
[Applause] [Music]
[Music]
[Music] oh that was that was terrible
oh that was that was terrible
oh that was that was terrible Wow did you recognize what it was yeah
Wow did you recognize what it was yeah
Wow did you recognize what it was yeah Beethoven’s 5th Symphony almost do you
Beethoven’s 5th Symphony almost do you
Beethoven’s 5th Symphony almost do you see what we’ve done we’ve misaligned in
see what we’ve done we’ve misaligned in
see what we’ve done we’ve misaligned in time the individual instruments they did
time the individual instruments they did
time the individual instruments they did not play together you’ve heard them but
not play together you’ve heard them but
not play together you’ve heard them but you what you heard was not really what
you what you heard was not really what
you what you heard was not really what you wanted to hear the timing was off
you wanted to hear the timing was off
you wanted to hear the timing was off the individual instruments were not
the individual instruments were not
the individual instruments were not aligned in time they were not
aligned in time they were not
aligned in time they were not synchronized they did not share the same
synchronized they did not share the same
synchronized they did not share the same clock or the same time now I apologize
clock or the same time now I apologize
clock or the same time now I apologize that you had to listen to that but
that you had to listen to that but
that you had to listen to that but there’s a point to it
there’s a point to it
there’s a point to it now typically fortunately it does not
now typically fortunately it does not
now typically fortunately it does not sound like that and there’s an obvious
sound like that and there’s an obvious
sound like that and there’s an obvious reason and the reason is the conductor
reason and the reason is the conductor
reason and the reason is the conductor right the conductor provides that time
right the conductor provides that time
right the conductor provides that time reference the conductor provides a clock
reference the conductor provides a clock
reference the conductor provides a clock such a musicians know when and how to
such a musicians know when and how to
such a musicians know when and how to play such an overall music emerges and
play such an overall music emerges and
play such an overall music emerges and not what you’ve just heard so let’s
not what you’ve just heard so let’s
not what you’ve just heard so let’s listen to it again this time with
listen to it again this time with
listen to it again this time with conductor there you go
you had to wait for it but it was worth
you had to wait for it but it was worth it
[Music]
[Music] that is music
that is music
that is music that is synchronization that is the
that is synchronization that is the
that is synchronization that is the individual musicians within the
individual musicians within the
individual musicians within the orchestra playing together being on the
orchestra playing together being on the
orchestra playing together being on the same clock and we can visualize this in
same clock and we can visualize this in
same clock and we can visualize this in a much simpler way what you see here is
a much simpler way what you see here is
a much simpler way what you see here is blue and yellow two rhythms two parts of
blue and yellow two rhythms two parts of
blue and yellow two rhythms two parts of the music and they’re nicely aligned in
the music and they’re nicely aligned in
the music and they’re nicely aligned in time as illustrated by the yellow lines
time as illustrated by the yellow lines
time as illustrated by the yellow lines data sync recession different elements
data sync recession different elements
data sync recession different elements in this case the musicians coming
in this case the musicians coming
in this case the musicians coming together being on the same clock all
together being on the same clock all
together being on the same clock all right so I don’t study Beethoven yeah my
right so I don’t study Beethoven yeah my
right so I don’t study Beethoven yeah my name is dr. Flavia frolic I’m an
name is dr. Flavia frolic I’m an
name is dr. Flavia frolic I’m an assistant professor at the University of
assistant professor at the University of
assistant professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and I run
North Carolina at Chapel Hill and I run
North Carolina at Chapel Hill and I run a research lab and we study the brain
a research lab and we study the brain
a research lab and we study the brain now the principle of synchronization
now the principle of synchronization
now the principle of synchronization that have just demonstrated to you with
that have just demonstrated to you with
that have just demonstrated to you with Beethoven’s fifth that we believe is a
Beethoven’s fifth that we believe is a
Beethoven’s fifth that we believe is a fundamental mechanism of how the brain
fundamental mechanism of how the brain
fundamental mechanism of how the brain works that ability for different parts
works that ability for different parts
works that ability for different parts to come together in time to synchronize
to come together in time to synchronize
to come together in time to synchronize is not only how your brain works it also
is not only how your brain works it also
is not only how your brain works it also what we need to consider to understand
what we need to consider to understand
what we need to consider to understand the biological basis of disorders of the
the biological basis of disorders of the
the biological basis of disorders of the central nervous system such as a
central nervous system such as a
central nervous system such as a theatrical Ness
theatrical Ness
theatrical Ness it encompasses depression schizophrenia
it encompasses depression schizophrenia
it encompasses depression schizophrenia autism spectrum disorders and many other
autism spectrum disorders and many other
autism spectrum disorders and many other illnesses we need to understand death
illnesses we need to understand death
illnesses we need to understand death synchronization to understand how the
synchronization to understand how the
synchronization to understand how the brain works and how in a novel and safe
brain works and how in a novel and safe
brain works and how in a novel and safe way we can treat this is orders and
way we can treat this is orders and
way we can treat this is orders and that’s what I would like to explain to
that’s what I would like to explain to
that’s what I would like to explain to you now let’s have a look at brain
you now let’s have a look at brain
you now let’s have a look at brain activity let’s actually listen to it
activity let’s actually listen to it
activity let’s actually listen to it it doesn’t sound like Beethoven’s fifth
it doesn’t sound like Beethoven’s fifth
it doesn’t sound like Beethoven’s fifth but when I show it to you you see that
but when I show it to you you see that
but when I show it to you you see that rhythmic structure what you’re looking
rhythmic structure what you’re looking
rhythmic structure what you’re looking at here is the recording of electric
at here is the recording of electric
at here is the recording of electric activity in a human brain and you see it
activity in a human brain and you see it
activity in a human brain and you see it has this temporal structure it has that
has this temporal structure it has that
has this temporal structure it has that rhythm that is a brain rhythm now how
rhythm that is a brain rhythm now how
rhythm that is a brain rhythm now how does such rhythm emerge in your brain
does such rhythm emerge in your brain
does such rhythm emerge in your brain let me explain what you need to know is
let me explain what you need to know is
let me explain what you need to know is that individual piece is within the
that individual piece is within the
that individual piece is within the brain individual brain cells small
brain individual brain cells small
brain individual brain cells small networks within the brain they all have
networks within the brain they all have
networks within the brain they all have their own rhythm meaning they like to
their own rhythm meaning they like to
their own rhythm meaning they like to exhibit this type of rhythmically
exhibit this type of rhythmically
exhibit this type of rhythmically patterned electric activity and that’s
patterned electric activity and that’s
patterned electric activity and that’s what you see here in blue now the way
what you see here in blue now the way
what you see here in blue now the way I’ve drawn them here is that they’re all
I’ve drawn them here is that they’re all
I’ve drawn them here is that they’re all lined up in time they’re all
lined up in time they’re all
lined up in time they’re all synchronized and what we get when we
synchronized and what we get when we
synchronized and what we get when we look at the emerging overall signal if
look at the emerging overall signal if
look at the emerging overall signal if you will the sum of all these blue
you will the sum of all these blue
you will the sum of all these blue pieces of activity you get the orange
pieces of activity you get the orange
pieces of activity you get the orange you get a nice list structured rhythm
you get a nice list structured rhythm
you get a nice list structured rhythm that is how these brain rhythms emerge
that is how these brain rhythms emerge
that is how these brain rhythms emerge they emerge through the synchronization
they emerge through the synchronization
they emerge through the synchronization through the shared timing of all the
through the shared timing of all the
through the shared timing of all the individual bits and pieces of electric
individual bits and pieces of electric
individual bits and pieces of electric activity in the brain and the
activity in the brain and the
activity in the brain and the synchronization is fundamental for your
synchronization is fundamental for your
synchronization is fundamental for your brain to be able to generate such
brain to be able to generate such
brain to be able to generate such rhythms and I can show that to you if we
rhythms and I can show that to you if we
rhythms and I can show that to you if we shift those individual pieces of
shift those individual pieces of
shift those individual pieces of activity shown in blue in time relative
activity shown in blue in time relative
activity shown in blue in time relative to each other and we again look at the
to each other and we again look at the
to each other and we again look at the overall emerging picture the sum of all
overall emerging picture the sum of all
overall emerging picture the sum of all of it what we see here in orange is what
of it what we see here in orange is what
of it what we see here in orange is what we get namely nothing so you understand
we get namely nothing so you understand
we get namely nothing so you understand how important it is for a different
how important it is for a different
how important it is for a different piece of the brain to be on the same
piece of the brain to be on the same
piece of the brain to be on the same clock to share time like the musicians
clock to share time like the musicians
clock to share time like the musicians when they play Beethoven’s fifth they
when they play Beethoven’s fifth they
when they play Beethoven’s fifth they need to be synchronized for an overall
need to be synchronized for an overall
need to be synchronized for an overall meaningful activity pattern to emerge
meaningful activity pattern to emerge
meaningful activity pattern to emerge now the brain does not have a conductor
now the brain does not have a conductor
now the brain does not have a conductor and what I mean with that there is no
and what I mean with that there is no
and what I mean with that there is no signal no timing signal that helps
signal no timing signal that helps
signal no timing signal that helps oldest different piece of the brain to
oldest different piece of the brain to
oldest different piece of the brain to follow and beyond the same time it works
follow and beyond the same time it works
follow and beyond the same time it works fundamentally different from your
fundamentally different from your
fundamentally different from your orchestra in what you need to know is
orchestra in what you need to know is
orchestra in what you need to know is that when we look at the brain in terms
that when we look at the brain in terms
that when we look at the brain in terms of its structures one of its main
of its structures one of its main
of its structures one of its main features are the gazillion of
features are the gazillion of
features are the gazillion of connections between individual brain
connections between individual brain
connections between individual brain cells the nerve fibers all these brain
cells the nerve fibers all these brain
cells the nerve fibers all these brain cells they talk with each other they
cells they talk with each other they
cells they talk with each other they talk with a lot a lot of other brain
talk with a lot a lot of other brain
talk with a lot a lot of other brain cells and the same time they’re also
cells and the same time they’re also
cells and the same time they’re also receiving input or if you will listen to
receiving input or if you will listen to
receiving input or if you will listen to a lot of other cells so now what you
a lot of other cells so now what you
a lot of other cells so now what you have is not a central signal providing
have is not a central signal providing
have is not a central signal providing the clock like the conductor in your
the clock like the conductor in your
the clock like the conductor in your orchestra but rather you have this
orchestra but rather you have this
orchestra but rather you have this self-organized behavior of all the
self-organized behavior of all the
self-organized behavior of all the different pieces networks and individual
different pieces networks and individual
different pieces networks and individual cells in the brain talking and listening
cells in the brain talking and listening
cells in the brain talking and listening adjusting their own activity based on
adjusting their own activity based on
adjusting their own activity based on the input they’re receiving and together
the input they’re receiving and together
the input they’re receiving and together they manage to synchronize and generate
they manage to synchronize and generate
they manage to synchronize and generate those rhythms amazing now I want to
those rhythms amazing now I want to
those rhythms amazing now I want to illustrate that and what I brought is
illustrate that and what I brought is
illustrate that and what I brought is now two brain cells but two metronomes
now two brain cells but two metronomes
now two brain cells but two metronomes those are old-fashioned mechanical
those are old-fashioned mechanical
those are old-fashioned mechanical metronomes they go tick-tock tick-tock
metronomes they go tick-tock tick-tock
metronomes they go tick-tock tick-tock they have their own rhythm they’re set
they have their own rhythm they’re set
they have their own rhythm they’re set both to go at the same frequency so you
both to go at the same frequency so you
both to go at the same frequency so you can think of them as two brain cells
can think of them as two brain cells
can think of them as two brain cells having their own rhythm and now we’re
having their own rhythm and now we’re
having their own rhythm and now we’re going to have them talk to each other so
going to have them talk to each other so
going to have them talk to each other so how can two metronomes talk to each
how can two metronomes talk to each
how can two metronomes talk to each other well I’ve put them on a board that
other well I’ve put them on a board that
other well I’ve put them on a board that can very easily move so as the metronome
can very easily move so as the metronome
can very easily move so as the metronome goes tick-tock their mechanical motion
goes tick-tock their mechanical motion
goes tick-tock their mechanical motion translates that board and which to
translates that board and which to
translates that board and which to metronome set so that is the metronome
metronome set so that is the metronome
metronome set so that is the metronome or the brain cell talking now what is
or the brain cell talking now what is
or the brain cell talking now what is the listening in that process of self
the listening in that process of self
the listening in that process of self emergent synchronization the listening
emergent synchronization the listening
emergent synchronization the listening is that as the metronome is moving and
is that as the metronome is moving and
is that as the metronome is moving and it stands on this moving platform and
it stands on this moving platform and
it stands on this moving platform and that movement actually affects how the
that movement actually affects how the
that movement actually affects how the metronome goes tick-tock let’s look at
metronome goes tick-tock let’s look at
metronome goes tick-tock let’s look at it
it
it so you have to to metronomes
so you have to to metronomes
so you have to to metronomes synchronized you see how the platform is
synchronized you see how the platform is
synchronized you see how the platform is moving that is them in a self-organized
moving that is them in a self-organized
moving that is them in a self-organized way talk with each other and figure out
way talk with each other and figure out
way talk with each other and figure out how to gain beyond the same clock now it
how to gain beyond the same clock now it
how to gain beyond the same clock now it took them off they’re not talking with
took them off they’re not talking with
took them off they’re not talking with each other anymore you see what happens
each other anymore you see what happens
each other anymore you see what happens the communication link is broken think
the communication link is broken think
the communication link is broken think of two brain areas or two brain cells
of two brain areas or two brain cells
of two brain areas or two brain cells they can’t properly listen and talk to
they can’t properly listen and talk to
they can’t properly listen and talk to each other they cannot synchronize and
each other they cannot synchronize and
each other they cannot synchronize and they cannot generate those all-important
they cannot generate those all-important
they cannot generate those all-important electric rhythms those brain rhythms now
electric rhythms those brain rhythms now
electric rhythms those brain rhythms now the reason why we’re so interested in
the reason why we’re so interested in
the reason why we’re so interested in synchronization is because there’s a lot
synchronization is because there’s a lot
synchronization is because there’s a lot of evidence that an impairment of the
of evidence that an impairment of the
of evidence that an impairment of the brain in terms of its ability to
brain in terms of its ability to
brain in terms of its ability to synchronize and generate this rhythm is
synchronize and generate this rhythm is
synchronize and generate this rhythm is very tightly linked with mental illness
very tightly linked with mental illness
very tightly linked with mental illness there’s quite convincing evidence that
there’s quite convincing evidence that
there’s quite convincing evidence that the inability to sufficiently
the inability to sufficiently
the inability to sufficiently synchronize electric activity in
synchronize electric activity in
synchronize electric activity in different parts of the brain is impaired
different parts of the brain is impaired
different parts of the brain is impaired in disorders such as depression
in disorders such as depression
in disorders such as depression schizophrenia autism ADHD perhaps
schizophrenia autism ADHD perhaps
schizophrenia autism ADHD perhaps Alzheimer’s and many others so by
Alzheimer’s and many others so by
Alzheimer’s and many others so by understanding synchronization we
understanding synchronization we
understanding synchronization we actually believe we start to understand
actually believe we start to understand
actually believe we start to understand the biological mechanism of psychiatric
the biological mechanism of psychiatric
the biological mechanism of psychiatric illness and we don’t stop there
illness and we don’t stop there
illness and we don’t stop there understanding the biological cause of
understanding the biological cause of
understanding the biological cause of mental illness is obviously incredibly
mental illness is obviously incredibly
mental illness is obviously incredibly important but how about if we use that
important but how about if we use that
important but how about if we use that mechanism as a treatment target so
mechanism as a treatment target so
mechanism as a treatment target so typically when we say target what we
typically when we say target what we
typically when we say target what we mean is a specific receptor or a
mean is a specific receptor or a
mean is a specific receptor or a specific molecule or we could design a
specific molecule or we could design a
specific molecule or we could design a new drug that matches that receptor
new drug that matches that receptor
new drug that matches that receptor that’s not what I mean here what I’m
that’s not what I mean here what I’m
that’s not what I mean here what I’m talking about is using those electric
talking about is using those electric
talking about is using those electric activity patterns as a target and
activity patterns as a target and
activity patterns as a target and designing new interventions that helps
designing new interventions that helps
designing new interventions that helps to restore and enhance that
to restore and enhance that
to restore and enhance that synchronization and one way how we can
synchronization and one way how we can
synchronization and one way how we can do that
do that
do that is with non-invasive brain stimulation
is with non-invasive brain stimulation
is with non-invasive brain stimulation specifically we call it transcranial
specifically we call it transcranial
specifically we call it transcranial alternating current stimulation or TSEs
alternating current stimulation or TSEs
alternating current stimulation or TSEs let me explain what you see here is that
let me explain what you see here is that
let me explain what you see here is that we’re attaching electrodes to the scalp
we’re attaching electrodes to the scalp
we’re attaching electrodes to the scalp and this is not electroconvulsive
and this is not electroconvulsive
and this is not electroconvulsive therapy we’re using an incredibly weak
therapy we’re using an incredibly weak
therapy we’re using an incredibly weak current an electric current that you can
current an electric current that you can
current an electric current that you can barely feel and we pattern that electric
barely feel and we pattern that electric
barely feel and we pattern that electric current into a meaningful waveform to
current into a meaningful waveform to
current into a meaningful waveform to target this but in a frequency specific
target this but in a frequency specific
target this but in a frequency specific way the synchronization that we want to
way the synchronization that we want to
way the synchronization that we want to restore or enhance so we are not
restore or enhance so we are not
restore or enhance so we are not overriding brain activity rather we’re
overriding brain activity rather we’re
overriding brain activity rather we’re just adding back in that conductor to
just adding back in that conductor to
just adding back in that conductor to help restore and enhance that
help restore and enhance that
help restore and enhance that synchronization so what you want to know
synchronization so what you want to know
synchronization so what you want to know now is whether such a treatment really
now is whether such a treatment really
now is whether such a treatment really treats those patients and we have
treats those patients and we have
treats those patients and we have several clinical trials ongoing and I
several clinical trials ongoing and I
several clinical trials ongoing and I don’t get have the answer for you but I
don’t get have the answer for you but I
don’t get have the answer for you but I want to show you why we’re very hopeful
want to show you why we’re very hopeful
want to show you why we’re very hopeful one example where brain synchronization
one example where brain synchronization
one example where brain synchronization has been shown to be crucial is
has been shown to be crucial is
has been shown to be crucial is creativity creativity is the ability to
creativity creativity is the ability to
creativity creativity is the ability to generate something new and meaningful
generate something new and meaningful
generate something new and meaningful based on your previous experiences and
based on your previous experiences and
based on your previous experiences and your existing knowledge such an outcome
your existing knowledge such an outcome
your existing knowledge such an outcome as a surprise that synchronization that
as a surprise that synchronization that
as a surprise that synchronization that enables different parts of the brain
enables different parts of the brain
enables different parts of the brain that store different aspects of your
that store different aspects of your
that store different aspects of your knowledge and your previous experience
knowledge and your previous experience
knowledge and your previous experience is absolutely crucial such that you can
is absolutely crucial such that you can
is absolutely crucial such that you can combine all this into a new important
combine all this into a new important
combine all this into a new important way so the question we ask if we use
way so the question we ask if we use
way so the question we ask if we use this novel form of non-invasive brain
this novel form of non-invasive brain
this novel form of non-invasive brain stimulation and enhance synchronization
stimulation and enhance synchronization
stimulation and enhance synchronization can be actually out the creativity the
can be actually out the creativity the
can be actually out the creativity the question you have now is is that really
question you have now is is that really
question you have now is is that really a way to measure creativity in a
a way to measure creativity in a
a way to measure creativity in a scientific way and the answer is
scientific way and the answer is
scientific way and the answer is actually yes there’s a test which is
actually yes there’s a test which is
actually yes there’s a test which is like an IQ test but instead of measuring
like an IQ test but instead of measuring
like an IQ test but instead of measuring intelligence
intelligence
intelligence it measures creativity let me briefly
it measures creativity let me briefly
it measures creativity let me briefly show you here’s a test question you have
show you here’s a test question you have
show you here’s a test question you have a little bit of time
a little bit of time
a little bit of time please come up with a drawing including
please come up with a drawing including
please come up with a drawing including that black line and the drawing should
that black line and the drawing should
that black line and the drawing should be creative new meaningful and also add
be creative new meaningful and also add
be creative new meaningful and also add a great title few seconds here is what
a great title few seconds here is what
a great title few seconds here is what I’ve probably done and you don’t need to
I’ve probably done and you don’t need to
I’ve probably done and you don’t need to stand up here to understand that this is
stand up here to understand that this is
stand up here to understand that this is not very creative now let me show you
not very creative now let me show you
not very creative now let me show you the response of one of the participants
the response of one of the participants
the response of one of the participants our study here received a brain
our study here received a brain
our study here received a brain stimulation same question very different
stimulation same question very different
stimulation same question very different answer
answer
answer now there are a lot of scientific ways
now there are a lot of scientific ways
now there are a lot of scientific ways how to exactly assay creativity based on
how to exactly assay creativity based on
how to exactly assay creativity based on these responses but I think the
these responses but I think the
these responses but I think the principle is clear so what we’ve done is
principle is clear so what we’ve done is
principle is clear so what we’ve done is we’ve borrowed a study design
we’ve borrowed a study design
we’ve borrowed a study design essentially from clinical trials and we
essentially from clinical trials and we
essentially from clinical trials and we performed a study where we evaluated
performed a study where we evaluated
performed a study where we evaluated whether this novel form of brain
whether this novel form of brain
whether this novel form of brain stimulation TAC s really can out their
stimulation TAC s really can out their
stimulation TAC s really can out their creativity in comparison to a placebo or
creativity in comparison to a placebo or
creativity in comparison to a placebo or sham stimulation and what we found is
sham stimulation and what we found is
sham stimulation and what we found is that yes indeed we managed to
that yes indeed we managed to
that yes indeed we managed to significantly and substantially enhance
significantly and substantially enhance
significantly and substantially enhance creativity by targeting synchronization
creativity by targeting synchronization
creativity by targeting synchronization now that is a study in healthy controls
now that is a study in healthy controls
now that is a study in healthy controls and it’s important to emphasize there’s
and it’s important to emphasize there’s
and it’s important to emphasize there’s still a lot of work we need to do until
still a lot of work we need to do until
still a lot of work we need to do until we can establish such new interventions
we can establish such new interventions
we can establish such new interventions as treatment for serious mental illness
as treatment for serious mental illness
as treatment for serious mental illness but the reason why we’re hopeful is
but the reason why we’re hopeful is
but the reason why we’re hopeful is because the type of brain rhythm and
because the type of brain rhythm and
because the type of brain rhythm and synchronization we targeted here is
synchronization we targeted here is
synchronization we targeted here is exactly the same that we know is
exactly the same that we know is
exactly the same that we know is impaired in patients for example with
impaired in patients for example with
impaired in patients for example with depression so here is where we’re going
depression so here is where we’re going
depression so here is where we’re going with this we understand that
with this we understand that
with this we understand that synchronization of brain activity is
synchronization of brain activity is
synchronization of brain activity is absolutely vital not only for normal
absolutely vital not only for normal
absolutely vital not only for normal brain function but also in terms of us
brain function but also in terms of us
brain function but also in terms of us understanding it as a fundamental
understanding it as a fundamental
understanding it as a fundamental mechanism that is impaired in
mechanism that is impaired in
mechanism that is impaired in psychiatric illness so synchronization
psychiatric illness so synchronization
psychiatric illness so synchronization of brain activity these brain rhythms
of brain activity these brain rhythms
of brain activity these brain rhythms that emerge from that synchronization
that emerge from that synchronization
that emerge from that synchronization for us we think of them as a treatment
for us we think of them as a treatment
for us we think of them as a treatment target and we hope and they’re currently
target and we hope and they’re currently
target and we hope and they’re currently evaluating that through targeting
evaluating that through targeting
evaluating that through targeting synchronization and restoring synchro’s
synchronization and restoring synchro’s
synchronization and restoring synchro’s ation
ation
ation with non-invasive brain stimulation we
with non-invasive brain stimulation we
with non-invasive brain stimulation we can provide relief to those so many
can provide relief to those so many
can provide relief to those so many patients with mental illness that suffer
patients with mental illness that suffer
patients with mental illness that suffer today because we don’t yet have an
today because we don’t yet have an
today because we don’t yet have an adequate treatment arsenal thank you
adequate treatment arsenal thank you
adequate treatment arsenal thank you very much
very much
very much [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment