted household she was verbally physically sexually abused as a child

physically sexually abused as a child

physically sexually abused as a child she ended up homeless and bounced around

she ended up homeless and bounced around

she ended up homeless and bounced around from family member to family member she

from family member to family member she

from family member to family member she got involved in a pretty intense

got involved in a pretty intense

got involved in a pretty intense romantic relationship at the age of 13

romantic relationship at the age of 13

romantic relationship at the age of 13 she attempted suicide as a teenager

she attempted suicide as a teenager

she attempted suicide as a teenager ultimately she began using drugs to cope

ultimately she began using drugs to cope

ultimately she began using drugs to cope with everything she’d experienced got

with everything she’d experienced got

with everything she’d experienced got involved with prostitution

involved with prostitution

involved with prostitution and then she was recruited by a pimp on

and then she was recruited by a pimp on

and then she was recruited by a pimp on the east side of Columbus and in her

the east side of Columbus and in her

the east side of Columbus and in her time in the life she had her jaw broken

time in the life she had her jaw broken

time in the life she had her jaw broken and a gun to her head she was raped and

and a gun to her head she was raped and

and a gun to her head she was raped and of course eventually she began picking

of course eventually she began picking

of course eventually she began picking up criminal charges of prostitution and

up criminal charges of prostitution and

up criminal charges of prostitution and ended up incarcerated in our system but

ended up incarcerated in our system but

ended up incarcerated in our system but Mandy also had a dream

Mandy also had a dream

Mandy also had a dream Mandy’s dream was to be a mom and Mandy

Mandy’s dream was to be a mom and Mandy

Mandy’s dream was to be a mom and Mandy tells the story that it was one of these

tells the story that it was one of these

tells the story that it was one of these times that she had men in jail and she

times that she had men in jail and she

times that she had men in jail and she was served papers and these papers

was served papers and these papers

was served papers and these papers indicated that her father now clean had

indicated that her father now clean had

indicated that her father now clean had filed for emergency custody of Mandy’s

filed for emergency custody of Mandy’s

filed for emergency custody of Mandy’s son because his father also was not

son because his father also was not

son because his father also was not doing well and she describes that this

doing well and she describes that this

doing well and she describes that this was the moment that she was ready for

was the moment that she was ready for

was the moment that she was ready for something different

something different

something different ready for change and so Mandy opted in

ready for change and so Mandy opted in

ready for change and so Mandy opted in to the catch court program so instead of

to the catch court program so instead of

to the catch court program so instead of being in jail she was placed on two

being in jail she was placed on two

being in jail she was placed on two years of probation and in our program

years of probation and in our program

years of probation and in our program and she had a lot of expectations that

and she had a lot of expectations that

and she had a lot of expectations that go along with this program catch court

go along with this program catch court

go along with this program catch court participants have to come to court every

participants have to come to court every

participants have to come to court every single week to check in with the judge

single week to check in with the judge

single week to check in with the judge they have to meet with their probation

they have to meet with their probation

they have to meet with their probation officer and other catch staff on at

officer and other catch staff on at

officer and other catch staff on at least a monthly basis they have to

least a monthly basis they have to

least a monthly basis they have to provide urine drug screens very

provide urine drug screens very

provide urine drug screens very regularly to hold them accountable

regularly to hold them accountable

regularly to hold them accountable they’re referred to typically

they’re referred to typically

they’re referred to typically residential treatment so places where

residential treatment so places where

residential treatment so places where they’re living and receiving treatment

they’re living and receiving treatment

they’re living and receiving treatment and then they also have these things

and then they also have these things

and then they also have these things called stay away sparts of town they’re

called stay away sparts of town they’re

called stay away sparts of town they’re not allowed to go to or people frankly

not allowed to go to or people frankly

not allowed to go to or people frankly they’re not allowed to see which is

they’re not allowed to see which is

they’re not allowed to see which is really all about their safety so it’s a

really all about their safety so it’s a

really all about their safety so it’s a difficult program but there are also a

difficult program but there are also a

difficult program but there are also a lot of benefits to the program probably

lot of benefits to the program probably

lot of benefits to the program probably to me most importantly is that Mandy and

to me most importantly is that Mandy and

to me most importantly is that Mandy and others like her gain a family a

others like her gain a family a

others like her gain a family a community of support a courtroom of

community of support a courtroom of

community of support a courtroom of women who say over and over we’re gonna

women who say over and over we’re gonna

women who say over and over we’re gonna love you until you love yourself and

love you until you love yourself and

love you until you love yourself and then they go do it

then they go do it

then they go do it all of Mandy’s needs basic needs were

all of Mandy’s needs basic needs were

all of Mandy’s needs basic needs were met for the two years she was in our

met for the two years she was in our

met for the two years she was in our program and a partnering nonprofit

program and a partnering nonprofit

program and a partnering nonprofit called freedom ala carte Google them

called freedom ala carte Google them

called freedom ala carte Google them later provide a ton of supportive

later provide a ton of supportive

later provide a ton of supportive services including

services including

services including making sure that every single week when

making sure that every single week when

making sure that every single week when the women come to court they’re fed they

the women come to court they’re fed they

the women come to court they’re fed they bring a meal every week they plan a

bring a meal every week they plan a

bring a meal every week they plan a monthly outing so that these ladies can

monthly outing so that these ladies can

monthly outing so that these ladies can learn how to have fun again it’s been a

learn how to have fun again it’s been a

learn how to have fun again it’s been a long time if ever and they also train

long time if ever and they also train

long time if ever and they also train and provide a mentor who will journey

and provide a mentor who will journey

and provide a mentor who will journey alongside each woman while she’s in our

alongside each woman while she’s in our

alongside each woman while she’s in our program and of course one of the biggest

program and of course one of the biggest

program and of course one of the biggest benefits of successfully completing the

benefits of successfully completing the

benefits of successfully completing the catch Court program is that your charges

catch Court program is that your charges

catch Court program is that your charges are dismissed unsealed now

are dismissed unsealed now

are dismissed unsealed now ceiling or expungement of records is a

ceiling or expungement of records is a

ceiling or expungement of records is a big deal

big deal

big deal that’s our criminal justices way of

that’s our criminal justices way of

that’s our criminal justices way of saying it’s as if you never committed

saying it’s as if you never committed

saying it’s as if you never committed this crime we trust you and that’s a

this crime we trust you and that’s a

this crime we trust you and that’s a woman who can go on to find housing and

woman who can go on to find housing and

woman who can go on to find housing and employment it changes everything for her

employment it changes everything for her

employment it changes everything for her so Mandy today is employed in the

so Mandy today is employed in the

so Mandy today is employed in the recovery field she has her own place her

recovery field she has her own place her

recovery field she has her own place her own car a thriving relationship with her

own car a thriving relationship with her

own car a thriving relationship with her son and she says over and over you know

son and she says over and over you know

son and she says over and over you know I love being an independent woman so it

I love being an independent woman so it

I love being an independent woman so it worked for Mandy but does it work in

worked for Mandy but does it work in

worked for Mandy but does it work in general and is it worth it well let me

general and is it worth it well let me

general and is it worth it well let me just break down one example one cost for

just break down one example one cost for

just break down one example one cost for you because over and over again if you

you because over and over again if you

you because over and over again if you compare legal costs and medical costs of

compare legal costs and medical costs of

compare legal costs and medical costs of traditional justice models and

traditional justice models and

traditional justice models and restorative justice models over and over

restorative justice models over and over

restorative justice models over and over again restorative justice will win but

again restorative justice will win but

again restorative justice will win but just one example is that the annual cost

just one example is that the annual cost

just one example is that the annual cost of incarcerating a woman in the state of

of incarcerating a woman in the state of

of incarcerating a woman in the state of Ohio is just over $26,000 now that same

Ohio is just over $26,000 now that same

Ohio is just over $26,000 now that same woman instead of being incarcerated go

woman instead of being incarcerated go

woman instead of being incarcerated go to treatment where she has shelter all

to treatment where she has shelter all

to treatment where she has shelter all her basic needs are met and she’s

her basic needs are met and she’s

her basic needs are met and she’s receiving good care and that’s just over

receiving good care and that’s just over

receiving good care and that’s just over $10,000 that’s a significant taxpayer

$10,000 that’s a significant taxpayer

$10,000 that’s a significant taxpayer benefit recidivism now that’s one of

benefit recidivism now that’s one of

benefit recidivism now that’s one of those fancy words that just means

those fancy words that just means

those fancy words that just means someone’s likeliness to reoffended

someone’s likeliness to reoffended

someone’s likeliness to reoffended commit the same crime the lady’s really

commit the same crime the lady’s really

commit the same crime the lady’s really just describe it as about you know you

just describe it as about you know you

just describe it as about you know you get stuck in a lifestyle that you want

get stuck in a lifestyle that you want

get stuck in a lifestyle that you want to get out of but you can’t and this is

to get out of but you can’t and this is

to get out of but you can’t and this is a population women involved in

a population women involved in

a population women involved in prostitution that are

prostitution that are

prostitution that are known for their high recidivism rates so

known for their high recidivism rates so

known for their high recidivism rates so nationally it’s about 80 percent for

nationally it’s about 80 percent for

nationally it’s about 80 percent for women cotton prostitution for catch

women cotton prostitution for catch

women cotton prostitution for catch court women and this is true for women

court women and this is true for women

court women and this is true for women who have been in this program for two

who have been in this program for two

who have been in this program for two weeks or six months or the full two

weeks or six months or the full two

weeks or six months or the full two years our recidivism rates are just 29%

it’s a significant decrease now you may

it’s a significant decrease now you may have heard or sorry said in another way

have heard or sorry said in another way

have heard or sorry said in another way of a hundred and fifty seven women who

of a hundred and fifty seven women who

of a hundred and fifty seven women who have had the opportunity to complete the

have had the opportunity to complete the

have had the opportunity to complete the program in the two years that they

program in the two years that they

program in the two years that they before they got to catch Court those 157

before they got to catch Court those 157

before they got to catch Court those 157 women picked up just over 1200 criminal

women picked up just over 1200 criminal

women picked up just over 1200 criminal cases that’s a chunk in the two years

cases that’s a chunk in the two years

cases that’s a chunk in the two years that they spent with us just 67 and in

that they spent with us just 67 and in

that they spent with us just 67 and in the two years following 350 that’s a 75%

the two years following 350 that’s a 75%

the two years following 350 that’s a 75% decrease of criminal cases so you may

decrease of criminal cases so you may

decrease of criminal cases so you may have heard that we have a mass

have heard that we have a mass

have heard that we have a mass incarceration issue in this country and

incarceration issue in this country and

incarceration issue in this country and it’s true according to the national

it’s true according to the national

it’s true according to the national institute of justice we have 2.3 million

institute of justice we have 2.3 million

institute of justice we have 2.3 million americans who are incarcerated today and

americans who are incarcerated today and

americans who are incarcerated today and our national recidivism rates are just

our national recidivism rates are just

our national recidivism rates are just about 68% we have a problem and we need

about 68% we have a problem and we need

about 68% we have a problem and we need programs like catch court and other

programs like catch court and other

programs like catch court and other similar to be replicated if we’re gonna

similar to be replicated if we’re gonna

similar to be replicated if we’re gonna do anything about these numbers if we’re

do anything about these numbers if we’re

do anything about these numbers if we’re gonna help people get unstuck from a

gonna help people get unstuck from a

gonna help people get unstuck from a life they don’t want to be in finally

life they don’t want to be in finally

life they don’t want to be in finally when I think of catch court when I think

when I think of catch court when I think

when I think of catch court when I think of Judge Herbert I think I’m another old

of Judge Herbert I think I’m another old

of Judge Herbert I think I’m another old story and it’s a biblical story actually

story and it’s a biblical story actually

story and it’s a biblical story actually which regardless of your religious

which regardless of your religious

which regardless of your religious affiliation I think extends an important

affiliation I think extends an important

affiliation I think extends an important lesson it’s the story of a known

lesson it’s the story of a known

lesson it’s the story of a known prostitute from a particular village who

prostitute from a particular village who

prostitute from a particular village who enters a room full of religious leaders

enters a room full of religious leaders

enters a room full of religious leaders and judges and there’s a kind judge in

and judges and there’s a kind judge in

and judges and there’s a kind judge in the room he notices her he notices not

the room he notices her he notices not

the room he notices her he notices not just what she’s done but also the things

just what she’s done but also the things

just what she’s done but also the things that have been done to her he knows a

that have been done to her he knows a

that have been done to her he knows a lot about her life and he accepts her he

lot about her life and he accepts her he

lot about her life and he accepts her he welcomes her and it changes everything

welcomes her and it changes everything

welcomes her and it changes everything for her but you know he notices

for her but you know he notices

for her but you know he notices something else he notices the room

something else he notices the room

something else he notices the room of judges and he asks this question to

of judges and he asks this question to

of judges and he asks this question to them he says do you see this woman now

them he says do you see this woman now

them he says do you see this woman now it’s kind of a silly question because

it’s kind of a silly question because

it’s kind of a silly question because everybody notices when I prostitutes in

everybody notices when I prostitutes in

everybody notices when I prostitutes in a room she clearly doesn’t belong hint

a room she clearly doesn’t belong hint

a room she clearly doesn’t belong hint right but it’s as if he’s asking a

right but it’s as if he’s asking a

right but it’s as if he’s asking a deeper question like do you really see

deeper question like do you really see

deeper question like do you really see this woman

this woman

this woman and so forgive when you’re driving down

and so forgive when you’re driving down

and so forgive when you’re driving down the street and you see a woman who may

the street and you see a woman who may

the street and you see a woman who may be caught up in the prostitution

be caught up in the prostitution

be caught up in the prostitution lifestyle what are you gonna see are you

lifestyle what are you gonna see are you

lifestyle what are you gonna see are you gonna see the crime that she’s

gonna see the crime that she’s

gonna see the crime that she’s committing are you gonna see the crimes

committing are you gonna see the crimes

committing are you gonna see the crimes that have been committed against her are

that have been committed against her are

that have been committed against her are you gonna see the dreams that maybe she

you gonna see the dreams that maybe she

you gonna see the dreams that maybe she had as a little girl do you see this

had as a little girl do you see this

had as a little girl do you see this woman thank you

woman thank you

woman thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *