Press "Enter" to skip to content

Solving the Achievement Gap Through Equity, Not Equality | Lindsey Ott | TEDxYouth@Columbia


consider a student that’s 19 is a

consider a student that’s 19 is a fifth-year graduate and considered to be

fifth-year graduate and considered to be

fifth-year graduate and considered to be at risk the student has an extremely low

at risk the student has an extremely low

at risk the student has an extremely low GPA and is what teachers like to refer

GPA and is what teachers like to refer

GPA and is what teachers like to refer to as a challenge in the classroom which

to as a challenge in the classroom which

to as a challenge in the classroom which really means that they’re a terror

really means that they’re a terror

really means that they’re a terror judging by our current education system

judging by our current education system

judging by our current education system this student appears to be a failure

this student appears to be a failure

this student appears to be a failure well in reality the student went on to

well in reality the student went on to

well in reality the student went on to attend a prestigious culinary program

attend a prestigious culinary program

attend a prestigious culinary program and became very successful as a

and became very successful as a

and became very successful as a beginning teacher I thought that I would

beginning teacher I thought that I would

beginning teacher I thought that I would walk into a classroom and I would have

walk into a classroom and I would have

walk into a classroom and I would have lots of eager students and careful

lots of eager students and careful

lots of eager students and careful lesson plans and assessments and I would

lesson plans and assessments and I would

lesson plans and assessments and I would grade all my students based on how well

grade all my students based on how well

grade all my students based on how well they did on those assessments everything

they did on those assessments everything

they did on those assessments everything would be based on equality I read all

would be based on equality I read all

would be based on equality I read all the research on learning styles and how

the research on learning styles and how

the research on learning styles and how to teach all the way up to the newest

to teach all the way up to the newest

to teach all the way up to the newest instructional impacts what I almost

instructional impacts what I almost

instructional impacts what I almost immediately found out is that reality

immediately found out is that reality

immediately found out is that reality almost never matches the textbooks just

almost never matches the textbooks just

almost never matches the textbooks just like grades almost never match students

like grades almost never match students

like grades almost never match students so let’s consider two students that have

so let’s consider two students that have

so let’s consider two students that have taught the first is a 15 year old

taught the first is a 15 year old

taught the first is a 15 year old student who is a head of state

student who is a head of state

student who is a head of state requirements for graduation the student

requirements for graduation the student

requirements for graduation the student lives in a two-parent home and the

lives in a two-parent home and the

lives in a two-parent home and the suburbs and drops to school every day

suburbs and drops to school every day

suburbs and drops to school every day right now the student is taking college

right now the student is taking college

right now the student is taking college classes while working to improve ACC

classes while working to improve ACC

classes while working to improve ACC scores the student wants to get a full

scores the student wants to get a full

scores the student wants to get a full academic scholarship and become an

academic scholarship and become an

academic scholarship and become an environmental engineer the second

environmental engineer the second

environmental engineer the second student is a bit behind in state

student is a bit behind in state

student is a bit behind in state requirements for graduation but is very

requirements for graduation but is very

requirements for graduation but is very persistent in working towards a diploma

persistent in working towards a diploma

persistent in working towards a diploma the student wants to be a cosmetologist

the student wants to be a cosmetologist

the student wants to be a cosmetologist but has faced more than a fair share of

but has faced more than a fair share of

but has faced more than a fair share of adversity the student lives in an

adversity the student lives in an

adversity the student lives in an extended-stay hotel with multiple other

extended-stay hotel with multiple other

extended-stay hotel with multiple other adults and struggles to find

adults and struggles to find

adults and struggles to find transportation so the way I thought I

transportation so the way I thought I

transportation so the way I thought I would teach I would have both of these

would teach I would have both of these

would teach I would have both of these students in my classroom I would give

students in my classroom I would give

students in my classroom I would give them the same work they would be

them the same work they would be

them the same work they would be assessed on the same standards all of

assessed on the same standards all of

assessed on the same standards all of this to level the playing field for

this to level the playing field for

this to level the playing field for these two students in reality what this

these two students in reality what this

these two students in reality what this does is it

does is it

does is it really magnifies the differences in

really magnifies the differences in

really magnifies the differences in these two students everyone knows the

these two students everyone knows the

these two students everyone knows the results of equal education you’ve all

results of equal education you’ve all

results of equal education you’ve all heard of the achievement gap an

heard of the achievement gap an

heard of the achievement gap an achievement gap occurs when one group of

achievement gap occurs when one group of

achievement gap occurs when one group of students scores higher than another when

students scores higher than another when

students scores higher than another when they’re grouped by gender race ethnicity

they’re grouped by gender race ethnicity

they’re grouped by gender race ethnicity socioeconomic status equality reinforces

socioeconomic status equality reinforces

socioeconomic status equality reinforces that achievement gap by imposing the

that achievement gap by imposing the

that achievement gap by imposing the same standards and norms on really

same standards and norms on really

same standards and norms on really different groups of people equity on the

different groups of people equity on the

different groups of people equity on the other hand would close that achievement

other hand would close that achievement

other hand would close that achievement gap by giving the needed support and

gap by giving the needed support and

gap by giving the needed support and support structures to those very

support structures to those very

support structures to those very different groups equality and equity are

different groups equality and equity are

different groups equality and equity are not synonymous equality is giving

not synonymous equality is giving

not synonymous equality is giving everybody a size 10 pair of shoes some

everybody a size 10 pair of shoes some

everybody a size 10 pair of shoes some people are gonna be really excited about

people are gonna be really excited about

people are gonna be really excited about the size 10 pair of shoes unless you

the size 10 pair of shoes unless you

the size 10 pair of shoes unless you don’t wear a size 10 equity is giving

don’t wear a size 10 equity is giving

don’t wear a size 10 equity is giving everyone a pair of shoes that fits in

everyone a pair of shoes that fits in

everyone a pair of shoes that fits in order to close the achievement gap we

order to close the achievement gap we

order to close the achievement gap we have to give every student a pair of

have to give every student a pair of

have to give every student a pair of shoes that fits and that means designing

shoes that fits and that means designing

shoes that fits and that means designing curriculum and instruction for each

curriculum and instruction for each

curriculum and instruction for each individual student and their personal

individual student and their personal

individual student and their personal challenges so let’s go back to my two

challenges so let’s go back to my two

challenges so let’s go back to my two students the way education works now

students the way education works now

students the way education works now both of these students are expected to

both of these students are expected to

both of these students are expected to come to school and sit in a class for

come to school and sit in a class for

come to school and sit in a class for 120 hours over the course of a year or a

120 hours over the course of a year or a

120 hours over the course of a year or a semester and they complete coursework

semester and they complete coursework

semester and they complete coursework that’s aligned to a set of standards

that’s aligned to a set of standards

that’s aligned to a set of standards that are developed by an outside agency

that are developed by an outside agency

that are developed by an outside agency on the most basic level of just showing

on the most basic level of just showing

on the most basic level of just showing up for school you can really see the

up for school you can really see the

up for school you can really see the difference in these two students for the

difference in these two students for the

difference in these two students for the engineer showing up to school is really

engineer showing up to school is really

engineer showing up to school is really easy transportation the hot breakfast

easy transportation the hot breakfast

easy transportation the hot breakfast clean clothes all of that stuff has

clean clothes all of that stuff has

clean clothes all of that stuff has already been provided for the

already been provided for the

already been provided for the cosmetologist just the act of showing up

cosmetologist just the act of showing up

cosmetologist just the act of showing up to the building requires a huge

to the building requires a huge

to the building requires a huge expenditure of energy and resources and

expenditure of energy and resources and

expenditure of energy and resources and what’s in the classroom those

what’s in the classroom those

what’s in the classroom those differences get even larger when the

differences get even larger when the

differences get even larger when the students have to start completing

students have to start completing

students have to start completing assignments Yong Zhao author and

assignments Yong Zhao author and

assignments Yong Zhao author and professor of Education measurement

professor of Education measurement

professor of Education measurement policy

policy

policy in leadership sites a Yale University

in leadership sites a Yale University

in leadership sites a Yale University study that groups the abilities of high

study that groups the abilities of high

study that groups the abilities of high school students all the students are

school students all the students are

school students all the students are placed into five groups high practical

placed into five groups high practical

placed into five groups high practical high analytical high creative high and

high analytical high creative high and

high analytical high creative high and all three or low in all three and the

all three or low in all three and the

all three or low in all three and the results of this study overwhelmingly

results of this study overwhelmingly

results of this study overwhelmingly show that those students who score high

show that those students who score high

show that those students who score high analytical are white middle class and

analytical are white middle class and

analytical are white middle class and from strong educational backgrounds

from strong educational backgrounds

from strong educational backgrounds those who score high practical and high

those who score high practical and high

those who score high practical and high creative are from much more diverse

creative are from much more diverse

creative are from much more diverse backgrounds in terms of ethnicity

backgrounds in terms of ethnicity

backgrounds in terms of ethnicity socioeconomic status and educational

socioeconomic status and educational

socioeconomic status and educational background the problem is the only type

background the problem is the only type

background the problem is the only type of ability that’s really valued by our

of ability that’s really valued by our

of ability that’s really valued by our education system is that high analytical

education system is that high analytical

education system is that high analytical ability that’s generally correlated with

ability that’s generally correlated with

ability that’s generally correlated with problem-solving in math and languages

when I walk into a classroom and hand

when I walk into a classroom and hand every student in my classroom one

every student in my classroom one

every student in my classroom one uniform assignment I’m giving everybody

uniform assignment I’m giving everybody

uniform assignment I’m giving everybody in there a size 10 pair of shoes those

in there a size 10 pair of shoes those

in there a size 10 pair of shoes those shoes may fit a few students but it’s

shoes may fit a few students but it’s

shoes may fit a few students but it’s not going to fit the majority of

not going to fit the majority of

not going to fit the majority of students what I should be doing is

students what I should be doing is

students what I should be doing is walking into a classroom and giving a

walking into a classroom and giving a

walking into a classroom and giving a student an assignment that supports that

student an assignment that supports that

student an assignment that supports that students talents abilities and goals

students talents abilities and goals

students talents abilities and goals that’s providing equity in the classroom

that’s providing equity in the classroom

that’s providing equity in the classroom I have a lot of colleagues who are gonna

I have a lot of colleagues who are gonna

I have a lot of colleagues who are gonna say oh no absolutely not

say oh no absolutely not

say oh no absolutely not they have to meet the standard how are

they have to meet the standard how are

they have to meet the standard how are you gonna grade them and I certainly do

you gonna grade them and I certainly do

you gonna grade them and I certainly do not have time to create 30 assignments

not have time to create 30 assignments

not have time to create 30 assignments in one day I understand that but I also

in one day I understand that but I also

in one day I understand that but I also understand that the core business of a

understand that the core business of a

understand that the core business of a teacher is to provide students with the

teacher is to provide students with the

teacher is to provide students with the tools that they need to succeed not to

tools that they need to succeed not to

tools that they need to succeed not to provide them grades so in order to close

provide them grades so in order to close

provide them grades so in order to close that achievement gap and to promote

that achievement gap and to promote

that achievement gap and to promote success for every student those are the

success for every student those are the

success for every student those are the steps we have to take young Sal says

steps we have to take young Sal says

steps we have to take young Sal says also that the consequences of equality

also that the consequences of equality

also that the consequences of equality and education could be a situation where

and education could be a situation where

and education could be a situation where the government has to provide more

the government has to provide more

the government has to provide more social services but lacks a revenue

social services but lacks a revenue

social services but lacks a revenue stream to do so or tensions between

stream to do so or tensions between

stream to do so or tensions between skilled and unskilled

skilled and unskilled

skilled and unskilled rich and poor reach revolutionary levels

rich and poor reach revolutionary levels

rich and poor reach revolutionary levels on an individual level students face

on an individual level students face

on an individual level students face this increasing negative self-concept

this increasing negative self-concept

this increasing negative self-concept based on the fact that they can’t fit

based on the fact that they can’t fit

based on the fact that they can’t fit into this norms that are being placed

into this norms that are being placed

into this norms that are being placed upon them self discrepancy happens when

upon them self discrepancy happens when

upon them self discrepancy happens when your idea of yourself doesn’t match the

your idea of yourself doesn’t match the

your idea of yourself doesn’t match the outcomes that you receive so a student

outcomes that you receive so a student

outcomes that you receive so a student that already has a positive self-concept

that already has a positive self-concept

that already has a positive self-concept but receives negative outcomes in the

but receives negative outcomes in the

but receives negative outcomes in the form of grades test scores or emotional

form of grades test scores or emotional

form of grades test scores or emotional feedback from teachers it’s going to

feedback from teachers it’s going to

feedback from teachers it’s going to have a discrepancy in their actual and

have a discrepancy in their actual and

have a discrepancy in their actual and ideal self

ideal self

ideal self what happens in this case is that

what happens in this case is that

what happens in this case is that student develops dissatisfaction

student develops dissatisfaction

student develops dissatisfaction disappointment and low self esteem right

disappointment and low self esteem right

disappointment and low self esteem right now in the United States twenty-one

now in the United States twenty-one

now in the United States twenty-one percent are ten point nine million

percent are ten point nine million

percent are ten point nine million school children live below the poverty

school children live below the poverty

school children live below the poverty line those students show up to school

line those students show up to school

line those students show up to school every day with additional challenges an

every day with additional challenges an

every day with additional challenges an increasingly negative self-concept

increasingly negative self-concept

increasingly negative self-concept because they can’t fit into the

because they can’t fit into the

because they can’t fit into the standards that society expects them to

standards that society expects them to

standards that society expects them to fit into we have to embrace equity and

fit into we have to embrace equity and

fit into we have to embrace equity and move away from inequality in order to

move away from inequality in order to

move away from inequality in order to change the situation a Retta status on

change the situation a Retta status on

change the situation a Retta status on social media from one of my students it

social media from one of my students it

social media from one of my students it said I’m proud of myself I was expelled

said I’m proud of myself I was expelled

said I’m proud of myself I was expelled from school twice almost three times I’m

from school twice almost three times I’m

from school twice almost three times I’m sad to say I almost gave up it didn’t

sad to say I almost gave up it didn’t

sad to say I almost gave up it didn’t care anymore but something told me to

care anymore but something told me to

care anymore but something told me to keep going now I’m in a new school I

keep going now I’m in a new school I

keep going now I’m in a new school I have a 3.6 GPA and I’m starting college

have a 3.6 GPA and I’m starting college

have a 3.6 GPA and I’m starting college classes in the fall I am proud of me

classes in the fall I am proud of me

classes in the fall I am proud of me students like this student or why I

students like this student or why I

students like this student or why I teach providing equity and opportunity

teach providing equity and opportunity

teach providing equity and opportunity for this student and every student like

for this student and every student like

for this student and every student like this student or why we absolutely must

this student or why we absolutely must

this student or why we absolutely must abandon standardized talent sorting

abandon standardized talent sorting

abandon standardized talent sorting education and immediately embrace

education and immediately embrace

education and immediately embrace individualized talent developing

individualized talent developing

individualized talent developing education

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *