Press "Enter" to skip to content

Bringing Existential Risk Home | Dr. Catherine Rhodes | TEDxUCLWomen


today I’m going to talk to you about

today I’m going to talk to you about boundaries communities and things that

boundaries communities and things that

boundaries communities and things that can kill us all boundaries and

can kill us all boundaries and

can kill us all boundaries and communities shape our responses to

communities shape our responses to

communities shape our responses to catastrophes including those that can

catastrophes including those that can

catastrophes including those that can kill us all we regularly see disasters

kill us all we regularly see disasters

kill us all we regularly see disasters unfolding in the news and we hear of

unfolding in the news and we hear of

unfolding in the news and we hear of deaths and large scale suffering on a

deaths and large scale suffering on a

deaths and large scale suffering on a daily basis but we could and most likely

daily basis but we could and most likely

daily basis but we could and most likely will faced far worse disasters than

will faced far worse disasters than

will faced far worse disasters than these there are risks that threaten

these there are risks that threaten

these there are risks that threaten humanity’s existence as a whole I work

humanity’s existence as a whole I work

humanity’s existence as a whole I work for the Center for the Study of

for the Center for the Study of

for the Center for the Study of existential risk in Cambridge one of a

existential risk in Cambridge one of a

existential risk in Cambridge one of a small number of research groups

small number of research groups

small number of research groups worldwide that focus on understanding

worldwide that focus on understanding

worldwide that focus on understanding existential risks those threats to

existential risks those threats to

existential risks those threats to humanity’s survival and what might be

humanity’s survival and what might be

humanity’s survival and what might be done to manage them some sources of

done to manage them some sources of

done to manage them some sources of existential risk may only be familiar

existential risk may only be familiar

existential risk may only be familiar from disaster movies they may appear to

from disaster movies they may appear to

from disaster movies they may appear to have little to do with real life or at

have little to do with real life or at

have little to do with real life or at least seem very remote and unlikely but

least seem very remote and unlikely but

least seem very remote and unlikely but these are not just fictional scenarios

these are not just fictional scenarios

these are not just fictional scenarios examples include extreme risks of

examples include extreme risks of

examples include extreme risks of natural origin such as asteroid strikes

natural origin such as asteroid strikes

natural origin such as asteroid strikes solar storms super volcanic eruptions

solar storms super volcanic eruptions

solar storms super volcanic eruptions and pandemic disease outbreaks as well

and pandemic disease outbreaks as well

and pandemic disease outbreaks as well as these natural risks which humanity is

as these natural risks which humanity is

as these natural risks which humanity is always faced we have created new sources

always faced we have created new sources

always faced we have created new sources of risk over the last couple of

of risk over the last couple of

of risk over the last couple of centuries for instance climate change

centuries for instance climate change

centuries for instance climate change nuclear winter and misuse of or mistakes

nuclear winter and misuse of or mistakes

nuclear winter and misuse of or mistakes with advanced technologies such as bio

with advanced technologies such as bio

with advanced technologies such as bio technologies and artificial intelligence

technologies and artificial intelligence

technologies and artificial intelligence with some of these risks reaching the

with some of these risks reaching the

with some of these risks reaching the level of wiping out humanity may be

level of wiping out humanity may be

level of wiping out humanity may be unlikely but it is not impossible

unlikely but it is not impossible

unlikely but it is not impossible Humanity has faced such risks in the

Humanity has faced such risks in the

Humanity has faced such risks in the past and our vulnerability to them is

past and our vulnerability to them is

past and our vulnerability to them is increasing what do I mean when I say of

increasing what do I mean when I say of

increasing what do I mean when I say of honour ability is increasing surely we

honour ability is increasing surely we

honour ability is increasing surely we have much better capacity to identify

have much better capacity to identify

have much better capacity to identify and respond to such risks than in the

and respond to such risks than in the

and respond to such risks than in the past

past

past we can take a particular historic

we can take a particular historic

we can take a particular historic scenario involving a community’s

scenario involving a community’s

scenario involving a community’s reaction to an extreme risk to explore

reaction to an extreme risk to explore

reaction to an extreme risk to explore how vulnerability has changed this image

how vulnerability has changed this image

how vulnerability has changed this image is of the gates of a school in a small

is of the gates of a school in a small

is of the gates of a school in a small village in the Peak District

village in the Peak District

village in the Peak District in 1665 with an outbreak already

in 1665 with an outbreak already

in 1665 with an outbreak already underway in London transport of cloths

underway in London transport of cloths

underway in London transport of cloths from the capital introduced plague to

from the capital introduced plague to

from the capital introduced plague to the village on noticing the first case

the village on noticing the first case

the village on noticing the first case the community responded by quarantine in

the community responded by quarantine in

the community responded by quarantine in itself for over a year no one was

itself for over a year no one was

itself for over a year no one was allowed to enter or leave the village in

allowed to enter or leave the village in

allowed to enter or leave the village in order to prevent spread of the disease

order to prevent spread of the disease

order to prevent spread of the disease to other local communities even at this

to other local communities even at this

to other local communities even at this time such actions were possible in small

time such actions were possible in small

time such actions were possible in small isolated communities but not in larger

isolated communities but not in larger

isolated communities but not in larger urban areas we are far more connected

urban areas we are far more connected

urban areas we are far more connected today our populations are much larger

today our populations are much larger

today our populations are much larger and mostly concentrated in large towns

and mostly concentrated in large towns

and mostly concentrated in large towns and cities attempting to isolate

and cities attempting to isolate

and cities attempting to isolate ourselves as an existential catastrophe

ourselves as an existential catastrophe

ourselves as an existential catastrophe unfolds will be futile and probably

unfolds will be futile and probably

unfolds will be futile and probably counterproductive more than this the

counterproductive more than this the

counterproductive more than this the systems we depend on are also deeply

systems we depend on are also deeply

systems we depend on are also deeply connected globally

connected globally

connected globally these include communications transport

these include communications transport

these include communications transport and trade financial systems and our food

and trade financial systems and our food

and trade financial systems and our food and energy supply networks these high

and energy supply networks these high

and energy supply networks these high levels of connectivity bring many

levels of connectivity bring many

levels of connectivity bring many benefits in daily life but they also

benefits in daily life but they also

benefits in daily life but they also create deep vulnerabilities a

create deep vulnerabilities a

create deep vulnerabilities a catastrophic event impacting one part of

catastrophic event impacting one part of

catastrophic event impacting one part of a system can rapidly spread through that

a system can rapidly spread through that

a system can rapidly spread through that system and to other systems as well a

system and to other systems as well a

system and to other systems as well a severe solar storm for example would

severe solar storm for example would

severe solar storm for example would knock out power grids for several weeks

knock out power grids for several weeks

knock out power grids for several weeks and leave millions of people without

and leave millions of people without

and leave millions of people without electricity for months it would have

electricity for months it would have

electricity for months it would have cascading impacts on global

cascading impacts on global

cascading impacts on global communications transport healthcare food

communications transport healthcare food

communications transport healthcare food distribution and so on it would also put

distribution and so on it would also put

distribution and so on it would also put severe strain on our social and

severe strain on our social and

severe strain on our social and political systems we have no easy way of

political systems we have no easy way of

political systems we have no easy way of setting boundaries on this connectedness

setting boundaries on this connectedness

setting boundaries on this connectedness no easy way of putting barriers in place

no easy way of putting barriers in place

no easy way of putting barriers in place to prevent an initial event from

to prevent an initial event from

to prevent an initial event from spreading through multiple systems this

spreading through multiple systems this

spreading through multiple systems this means we are more likely to see

means we are more likely to see

means we are more likely to see existential risks for multiple

existential risks for multiple

existential risks for multiple catastrophes in combination rather than

catastrophes in combination rather than

catastrophes in combination rather than from a single event our deep global

from a single event our deep global

from a single event our deep global connections are why it is valuable to

connections are why it is valuable to

connections are why it is valuable to consider both boundaries and communities

consider both boundaries and communities

consider both boundaries and communities in how we respond to existential risks

in how we respond to existential risks

in how we respond to existential risks focusing on one particular type of risk

focusing on one particular type of risk

focusing on one particular type of risk can help us to explore this further and

can help us to explore this further and

can help us to explore this further and I’m going to focus on pandemic disease

I’m going to focus on pandemic disease

I’m going to focus on pandemic disease threats

pandemics are a type of extreme risk

pandemics are a type of extreme risk where the initial event the disease

where the initial event the disease

where the initial event the disease outbreak is unlikely to wipe out

outbreak is unlikely to wipe out

outbreak is unlikely to wipe out humanity but it’s knock-on impacts on

humanity but it’s knock-on impacts on

humanity but it’s knock-on impacts on society may be very severe making

society may be very severe making

society may be very severe making recovery difficult and massively

recovery difficult and massively

recovery difficult and massively increasing our vulnerability to further

increasing our vulnerability to further

increasing our vulnerability to further disasters the risks of pandemic disease

disasters the risks of pandemic disease

disasters the risks of pandemic disease are not far-fetched we have faced them

are not far-fetched we have faced them

are not far-fetched we have faced them before and will again likely in the

before and will again likely in the

before and will again likely in the relatively near future

relatively near future

relatively near future what have we faced before this includes

what have we faced before this includes

what have we faced before this includes major outbreaks of plague and influenza

major outbreaks of plague and influenza

major outbreaks of plague and influenza such as the Black Death and the Great

such as the Black Death and the Great

such as the Black Death and the Great Plague of London which killed high

Plague of London which killed high

Plague of London which killed high proportions of the population and the

proportions of the population and the

proportions of the population and the Spanish influenza outbreak of 1918 to

Spanish influenza outbreak of 1918 to

Spanish influenza outbreak of 1918 to 1919 which killed more than 50 million

1919 which killed more than 50 million

1919 which killed more than 50 million people worldwide and what is the threat

people worldwide and what is the threat

people worldwide and what is the threat now the disease outbreak that’s received

now the disease outbreak that’s received

now the disease outbreak that’s received most attention in recent years is a bola

most attention in recent years is a bola

most attention in recent years is a bola and epidemics of cholera and plague are

and epidemics of cholera and plague are

and epidemics of cholera and plague are currently in the news but these are not

currently in the news but these are not

currently in the news but these are not the most serious threats that we face

the most serious threats that we face

the most serious threats that we face the most likely extreme disease threat

the most likely extreme disease threat

the most likely extreme disease threat is an influenza pandemic a severe

is an influenza pandemic a severe

is an influenza pandemic a severe pandemic is expected to cause more than

pandemic is expected to cause more than

pandemic is expected to cause more than 100 million deaths worldwide and between

100 million deaths worldwide and between

100 million deaths worldwide and between 200,000 and 300,000 deaths in the UK to

200,000 and 300,000 deaths in the UK to

200,000 and 300,000 deaths in the UK to put that in context the total number of

put that in context the total number of

put that in context the total number of deaths in England and Wales in 2016 was

deaths in England and Wales in 2016 was

deaths in England and Wales in 2016 was just over five hundred and twenty five

just over five hundred and twenty five

just over five hundred and twenty five thousand a pandemic influenza outbreak

thousand a pandemic influenza outbreak

thousand a pandemic influenza outbreak is high probability indeed it is viewed

is high probability indeed it is viewed

is high probability indeed it is viewed as inevitable in assessing risks to

as inevitable in assessing risks to

as inevitable in assessing risks to national security over the next five

national security over the next five

national security over the next five years the UK government ranks pandemic

years the UK government ranks pandemic

years the UK government ranks pandemic influenza is highest in both probability

influenza is highest in both probability

influenza is highest in both probability and severity here we can see how it’s

and severity here we can see how it’s

and severity here we can see how it’s ranked against for example flooding and

ranked against for example flooding and

ranked against for example flooding and extreme weather events if we go back to

extreme weather events if we go back to

extreme weather events if we go back to the story of aim the ideas of both

the story of aim the ideas of both

the story of aim the ideas of both boundaries and communities feature in

boundaries and communities feature in

boundaries and communities feature in the villages reactions to the plague

the villages reactions to the plague

the villages reactions to the plague both physical and moral boundaries were

both physical and moral boundaries were

both physical and moral boundaries were used to control the outbreak physical

used to control the outbreak physical

used to control the outbreak physical barriers were established to prevent

barriers were established to prevent

barriers were established to prevent movement of people and these were backed

movement of people and these were backed

movement of people and these were backed up with moral force as the community

up with moral force as the community

up with moral force as the community sought to avoid spread of the disease to

sought to avoid spread of the disease to

sought to avoid spread of the disease to other villages at a cost of considerable

other villages at a cost of considerable

other villages at a cost of considerable hardship and likely higher loss of life

hardship and likely higher loss of life

hardship and likely higher loss of life within

setting up barriers is a frequent

setting up barriers is a frequent reaction to catastrophic events and

reaction to catastrophic events and

reaction to catastrophic events and humanitarian crises think of the

humanitarian crises think of the

humanitarian crises think of the barriers Europe put in place in the face

barriers Europe put in place in the face

barriers Europe put in place in the face of large flows of refugees for disease

of large flows of refugees for disease

of large flows of refugees for disease outbreaks in particular use of some

outbreaks in particular use of some

outbreaks in particular use of some physical measures may make sense for

physical measures may make sense for

physical measures may make sense for containing outbreaks but we need to be

containing outbreaks but we need to be

containing outbreaks but we need to be careful about such reactions

careful about such reactions

careful about such reactions particularly in the face of existential

particularly in the face of existential

particularly in the face of existential risks our practical ability to isolate

risks our practical ability to isolate

risks our practical ability to isolate ourselves from what is happening in the

ourselves from what is happening in the

ourselves from what is happening in the rest of the world is extremely limited

rest of the world is extremely limited

rest of the world is extremely limited as I pointed out earlier we rely on

as I pointed out earlier we rely on

as I pointed out earlier we rely on international systems for food and

international systems for food and

international systems for food and energy communications and so on we will

energy communications and so on we will

energy communications and so on we will also need high levels of cooperation

also need high levels of cooperation

also need high levels of cooperation between countries to successfully

between countries to successfully

between countries to successfully address catastrophes as they unfold and

address catastrophes as they unfold and

address catastrophes as they unfold and prevent them overwhelming us all

prevent them overwhelming us all

prevent them overwhelming us all attempting to isolate ourselves and

attempting to isolate ourselves and

attempting to isolate ourselves and protect our own interests first will

protect our own interests first will

protect our own interests first will erode the trust that’s vital for such

erode the trust that’s vital for such

erode the trust that’s vital for such cooperation such actions will also be

cooperation such actions will also be

cooperation such actions will also be morally problematic for most of us it is

morally problematic for most of us it is

morally problematic for most of us it is already difficult to ignore widespread

already difficult to ignore widespread

already difficult to ignore widespread suffering in the world and leave it

suffering in the world and leave it

suffering in the world and leave it unaddressed even with multiple disasters

unaddressed even with multiple disasters

unaddressed even with multiple disasters around us now we are far short of the

around us now we are far short of the

around us now we are far short of the suffering we could see as such a

suffering we could see as such a

suffering we could see as such a pandemic played out and while the

pandemic played out and while the

pandemic played out and while the impacts in the UK could be devastating

impacts in the UK could be devastating

impacts in the UK could be devastating we are still in a much better position

we are still in a much better position

we are still in a much better position than most of the world will be it has

than most of the world will be it has

than most of the world will be it has been projected that in a pandemic of

been projected that in a pandemic of

been projected that in a pandemic of similar severity to the 1918 influenza

similar severity to the 1918 influenza

similar severity to the 1918 influenza 96% of deaths will be in the developing

96% of deaths will be in the developing

96% of deaths will be in the developing world we already give moral

world we already give moral

world we already give moral consideration to people in other

consideration to people in other

consideration to people in other countries the nature of existential

countries the nature of existential

countries the nature of existential risks and the responses most likely to

risks and the responses most likely to

risks and the responses most likely to get us through them should simply

get us through them should simply

get us through them should simply amplify these moral concerns we should

amplify these moral concerns we should

amplify these moral concerns we should shift both our physical and moral

shift both our physical and moral

shift both our physical and moral boundaries to the level of humanity

boundaries to the level of humanity

boundaries to the level of humanity physical boundaries have no practical

physical boundaries have no practical

physical boundaries have no practical relevance in the face of existential

relevance in the face of existential

relevance in the face of existential risks and a shift in moral boundaries

risks and a shift in moral boundaries

risks and a shift in moral boundaries may be key to our collective survival

may be key to our collective survival

may be key to our collective survival following a globally catastrophic event

following a globally catastrophic event

following a globally catastrophic event one level then we should consider

one level then we should consider

one level then we should consider ourselves to be a global community

ourselves to be a global community

ourselves to be a global community however there are good reasons to focus

however there are good reasons to focus

however there are good reasons to focus on the local level too

on the local level too

on the local level too what you do locally can make a

what you do locally can make a

what you do locally can make a difference again taking pandemic

difference again taking pandemic

difference again taking pandemic influenza as an example societal

influenza as an example societal

influenza as an example societal responses will have significant

responses will have significant

responses will have significant influence on the course of an outbreak

influence on the course of an outbreak

influence on the course of an outbreak on the effectiveness of response efforts

on the effectiveness of response efforts

on the effectiveness of response efforts and on recovery so what sort of effects

and on recovery so what sort of effects

and on recovery so what sort of effects would a pandemic have locally recent

would a pandemic have locally recent

would a pandemic have locally recent experience may lead us to feel

experience may lead us to feel

experience may lead us to feel unconcerned the most recent pandemic

unconcerned the most recent pandemic

unconcerned the most recent pandemic influenza outbreak the swine flu in 2009

influenza outbreak the swine flu in 2009

influenza outbreak the swine flu in 2009 was mild compared to others with around

was mild compared to others with around

was mild compared to others with around 450 deaths in the UK but infection and

450 deaths in the UK but infection and

450 deaths in the UK but infection and death rates are expected to be far

death rates are expected to be far

death rates are expected to be far higher in a future outbreak government

higher in a future outbreak government

higher in a future outbreak government advice to local authorities is to

advice to local authorities is to

advice to local authorities is to prepare for between two hundred thousand

prepare for between two hundred thousand

prepare for between two hundred thousand and three hundred and fifteen thousand

and three hundred and fifteen thousand

and three hundred and fifteen thousand extra deaths over a 15 week period

extra deaths over a 15 week period

extra deaths over a 15 week period during a future pandemic so we can

during a future pandemic so we can

during a future pandemic so we can expect something much more socially

expect something much more socially

expect something much more socially disruptive there are things we can all

disruptive there are things we can all

disruptive there are things we can all do to be better prepared for the social

do to be better prepared for the social

do to be better prepared for the social impacts of a pandemic which will play

impacts of a pandemic which will play

impacts of a pandemic which will play out at a local level an important first

out at a local level an important first

out at a local level an important first step is for communities to work out how

step is for communities to work out how

step is for communities to work out how to handle the practical and

to handle the practical and

to handle the practical and psychological impacts and to build

psychological impacts and to build

psychological impacts and to build knowledge about local needs and

knowledge about local needs and

knowledge about local needs and resources

resources

resources this could include working out how we

this could include working out how we

this could include working out how we might best respond to particular

might best respond to particular

might best respond to particular scenarios for example how would local

scenarios for example how would local

scenarios for example how would local businesses and services cope without a

businesses and services cope without a

businesses and services cope without a third of their workforce worker absence

third of their workforce worker absence

third of their workforce worker absence will be particularly problematic in key

will be particularly problematic in key

will be particularly problematic in key sectors like health care social services

sectors like health care social services

sectors like health care social services and energy supply our communities will

and energy supply our communities will

and energy supply our communities will be better able to respond to such a

be better able to respond to such a

be better able to respond to such a scenario if we have worked out in

scenario if we have worked out in

scenario if we have worked out in advance how we might support key sectors

advance how we might support key sectors

advance how we might support key sectors for example we could identify people

for example we could identify people

for example we could identify people with relevant skills and experience who

with relevant skills and experience who

with relevant skills and experience who could step in at times of high work

could step in at times of high work

could step in at times of high work absence and we could train volunteer

absence and we could train volunteer

absence and we could train volunteer support workers a related example is to

support workers a related example is to

support workers a related example is to work out how the community might be

work out how the community might be

work out how the community might be affected if schools or public transport

affected if schools or public transport

affected if schools or public transport had to shut down how many more people

had to shut down how many more people

had to shut down how many more people would be unable to work are there ways

would be unable to work are there ways

would be unable to work are there ways in which the community could organize

in which the community could organize

in which the community could organize child care and share transport to

child care and share transport to

child care and share transport to minimize disruption and how might the

minimize disruption and how might the

minimize disruption and how might the community support those who for example

community support those who for example

community support those who for example will struggle to afford food without an

will struggle to afford food without an

will struggle to afford food without an income for a few weeks

income for a few weeks

income for a few weeks it is not only these sorts of practical

it is not only these sorts of practical

it is not only these sorts of practical impacts that community activities can

impacts that community activities can

impacts that community activities can help to address building local awareness

help to address building local awareness

help to address building local awareness in advance may also help with acceptance

in advance may also help with acceptance

in advance may also help with acceptance of extraordinary measures needed to cope

of extraordinary measures needed to cope

of extraordinary measures needed to cope with the increased number of death

with the increased number of death

with the increased number of death and the psychological impacts of this

and the psychological impacts of this

and the psychological impacts of this death rates are expected to be between

death rates are expected to be between

death rates are expected to be between two and five times higher during the

two and five times higher during the

two and five times higher during the pandemic period this will be distressing

pandemic period this will be distressing

pandemic period this will be distressing in itself but will be compounded by the

in itself but will be compounded by the

in itself but will be compounded by the fact that mortuary capacities will be

fact that mortuary capacities will be

fact that mortuary capacities will be severely stretched and that standard

severely stretched and that standard

severely stretched and that standard practices for funerals burials

practices for funerals burials

practices for funerals burials informations cannot be followed only

informations cannot be followed only

informations cannot be followed only finding out as a crisis unfolds that you

finding out as a crisis unfolds that you

finding out as a crisis unfolds that you cannot give your loved ones a

cannot give your loved ones a

cannot give your loved ones a traditional funeral service or that a

traditional funeral service or that a

traditional funeral service or that a local community building needs to be

local community building needs to be

local community building needs to be used as a temporary mortaring

used as a temporary mortaring

used as a temporary mortaring will likely be far more upsetting than

will likely be far more upsetting than

will likely be far more upsetting than if you had been informed about the

if you had been informed about the

if you had been informed about the likelihood and justifications for such

likelihood and justifications for such

likelihood and justifications for such actions in advance and if the community

actions in advance and if the community

actions in advance and if the community had been able to consider options

had been able to consider options

had been able to consider options together but currently I think these are

together but currently I think these are

together but currently I think these are things that we mostly just have no

things that we mostly just have no

things that we mostly just have no awareness of such local community

awareness of such local community

awareness of such local community activities imply a sense of boundaries

activities imply a sense of boundaries

activities imply a sense of boundaries again and we should be careful about who

again and we should be careful about who

again and we should be careful about who may be overlooked or excluded in such a

may be overlooked or excluded in such a

may be overlooked or excluded in such a process it will also be useful for local

process it will also be useful for local

process it will also be useful for local communities to form networks amongst

communities to form networks amongst

communities to form networks amongst themselves and share experience and

themselves and share experience and

themselves and share experience and resources these ideas about building

resources these ideas about building

resources these ideas about building local awareness and planning for

local awareness and planning for

local awareness and planning for catastrophes in advance will be really

catastrophes in advance will be really

catastrophes in advance will be really valuable for our responses to other

valuable for our responses to other

valuable for our responses to other disasters simply knowing about the

disasters simply knowing about the

disasters simply knowing about the resources knowledge and experience

resources knowledge and experience

resources knowledge and experience available in your neighborhood and

available in your neighborhood and

available in your neighborhood and having an idea of local support needs

having an idea of local support needs

having an idea of local support needs will more generally contribute to

will more generally contribute to

will more generally contribute to community resilience to disasters many

community resilience to disasters many

community resilience to disasters many people willingly volunteer when a crisis

people willingly volunteer when a crisis

people willingly volunteer when a crisis hits and I hope we’re among them our

hits and I hope we’re among them our

hits and I hope we’re among them our contributions will be more effective

contributions will be more effective

contributions will be more effective when coordinated at a community level

when coordinated at a community level

when coordinated at a community level and planned in advance the range in

and planned in advance the range in

and planned in advance the range in complexity of extreme risks that

complexity of extreme risks that

complexity of extreme risks that humanity currently faces can with

humanity currently faces can with

humanity currently faces can with justification seem overwhelming and

justification seem overwhelming and

justification seem overwhelming and inescapable risks at this scale should

inescapable risks at this scale should

inescapable risks at this scale should strengthen our sense of global community

strengthen our sense of global community

strengthen our sense of global community where physical and moral boundaries

where physical and moral boundaries

where physical and moral boundaries between people become irrelevant

between people become irrelevant

between people become irrelevant all at the same time encouraging local

all at the same time encouraging local

all at the same time encouraging local community efforts as an essential first

community efforts as an essential first

community efforts as an essential first level of response separating out

level of response separating out

level of response separating out different sources of risk and different

different sources of risk and different

different sources of risk and different levels of response can make it easier to

levels of response can make it easier to

levels of response can make it easier to understand how we might address them

understand how we might address them

understand how we might address them there are things we can do and these

there are things we can do and these

there are things we can do and these things are worth doing rather than not

things are worth doing rather than not

things are worth doing rather than not knowing about these risks and therefore

knowing about these risks and therefore

knowing about these risks and therefore being unable to do anything to address

being unable to do anything to address

being unable to do anything to address them it is better to know and to make

them it is better to know and to make

them it is better to know and to make efforts to as

efforts to as

efforts to as bond thank you

bond thank you

bond thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *