Press "Enter" to skip to content

Passive Democracy to Engaging Citizens | Charlotte Norlund-Matthiessen | TEDxCollegeofEuropeNatolin


I don’t know about you but I never

I don’t know about you but I never really believed in democracy in fact

really believed in democracy in fact

really believed in democracy in fact there is something rotten in the state

there is something rotten in the state

there is something rotten in the state of our representative democracy who can

of our representative democracy who can

of our representative democracy who can you trust

you trust

you trust the career-minded politician or the

the career-minded politician or the

the career-minded politician or the biased and disengaged citizen but can

biased and disengaged citizen but can

biased and disengaged citizen but can you blame them

you blame them

you blame them no the system has made us sue elections

no the system has made us sue elections

no the system has made us sue elections and referendums are the essence of our

and referendums are the essence of our

and referendums are the essence of our representative democracy today so with

representative democracy today so with

representative democracy today so with elections every five years

elections every five years

elections every five years no wonder the politician gets antsy

no wonder the politician gets antsy

no wonder the politician gets antsy about his future

about his future

about his future no wonder the the citizen disengages the

no wonder the the citizen disengages the

no wonder the the citizen disengages the rest of the time and it’s not a surprise

rest of the time and it’s not a surprise

rest of the time and it’s not a surprise either that referendums our recipe for

either that referendums our recipe for

either that referendums our recipe for disaster so in 2012 when Francois a

disaster so in 2012 when Francois a

disaster so in 2012 when Francois a friend from university came to me and

friend from university came to me and

friend from university came to me and asked me what do I think about the

asked me what do I think about the

asked me what do I think about the European citizens initiative the

European citizens initiative the

European citizens initiative the optimist in me bursted out this can be a

optimist in me bursted out this can be a

optimist in me bursted out this can be a revolution for democracy in Europe this

revolution for democracy in Europe this

revolution for democracy in Europe this can be the beginning for participatory

can be the beginning for participatory

can be the beginning for participatory democracy in Europe let me just pause

democracy in Europe let me just pause

democracy in Europe let me just pause here so as you know as an alumni of the

here so as you know as an alumni of the

here so as you know as an alumni of the College of Europe here naturally I think

College of Europe here naturally I think

College of Europe here naturally I think that everyone here in the rooms know

that everyone here in the rooms know

that everyone here in the rooms know what European citizens initiative is

what European citizens initiative is

what European citizens initiative is right so for all those out there in

right so for all those out there in

right so for all those out there in there on the web and online who want a

there on the web and online who want a

there on the web and online who want a little explanation still in 2012 the EU

little explanation still in 2012 the EU

little explanation still in 2012 the EU put in place a tool that allows all

put in place a tool that allows all

put in place a tool that allows all citizens to propose laws in Europe this

citizens to propose laws in Europe this

citizens to propose laws in Europe this was a novelty until then only the

was a novelty until then only the

was a novelty until then only the European Commission was allowed to

European Commission was allowed to

European Commission was allowed to propose laws in fact even today not even

propose laws in fact even today not even

propose laws in fact even today not even the European Parliament the only

the European Parliament the only

the European Parliament the only democratically elected body has this

democratically elected body has this

democratically elected body has this right to initiative so it’s quite

right to initiative so it’s quite

right to initiative so it’s quite something but there’s no free lunch as

something but there’s no free lunch as

something but there’s no free lunch as you know and in fact this thing also

you know and in fact this thing also

you know and in fact this thing also comes with terms and conditions in facts

comes with terms and conditions in facts

comes with terms and conditions in facts so first to propose an initiative you

so first to propose an initiative you

so first to propose an initiative you need to be seven different

need to be seven different

need to be seven different also you need to live in seven different

also you need to live in seven different

also you need to live in seven different European countries

European countries

European countries good luck with that then you need to get

good luck with that then you need to get

good luck with that then you need to get 1 million signatures in one year and by

1 million signatures in one year and by

1 million signatures in one year and by the way you also need to have a quota of

the way you also need to have a quota of

the way you also need to have a quota of signatures per country’s in that seven

signatures per country’s in that seven

signatures per country’s in that seven countries minimum oh and by the way the

countries minimum oh and by the way the

countries minimum oh and by the way the European Commission has the right to

European Commission has the right to

European Commission has the right to veto your initiative at any time before

veto your initiative at any time before

veto your initiative at any time before it gets to the vote in the European

it gets to the vote in the European

it gets to the vote in the European Parliament in other words designed to be

Parliament in other words designed to be

Parliament in other words designed to be impossible for citizens like you and me

impossible for citizens like you and me

impossible for citizens like you and me but that was exactly why we wanted to do

but that was exactly why we wanted to do

but that was exactly why we wanted to do something about it that’s what’s exactly

something about it that’s what’s exactly

something about it that’s what’s exactly why we had to make it accessible to

why we had to make it accessible to

why we had to make it accessible to citizens on the parallel I was engaging

citizens on the parallel I was engaging

citizens on the parallel I was engaging my or finishing my fifth year in

my or finishing my fifth year in

my or finishing my fifth year in European studies soon six year and I was

European studies soon six year and I was

European studies soon six year and I was beginning to feel a little bit

beginning to feel a little bit

beginning to feel a little bit disenchanted by the European

disenchanted by the European

disenchanted by the European institutions and the European in me was

institutions and the European in me was

institutions and the European in me was asking what can I possibly do how can I

asking what can I possibly do how can I

asking what can I possibly do how can I help you to build and be continued to be

help you to build and be continued to be

help you to build and be continued to be constructed without being inside the

constructed without being inside the

constructed without being inside the walls so I didn’t hesitate one moment to

walls so I didn’t hesitate one moment to

walls so I didn’t hesitate one moment to start this I just had to do it it was a

start this I just had to do it it was a

start this I just had to do it it was a gut feeling so we took on the adventure

gut feeling so we took on the adventure

gut feeling so we took on the adventure I would call it to start this platform

I would call it to start this platform

I would call it to start this platform it would be a unique platform to allow

it would be a unique platform to allow

it would be a unique platform to allow all the European citizens initiative to

all the European citizens initiative to

all the European citizens initiative to be on one platform visible to one each

be on one platform visible to one each

be on one platform visible to one each other which would help them get more

other which would help them get more

other which would help them get more signatures and in that way we we would

signatures and in that way we we would

signatures and in that way we we would also support them in signal we will also

also support them in signal we will also

also support them in signal we will also support them in legal advice as well as

support them in legal advice as well as

support them in legal advice as well as online campaigning so participatory

online campaigning so participatory

online campaigning so participatory democracy here we come or not because

democracy here we come or not because

democracy here we come or not because apart from the usual stumbling blocks to

apart from the usual stumbling blocks to

apart from the usual stumbling blocks to meet as a first-time entrepreneur we

meet as a first-time entrepreneur we

meet as a first-time entrepreneur we also discovered that there were much

also discovered that there were much

also discovered that there were much larger problems for the European

larger problems for the European

larger problems for the European citizens initiative to become a

citizens initiative to become a

citizens initiative to become a participatory democracy tool first the

participatory democracy tool first the

participatory democracy tool first the number of citizens initiatives in fact

number of citizens initiatives in fact

number of citizens initiatives in fact remained very very low so at our prime

remained very very low so at our prime

remained very very low so at our prime time we had nine citizens

time we had nine citizens

time we had nine citizens initiative of our on our platform since

initiative of our on our platform since

initiative of our on our platform since then today there has been 28 citizens

then today there has been 28 citizens

then today there has been 28 citizens initiative who’s seen the light only

initiative who’s seen the light only

initiative who’s seen the light only three of them succeeded and 14 of them

three of them succeeded and 14 of them

three of them succeeded and 14 of them were withdrawn by the organizers the

were withdrawn by the organizers the

were withdrawn by the organizers the rest didn’t acquire the signatures they

rest didn’t acquire the signatures they

rest didn’t acquire the signatures they needed so at this pace it was quite

needed so at this pace it was quite

needed so at this pace it was quite difficult to reach that level the

difficult to reach that level the

difficult to reach that level the traction you needed to have one platform

traction you needed to have one platform

traction you needed to have one platform going to help them all second obstacle

going to help them all second obstacle

going to help them all second obstacle the organizers had realized the ones who

the organizers had realized the ones who

the organizers had realized the ones who succeeded were quite different than what

succeeded were quite different than what

succeeded were quite different than what we had expected it wasn’t the usual kind

we had expected it wasn’t the usual kind

we had expected it wasn’t the usual kind of it wasn’t the usual citizen like you

of it wasn’t the usual citizen like you

of it wasn’t the usual citizen like you and me

and me

and me in fact the three or the three

in fact the three or the three

in fact the three or the three initiative that succeeded were all

initiative that succeeded were all

initiative that succeeded were all organized by organizations or

organized by organizations or

organized by organizations or associations who were for a long time

associations who were for a long time

associations who were for a long time working on that cause in that way they

working on that cause in that way they

working on that cause in that way they could use their working time to campaign

could use their working time to campaign

could use their working time to campaign and they could also use their budget to

and they could also use their budget to

and they could also use their budget to provide the campaigning in fact

provide the campaigning in fact

provide the campaigning in fact organizing a European citizens

organizing a European citizens

organizing a European citizens initiative is a full-time job so there

initiative is a full-time job so there

initiative is a full-time job so there are a couple of normal citizens like you

are a couple of normal citizens like you

are a couple of normal citizens like you me who really tried to do it themselves

me who really tried to do it themselves

me who really tried to do it themselves well there was a really tough time and

well there was a really tough time and

well there was a really tough time and as soon as they registered the

as soon as they registered the

as soon as they registered the initiative the 12 months would be gone

initiative the 12 months would be gone

initiative the 12 months would be gone in a snap and we couldn’t even help them

in a snap and we couldn’t even help them

in a snap and we couldn’t even help them at that stage so on another hand well

at that stage so on another hand well

at that stage so on another hand well they tried really hard and we we helped

they tried really hard and we we helped

they tried really hard and we we helped them as much as we could but you just

them as much as we could but you just

them as much as we could but you just had to have their big organisation

had to have their big organisation

had to have their big organisation behind you a third obstacle was the

behind you a third obstacle was the

behind you a third obstacle was the procedures okay I’m not gonna share the

procedures okay I’m not gonna share the

procedures okay I’m not gonna share the whole frustration the procedures have

whole frustration the procedures have

whole frustration the procedures have brought me but this is something all

brought me but this is something all

brought me but this is something all organizers of European citizens

organizers of European citizens

organizers of European citizens initiative have felt but in specially

initiative have felt but in specially

initiative have felt but in specially the the signature online signature

the the signature online signature

the the signature online signature collections will was

collections will was

collections will was impossible it was really something from

impossible it was really something from

impossible it was really something from the 90s you would expect now nowadays to

the 90s you would expect now nowadays to

the 90s you would expect now nowadays to have just one platform you can click

have just one platform you can click

have just one platform you can click sign and then you would have signed this

sign and then you would have signed this

sign and then you would have signed this online you would have signed a citizen’s

online you would have signed a citizen’s

online you would have signed a citizen’s initiative but no you had to enter

initiative but no you had to enter

initiative but no you had to enter information you had to be sure that it

information you had to be sure that it

information you had to be sure that it was off authenticated with your Member

was off authenticated with your Member

was off authenticated with your Member State and then back to the European

State and then back to the European

State and then back to the European Commission it was a mess

Commission it was a mess

Commission it was a mess and finally one very big obstacle which

and finally one very big obstacle which

and finally one very big obstacle which was kind of the inherent problem it was

was kind of the inherent problem it was

was kind of the inherent problem it was that we didn’t really find interest with

that we didn’t really find interest with

that we didn’t really find interest with the citizens at that point we were in an

the citizens at that point we were in an

the citizens at that point we were in an incubator with Avaz which is a petition

incubator with Avaz which is a petition

incubator with Avaz which is a petition platform and and so we shared some

platform and and so we shared some

platform and and so we shared some experience with them and we very fast

experience with them and we very fast

experience with them and we very fast learned that in order to engage citizens

learned that in order to engage citizens

learned that in order to engage citizens you need to really romanticize an issue

you need to really romanticize an issue

you need to really romanticize an issue and of course that’s fine that’s what

and of course that’s fine that’s what

and of course that’s fine that’s what you call storytelling that’s what

you call storytelling that’s what

you call storytelling that’s what happens all the time but there comes a

happens all the time but there comes a

happens all the time but there comes a point where you’re romanticizing the

point where you’re romanticizing the

point where you’re romanticizing the topic so much that you’re thinking for a

topic so much that you’re thinking for a

topic so much that you’re thinking for a law is this really what I have to do to

law is this really what I have to do to

law is this really what I have to do to create interest from citizens is this

create interest from citizens is this

create interest from citizens is this really what I want to do shouldn’t the

really what I want to do shouldn’t the

really what I want to do shouldn’t the interest just not live with them

interest just not live with them

interest just not live with them automatically it was frustrating

automatically it was frustrating

automatically it was frustrating so obstacle after obstacle it became

so obstacle after obstacle it became

so obstacle after obstacle it became more and more clear to me that the

more and more clear to me that the

more and more clear to me that the European citizens initiative is not a

European citizens initiative is not a

European citizens initiative is not a participatory democracy tool it was

participatory democracy tool it was

participatory democracy tool it was bound to become a mobilization tool at

bound to become a mobilization tool at

bound to become a mobilization tool at European level for organizations and

European level for organizations and

European level for organizations and causes I would call it institutionalized

causes I would call it institutionalized

causes I would call it institutionalized activism it was a way to engage citizens

activism it was a way to engage citizens

activism it was a way to engage citizens at European level all while keeping them

at European level all while keeping them

at European level all while keeping them on Cerrito well don’t get me wrong

on Cerrito well don’t get me wrong

on Cerrito well don’t get me wrong activism is important and it’s needed

activism is important and it’s needed

activism is important and it’s needed more than ever

more than ever

more than ever however we grow up being taught to be

however we grow up being taught to be

however we grow up being taught to be reactive not to be proactive let me get

reactive not to be proactive let me get

reactive not to be proactive let me get back to that example of

back to that example of

back to that example of the elections every five years that

the elections every five years that

the elections every five years that creates the citizen who’s tested in

creates the citizen who’s tested in

creates the citizen who’s tested in pegasus armchair and and every five

pegasus armchair and and every five

pegasus armchair and and every five years he will go to vote and according

years he will go to vote and according

years he will go to vote and according to the system as soon as he has done

to the system as soon as he has done

to the system as soon as he has done that he will have done his civic duty so

that he will have done his civic duty so

that he will have done his civic duty so he’s good he has no more to do if he

he’s good he has no more to do if he

he’s good he has no more to do if he feels want to feel really good about

feels want to feel really good about

feels want to feel really good about himself well he can engage in some

himself well he can engage in some

himself well he can engage in some clicktivism and sign one or two

clicktivism and sign one or two

clicktivism and sign one or two petitions not at European citizens

petitions not at European citizens

petitions not at European citizens initiative though that’s too complex so

initiative though that’s too complex so

initiative though that’s too complex so unless we’re taught otherwise we won’t

unless we’re taught otherwise we won’t

unless we’re taught otherwise we won’t engage more and we won’t engage

engage more and we won’t engage

engage more and we won’t engage differently I’m a cop of I’m of course

differently I’m a cop of I’m of course

differently I’m a cop of I’m of course exaggerating my point to make the points

exaggerating my point to make the points

exaggerating my point to make the points and a rising number of citizens are also

and a rising number of citizens are also

and a rising number of citizens are also engaging differently in hacktivism

engaging differently in hacktivism

engaging differently in hacktivism sittings marches and this is great but

sittings marches and this is great but

sittings marches and this is great but we are still reactive our representative

we are still reactive our representative

we are still reactive our representative democracy is what I call a reactive

democracy is what I call a reactive

democracy is what I call a reactive democracy because we need a legitimate

democracy because we need a legitimate

democracy because we need a legitimate space to be proactive the European

space to be proactive the European

space to be proactive the European citizens initiative could have been such

citizens initiative could have been such

citizens initiative could have been such a legitimate legitimate space to be

a legitimate legitimate space to be

a legitimate legitimate space to be proactive at European level but it

proactive at European level but it

proactive at European level but it failed it failed for various reasons but

failed it failed for various reasons but

failed it failed for various reasons but in my opinion it failed because it

in my opinion it failed because it

in my opinion it failed because it didn’t have a raison d’etre

didn’t have a raison d’etre

didn’t have a raison d’etre I have come to believe that

I have come to believe that

I have come to believe that participatory democracy it’s not

participatory democracy it’s not

participatory democracy it’s not necessarily needed nor efficient at EU

necessarily needed nor efficient at EU

necessarily needed nor efficient at EU level maybe not even at national level

level maybe not even at national level

level maybe not even at national level the exception of course would be

the exception of course would be

the exception of course would be Switzerland who’s managed to do that

Switzerland who’s managed to do that

Switzerland who’s managed to do that well but we would need to change our

well but we would need to change our

well but we would need to change our whole political system to get there so

whole political system to get there so

whole political system to get there so let’s not try but then would need a

let’s not try but then would need a

let’s not try but then would need a revolution instead others start-ups and

revolution instead others start-ups and

revolution instead others start-ups and other initiatives have managed to create

other initiatives have managed to create

other initiatives have managed to create a participatory democracy at local level

a participatory democracy at local level

a participatory democracy at local level at regional level in cities and it looks

at regional level in cities and it looks

at regional level in cities and it looks more and more like participatory

more and more like participatory

more and more like participatory democracy to me and for me this is

democracy to me and for me this is

democracy to me and for me this is exciting I feel that I can begin to

exciting I feel that I can begin to

exciting I feel that I can begin to believe in our democracy again

believe in our democracy again

believe in our democracy again in fact if I were to do all this over

in fact if I were to do all this over

in fact if I were to do all this over again these will be my three rolls of

again these will be my three rolls of

again these will be my three rolls of tongue one the space where citizens can

tongue one the space where citizens can

tongue one the space where citizens can engage and be proactive it needs to be

engage and be proactive it needs to be

engage and be proactive it needs to be created by the citizens so that they

created by the citizens so that they

created by the citizens so that they have this sense of ownership second it

have this sense of ownership second it

have this sense of ownership second it must be created at a level where their

must be created at a level where their

must be created at a level where their interests are close to the hearts so

interests are close to the hearts so

interests are close to the hearts so this is very often at local regional

this is very often at local regional

this is very often at local regional city level on their streets but it’s

city level on their streets but it’s

city level on their streets but it’s very difficult to create that at EU

very difficult to create that at EU

very difficult to create that at EU level because they’re the topics are

level because they’re the topics are

level because they’re the topics are technical they’re lengthy and don’t get

technical they’re lengthy and don’t get

technical they’re lengthy and don’t get me started and third it must be an

me started and third it must be an

me started and third it must be an interaction with a public authority to

interaction with a public authority to

interaction with a public authority to legitimize the whole thing so to

legitimize the whole thing so to

legitimize the whole thing so to contradict Frank Underwood democracy is

contradict Frank Underwood democracy is

contradict Frank Underwood democracy is not overrated we simply need to seize it

not overrated we simply need to seize it

not overrated we simply need to seize it thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *