Press "Enter" to skip to content

What bird food teaches us about pain | Dr. Thomas Taylor-Clark | TEDxCarrollwoodDaySchool


good morning everyone I’m really happy

good morning everyone I’m really happy to be here like my introduction said my

to be here like my introduction said my

to be here like my introduction said my name is dr. Tom Taylor Clark and I want

name is dr. Tom Taylor Clark and I want

name is dr. Tom Taylor Clark and I want to tell you a story about how squirrels

to tell you a story about how squirrels

to tell you a story about how squirrels and chili and birds taught us something

and chili and birds taught us something

and chili and birds taught us something about pain but first let’s start off

about pain but first let’s start off

about pain but first let’s start off with something really simple

with something really simple

with something really simple how many senses do humans have anyone

how many senses do humans have anyone

how many senses do humans have anyone want to say okay there how many senses

want to say okay there how many senses

want to say okay there how many senses do we have I’m sorry five good that’s

do we have I’m sorry five good that’s

do we have I’m sorry five good that’s what we teach our children and that’s

what we teach our children and that’s

what we teach our children and that’s all well and good but of course what we

all well and good but of course what we

all well and good but of course what we teach our children is rarely the whole

teach our children is rarely the whole

teach our children is rarely the whole truth and so actually scientists have

truth and so actually scientists have

truth and so actually scientists have worked out the humans have many more

worked out the humans have many more

worked out the humans have many more senses than just five we’re all familiar

senses than just five we’re all familiar

senses than just five we’re all familiar with sight and hearing taste touch and

with sight and hearing taste touch and

with sight and hearing taste touch and smell however you all have other senses

smell however you all have other senses

smell however you all have other senses an example of a sense that is not

an example of a sense that is not

an example of a sense that is not described by those five senses as a

described by those five senses as a

described by those five senses as a sense of balance or a sense of

sense of balance or a sense of

sense of balance or a sense of temperature you know when something is

temperature you know when something is

temperature you know when something is cold or it’s warm this is another sense

cold or it’s warm this is another sense

cold or it’s warm this is another sense a great sense and an example that we can

a great sense and an example that we can

a great sense and an example that we can all do now if we all do an experiment is

all do now if we all do an experiment is

all do now if we all do an experiment is something a sense called proprioception

something a sense called proprioception

something a sense called proprioception and this allows us to know where our

and this allows us to know where our

and this allows us to know where our joints are now this is a test that maybe

joints are now this is a test that maybe

joints are now this is a test that maybe some of the adults in the audience of

some of the adults in the audience of

some of the adults in the audience of done before where you close your eye and

done before where you close your eye and

done before where you close your eye and with your hand out you can touch the tip

with your hand out you can touch the tip

with your hand out you can touch the tip of your nose now how can you do that if

of your nose now how can you do that if

of your nose now how can you do that if you can’t see your finger well you can

you can’t see your finger well you can

you can’t see your finger well you can do that because you sense through

do that because you sense through

do that because you sense through sensors in your joints and your muscles

sensors in your joints and your muscles

sensors in your joints and your muscles and your skin where your bones are and

and your skin where your bones are and

and your skin where your bones are and therefore you can direct your limbs in

therefore you can direct your limbs in

therefore you can direct your limbs in the correct direction this is obviously

the correct direction this is obviously

the correct direction this is obviously critically important for running or

critically important for running or

critically important for running or catching or spearing a Tyrannosaurus Rex

catching or spearing a Tyrannosaurus Rex

catching or spearing a Tyrannosaurus Rex back in the day so we have all these new

back in the day so we have all these new

back in the day so we have all these new senses I want to talk to you about a

senses I want to talk to you about a

senses I want to talk to you about a sense of pain a sense of damage we’re

sense of pain a sense of damage we’re

sense of pain a sense of damage we’re all familiar when we do something wrong

all familiar when we do something wrong

all familiar when we do something wrong for our body we stub our toe or we touch

for our body we stub our toe or we touch

for our body we stub our toe or we touch a hot stove and what does it feel like

a hot stove and what does it feel like

a hot stove and what does it feel like it feels painful well the reason why it

it feels painful well the reason why it

it feels painful well the reason why it feels painful is because we have sensors

feels painful is because we have sensors

feels painful is because we have sensors in our skin and throughout our body

in our skin and throughout our body

in our skin and throughout our body fact which detect noxious damage so how

fact which detect noxious damage so how

fact which detect noxious damage so how does this work well there’s a nice

does this work well there’s a nice

does this work well there’s a nice little picture that I cobbled together

little picture that I cobbled together

little picture that I cobbled together in about 20 seconds which kind of

in about 20 seconds which kind of

in about 20 seconds which kind of describes the general neuroscience

describes the general neuroscience

describes the general neuroscience behind sensing now this could be any

behind sensing now this could be any

behind sensing now this could be any type of sensor but in general it’s

type of sensor but in general it’s

type of sensor but in general it’s simple you have a sensor in a part of

simple you have a sensor in a part of

simple you have a sensor in a part of your body and then that sensor is linked

your body and then that sensor is linked

your body and then that sensor is linked by a nerve all the way into your brain

by a nerve all the way into your brain

by a nerve all the way into your brain so for example you have a sensor in your

so for example you have a sensor in your

so for example you have a sensor in your hand for touch when I broke my hand that

hand for touch when I broke my hand that

hand for touch when I broke my hand that sense the sense is that mechanical

sense the sense is that mechanical

sense the sense is that mechanical effort and then transmits the

effort and then transmits the

effort and then transmits the information into the brain

information into the brain

information into the brain now we would like to know how these work

now we would like to know how these work

now we would like to know how these work we’d like to know because we want to

we’d like to know because we want to

we’d like to know because we want to know how the human body works but

know how the human body works but

know how the human body works but particularly for pain because pain is a

particularly for pain because pain is a

particularly for pain because pain is a very useful sensation it teaches us what

very useful sensation it teaches us what

very useful sensation it teaches us what is good and is bad for our body

is good and is bad for our body

is good and is bad for our body however pain can be really debilitating

however pain can be really debilitating

however pain can be really debilitating as well if you have an acute pain like

as well if you have an acute pain like

as well if you have an acute pain like say if you’re a four-year-old and you’re

say if you’re a four-year-old and you’re

say if you’re a four-year-old and you’re tottering around your mom’s kitchen and

tottering around your mom’s kitchen and

tottering around your mom’s kitchen and you touch the hot stove and it hurts you

you touch the hot stove and it hurts you

you touch the hot stove and it hurts you learn never to do that again this is

learn never to do that again this is

learn never to do that again this is useful but what happens if you have

useful but what happens if you have

useful but what happens if you have chronic pain if you’re constantly in

chronic pain if you’re constantly in

chronic pain if you’re constantly in pain for example older people often get

pain for example older people often get

pain for example older people often get something called arthritis which is

something called arthritis which is

something called arthritis which is inflammation in your joints and you

inflammation in your joints and you

inflammation in your joints and you can’t and it’s so painful that you

can’t and it’s so painful that you

can’t and it’s so painful that you cannot use your hands so this is a

cannot use your hands so this is a

cannot use your hands so this is a chronic pain which is stopping you from

chronic pain which is stopping you from

chronic pain which is stopping you from living your life so we want to learn how

living your life so we want to learn how

living your life so we want to learn how these processes work so that then we can

these processes work so that then we can

these processes work so that then we can potentially create therapies to treat

potentially create therapies to treat

potentially create therapies to treat these pain and alleviate these symptoms

these pain and alleviate these symptoms

these pain and alleviate these symptoms and this dysfunction okay

and this dysfunction okay

and this dysfunction okay so a long time ago about in the last 80

so a long time ago about in the last 80

so a long time ago about in the last 80 years or so it’s been very clear that

years or so it’s been very clear that

years or so it’s been very clear that there’s one chemical that we can find in

there’s one chemical that we can find in

there’s one chemical that we can find in our environment that consistently evokes

our environment that consistently evokes

our environment that consistently evokes pain and this is from the chili plant

pain and this is from the chili plant

pain and this is from the chili plant now you guys are probably familiar with

now you guys are probably familiar with

now you guys are probably familiar with eating chili and sometimes if you’re

eating chili and sometimes if you’re

eating chili and sometimes if you’re like me even a little bit of chili is

like me even a little bit of chili is

like me even a little bit of chili is painful in the mouth okay now if you’ve

painful in the mouth okay now if you’ve

painful in the mouth okay now if you’ve ever chopped chili on your kitchen

ever chopped chili on your kitchen

ever chopped chili on your kitchen chopper

chopper

chopper and you’ve got a little cut on your hand

and you’ve got a little cut on your hand

and you’ve got a little cut on your hand and the chilli gets into there cut it

and the chilli gets into there cut it

and the chilli gets into there cut it really hurts now scientists have worked

really hurts now scientists have worked

really hurts now scientists have worked out how the body senses this chilli and

out how the body senses this chilli and

out how the body senses this chilli and this is a little bit of scientific

this is a little bit of scientific

this is a little bit of scientific jargon for you guys it senses chilli was

jargon for you guys it senses chilli was

jargon for you guys it senses chilli was something called the v1 receptor now the

something called the v1 receptor now the

something called the v1 receptor now the v1 receptor or the v1 sensor is upon the

v1 receptor or the v1 sensor is upon the

v1 receptor or the v1 sensor is upon the sensory nerves in your skin on your

sensory nerves in your skin on your

sensory nerves in your skin on your tongue throughout your body now why does

tongue throughout your body now why does

tongue throughout your body now why does chilli cause pain it doesn’t actually do

chilli cause pain it doesn’t actually do

chilli cause pain it doesn’t actually do any damage to your skin it just you just

any damage to your skin it just you just

any damage to your skin it just you just feel like it’s doing damage so it’s

feel like it’s doing damage so it’s

feel like it’s doing damage so it’s mimicking damage but what else does

mimicking damage but what else does

mimicking damage but what else does chilli feel like when you eat it what

chilli feel like when you eat it what

chilli feel like when you eat it what does it feel like when you eat a lot of

does it feel like when you eat a lot of

does it feel like when you eat a lot of chilli in your mouth yes it’s still

chilli in your mouth yes it’s still

chilli in your mouth yes it’s still spicy it feels hot doesn’t it now why is

spicy it feels hot doesn’t it now why is

spicy it feels hot doesn’t it now why is that well the reason why chilli feels

that well the reason why chilli feels

that well the reason why chilli feels hot is because the v1 sensor not only

hot is because the v1 sensor not only

hot is because the v1 sensor not only detects chilli it also detects heat so

detects chilli it also detects heat so

detects chilli it also detects heat so your body can’t tell the difference

your body can’t tell the difference

your body can’t tell the difference between a chemical which is found in

between a chemical which is found in

between a chemical which is found in chile

chile

chile and actual heat and so when the

and actual heat and so when the

and actual heat and so when the four-year-old puts her hand on the stove

four-year-old puts her hand on the stove

four-year-old puts her hand on the stove and goes ah this is painful because it’s

and goes ah this is painful because it’s

and goes ah this is painful because it’s hot it’s activating the v1 sensor and in

hot it’s activating the v1 sensor and in

hot it’s activating the v1 sensor and in fact we can create drugs which block the

fact we can create drugs which block the

fact we can create drugs which block the v1 sensor and you stop the sensation of

v1 sensor and you stop the sensation of

v1 sensor and you stop the sensation of both Chile and of heat so why is Chile

both Chile and of heat so why is Chile

both Chile and of heat so why is Chile painful well it turns out that there’s

painful well it turns out that there’s

painful well it turns out that there’s another thing which is painful and

another thing which is painful and

another thing which is painful and that’s inflammation here’s a picture of

that’s inflammation here’s a picture of

that’s inflammation here’s a picture of a rather unfortunate individual with a

a rather unfortunate individual with a

a rather unfortunate individual with a sunburn now I don’t know if you’re like

sunburn now I don’t know if you’re like

sunburn now I don’t know if you’re like me but when I get a sunburn it feels

me but when I get a sunburn it feels

me but when I get a sunburn it feels really painful really sensitive to the

really painful really sensitive to the

really painful really sensitive to the touch a little touch like this would be

touch a little touch like this would be

touch a little touch like this would be ah agony if you’ve got a sunburn and it

ah agony if you’ve got a sunburn and it

ah agony if you’ve got a sunburn and it turns out that the chemicals produced by

turns out that the chemicals produced by

turns out that the chemicals produced by inflammation like this sunburn in the

inflammation like this sunburn in the

inflammation like this sunburn in the skin look very much like the chemical

skin look very much like the chemical

skin look very much like the chemical which is in chile which causes pain so

which is in chile which causes pain so

which is in chile which causes pain so what the Chile plant has done is

what the Chile plant has done is

what the Chile plant has done is produced a chemical through evolution

produced a chemical through evolution

produced a chemical through evolution which mimics and looks like what is

which mimics and looks like what is

which mimics and looks like what is produced

produced

produced the skin when it’s damaged okay so this

the skin when it’s damaged okay so this

the skin when it’s damaged okay so this tells us that if we know how chili works

tells us that if we know how chili works

tells us that if we know how chili works we can know how pain is produced by

we can know how pain is produced by

we can know how pain is produced by inflammation like arthritis and other

inflammation like arthritis and other

inflammation like arthritis and other diseases like that so scientists decided

diseases like that so scientists decided

diseases like that so scientists decided to find out how chili worked and the

to find out how chili worked and the

to find out how chili worked and the question to start off with is why would

question to start off with is why would

question to start off with is why would chili make something which is painful to

chili make something which is painful to

chili make something which is painful to eat that doesn’t make any sense

eat that doesn’t make any sense

eat that doesn’t make any sense whatsoever fruit and this is a fruit

whatsoever fruit and this is a fruit

whatsoever fruit and this is a fruit chili as a fruit it’s got its got some

chili as a fruit it’s got its got some

chili as a fruit it’s got its got some fleshy stuff and some seeds and you know

fleshy stuff and some seeds and you know

fleshy stuff and some seeds and you know why plants produce fruit it’s to

why plants produce fruit it’s to

why plants produce fruit it’s to disperse their seeds get animals to eat

disperse their seeds get animals to eat

disperse their seeds get animals to eat and then disperse their seeds so why

and then disperse their seeds so why

and then disperse their seeds so why would chili plant produce something

would chili plant produce something

would chili plant produce something which is ah really painful to eat

which is ah really painful to eat

which is ah really painful to eat although the joke’s on the chili plants

although the joke’s on the chili plants

although the joke’s on the chili plants because humans like to eat chili but

because humans like to eat chili but

because humans like to eat chili but that’s another matter

that’s another matter

that’s another matter so the reason is because of these cute

so the reason is because of these cute

so the reason is because of these cute guys okay so we’ve got some monkeys

guys okay so we’ve got some monkeys

guys okay so we’ve got some monkeys we’ve got some squirrels any mammal that

we’ve got some squirrels any mammal that

we’ve got some squirrels any mammal that eats a chili plant will destroy the

eats a chili plant will destroy the

eats a chili plant will destroy the seeds inside its digestive tract there

seeds inside its digestive tract there

seeds inside its digestive tract there are different enzymes in your body which

are different enzymes in your body which

are different enzymes in your body which when it’s breaking down your food makes

when it’s breaking down your food makes

when it’s breaking down your food makes the seeds unable to then germinate when

the seeds unable to then germinate when

the seeds unable to then germinate when they pass through the animal into the

they pass through the animal into the

they pass through the animal into the stool

stool

stool okay so chili has adapted to prevent

okay so chili has adapted to prevent

okay so chili has adapted to prevent mammals from eating it

mammals from eating it

mammals from eating it so what else eats it birds eat chili and

so what else eats it birds eat chili and

so what else eats it birds eat chili and whence when birds eat a chili pepper

whence when birds eat a chili pepper

whence when birds eat a chili pepper fruit and the seeds passed through the

fruit and the seeds passed through the

fruit and the seeds passed through the bird they do not get broken down the

bird they do not get broken down the

bird they do not get broken down the seeds can then germinate properly so the

seeds can then germinate properly so the

seeds can then germinate properly so the chili plant has a decision to make

chili plant has a decision to make

chili plant has a decision to make do I get eaten by a mammal or do I get

do I get eaten by a mammal or do I get

do I get eaten by a mammal or do I get eaten by a bird if I get eaten by an

eaten by a bird if I get eaten by an

eaten by a bird if I get eaten by an animal my seeds will not work if I get

animal my seeds will not work if I get

animal my seeds will not work if I get eaten by a bird my seeds will work so we

eaten by a bird my seeds will work so we

eaten by a bird my seeds will work so we want to ink the at the plant wishes to

want to ink the at the plant wishes to

want to ink the at the plant wishes to encourage the animals not to eat it and

encourage the animals not to eat it and

encourage the animals not to eat it and the birds to eat it and it turns out

the birds to eat it and it turns out

the birds to eat it and it turns out that mammals like I said a respond

that mammals like I said a respond

that mammals like I said a respond negatively to chili it’s painful but

negatively to chili it’s painful but

negatively to chili it’s painful but birds don’t care they just eaten tons of

birds don’t care they just eaten tons of

birds don’t care they just eaten tons of chili yeah the most chili we can eat

chili yeah the most chili we can eat

chili yeah the most chili we can eat doesn’t matter

doesn’t matter

doesn’t matter birds don’t seem to care

birds don’t seem to care

birds don’t seem to care so what does this mean does this mean

so what does this mean does this mean

so what does this mean does this mean that birds do not have the v1 sensor

that birds do not have the v1 sensor

that birds do not have the v1 sensor well it turns out the birds do have the

well it turns out the birds do have the

well it turns out the birds do have the v1 sensor birds respond to heat in an in

v1 sensor birds respond to heat in an in

v1 sensor birds respond to heat in an in a defensive way if you if you put a bird

a defensive way if you if you put a bird

a defensive way if you if you put a bird near a hot flame it retreats because

near a hot flame it retreats because

near a hot flame it retreats because it’s hot and it’s got that v1 sensor so

it’s hot and it’s got that v1 sensor so

it’s hot and it’s got that v1 sensor so what’s going on well it turns out that

what’s going on well it turns out that

what’s going on well it turns out that the birds do have the v1 sensor but the

the birds do have the v1 sensor but the

the birds do have the v1 sensor but the v1 sensor does not get activated by

v1 sensor does not get activated by

v1 sensor does not get activated by chilly okay

chilly okay

chilly okay and this is where the scientists got

and this is where the scientists got

and this is where the scientists got together and worked out that this rather

together and worked out that this rather

together and worked out that this rather esoteric point that you put Chilean bird

esoteric point that you put Chilean bird

esoteric point that you put Chilean bird feed so that the mammals don’t eat it

feed so that the mammals don’t eat it

feed so that the mammals don’t eat it and let the birds eat it this can help

and let the birds eat it this can help

and let the birds eat it this can help us understand pain why does it help us

us understand pain why does it help us

us understand pain why does it help us understand pain because if we can

understand pain because if we can

understand pain because if we can compare the v1 sensor from mammals with

compare the v1 sensor from mammals with

compare the v1 sensor from mammals with the v1 sensor from birds we can work out

the v1 sensor from birds we can work out

the v1 sensor from birds we can work out where the Chile works so you guys know

where the Chile works so you guys know

where the Chile works so you guys know about DNA DNA is the genetic code it

about DNA DNA is the genetic code it

about DNA DNA is the genetic code it allows us to know exactly the building

allows us to know exactly the building

allows us to know exactly the building blocks for all biological life and what

blocks for all biological life and what

blocks for all biological life and what we can do is the biological scientists

we can do is the biological scientists

we can do is the biological scientists got together and they worked out the

got together and they worked out the

got together and they worked out the genetic code of all the mammals and all

genetic code of all the mammals and all

genetic code of all the mammals and all the birds and what they compared was

the birds and what they compared was

the birds and what they compared was they wanted to look at the genetic code

they wanted to look at the genetic code

they wanted to look at the genetic code which made the v1 sensor okay so we can

which made the v1 sensor okay so we can

which made the v1 sensor okay so we can look at the two different structures now

look at the two different structures now

look at the two different structures now the v1 sensor has 900 separate

the v1 sensor has 900 separate

the v1 sensor has 900 separate components this thing is complex it’s

components this thing is complex it’s

components this thing is complex it’s complicated so you’d never work out

complicated so you’d never work out

complicated so you’d never work out where the the Chile activated the v1

where the the Chile activated the v1

where the the Chile activated the v1 sensor if you were just to change each

sensor if you were just to change each

sensor if you were just to change each and every one so instead they compared

and every one so instead they compared

and every one so instead they compared the mammalian sensor with the bird

the mammalian sensor with the bird

the mammalian sensor with the bird sensor and you see there’s a tiny bit

sensor and you see there’s a tiny bit

sensor and you see there’s a tiny bit which is different don’t you the little

which is different don’t you the little

which is different don’t you the little yellow boxes and those yellow boxes that

yellow boxes and those yellow boxes that

yellow boxes and those yellow boxes that was the only difference between the bird

was the only difference between the bird

was the only difference between the bird and the mammal so this must mean that

and the mammal so this must mean that

and the mammal so this must mean that that’s where the Chile works

that’s where the Chile works

that’s where the Chile works chili works on that little yellow box or

chili works on that little yellow box or

chili works on that little yellow box or it doesn’t work on that yellow box

it doesn’t work on that yellow box

it doesn’t work on that yellow box because that’s the bird version so if we

because that’s the bird version so if we

because that’s the bird version so if we now know where the chili works I want to

now know where the chili works I want to

now know where the chili works I want to remind you that chili mimics what the

remind you that chili mimics what the

remind you that chili mimics what the body produces when it’s damaged so now

body produces when it’s damaged so now

body produces when it’s damaged so now we know from this experiment where the

we know from this experiment where the

we know from this experiment where the little bits of your own body and

little bits of your own body and

little bits of your own body and inflammation where that attacks the v1

inflammation where that attacks the v1

inflammation where that attacks the v1 sensor so now we can design some drugs

sensor so now we can design some drugs

sensor so now we can design some drugs which target that tiny little sensor

which target that tiny little sensor

which target that tiny little sensor that tiny bit in this huge sensor we can

that tiny bit in this huge sensor we can

that tiny bit in this huge sensor we can now block with drugs there for treating

now block with drugs there for treating

now block with drugs there for treating pain and I just want to end up by saying

pain and I just want to end up by saying

pain and I just want to end up by saying this is about new perspectives ok and

this is about new perspectives ok and

this is about new perspectives ok and the new perspectives is that if we can

the new perspectives is that if we can

the new perspectives is that if we can use different scientists these are neuro

use different scientists these are neuro

use different scientists these are neuro scientists these are molecular

scientists these are molecular

scientists these are molecular biologists these are zoologist and

biologists these are zoologist and

biologists these are zoologist and botanist everyone joined together so

botanist everyone joined together so

botanist everyone joined together so that now we have a target for treating

that now we have a target for treating

that now we have a target for treating pain and I think in the near future

pain and I think in the near future

pain and I think in the near future we’re going to have drugs which can help

we’re going to have drugs which can help

we’re going to have drugs which can help people with all their pain syndromes so

people with all their pain syndromes so

people with all their pain syndromes so I’d like to thank everyone for their

I’d like to thank everyone for their

I’d like to thank everyone for their attention and have a great day

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *