Press "Enter" to skip to content

How to Win an Argument Online | Jake Wilhelm | TEDxBOVSchool


[Applause]

[Applause] modern technology has ushered in a new

modern technology has ushered in a new

modern technology has ushered in a new cultural citizenship test that needs to

cultural citizenship test that needs to

cultural citizenship test that needs to be passed in order to be accepted in the

be passed in order to be accepted in the

be passed in order to be accepted in the 21st century world the participation in

21st century world the participation in

21st century world the participation in social media I remember the first time I

social media I remember the first time I

social media I remember the first time I logged in and created my Facebook

logged in and created my Facebook

logged in and created my Facebook account it was the day after I graduated

account it was the day after I graduated

account it was the day after I graduated high school and by the end of the week

high school and by the end of the week

high school and by the end of the week my feeling of acceptance skyrocketed as

my feeling of acceptance skyrocketed as

my feeling of acceptance skyrocketed as I already had 50 friends and over the

I already had 50 friends and over the

I already had 50 friends and over the course of the next few years I started

course of the next few years I started

course of the next few years I started to discover the dark side of social

to discover the dark side of social

to discover the dark side of social media the social media argument now

media the social media argument now

media the social media argument now whether or not we have seen this or

whether or not we have seen this or

whether or not we have seen this or participated in it we have all felt the

participated in it we have all felt the

participated in it we have all felt the emotion that goes along with it that the

emotion that goes along with it that the

emotion that goes along with it that the anger the rage the jealousy all aimed at

anger the rage the jealousy all aimed at

anger the rage the jealousy all aimed at somebody on the computer screen the

somebody on the computer screen the

somebody on the computer screen the nature of social media itself openly

nature of social media itself openly

nature of social media itself openly drives its users to conflict because as

drives its users to conflict because as

drives its users to conflict because as Facebook says users can express what

Facebook says users can express what

Facebook says users can express what matters to them now there will be ideas

matters to them now there will be ideas

matters to them now there will be ideas that come into conflict with one another

that come into conflict with one another

that come into conflict with one another and human history that’s nothing new

and human history that’s nothing new

and human history that’s nothing new differences of ideas usually drive to

differences of ideas usually drive to

differences of ideas usually drive to conflict but what’s different about the

conflict but what’s different about the

conflict but what’s different about the social media online presence is a

social media online presence is a

social media online presence is a significant degree of anonymity let’s

significant degree of anonymity let’s

significant degree of anonymity let’s take a look at how this works in a

take a look at how this works in a

take a look at how this works in a social media argument probably the most

social media argument probably the most

social media argument probably the most crucial one we’re going to deal with

crucial one we’re going to deal with

crucial one we’re going to deal with today most crucial debate ever is Harry

today most crucial debate ever is Harry

today most crucial debate ever is Harry Potter greater than Voldemort

Potter greater than Voldemort

Potter greater than Voldemort now these two individuals they’re going

now these two individuals they’re going

now these two individuals they’re going at it and they have multiple posts

at it and they have multiple posts

at it and they have multiple posts eventually they do come to the degree to

eventually they do come to the degree to

eventually they do come to the degree to be this discussion they don’t solve the

be this discussion they don’t solve the

be this discussion they don’t solve the issue for us however they do come to the

issue for us however they do come to the

issue for us however they do come to the conclusion that Death Eaters are better

conclusion that Death Eaters are better

conclusion that Death Eaters are better than Hagrid because they have tattoos

than Hagrid because they have tattoos

than Hagrid because they have tattoos now when it comes to the social media

now when it comes to the social media

now when it comes to the social media argument the goal is not to come to an

argument the goal is not to come to an

argument the goal is not to come to an agreeable conclusion but rather to have

agreeable conclusion but rather to have

agreeable conclusion but rather to have your voice be heard let’s look at him

your voice be heard let’s look at him

your voice be heard let’s look at him one more serious in nature this was a

one more serious in nature this was a

one more serious in nature this was a history article post on Facebook by the

history article post on Facebook by the

history article post on Facebook by the History Channel

History Channel

History Channel celebrating the anniversary of the USS

celebrating the anniversary of the USS

celebrating the anniversary of the USS Maine explosion in 1898 although in 1898

Maine explosion in 1898 although in 1898

Maine explosion in 1898 although in 1898 it was believed to be sabotage by Spain

it was believed to be sabotage by Spain

it was believed to be sabotage by Spain an investigation in 1976 discovered that

an investigation in 1976 discovered that

an investigation in 1976 discovered that it was most likely an internal fire that

it was most likely an internal fire that

it was most likely an internal fire that caused the ammunition to explode now

caused the ammunition to explode now

caused the ammunition to explode now let’s look at some of the comments

let’s look at some of the comments

let’s look at some of the comments our original poster of Jason here he’s

our original poster of Jason here he’s

our original poster of Jason here he’s not upset over the History Channel

not upset over the History Channel

not upset over the History Channel article but rather their use of likely

article but rather their use of likely

article but rather their use of likely in their description and so thus ensues

in their description and so thus ensues

in their description and so thus ensues the debate Mallory comes on the scene

the debate Mallory comes on the scene

the debate Mallory comes on the scene here and she very clearly denotes that

here and she very clearly denotes that

here and she very clearly denotes that likely does not mean definitive and she

likely does not mean definitive and she

likely does not mean definitive and she also backs it up with a personal attack

also backs it up with a personal attack

also backs it up with a personal attack against Jason a tactic that is very

against Jason a tactic that is very

against Jason a tactic that is very commonly used in Facebook and other

commonly used in Facebook and other

commonly used in Facebook and other social media arguments Brennan joins

social media arguments Brennan joins

social media arguments Brennan joins Mallory’s team in attacking Jason and

Mallory’s team in attacking Jason and

Mallory’s team in attacking Jason and calling on him to quote swim with the

calling on him to quote swim with the

calling on him to quote swim with the crocodiles furthermore the argument goes

crocodiles furthermore the argument goes

crocodiles furthermore the argument goes on and Mallory helps us out by giving us

on and Mallory helps us out by giving us

on and Mallory helps us out by giving us some definition something that is always

some definition something that is always

some definition something that is always helpful in a social media argument and

helpful in a social media argument and

helpful in a social media argument and eventually we reach the breaking point

eventually we reach the breaking point

eventually we reach the breaking point of every online argument as our original

of every online argument as our original

of every online argument as our original poster Jason and Mallory devolved into

poster Jason and Mallory devolved into

poster Jason and Mallory devolved into personal attacks eventually leading to

personal attacks eventually leading to

personal attacks eventually leading to Mallory telling Jason and giving him

Mallory telling Jason and giving him

Mallory telling Jason and giving him advice of how to be promoted from being

advice of how to be promoted from being

advice of how to be promoted from being a fry cook at McDonald’s now where did

a fry cook at McDonald’s now where did

a fry cook at McDonald’s now where did these and so many other social media

these and so many other social media

these and so many other social media arguments go wrong well there’s three

arguments go wrong well there’s three

arguments go wrong well there’s three main reasons why often online your

main reasons why often online your

main reasons why often online your disagreements do not come to an

disagreements do not come to an

disagreements do not come to an agreeable conclusion but rather

agreeable conclusion but rather

agreeable conclusion but rather developing as these cases did with

developing as these cases did with

developing as these cases did with name-calling

name-calling

name-calling the first main reason why your online

the first main reason why your online

the first main reason why your online arguments fail is the first beast

arguments fail is the first beast

arguments fail is the first beast difficut use of logical fallacies we’ve

difficut use of logical fallacies we’ve

difficut use of logical fallacies we’ve already seen how this works with our

already seen how this works with our

already seen how this works with our example the first one was ad hominem

example the first one was ad hominem

example the first one was ad hominem which essentially means of reverting to

which essentially means of reverting to

which essentially means of reverting to attacking your opponent the established

attacking your opponent the established

attacking your opponent the established rules of rhetoric do not apply to the

rules of rhetoric do not apply to the

rules of rhetoric do not apply to the online world the second main reason is

online world the second main reason is

online world the second main reason is you can’t see your person’s faith you

you can’t see your person’s faith you

you can’t see your person’s faith you can’t see your opponent’s face the chief

can’t see your opponent’s face the chief

can’t see your opponent’s face the chief contributor to negative online

contributor to negative online

contributor to negative online interactions studies have shown is the

interactions studies have shown is the

interactions studies have shown is the lack of eye contact when you’re talking

lack of eye contact when you’re talking

lack of eye contact when you’re talking face-to-face with a person you see those

face-to-face with a person you see those

face-to-face with a person you see those nonverbal cues and you naturally pick up

nonverbal cues and you naturally pick up

nonverbal cues and you naturally pick up on them in real life online that just

on them in real life online that just

on them in real life online that just doesn’t happen the last reason is online

doesn’t happen the last reason is online

doesn’t happen the last reason is online arguments are in the public’s view now

arguments are in the public’s view now

arguments are in the public’s view now we don’t have to think about this but

we don’t have to think about this but

we don’t have to think about this but your conversation on Facebook or other

your conversation on Facebook or other

your conversation on Facebook or other social media outlets is not in person it

social media outlets is not in person it

social media outlets is not in person it the world can see it

the world can see it

the world can see it other people can can see what you’re

other people can can see what you’re

other people can can see what you’re saying and so when it comes to your

saying and so when it comes to your

saying and so when it comes to your social media argument you’re more apt to

social media argument you’re more apt to

social media argument you’re more apt to defend yourself and you’re more apt to

defend yourself and you’re more apt to

defend yourself and you’re more apt to show to yourself and to those around you

show to yourself and to those around you

show to yourself and to those around you that you’re intelligent and so you’ll

that you’re intelligent and so you’ll

that you’re intelligent and so you’ll try harder to prove your point so with

try harder to prove your point so with

try harder to prove your point so with all these problems what do social media

all these problems what do social media

all these problems what do social media arguments actually accomplish well

arguments actually accomplish well

arguments actually accomplish well according to multiple studies not very

according to multiple studies not very

according to multiple studies not very much when it comes to studies we have a

much when it comes to studies we have a

much when it comes to studies we have a Cornell University study which they use

Cornell University study which they use

Cornell University study which they use the the subreddit changed my mind and

the the subreddit changed my mind and

the the subreddit changed my mind and over the course of the next two and a

over the course of the next two and a

over the course of the next two and a half years they had over 18,000 threads

half years they had over 18,000 threads

half years they had over 18,000 threads in which users would post on any

in which users would post on any

in which users would post on any particular topic and the internet would

particular topic and the internet would

particular topic and the internet would try and change their mind what they

try and change their mind what they

try and change their mind what they concluded they gathered the data and

concluded they gathered the data and

concluded they gathered the data and they concluded that in only 30 percent

they concluded that in only 30 percent

they concluded that in only 30 percent of the conversations online was the

of the conversations online was the

of the conversations online was the original poster only slightly persuaded

original poster only slightly persuaded

original poster only slightly persuaded this artificial environment

this artificial environment

this artificial environment you only have a 30 percent persuasion

you only have a 30 percent persuasion

you only have a 30 percent persuasion rate chances are in a real life online

rate chances are in a real life online

rate chances are in a real life online Congress a

Congress a

Congress a on topics that people actually actually

on topics that people actually actually

on topics that people actually actually care about this number is going to be

care about this number is going to be

care about this number is going to be significantly less furthermore what they

significantly less furthermore what they

significantly less furthermore what they concluded is that your online argument

concluded is that your online argument

concluded is that your online argument after five posts only a after five post

after five posts only a after five post

after five posts only a after five post your online argument your chances of

your online argument your chances of

your online argument your chances of persuasion are virtually impossible so

persuasion are virtually impossible so

persuasion are virtually impossible so what this means best-case scenario you

what this means best-case scenario you

what this means best-case scenario you have a one in three chance to persuade

have a one in three chance to persuade

have a one in three chance to persuade your opponent and you have to do it in

your opponent and you have to do it in

your opponent and you have to do it in less than five posts and so when it

less than five posts and so when it

less than five posts and so when it comes to your online argument chances

comes to your online argument chances

comes to your online argument chances are it’s going to be unsuccessful now

are it’s going to be unsuccessful now

are it’s going to be unsuccessful now there has been one thing that online

there has been one thing that online

there has been one thing that online arguments have been known to be a

arguments have been known to be a

arguments have been known to be a successful in emotional stress and

successful in emotional stress and

successful in emotional stress and fatigue multiple psychologists have come

fatigue multiple psychologists have come

fatigue multiple psychologists have come and said including John Sewell ur an art

and said including John Sewell ur an art

and said including John Sewell ur an art Markman of the University of Texas

Markman of the University of Texas

Markman of the University of Texas Austin have come and they have said that

Austin have come and they have said that

Austin have come and they have said that those nonverbal cues that we pick up on

those nonverbal cues that we pick up on

those nonverbal cues that we pick up on in everyday life we can’t do that online

in everyday life we can’t do that online

in everyday life we can’t do that online because we’re looking at a computer

because we’re looking at a computer

because we’re looking at a computer screen and so what this does is it

screen and so what this does is it

screen and so what this does is it enables the online argument to become

enables the online argument to become

enables the online argument to become emotionally charged faster than

emotionally charged faster than

emotionally charged faster than face-to-face John’s really would go on

face-to-face John’s really would go on

face-to-face John’s really would go on to note that online you have the chance

to note that online you have the chance

to note that online you have the chance to research your article your argument

to research your article your argument

to research your article your argument you have the chance to rewrite it

you have the chance to rewrite it

you have the chance to rewrite it possibly find a picture of your opponent

possibly find a picture of your opponent

possibly find a picture of your opponent and to face it and thus because of those

and to face it and thus because of those

and to face it and thus because of those reasons your arguments become

reasons your arguments become

reasons your arguments become emotionally charged faster online than

emotionally charged faster online than

emotionally charged faster online than in face-to-face and so when it comes to

in face-to-face and so when it comes to

in face-to-face and so when it comes to the internet it is an amazing tool we

the internet it is an amazing tool we

the internet it is an amazing tool we have had more social interaction with

have had more social interaction with

have had more social interaction with those we know and those we don’t than

those we know and those we don’t than

those we know and those we don’t than ever before the Internet is amazing tool

ever before the Internet is amazing tool

ever before the Internet is amazing tool we have a massive amount of information

we have a massive amount of information

we have a massive amount of information however when it comes to online

however when it comes to online

however when it comes to online arguments and quarrels we have a better

arguments and quarrels we have a better

arguments and quarrels we have a better tool face-to-face interaction sitting

tool face-to-face interaction sitting

tool face-to-face interaction sitting with a person getting a cup of coffee

with a person getting a cup of coffee

with a person getting a cup of coffee sitting across the table and having a

sitting across the table and having a

sitting across the table and having a real conversation

real conversation

real conversation that’s where arguments will be concluded

that’s where arguments will be concluded

that’s where arguments will be concluded in an agreeable fashion and so when I

in an agreeable fashion and so when I

in an agreeable fashion and so when I joined social media all those years ago

joined social media all those years ago

joined social media all those years ago I entered into a brand new world that in

I entered into a brand new world that in

I entered into a brand new world that in which I could be a part of but what I

which I could be a part of but what I

which I could be a part of but what I did see where its limits online

did see where its limits online

did see where its limits online argumentation is unsuccessful and so

argumentation is unsuccessful and so

argumentation is unsuccessful and so let’s return to civility let’s return to

let’s return to civility let’s return to

let’s return to civility let’s return to personhood in our arguments not by

personhood in our arguments not by

personhood in our arguments not by looking to the computer screen to make a

looking to the computer screen to make a

looking to the computer screen to make a change but rather looking to the face of

change but rather looking to the face of

change but rather looking to the face of a human person thank you

a human person thank you

a human person thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *