Press "Enter" to skip to content

Learning to become comfortable with being uncomfortable | Mike Ellicock | TEDxRoyalHolloway


I’m going to take you back a few years

I’m going to take you back a few years to your math classroom which I hope

to your math classroom which I hope

to your math classroom which I hope didn’t look something like this and I’m

didn’t look something like this and I’m

didn’t look something like this and I’m going to ask your maths question and

going to ask your maths question and

going to ask your maths question and then I’m going to get one of you to

then I’m going to get one of you to

then I’m going to get one of you to stand up and tell us all the answer so

stand up and tell us all the answer so

stand up and tell us all the answer so what is 17 times 24

now I’m not actually going to get one of

now I’m not actually going to get one of you to stand up because that’ll be

you to stand up because that’ll be

you to stand up because that’ll be horrible and I’ve put the answer up here

horrible and I’ve put the answer up here

horrible and I’ve put the answer up here on the board because to stop those of

on the board because to stop those of

on the board because to stop those of you who like this kind of thing from

you who like this kind of thing from

you who like this kind of thing from being unable to hear me until you’ve

being unable to hear me until you’ve

being unable to hear me until you’ve worked it out

worked it out

worked it out but for most of you the majority I

but for most of you the majority I

but for most of you the majority I suspect to stop that uncomfortable

suspect to stop that uncomfortable

suspect to stop that uncomfortable feeling that it’s maybe something like

feeling that it’s maybe something like

feeling that it’s maybe something like this or this or this or this everyone

this or this or this or this everyone

this or this or this or this everyone has a physiological response to a

has a physiological response to a

has a physiological response to a question such as seventeen times

question such as seventeen times

question such as seventeen times twenty-four your heart rate elevates

twenty-four your heart rate elevates

twenty-four your heart rate elevates your pupils dilate is part of your

your pupils dilate is part of your

your pupils dilate is part of your so-called fight-or-flight mechanism

so-called fight-or-flight mechanism

so-called fight-or-flight mechanism which by its nature is uncomfortable

which by its nature is uncomfortable

which by its nature is uncomfortable it’s great for the original purpose of

it’s great for the original purpose of

it’s great for the original purpose of preparing you to run away from a lion or

preparing you to run away from a lion or

preparing you to run away from a lion or to fight the tribe coming over the next

to fight the tribe coming over the next

to fight the tribe coming over the next hill but it’s not so great for mental

hill but it’s not so great for mental

hill but it’s not so great for mental arithmetic so the easiest response for

arithmetic so the easiest response for

arithmetic so the easiest response for many is to fold your arms and say I

many is to fold your arms and say I

many is to fold your arms and say I can’t do that especially when others

can’t do that especially when others

can’t do that especially when others seem to always get the answer before you

seem to always get the answer before you

seem to always get the answer before you and there are some real problems that

and there are some real problems that

and there are some real problems that with the way we conceive of maths here

with the way we conceive of maths here

with the way we conceive of maths here in the UK in school it’s often a very

in the UK in school it’s often a very

in the UK in school it’s often a very starkly binary approach with all the

starkly binary approach with all the

starkly binary approach with all the focus on the answer rather than the

focus on the answer rather than the

focus on the answer rather than the process and when you’re going through

process and when you’re going through

process and when you’re going through the process the question either seems

the process the question either seems

the process the question either seems impossible because you haven’t worked it

impossible because you haven’t worked it

impossible because you haven’t worked it out yet or easy because you just have

out yet or easy because you just have

out yet or easy because you just have which brings to mind Nelson Mandela’s

which brings to mind Nelson Mandela’s

which brings to mind Nelson Mandela’s quote that everything seems impossible

quote that everything seems impossible

quote that everything seems impossible until it’s done nowhere is this more

until it’s done nowhere is this more

until it’s done nowhere is this more glaring than in maths

glaring than in maths

glaring than in maths and inevitably for the majority of

and inevitably for the majority of

and inevitably for the majority of children they’ll always be other kids

children they’ll always be other kids

children they’ll always be other kids who seem to get the answer more quickly

who seem to get the answer more quickly

who seem to get the answer more quickly and easily than they do while they’re

and easily than they do while they’re

and easily than they do while they’re still stuck at the impossible stage an

still stuck at the impossible stage an

still stuck at the impossible stage an Oran thew Z Azzam four categorized by

Oran thew Z Azzam four categorized by

Oran thew Z Azzam four categorized by ability at a young age and then put kids

ability at a young age and then put kids

ability at a young age and then put kids into ability groups or sets creates an

into ability groups or sets creates an

into ability groups or sets creates an unhelpful divide between those who are

unhelpful divide between those who are

unhelpful divide between those who are fast at maths at a young age which in

fast at maths at a young age which in

fast at maths at a young age which in itself is not a great predictor of

itself is not a great predictor of

itself is not a great predictor of future potential Einstein for example

future potential Einstein for example

future potential Einstein for example was very slow and those who aren’t

was very slow and those who aren’t

was very slow and those who aren’t so if you’re slow you get put in a

so if you’re slow you get put in a

so if you’re slow you get put in a bottom or a low set and which kids is it

bottom or a low set and which kids is it

bottom or a low set and which kids is it that often end up in these sets we’ll

that often end up in these sets we’ll

that often end up in these sets we’ll often those who’ve had less parental

often those who’ve had less parental

often those who’ve had less parental input or less rich intellectually

input or less rich intellectually

input or less rich intellectually stimulating out of school or preschool

stimulating out of school or preschool

stimulating out of school or preschool experiences in other words nothing to do

experiences in other words nothing to do

experiences in other words nothing to do with their future potential and we’ve

with their future potential and we’ve

with their future potential and we’ve got research to show that 85% of kids

got research to show that 85% of kids

got research to show that 85% of kids who get put in a bottom set for maths

who get put in a bottom set for maths

who get put in a bottom set for maths stay there throughout their school

stay there throughout their school

stay there throughout their school career which is hardly a recipe for

career which is hardly a recipe for

career which is hardly a recipe for social mobility at national numeracy we

social mobility at national numeracy we

social mobility at national numeracy we don’t believe these children are

don’t believe these children are

don’t believe these children are actually bad at maths but they start to

actually bad at maths but they start to

actually bad at maths but they start to see themselves in that way and others

see themselves in that way and others

see themselves in that way and others categorize them as such and so maybe

categorize them as such and so maybe

categorize them as such and so maybe it’s slightly logical to kind of give up

it’s slightly logical to kind of give up

it’s slightly logical to kind of give up on maths and focus your efforts on other

on maths and focus your efforts on other

on maths and focus your efforts on other areas where you feel yourself as being

areas where you feel yourself as being

areas where you feel yourself as being good at or others other people say that

good at or others other people say that

good at or others other people say that you good at and we think a fundamental

you good at and we think a fundamental

you good at and we think a fundamental problem with maths here in the UK and

problem with maths here in the UK and

problem with maths here in the UK and it’s also true in the u.s. is our

it’s also true in the u.s. is our

it’s also true in the u.s. is our enthusiasm to categorize current low

enthusiasm to categorize current low

enthusiasm to categorize current low attainment as some kind of quasar

attainment as some kind of quasar

attainment as some kind of quasar genetic low ability the math gene myth

genetic low ability the math gene myth

genetic low ability the math gene myth something that simply doesn’t happen in

something that simply doesn’t happen in

something that simply doesn’t happen in high-performing countries as an example

high-performing countries as an example

high-performing countries as an example the OECD asks 15 year olds what does it

the OECD asks 15 year olds what does it

the OECD asks 15 year olds what does it take to be successful in maths they

take to be successful in maths they

take to be successful in maths they didn’t ask the question here in the UK

didn’t ask the question here in the UK

didn’t ask the question here in the UK but in the u.s. 40 percent of kids said

but in the u.s. 40 percent of kids said

but in the u.s. 40 percent of kids said it’s about talent you buy the got it or

it’s about talent you buy the got it or

it’s about talent you buy the got it or you haven’t in Japan which performs much

you haven’t in Japan which performs much

you haven’t in Japan which performs much more highly 80% of kids said matters

more highly 80% of kids said matters

more highly 80% of kids said matters about effort you just need to stick with

about effort you just need to stick with

about effort you just need to stick with it so how does this relate to later life

it so how does this relate to later life

it so how does this relate to later life and does being able to calculate 17

and does being able to calculate 17

and does being able to calculate 17 times 24 rapidly really matter I’d argue

times 24 rapidly really matter I’d argue

times 24 rapidly really matter I’d argue not really it’s important to know the

not really it’s important to know the

not really it’s important to know the answer is going to be about 400 but we

answer is going to be about 400 but we

answer is going to be about 400 but we all carry around with us a tool in our

all carry around with us a tool in our

all carry around with us a tool in our pocket that has more computing power

pocket that has more computing power

pocket that has more computing power than it took to get to the moon but and

than it took to get to the moon but and

than it took to get to the moon but and this is a big but if the formative

this is a big but if the formative

this is a big but if the formative moments in your math classroom mean that

moments in your math classroom mean that

moments in your math classroom mean that I can’t do maths is your overwhelming

I can’t do maths is your overwhelming

I can’t do maths is your overwhelming emotion when you’re presented with

emotion when you’re presented with

emotion when you’re presented with numbers and data in adult life then it

numbers and data in adult life then it

numbers and data in adult life then it really does matter

really does matter

really does matter because it’s simply not possible to make

because it’s simply not possible to make

because it’s simply not possible to make good decisions without engaging with and

good decisions without engaging with and

good decisions without engaging with and potentially manipulating quantitative

potentially manipulating quantitative

potentially manipulating quantitative information so what kind of things are

information so what kind of things are

information so what kind of things are we thinking about well potentially

we thinking about well potentially

we thinking about well potentially mundane activities such as choosing a

mundane activities such as choosing a

mundane activities such as choosing a phone contract or planning a journey

phone contract or planning a journey

phone contract or planning a journey socially important activities such as

socially important activities such as

socially important activities such as cooking a meal for your new girlfriend

cooking a meal for your new girlfriend

cooking a meal for your new girlfriend or boyfriend boring but personal vital

or boyfriend boring but personal vital

or boyfriend boring but personal vital things such as checking your pay

things such as checking your pay

things such as checking your pay statement or planning your future

statement or planning your future

statement or planning your future finances and I also think it’s important

finances and I also think it’s important

finances and I also think it’s important to be able to use numbers and data to

to be able to use numbers and data to

to be able to use numbers and data to engage effectively as a citizen in a

engage effectively as a citizen in a

engage effectively as a citizen in a democracy and yes I absolutely am

democracy and yes I absolutely am

democracy and yes I absolutely am thinking about three hundred and fifty

thinking about three hundred and fifty

thinking about three hundred and fifty million pounds on the side of a bus but

million pounds on the side of a bus but

million pounds on the side of a bus but surely most people just get masks

surely most people just get masks

surely most people just get masks qualifications at school and that sets

qualifications at school and that sets

qualifications at school and that sets them up just fine

them up just fine

them up just fine unfortunately that’s not the case the

unfortunately that’s not the case the

unfortunately that’s not the case the most recent government commissioned

most recent government commissioned

most recent government commissioned survey of adult skills use questions

survey of adult skills use questions

survey of adult skills use questions such as this one to assess everyday math

such as this one to assess everyday math

such as this one to assess everyday math levels and that’s multiple choice and

levels and that’s multiple choice and

levels and that’s multiple choice and also using a calculator remarkably less

also using a calculator remarkably less

also using a calculator remarkably less than a quarter of those who had got a 2

than a quarter of those who had got a 2

than a quarter of those who had got a 2 C at GCSE within the last eight years

C at GCSE within the last eight years

C at GCSE within the last eight years were able to answer this kind of

were able to answer this kind of

were able to answer this kind of question correctly and across the whole

question correctly and across the whole

question correctly and across the whole population that figures 22% so I’m

population that figures 22% so I’m

population that figures 22% so I’m pretty sure this room is not a

pretty sure this room is not a

pretty sure this room is not a representative sample but if it were

representative sample but if it were

representative sample but if it were that would just be this little group

that would just be this little group

that would just be this little group down here he’s getting worse for

down here he’s getting worse for

down here he’s getting worse for numeracy but getting better for literacy

numeracy but getting better for literacy

numeracy but getting better for literacy and it really does matter both for the

and it really does matter both for the

and it really does matter both for the UK and for individuals themselves for

UK and for individuals themselves for

UK and for individuals themselves for the UK a conservative estimate sees poor

the UK a conservative estimate sees poor

the UK a conservative estimate sees poor numeracy costing the economy twenty

numeracy costing the economy twenty

numeracy costing the economy twenty point two billion pounds a year and for

point two billion pounds a year and for

point two billion pounds a year and for individuals research than the OECD

individuals research than the OECD

individuals research than the OECD suggests that good numeracy is the best

suggests that good numeracy is the best

suggests that good numeracy is the best protection against unemployment low

protection against unemployment low

protection against unemployment low wages and poor health more significant

wages and poor health more significant

wages and poor health more significant than literacy or any other variable but

than literacy or any other variable but

than literacy or any other variable but they measure so this is an issue for

they measure so this is an issue for

they measure so this is an issue for millions across the country and indeed

millions across the country and indeed

millions across the country and indeed across the world but there is a way

across the world but there is a way

across the world but there is a way forward and it’s not about teaching ever

forward and it’s not about teaching ever

forward and it’s not about teaching ever more complex

more complex

more complex in schools instead there are three

in schools instead there are three

in schools instead there are three things that we need to enable everyone

things that we need to enable everyone

things that we need to enable everyone to be confident and competent to use

to be confident and competent to use

to be confident and competent to use numbers and data in daily life

numbers and data in daily life

numbers and data in daily life the first is value valuing the

the first is value valuing the

the first is value valuing the importance not so much of the complex

importance not so much of the complex

importance not so much of the complex maths in simple situations that you’re

maths in simple situations that you’re

maths in simple situations that you’re often presented with at school but

often presented with at school but

often presented with at school but instead the value of being able to use

instead the value of being able to use

instead the value of being able to use normally rather simple maths but to help

normally rather simple maths but to help

normally rather simple maths but to help you make good decisions in daily life

you make good decisions in daily life

you make good decisions in daily life the second element is belief or mindset

the second element is belief or mindset

the second element is belief or mindset and this is basically shifting from I

and this is basically shifting from I

and this is basically shifting from I can’t do maths to I can’t do math yet

can’t do maths to I can’t do math yet

can’t do maths to I can’t do math yet there is no math gene or to put it

there is no math gene or to put it

there is no math gene or to put it another way we all have the genetic

another way we all have the genetic

another way we all have the genetic makeup to become numerous and there’s a

makeup to become numerous and there’s a

makeup to become numerous and there’s a growing body of evidence from

growing body of evidence from

growing body of evidence from neuroscience and behavioral psychology

neuroscience and behavioral psychology

neuroscience and behavioral psychology from the work of Carol Dweck Angela

from the work of Carol Dweck Angela

from the work of Carol Dweck Angela Duckworth Joe bola Daniel Kahneman 17

Duckworth Joe bola Daniel Kahneman 17

Duckworth Joe bola Daniel Kahneman 17 times 24 is from him by the way and

times 24 is from him by the way and

times 24 is from him by the way and indeed our work at national numeracy

indeed our work at national numeracy

indeed our work at national numeracy that’s starting to destroy what Matthew

that’s starting to destroy what Matthew

that’s starting to destroy what Matthew cyi calls the talent myth something

cyi calls the talent myth something

cyi calls the talent myth something particularly prevalent around maths and

particularly prevalent around maths and

particularly prevalent around maths and the final elements is effort what does

the final elements is effort what does

the final elements is effort what does it feel like when you don’t know what to

it feel like when you don’t know what to

it feel like when you don’t know what to do formative moments always start by

do formative moments always start by

do formative moments always start by being uncomfortable

being uncomfortable

being uncomfortable that’s mentally but it also applies

that’s mentally but it also applies

that’s mentally but it also applies physically we’ve got to struggle and get

physically we’ve got to struggle and get

physically we’ve got to struggle and get things wrong a lot in order to

things wrong a lot in order to

things wrong a lot in order to eventually succeed

eventually succeed

eventually succeed indeed as NASA Nicholas Taleb points out

indeed as NASA Nicholas Taleb points out

indeed as NASA Nicholas Taleb points out acute or short-term effort and

acute or short-term effort and

acute or short-term effort and discomfort is good or probably even

discomfort is good or probably even

discomfort is good or probably even vital for us and the avoidance of

vital for us and the avoidance of

vital for us and the avoidance of short-term discomfort leads to chronic

short-term discomfort leads to chronic

short-term discomfort leads to chronic or long-term discomfort and if you buy

or long-term discomfort and if you buy

or long-term discomfort and if you buy that it might be worth thinking about

that it might be worth thinking about

that it might be worth thinking about when was the last time you were outside

when was the last time you were outside

when was the last time you were outside your comfort zone and I’m not including

your comfort zone and I’m not including

your comfort zone and I’m not including a few seconds nine and a half minutes

a few seconds nine and a half minutes

a few seconds nine and a half minutes ago so to sum up the lesson that we need

ago so to sum up the lesson that we need

ago so to sum up the lesson that we need to take from the mass classroom is not I

to take from the mass classroom is not I

to take from the mass classroom is not I can’t do maths but instead that

can’t do maths but instead that

can’t do maths but instead that discomfort is the starting point for any

discomfort is the starting point for any

discomfort is the starting point for any formative moment or opportunity for

formative moment or opportunity for

formative moment or opportunity for learning and that this is at its most

learning and that this is at its most

learning and that this is at its most stark in

stark in

stark in so no matter what stage of life you’re

so no matter what stage of life you’re

so no matter what stage of life you’re at you can reform formative moments if

at you can reform formative moments if

at you can reform formative moments if you need to you can become numerous

you need to you can become numerous

you need to you can become numerous indeed you can do almost anything to a

indeed you can do almost anything to a

indeed you can do almost anything to a decent level but only if you’re prepared

decent level but only if you’re prepared

decent level but only if you’re prepared to become comfortable with being

to become comfortable with being

to become comfortable with being uncomfortable thank you

uncomfortable thank you

uncomfortable thank you [Applause]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *