Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Importance of Developing Your Foreign Policy | Stéfanie von Hlatky | TEDxQueensU


what is your foreign policy if you’re in

what is your foreign policy if you’re in this audience you’re probably thinking

this audience you’re probably thinking

this audience you’re probably thinking about Canada’s foreign policy maybe

about Canada’s foreign policy maybe

about Canada’s foreign policy maybe you’re thinking about peacekeeping free

you’re thinking about peacekeeping free

you’re thinking about peacekeeping free trade agreements climate change the

trade agreements climate change the

trade agreements climate change the United States Trudeau is about to unveil

United States Trudeau is about to unveil

United States Trudeau is about to unveil a new defense policy after months and

a new defense policy after months and

a new defense policy after months and months of public consultations yet there

months of public consultations yet there

months of public consultations yet there has been no similar exercise done on the

has been no similar exercise done on the

has been no similar exercise done on the foreign policy side under the Harper

foreign policy side under the Harper

foreign policy side under the Harper government there was a defence policy

government there was a defence policy

government there was a defence policy statements but no foreign policy

statements but no foreign policy

statements but no foreign policy statement so I guess it’s up to us

statement so I guess it’s up to us

statement so I guess it’s up to us individual citizens to define our own

individual citizens to define our own

individual citizens to define our own foreign policy preferences foreign

foreign policy preferences foreign

foreign policy preferences foreign policy is about how governments engage

policy is about how governments engage

policy is about how governments engage internationally to uphold foreign policy

internationally to uphold foreign policy

internationally to uphold foreign policy principles you need sound diplomacy you

principles you need sound diplomacy you

principles you need sound diplomacy you need aid dollars for International

need aid dollars for International

need aid dollars for International Development and sometimes you need to

Development and sometimes you need to

Development and sometimes you need to protect these principles with military

protect these principles with military

protect these principles with military force and as this last scenario that I

force and as this last scenario that I

force and as this last scenario that I want to discuss with you today by asking

want to discuss with you today by asking

want to discuss with you today by asking which principles should we defend on the

which principles should we defend on the

which principles should we defend on the international stage which countries

international stage which countries

international stage which countries should we be willing to send troops into

should we be willing to send troops into

should we be willing to send troops into harm’s way for to explore these

harm’s way for to explore these

harm’s way for to explore these questions I want to think about events

questions I want to think about events

questions I want to think about events of the recent past in 2014 we witnessed

of the recent past in 2014 we witnessed

of the recent past in 2014 we witnessed the territorial aggression of Ukraine by

the territorial aggression of Ukraine by

the territorial aggression of Ukraine by Russia to protect russian-speaking

Russia to protect russian-speaking

Russia to protect russian-speaking minorities according to Putin now Canada

minorities according to Putin now Canada

minorities according to Putin now Canada is under no obligation to protect

is under no obligation to protect

is under no obligation to protect Ukraine Ukraine is not a member of NATO

Ukraine Ukraine is not a member of NATO

Ukraine Ukraine is not a member of NATO Ukraine is not protected by article 5 of

Ukraine is not protected by article 5 of

Ukraine is not protected by article 5 of The Washington treaty NATO’s founding

The Washington treaty NATO’s founding

The Washington treaty NATO’s founding treaty which promises mutual defense in

treaty which promises mutual defense in

treaty which promises mutual defense in case of an attack now there are other

case of an attack now there are other

case of an attack now there are other countries NATO countries who also have

countries NATO countries who also have

countries NATO countries who also have Russian

Russian

Russian speaking minorities on their territory

speaking minorities on their territory

speaking minorities on their territory think about the Baltic States can anyone

think about the Baltic States can anyone

think about the Baltic States can anyone tell me where a dodgy is well it’s in

tell me where a dodgy is well it’s in

tell me where a dodgy is well it’s in Latvia and it’s where the Canadian Armed

Latvia and it’s where the Canadian Armed

Latvia and it’s where the Canadian Armed Forces will be deployed to this spring

Forces will be deployed to this spring

Forces will be deployed to this spring the United States Germany the UK are

the United States Germany the UK are

the United States Germany the UK are doing something similar by sending

doing something similar by sending

doing something similar by sending forces to Estonia Lithuania Poland these

forces to Estonia Lithuania Poland these

forces to Estonia Lithuania Poland these deployments should be understood through

deployments should be understood through

deployments should be understood through the prism of collective defence Canada

the prism of collective defence Canada

the prism of collective defence Canada and its 27 other NATO allies are bound

and its 27 other NATO allies are bound

and its 27 other NATO allies are bound together by this pledge now it’s not the

together by this pledge now it’s not the

together by this pledge now it’s not the first time that Canadian troops are

first time that Canadian troops are

first time that Canadian troops are going to Europe vimi’s centennial

going to Europe vimi’s centennial

going to Europe vimi’s centennial anniversary is a reminder of that are we

anniversary is a reminder of that are we

anniversary is a reminder of that are we inching closer to World War 3 think

inching closer to World War 3 think

inching closer to World War 3 think about the impact of such a war with

about the impact of such a war with

about the impact of such a war with today’s technology armed drones smart

today’s technology armed drones smart

today’s technology armed drones smart bombs stealth fighters and of course

bombs stealth fighters and of course

bombs stealth fighters and of course nuclear weapons are still around

nuclear weapons are still around

nuclear weapons are still around worrying indeed which is all the more

worrying indeed which is all the more

worrying indeed which is all the more reason not to be passive observers of

reason not to be passive observers of

reason not to be passive observers of foreign policy NATO allies including

foreign policy NATO allies including

foreign policy NATO allies including Canada have been used to following the

Canada have been used to following the

Canada have been used to following the u.s. lead for so long but now with an

u.s. lead for so long but now with an

u.s. lead for so long but now with an ill-conceived grand strategy under

ill-conceived grand strategy under

ill-conceived grand strategy under President Donald Trump look no further

President Donald Trump look no further

President Donald Trump look no further than Twitter it’s time for Canada to

than Twitter it’s time for Canada to

than Twitter it’s time for Canada to start identifying foreign policy

start identifying foreign policy

start identifying foreign policy priorities and defense capabilities to

priorities and defense capabilities to

priorities and defense capabilities to match and they go hand in hand

match and they go hand in hand

match and they go hand in hand by the way our elected officials are

by the way our elected officials are

by the way our elected officials are meant to identify foreign policy

meant to identify foreign policy

meant to identify foreign policy priorities and these priorities are

priorities and these priorities are

priorities and these priorities are supposed to shape the types of defense

supposed to shape the types of defense

supposed to shape the types of defense capabilities that we need but how do we

capabilities that we need but how do we

capabilities that we need but how do we know where to invest if there are no

know where to invest if there are no

know where to invest if there are no clear foreign policy objectives how do

clear foreign policy objectives how do

clear foreign policy objectives how do we know what to buy with our hard-earned

we know what to buy with our hard-earned

we know what to buy with our hard-earned dollars when budgets are always so tight

dollars when budgets are always so tight

dollars when budgets are always so tight in the military at least there are

in the military at least there are

in the military at least there are forecasting

forecasting

forecasting exercises to help us think through these

exercises to help us think through these

exercises to help us think through these questions by comparing alternative

questions by comparing alternative

questions by comparing alternative scenarios were able to identify

scenarios were able to identify

scenarios were able to identify potential missions defense capabilities

potential missions defense capabilities

potential missions defense capabilities and training requirements now I’ve had

and training requirements now I’ve had

and training requirements now I’ve had the opportunity to take part in these

the opportunity to take part in these

the opportunity to take part in these forecasting exercises with both the

forecasting exercises with both the

forecasting exercises with both the Canadian Army and the US Army and I

Canadian Army and the US Army and I

Canadian Army and the US Army and I always learn a lot they go a little

always learn a lot they go a little

always learn a lot they go a little something like this I want everyone here

something like this I want everyone here

something like this I want everyone here to imagine two alternative futures the

to imagine two alternative futures the

to imagine two alternative futures the first one which we’ll call the perfect

first one which we’ll call the perfect

first one which we’ll call the perfect green world is a world where

green world is a world where

green world is a world where technological innovation is supporting

technological innovation is supporting

technological innovation is supporting economic growth in a sustainable way and

economic growth in a sustainable way and

economic growth in a sustainable way and the world’s problems are addressed by

the world’s problems are addressed by

the world’s problems are addressed by States working collectively the other

States working collectively the other

States working collectively the other world will call the hopeless world and

world will call the hopeless world and

world will call the hopeless world and in this world there’s acute resource

in this world there’s acute resource

in this world there’s acute resource scarcity there are pockets of

scarcity there are pockets of

scarcity there are pockets of instability in every single region of

instability in every single region of

instability in every single region of the world and there’s profound distrust

the world and there’s profound distrust

the world and there’s profound distrust between states which makes international

between states which makes international

between states which makes international cooperation almost impossible in this

cooperation almost impossible in this

cooperation almost impossible in this world Canada is targeted by resource

world Canada is targeted by resource

world Canada is targeted by resource starved adversaries let’s face it

starved adversaries let’s face it

starved adversaries let’s face it Canada is rich but vulnerable and in the

Canada is rich but vulnerable and in the

Canada is rich but vulnerable and in the hopeless world Canada cannot rely on

hopeless world Canada cannot rely on

hopeless world Canada cannot rely on Uncle Sam the bodyguard by contrast in

Uncle Sam the bodyguard by contrast in

Uncle Sam the bodyguard by contrast in the perfect green world Canada is

the perfect green world Canada is

the perfect green world Canada is primarily focused on upholding

primarily focused on upholding

primarily focused on upholding international institutions an

international institutions an

international institutions an international law the Canadian Forces

international law the Canadian Forces

international law the Canadian Forces would be called upon to respond to

would be called upon to respond to

would be called upon to respond to environmental disasters and humanitarian

environmental disasters and humanitarian

environmental disasters and humanitarian crises so we would be primarily focused

crises so we would be primarily focused

crises so we would be primarily focused on disaster assistance much like they

on disaster assistance much like they

on disaster assistance much like they did two years ago in the Philippines

did two years ago in the Philippines

did two years ago in the Philippines under that scenario the military needs a

under that scenario the military needs a

under that scenario the military needs a diverse toolkit needs to work very

diverse toolkit needs to work very

diverse toolkit needs to work very closely with

closely with

closely with they’re government partners and NGOs but

they’re government partners and NGOs but

they’re government partners and NGOs but you do not you do not need a very large

you do not you do not need a very large

you do not you do not need a very large military force and you certainly do not

military force and you certainly do not

military force and you certainly do not need a fifth-generation stealth fighter

need a fifth-generation stealth fighter

need a fifth-generation stealth fighter jets but you better hope and pray that

jets but you better hope and pray that

jets but you better hope and pray that the world does not change in the

the world does not change in the

the world does not change in the hopeless world Canada is being targeted

hopeless world Canada is being targeted

hopeless world Canada is being targeted because of its abundant resources water

because of its abundant resources water

because of its abundant resources water and breathable air remember this is a

and breathable air remember this is a

and breathable air remember this is a world where there is competition between

world where there is competition between

world where there is competition between states these states pursue their very

states these states pursue their very

states these states pursue their very narrow interests and where resources are

narrow interests and where resources are

narrow interests and where resources are rare and extremely valuable under this

rare and extremely valuable under this

rare and extremely valuable under this scenario Canada would need a much more

scenario Canada would need a much more

scenario Canada would need a much more important land component to protect

important land component to protect

important land component to protect critical infrastructure and coastlines a

critical infrastructure and coastlines a

critical infrastructure and coastlines a much bigger naval presence perfect

much bigger naval presence perfect

much bigger naval presence perfect surveillance across Canada’s very vast

surveillance across Canada’s very vast

surveillance across Canada’s very vast territory Canada would need probably to

territory Canada would need probably to

territory Canada would need probably to triple its military at least and to

triple its military at least and to

triple its military at least and to invest in high-tech weapon systems

invest in high-tech weapon systems

invest in high-tech weapon systems does this sound expensive you bet but

does this sound expensive you bet but

does this sound expensive you bet but Canada would be facing a threats to its

Canada would be facing a threats to its

Canada would be facing a threats to its core interests its sovereignty its

core interests its sovereignty its

core interests its sovereignty its territorial integrity now the point of

territorial integrity now the point of

territorial integrity now the point of comparing these two worlds is to

comparing these two worlds is to

comparing these two worlds is to understand that international events

understand that international events

understand that international events evolve really quickly and that they are

evolve really quickly and that they are

evolve really quickly and that they are very often outside of your control the

very often outside of your control the

very often outside of your control the rub is that procurement cycle meaning

rub is that procurement cycle meaning

rub is that procurement cycle meaning the time between when you identify a

the time between when you identify a

the time between when you identify a capability that you need then you buy it

capability that you need then you buy it

capability that you need then you buy it and then it becomes operational can take

and then it becomes operational can take

and then it becomes operational can take decades and because we cannot afford to

decades and because we cannot afford to

decades and because we cannot afford to be reactive we hedge our bets we try to

be reactive we hedge our bets we try to

be reactive we hedge our bets we try to find the overlap between the perfect

find the overlap between the perfect

find the overlap between the perfect world and the hopeless world in both

world and the hopeless world in both

world and the hopeless world in both worlds you need a respectable

worlds you need a respectable

worlds you need a respectable well-trained military to protect foreign

well-trained military to protect foreign

well-trained military to protect foreign policy objectives otherwise your only

policy objectives otherwise your only

policy objectives otherwise your only option is to follow

option is to follow

option is to follow or be submissive when challenged let’s

or be submissive when challenged let’s

or be submissive when challenged let’s bring this back to the challenges that

bring this back to the challenges that

bring this back to the challenges that we’re facing today there are enduring

we’re facing today there are enduring

we’re facing today there are enduring conflicts and the international

conflicts and the international

conflicts and the international community is divided on how to respond

community is divided on how to respond

community is divided on how to respond think about the Islamic state militants

think about the Islamic state militants

think about the Islamic state militants in Iraq and Syria think about Russia and

in Iraq and Syria think about Russia and

in Iraq and Syria think about Russia and Ukraine think about North Korea’s mood

Ukraine think about North Korea’s mood

Ukraine think about North Korea’s mood swings or tensions in the East and South

swings or tensions in the East and South

swings or tensions in the East and South China Sea with such pressing global

China Sea with such pressing global

China Sea with such pressing global problems why is it so hard for Canadian

problems why is it so hard for Canadian

problems why is it so hard for Canadian citizens to engage in this foreign

citizens to engage in this foreign

citizens to engage in this foreign policy debate I think that much of this

policy debate I think that much of this

policy debate I think that much of this did ring in foreign policy is due to the

did ring in foreign policy is due to the

did ring in foreign policy is due to the fact that most of us who have not served

fact that most of us who have not served

fact that most of us who have not served in the military have never asked

in the military have never asked

in the military have never asked ourselves what we would be willing to

ourselves what we would be willing to

ourselves what we would be willing to fight for and I don’t mean that

fight for and I don’t mean that

fight for and I don’t mean that figuratively I don’t mean tweet shaming

figuratively I don’t mean tweet shaming

figuratively I don’t mean tweet shaming Boko Haram or dumping an ice bucket on

Boko Haram or dumping an ice bucket on

Boko Haram or dumping an ice bucket on your head I mean really fighting

your head I mean really fighting

your head I mean really fighting fighting knowing that you might die in

fighting knowing that you might die in

fighting knowing that you might die in the process so I want to go back to the

the process so I want to go back to the

the process so I want to go back to the questions I posed earlier and this time

questions I posed earlier and this time

questions I posed earlier and this time I want us to think about it on a more

I want us to think about it on a more

I want us to think about it on a more personal level what would you be willing

personal level what would you be willing

personal level what would you be willing to fight for which principles would you

to fight for which principles would you

to fight for which principles would you be willing to die to uphold and which

be willing to die to uphold and which

be willing to die to uphold and which countries deserve the protection of

countries deserve the protection of

countries deserve the protection of those security assurances when you put

those security assurances when you put

those security assurances when you put it in those terms foreign policy becomes

it in those terms foreign policy becomes

it in those terms foreign policy becomes a high-stakes game and this brings me to

a high-stakes game and this brings me to

a high-stakes game and this brings me to my last point I believe that military

my last point I believe that military

my last point I believe that military interventions should be as costly as

interventions should be as costly as

interventions should be as costly as possible not because we want to

possible not because we want to

possible not because we want to mismanage or waste money no but because

mismanage or waste money no but because

mismanage or waste money no but because it should imply a sacrifice I’m very

it should imply a sacrifice I’m very

it should imply a sacrifice I’m very partial to the argument that when we

partial to the argument that when we

partial to the argument that when we borrow money to fund wars or when we

borrow money to fund wars or when we

borrow money to fund wars or when we rely on an all voluntary professed

rely on an all voluntary professed

rely on an all voluntary professed a military force to do the fighting the

a military force to do the fighting the

a military force to do the fighting the average citizen does not feel the cost

average citizen does not feel the cost

average citizen does not feel the cost of war the average citizen does feel the

of war the average citizen does feel the

of war the average citizen does feel the cost of war when we’re doing the

cost of war when we’re doing the

cost of war when we’re doing the fighting or when we’re feeling a

fighting or when we’re feeling a

fighting or when we’re feeling a significant financial strain and when

significant financial strain and when

significant financial strain and when that’s the case then we pay much greater

that’s the case then we pay much greater

that’s the case then we pay much greater attention to foreign policy and demand

attention to foreign policy and demand

attention to foreign policy and demand accountability for decisions involving

accountability for decisions involving

accountability for decisions involving the use of force now I’m not advocating

the use of force now I’m not advocating

the use of force now I’m not advocating for a war tax and I’m not advocating for

for a war tax and I’m not advocating for

for a war tax and I’m not advocating for conscription but I am advocating for

conscription but I am advocating for

conscription but I am advocating for greater engagement on foreign policy and

greater engagement on foreign policy and

greater engagement on foreign policy and the way that we can do that is by making

the way that we can do that is by making

the way that we can do that is by making these decisions our business and here

these decisions our business and here

these decisions our business and here I’m gonna refer to another cost distinct

I’m gonna refer to another cost distinct

I’m gonna refer to another cost distinct from blood and treasure which is a

from blood and treasure which is a

from blood and treasure which is a personal cost politicians can be

personal cost politicians can be

personal cost politicians can be lampooned for ill-conceived

lampooned for ill-conceived

lampooned for ill-conceived foreign policy designs think iran-contra

foreign policy designs think iran-contra

foreign policy designs think iran-contra think the Iraq war of 2003 but average

think the Iraq war of 2003 but average

think the Iraq war of 2003 but average citizens won’t find their face on the

citizens won’t find their face on the

citizens won’t find their face on the front page of a newspaper if a foreign

front page of a newspaper if a foreign

front page of a newspaper if a foreign policy goes wrong but we can take

policy goes wrong but we can take

policy goes wrong but we can take greater ownership however and to do that

greater ownership however and to do that

greater ownership however and to do that you’ve got to put yourself out there

you’ve got to put yourself out there

you’ve got to put yourself out there here’s how step one pick a foreign

here’s how step one pick a foreign

here’s how step one pick a foreign policy issue that you’re interested in

policy issue that you’re interested in

policy issue that you’re interested in step two study both sides of the issue

step two study both sides of the issue

step two study both sides of the issue like you are preparing for a debate

like you are preparing for a debate

like you are preparing for a debate step three find at least two people that

step three find at least two people that

step three find at least two people that you can discuss the issue with

you can discuss the issue with

you can discuss the issue with and they may not agree with you step 4

and they may not agree with you step 4

and they may not agree with you step 4 articulate that position publicly either

articulate that position publicly either

articulate that position publicly either on social media on a blog or in the

on social media on a blog or in the

on social media on a blog or in the opinion pages of your favorite newspaper

opinion pages of your favorite newspaper

opinion pages of your favorite newspaper step 5

step 5

step 5 update your position as new information

update your position as new information

update your position as new information becomes available and step 6 repeat with

becomes available and step 6 repeat with

becomes available and step 6 repeat with the same issue or a new one by doing

the same issue or a new one by doing

the same issue or a new one by doing that you are doing your part to help

that you are doing your part to help

that you are doing your part to help democratize foreign policy challenge

democratize foreign policy challenge

democratize foreign policy challenge your social networks

your social networks

your social networks both online and offline to think about

both online and offline to think about

both online and offline to think about the kind of world they want to live in

the kind of world they want to live in

the kind of world they want to live in by taking a public stance on an issue

by taking a public stance on an issue

by taking a public stance on an issue you are becoming a stakeholder and you

you are becoming a stakeholder and you

you are becoming a stakeholder and you will begin to feel a closer tie to the

will begin to feel a closer tie to the

will begin to feel a closer tie to the decisions that are made by our political

decisions that are made by our political

decisions that are made by our political leaders so I hope that today you answer

leaders so I hope that today you answer

leaders so I hope that today you answer the call for deeper engagement on

the call for deeper engagement on

the call for deeper engagement on foreign policy in fact I hope that you

foreign policy in fact I hope that you

foreign policy in fact I hope that you now see this as part of your civic duty

now see this as part of your civic duty

now see this as part of your civic duty as a parting thought I will take the

as a parting thought I will take the

as a parting thought I will take the easy way out and quote Albert Einstein

easy way out and quote Albert Einstein

easy way out and quote Albert Einstein peace cannot be kept by force

peace cannot be kept by force

peace cannot be kept by force it can only be achieved by understanding

it can only be achieved by understanding

it can only be achieved by understanding now be part of shaping that

now be part of shaping that

now be part of shaping that understanding

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

[Music]

[Music] [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *