Press "Enter" to skip to content

Feminism, fatherhood and the nurturing instinct | Gavin Evans | TEDxCoventGardenWomen


I want to go back 22 years to the

I want to go back 22 years to the mid-1990s when my second daughter was

mid-1990s when my second daughter was

mid-1990s when my second daughter was still a toddler she’s in fact here with

still a toddler she’s in fact here with

still a toddler she’s in fact here with me this evening

me this evening

me this evening and every day I used to take her along

and every day I used to take her along

and every day I used to take her along to play groups and library sing-alongs

to play groups and library sing-alongs

to play groups and library sing-alongs and romps in the park and quite often I

and romps in the park and quite often I

and romps in the park and quite often I was the only dad present and I remember

was the only dad present and I remember

was the only dad present and I remember on one of those play days a mother came

on one of those play days a mother came

on one of those play days a mother came up to me and she was a newbie in the

up to me and she was a newbie in the

up to me and she was a newbie in the group and she said it’s so nice that you

group and she said it’s so nice that you

group and she said it’s so nice that you take a turn with the babysitting well I

take a turn with the babysitting well I

take a turn with the babysitting well I sort of bristled inside but I didn’t say

sort of bristled inside but I didn’t say

sort of bristled inside but I didn’t say anything a little bit later when I was

anything a little bit later when I was

anything a little bit later when I was changing my daughter’s nappy she kind of

changing my daughter’s nappy she kind of

changing my daughter’s nappy she kind of hovered over me as if she was inspecting

hovered over me as if she was inspecting

hovered over me as if she was inspecting my handiwork and again I didn’t say

my handiwork and again I didn’t say

my handiwork and again I didn’t say anything

anything

anything finally when my daughter was tired and

finally when my daughter was tired and

finally when my daughter was tired and tetchy she scooped up and she said to me

tetchy she scooped up and she said to me

tetchy she scooped up and she said to me you go get yourself a nice cup of tea

you go get yourself a nice cup of tea

you go get yourself a nice cup of tea we mums will look after her well I’m

we mums will look after her well I’m

we mums will look after her well I’m sure she meant well

sure she meant well

sure she meant well but I didn’t respond very kindly I just

but I didn’t respond very kindly I just

but I didn’t respond very kindly I just said retreat my daughter and I said I

said retreat my daughter and I said I

said retreat my daughter and I said I said to her I really don’t need your

said to her I really don’t need your

said to her I really don’t need your help thank you and by the way I’m not

help thank you and by the way I’m not

help thank you and by the way I’m not taking a turn with the babysitting I’m

taking a turn with the babysitting I’m

taking a turn with the babysitting I’m just doing what comes naturally not over

just doing what comes naturally not over

just doing what comes naturally not over the previous few years of parenting I’d

the previous few years of parenting I’d

the previous few years of parenting I’d had a few experiences was suggested that

had a few experiences was suggested that

had a few experiences was suggested that not everybody thought that the presence

not everybody thought that the presence

not everybody thought that the presence of fathers in playgroups was quite so

of fathers in playgroups was quite so

of fathers in playgroups was quite so natural sometimes it was just a

natural sometimes it was just a

natural sometimes it was just a quizzical look or a backhanded

quizzical look or a backhanded

quizzical look or a backhanded compliment well done dad as if I had

compliment well done dad as if I had

compliment well done dad as if I had special needs or maybe just being left

special needs or maybe just being left

special needs or maybe just being left out of the the playful banter but it was

out of the the playful banter but it was

out of the the playful banter but it was that babysitting one that really struck

that babysitting one that really struck

that babysitting one that really struck and I remember for the rest of that

and I remember for the rest of that

and I remember for the rest of that session I made less effort with the

session I made less effort with the

session I made less effort with the other parents and I think behind that

other parents and I think behind that

other parents and I think behind that was a sort of fleeting suspicion that I

was a sort of fleeting suspicion that I

was a sort of fleeting suspicion that I was there as an impostor maybe some of

was there as an impostor maybe some of

was there as an impostor maybe some of you have had that experience in in

you have had that experience in in

you have had that experience in in different circumstances before anyway

different circumstances before anyway

different circumstances before anyway when I went home that afternoon I sort

when I went home that afternoon I sort

when I went home that afternoon I sort of shooed it over and

of shooed it over and

of shooed it over and thought that behind that well-meaning

thought that behind that well-meaning

thought that behind that well-meaning mother’s response was a view that

mother’s response was a view that

mother’s response was a view that fathers were not natural carers that

fathers were not natural carers that

fathers were not natural carers that they lacked the required mindset and

they lacked the required mindset and

they lacked the required mindset and skills for the job and the reason it

skills for the job and the reason it

skills for the job and the reason it exasperated me so much was because I

exasperated me so much was because I

exasperated me so much was because I knew from my own experience that this

knew from my own experience that this

knew from my own experience that this wasn’t true so it didn’t take me very

wasn’t true so it didn’t take me very

wasn’t true so it didn’t take me very long to join up the dots and to see that

long to join up the dots and to see that

long to join up the dots and to see that that little experience of prejudice on

that little experience of prejudice on

that little experience of prejudice on the sing-alongs circuit might just have

the sing-alongs circuit might just have

the sing-alongs circuit might just have something in common with the experience

something in common with the experience

something in common with the experience of so many women in the world at work

of so many women in the world at work

of so many women in the world at work the false assumption that because of

the false assumption that because of

the false assumption that because of their gender they weren’t quite up to

their gender they weren’t quite up to

their gender they weren’t quite up to the job and it was then that it dawned

the job and it was then that it dawned

the job and it was then that it dawned on me that fatherhood is a feminist

on me that fatherhood is a feminist

on me that fatherhood is a feminist issue now I want to wrote back a little

issue now I want to wrote back a little

issue now I want to wrote back a little bit

bit

bit and to say something about my own

and to say something about my own

and to say something about my own upbringing my own father Bruce Evans was

upbringing my own father Bruce Evans was

upbringing my own father Bruce Evans was very much head of the family he said so

very much head of the family he said so

very much head of the family he said so himself as he sat at the head of the

himself as he sat at the head of the

himself as he sat at the head of the table what he called the head of the

table what he called the head of the

table what he called the head of the table and he worked six days a week long

table and he worked six days a week long

table and he worked six days a week long hours my mother Joan Evans or

hours my mother Joan Evans or

hours my mother Joan Evans or occasionally mrs. Bruce Evans didn’t

occasionally mrs. Bruce Evans didn’t

occasionally mrs. Bruce Evans didn’t have a job of her own her role was to

have a job of her own her role was to

have a job of her own her role was to support my father and to look after the

support my father and to look after the

support my father and to look after the three children now that didn’t mean that

three children now that didn’t mean that

three children now that didn’t mean that my loving dad played no domestic role he

my loving dad played no domestic role he

my loving dad played no domestic role he could change a nappy he could wash the

could change a nappy he could wash the

could change a nappy he could wash the dishes he could dispense advice he would

dishes he could dispense advice he would

dishes he could dispense advice he would listen to us and he was the last word in

listen to us and he was the last word in

listen to us and he was the last word in discipline which very occasionally took

discipline which very occasionally took

discipline which very occasionally took on physical dimensions so that then was

on physical dimensions so that then was

on physical dimensions so that then was the model the fatherhood that I grew up

the model the fatherhood that I grew up

the model the fatherhood that I grew up with and just to add to the picture I

with and just to add to the picture I

with and just to add to the picture I was sent to an all-boys state school

was sent to an all-boys state school

was sent to an all-boys state school where very soon learned to keep a stiff

where very soon learned to keep a stiff

where very soon learned to keep a stiff upper lip when being caned and we would

upper lip when being caned and we would

upper lip when being caned and we would march around in cocky uniforms and I

march around in cocky uniforms and I

march around in cocky uniforms and I learned to handle guns and then outside

learned to handle guns and then outside

learned to handle guns and then outside the school gates this kind of male-only

the school gates this kind of male-only

the school gates this kind of male-only world was reinforced by my obsession

world was reinforced by my obsession

world was reinforced by my obsession with boxing my maiden career ambition

with boxing my maiden career ambition

with boxing my maiden career ambition was to be heavyweight champion of the

was to be heavyweight champion of the

was to be heavyweight champion of the world

world

world yeah that one worked out really well

yeah that one worked out really well

yeah that one worked out really well and I didn’t have any really intimate

and I didn’t have any really intimate

and I didn’t have any really intimate female friends until I was 17 and I

female friends until I was 17 and I

female friends until I was 17 and I guess all this is world dug in because

guess all this is world dug in because

guess all this is world dug in because the impact of your first 17 years of

the impact of your first 17 years of

the impact of your first 17 years of life is very likely to be more profound

life is very likely to be more profound

life is very likely to be more profound than the impact of much of what follows

than the impact of much of what follows

than the impact of much of what follows but when I went to university I was

but when I went to university I was

but when I went to university I was first confronted with feminist ideas and

first confronted with feminist ideas and

first confronted with feminist ideas and this prompted me to change many of the

this prompted me to change many of the

this prompted me to change many of the notions that I’d grown up with but the

notions that I’d grown up with but the

notions that I’d grown up with but the more profound challenge I think came

more profound challenge I think came

more profound challenge I think came when I had two children of my own and

when I had two children of my own and

when I had two children of my own and they were both daughters and I longed

they were both daughters and I longed

they were both daughters and I longed for them to excel in life and not to be

for them to excel in life and not to be

for them to excel in life and not to be held back by the sexist detritus of the

held back by the sexist detritus of the

held back by the sexist detritus of the culture around them and I also realized

culture around them and I also realized

culture around them and I also realized a little bit to my surprise actually

a little bit to my surprise actually

a little bit to my surprise actually that I was quite good with looking after

that I was quite good with looking after

that I was quite good with looking after children and that I wanted to play at

children and that I wanted to play at

children and that I wanted to play at least an equal role in the upbringing

least an equal role in the upbringing

least an equal role in the upbringing and so we arranged our lives and work

and so we arranged our lives and work

and so we arranged our lives and work accordingly we were both providers and

accordingly we were both providers and

accordingly we were both providers and we both played equal roles in the

we both played equal roles in the

we both played equal roles in the child-rearing and the housework worked

child-rearing and the housework worked

child-rearing and the housework worked out in meticulous detail and by the way

out in meticulous detail and by the way

out in meticulous detail and by the way when we finally got married my wife

when we finally got married my wife

when we finally got married my wife didn’t become another mrs. Evans now all

didn’t become another mrs. Evans now all

didn’t become another mrs. Evans now all this was hardly typical of my generation

this was hardly typical of my generation

this was hardly typical of my generation I’d have to admit but by 1990 when my

I’d have to admit but by 1990 when my

I’d have to admit but by 1990 when my first child was born

first child was born

first child was born I think things were starting to change

I think things were starting to change

I think things were starting to change but gradually and unevenly and I

but gradually and unevenly and I

but gradually and unevenly and I realized this because as a result of

realized this because as a result of

realized this because as a result of these experiences I began researching

these experiences I began researching

these experiences I began researching this issue and then writing on it and

this issue and then writing on it and

this issue and then writing on it and lettering on it so if we would take a

lettering on it so if we would take a

lettering on it so if we would take a screen shot of gender relations today we

screen shot of gender relations today we

screen shot of gender relations today we would see that all over the world men

would see that all over the world men

would see that all over the world men are working longer hours and are earning

are working longer hours and are earning

are working longer hours and are earning considerably more and that women are

considerably more and that women are

considerably more and that women are spending longer hours on childcare and

spending longer hours on childcare and

spending longer hours on childcare and housework but if instead we took a

housework but if instead we took a

housework but if instead we took a cross-generational film we would see

cross-generational film we would see

cross-generational film we would see that men are spending more time on

that men are spending more time on

that men are spending more time on childcare and more time on housework

childcare and more time on housework

childcare and more time on housework than they ever did in the 20th century

than they ever did in the 20th century

than they ever did in the 20th century and that women are on spending longer

and that women are on spending longer

and that women are on spending longer hours at work now a great deal has been

hours at work now a great deal has been

hours at work now a great deal has been written on whether the gender gap is

written on whether the gender gap is

written on whether the gender gap is closing in the world at work but not so

closing in the world at work but not so

closing in the world at work but not so much has been written on the world of

much has been written on the world of

much has been written on the world of the home but there too the changes are

the home but there too the changes are

the home but there too the changes are real just a couple of examples in

real just a couple of examples in

real just a couple of examples in 1865 American men put in just 13% of the

1865 American men put in just 13% of the

1865 American men put in just 13% of the combined childcare and housework by 2011

combined childcare and housework by 2011

combined childcare and housework by 2011 that had risen to 35% and bear with me

that had risen to 35% and bear with me

that had risen to 35% and bear with me just one more in 1957 one percent of

just one more in 1957 one percent of

just one more in 1957 one percent of British fathers attended the births of

British fathers attended the births of

British fathers attended the births of their children today 93 percent so it’s

their children today 93 percent so it’s

their children today 93 percent so it’s clear that the tectonic plates are

clear that the tectonic plates are

clear that the tectonic plates are shifting in the way that men relate to

shifting in the way that men relate to

shifting in the way that men relate to their children but perhaps not quite as

their children but perhaps not quite as

their children but perhaps not quite as fast as the way that women are relating

fast as the way that women are relating

fast as the way that women are relating to the world at work now why is that and

to the world at work now why is that and

to the world at work now why is that and one answer might be that it’s perfectly

one answer might be that it’s perfectly

one answer might be that it’s perfectly natural and there’s some truth in that

natural and there’s some truth in that

natural and there’s some truth in that after all women have nine months of

after all women have nine months of

after all women have nine months of pregnancy and that allows them to bond

pregnancy and that allows them to bond

pregnancy and that allows them to bond with their babies in a way that’s not

with their babies in a way that’s not

with their babies in a way that’s not available to fathers but there’s a

available to fathers but there’s a

available to fathers but there’s a widespread belief that it goes far far

widespread belief that it goes far far

widespread belief that it goes far far further than that that men are

further than that that men are

further than that that men are hard-wired for single-minded striving

hard-wired for single-minded striving

hard-wired for single-minded striving and that women are hard-wired for caring

and that women are hard-wired for caring

and that women are hard-wired for caring and sharing and the multitasking that’s

and sharing and the multitasking that’s

and sharing and the multitasking that’s so necessary to run a family and a

so necessary to run a family and a

so necessary to run a family and a hasselt and related to that is a view

hasselt and related to that is a view

hasselt and related to that is a view that women are drenched with these

that women are drenched with these

that women are drenched with these loving nurturing hormones and this helps

loving nurturing hormones and this helps

loving nurturing hormones and this helps prompt the maternal instinct so let’s

prompt the maternal instinct so let’s

prompt the maternal instinct so let’s have a look at these two claims starting

have a look at these two claims starting

have a look at these two claims starting with the multitasking one and this is

with the multitasking one and this is

with the multitasking one and this is often based on the belief that men’s

often based on the belief that men’s

often based on the belief that men’s brains and women’s brains are completely

brains and women’s brains are completely

brains and women’s brains are completely different and those holding this belief

different and those holding this belief

different and those holding this belief often say that the communication center

often say that the communication center

often say that the communication center between the two hemispheres of our brain

between the two hemispheres of our brain

between the two hemispheres of our brain which is called the corpus callosum is

which is called the corpus callosum is

which is called the corpus callosum is larger and more substantial in a woman’s

larger and more substantial in a woman’s

larger and more substantial in a woman’s brain than in a man’s brain and this

brain than in a man’s brain and this

brain than in a man’s brain and this helps them be much better multitaskers

helps them be much better multitaskers

helps them be much better multitaskers and this is simply untrue they’ve been

and this is simply untrue they’ve been

and this is simply untrue they’ve been hundreds of studies of the size of the

hundreds of studies of the size of the

hundreds of studies of the size of the corpus callosum and there’s no gender

corpus callosum and there’s no gender

corpus callosum and there’s no gender difference whatsoever in them and by the

difference whatsoever in them and by the

difference whatsoever in them and by the way they’ve also been studies of

way they’ve also been studies of

way they’ve also been studies of multitasking ability and again no gender

multitasking ability and again no gender

multitasking ability and again no gender difference now the issue of hormones

difference now the issue of hormones

difference now the issue of hormones that that prompt maternal instinct is a

that that prompt maternal instinct is a

that that prompt maternal instinct is a trickier one the two candidates there

trickier one the two candidates there

trickier one the two candidates there are the so-called love hormone oxytocin

are the so-called love hormone oxytocin

are the so-called love hormone oxytocin and the social bonding hormone

and the social bonding hormone

and the social bonding hormone vasopressin and again is a belief that

vasopressin and again is a belief that

vasopressin and again is a belief that these are female and only hormones and

these are female and only hormones and

these are female and only hormones and again this is false and in fact when

again this is false and in fact when

again this is false and in fact when very

very

very our sample studies showed that

our sample studies showed that

our sample studies showed that vasopressin levels were slightly higher

vasopressin levels were slightly higher

vasopressin levels were slightly higher in boys oxytocin levels slightly higher

in boys oxytocin levels slightly higher

in boys oxytocin levels slightly higher in girls but the differences were

in girls but the differences were

in girls but the differences were meniscal now certainly women do receive

meniscal now certainly women do receive

meniscal now certainly women do receive an oxytocin boost during pregnancy but

an oxytocin boost during pregnancy but

an oxytocin boost during pregnancy but studies have also shown that men receive

studies have also shown that men receive

studies have also shown that men receive an oxytocin boost through intimate

an oxytocin boost through intimate

an oxytocin boost through intimate contacts with their children so I think

contacts with their children so I think

contacts with their children so I think what we could say is that both men and

what we could say is that both men and

what we could say is that both men and women get a nurturing instinct boost

women get a nurturing instinct boost

women get a nurturing instinct boost from spending time with their children

from spending time with their children

from spending time with their children what an argument that I often heard when

what an argument that I often heard when

what an argument that I often heard when I was raising my children was that we

I was raising my children was that we

I was raising my children was that we knew dads were a kind of cultural

knew dads were a kind of cultural

knew dads were a kind of cultural aberration going against thousands of

aberration going against thousands of

aberration going against thousands of years of history and tens of thousands

years of history and tens of thousands

years of history and tens of thousands of years of prehistory

of years of prehistory

of years of prehistory well actually we know absolutely nothing

well actually we know absolutely nothing

well actually we know absolutely nothing about gender in in prehistory but what

about gender in in prehistory but what

about gender in in prehistory but what the least we can say well the little

the least we can say well the little

the least we can say well the little thing we can say is that studies of

thing we can say is that studies of

thing we can say is that studies of tribes today hunter-gatherer tribes the

tribes today hunter-gatherer tribes the

tribes today hunter-gatherer tribes the few remaining hunter-gatherer tribes

few remaining hunter-gatherer tribes

few remaining hunter-gatherer tribes today show that in several of them

today show that in several of them

today show that in several of them fathers play a very substantial role and

fathers play a very substantial role and

fathers play a very substantial role and one of these studies involve the Acker

one of these studies involve the Acker

one of these studies involve the Acker community in the Congo Basin and Barry

community in the Congo Basin and Barry

community in the Congo Basin and Barry Hewlett an American anthropologist spent

Hewlett an American anthropologist spent

Hewlett an American anthropologist spent 13 years and studying them and he found

13 years and studying them and he found

13 years and studying them and he found that Agra dads spent at least five times

that Agra dads spent at least five times

that Agra dads spent at least five times as much time with their infants as was

as much time with their infants as was

as much time with their infants as was the norm in Western society and he often

the norm in Western society and he often

the norm in Western society and he often absorbed this observed them holding them

absorbed this observed them holding them

absorbed this observed them holding them close to their bodies for an hour or

close to their bodies for an hour or

close to their bodies for an hour or more at a time and letting them suck on

more at a time and letting them suck on

more at a time and letting them suck on their nipples now I mentioned this

their nipples now I mentioned this

their nipples now I mentioned this little example because what we often

little example because what we often

little example because what we often assumed to be immutable and innate turns

assumed to be immutable and innate turns

assumed to be immutable and innate turns out to be cultural and therefore

out to be cultural and therefore

out to be cultural and therefore changeable we are not computers and our

changeable we are not computers and our

changeable we are not computers and our brains really aren’t hardwired for

brains really aren’t hardwired for

brains really aren’t hardwired for anything much at all instead they are

anything much at all instead they are

anything much at all instead they are molded by experience now certainly

molded by experience now certainly

molded by experience now certainly cultural traditions going back thousands

cultural traditions going back thousands

cultural traditions going back thousands of years can be very hard to budge but

of years can be very hard to budge but

of years can be very hard to budge but sometimes economic necessity has a way

sometimes economic necessity has a way

sometimes economic necessity has a way of opening up options here and closing

of opening up options here and closing

of opening up options here and closing off others there and that is true of the

off others there and that is true of the

off others there and that is true of the household as it is of the workplace so

household as it is of the workplace so

household as it is of the workplace so if women are narrowing the gap

if women are narrowing the gap

if women are narrowing the gap in terms of hours spent at work but are

in terms of hours spent at work but are

in terms of hours spent at work but are still way outpacing men when it comes to

still way outpacing men when it comes to

still way outpacing men when it comes to hours spent on childcare and housework

hours spent on childcare and housework

hours spent on childcare and housework then something has to give and it’s not

then something has to give and it’s not

then something has to give and it’s not likely that women are going to retreat

likely that women are going to retreat

likely that women are going to retreat from the world at work not when girls

from the world at work not when girls

from the world at work not when girls are outperforming boys in just about

are outperforming boys in just about

are outperforming boys in just about every subject in just about every

every subject in just about every

every subject in just about every country so the other alternative is that

country so the other alternative is that

country so the other alternative is that men increase their domestic role so that

men increase their domestic role so that

men increase their domestic role so that in future the presence of fathers in

in future the presence of fathers in

in future the presence of fathers in play groups would be unremarkable and no

play groups would be unremarkable and no

play groups would be unremarkable and no one would say so nice that you take a

one would say so nice that you take a

one would say so nice that you take a turn with the babysitting I would you

turn with the babysitting I would you

turn with the babysitting I would you end on a more personal note I’ve already

end on a more personal note I’ve already

end on a more personal note I’ve already mentioned how the experience of having

mentioned how the experience of having

mentioned how the experience of having two daughters nudged me to understand

two daughters nudged me to understand

two daughters nudged me to understand that fatherhood was a feminist issue and

that fatherhood was a feminist issue and

that fatherhood was a feminist issue and along the way I came to see that

along the way I came to see that

along the way I came to see that feminism had a lot to offer me as a man

feminism had a lot to offer me as a man

feminism had a lot to offer me as a man specifically that I would broaden my

specifically that I would broaden my

specifically that I would broaden my horizons if I brace the idea that I was

horizons if I brace the idea that I was

horizons if I brace the idea that I was good at nurturing children and that the

good at nurturing children and that the

good at nurturing children and that the ability to read their emotions or indeed

ability to read their emotions or indeed

ability to read their emotions or indeed express my own was not beyond me and

express my own was not beyond me and

express my own was not beyond me and that the multitasking necessary to run a

that the multitasking necessary to run a

that the multitasking necessary to run a household was also within my range and I

household was also within my range and I

household was also within my range and I also came to see that my prime role in

also came to see that my prime role in

also came to see that my prime role in life wasn’t one of shimmying up a greasy

life wasn’t one of shimmying up a greasy

life wasn’t one of shimmying up a greasy career ladder while somebody else looked

career ladder while somebody else looked

career ladder while somebody else looked after my children and for that matter

after my children and for that matter

after my children and for that matter that I didn’t always need to wear the

that I didn’t always need to wear the

that I didn’t always need to wear the trousers in my relationships as my

trousers in my relationships as my

trousers in my relationships as my father used to put it so while feminism

father used to put it so while feminism

father used to put it so while feminism is mainly about the advance of women it

is mainly about the advance of women it

is mainly about the advance of women it seems to me it also has a lot to offer

seems to me it also has a lot to offer

seems to me it also has a lot to offer in terms of the advance of men what it

in terms of the advance of men what it

in terms of the advance of men what it offers us is a much broader suspect

offers us is a much broader suspect

offers us is a much broader suspect perspective of our own humanity more

perspective of our own humanity more

perspective of our own humanity more room to spread our wings as fathers as

room to spread our wings as fathers as

room to spread our wings as fathers as lovers and as human beings thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *