Press "Enter" to skip to content

In Defense of Internal Combustion | Kelly Senecal | TEDxMadison


what do you hear the word combustion

what do you hear the word combustion what does it make you think of a

what does it make you think of a

what does it make you think of a campfire maybe a candlelit dinner

campfire maybe a candlelit dinner

campfire maybe a candlelit dinner how about spontaneous combustion for

how about spontaneous combustion for

how about spontaneous combustion for many people like myself combustion means

many people like myself combustion means

many people like myself combustion means power it’s a source of power and I don’t

power it’s a source of power and I don’t

power it’s a source of power and I don’t mean the type of power stop by dictators

mean the type of power stop by dictators

mean the type of power stop by dictators or politicians

or politicians

or politicians I mean horse power the rate of doing

I mean horse power the rate of doing

I mean horse power the rate of doing work getting from point A to point B now

work getting from point A to point B now

work getting from point A to point B now a popular way of getting from point A to

a popular way of getting from point A to

a popular way of getting from point A to point B is with your car right most of

point B is with your car right most of

point B is with your car right most of the cars on the road today

the cars on the road today

the cars on the road today use combustion internal combustion and

use combustion internal combustion and

use combustion internal combustion and the engine that powers your car now

the engine that powers your car now

the engine that powers your car now internal combustion has been around for

internal combustion has been around for

internal combustion has been around for a long time since about the 1790s

a long time since about the 1790s

a long time since about the 1790s Nicholas Otto and others developed the

Nicholas Otto and others developed the

Nicholas Otto and others developed the basis of the internal combustion in the

basis of the internal combustion in the

basis of the internal combustion in the 1860s and 1870s Oh about a hundred fifty

1860s and 1870s Oh about a hundred fifty

1860s and 1870s Oh about a hundred fifty years ago now internal combustion has

years ago now internal combustion has

years ago now internal combustion has come a long way since then not only does

come a long way since then not only does

come a long way since then not only does it have the potential to go further I

it have the potential to go further I

it have the potential to go further I would argue that it needs to go further

would argue that it needs to go further

would argue that it needs to go further and that we should want it to go further

and that we should want it to go further

and that we should want it to go further now whether we like it or not internal

now whether we like it or not internal

now whether we like it or not internal combustion will be in our lives for the

combustion will be in our lives for the

combustion will be in our lives for the next 30 to 40 years it just will be so

next 30 to 40 years it just will be so

next 30 to 40 years it just will be so here’s an idea why don’t we keep

here’s an idea why don’t we keep

here’s an idea why don’t we keep improving it one of the most immediate

improving it one of the most immediate

improving it one of the most immediate ways that we can go green is by

ways that we can go green is by

ways that we can go green is by advancing the internal combustion engine

advancing the internal combustion engine

advancing the internal combustion engine now I know the idea of going green with

now I know the idea of going green with

now I know the idea of going green with internal combustion probably sounds

internal combustion probably sounds

internal combustion probably sounds outrageous to many of you and I get that

outrageous to many of you and I get that

outrageous to many of you and I get that recent events like the dieselgate

recent events like the dieselgate

recent events like the dieselgate scandal don’t help this mindset at all

scandal don’t help this mindset at all

scandal don’t help this mindset at all pop culture and the media have many of

pop culture and the media have many of

pop culture and the media have many of us believing we’re already on the cusp

us believing we’re already on the cusp

us believing we’re already on the cusp of a post fossil fuel society but it’s

of a post fossil fuel society but it’s

of a post fossil fuel society but it’s actually much further away than you

actually much further away than you

actually much further away than you might think

might think

might think check this out in 2008 when a gallon of

check this out in 2008 when a gallon of

check this out in 2008 when a gallon of gasoline was about $4 President Obama

gasoline was about $4 President Obama

gasoline was about $4 President Obama set a goal of putting 1 million electric

set a goal of putting 1 million electric

set a goal of putting 1 million electric vehicles on the road by the end of 2015

vehicles on the road by the end of 2015

vehicles on the road by the end of 2015 but actually only about 400,000 electric

but actually only about 400,000 electric

but actually only about 400,000 electric vehicles were sold in that time frame

vehicles were sold in that time frame

vehicles were sold in that time frame why not more why weren’t consumers

why not more why weren’t consumers

why not more why weren’t consumers flocking to electric vehicles

flocking to electric vehicles

flocking to electric vehicles well the answer is actually pretty

well the answer is actually pretty

well the answer is actually pretty straightforward fuel prices came way

straightforward fuel prices came way

straightforward fuel prices came way down electric vehicles tend to cost more

down electric vehicles tend to cost more

down electric vehicles tend to cost more they have a limited range and there’s

they have a limited range and there’s

they have a limited range and there’s usually a limited availability of

usually a limited availability of

usually a limited availability of charging stations in fact the Department

charging stations in fact the Department

charging stations in fact the Department of Energy projects that in 2040 about 99

of Energy projects that in 2040 about 99

of Energy projects that in 2040 about 99 percent of new cars sold in the US will

percent of new cars sold in the US will

percent of new cars sold in the US will still use internal combustion so think

still use internal combustion so think

still use internal combustion so think about that for a second in 25 years most

about that for a second in 25 years most

about that for a second in 25 years most of the cars on the road in the US will

of the cars on the road in the US will

of the cars on the road in the US will still use internal combustion engine now

still use internal combustion engine now

still use internal combustion engine now Prius and Tesla have become household

Prius and Tesla have become household

Prius and Tesla have become household names and why wouldn’t they they’re

names and why wouldn’t they they’re

names and why wouldn’t they they’re green

green

green but remember Prius uses what’s known as

but remember Prius uses what’s known as

but remember Prius uses what’s known as a hybrid engine which is a combination

a hybrid engine which is a combination

a hybrid engine which is a combination of an electric motor and an internal

of an electric motor and an internal

of an electric motor and an internal combustion engine

combustion engine

combustion engine now Tesla and other electric vehicles

now Tesla and other electric vehicles

now Tesla and other electric vehicles they are in fact fully electric the cars

they are in fact fully electric the cars

they are in fact fully electric the cars themselves produce zero emissions in

themselves produce zero emissions in

themselves produce zero emissions in zero greenhouse gases but here’s the

zero greenhouse gases but here’s the

zero greenhouse gases but here’s the thing to think about it’s not just about

thing to think about it’s not just about

thing to think about it’s not just about the car there are a lot of other issues

the car there are a lot of other issues

the car there are a lot of other issues that have to be considered or should be

that have to be considered or should be

that have to be considered or should be considered when we think about total

considered when we think about total

considered when we think about total emissions from a vehicle today I’m just

emissions from a vehicle today I’m just

emissions from a vehicle today I’m just gonna focus on one of those and that’s

gonna focus on one of those and that’s

gonna focus on one of those and that’s the energy sources for electricity where

the energy sources for electricity where

the energy sources for electricity where does the electricity that powers your

does the electricity that powers your

does the electricity that powers your electric vehicle come from in 2015 about

electric vehicle come from in 2015 about

electric vehicle come from in 2015 about two-thirds of electricity in the US came

two-thirds of electricity in the US came

two-thirds of electricity in the US came from fossil fuels well guess what in

from fossil fuels well guess what in

from fossil fuels well guess what in 1985 about two-thirds of electricity in

1985 about two-thirds of electricity in

1985 about two-thirds of electricity in the US also came from fossil fuels

the US also came from fossil fuels

the US also came from fossil fuels now we’ve definitely made a positive

now we’ve definitely made a positive

now we’ve definitely made a positive transition from coal to natural gas in

transition from coal to natural gas in

transition from coal to natural gas in that time frame and that’s great but the

that time frame and that’s great but the

that time frame and that’s great but the fact is on a percentage basis the amount

fact is on a percentage basis the amount

fact is on a percentage basis the amount of fossil fuels used to create

of fossil fuels used to create

of fossil fuels used to create electricity in the US has remained

electricity in the US has remained

electricity in the US has remained unchanged for the last 30 years

unchanged for the last 30 years

unchanged for the last 30 years another example is China in China about

another example is China in China about

another example is China in China about 75 percent of their electricity comes

75 percent of their electricity comes

75 percent of their electricity comes from fossil fuels specifically coal is

from fossil fuels specifically coal is

from fossil fuels specifically coal is the majority but then you have a country

the majority but then you have a country

the majority but then you have a country like Norway in Norway very little fossil

like Norway in Norway very little fossil

like Norway in Norway very little fossil fuels are used to create electricity

fuels are used to create electricity

fuels are used to create electricity about 90 percent of their electricity

about 90 percent of their electricity

about 90 percent of their electricity comes from hydroelectric power which is

comes from hydroelectric power which is

comes from hydroelectric power which is power derived from the potential energy

power derived from the potential energy

power derived from the potential energy of dammed water so in Norway for example

of dammed water so in Norway for example

of dammed water so in Norway for example electric vehicles do in fact produce

electric vehicles do in fact produce

electric vehicles do in fact produce zero or near zero emissions because

zero or near zero emissions because

zero or near zero emissions because fossil fuels don’t really come into the

fossil fuels don’t really come into the

fossil fuels don’t really come into the play so it is possible but the problem

play so it is possible but the problem

play so it is possible but the problem is that zero emissions vehicles green

is that zero emissions vehicles green

is that zero emissions vehicles green cars that are truly green only make up a

cars that are truly green only make up a

cars that are truly green only make up a very small portion of the cars on the

very small portion of the cars on the

very small portion of the cars on the road today to go green we must keep

road today to go green we must keep

road today to go green we must keep improving the internal combustion engine

improving the internal combustion engine

improving the internal combustion engine so you’re probably wondering why am I so

so you’re probably wondering why am I so

so you’re probably wondering why am I so confident that we can do more with the

confident that we can do more with the

confident that we can do more with the internal combustion engine well look at

internal combustion engine well look at

internal combustion engine well look at how far we’ve come as an example let’s

how far we’ve come as an example let’s

how far we’ve come as an example let’s take carbon dioxide carbon dioxide is

take carbon dioxide carbon dioxide is

take carbon dioxide carbon dioxide is one of the major sources of greenhouse

one of the major sources of greenhouse

one of the major sources of greenhouse gases carbon dioxide along with water

gases carbon dioxide along with water

gases carbon dioxide along with water vapour is also a product of complete

vapour is also a product of complete

vapour is also a product of complete combustion so the more fuel-efficient

combustion so the more fuel-efficient

combustion so the more fuel-efficient your car is the less fuel you need to

your car is the less fuel you need to

your car is the less fuel you need to get from point A to point B and the less

get from point A to point B and the less

get from point A to point B and the less carbon dioxide you’ll produce now we’ve

carbon dioxide you’ll produce now we’ve

carbon dioxide you’ll produce now we’ve made significant strides and fuel

made significant strides and fuel

made significant strides and fuel efficiency since the onset of internal

efficiency since the onset of internal

efficiency since the onset of internal combustion cars today are about twice as

combustion cars today are about twice as

combustion cars today are about twice as fuel-efficient as they were in 1975 in

fuel-efficient as they were in 1975 in

fuel-efficient as they were in 1975 in the last 10 years we’ve improved our

the last 10 years we’ve improved our

the last 10 years we’ve improved our fuel economy by about 25 percent and we

fuel economy by about 25 percent and we

fuel economy by about 25 percent and we will continue to improve it by another

will continue to improve it by another

will continue to improve it by another 50% in order to keep up with federal

50% in order to keep up with federal

50% in order to keep up with federal regulations in addition harmful

regulations in addition harmful

regulations in addition harmful emissions like nitrous nitrogen oxides

emissions like nitrous nitrogen oxides

emissions like nitrous nitrogen oxides and particulate matter or soot are at

and particulate matter or soot are at

and particulate matter or soot are at historic lows now how we’ve been able to

historic lows now how we’ve been able to

historic lows now how we’ve been able to do this how how have we been able to

do this how how have we been able to

do this how how have we been able to reduce emissions and improve fuel

reduce emissions and improve fuel

reduce emissions and improve fuel economy we’ve done this by innovating so

economy we’ve done this by innovating so

economy we’ve done this by innovating so in order to talk about how we innovate

in order to talk about how we innovate

in order to talk about how we innovate with internal combustion engines let’s

with internal combustion engines let’s

with internal combustion engines let’s first review how an internal combustion

first review how an internal combustion

first review how an internal combustion engine works so in most modern engines

engine works so in most modern engines

engine works so in most modern engines fuel is injected directly into the

fuel is injected directly into the

fuel is injected directly into the combustion chamber it evaporates mixes

combustion chamber it evaporates mixes

combustion chamber it evaporates mixes with air its ignited forms a high

with air its ignited forms a high

with air its ignited forms a high temperature flame which increases the

temperature flame which increases the

temperature flame which increases the pressure in the combustion chamber and

pressure in the combustion chamber and

pressure in the combustion chamber and does work on the piston now it sounds

does work on the piston now it sounds

does work on the piston now it sounds pretty straightforward right well

pretty straightforward right well

pretty straightforward right well actually it’s not so I’ll start with the

actually it’s not so I’ll start with the

actually it’s not so I’ll start with the bad news the bad news is that an

bad news the bad news is that an

bad news the bad news is that an internal combustion engine is actually

internal combustion engine is actually

internal combustion engine is actually one of the most complicated engineering

one of the most complicated engineering

one of the most complicated engineering problems out there

problems out there

problems out there it relies on turbulent flow fuel

it relies on turbulent flow fuel

it relies on turbulent flow fuel injection fuel properties feel chemistry

injection fuel properties feel chemistry

injection fuel properties feel chemistry an ignition system and combustion

an ignition system and combustion

an ignition system and combustion chamber design

chamber design

chamber design there are literally hundreds of

there are literally hundreds of

there are literally hundreds of parameters that can be tweaked in an

parameters that can be tweaked in an

parameters that can be tweaked in an engine to come up with an optimal

engine to come up with an optimal

engine to come up with an optimal configuration but the greenest engine

configuration but the greenest engine

configuration but the greenest engine which is our goal is the soft moon

which is our goal is the soft moon

which is our goal is the soft moon combination and we need to find it we

combination and we need to find it we

combination and we need to find it we need to find the recipe of design

need to find the recipe of design

need to find the recipe of design parameters that allow us to go as green

parameters that allow us to go as green

parameters that allow us to go as green as possible with internal combustion now

as possible with internal combustion now

as possible with internal combustion now finding that it’s not easy how can we

finding that it’s not easy how can we

finding that it’s not easy how can we possibly build and test engines out of

possibly build and test engines out of

possibly build and test engines out of all combinations of parameters we can’t

all combinations of parameters we can’t

all combinations of parameters we can’t so that’s the bad news

so that’s the bad news

so that’s the bad news but I’m not going to suggest we improve

but I’m not going to suggest we improve

but I’m not going to suggest we improve something talked about how hard it is

something talked about how hard it is

something talked about how hard it is and then not offer suggestions to

and then not offer suggestions to

and then not offer suggestions to improve it the good news is is there is

improve it the good news is is there is

improve it the good news is is there is an optimal recipe out there there’s a

an optimal recipe out there there’s a

an optimal recipe out there there’s a set of design parameters that does allow

set of design parameters that does allow

set of design parameters that does allow us to go as green as possible with

us to go as green as possible with

us to go as green as possible with internal combustion engines and we have

internal combustion engines and we have

internal combustion engines and we have the tools to help us get there without

the tools to help us get there without

the tools to help us get there without having to build hundreds thousands or

having to build hundreds thousands or

having to build hundreds thousands or even millions of designs we have really

even millions of designs we have really

even millions of designs we have really big computers we have software that runs

big computers we have software that runs

big computers we have software that runs on these computers that allows us to

on these computers that allows us to

on these computers that allows us to test engine concepts before we build

test engine concepts before we build

test engine concepts before we build them and we have optimization software

them and we have optimization software

them and we have optimization software that allows us to run a reduced set of

that allows us to run a reduced set of

that allows us to run a reduced set of designs in order to find an optimum now

designs in order to find an optimum now

designs in order to find an optimum now these tools along with experiments have

these tools along with experiments have

these tools along with experiments have helped us meet emissions and fuel

helped us meet emissions and fuel

helped us meet emissions and fuel economy mandates throughout federal

economy mandates throughout federal

economy mandates throughout federal regulation history now the engine keeps

regulation history now the engine keeps

regulation history now the engine keeps improving partly because consumers want

improving partly because consumers want

improving partly because consumers want to fill up their tanks less often but

to fill up their tanks less often but

to fill up their tanks less often but also because the federal regulations are

also because the federal regulations are

also because the federal regulations are forcing engine makers to find solutions

forcing engine makers to find solutions

forcing engine makers to find solutions in order to keep selling cars now one

in order to keep selling cars now one

in order to keep selling cars now one approach that helps us improve

approach that helps us improve

approach that helps us improve combustion engines and has helped us is

combustion engines and has helped us is

combustion engines and has helped us is actually based on the theories of

actually based on the theories of

actually based on the theories of natural selection to find an optimum in

natural selection to find an optimum in

natural selection to find an optimum in nature how do organisms improve and

nature how do organisms improve and

nature how do organisms improve and adapt to their surroundings they evolve

adapt to their surroundings they evolve

adapt to their surroundings they evolve nature can actually teach us how to save

nature can actually teach us how to save

nature can actually teach us how to save itself a great example of this is the

itself a great example of this is the

itself a great example of this is the peppered moth so before the Industrial

peppered moth so before the Industrial

peppered moth so before the Industrial Revolution typically the peppered moth

Revolution typically the peppered moth

Revolution typically the peppered moth was light with dark spots and this

was light with dark spots and this

was light with dark spots and this served as great camouflage against

served as great camouflage against

served as great camouflage against predators only about 2% of the

predators only about 2% of the

predators only about 2% of the population was dark after the Industrial

population was dark after the Industrial

population was dark after the Industrial Revolution started

Revolution started

Revolution started was pollution that actually darkened

was pollution that actually darkened

was pollution that actually darkened surfaces on which moths rested causing

surfaces on which moths rested causing

surfaces on which moths rested causing the lighter moths to be eaten and the

the lighter moths to be eaten and the

the lighter moths to be eaten and the darker wants to survive the moth

darker wants to survive the moth

darker wants to survive the moth population evolved based on a change in

population evolved based on a change in

population evolved based on a change in its environment so for internal

its environment so for internal

its environment so for internal combustion engines concern for the

combustion engines concern for the

combustion engines concern for the planet and also federal regulations

planet and also federal regulations

planet and also federal regulations represent a change literally in its

represent a change literally in its

represent a change literally in its environment now we can either allow

environment now we can either allow

environment now we can either allow engines to evolve to this environment

engines to evolve to this environment

engines to evolve to this environment more organically through trial and error

more organically through trial and error

more organically through trial and error or we can directly use the principles of

or we can directly use the principles of

or we can directly use the principles of evolution to help us get there quicker

evolution to help us get there quicker

evolution to help us get there quicker this is the premise of a genetic

this is the premise of a genetic

this is the premise of a genetic algorithm a genetic algorithm is a

algorithm a genetic algorithm is a

algorithm a genetic algorithm is a procedure that runs on the computer that

procedure that runs on the computer that

procedure that runs on the computer that allows you to optimize a problem that

allows you to optimize a problem that

allows you to optimize a problem that has a lot of different parameters in it

has a lot of different parameters in it

has a lot of different parameters in it so to see kind of how this works let’s

so to see kind of how this works let’s

so to see kind of how this works let’s go back to our moths so you start with a

go back to our moths so you start with a

go back to our moths so you start with a population of designs or in this case a

population of designs or in this case a

population of designs or in this case a set of peppered moths each with very

set of peppered moths each with very

set of peppered moths each with very traits in this case number of spots now

traits in this case number of spots now

traits in this case number of spots now remember after the Industrial Revolution

remember after the Industrial Revolution

remember after the Industrial Revolution a moths chance of survival was directly

a moths chance of survival was directly

a moths chance of survival was directly proportional to how dark it was the lot

proportional to how dark it was the lot

proportional to how dark it was the lot lighter Moss would be eaten and the

lighter Moss would be eaten and the

lighter Moss would be eaten and the darker ones would survive so we start

darker ones would survive so we start

darker ones would survive so we start with this population of moths we mix the

with this population of moths we mix the

with this population of moths we mix the traits to form a new generation we

traits to form a new generation we

traits to form a new generation we select survivors to parent the following

select survivors to parent the following

select survivors to parent the following generation and we keep doing this over a

generation and we keep doing this over a

generation and we keep doing this over a number of generations until the optimal

number of generations until the optimal

number of generations until the optimal design or the darkest moth is found now

design or the darkest moth is found now

design or the darkest moth is found now we can do this with engines and we have

we can do this with engines and we have

we can do this with engines and we have done it but there’s a lot more work to

done it but there’s a lot more work to

done it but there’s a lot more work to be done the computer software that we

be done the computer software that we

be done the computer software that we can use to simulate these engines before

can use to simulate these engines before

can use to simulate these engines before building them is really good but far

building them is really good but far

building them is really good but far from perfect under a lot of conditions

from perfect under a lot of conditions

from perfect under a lot of conditions and it takes a long time to run so for

and it takes a long time to run so for

and it takes a long time to run so for an example think about an engine running

an example think about an engine running

an example think about an engine running at 2,000 rpm one engine revolution takes

at 2,000 rpm one engine revolution takes

at 2,000 rpm one engine revolution takes about a tenth of a second but to run

about a tenth of a second but to run

about a tenth of a second but to run that same engine revolution on the

that same engine revolution on the

that same engine revolution on the computer can take up to 24 hours so

computer can take up to 24 hours so

computer can take up to 24 hours so computer methods and speeds both need to

computer methods and speeds both need to

computer methods and speeds both need to improve significantly to get us better

improve significantly to get us better

improve significantly to get us better answers quicker but it’s worth the

answers quicker but it’s worth the

answers quicker but it’s worth the effort it’s an important piece to allow

effort it’s an important piece to allow

effort it’s an important piece to allow us to go greener with internal

us to go greener with internal

us to go greener with internal combustion engines now there tends to be

combustion engines now there tends to be

combustion engines now there tends to be an us-versus-them mentality when it

an us-versus-them mentality when it

an us-versus-them mentality when it comes to

comes to

comes to energy sources for transportation

energy sources for transportation

energy sources for transportation diehard environmentalists tend to preach

diehard environmentalists tend to preach

diehard environmentalists tend to preach the impending doom of the internal

the impending doom of the internal

the impending doom of the internal combustion engine in favor of a full

combustion engine in favor of a full

combustion engine in favor of a full electrification of vehicles a fleet of

electrification of vehicles a fleet of

electrification of vehicles a fleet of cars that gets zero emissions now I

cars that gets zero emissions now I

cars that gets zero emissions now I would invite them to reevaluate their

would invite them to reevaluate their

would invite them to reevaluate their current thinking not because I disagree

current thinking not because I disagree

current thinking not because I disagree but because I think there’s a middle

but because I think there’s a middle

but because I think there’s a middle ground that helps us get to a better

ground that helps us get to a better

ground that helps us get to a better solution we shouldn’t take our eyes off

solution we shouldn’t take our eyes off

solution we shouldn’t take our eyes off of short-term issues for long term gains

of short-term issues for long term gains

of short-term issues for long term gains especially when the short term directly

especially when the short term directly

especially when the short term directly feeds into the long term we can do both

feeds into the long term we can do both

feeds into the long term we can do both we can push both even multiple

we can push both even multiple

we can push both even multiple strategies forward solar wind

strategies forward solar wind

strategies forward solar wind hydroelectric nuclear these are all

hydroelectric nuclear these are all

hydroelectric nuclear these are all viable energy options they all need more

viable energy options they all need more

viable energy options they all need more research they’re all individual pieces

research they’re all individual pieces

research they’re all individual pieces of a bigger puzzle so yeah let’s keep

of a bigger puzzle so yeah let’s keep

of a bigger puzzle so yeah let’s keep hugging trees but why not also start

hugging trees but why not also start

hugging trees but why not also start hugging engines one of the most

hugging engines one of the most

hugging engines one of the most immediate ways we can go green is by

immediate ways we can go green is by

immediate ways we can go green is by improving the internal combustion engine

improving the internal combustion engine

improving the internal combustion engine thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *