Press "Enter" to skip to content

Shedding Light on the Nature of Light… | Bassam AlFeeli | TEDxAlShuwaikh


a show of hands how many think that

a show of hands how many think that there is an alligator that makes this

there is an alligator that makes this

there is an alligator that makes this sound not so many now take a second to

sound not so many now take a second to

sound not so many now take a second to think about this picture how does it

think about this picture how does it

think about this picture how does it make you feel bothersome right it’s it’s

make you feel bothersome right it’s it’s

make you feel bothersome right it’s it’s a realistic it’s very difficult for us

a realistic it’s very difficult for us

a realistic it’s very difficult for us to accept such image when I studied

to accept such image when I studied

to accept such image when I studied quantum mechanics I came about this

quantum mechanics I came about this

quantum mechanics I came about this picture it made me uncomfortable just

picture it made me uncomfortable just

picture it made me uncomfortable just the same way as the previous picture

the same way as the previous picture

the same way as the previous picture made you uncomfortable what does this

made you uncomfortable what does this

made you uncomfortable what does this picture mean it says and according to

picture mean it says and according to

picture mean it says and according to physics that it is accepted that light

physics that it is accepted that light

physics that it is accepted that light can be both particle and a wave at the

can be both particle and a wave at the

can be both particle and a wave at the same time how is that possible you know

same time how is that possible you know

same time how is that possible you know an ocean wave is a wave anorak is a hug

an ocean wave is a wave anorak is a hug

an ocean wave is a wave anorak is a hug how can a wave be a rock and a rock be a

how can a wave be a rock and a rock be a

how can a wave be a rock and a rock be a wave at the same time not only that it

wave at the same time not only that it

wave at the same time not only that it you know what quantum mechanics says

you know what quantum mechanics says

you know what quantum mechanics says that you know a wave sometimes can

that you know a wave sometimes can

that you know a wave sometimes can behave like a rock and sometimes can

behave like a rock and sometimes can

behave like a rock and sometimes can behave like a wave and sometimes it

behave like a wave and sometimes it

behave like a wave and sometimes it could be a third option imagine you’re

could be a third option imagine you’re

could be a third option imagine you’re at the beach and an approaching wave all

at the beach and an approaching wave all

at the beach and an approaching wave all of a sudden turns into a hug that’s

of a sudden turns into a hug that’s

of a sudden turns into a hug that’s crazy

crazy

crazy or if somebody throws a rock at you and

or if somebody throws a rock at you and

or if somebody throws a rock at you and then just before hitting you is splash

then just before hitting you is splash

then just before hitting you is splash into water you know there’s no way this

into water you know there’s no way this

into water you know there’s no way this could happen we don’t experience that as

could happen we don’t experience that as

could happen we don’t experience that as humans unless you know you see it in the

humans unless you know you see it in the

humans unless you know you see it in the Matrix movies or something so why

Matrix movies or something so why

Matrix movies or something so why scientists have accepted such crazy idea

scientists have accepted such crazy idea

scientists have accepted such crazy idea or concept in such field of science well

or concept in such field of science well

or concept in such field of science well maybe to find an answer to this is to

maybe to find an answer to this is to

maybe to find an answer to this is to look into history for a long time

look into history for a long time

look into history for a long time people felt that light is made of

people felt that light is made of

people felt that light is made of particles and then all a sudden

particles and then all a sudden

particles and then all a sudden Descartes showed that light can be

Descartes showed that light can be

Descartes showed that light can be modelled as a wave propagating through a

modelled as a wave propagating through a

modelled as a wave propagating through a medium which he thought it was a

medium which he thought it was a

medium which he thought it was a universal medium and he called it plenum

universal medium and he called it plenum

universal medium and he called it plenum I’ll come back to this plenum stuff

I’ll come back to this plenum stuff

I’ll come back to this plenum stuff later on but then Newton came along and

later on but then Newton came along and

later on but then Newton came along and you probably heard he spent a lot of

you probably heard he spent a lot of

you probably heard he spent a lot of time studying light he spent over 30

time studying light he spent over 30

time studying light he spent over 30 years just studying light and the nature

years just studying light and the nature

years just studying light and the nature of light and then he concluded that

of light and then he concluded that

of light and then he concluded that light must be particles that light beams

light must be particles that light beams

light must be particles that light beams are made out of particles at the same

are made out of particles at the same

are made out of particles at the same time Huygens was also investigating

time Huygens was also investigating

time Huygens was also investigating light but he showed that light is made

light but he showed that light is made

light but he showed that light is made out of waves so it behaves like a wave

out of waves so it behaves like a wave

out of waves so it behaves like a wave is not a particle but back then Newton

is not a particle but back then Newton

is not a particle but back then Newton has a much stronger position Newton was

has a much stronger position Newton was

has a much stronger position Newton was a very respected will established

a very respected will established

a very respected will established scientists we have made so many

scientists we have made so many

scientists we have made so many accomplishments so that the way the wave

accomplishments so that the way the wave

accomplishments so that the way the wave view of light was was ignored because

view of light was was ignored because

view of light was was ignored because you know Newton said light is a particle

you know Newton said light is a particle

you know Newton said light is a particle so we cannot dispute that and imagine it

so we cannot dispute that and imagine it

so we cannot dispute that and imagine it took 200 years after Newton died to make

took 200 years after Newton died to make

took 200 years after Newton died to make people comfortable to say that he was

people comfortable to say that he was

people comfortable to say that he was incorrect you know 200 years was wasted

incorrect you know 200 years was wasted

incorrect you know 200 years was wasted just because people trusted what Newton

just because people trusted what Newton

just because people trusted what Newton say without question of that but luckily

say without question of that but luckily

say without question of that but luckily over time the a lot of evidence surface

over time the a lot of evidence surface

over time the a lot of evidence surface that light behaves like a wave and that

that light behaves like a wave and that

that light behaves like a wave and that was in the mid 19th century and then

was in the mid 19th century and then

was in the mid 19th century and then comes M Stein I call him the

comes M Stein I call him the

comes M Stein I call him the troublemaker

troublemaker

troublemaker Einstein said sorry guys

Einstein said sorry guys

Einstein said sorry guys light is made of particles and knowledge

light is made of particles and knowledge

light is made of particles and knowledge I am calling them photons but then he

I am calling them photons but then he

I am calling them photons but then he was faced the dilemma

was faced the dilemma

was faced the dilemma how can he justify

how can he justify

how can he justify that in all the evidences over the past

that in all the evidences over the past

that in all the evidences over the past hundred years that showed or all the

hundred years that showed or all the

hundred years that showed or all the experiments that showed that light

experiments that showed that light

experiments that showed that light behaves like a wave all a sudden now

behaves like a wave all a sudden now

behaves like a wave all a sudden now he’s saying that it’s a particle and he

he’s saying that it’s a particle and he

he’s saying that it’s a particle and he has experimental evidences shows that

has experimental evidences shows that

has experimental evidences shows that light is a particle he said guys let’s

light is a particle he said guys let’s

light is a particle he said guys let’s compromise and I have a clever idea he

compromise and I have a clever idea he

compromise and I have a clever idea he was very creative and he said well let’s

was very creative and he said well let’s

was very creative and he said well let’s call it both let’s just say light behave

call it both let’s just say light behave

call it both let’s just say light behave like a wave and a particle at the same

like a wave and a particle at the same

like a wave and a particle at the same time and this is where the concept of

time and this is where the concept of

time and this is where the concept of particle wave duality was born it was

particle wave duality was born it was

particle wave duality was born it was born from managed time and his creative

born from managed time and his creative

born from managed time and his creative thinking of what light could be now

thinking of what light could be now

thinking of what light could be now duality is not new it is deeply rooted

duality is not new it is deeply rooted

duality is not new it is deeply rooted in human cultures we have many examples

in human cultures we have many examples

in human cultures we have many examples that shows duality throughout history if

that shows duality throughout history if

that shows duality throughout history if we take centers as an example in this

we take centers as an example in this

we take centers as an example in this belief that the idea of centers was a

belief that the idea of centers was a

belief that the idea of centers was a reaction to people who never saw a human

reaction to people who never saw a human

reaction to people who never saw a human riding a horse

riding a horse

riding a horse so horse riders from far away and

so horse riders from far away and

so horse riders from far away and because they didn’t understand what that

because they didn’t understand what that

because they didn’t understand what that meant they thought was a creature that

meant they thought was a creature that

meant they thought was a creature that is half human half animal but then of

is half human half animal but then of

is half human half animal but then of course when the rider came closer they

course when the rider came closer they

course when the rider came closer they realized it’s just two creatures on top

realized it’s just two creatures on top

realized it’s just two creatures on top of each other

of each other

of each other well quantum mechanics is telling us

well quantum mechanics is telling us

well quantum mechanics is telling us right now is to accept that light is

right now is to accept that light is

right now is to accept that light is like a center it’s both wave and a

like a center it’s both wave and a

like a center it’s both wave and a particle at the same time now light or

particle at the same time now light or

particle at the same time now light or theories about light were not the only

theories about light were not the only

theories about light were not the only ones that faced such drama there are

ones that faced such drama there are

ones that faced such drama there are other theories that have similar or face

other theories that have similar or face

other theories that have similar or face similar pattern if we take for example

similar pattern if we take for example

similar pattern if we take for example either since the beginning of human

either since the beginning of human

either since the beginning of human thinking either what was proposed as a

thinking either what was proposed as a

thinking either what was proposed as a medium that fills empty space throughout

medium that fills empty space throughout

medium that fills empty space throughout our universe they thought it can be

our universe they thought it can be

our universe they thought it can be vacuum there has to be something that

vacuum there has to be something that

vacuum there has to be something that fills all the empty space in our

fills all the empty space in our

fills all the empty space in our universe and they give it a name and

universe and they give it a name and

universe and they give it a name and they call it either now

they call it either now

they call it either now in the 19th century the view of light as

in the 19th century the view of light as

in the 19th century the view of light as a wave became strong but for that to be

a wave became strong but for that to be

a wave became strong but for that to be supported there was a need for a medium

supported there was a need for a medium

supported there was a need for a medium for the for the light waves to propagate

for the for the light waves to propagate

for the for the light waves to propagate in and this has to be a strange medium

in and this has to be a strange medium

in and this has to be a strange medium it has to be invisible and it has to be

it has to be invisible and it has to be

it has to be invisible and it has to be infinite and it has to be something that

infinite and it has to be something that

infinite and it has to be something that does not interact with physical objects

does not interact with physical objects

does not interact with physical objects so now we’re faced with other dilemmas

so now we’re faced with other dilemmas

so now we’re faced with other dilemmas how can you even imagine such material

how can you even imagine such material

how can you even imagine such material in existence so there was a long debate

in existence so there was a long debate

in existence so there was a long debate throughout history whether either exists

throughout history whether either exists

throughout history whether either exists or not some people said yes it does

or not some people said yes it does

or not some people said yes it does exist some people say no way that’s not

exist some people say no way that’s not

exist some people say no way that’s not possible it’s not realistic well then

possible it’s not realistic well then

possible it’s not realistic well then comes mekansm Mendelson took it upon

comes mekansm Mendelson took it upon

comes mekansm Mendelson took it upon himself once for all to settle this

himself once for all to settle this

himself once for all to settle this debate so he came up with a very clever

debate so he came up with a very clever

debate so he came up with a very clever experiment to measure or detect ether

experiment to measure or detect ether

experiment to measure or detect ether and he tried tirelessly to measure

and he tried tirelessly to measure

and he tried tirelessly to measure either but he couldn’t so at the end he

either but he couldn’t so at the end he

either but he couldn’t so at the end he said well I give up and you know I’m

said well I give up and you know I’m

said well I give up and you know I’m saying that there’s no ether it does not

saying that there’s no ether it does not

saying that there’s no ether it does not exist well then at the same time

exist well then at the same time

exist well then at the same time Lawrence said well just because we

Lawrence said well just because we

Lawrence said well just because we couldn’t measure it it does not mean it

couldn’t measure it it does not mean it

couldn’t measure it it does not mean it doesn’t exist maybe there’s something

doesn’t exist maybe there’s something

doesn’t exist maybe there’s something wrong with the experiment and then he

wrong with the experiment and then he

wrong with the experiment and then he came up with some explanation to justify

came up with some explanation to justify

came up with some explanation to justify why either could not be detected through

why either could not be detected through

why either could not be detected through this specific experiment well most

this specific experiment well most

this specific experiment well most people did not believe that so what what

people did not believe that so what what

people did not believe that so what what most of the scientists decide to is to

most of the scientists decide to is to

most of the scientists decide to is to look for alternatives to how can light

look for alternatives to how can light

look for alternatives to how can light travels without such medium and then

travels without such medium and then

travels without such medium and then comes the troublemaker again and Stein

comes the troublemaker again and Stein

comes the troublemaker again and Stein and he finds a very convincing way using

and he finds a very convincing way using

and he finds a very convincing way using his relativity to explain why Michelson

his relativity to explain why Michelson

his relativity to explain why Michelson could not measure

could not measure

could not measure he also said is not needed now what does

he also said is not needed now what does

he also said is not needed now what does that mean he meant or what he said

that mean he meant or what he said

that mean he meant or what he said guys look you know we’ve been crazy

guys look you know we’ve been crazy

guys look you know we’ve been crazy enough to accept the concept of light

enough to accept the concept of light

enough to accept the concept of light duality so when I just accept that light

duality so when I just accept that light

duality so when I just accept that light just travel in vacuum at constant speed

just travel in vacuum at constant speed

just travel in vacuum at constant speed and this one the speed of light came

and this one the speed of light came

and this one the speed of light came about so he just proposed that another

about so he just proposed that another

about so he just proposed that another solution another crazy solution to the

solution another crazy solution to the

solution another crazy solution to the problem now what does that tell us it

problem now what does that tell us it

problem now what does that tell us it tells us that science is always in

tells us that science is always in

tells us that science is always in progress you know we should not take

progress you know we should not take

progress you know we should not take [Music]

[Music]

[Music] scientific theories for granted

scientific theories for granted

scientific theories for granted you have witness how scientists went

you have witness how scientists went

you have witness how scientists went back and forth between different

back and forth between different

back and forth between different theories throughout history what if what

theories throughout history what if what

theories throughout history what if what if you know new ideas come up what what

if you know new ideas come up what what

if you know new ideas come up what what can we do you know even understand

can we do you know even understand

can we do you know even understand himself when he said that we don’t need

himself when he said that we don’t need

himself when he said that we don’t need to either and this is doing his when we

to either and this is doing his when we

to either and this is doing his when we was working out his special relativity

was working out his special relativity

was working out his special relativity theory later on when he developed his

theory later on when he developed his

theory later on when he developed his generality theory he realized well we

generality theory he realized well we

generality theory he realized well we need something similar to either so even

need something similar to either so even

need something similar to either so even Einstein changed his mind later on about

Einstein changed his mind later on about

Einstein changed his mind later on about some medium that should be in an empty

some medium that should be in an empty

some medium that should be in an empty space so could either be the space-time

space so could either be the space-time

space so could either be the space-time continuum that Einstein talked about

continuum that Einstein talked about

continuum that Einstein talked about could either be dark energy that now

could either be dark energy that now

could either be dark energy that now other people talked about we don’t know

other people talked about we don’t know

other people talked about we don’t know and I hope maybe someday somebody in a

and I hope maybe someday somebody in a

and I hope maybe someday somebody in a TED talk would tell us what either’s all

TED talk would tell us what either’s all

TED talk would tell us what either’s all about

about

about now scientific theories are you know the

now scientific theories are you know the

now scientific theories are you know the best possible or best available

best possible or best available

best possible or best available explanation to things as we know them

explanation to things as we know them

explanation to things as we know them now we should not take them for granted

now we should not take them for granted

now we should not take them for granted sign you know scientific theory

sign you know scientific theory

sign you know scientific theory does not provide absolute truth it’s

does not provide absolute truth it’s

does not provide absolute truth it’s just telling us what we know so far so

just telling us what we know so far so

just telling us what we know so far so and I hope that that that message you

and I hope that that that message you

and I hope that that that message you know gets across to a lot of people

know gets across to a lot of people

know gets across to a lot of people because our people just think just

because our people just think just

because our people just think just because an accepted theory is there we

because an accepted theory is there we

because an accepted theory is there we think it’s that’s the absolute truth

think it’s that’s the absolute truth

think it’s that’s the absolute truth well that’s now that that’s not the case

well that’s now that that’s not the case

well that’s now that that’s not the case now I should also clarify that such that

now I should also clarify that such that

now I should also clarify that such that the term or the expression

the term or the expression

the term or the expression scientifically proven is a contradiction

scientifically proven is a contradiction

scientifically proven is a contradiction in terms

in terms

in terms there is nothing scientifically proven

there is nothing scientifically proven

there is nothing scientifically proven you know what what what we know is

you know what what what we know is

you know what what what we know is basically what you know whatever

basically what you know whatever

basically what you know whatever experiments on toughness but that does

experiments on toughness but that does

experiments on toughness but that does not mean that that’s the absolute truth

not mean that that’s the absolute truth

not mean that that’s the absolute truth now in traditional schools students are

now in traditional schools students are

now in traditional schools students are focusing on learning or understanding

focusing on learning or understanding

focusing on learning or understanding accepted theories it is very rare that

accepted theories it is very rare that

accepted theories it is very rare that students are being taught how to

students are being taught how to

students are being taught how to challenge these theories and models you

challenge these theories and models you

challenge these theories and models you know we should not teach students what

know we should not teach students what

know we should not teach students what to think we should teach them how to

to think we should teach them how to

to think we should teach them how to think and you know when when examining

think and you know when when examining

think and you know when when examining any theory whether it’s physical or

any theory whether it’s physical or

any theory whether it’s physical or biological or chemical theory you should

biological or chemical theory you should

biological or chemical theory you should always consider or question the

always consider or question the

always consider or question the assumptions what were the assumptions

assumptions what were the assumptions

assumptions what were the assumptions when they were discussing this theory

when they were discussing this theory

when they were discussing this theory also you should always question the way

also you should always question the way

also you should always question the way the test was done not only that also the

the test was done not only that also the

the test was done not only that also the way data was collected

way data was collected

way data was collected remember mackelson experiment initially

remember mackelson experiment initially

remember mackelson experiment initially he thought that his experiment proved is

he thought that his experiment proved is

he thought that his experiment proved is still what they turned out it was wrong

still what they turned out it was wrong

still what they turned out it was wrong and this experiment have been repeated

and this experiment have been repeated

and this experiment have been repeated so many times you know he tried in the

so many times you know he tried in the

so many times you know he tried in the mountains he charged in a cave it turned

mountains he charged in a cave it turned

mountains he charged in a cave it turned the desert he tried

the desert he tried

the desert he tried everywhere in different dimensions

everywhere in different dimensions

everywhere in different dimensions different spaces even others not only

different spaces even others not only

different spaces even others not only himself others have tried it just to

himself others have tried it just to

himself others have tried it just to make sure that the test is correct and

make sure that the test is correct and

make sure that the test is correct and this experiment is famous or known to be

this experiment is famous or known to be

this experiment is famous or known to be the most famous failed experiment in

the most famous failed experiment in

the most famous failed experiment in history so even though he failed he

history so even though he failed he

history so even though he failed he still was recognized also we should look

still was recognized also we should look

still was recognized also we should look into or we should always question

into or we should always question

into or we should always question interpretations just like anything else

interpretations just like anything else

interpretations just like anything else observations and data are open to

observations and data are open to

observations and data are open to different interpretations just to give

different interpretations just to give

different interpretations just to give you an example quantum mechanics and

you an example quantum mechanics and

you an example quantum mechanics and quantum against there are ten

quantum against there are ten

quantum against there are ten interpretations from quantum mechanics

interpretations from quantum mechanics

interpretations from quantum mechanics what does that mean well to be frank

what does that mean well to be frank

what does that mean well to be frank with you it means we don’t understand

with you it means we don’t understand

with you it means we don’t understand quantum mechanics otherwise we wouldn’t

quantum mechanics otherwise we wouldn’t

quantum mechanics otherwise we wouldn’t have ten interpretations for quantum

have ten interpretations for quantum

have ten interpretations for quantum mechanics so don’t feel bad if you don’t

mechanics so don’t feel bad if you don’t

mechanics so don’t feel bad if you don’t understand quantum mechanics some of the

understand quantum mechanics some of the

understand quantum mechanics some of the smartest people have said they don’t

smartest people have said they don’t

smartest people have said they don’t understand quantum mechanics I can give

understand quantum mechanics I can give

understand quantum mechanics I can give you an example fireman he’s a Nobel

you an example fireman he’s a Nobel

you an example fireman he’s a Nobel Prize winner in physics and he said it

Prize winner in physics and he said it

Prize winner in physics and he said it he didn’t he does not understand quantum

he didn’t he does not understand quantum

he didn’t he does not understand quantum mechanics duality does exist it’s not

mechanics duality does exist it’s not

mechanics duality does exist it’s not just in our imagination an object such

just in our imagination an object such

just in our imagination an object such as this cylinder this picture can

as this cylinder this picture can

as this cylinder this picture can produce two forms of shadow at the same

produce two forms of shadow at the same

produce two forms of shadow at the same time we can have a circle and a square

time we can have a circle and a square

time we can have a circle and a square and in one setting what does that mean

and in one setting what does that mean

and in one setting what does that mean it means it does exist but there are

it means it does exist but there are

it means it does exist but there are also other alternatives the picture of

also other alternatives the picture of

also other alternatives the picture of particle wave duality does not make me

particle wave duality does not make me

particle wave duality does not make me comfortable and I would like to share

comfortable and I would like to share

comfortable and I would like to share with you an alternative view or

with you an alternative view or

with you an alternative view or alternative theory to which instead of

alternative theory to which instead of

alternative theory to which instead of having a center you know a fake figure

having a center you know a fake figure

having a center you know a fake figure we can have a particle surfing on a wave

we can have a particle surfing on a wave

we can have a particle surfing on a wave and this this deal is known as the pilot

and this this deal is known as the pilot

and this this deal is known as the pilot wave theory which was proposed initially

wave theory which was proposed initially

wave theory which was proposed initially by debroglie in nineteen

by debroglie in nineteen

by debroglie in nineteen twenty-seven and then restart again by

twenty-seven and then restart again by

twenty-seven and then restart again by boom in 1952 what this theory tells us

boom in 1952 what this theory tells us

boom in 1952 what this theory tells us that there is both a real particle and a

that there is both a real particle and a

that there is both a real particle and a real wave but the wave actually

real wave but the wave actually

real wave but the wave actually influenced that how the particle

influenced that how the particle

influenced that how the particle behavior this concept has been recently

behavior this concept has been recently

behavior this concept has been recently demonstrated experimentally by a group

demonstrated experimentally by a group

demonstrated experimentally by a group at MIT and this is a video to show you

at MIT and this is a video to show you

at MIT and this is a video to show you how this happens basically a group at

how this happens basically a group at

how this happens basically a group at MIT managed to produce a droplet that

MIT managed to produce a droplet that

MIT managed to produce a droplet that bounced on a surface of liquid and as as

bounced on a surface of liquid and as as

bounced on a surface of liquid and as as this droplet bounced on that surface it

this droplet bounced on that surface it

this droplet bounced on that surface it creates waves and then they were able to

creates waves and then they were able to

creates waves and then they were able to demonstrate that these waves actually

demonstrate that these waves actually

demonstrate that these waves actually guide their particle as it moves or as

guide their particle as it moves or as

guide their particle as it moves or as it hovers over that that wave so after

it hovers over that that wave so after

it hovers over that that wave so after all you know it is possible to have an

all you know it is possible to have an

all you know it is possible to have an alligator that makes bird sound only if

alligator that makes bird sound only if

alligator that makes bird sound only if we think that the bird is actually just

we think that the bird is actually just

we think that the bird is actually just on top of the alligator it’s now

on top of the alligator it’s now

on top of the alligator it’s now actually have alligator have bird I hope

actually have alligator have bird I hope

actually have alligator have bird I hope I have sparked dance time in you to

I have sparked dance time in you to

I have sparked dance time in you to think about the nature of flight because

think about the nature of flight because

think about the nature of flight because we don’t know what we don’t fully

we don’t know what we don’t fully

we don’t know what we don’t fully understand what light is and maybe one

understand what light is and maybe one

understand what light is and maybe one of you someday will come up with an

of you someday will come up with an

of you someday will come up with an alternative theory to explain the

alternative theory to explain the

alternative theory to explain the behavior of light thank you very much

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *