
good morning thank you for being here April 26th 1986 you probably don’t
April 26th 1986 you probably don’t
April 26th 1986 you probably don’t remember where you were I was 11 but
remember where you were I was 11 but
remember where you were I was 11 but there’s some big stuff happening in
there’s some big stuff happening in
there’s some big stuff happening in Europe Geiger counters all over Europe
Europe Geiger counters all over Europe
Europe Geiger counters all over Europe were going crazy nothing was going on in
were going crazy nothing was going on in
were going crazy nothing was going on in Europe though and so they started
Europe though and so they started
Europe though and so they started looking at the neighbor Soviet the
looking at the neighbor Soviet the
looking at the neighbor Soviet the Soviet Union and the Soviet said there’s
Soviet Union and the Soviet said there’s
Soviet Union and the Soviet said there’s nothing going on here and they said we
nothing going on here and they said we
nothing going on here and they said we can see the smoke there’s something
can see the smoke there’s something
can see the smoke there’s something happening
happening
happening well they said well yeah there might be
well they said well yeah there might be
well they said well yeah there might be a fire but it’s outside of our chair
a fire but it’s outside of our chair
a fire but it’s outside of our chair noble nuclear facility it’s not anything
noble nuclear facility it’s not anything
noble nuclear facility it’s not anything to do with that well there’s no way for
to do with that well there’s no way for
to do with that well there’s no way for us to verify that story we the Soviet
us to verify that story we the Soviet
us to verify that story we the Soviet Union was basically remote politically
Union was basically remote politically
Union was basically remote politically we couldn’t go and verify the story
we couldn’t go and verify the story
we couldn’t go and verify the story especially their nuclear programs and so
especially their nuclear programs and so
especially their nuclear programs and so lucky for the world Landsat 5 flew
lucky for the world Landsat 5 flew
lucky for the world Landsat 5 flew overhead three days later so this image
overhead three days later so this image
overhead three days later so this image is from April 29th 1986 and we were able
is from April 29th 1986 and we were able
is from April 29th 1986 and we were able to document you can maybe see a tiny
to document you can maybe see a tiny
to document you can maybe see a tiny little pinkish red dot way at the top
little pinkish red dot way at the top
little pinkish red dot way at the top there above the little white line and
there above the little white line and
there above the little white line and that was all we needed to determine that
that was all we needed to determine that
that was all we needed to determine that there was actually a fire at Chernobyl
there was actually a fire at Chernobyl
there was actually a fire at Chernobyl in react but it was inside reactor
in react but it was inside reactor
in react but it was inside reactor number 4 Landsat 5 has a thermal
number 4 Landsat 5 has a thermal
number 4 Landsat 5 has a thermal instrument on board which means that it
instrument on board which means that it
instrument on board which means that it can actually see in the spectrum of
can actually see in the spectrum of
can actually see in the spectrum of thermal that you and I can’t see in but
thermal that you and I can’t see in but
thermal that you and I can’t see in but we learned later that that meltdown fire
we learned later that that meltdown fire
we learned later that that meltdown fire was probably in excess of 3,600 degrees
was probably in excess of 3,600 degrees
was probably in excess of 3,600 degrees Fahrenheit which is why we were able to
Fahrenheit which is why we were able to
Fahrenheit which is why we were able to determine it was in fact a nuclear
determine it was in fact a nuclear
determine it was in fact a nuclear meltdown I’m studying the Earth from
meltdown I’m studying the Earth from
meltdown I’m studying the Earth from space for over 20 years and it’s changed
space for over 20 years and it’s changed
space for over 20 years and it’s changed the way that I look at really
the way that I look at really
the way that I look at really complicated problems in fact I’ve had to
complicated problems in fact I’ve had to
complicated problems in fact I’ve had to sort of realize that there might never
sort of realize that there might never
sort of realize that there might never be a right answer to some things and so
be a right answer to some things and so
be a right answer to some things and so I’m going to challenge you today to
I’m going to challenge you today to
I’m going to challenge you today to consider that everything you know may
consider that everything you know may
consider that everything you know may not be true and that your life
not be true and that your life
not be true and that your life experience has most certainly sets you
experience has most certainly sets you
experience has most certainly sets you up to only see a part of any story I’m
up to only see a part of any story I’m
up to only see a part of any story I’m going to take you on a journey today
going to take you on a journey today
going to take you on a journey today around the world
around the world
around the world from the 7:05 orbit which is about 438
from the 7:05 orbit which is about 438
from the 7:05 orbit which is about 438 miles above the Earth’s surface and I’m
miles above the Earth’s surface and I’m
miles above the Earth’s surface and I’m going to share with you just a few
going to share with you just a few
going to share with you just a few stories about this tension that we see
stories about this tension that we see
stories about this tension that we see all the time between earthlings and the
all the time between earthlings and the
all the time between earthlings and the planet we inhabit we’re gonna start in
planet we inhabit we’re gonna start in
planet we inhabit we’re gonna start in Costa Rica Costa Rica has a really
Costa Rica Costa Rica has a really
Costa Rica Costa Rica has a really impressive array of preserves national
impressive array of preserves national
impressive array of preserves national parks biological stations and the one
parks biological stations and the one
parks biological stations and the one that I know best is in the southeastern
that I know best is in the southeastern
that I know best is in the southeastern part of the country called las cruces
part of the country called las cruces
part of the country called las cruces biological reserve and in this image you
biological reserve and in this image you
biological reserve and in this image you can see the outline of the park right
can see the outline of the park right
can see the outline of the park right you can see that southern border and the
you can see that southern border and the
you can see that southern border and the western border really distinctively and
western border really distinctively and
western border really distinctively and so this is a lustrated of this tension
so this is a lustrated of this tension
so this is a lustrated of this tension between humans and the planet right in
between humans and the planet right in
between humans and the planet right in the sense of the whole idea behind
the sense of the whole idea behind
the sense of the whole idea behind protecting places is if we don’t protect
protecting places is if we don’t protect
protecting places is if we don’t protect it
it
it people will destroy it right and so what
people will destroy it right and so what
people will destroy it right and so what you see around Los Cruces Biological
you see around Los Cruces Biological
you see around Los Cruces Biological Station today is ranch land so it’s
Station today is ranch land so it’s
Station today is ranch land so it’s people trying to make a living very
people trying to make a living very
people trying to make a living very similar to what we have around here
similar to what we have around here
similar to what we have around here except there’s a lot more rain there the
except there’s a lot more rain there the
except there’s a lot more rain there the Los Cruces is a place it’s very
Los Cruces is a place it’s very
Los Cruces is a place it’s very biologically diverse I saw hummingbirds
biologically diverse I saw hummingbirds
biologically diverse I saw hummingbirds with a nest with eggs that were about
with a nest with eggs that were about
with a nest with eggs that were about the half the size of a pencil eraser and
the half the size of a pencil eraser and
the half the size of a pencil eraser and I was on a walk at dusk by accident
I was on a walk at dusk by accident
I was on a walk at dusk by accident really that’s a different story
really that’s a different story
really that’s a different story and I jumped I had to jump over the
and I jumped I had to jump over the
and I jumped I had to jump over the faired Alliance which is a deadly snake
faired Alliance which is a deadly snake
faired Alliance which is a deadly snake Monteverde cloud forest and the northern
Monteverde cloud forest and the northern
Monteverde cloud forest and the northern more northern part of the country has
more northern part of the country has
more northern part of the country has over 400 species of orchids alone and
over 400 species of orchids alone and
over 400 species of orchids alone and probably a lot of bugs but whatever I’m
probably a lot of bugs but whatever I’m
probably a lot of bugs but whatever I’m sure they’re very important but the idea
sure they’re very important but the idea
sure they’re very important but the idea about protecting land so that we don’t
about protecting land so that we don’t
about protecting land so that we don’t destroy them is really a complicated
destroy them is really a complicated
destroy them is really a complicated issue because it’s a very simplistic
issue because it’s a very simplistic
issue because it’s a very simplistic view because under the canopy of this
view because under the canopy of this
view because under the canopy of this forest lies the secret that it’s no
forest lies the secret that it’s no
forest lies the secret that it’s no virgin 400 years ago this forest had
virgin 400 years ago this forest had
virgin 400 years ago this forest had maize growing the forest is today and we
maize growing the forest is today and we
maize growing the forest is today and we know this by looking at lake sediments
know this by looking at lake sediments
know this by looking at lake sediments that preserve in this case up to 3,000
that preserve in this case up to 3,000
that preserve in this case up to 3,000 years of pollen that we can then
years of pollen that we can then
years of pollen that we can then reconstruct and check out what was going
reconstruct and check out what was going
reconstruct and check out what was going on in the land
on in the land
on in the land thousands of years ago and so mazes
thousands of years ago and so mazes
thousands of years ago and so mazes present on this landscape for almost
present on this landscape for almost
present on this landscape for almost 3,000 years as well as a pretty high
3,000 years as well as a pretty high
3,000 years as well as a pretty high density of charcoal which means humans
density of charcoal which means humans
density of charcoal which means humans were involved because the the rainforest
were involved because the the rainforest
were involved because the the rainforest doesn’t burn by itself and so how do we
doesn’t burn by itself and so how do we
doesn’t burn by itself and so how do we determine what to save and our
determine what to save and our
determine what to save and our landscapes truly apart from humans how
landscapes truly apart from humans how
landscapes truly apart from humans how do we balance these save the earth
do we balance these save the earth
do we balance these save the earth versus put humans first there’s the the
versus put humans first there’s the the
versus put humans first there’s the the magic is usually somewhere in between
magic is usually somewhere in between
magic is usually somewhere in between and we’re gonna go to the Colorado River
and we’re gonna go to the Colorado River
and we’re gonna go to the Colorado River the Colorado River headwaters are in the
the Colorado River headwaters are in the
the Colorado River headwaters are in the Rockies I’ve actually jumped across it
Rockies I’ve actually jumped across it
Rockies I’ve actually jumped across it just to say that I did right because
just to say that I did right because
just to say that I did right because this river is huge it runs 1,450 miles
this river is huge it runs 1,450 miles
this river is huge it runs 1,450 miles across the American Southwest all the
across the American Southwest all the
across the American Southwest all the way to the Sea of Cortez Gulf of
way to the Sea of Cortez Gulf of
way to the Sea of Cortez Gulf of California if you’ve been to the Grand
California if you’ve been to the Grand
California if you’ve been to the Grand Canyon Moab Utah the Hoover Dam you’ve
Canyon Moab Utah the Hoover Dam you’ve
Canyon Moab Utah the Hoover Dam you’ve been to the Colorado River it waters
been to the Colorado River it waters
been to the Colorado River it waters agricultural areas Tucson Phoenix Vegas
agricultural areas Tucson Phoenix Vegas
agricultural areas Tucson Phoenix Vegas the Imperial Valley of California
the Imperial Valley of California
the Imperial Valley of California unfettered it delivers 16 million acre
unfettered it delivers 16 million acre
unfettered it delivers 16 million acre feet to the ocean but today from this
feet to the ocean but today from this
feet to the ocean but today from this image you can see this is the Delta
image you can see this is the Delta
image you can see this is the Delta today two hundred years ago this Delta
today two hundred years ago this Delta
today two hundred years ago this Delta was filled with millions of birds and
was filled with millions of birds and
was filled with millions of birds and lush vegetation so you can see
lush vegetation so you can see
lush vegetation so you can see immediately that there’s no vegetation
immediately that there’s no vegetation
immediately that there’s no vegetation here even more tragically perhaps today
here even more tragically perhaps today
here even more tragically perhaps today the Colorado River doesn’t actually even
the Colorado River doesn’t actually even
the Colorado River doesn’t actually even reach the ocean most years and you can
reach the ocean most years and you can
reach the ocean most years and you can see in this image where I’m going to try
see in this image where I’m going to try
see in this image where I’m going to try to point this out to you where it ends
to point this out to you where it ends
to point this out to you where it ends about right here and this is the tidal
about right here and this is the tidal
about right here and this is the tidal flats then of the ocean so it doesn’t
flats then of the ocean so it doesn’t
flats then of the ocean so it doesn’t even get there anymore
even get there anymore
even get there anymore how did this happen well I mentioned the
how did this happen well I mentioned the
how did this happen well I mentioned the dams and the diversions on the
dams and the diversions on the
dams and the diversions on the agriculture well what happened is in
agriculture well what happened is in
agriculture well what happened is in 1922 all the states got together and
1922 all the states got together and
1922 all the states got together and decided okay we’re gonna divide the
decided okay we’re gonna divide the
decided okay we’re gonna divide the river up and they didn’t do it
river up and they didn’t do it
river up and they didn’t do it arbitrarily they looked at 30 years of
arbitrarily they looked at 30 years of
arbitrarily they looked at 30 years of data and they said this is a reasonable
data and they said this is a reasonable
data and they said this is a reasonable amount of water to take out of the
amount of water to take out of the
amount of water to take out of the system and still leave ten percent to
system and still leave ten percent to
system and still leave ten percent to flow through Mexico into the ocean well
flow through Mexico into the ocean well
flow through Mexico into the ocean well what happened was
what happened was
what happened was that thirty years of data was at the
that thirty years of data was at the
that thirty years of data was at the wettest or one of the wettest 30 years
wettest or one of the wettest 30 years
wettest or one of the wettest 30 years in a thousand years so when the
in a thousand years so when the
in a thousand years so when the researchers started looking at tree
researchers started looking at tree
researchers started looking at tree rings and reconstructing wet years and
rings and reconstructing wet years and
rings and reconstructing wet years and dryers there’s a couple of peaks of
dryers there’s a couple of peaks of
dryers there’s a couple of peaks of wetness and the last that was in years
wetness and the last that was in years
wetness and the last that was in years of dryness and one of them just happened
of dryness and one of them just happened
of dryness and one of them just happened to be right before 1922 so what do we do
to be right before 1922 so what do we do
to be right before 1922 so what do we do how do we change in this we have people
how do we change in this we have people
how do we change in this we have people depending on water do we let the planet
depending on water do we let the planet
depending on water do we let the planet suffer to keep the humans happy to keep
suffer to keep the humans happy to keep
suffer to keep the humans happy to keep the humans and not only happy fed
the humans and not only happy fed
the humans and not only happy fed clothed you we’re not talking like
clothed you we’re not talking like
clothed you we’re not talking like people are just dumping this water you
people are just dumping this water you
people are just dumping this water you know out in the desert for no good
know out in the desert for no good
know out in the desert for no good reason right they’re using this water
reason right they’re using this water
reason right they’re using this water for bet to better their lives well the
for bet to better their lives well the
for bet to better their lives well the good news is is that we can learn from
good news is is that we can learn from
good news is is that we can learn from our past and today the water does
our past and today the water does
our past and today the water does actually reach the ocean and the reason
actually reach the ocean and the reason
actually reach the ocean and the reason this happened is because everyone got
this happened is because everyone got
this happened is because everyone got together US and Mexico mostly and said
together US and Mexico mostly and said
together US and Mexico mostly and said you know what we can’t prioritize humans
you know what we can’t prioritize humans
you know what we can’t prioritize humans alone and so we have to reestablish some
alone and so we have to reestablish some
alone and so we have to reestablish some water to Mexico that was the real key
water to Mexico that was the real key
water to Mexico that was the real key it’s a Mexico basal flow and periodic
it’s a Mexico basal flow and periodic
it’s a Mexico basal flow and periodic pulses to wash out sandbars and you may
pulses to wash out sandbars and you may
pulses to wash out sandbars and you may have heard about some of that going on
have heard about some of that going on
have heard about some of that going on but surprisingly the river reached the
but surprisingly the river reached the
but surprisingly the river reached the ocean again they didn’t really expect
ocean again they didn’t really expect
ocean again they didn’t really expect that to happen and so this is the good
that to happen and so this is the good
that to happen and so this is the good this is a good news story although you
this is a good news story although you
this is a good news story although you can see that the Delta is still far from
can see that the Delta is still far from
can see that the Delta is still far from the millions of birds and lost budget
the millions of birds and lost budget
the millions of birds and lost budget lush vegetation sort of on that topic of
lush vegetation sort of on that topic of
lush vegetation sort of on that topic of dryness seems like our the western US
dryness seems like our the western US
dryness seems like our the western US can burn some years from the end end and
can burn some years from the end end and
can burn some years from the end end and why does this happen so I’m gonna take
why does this happen so I’m gonna take
why does this happen so I’m gonna take you to Wallace Idaho Wallace Idaho is a
you to Wallace Idaho Wallace Idaho is a
you to Wallace Idaho Wallace Idaho is a small town in the beautiful forests in
small town in the beautiful forests in
small town in the beautiful forests in northern Idaho and it was in the literal
northern Idaho and it was in the literal
northern Idaho and it was in the literal middle of a literal firestorm in 1910 it
middle of a literal firestorm in 1910 it
middle of a literal firestorm in 1910 it was actually called the Great Fire of
was actually called the Great Fire of
was actually called the Great Fire of 1910 and it was the talk of the country
1910 and it was the talk of the country
1910 and it was the talk of the country at the time I mean we see a lot of fires
at the time I mean we see a lot of fires
at the time I mean we see a lot of fires today and you don’t even hear about him
today and you don’t even hear about him
today and you don’t even hear about him it might roll through your Facebook feed
it might roll through your Facebook feed
it might roll through your Facebook feed you’re like oh look there’s fire
you’re like oh look there’s fire
you’re like oh look there’s fire somewhere but you know it’s not really a
somewhere but you know it’s not really a
somewhere but you know it’s not really a topic of conversation well this was a
topic of conversation well this was a
topic of conversation well this was a massive fire and but the rete one of the
massive fire and but the rete one of the
massive fire and but the rete one of the reasons it was such a big deal to
reasons it was such a big deal to
reasons it was such a big deal to everyone is because there’s overlain on
everyone is because there’s overlain on
everyone is because there’s overlain on a really interesting pullet of
a really interesting pullet of
a really interesting pullet of goal firestorm so the man on the left is
goal firestorm so the man on the left is
goal firestorm so the man on the left is Pinchot he believed that four should be
Pinchot he believed that four should be
Pinchot he believed that four should be used for humans to the best we could do
used for humans to the best we could do
used for humans to the best we could do it so timber wood products ATV riding
it so timber wood products ATV riding
it so timber wood products ATV riding cutting down your Christmas tree
cutting down your Christmas tree
cutting down your Christmas tree whatever that means John Muir on the
whatever that means John Muir on the
whatever that means John Muir on the other hand believes that forests where a
other hand believes that forests where a
other hand believes that forests where a Cathedral should be kept apart from the
Cathedral should be kept apart from the
Cathedral should be kept apart from the saw well these two men their vision we
saw well these two men their vision we
saw well these two men their vision we see today in the US Forest Service for
see today in the US Forest Service for
see today in the US Forest Service for Pinchot Park Service for mirror
Pinchot Park Service for mirror
Pinchot Park Service for mirror interesting thing these men were bitter
interesting thing these men were bitter
interesting thing these men were bitter enemies because they were contemporaries
enemies because they were contemporaries
enemies because they were contemporaries they were fighting for completely
they were fighting for completely
they were fighting for completely different use of the land of the West
different use of the land of the West
different use of the land of the West Teddy Roosevelt was president at the
Teddy Roosevelt was president at the
Teddy Roosevelt was president at the time interesting thing though and one
time interesting thing though and one
time interesting thing though and one thing that United them was their hatred
thing that United them was their hatred
thing that United them was their hatred of fire because if you believe the
of fire because if you believe the
of fire because if you believe the forest is a cathedral or you believe its
forest is a cathedral or you believe its
forest is a cathedral or you believe its resource for use the worst thing that
resource for use the worst thing that
resource for use the worst thing that can happen is for it to burn to the
can happen is for it to burn to the
can happen is for it to burn to the ground
ground
ground and so by 1935 the rule in the United
and so by 1935 the rule in the United
and so by 1935 the rule in the United States was that you should put out a
States was that you should put out a
States was that you should put out a fire by 10:00 a.m. the next morning
fire by 10:00 a.m. the next morning
fire by 10:00 a.m. the next morning after a fire responded the tricky thing
after a fire responded the tricky thing
after a fire responded the tricky thing about putting out fires though is that
about putting out fires though is that
about putting out fires though is that fires are essential to Western forests
fires are essential to Western forests
fires are essential to Western forests to keep them healthy burns the old
to keep them healthy burns the old
to keep them healthy burns the old needles out at dead and dying trees in
needles out at dead and dying trees in
needles out at dead and dying trees in fact the adaptation to fire is so so
fact the adaptation to fire is so so
fact the adaptation to fire is so so advanced in some in some cases that you
advanced in some in some cases that you
advanced in some in some cases that you need fire to open the cones so that the
need fire to open the cones so that the
need fire to open the cones so that the seeds can drop and new baby trees can
seeds can drop and new baby trees can
seeds can drop and new baby trees can grow so it should have fire about every
grow so it should have fire about every
grow so it should have fire about every five years or so low burning fire it
five years or so low burning fire it
five years or so low burning fire it lets the big trees stay big and happy
lets the big trees stay big and happy
lets the big trees stay big and happy who just keeps that understory open deer
who just keeps that understory open deer
who just keeps that understory open deer love it animals love it well what
love it animals love it well what
love it animals love it well what happens when we suppress these fires for
happens when we suppress these fires for
happens when we suppress these fires for decades and decades really big fires
decades and decades really big fires
decades and decades really big fires happen so when I was in Yosemite this is
happen so when I was in Yosemite this is
happen so when I was in Yosemite this is a Yellowstone when I was in Yosemite
a Yellowstone when I was in Yosemite
a Yellowstone when I was in Yosemite about ten years ago with some friends or
about ten years ago with some friends or
about ten years ago with some friends or doing some research there we were out
doing some research there we were out
doing some research there we were out walking through the woods and there was
walking through the woods and there was
walking through the woods and there was dead wood that was higher than my head
dead wood that was higher than my head
dead wood that was higher than my head so you can imagine a lightning strike
so you can imagine a lightning strike
so you can imagine a lightning strike that happens in that kind of forest so
that happens in that kind of forest so
that happens in that kind of forest so what happens is on the left here you see
what happens is on the left here you see
what happens is on the left here you see yes Yellowstone in 1987 and on the right
yes Yellowstone in 1987 and on the right
yes Yellowstone in 1987 and on the right you see yellow
you see yellow
you see yellow in 1988 and and Yellowstone is 3,500
in 1988 and and Yellowstone is 3,500
in 1988 and and Yellowstone is 3,500 square miles it’s huge and this image is
square miles it’s huge and this image is
square miles it’s huge and this image is actually a little bigger than the park
actually a little bigger than the park
actually a little bigger than the park boundaries so Yellowstone alone lost
boundaries so Yellowstone alone lost
boundaries so Yellowstone alone lost over 30% of its forests to this one big
over 30% of its forests to this one big
over 30% of its forests to this one big fire season the fire’s didn’t go out and
fire season the fire’s didn’t go out and
fire season the fire’s didn’t go out and tell snow fell it was so big they come
tell snow fell it was so big they come
tell snow fell it was so big they come put them out so this really started us
put them out so this really started us
put them out so this really started us pushing back on that idea that we need
pushing back on that idea that we need
pushing back on that idea that we need to suppress fire because again we need
to suppress fire because again we need
to suppress fire because again we need to see the earth as the as its whole
to see the earth as the as its whole
to see the earth as the as its whole system not just what we choose to see in
system not just what we choose to see in
system not just what we choose to see in it today we try to let those fires burn
it today we try to let those fires burn
it today we try to let those fires burn and protect people and their things and
and protect people and their things and
and protect people and their things and it’s this really wonky balance that
it’s this really wonky balance that
it’s this really wonky balance that sometimes it’s very successful
sometimes it’s very successful
sometimes it’s very successful other times it’s not we just hope these
other times it’s not we just hope these
other times it’s not we just hope these folks stay safe while doing it so the
folks stay safe while doing it so the
folks stay safe while doing it so the next place we’re gonna go to is probably
next place we’re gonna go to is probably
next place we’re gonna go to is probably one of the largest environmental
one of the largest environmental
one of the largest environmental disasters in the world and you’ve
disasters in the world and you’ve
disasters in the world and you’ve probably never heard of it this is the
probably never heard of it this is the
probably never heard of it this is the Aral Sea or was the Aral Sea and you can
Aral Sea or was the Aral Sea and you can
Aral Sea or was the Aral Sea and you can maybe see the old lake bed here it’s
maybe see the old lake bed here it’s
maybe see the old lake bed here it’s actually runs off the bottom of the
actually runs off the bottom of the
actually runs off the bottom of the screen and this is several hundred miles
screen and this is several hundred miles
screen and this is several hundred miles across the Aral Sea used to be the fifth
across the Aral Sea used to be the fifth
across the Aral Sea used to be the fifth largest inland water body in the world
largest inland water body in the world
largest inland water body in the world and this is what it looks like today in
and this is what it looks like today in
and this is what it looks like today in the 1960s the Soviet started to divert
the 1960s the Soviet started to divert
the 1960s the Soviet started to divert water in flowing rivers for agriculture
water in flowing rivers for agriculture
water in flowing rivers for agriculture for everything from melons to cotton and
for everything from melons to cotton and
for everything from melons to cotton and it’s really because the arid steppe is a
it’s really because the arid steppe is a
it’s really because the arid steppe is a very hard place to have a lot of success
very hard place to have a lot of success
very hard place to have a lot of success financially like it’s really kind of
financially like it’s really kind of
financially like it’s really kind of hard to Scrabble living so I thought
hard to Scrabble living so I thought
hard to Scrabble living so I thought well here’s this water resource let’s
well here’s this water resource let’s
well here’s this water resource let’s use it to raise up our standard of
use it to raise up our standard of
use it to raise up our standard of living
living
living so in fact cotton was called white gold
so in fact cotton was called white gold
so in fact cotton was called white gold at the time and so they started growing
at the time and so they started growing
at the time and so they started growing cotton in the middle of was Becca Stan
cotton in the middle of was Becca Stan
cotton in the middle of was Becca Stan what is today was Becca Stan so here you
what is today was Becca Stan so here you
what is today was Becca Stan so here you can see in 1977 on the Left this was
can see in 1977 on the Left this was
can see in 1977 on the Left this was about ten years after they started
about ten years after they started
about ten years after they started drawing down the water now the thing to
drawing down the water now the thing to
drawing down the water now the thing to remember about the arid steppe of Asia
remember about the arid steppe of Asia
remember about the arid steppe of Asia is that there’s more evaporation out of
is that there’s more evaporation out of
is that there’s more evaporation out of the lake and there is rainfall so the
the lake and there is rainfall so the
the lake and there is rainfall so the only way to keep that lake actually a
only way to keep that lake actually a
only way to keep that lake actually a lake is to let the rivers flow into it
lake is to let the rivers flow into it
lake is to let the rivers flow into it and so it was vexed Anne has continued
and so it was vexed Anne has continued
and so it was vexed Anne has continued to keep that irrigation going can you
to keep that irrigation going can you
to keep that irrigation going can you imagine if we told farmers today sorry
imagine if we told farmers today sorry
imagine if we told farmers today sorry you can’t have the water you’ve been
you can’t have the water you’ve been
you can’t have the water you’ve been using for the last 50 years there to be
using for the last 50 years there to be
using for the last 50 years there to be a revolt right as probably there should
a revolt right as probably there should
a revolt right as probably there should be so again we have this challenge
be so again we have this challenge
be so again we have this challenge between earthlings and the planet how
between earthlings and the planet how
between earthlings and the planet how we’re going to work together one of the
we’re going to work together one of the
we’re going to work together one of the good news stories about this is that the
good news stories about this is that the
good news stories about this is that the North Aral Sea has been recognized as
North Aral Sea has been recognized as
North Aral Sea has been recognized as perhaps savable so in the last few years
perhaps savable so in the last few years
perhaps savable so in the last few years I’ve actually put a dam on the south
I’ve actually put a dam on the south
I’ve actually put a dam on the south side of the lake and that Lake is
side of the lake and that Lake is
side of the lake and that Lake is actually refilling up and the fisheries
actually refilling up and the fisheries
actually refilling up and the fisheries are starting to come back to a
are starting to come back to a
are starting to come back to a harvestable size so that’s an exciting
harvestable size so that’s an exciting
harvestable size so that’s an exciting lesson that we’ve all learned and we’ve
lesson that we’ve all learned and we’ve
lesson that we’ve all learned and we’ve talked about eating food off the land
talked about eating food off the land
talked about eating food off the land but what if you depend on the ocean for
but what if you depend on the ocean for
but what if you depend on the ocean for most of your protein well we’ve all
most of your protein well we’ve all
most of your protein well we’ve all heard about the oceans being overfished
heard about the oceans being overfished
heard about the oceans being overfished so what is there to do harder to show on
so what is there to do harder to show on
so what is there to do harder to show on a satellite data on a side image but
a satellite data on a side image but
a satellite data on a side image but this is Singapore 18,000 people per
this is Singapore 18,000 people per
this is Singapore 18,000 people per square mile in South Dakota there are
square mile in South Dakota there are
square mile in South Dakota there are counties with less than one person per
counties with less than one person per
counties with less than one person per square mile so that’s quite a bit
square mile so that’s quite a bit
square mile so that’s quite a bit different so what people are trying to
different so what people are trying to
different so what people are trying to do for food from the ocean is farming
do for food from the ocean is farming
do for food from the ocean is farming and so this is a picture from Greece
and so this is a picture from Greece
and so this is a picture from Greece actually and so what they do is they
actually and so what they do is they
actually and so what they do is they inside each one of those circles they
inside each one of those circles they
inside each one of those circles they farm fish and this seems like one of
farm fish and this seems like one of
farm fish and this seems like one of those maybe don’t prioritize humans or
those maybe don’t prioritize humans or
those maybe don’t prioritize humans or don’t prioritize the earth but somehow
don’t prioritize the earth but somehow
don’t prioritize the earth but somehow find a middle ground that magic place in
find a middle ground that magic place in
find a middle ground that magic place in between there are still the jury’s still
between there are still the jury’s still
between there are still the jury’s still a bit out on this because as you can
a bit out on this because as you can
a bit out on this because as you can imagine when you put food in there and
imagine when you put food in there and
imagine when you put food in there and all the fish don’t eat the food the food
all the fish don’t eat the food the food
all the fish don’t eat the food the food goes out into the ocean causing some
goes out into the ocean causing some
goes out into the ocean causing some over nutrient press super nutrient
over nutrient press super nutrient
over nutrient press super nutrient problems also they’re afraid that fish
problems also they’re afraid that fish
problems also they’re afraid that fish might escape and start commingling with
might escape and start commingling with
might escape and start commingling with the wild fish and messing up the DNA and
the wild fish and messing up the DNA and
the wild fish and messing up the DNA and so this is might be one of those
so this is might be one of those
so this is might be one of those compromises that we can come to when we
compromises that we can come to when we
compromises that we can come to when we bring the two outsides closer to the
bring the two outsides closer to the
bring the two outsides closer to the middle when I was in college I used to
middle when I was in college I used to
middle when I was in college I used to be able to talk both sides of any
be able to talk both sides of any
be able to talk both sides of any argument and used to drive everyone
argument and used to drive everyone
argument and used to drive everyone crazy but it also used to make me feel
crazy but it also used to make me feel
crazy but it also used to make me feel like that was a weakness like I had a
like that was a weakness like I had a
like that was a weakness like I had a lack of conviction
lack of conviction
lack of conviction to one side or the other but today I
to one side or the other but today I
to one side or the other but today I really try to channel that feeling
really try to channel that feeling
really try to channel that feeling because I think that the answers to
because I think that the answers to
because I think that the answers to really complicated problems like the
really complicated problems like the
really complicated problems like the ones we looked at today are never on the
ones we looked at today are never on the
ones we looked at today are never on the ends they’re always in the magic place
ends they’re always in the magic place
ends they’re always in the magic place in the middle so I challenge you to try
in the middle so I challenge you to try
in the middle so I challenge you to try to do that for yourself to turn to a
to do that for yourself to turn to a
to do that for yourself to turn to a neighbor today find something
neighbor today find something
neighbor today find something intentionally that you disagree about
intentionally that you disagree about
intentionally that you disagree about and actually have a conversation about
and actually have a conversation about
and actually have a conversation about why ask them why you tell your story
why ask them why you tell your story
why ask them why you tell your story find that magic in-between place where
find that magic in-between place where
find that magic in-between place where you actually find out you know what you
you actually find out you know what you
you actually find out you know what you actually agree like 80% on this we might
actually agree like 80% on this we might
actually agree like 80% on this we might disagree on a few other details it’s
disagree on a few other details it’s
disagree on a few other details it’s vitally important as landsat pushes into
vitally important as landsat pushes into
vitally important as landsat pushes into the development of its ninth space craft
the development of its ninth space craft
the development of its ninth space craft we’re gonna start talking a lot more
we’re gonna start talking a lot more
we’re gonna start talking a lot more about the cryosphere or the frozen water
about the cryosphere or the frozen water
about the cryosphere or the frozen water on our earth on our ever warming earth
on our earth on our ever warming earth
on our earth on our ever warming earth so wouldn’t it be great if by the time
so wouldn’t it be great if by the time
so wouldn’t it be great if by the time we actually get to those really hard
we actually get to those really hard
we actually get to those really hard conversations that we can actually talk
conversations that we can actually talk
conversations that we can actually talk to each other and come and pick
to each other and come and pick
to each other and come and pick solutions not from the ends but from in
solutions not from the ends but from in
solutions not from the ends but from in the middle somewhere and that we find
the middle somewhere and that we find
the middle somewhere and that we find solutions that that satisfy my needs and
solutions that that satisfy my needs and
solutions that that satisfy my needs and your needs and your needs it may be even
your needs and your needs it may be even
your needs and your needs it may be even your needs by the time we get there I
your needs by the time we get there I
your needs by the time we get there I think it’s vital to the progression
think it’s vital to the progression
think it’s vital to the progression success of dealing with these ever more
success of dealing with these ever more
success of dealing with these ever more complicated challenges as we move
complicated challenges as we move
complicated challenges as we move forward thank you
you
you [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment