Press "Enter" to skip to content

Patient-Centered Care Systems: A View From Chronic Illness | Candy Gan | TEDxKingstonUponThamesSalon


Shanghai September 26th 1998 my parents

Shanghai September 26th 1998 my parents awoke to faint cries between laboured

awoke to faint cries between laboured

awoke to faint cries between laboured breathing from their first child at 18

breathing from their first child at 18

breathing from their first child at 18 months old I was dying and they didn’t

months old I was dying and they didn’t

months old I was dying and they didn’t know why they rushed me to the only

know why they rushed me to the only

know why they rushed me to the only Children’s Hospital still open that

Children’s Hospital still open that

Children’s Hospital still open that night my mom never carried me in her

night my mom never carried me in her

night my mom never carried me in her arms were feared that I would just go

had type 1 diabetes unsure of what that

had type 1 diabetes unsure of what that meant in terms of raising a child they

meant in terms of raising a child they

meant in terms of raising a child they decided to evacuate me back to Singapore

decided to evacuate me back to Singapore

decided to evacuate me back to Singapore essentially moving their lives back home

the first question my mom asks the

the first question my mom asks the doctor there was whether she’d be able

doctor there was whether she’d be able

doctor there was whether she’d be able to see me grow up now

to see me grow up now

to see me grow up now university wasn’t even in the question

university wasn’t even in the question

university wasn’t even in the question at that point she just wanted to know if

at that point she just wanted to know if

at that point she just wanted to know if I’d get past childhood the medical staff

I’d get past childhood the medical staff

I’d get past childhood the medical staff though focused on treating my condition

though focused on treating my condition

though focused on treating my condition in a very mechanical way and that left

in a very mechanical way and that left

in a very mechanical way and that left my mom’s emotional stress in a corner

so I’ve had type 1 diabetes for most of

so I’ve had type 1 diabetes for most of my life

my life

my life it’s an autoimmune disease which means

it’s an autoimmune disease which means

it’s an autoimmune disease which means that I have to do daily injections or

that I have to do daily injections or

that I have to do daily injections or wear an insulin pump as I am right now

wear an insulin pump as I am right now

wear an insulin pump as I am right now and I have to check my blood glucose

and I have to check my blood glucose

and I have to check my blood glucose multiple times a day having a chronic

multiple times a day having a chronic

multiple times a day having a chronic illness can feel quite isolating so last

illness can feel quite isolating so last

illness can feel quite isolating so last year I decided to write to a pen pal in

year I decided to write to a pen pal in

year I decided to write to a pen pal in Australia she also has type 1 and in one

Australia she also has type 1 and in one

Australia she also has type 1 and in one of her letters she said she doesn’t like

of her letters she said she doesn’t like

of her letters she said she doesn’t like being called a diabetic

being called a diabetic

being called a diabetic instead she introduces herself as a

instead she introduces herself as a

instead she introduces herself as a person with diabetes now to those who

person with diabetes now to those who

person with diabetes now to those who aren’t familiar with this disease it may

aren’t familiar with this disease it may

aren’t familiar with this disease it may seem like a small thing to fuss over I

seem like a small thing to fuss over I

seem like a small thing to fuss over I mean if we identify people based on

mean if we identify people based on

mean if we identify people based on their hair color their nationality then

their hair color their nationality then

their hair color their nationality then if our health statuses are just another

if our health statuses are just another

if our health statuses are just another feature of us being called a diabetic

feature of us being called a diabetic

feature of us being called a diabetic and amputee it shouldn’t matter so much

and amputee it shouldn’t matter so much

and amputee it shouldn’t matter so much right

at a discussion group by Diabetes UK I

at a discussion group by Diabetes UK I decided to ask my table the same

decided to ask my table the same

decided to ask my table the same question are you if somebody called you

question are you if somebody called you

question are you if somebody called you a diabetic rather than a pain a person

a diabetic rather than a pain a person

a diabetic rather than a pain a person with diabetes and the human was

with diabetes and the human was

with diabetes and the human was unanimous but why does the mere

unanimous but why does the mere

unanimous but why does the mere description of a disease matter so much

because the term diabetic is loaded it’s

because the term diabetic is loaded it’s loaded with the presumption that we are

loaded with the presumption that we are

loaded with the presumption that we are wholly responsible for our disease for

wholly responsible for our disease for

wholly responsible for our disease for the outcomes that medical staff and

the outcomes that medical staff and

the outcomes that medical staff and society charge us upon essentially

society charge us upon essentially

society charge us upon essentially because we’re seeing as accountable for

because we’re seeing as accountable for

because we’re seeing as accountable for our self-care we’re also assumed to be

our self-care we’re also assumed to be

our self-care we’re also assumed to be responsible for our measurable health

responsible for our measurable health

responsible for our measurable health outcomes now this is seeing the patient

outcomes now this is seeing the patient

outcomes now this is seeing the patient as their disease but tonight I want to

as their disease but tonight I want to

as their disease but tonight I want to talk about how disconnecting the –

talk about how disconnecting the –

talk about how disconnecting the – seeing the patient as more than their

seeing the patient as more than their

seeing the patient as more than their disease can essentially change our

disease can essentially change our

disease can essentially change our delivery of healthcare healthcare

delivery of healthcare healthcare

delivery of healthcare healthcare systems and developed countries are

systems and developed countries are

systems and developed countries are striving towards a new paradigm what is

striving towards a new paradigm what is

striving towards a new paradigm what is known as patient-centered care in this

known as patient-centered care in this

known as patient-centered care in this patients would share in the

patients would share in the

patients would share in the decision-making process rather than

decision-making process rather than

decision-making process rather than being told how to take care of

being told how to take care of

being told how to take care of themselves

themselves

themselves governments are realizing that by

governments are realizing that by

governments are realizing that by empowering patients and making health

empowering patients and making health

empowering patients and making health decisions this leads to better patient

decisions this leads to better patient

decisions this leads to better patient outcomes because they become happier

outcomes because they become happier

outcomes because they become happier with the treatment that they’re getting

with the treatment that they’re getting

with the treatment that they’re getting I remember being so afraid of going back

I remember being so afraid of going back

I remember being so afraid of going back to fencing when I first got my insulin

to fencing when I first got my insulin

to fencing when I first got my insulin pump I was so afraid of my opponent’s

pump I was so afraid of my opponent’s

pump I was so afraid of my opponent’s weapons striking the plastic tube

weapons striking the plastic tube

weapons striking the plastic tube acting my pumped my body because if that

acting my pumped my body because if that

acting my pumped my body because if that happens then there’ll be lots of

happens then there’ll be lots of

happens then there’ll be lots of bleeding I’ll have to change the whole

bleeding I’ll have to change the whole

bleeding I’ll have to change the whole set and I didn’t want to go through all

set and I didn’t want to go through all

set and I didn’t want to go through all of that hassle it’s just too much to

of that hassle it’s just too much to

of that hassle it’s just too much to deal with so for a whole term I didn’t

deal with so for a whole term I didn’t

deal with so for a whole term I didn’t turn up to any training session and when

turn up to any training session and when

turn up to any training session and when I talked to my endocrinologist back in

I talked to my endocrinologist back in

I talked to my endocrinologist back in Singapore he was shocked he suggested

Singapore he was shocked he suggested

Singapore he was shocked he suggested ways to protect my insulin pump

ways to protect my insulin pump

ways to protect my insulin pump strategies to manage this disease whilst

strategies to manage this disease whilst

strategies to manage this disease whilst doing such an intensive sport my doctor

doing such an intensive sport my doctor

doing such an intensive sport my doctor worked with me he respected my lifestyle

worked with me he respected my lifestyle

worked with me he respected my lifestyle decisions he showed me how to fit

decisions he showed me how to fit

decisions he showed me how to fit diabetes into my life rather than how I

diabetes into my life rather than how I

diabetes into my life rather than how I had to fit around my diabetes he showed

had to fit around my diabetes he showed

had to fit around my diabetes he showed me how I am NOT my disease

patient empowerment doesn’t mean the

patient empowerment doesn’t mean the patient is always right certainly it

patient is always right certainly it

patient is always right certainly it doesn’t mean any disrespect to the

doesn’t mean any disrespect to the

doesn’t mean any disrespect to the amazing training our health care

amazing training our health care

amazing training our health care professionals already go through but I

professionals already go through but I

professionals already go through but I believe that the way medicine has been

believe that the way medicine has been

believe that the way medicine has been traditionally practiced has focused too

traditionally practiced has focused too

traditionally practiced has focused too much on dissecting the patient into

much on dissecting the patient into

much on dissecting the patient into their individual health failings we’re

their individual health failings we’re

their individual health failings we’re not seeing all of these parts as a whole

not seeing all of these parts as a whole

not seeing all of these parts as a whole person with the rise in the number of

person with the rise in the number of

person with the rise in the number of people living to old age

people living to old age

people living to old age we need to drastically change the way we

we need to drastically change the way we

we need to drastically change the way we deliver healthcare because the key to

deliver healthcare because the key to

deliver healthcare because the key to good long-term sustainable care is

good long-term sustainable care is

good long-term sustainable care is patient empowerment and how are we

patient empowerment and how are we

patient empowerment and how are we supposed to care for them if we don’t

supposed to care for them if we don’t

supposed to care for them if we don’t know what they want one of my uncles has

know what they want one of my uncles has

know what they want one of my uncles has mild dementia high blood pressure and

mild dementia high blood pressure and

mild dementia high blood pressure and cataracts my on his caregiver she only

cataracts my on his caregiver she only

cataracts my on his caregiver she only wants to fix the last two she doesn’t

wants to fix the last two she doesn’t

wants to fix the last two she doesn’t feel that his dementia is causing any

feel that his dementia is causing any

feel that his dementia is causing any big challenges in her daily caregiving

big challenges in her daily caregiving

big challenges in her daily caregiving so they went to see his doctor and the

so they went to see his doctor and the

so they went to see his doctor and the doctor listened to my aunt’s health

doctor listened to my aunt’s health

doctor listened to my aunt’s health priorities signed up signed my uncle up

priorities signed up signed my uncle up

priorities signed up signed my uncle up for some simple cataract surgery

for some simple cataract surgery

for some simple cataract surgery prescribed medication and that was it

prescribed medication and that was it

prescribed medication and that was it they didn’t need to go through extensive

they didn’t need to go through extensive

they didn’t need to go through extensive complicated dementia treatments which

complicated dementia treatments which

complicated dementia treatments which may have very well induced more

may have very well induced more

may have very well induced more emotional stress for their family the

emotional stress for their family the

emotional stress for their family the doctor worked with them to achieve my

doctor worked with them to achieve my

doctor worked with them to achieve my uncle’s health goals even though that

uncle’s health goals even though that

uncle’s health goals even though that meant not addressing every single one of

meant not addressing every single one of

meant not addressing every single one of his conditions with the rise in the

his conditions with the rise in the

his conditions with the rise in the aging population these generations are

aging population these generations are

aging population these generations are now living with

now living with

now living with for five different conditions that all

for five different conditions that all

for five different conditions that all interact with each other

interact with each other

interact with each other treating them will mean ensuring both

treating them will mean ensuring both

treating them will mean ensuring both their safety and happiness but that may

their safety and happiness but that may

their safety and happiness but that may mean not addressing every single one of

mean not addressing every single one of

mean not addressing every single one of their health conditions and that is okay

their health conditions and that is okay

their health conditions and that is okay that is okay I know it sounds

that is okay I know it sounds

that is okay I know it sounds counterintuitive but patients and their

counterintuitive but patients and their

counterintuitive but patients and their caregivers will actually be more

caregivers will actually be more

caregivers will actually be more motivated to take care of themselves if

motivated to take care of themselves if

motivated to take care of themselves if they know they’ve had a part in the

they know they’ve had a part in the

they know they’ve had a part in the decision making process and there’s a

decision making process and there’s a

decision making process and there’s a societal benefit to it can be

societal benefit to it can be

societal benefit to it can be cost-saving if patients don’t want to go

cost-saving if patients don’t want to go

cost-saving if patients don’t want to go through unnecessary expensive medical

through unnecessary expensive medical

through unnecessary expensive medical procedures then why should we push them

procedures then why should we push them

procedures then why should we push them to do it when we see patients as more

to do it when we see patients as more

to do it when we see patients as more than their disease we are changing the

than their disease we are changing the

than their disease we are changing the paradigm from doctor versus patient to

paradigm from doctor versus patient to

paradigm from doctor versus patient to doctor and patient versus disease so the

doctor and patient versus disease so the

doctor and patient versus disease so the next question is how do we get there

Benjamin Zander conductor of the Boston

Benjamin Zander conductor of the Boston Philharmonic proposes a method called

Philharmonic proposes a method called

Philharmonic proposes a method called giving an A it all started when he walks

giving an A it all started when he walks

giving an A it all started when he walks into his music class the start of the

into his music class the start of the

into his music class the start of the academic year and he says to his

academic year and he says to his

academic year and he says to his students guys at the end of this year

students guys at the end of this year

students guys at the end of this year you’re all going to be getting an A

you’re all going to be getting an A

you’re all going to be getting an A that’s right the top grade it sounds

that’s right the top grade it sounds

that’s right the top grade it sounds like a good deal right but I want you to

like a good deal right but I want you to

like a good deal right but I want you to write a letter addressed to me imagining

write a letter addressed to me imagining

write a letter addressed to me imagining yourself in the position a year from now

yourself in the position a year from now

yourself in the position a year from now telling me why you deserved your a and

telling me why you deserved your a and

telling me why you deserved your a and that’s what they did in that very first

that’s what they did in that very first

that’s what they did in that very first class you see by doing this

class you see by doing this

class you see by doing this Zander has allowed the students not to

Zander has allowed the students not to

Zander has allowed the students not to be defined but that singular letter

be defined but that singular letter

be defined but that singular letter grade and instead explore their passions

grade and instead explore their passions

grade and instead explore their passions their motivations for why they wanted to

their motivations for why they wanted to

their motivations for why they wanted to take his music class in the first place

take his music class in the first place

take his music class in the first place and allowed that to carry them

and allowed that to carry them

and allowed that to carry them throughout the year in the world of help

throughout the year in the world of help

throughout the year in the world of help this would be asking patients what they

this would be asking patients what they

this would be asking patients what they want to achieve out of their health care

when doctors give patients and a they

when doctors give patients and a they choose to line up with the patient to

choose to line up with the patient to

choose to line up with the patient to combat their disease rather than lining

combat their disease rather than lining

combat their disease rather than lining up with the standards against the

up with the standards against the

up with the standards against the patient they’re inviting them as

patient they’re inviting them as

patient they’re inviting them as colleagues rather than speaking to them

colleagues rather than speaking to them

colleagues rather than speaking to them from a position of power and patience

from a position of power and patience

from a position of power and patience then become equally valid

then become equally valid

then become equally valid Wheeler’s of knowledge of their own

Wheeler’s of knowledge of their own

Wheeler’s of knowledge of their own health

they’re seen as individuals rather than

they’re seen as individuals rather than just an amalgamation of their health

just an amalgamation of their health

just an amalgamation of their health conditions ladies and gentlemen this

conditions ladies and gentlemen this

conditions ladies and gentlemen this simple act of giving an A will

simple act of giving an A will

simple act of giving an A will revolutionize centuries of doctor and

revolutionize centuries of doctor and

revolutionize centuries of doctor and patient relationships from this we get

patient relationships from this we get

patient relationships from this we get to immediate results the first is that

to immediate results the first is that

to immediate results the first is that doctors get new information about what

doctors get new information about what

doctors get new information about what the patient’s thoughts and fears about

the patient’s thoughts and fears about

the patient’s thoughts and fears about their illnesses are they can address any

their illnesses are they can address any

their illnesses are they can address any knowledge gaps when doctors get patients

knowledge gaps when doctors get patients

knowledge gaps when doctors get patients in ale they’re opening up to a new point

in ale they’re opening up to a new point

in ale they’re opening up to a new point of view

of view

of view second the patient gets to speak about

second the patient gets to speak about

second the patient gets to speak about any insecurities any concerns they’ve

any insecurities any concerns they’ve

any insecurities any concerns they’ve had about their illnesses their health

had about their illnesses their health

had about their illnesses their health in general things that they may not have

in general things that they may not have

in general things that they may not have spoken about because of the traditional

spoken about because of the traditional

spoken about because of the traditional power inequality in the doctor and

power inequality in the doctor and

power inequality in the doctor and patient relationship these two results

patient relationship these two results

patient relationship these two results of what I believe will carry us towards

of what I believe will carry us towards

of what I believe will carry us towards the patient-centered care system we need

the patient-centered care system we need

the patient-centered care system we need I’m not calling for a SurveyMonkey type

I’m not calling for a SurveyMonkey type

I’m not calling for a SurveyMonkey type of intervention no that’s too

of intervention no that’s too

of intervention no that’s too superficial I mean we don’t know if

superficial I mean we don’t know if

superficial I mean we don’t know if hospitals will read our feedback or if

hospitals will read our feedback or if

hospitals will read our feedback or if they’ll even address it in the way that

they’ll even address it in the way that

they’ll even address it in the way that we want them to know what I’m proposing

we want them to know what I’m proposing

we want them to know what I’m proposing it’s a method by which health care

it’s a method by which health care

it’s a method by which health care systems can holistically respond to us

systems can holistically respond to us

systems can holistically respond to us as individuals rather than segmenting

as individuals rather than segmenting

as individuals rather than segmenting and segregating us into all our

and segregating us into all our

and segregating us into all our different illnesses

nineteen years ago if the medical staff

nineteen years ago if the medical staff had talked my mom through what it meant

had talked my mom through what it meant

had talked my mom through what it meant to raise a child with diabetes what it

to raise a child with diabetes what it

to raise a child with diabetes what it meant to go through that emotional

meant to go through that emotional

meant to go through that emotional stress then maybe she wouldn’t have had

stress then maybe she wouldn’t have had

stress then maybe she wouldn’t have had such a traumatic experience with my

such a traumatic experience with my

such a traumatic experience with my diagnosis maybe she’d be able to look at

diagnosis maybe she’d be able to look at

diagnosis maybe she’d be able to look at old photographs and not feel guilty by

old photographs and not feel guilty by

old photographs and not feel guilty by realizing that accountability does not

realizing that accountability does not

realizing that accountability does not necessitate personal responsibility we

necessitate personal responsibility we

necessitate personal responsibility we are seeing patients as more than their

are seeing patients as more than their

are seeing patients as more than their disease this allows doctors to give

disease this allows doctors to give

disease this allows doctors to give patients okay

patients okay

patients okay which then puts both doctor and patient

which then puts both doctor and patient

which then puts both doctor and patient on a level battleground United in

on a level battleground United in

on a level battleground United in achieving the patient’s health goals

so tonight tonight I invite you to join

so tonight tonight I invite you to join me in support of a health policy that

me in support of a health policy that

me in support of a health policy that facilitates communication with this very

facilitates communication with this very

facilitates communication with this very attitude because effective communication

attitude because effective communication

attitude because effective communication is achieved when we have both sides

is achieved when we have both sides

is achieved when we have both sides learning from each other

this three-step process is what will

this three-step process is what will help us truly achieve the

help us truly achieve the

help us truly achieve the patient-centered care systems we need

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *