Press "Enter" to skip to content

Into the Canon: Equity in Classical Music | Steven Banks | TEDxNorthwesternU


so we’re gonna talk about classical

so we’re gonna talk about classical music I thought what better way to start

music I thought what better way to start

music I thought what better way to start them with a little bit of listening so

them with a little bit of listening so

them with a little bit of listening so I’m going to play two pieces for you

I’m going to play two pieces for you

I’m going to play two pieces for you both written in the Classical period now

both written in the Classical period now

both written in the Classical period now listen very closely here’s the first

[Music]

[Music] all right now here’s the second

all right now here’s the second

all right now here’s the second [Music]

great so both of these beautiful violin

great so both of these beautiful violin concerto were composed in the 18th

concerto were composed in the 18th

concerto were composed in the 18th century by classical music composers one

century by classical music composers one

century by classical music composers one was written by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart

was written by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart

was written by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart who is one of the most iconic classical

who is one of the most iconic classical

who is one of the most iconic classical composers in the history of the world

composers in the history of the world

composers in the history of the world the other was written by this man Joseph

the other was written by this man Joseph

the other was written by this man Joseph Boulogne Chevalier the st. George

Boulogne Chevalier the st. George

Boulogne Chevalier the st. George now Joseph bulan was born about ten

now Joseph bulan was born about ten

now Joseph bulan was born about ten years before Mozart in Guadeloupe to a

years before Mozart in Guadeloupe to a

years before Mozart in Guadeloupe to a black slave and her white master he was

black slave and her white master he was

black slave and her white master he was a conductor composer and violinist

a conductor composer and violinist

a conductor composer and violinist during his lifetime he was appointed by

during his lifetime he was appointed by

during his lifetime he was appointed by the King of France to be the conductor

the King of France to be the conductor

the King of France to be the conductor of the prestigious Paris Opera however

of the prestigious Paris Opera however

of the prestigious Paris Opera however he was unfortunately never able to take

he was unfortunately never able to take

he was unfortunately never able to take that post because the members of the

that post because the members of the

that post because the members of the orchestra refused to be conducted by a

orchestra refused to be conducted by a

orchestra refused to be conducted by a mulatto man today approximately

mulatto man today approximately

mulatto man today approximately two-thirds of his works are lost

two-thirds of his works are lost

two-thirds of his works are lost and his work is seldom performed as many

and his work is seldom performed as many

and his work is seldom performed as many young people I spent a lot of my life

young people I spent a lot of my life

young people I spent a lot of my life trying to find a sense of belonging in

trying to find a sense of belonging in

trying to find a sense of belonging in the world and in my field as a musician

the world and in my field as a musician

the world and in my field as a musician myself I spent a lot of time performing

myself I spent a lot of time performing

myself I spent a lot of time performing and practicing and meeting with conduct

and practicing and meeting with conduct

and practicing and meeting with conduct conductors and professors that don’t

conductors and professors that don’t

conductors and professors that don’t look like me about the music of

look like me about the music of

look like me about the music of composers that don’t look like me either

composers that don’t look like me either

composers that don’t look like me either in my everyday endeavors performing and

in my everyday endeavors performing and

in my everyday endeavors performing and having class and my other things outside

having class and my other things outside

having class and my other things outside of school

of school

of school I’m often the only black person in the

I’m often the only black person in the

I’m often the only black person in the room many times I find myself being the

room many times I find myself being the

room many times I find myself being the only person of color at all as you can

only person of color at all as you can

only person of color at all as you can see in this picture you can spot me on

see in this picture you can spot me on

see in this picture you can spot me on the third row this was taken last

the third row this was taken last

the third row this was taken last quarter

quarter

quarter now I don’t say these things to complain

now I don’t say these things to complain

now I don’t say these things to complain that’s simply the state of things as

that’s simply the state of things as

that’s simply the state of things as they are now on the other hand I’ve

they are now on the other hand I’ve

they are now on the other hand I’ve spent a lot of time in high school and

spent a lot of time in high school and

spent a lot of time in high school and college asking myself questions like am

college asking myself questions like am

college asking myself questions like am i black enough

i black enough

i black enough does anyone that looks like me care

does anyone that looks like me care

does anyone that looks like me care about the same things that I do should I

about the same things that I do should I

about the same things that I do should I be spending my life pursuing something

be spending my life pursuing something

be spending my life pursuing something that’s more historically associated with

that’s more historically associated with

that’s more historically associated with black culture how could I not ask myself

black culture how could I not ask myself

black culture how could I not ask myself these things when people in in my high

these things when people in in my high

these things when people in in my high schools and in college have called me an

schools and in college have called me an

schools and in college have called me an Oreo because they thought that I was

Oreo because they thought that I was

Oreo because they thought that I was black on the outside yet somehow my

black on the outside yet somehow my

black on the outside yet somehow my interest made me white on the inside I

interest made me white on the inside I

interest made me white on the inside I don’t get it either I felt that I was

don’t get it either I felt that I was

don’t get it either I felt that I was spending my life pursuing an art that

spending my life pursuing an art that

spending my life pursuing an art that simply wasn’t meant for me however since

simply wasn’t meant for me however since

simply wasn’t meant for me however since this time I’ve come a long way to

this time I’ve come a long way to

this time I’ve come a long way to realize that the contributions of

realize that the contributions of

realize that the contributions of minorities and and women in the arts

minorities and and women in the arts

minorities and and women in the arts have been going on since the 18th

have been going on since the 18th

have been going on since the 18th century and and before now this brought

century and and before now this brought

century and and before now this brought me to a very common place where

me to a very common place where

me to a very common place where minorities often occupy seeing that

minorities often occupy seeing that

minorities often occupy seeing that people of their background have been

people of their background have been

people of their background have been doing amazing things in the field and

doing amazing things in the field and

doing amazing things in the field and contributing to our society yet they

contributing to our society yet they

contributing to our society yet they asked themselves questions like why

asked themselves questions like why

asked themselves questions like why didn’t I know about this why didn’t I

didn’t I know about this why didn’t I

didn’t I know about this why didn’t I learn about this in school the work of

learn about this in school the work of

learn about this in school the work of people of color has been marginalized as

people of color has been marginalized as

people of color has been marginalized as a side note if it’s mentioned at all in

a side note if it’s mentioned at all in

a side note if it’s mentioned at all in my 14 years of classical music study I

my 14 years of classical music study I

my 14 years of classical music study I have played three pieces by black

have played three pieces by black

have played three pieces by black composers one of which was by myself

this is a real problem and I think that

this is a real problem and I think that needs to be addressed when I first

needs to be addressed when I first

needs to be addressed when I first started getting interested in diversity

started getting interested in diversity

started getting interested in diversity inclusion in classical music I did what

inclusion in classical music I did what

inclusion in classical music I did what anyone else would do and started doing a

anyone else would do and started doing a

anyone else would do and started doing a lot of research I talked to my mentors

lot of research I talked to my mentors

lot of research I talked to my mentors colleagues professors went online did

colleagues professors went online did

colleagues professors went online did Google searches and because I was

Google searches and because I was

Google searches and because I was looking for what work was already being

looking for what work was already being

looking for what work was already being done in the field and to my surprise I

done in the field and to my surprise I

done in the field and to my surprise I actually found that there are a lot of

actually found that there are a lot of

actually found that there are a lot of initiatives that are trying to address

initiatives that are trying to address

initiatives that are trying to address this issue of diversity in classical

this issue of diversity in classical

this issue of diversity in classical music upon finding all of these

music upon finding all of these

music upon finding all of these different organizations that are out

different organizations that are out

different organizations that are out there I thought to myself how is it that

there I thought to myself how is it that

there I thought to myself how is it that I can’t name five black composers after

I can’t name five black composers after

I can’t name five black composers after going to some of the finest classical

going to some of the finest classical

going to some of the finest classical music institutions in the country in the

music institutions in the country in the

music institutions in the country in the University of North Carolina School of

University of North Carolina School of

University of North Carolina School of the Arts

the Arts

the Arts Indiana University Jacobs School of

Indiana University Jacobs School of

Indiana University Jacobs School of Music in Northwestern University

Music in Northwestern University

Music in Northwestern University something clearly was not working it’s

something clearly was not working it’s

something clearly was not working it’s very interesting when in moving forward

very interesting when in moving forward

very interesting when in moving forward with this I thought to myself not only

with this I thought to myself not only

with this I thought to myself not only are they are the problems within these

are they are the problems within these

are they are the problems within these schools the problems are in the

schools the problems are in the

schools the problems are in the professional scene as well if you look

professional scene as well if you look

professional scene as well if you look at the orchestras around the country

at the orchestras around the country

at the orchestras around the country four percent of performers in the top 25

four percent of performers in the top 25

four percent of performers in the top 25 orchestras are black or Latino combined

orchestras are black or Latino combined

orchestras are black or Latino combined zero percent statistically speaking of

zero percent statistically speaking of

zero percent statistically speaking of pieces performed were by any composer of

pieces performed were by any composer of

pieces performed were by any composer of color at all zero percent now I’m not

color at all zero percent now I’m not

color at all zero percent now I’m not saying that there were zero pieces

saying that there were zero pieces

saying that there were zero pieces performed by these major orchestras

performed by these major orchestras

performed by these major orchestras however the fact that the number is less

however the fact that the number is less

however the fact that the number is less than 0.5% of all the pieces is startling

than 0.5% of all the pieces is startling

than 0.5% of all the pieces is startling within itself and if you look at the

within itself and if you look at the

within itself and if you look at the conservatories around the world in the

conservatories around the world in the

conservatories around the world in the country you’ll see that the faculty

country you’ll see that the faculty

country you’ll see that the faculty students and administration simply do

students and administration simply do

students and administration simply do not represent the diverse world in which

not represent the diverse world in which

not represent the diverse world in which we live

we live

we live now I could give you single-digit

now I could give you single-digit

now I could give you single-digit statistics all day to explain how much

statistics all day to explain how much

statistics all day to explain how much this is an issue some of them might be

this is an issue some of them might be

this is an issue some of them might be two digits because there’s a decimal

two digits because there’s a decimal

two digits because there’s a decimal place but I think from here we need to

place but I think from here we need to

place but I think from here we need to move forward I had a conversation with

move forward I had a conversation with

move forward I had a conversation with Aaron Dworkin who is the Dean of the

Aaron Dworkin who is the Dean of the

Aaron Dworkin who is the Dean of the University of Michigan School of Music

University of Michigan School of Music

University of Michigan School of Music Theatre and dance and one of the most

Theatre and dance and one of the most

Theatre and dance and one of the most amazing advocates for diversity and

amazing advocates for diversity and

amazing advocates for diversity and inclusion in the performing arts and he

inclusion in the performing arts and he

inclusion in the performing arts and he told me something very interesting that

told me something very interesting that

told me something very interesting that has stuck with me ever since

has stuck with me ever since

has stuck with me ever since he said that in dealing with these

he said that in dealing with these

he said that in dealing with these issues of diversity many times it’s not

issues of diversity many times it’s not

issues of diversity many times it’s not difficult to address to address them

difficult to address to address them

difficult to address to address them they simply require that you think about

they simply require that you think about

they simply require that you think about them at all for example at the

them at all for example at the

them at all for example at the University of Michigan they’ve started

University of Michigan they’ve started

University of Michigan they’ve started recently an international chamber music

recently an international chamber music

recently an international chamber music competition called the M prize

competition called the M prize

competition called the M prize now the M prize is amazing in a lot of

now the M prize is amazing in a lot of

now the M prize is amazing in a lot of different ways it has some of the

different ways it has some of the

different ways it has some of the largest cash prizes I’ve ever seen there

largest cash prizes I’ve ever seen there

largest cash prizes I’ve ever seen there are there is phenomenal and media

are there is phenomenal and media

are there is phenomenal and media coverage for all the ensembles that

coverage for all the ensembles that

coverage for all the ensembles that participate and the ensembles get to

participate and the ensembles get to

participate and the ensembles get to collaborate with each other and it’s

collaborate with each other and it’s

collaborate with each other and it’s simply amazing however the most

simply amazing however the most

simply amazing however the most important thing to me about the Emprise

important thing to me about the Emprise

important thing to me about the Emprise competition is that if you look at the

competition is that if you look at the

competition is that if you look at the panel of judges and the board members

panel of judges and the board members

panel of judges and the board members you’ll find an extreme amount of

you’ll find an extreme amount of

you’ll find an extreme amount of diversity there are female musicians

diversity there are female musicians

diversity there are female musicians representatives black musicians Asian

representatives black musicians Asian

representatives black musicians Asian musicians Latino musicians now in doing

musicians Latino musicians now in doing

musicians Latino musicians now in doing this he did not have to sacrifice

this he did not have to sacrifice

this he did not have to sacrifice artistic excellence for the sake for the

artistic excellence for the sake for the

artistic excellence for the sake for the sake of diversity in fact the Emprise

sake of diversity in fact the Emprise

sake of diversity in fact the Emprise competition is now one of the most

competition is now one of the most

competition is now one of the most prestigious in the entire world he

prestigious in the entire world he

prestigious in the entire world he simply had to think about it at all here

simply had to think about it at all here

simply had to think about it at all here at Northwestern we are also making a few

at Northwestern we are also making a few

at Northwestern we are also making a few changes in speaking with a lot of my

changes in speaking with a lot of my

changes in speaking with a lot of my friends in the beena School of Music and

friends in the beena School of Music and

friends in the beena School of Music and colleagues I started a petition among

colleagues I started a petition among

colleagues I started a petition among students to show our administration that

students to show our administration that

students to show our administration that this is a serious issue that is a

this is a serious issue that is a

this is a serious issue that is a concern of the students now we’re not

concern of the students now we’re not

concern of the students now we’re not asking that anyone reinvent the wheel

asking that anyone reinvent the wheel

asking that anyone reinvent the wheel we’re not asking that anyone throw away

we’re not asking that anyone throw away

we’re not asking that anyone throw away what we already have we’re simply asking

what we already have we’re simply asking

what we already have we’re simply asking that the contributions of all people are

that the contributions of all people are

that the contributions of all people are considered in our music theory music

considered in our music theory music

considered in our music theory music history and oral skills curriculums now

history and oral skills curriculums now

history and oral skills curriculums now these are not difficult issues to

these are not difficult issues to

these are not difficult issues to address as Dorkin said some concrete

address as Dorkin said some concrete

address as Dorkin said some concrete things that we can do are simply adding

things that we can do are simply adding

things that we can do are simply adding sample materials by diverse composers by

sample materials by diverse composers by

sample materials by diverse composers by female composers into our everyday class

female composers into our everyday class

female composers into our everyday class classroom activities another thing that

classroom activities another thing that

classroom activities another thing that we could do is simply by when we are

we could do is simply by when we are

we could do is simply by when we are introducing a major work play a piece

introducing a major work play a piece

introducing a major work play a piece that has been recorded by a diverse

that has been recorded by a diverse

that has been recorded by a diverse musician this will allow the students to

musician this will allow the students to

musician this will allow the students to have a much more wide-ranging education

have a much more wide-ranging education

have a much more wide-ranging education and I think that this is a model that’s

and I think that this is a model that’s

and I think that this is a model that’s that’s conservatories all around the

that’s conservatories all around the

that’s conservatories all around the world can follow very easily now I know

world can follow very easily now I know

world can follow very easily now I know that there is definitely no quick fix

that there is definitely no quick fix

that there is definitely no quick fix for this issue however there are a few

for this issue however there are a few

for this issue however there are a few succinct things that I think are very

succinct things that I think are very

succinct things that I think are very important when we’re starting

important when we’re starting

important when we’re starting initiatives to combat diversity and

initiatives to combat diversity and

initiatives to combat diversity and inclusion firstly I think that all of

inclusion firstly I think that all of

inclusion firstly I think that all of these initiatives need to be thought of

these initiatives need to be thought of

these initiatives need to be thought of as top-down what I mean by that is that

as top-down what I mean by that is that

as top-down what I mean by that is that the nation’s best music schools the

the nation’s best music schools the

the nation’s best music schools the nation’s best orchestras wind ensembles

nation’s best orchestras wind ensembles

nation’s best orchestras wind ensembles chamber ensembles and soloists need to

chamber ensembles and soloists need to

chamber ensembles and soloists need to take it upon themselves and realize that

take it upon themselves and realize that

take it upon themselves and realize that they are the trendsetters in this field

they are the trendsetters in this field

they are the trendsetters in this field what they do other people will follow

what they do other people will follow

what they do other people will follow who they Commission for new works other

who they Commission for new works other

who they Commission for new works other people will Commission second we need to

people will Commission second we need to

people will Commission second we need to ensure that our initiatives are

ensure that our initiatives are

ensure that our initiatives are inherently inclusive and not more

inherently inclusive and not more

inherently inclusive and not more divisive many times there will be a

divisive many times there will be a

divisive many times there will be a black or Latino only orchestra that only

black or Latino only orchestra that only

black or Latino only orchestra that only plays the music of black or Latino

plays the music of black or Latino

plays the music of black or Latino musician of composers and there are also

musician of composers and there are also

musician of composers and there are also lots of initiatives where there are

lots of initiatives where there are

lots of initiatives where there are musicians that go into inner-city

musicians that go into inner-city

musicians that go into inner-city schools and they perform classical music

schools and they perform classical music

schools and they perform classical music for the students there and this is great

for the students there and this is great

for the students there and this is great however what they don’t realize is that

however what they don’t realize is that

however what they don’t realize is that these children are seeing people that

these children are seeing people that

these children are seeing people that don’t look like them coming into their

don’t look like them coming into their

don’t look like them coming into their school playing music of people that they

school playing music of people that they

school playing music of people that they can’t relate to they need to be hearing

can’t relate to they need to be hearing

can’t relate to they need to be hearing about people like Joseph boulogne

about people like Joseph boulogne

about people like Joseph boulogne because I can tell you from personal

because I can tell you from personal

because I can tell you from personal experience that learning about the

experience that learning about the

experience that learning about the contributions of people like you at such

contributions of people like you at such

contributions of people like you at such a high level it’s so empowering and

a high level it’s so empowering and

a high level it’s so empowering and gives you the confidence to know that

gives you the confidence to know that

gives you the confidence to know that your form of expression can also be

your form of expression can also be

your form of expression can also be appreciated third within our each of our

appreciated third within our each of our

appreciated third within our each of our minority groups we must value the people

minority groups we must value the people

minority groups we must value the people that have come before us and teach our

that have come before us and teach our

that have come before us and teach our children that they can truly do whatever

children that they can truly do whatever

children that they can truly do whatever they put their mind to when I was a boy

they put their mind to when I was a boy

they put their mind to when I was a boy I learned about people like Jackie

I learned about people like Jackie

I learned about people like Jackie Robinson Harriet Tubman George

Robinson Harriet Tubman George

Robinson Harriet Tubman George Washington Carver because they were

Washington Carver because they were

Washington Carver because they were people that I could look up to that have

people that I could look up to that have

people that I could look up to that have made major contributions to the world

made major contributions to the world

made major contributions to the world and are also black however I hope that

and are also black however I hope that

and are also black however I hope that the next generation can also learn about

the next generation can also learn about

the next generation can also learn about people like Sanford Allen who was the

people like Sanford Allen who was the

people like Sanford Allen who was the first black musician to ever enter the

first black musician to ever enter the

first black musician to ever enter the New York Philharmonic or people like

New York Philharmonic or people like

New York Philharmonic or people like Florence price who was the first black

Florence price who was the first black

Florence price who was the first black woman to have a piece performed by a

woman to have a piece performed by a

woman to have a piece performed by a major orchestra in the Chicago Symphony

finding out about people like this is

finding out about people like this is what’s truly going to create diversity

what’s truly going to create diversity

what’s truly going to create diversity in the field that we love so much now I

in the field that we love so much now I

in the field that we love so much now I realize that today I’ve focused a lot on

realize that today I’ve focused a lot on

realize that today I’ve focused a lot on black musicians and that’s simply

black musicians and that’s simply

black musicians and that’s simply because that’s my experience

because that’s my experience

because that’s my experience however in dealing with the petition

however in dealing with the petition

however in dealing with the petition I’ve realized that so many other of my

I’ve realized that so many other of my

I’ve realized that so many other of my colleagues feel the exact same way there

colleagues feel the exact same way there

colleagues feel the exact same way there are so many people that feel like the

are so many people that feel like the

are so many people that feel like the work of people of their background has

work of people of their background has

work of people of their background has been marginalized and pushed

been marginalized and pushed

been marginalized and pushed aside it’s time that we realized that

aside it’s time that we realized that

aside it’s time that we realized that the oppression of one of us is truly the

the oppression of one of us is truly the

the oppression of one of us is truly the oppression of us all we must fight for

oppression of us all we must fight for

oppression of us all we must fight for ourselves but we must also fight for our

ourselves but we must also fight for our

ourselves but we must also fight for our neighbors it’s time that we truly bring

neighbors it’s time that we truly bring

neighbors it’s time that we truly bring the contributions of minorities and

the contributions of minorities and

the contributions of minorities and women into the Canon of classical music

women into the Canon of classical music

women into the Canon of classical music now I’d like to close today just by

now I’d like to close today just by

now I’d like to close today just by performing a short little excerpt of a

performing a short little excerpt of a

performing a short little excerpt of a piece by William Grant still with one of

piece by William Grant still with one of

piece by William Grant still with one of my good friends in the School of Music

my good friends in the School of Music

my good friends in the School of Music and fellow musician Karen Zane thank you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *