Press "Enter" to skip to content

Les animaux ont ils des droits ? | Catherine Helayel | TEDxTours


[Applause]

malebranche a disciple of descartes

asserted when he was beating an animal

that the writing he was pushing was nothing

to do with the pain it was

just a malfunction in his

wheel

barely three centuries ago prevails and

the theory of the animal machine and

contrary to what you thought

Mr. Descartes and animals

are sensitive living beings without

that they amend felt even that’s

what an animal without tian and well the

Anglo Saxon uses this adjective for

designate the fact that animals

terrestrial and aquatic as we have

perceptions of desires a will

goals of their own they

experience emotions feelings

pleasant unpleasant they

Feel the pain and the terror

that they are trying to avoid

desperately because they hold

to their life I am a lawyer and during

over thirty years well I exercised

family law for more than

thirty years and I defended humans

well today I decided to

put my skills at the service of those

who do not have the floor in the service of

animals

it’s not a question of sentimentality

exacerbated because actually for me

it is above all a question of justice

justice for animals and when I

see an animal I do not see a thing

cute or horrible besides I see

an individual then my specialty is

the right of the animal

what is animal customs

quite simple is all of the

legal rules that are involved

our animals then as in France and not

code of animal rights

well we find them scattered a

little everywhere then we find in code

penal in the rural code in the code

civil

and then in the code of the environment

there are rules favorable to

animals or by animal protection

but there are also rules

unfavorable and they are even

Majority is giving you a single

example because it dates from the week

last one was allowed euthanasia of

more than 100 macaque monkeys of java know

not if you have heard of

in fact he was in a kind of zone

of reservation and because of a problem

sanitary is well over 100 macaques

have been euthanized here is an example

unfavorable right to animals then

a little bit of history of the right to

the animal or rather the protection

animal

because at the birth of the civil code

Napoleonic in 1804 well he

there was no protective rule

animals

the only rules that existed

unfavorable rules there have been five

important steps in

animal rights

5 the first we can talk about

the beginnings of the protection of the animal

it’s 1850 with the grammont law that I

would summarize in this sentence hide this

suffering that I can not see

grammond was a deputy general

who could not stand to see the

suffering of animals on the street and

especially horses because in 1850

there were still a lot of horses

in the street and actually this law

well she to punish with a simple

traffic ticket

animal abuse but

provided they have been

committed in public ie you

could continue to mistreat a

animal in your garage

but in public it was not possible and

in fact what does it protect this

law it does not protect animals

directly it protects the

human sensibility put to rough

test before the show of the

suffering of animals

it will take a century second

step 1959 for this law to be

repealed and replaced by another law

who actually goes this time consider

that we can not mistreat

animals also in the sphere

private

that is, in fact for the

first time we will consider that

animals have an interest not to

not suffer

third step 1963 what is

happened in 1963 well for now

it was just a contravention

and well in 1963 the law will create a

offense

the crime of acts of cruelty on

animals to give you just an order

of idea a speeding ticket this is a

contravention kill an animal without the

To make suffer

it’s a ticket steal it’s a

offense commit an act of cruelty on

an animal is a fourth offense

step 1976 for the first time the

law recognized the sensitivity of

the animal and this sensitivity of

the animal has been integrated in the code

rural under the article l 214 1 l214 you

maybe say something

and what tells us this article eh

well he says that animals being

sensitive beings living their

owner has to keep them in

conditions respecting their

biological imperatives the imperatives

of their species

the fifth most important step

end that is closest to us that’s

2015

and so it is the turn of the civil code

to have recognized that animals are

gentle living beings and sensitivity

then the question we ask ourselves

actually it’s since 2015 since

animals are living things

sensitive it had to change

considerably their fate bah no

well no it did not change much

why, because the civil code

he always considers them a that the

animals are things I explain to you

the rules for the protection of animals

does it its warehouse center and that’s

to say that it is the human being who is

always the referent and the civil code

do not see pets as

a thing belonging to the man and in

1804 and still today in fact and

well this famous civil code

it has only two categories to 3 2

the people

you me and things and in the

things are the modes and the buildings the

people are subjects of law and this

from birth a baby who comes

to be born is a subject of law he

was entitled

the legal subjects the people so

have even basic rights like

for example do not be tortured do not

to be arbitrarily detained in

France and in many countries and well

the animals are always in the

category of things then

actually they went to say

sensitive things

they are still there four in the

category of things that are thus

objects of law and objects of law

they do not have rights so they have

right to protection in certain

case but have no right and especially

we can appropriate them there is a

second much more favorable current

to animals that actually consider that

animals are subjects of law and

that they have rights and this current is

divide himself into two sub

categories then the right currents

the undercurrents the categories the

subcategories love her first

sub categories the animals must

to be included in the category of

people so we have the things and the

people because animals are

teachers and not but in

france companies are people

morals in India recently we granted

legal personality to

rivers and even to glaciers then

why we would not give animals

so what current is the most

favorable it’s a current that’s the

current which is the most minority

this leap under currents or second sub

categories we will extract the animals

of the category of things and we’re going

create a new category that of

animals

we would have things people

and animals well this third

category it already exists in

many European countries to mention

that Switzerland germany belgium

very recently

but in France not this third

category does not exist and so we can

say that in fact with regard to

protection and mina animal france is

very late is very late

on the animal rights plan there are

any protection that exists

but this protection

it’s not the same for all

animals plus animals are close to

we include his emotional plan and well

the stronger the protection

Conversely, animals are

far from us like animals

wild the fish is well the less they

are protected

why because he does not look like us

not because they live far from us

because they live sheltered from our

looks and adase away from the eyes away from

heart takes here all its meaning

did not actually believe this this

difference in treatment is fine

lead human beings to do

categories according to the utility

for the man and that’s how the spell

that man than human justice

grant to animals is not going to be the

even

according to their categorization so

we have the pets we must

to be registered on an istres the in

France we have cats hers

goldfish

the nac the guinea pigs and then

Besides, we can not eat them

when one is registered on the animals of

company then you have the animals

domestic or living in captivity then

then the wild animals and the game

gives in thousand there are sub

categories

but I’m going to help you

imagine

imagine for a moment that you are a

little pet rabbit announcement

too quick excuse me excused for his

exits

this is imagine that you are so I

start again

imagine that you are a little rabbit

of company well you won the

jackpot yeah yes because you’re

considered a living being

sensitive and your landlord does not have

the right neither to harm you nor to

kill you and even some humans are going

you consider yourself part of

their family

if your landlord kills you

cleanly without making you suffer

before it is a contravention and he

is liable to an amendment of

to go up to 750 euros if your

the owner commits acts of

cruelty over you acts the wrongs of

torture before you kill or even if

you escape from it well this

this time if he is sued

it is an offense he incurs a penalty

imprisonment up to

two years firm and almond can go

up to 30000 euros

imagine that you are rabbits of

wild live in freedom

okay and very unlucky because

you do not have the status of being alive

sensitive

nan nan nan because you’re in

remains more that is to say that you

do not belong to anyone so this is

not for you are not protected nor

by the Civil Code and the Penal Code

imagine that you are a rabbit of

laboratory then as you are held

in captivity

well then you are considered a

sentient sentient animal wishes yet

even if you escape the shampoo

in the eyes and at the lipstick on

anus

since a European directive of 2013

which forbids in principle that one tests

cosmetics on you eh

well we can continue to test all

kinds of products the products

talk about you we can

burn with corrosive deposit you can

you gorging on antidepressants one can

you can you are there you are

can you do anything you want

imagine that you are an angora rabbit

and well your magnificent toise we go

you need terrible suffering

because we are going to tie the four

paws

and then we’ll tear off the hair

live without anesthesia live you

leaving the skin bruised and then

we will put you back in your cage

will wait for your hair to grow back and

then we will start again two three four

time and then you will end up in a grab

garbage

imagine not looking at the picture I was

supposed to have a black the black for

you have it so here is imagine that

you are a rabbit raised to be

eaten like 99% of rabbits

consumption I mean 99% and well

you will live in one cage

on others we could not even

move not even move you will be

often hurt sometimes even your life

so little account that you will end live

in a slurry tank

and then at the age of six months

yes six months maximum well after having

spent long hours in a truck

on each other we will

end your life suspended by the

two rear legs bleeding and

sometimes even in full consciousness

how to explain place such a

inconsistency

how to explain legally and even

morally such a paradox ie

on one side of the animals

recognizes the existence of sensitivity

and then on the other hand these same

animals to whom one denies the existence and

all sensibilities the year man

machine is always present because

that in fact the human being leave the

the moment he exploits an animal is

well still considers it a

machine so low dairy cows

and machines to the east hens

laying machines their own

the animal is a simple product a

introduced food product

dress a decorative products a

leisure product

and then when there is not enough

profitable more enough milk more enough

of aisne the ac2a he finishes his short

living in a slaughterhouse the same

way that animals that have been

direct surveys

for their meat to finish on a

note a little more optimistic I’m going

tell you a story

I will tell you the story of

Cecilia Cecilia was detained in

an Argentine prison for very

long years in conditions of

deplorable detention

an association of Argentine lawyers has

seized the Argentine justice doing

argue that the conditions of detention

of Cecilia was detrimental to

his health both moral and physical and

especially since she was detained

unlawful and arbitrary manner

oh yes I forgot to tell you

Something

the association that seized justice

argentina is an association

advocates for the defense of

the animal and Cecilia I you the

present

it’s a chimpanzee is the judge who

was seized to do it he has

considered that Cecilia was not a

object of law that it was a subject of

right and ordered him released and

the 5th of April Cecilia was delivered

at liberty in on a reserve

natural in brazil so this judgment

he is historical he is historical

because it’s the first time

an animal is considered an

nobody and especially that we grant him the

fundamental right not to be

arbitrarily locked up then to

the way lamartine said

does not have a heart

one for the animal the other for the man

we have heart

there is none I would say there is no

justice there is an aura not two

justices one for man and another

for the animal there is a justice where he

there is none

[Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *