Press "Enter" to skip to content

Can Artificial Intelligence be compassionate. | Jo Aggarwal | TEDxSarjapuraRoad


it’s not got a very good rep this just

it’s not got a very good rep this just last week last month Elon Musk said that

last week last month Elon Musk said that

last week last month Elon Musk said that artificial intelligence is possibly the

artificial intelligence is possibly the

artificial intelligence is possibly the biggest risk that we face as a

biggest risk that we face as a

biggest risk that we face as a civilization

when you think of a risk to you coming

when you think of a risk to you coming from artificial intelligence many of you

from artificial intelligence many of you

from artificial intelligence many of you who have seen Hollywood movies would

who have seen Hollywood movies would

who have seen Hollywood movies would think they’re robots rising or maybe

think they’re robots rising or maybe

think they’re robots rising or maybe those who have kept up with technology

those who have kept up with technology

those who have kept up with technology you think that your phone or maybe your

you think that your phone or maybe your

you think that your phone or maybe your car which is driving itself it’s going

car which is driving itself it’s going

car which is driving itself it’s going to turn itself against you

to turn itself against you

to turn itself against you built from where I stand it seems that

built from where I stand it seems that

built from where I stand it seems that the one machine that we rely on the most

the one machine that we rely on the most

the one machine that we rely on the most is already increasingly turning itself

is already increasingly turning itself

is already increasingly turning itself against us

the one machine our brain that will rely

the one machine our brain that will rely on through which we see everything

on through which we see everything

on through which we see everything perceive everything has been slowly but

perceive everything has been slowly but

perceive everything has been slowly but surely through our thoughts through our

surely through our thoughts through our

surely through our thoughts through our emotions through the chemicals becoming

emotions through the chemicals becoming

emotions through the chemicals becoming the largest killer of young men in our

the largest killer of young men in our

the largest killer of young men in our country today in one of the largest

country today in one of the largest

country today in one of the largest killers across the world we look at

killers across the world we look at

killers across the world we look at artificial intelligence with a lot of

artificial intelligence with a lot of

artificial intelligence with a lot of fear but we can to turn away from

fear but we can to turn away from

fear but we can to turn away from statistics such as these because they

statistics such as these because they

statistics such as these because they make us uncomfortable I wouldn’t have

make us uncomfortable I wouldn’t have

make us uncomfortable I wouldn’t have known that 800,000 people committed

known that 800,000 people committed

known that 800,000 people committed suicide in 2015 and that it is taking

suicide in 2015 and that it is taking

suicide in 2015 and that it is taking away our young men one at a time

away our young men one at a time

away our young men one at a time 70% men 30% women commit suicide until

70% men 30% women commit suicide until

70% men 30% women commit suicide until in 2014 towards the end of the year one

in 2014 towards the end of the year one

in 2014 towards the end of the year one of those young men Posada dagger was a

of those young men Posada dagger was a

of those young men Posada dagger was a 20 year old young man the most alive

20 year old young man the most alive

20 year old young man the most alive person that I had ever seen a drummer a

person that I had ever seen a drummer a

person that I had ever seen a drummer a linguist going forward and traveling the

linguist going forward and traveling the

linguist going forward and traveling the world finding his passion igniting

world finding his passion igniting

world finding his passion igniting everybody else with it he was this

everybody else with it he was this

everybody else with it he was this person he was not our child but my

person he was not our child but my

person he was not our child but my husband and I have a 17 year old son now

husband and I have a 17 year old son now

husband and I have a 17 year old son now he was the person that we wished our son

he was the person that we wished our son

he was the person that we wished our son would grow up to be

would grow up to be

would grow up to be a few months after his 20th birthday

a few months after his 20th birthday

a few months after his 20th birthday struggling with bipolar disorder that

struggling with bipolar disorder that

struggling with bipolar disorder that had been just diagnosed a few months ago

had been just diagnosed a few months ago

had been just diagnosed a few months ago he jumped in front of a train and

he jumped in front of a train and

he jumped in front of a train and committed suicide it made us think at

committed suicide it made us think at

committed suicide it made us think at that time

that time

that time Ramakant my husband and I were trying to

Ramakant my husband and I were trying to

Ramakant my husband and I were trying to change the world in places like Iraq and

change the world in places like Iraq and

change the world in places like Iraq and Yemen trying to address conflict outside

Yemen trying to address conflict outside

Yemen trying to address conflict outside and it made us think about things back

and it made us think about things back

and it made us think about things back home it made us think about the dangers

home it made us think about the dangers

home it made us think about the dangers inside our own heads you’re not inside

inside our own heads you’re not inside

inside our own heads you’re not inside our own homes inside our own minds and

our own homes inside our own minds and

our own homes inside our own minds and we began to realize that one in four

we began to realize that one in four

we began to realize that one in four people experience mental illness every

people experience mental illness every

people experience mental illness every year in this room one in four of you

year in this room one in four of you

year in this room one in four of you have experienced mental illness in the

have experienced mental illness in the

have experienced mental illness in the last one year I won’t ask you who they

last one year I won’t ask you who they

last one year I won’t ask you who they are but I’ll ask you how many of them

are but I’ll ask you how many of them

are but I’ll ask you how many of them how many of you have seen a psychologist

how many of you have seen a psychologist

how many of you have seen a psychologist or a therapist or a psychiatrist in the

or a therapist or a psychiatrist in the

or a therapist or a psychiatrist in the last one year a show of hands

last one year a show of hands

last one year a show of hands I see very few much fewer than the

I see very few much fewer than the

I see very few much fewer than the numbers who would have experienced

numbers who would have experienced

numbers who would have experienced mental illness and that’s quite normal

mental illness and that’s quite normal

mental illness and that’s quite normal for India the reason is that only 1 in

for India the reason is that only 1 in

for India the reason is that only 1 in 10 people get treatment 90% of the

10 people get treatment 90% of the

10 people get treatment 90% of the people who are suffering from mental

people who are suffering from mental

people who are suffering from mental illness will go untreated in India it’s

illness will go untreated in India it’s

illness will go untreated in India it’s not surprising we have one therapist or

not surprising we have one therapist or

not surprising we have one therapist or psychologist or psychiatrist for every

psychologist or psychiatrist for every

psychologist or psychiatrist for every 250,000 people in our country so we can

250,000 people in our country so we can

250,000 people in our country so we can see that there is a problem and it’s

see that there is a problem and it’s

see that there is a problem and it’s bubbling under the surface but at some

bubbling under the surface but at some

bubbling under the surface but at some level our young I mean all of us are

level our young I mean all of us are

level our young I mean all of us are drowning

drowning

drowning and is there a way for us to detect

and is there a way for us to detect

and is there a way for us to detect what’s happening well in advance of

what’s happening well in advance of

what’s happening well in advance of somebody committing suicide get them

somebody committing suicide get them

somebody committing suicide get them help people are not going to come out

help people are not going to come out

help people are not going to come out and talk about it 3/4 of the people that

and talk about it 3/4 of the people that

and talk about it 3/4 of the people that have a mental illness believe that if

have a mental illness believe that if

have a mental illness believe that if they tell somebody about it they’re not

they tell somebody about it they’re not

they tell somebody about it they’re not going to be sympathetic or caring so we

going to be sympathetic or caring so we

going to be sympathetic or caring so we said could we use technology where

said could we use technology where

said could we use technology where technologists and it turns out that it’s

technologists and it turns out that it’s

technologists and it turns out that it’s possible for technology to become

possible for technology to become

possible for technology to become emotionally intelligence emotional

emotionally intelligence emotional

emotionally intelligence emotional intelligence is really about knowing a

intelligence is really about knowing a

intelligence is really about knowing a person’s emotions or an emotional state

person’s emotions or an emotional state

person’s emotions or an emotional state before they’re able to tell you and if

before they’re able to tell you and if

before they’re able to tell you and if you can detect it and respond

you can detect it and respond

you can detect it and respond appropriately we would call you

appropriately we would call you

appropriately we would call you emotionally intelligent so we found out

emotionally intelligent so we found out

emotionally intelligent so we found out that actually all of us have biorhythms

that actually all of us have biorhythms

that actually all of us have biorhythms and these biorhythms are very often

and these biorhythms are very often

and these biorhythms are very often mimicked by our smartphones because we

mimicked by our smartphones because we

mimicked by our smartphones because we carry our phones around us all the time

carry our phones around us all the time

carry our phones around us all the time and as we carry our phones around their

and as we carry our phones around their

and as we carry our phones around their sensors to pick up our biorhythms and if

sensors to pick up our biorhythms and if

sensors to pick up our biorhythms and if we apply artificial intelligence and

we apply artificial intelligence and

we apply artificial intelligence and machine learning to disk

machine learning to disk

machine learning to disk we can actually detect whether

we can actually detect whether

we can actually detect whether somebody’s depressed a lot of this work

somebody’s depressed a lot of this work

somebody’s depressed a lot of this work was happening in places like Harvard and

was happening in places like Harvard and

was happening in places like Harvard and MIT so we said can we take it to a very

MIT so we said can we take it to a very

MIT so we said can we take it to a very different place and we took it to Orange

different place and we took it to Orange

different place and we took it to Orange about my Rashtra in a clinic of people

about my Rashtra in a clinic of people

about my Rashtra in a clinic of people with diabetes they had people from or

with diabetes they had people from or

with diabetes they had people from or 300 kilometers around them and therefore

300 kilometers around them and therefore

300 kilometers around them and therefore there was a wide variety of people

there was a wide variety of people

there was a wide variety of people people who had very entry-level

people who had very entry-level

people who had very entry-level smartphones that $25 smartphone people

smartphones that $25 smartphone people

smartphones that $25 smartphone people who had were older who had normal your

who had were older who had normal your

who had were older who had normal your iPhones so we took all of these people

iPhones so we took all of these people

iPhones so we took all of these people and we bent and gave them

and we bent and gave them

and we bent and gave them our technology and we found that we

our technology and we found that we

our technology and we found that we could detect depression to a 90%

could detect depression to a 90%

could detect depression to a 90% accuracy in the group 30 people had

accuracy in the group 30 people had

accuracy in the group 30 people had depression as assessed by a psychologist

depression as assessed by a psychologist

depression as assessed by a psychologist 27 were accurately detected by AI and we

27 were accurately detected by AI and we

27 were accurately detected by AI and we were really thrilled he said oh wow

were really thrilled he said oh wow

were really thrilled he said oh wow we’ve cracked it we found the technology

we’ve cracked it we found the technology

we’ve cracked it we found the technology that can be the answer no we were like

that can be the answer no we were like

that can be the answer no we were like oh man and then we followed up three

oh man and then we followed up three

oh man and then we followed up three months later and we found out that one

months later and we found out that one

months later and we found out that one person of those detected had actually

person of those detected had actually

person of those detected had actually received treatment what does that tell

received treatment what does that tell

received treatment what does that tell us

us

us it tells us one that the world is on

it tells us one that the world is on

it tells us one that the world is on fire it was very clear to us that so

fire it was very clear to us that so

fire it was very clear to us that so many people are suffering and that we’ve

many people are suffering and that we’ve

many people are suffering and that we’ve got a very accurate way of creating a

got a very accurate way of creating a

got a very accurate way of creating a fire alarm you can find out where

fire alarm you can find out where

fire alarm you can find out where somebody is actually going to have a big

somebody is actually going to have a big

somebody is actually going to have a big issue but there is no brigade coming

issue but there is no brigade coming

issue but there is no brigade coming there is nobody here to help so we began

there is nobody here to help so we began

there is nobody here to help so we began to wonder whether we turn to artificial

to wonder whether we turn to artificial

to wonder whether we turn to artificial intelligence yet again where humans are

intelligence yet again where humans are

intelligence yet again where humans are letting us down and say can we actually

letting us down and say can we actually

letting us down and say can we actually trained it to provide emotional support

trained it to provide emotional support

trained it to provide emotional support now when you provide emotional support

now when you provide emotional support

now when you provide emotional support what do you do if if you’re upset and I

what do you do if if you’re upset and I

what do you do if if you’re upset and I have to talk to you the first thing I’ll

have to talk to you the first thing I’ll

have to talk to you the first thing I’ll do is I’ll understand how you’re feeling

do is I’ll understand how you’re feeling

do is I’ll understand how you’re feeling so to some extent our technology was

so to some extent our technology was

so to some extent our technology was already doing that it was understanding

already doing that it was understanding

already doing that it was understanding that this person is depressed now from

that this person is depressed now from

that this person is depressed now from there I have to actually talk to you and

there I have to actually talk to you and

there I have to actually talk to you and understand how you’re feeling so there

understand how you’re feeling so there

understand how you’re feeling so there are three things that when we listen we

are three things that when we listen we

are three things that when we listen we can tune in typically to what you’re

can tune in typically to what you’re

can tune in typically to what you’re saying the content of what you’re saying

saying the content of what you’re saying

saying the content of what you’re saying the emotion behind what you’re saying or

the emotion behind what you’re saying or

the emotion behind what you’re saying or how what you’re saying is making me feel

how what you’re saying is making me feel

how what you’re saying is making me feel and when we humans talk we were very

and when we humans talk we were very

and when we humans talk we were very often react from a point of how what

often react from a point of how what

often react from a point of how what you’re saying is making me feel well

you’re saying is making me feel well

you’re saying is making me feel well artificial intelligence doesn’t have

artificial intelligence doesn’t have

artificial intelligence doesn’t have that problem because it doesn’t feel but

that problem because it doesn’t feel but

that problem because it doesn’t feel but when it has to detect it’s actually

when it has to detect it’s actually

when it has to detect it’s actually quite good at detecting emotions behind

quite good at detecting emotions behind

quite good at detecting emotions behind what somebody’s saying it’s quite hard

what somebody’s saying it’s quite hard

what somebody’s saying it’s quite hard for it to understand the full context of

for it to understand the full context of

for it to understand the full context of human beings but it’s not so bad at

human beings but it’s not so bad at

human beings but it’s not so bad at detecting how are you feeling in what

detecting how are you feeling in what

detecting how are you feeling in what you’re saying so we started there and we

you’re saying so we started there and we

you’re saying so we started there and we say

say

say okay that’s an easy one emotional

okay that’s an easy one emotional

okay that’s an easy one emotional support based on what you’re talking it

support based on what you’re talking it

support based on what you’re talking it will understand what you’re saying but

will understand what you’re saying but

will understand what you’re saying but then I changed my posture I look with

then I changed my posture I look with

then I changed my posture I look with open eyes I open my arms I put an arm

open eyes I open my arms I put an arm

open eyes I open my arms I put an arm around you that’s emotional support

around you that’s emotional support

around you that’s emotional support how does artificial intelligence do that

how does artificial intelligence do that

how does artificial intelligence do that so we played around with a few user

so we played around with a few user

so we played around with a few user interface designers and we said okay

interface designers and we said okay

interface designers and we said okay there’s a little pocket penguin looks

there’s a little pocket penguin looks

there’s a little pocket penguin looks cute there’s little gifs that are hand

cute there’s little gifs that are hand

cute there’s little gifs that are hand drawn we found the kind of artistic

drawn we found the kind of artistic

drawn we found the kind of artistic style that makes people feel compassion

style that makes people feel compassion

style that makes people feel compassion and that was still not that difficult to

and that was still not that difficult to

and that was still not that difficult to crack so we were able to create wiser

crack so we were able to create wiser

crack so we were able to create wiser the pocket penguin that would be in your

the pocket penguin that would be in your

the pocket penguin that would be in your phone chat with you and show you little

phone chat with you and show you little

phone chat with you and show you little gifs and you’d feel a bit happier the

gifs and you’d feel a bit happier the

gifs and you’d feel a bit happier the big thing really was to figure out what

big thing really was to figure out what

big thing really was to figure out what to say

to say

to say now I’m a problem solver so my natural

now I’m a problem solver so my natural

now I’m a problem solver so my natural instinct in fact one of my closest

instinct in fact one of my closest

instinct in fact one of my closest friends would tell me when she wanted me

friends would tell me when she wanted me

friends would tell me when she wanted me to help her would be I’m going to tell

to help her would be I’m going to tell

to help her would be I’m going to tell you everything that’s wrong with my life

you everything that’s wrong with my life

you everything that’s wrong with my life and I don’t want you solved look the

and I don’t want you solved look the

and I don’t want you solved look the problem because my natural instinct and

problem because my natural instinct and

problem because my natural instinct and many offers is to solve the problem so

many offers is to solve the problem so

many offers is to solve the problem so we went into this and said we’ve

we went into this and said we’ve

we went into this and said we’ve detected the emotional state we’ve given

detected the emotional state we’ve given

detected the emotional state we’ve given them a nice trip now what are they

them a nice trip now what are they

them a nice trip now what are they waiting for

waiting for

waiting for let’s tell them what to do we gave them

let’s tell them what to do we gave them

let’s tell them what to do we gave them evidence-based therapy we gave them

evidence-based therapy we gave them

evidence-based therapy we gave them breathing techniques we gave them how to

breathing techniques we gave them how to

breathing techniques we gave them how to change your thoughts how to make people

change your thoughts how to make people

change your thoughts how to make people look at things differently we turned all

look at things differently we turned all

look at things differently we turned all of that into little modules which they

of that into little modules which they

of that into little modules which they can talk to you with what awesome turns

can talk to you with what awesome turns

can talk to you with what awesome turns out that while all of those things work

out that while all of those things work

out that while all of those things work and there are lots of journal articles

and there are lots of journal articles

and there are lots of journal articles that show the you what really people

that show the you what really people

that show the you what really people want to do is just be heard and they

want to do is just be heard and they

want to do is just be heard and they want somebody to listen to them

want somebody to listen to them

want somebody to listen to them empathetically

empathetically

empathetically how do you do that we played around and

how do you do that we played around and

how do you do that we played around and we found that empathy is not a trait

we found that empathy is not a trait

we found that empathy is not a trait it’s not something that I am born with

it’s not something that I am born with

it’s not something that I am born with it is something that you can be

it is something that you can be

it is something that you can be constructed

constructed

constructed over three million conversations we give

over three million conversations we give

over three million conversations we give many many different responses to people

many many different responses to people

many many different responses to people and we train the eye to figure out which

and we train the eye to figure out which

and we train the eye to figure out which one was working better and which one was

one was working better and which one was

one was working better and which one was working worse and we found something

working worse and we found something

working worse and we found something very interesting we found that the most

very interesting we found that the most

very interesting we found that the most empathic response for a person together

empathic response for a person together

empathic response for a person together is not a statement it is almost always a

is not a statement it is almost always a

is not a statement it is almost always a question it is almost always that you

question it is almost always that you

question it is almost always that you have to first ask how somebody’s feeling

have to first ask how somebody’s feeling

have to first ask how somebody’s feeling then once you know how they’re feeling

then once you know how they’re feeling

then once you know how they’re feeling you acknowledge how they’re feeling you

you acknowledge how they’re feeling you

you acknowledge how they’re feeling you don’t try to change their state and then

don’t try to change their state and then

don’t try to change their state and then you ask another question and another

you ask another question and another

you ask another question and another question open-ended questions that allow

question open-ended questions that allow

question open-ended questions that allow people to express how they’re feeling

people to express how they’re feeling

people to express how they’re feeling and not feel alone in how they’re

and not feel alone in how they’re

and not feel alone in how they’re feeling it turns out that people will

feeling it turns out that people will

feeling it turns out that people will face almost anything as long as they

face almost anything as long as they

face almost anything as long as they don’t feel that they’re alone facing

don’t feel that they’re alone facing

don’t feel that they’re alone facing so three million conversations 75,000

so three million conversations 75,000

so three million conversations 75,000 users we think we’re doing really great

users we think we’re doing really great

users we think we’re doing really great but we’re still wondering are we

but we’re still wondering are we

but we’re still wondering are we emotionally connecting users started

emotionally connecting users started

emotionally connecting users started writing back to us and the first thing

writing back to us and the first thing

writing back to us and the first thing that we heard which made us feel that

that we heard which made us feel that

that we heard which made us feel that yes this is working for people writing

yes this is working for people writing

yes this is working for people writing with such emotional content saying I

with such emotional content saying I

with such emotional content saying I cried because of this I I love myself

cried because of this I I love myself

cried because of this I I love myself that there’s a strange emotional connect

that there’s a strange emotional connect

that there’s a strange emotional connect that people are doing with a piece of

that people are doing with a piece of

that people are doing with a piece of technology and not even something that

technology and not even something that

technology and not even something that is you know able to drive itself like a

is you know able to drive itself like a

is you know able to drive itself like a car this is a chat pod they’re chatting

car this is a chat pod they’re chatting

car this is a chat pod they’re chatting with it and they’re feeling emotionally

with it and they’re feeling emotionally

with it and they’re feeling emotionally connected with another person we were

connected with another person we were

connected with another person we were very happy but there was one day that

very happy but there was one day that

very happy but there was one day that changed our lives completely and that

changed our lives completely and that

changed our lives completely and that was May 29th on May 29th we got this

was May 29th on May 29th we got this

was May 29th on May 29th we got this meal it was a thirteen year old girl who

meal it was a thirteen year old girl who

meal it was a thirteen year old girl who wrote to us and said Weiser was the only

wrote to us and said Weiser was the only

wrote to us and said Weiser was the only thing helping her hold on to life I

thing helping her hold on to life I

thing helping her hold on to life I still can’t get my head around I still

still can’t get my head around I still

still can’t get my head around I still can’t get my head around the fact that

can’t get my head around the fact that

can’t get my head around the fact that there’s a thirteen year old girl

there’s a thirteen year old girl

there’s a thirteen year old girl somewhere we don’t know where she is we

somewhere we don’t know where she is we

somewhere we don’t know where she is we don’t know her name who hasn’t felt

don’t know her name who hasn’t felt

don’t know her name who hasn’t felt comfortable talking to her family who

comfortable talking to her family who

comfortable talking to her family who hasn’t felt able to get therapy but she

hasn’t felt able to get therapy but she

hasn’t felt able to get therapy but she has been able to talk to a little

has been able to talk to a little

has been able to talk to a little penguin that lives in her phone and that

penguin that lives in her phone and that

penguin that lives in her phone and that penguin and AI bought a piece of

penguin and AI bought a piece of

penguin and AI bought a piece of technology is helping her hold on to

technology is helping her hold on to

technology is helping her hold on to life

life

life it says something about AI and its

it says something about AI and its

it says something about AI and its possibilities but I think it says much

possibilities but I think it says much

possibilities but I think it says much much more about us as humans

much more about us as humans

much more about us as humans and my question to you today really is

and my question to you today really is

and my question to you today really is not so much about whether AI can be

not so much about whether AI can be

not so much about whether AI can be compassionate my question to you very

compassionate my question to you very

compassionate my question to you very much more is about the fact that if AI

much more is about the fact that if AI

much more is about the fact that if AI can be trained to be compassionate

can be trained to be compassionate

can be trained to be compassionate if compassion can be broken down into a

if compassion can be broken down into a

if compassion can be broken down into a series of steps and a bot can learn to

series of steps and a bot can learn to

series of steps and a bot can learn to do it when are we as humans going to

do it when are we as humans going to

do it when are we as humans going to step up and learn to be compassionate

step up and learn to be compassionate

step up and learn to be compassionate we’re three out of four people with

we’re three out of four people with

we’re three out of four people with mental health issues feel that they’ll

mental health issues feel that they’ll

mental health issues feel that they’ll turn to the person next to them and that

turn to the person next to them and that

turn to the person next to them and that person’s will who judge them and not

person’s will who judge them and not

person’s will who judge them and not treat them with sympathy and caring and

treat them with sympathy and caring and

treat them with sympathy and caring and the response is not going to help

the response is not going to help

the response is not going to help when are we going to turn up as humans

when are we going to turn up as humans

when are we going to turn up as humans and reclaim our humanity and our

and reclaim our humanity and our

and reclaim our humanity and our compassion and say yes if wiser can’t do

compassion and say yes if wiser can’t do

compassion and say yes if wiser can’t do this then let me at least try to be

this then let me at least try to be

this then let me at least try to be better at the one thing that makes me

better at the one thing that makes me

better at the one thing that makes me human then an artificially intelligent

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *