
[Applause] let’s talk about artificial intelligence
let’s talk about artificial intelligence
let’s talk about artificial intelligence and before most of us were born there
and before most of us were born there
and before most of us were born there was already a good part of literature
was already a good part of literature
was already a good part of literature about science fiction and artificial
about science fiction and artificial
about science fiction and artificial intelligence for example Isaac Asimov
intelligence for example Isaac Asimov
intelligence for example Isaac Asimov has written a book about a robot who can
has written a book about a robot who can
has written a book about a robot who can think like a human and probably you’ve
think like a human and probably you’ve
think like a human and probably you’ve seen the film with this i robot with
seen the film with this i robot with
seen the film with this i robot with will smith and at the same time Philip
will smith and at the same time Philip
will smith and at the same time Philip dick wrote a novel story about a robot
dick wrote a novel story about a robot
dick wrote a novel story about a robot who was thinking he was a human and this
who was thinking he was a human and this
who was thinking he was a human and this story was the background for blade
story was the background for blade
story was the background for blade runner you have seen this film perhaps
runner you have seen this film perhaps
runner you have seen this film perhaps this movie so the idea of artificial
this movie so the idea of artificial
this movie so the idea of artificial intelligence that we can create
intelligence that we can create
intelligence that we can create computers that can really think like
computers that can really think like
computers that can really think like humans has been around for a very long
humans has been around for a very long
humans has been around for a very long time and i would like to combine it
time and i would like to combine it
time and i would like to combine it today with two different passions of
today with two different passions of
today with two different passions of mind behind science fiction literature
mind behind science fiction literature
mind behind science fiction literature so my second passion i would like to
so my second passion i would like to
so my second passion i would like to share with you it’s machine learning
share with you it’s machine learning
share with you it’s machine learning machine learning is this kind of pattern
machine learning is this kind of pattern
machine learning is this kind of pattern recognition that makes everything smart
recognition that makes everything smart
recognition that makes everything smart from your smartphone to ultra nomas cars
from your smartphone to ultra nomas cars
from your smartphone to ultra nomas cars and i’m teaching machine learning at the
and i’m teaching machine learning at the
and i’m teaching machine learning at the university and doing a lot of machine
university and doing a lot of machine
university and doing a lot of machine learning and from time to time i even
learning and from time to time i even
learning and from time to time i even dream machine learning and this sounds
dream machine learning and this sounds
dream machine learning and this sounds weird but it even gets worse because i’m
weird but it even gets worse because i’m
weird but it even gets worse because i’m a big fan of the philosophy of Hegel you
a big fan of the philosophy of Hegel you
a big fan of the philosophy of Hegel you know geography pleased with him he the
know geography pleased with him he the
know geography pleased with him he the old German philosopher was famous for
old German philosopher was famous for
old German philosopher was famous for his dialectics and what I would like to
his dialectics and what I would like to
his dialectics and what I would like to show to you is if you put these three
show to you is if you put these three
show to you is if you put these three things together artificial intelligence
things together artificial intelligence
things together artificial intelligence machine learning and the philosophy of
machine learning and the philosophy of
machine learning and the philosophy of legal you got a combination that is like
legal you got a combination that is like
legal you got a combination that is like gasoline and matches I think that we
gasoline and matches I think that we
gasoline and matches I think that we will see in the next five years
will see in the next five years
will see in the next five years something like artificial spirits with
something like artificial spirits with
something like artificial spirits with this I mean computer programs that are
this I mean computer programs that are
this I mean computer programs that are really able to
really able to
really able to you make operation similar to human
you make operation similar to human
you make operation similar to human thinking but without the complexity of
thinking but without the complexity of
thinking but without the complexity of the human mind but if we can reach this
the human mind but if we can reach this
the human mind but if we can reach this step then soon after perhaps even 2025
step then soon after perhaps even 2025
step then soon after perhaps even 2025 we might reach a point where we have an
we might reach a point where we have an
we might reach a point where we have an artificial mind the thing all this
artificial mind the thing all this
artificial mind the thing all this science fiction literature is dreaming
science fiction literature is dreaming
science fiction literature is dreaming about a computer that is able to think
about a computer that is able to think
about a computer that is able to think and has a consciousness and then if this
and has a consciousness and then if this
and has a consciousness and then if this would happen shortly after we probably
would happen shortly after we probably
would happen shortly after we probably will have super intelligence the
will have super intelligence the
will have super intelligence the computer that is superior in all kind of
computer that is superior in all kind of
computer that is superior in all kind of cognitive tasks compared with any human
cognitive tasks compared with any human
cognitive tasks compared with any human well I know that at least ninety percent
well I know that at least ninety percent
well I know that at least ninety percent of AI researchers will strongly disagree
of AI researchers will strongly disagree
of AI researchers will strongly disagree with me about this time scale but let’s
with me about this time scale but let’s
with me about this time scale but let’s have a look what a is and then I will
have a look what a is and then I will
have a look what a is and then I will give it a dialectic turn because i would
give it a dialectic turn because i would
give it a dialectic turn because i would like to convince you first that real AI
like to convince you first that real AI
like to convince you first that real AI a computer that things like a human is
a computer that things like a human is
a computer that things like a human is not possible and then i will convince
not possible and then i will convince
not possible and then i will convince you that this was wrong so this is my
you that this was wrong so this is my
you that this was wrong so this is my plan i I can be defined as intelligence
plan i I can be defined as intelligence
plan i I can be defined as intelligence exhibited by machines and this was the
exhibited by machines and this was the
exhibited by machines and this was the big program early AI researchers were
big program early AI researchers were
big program early AI researchers were trying to find from the beginning
trying to find from the beginning
trying to find from the beginning touring was dreaming about AI everyone
touring was dreaming about AI everyone
touring was dreaming about AI everyone was very excited in the 50s but what we
was very excited in the 50s but what we
was very excited in the 50s but what we have today is something else if you look
have today is something else if you look
have today is something else if you look at them state of the art in AI research
at them state of the art in AI research
at them state of the art in AI research we have mostly machine learning and
we have mostly machine learning and
we have mostly machine learning and Andrew entering one of the most
Andrew entering one of the most
Andrew entering one of the most important researchers in the field of AI
important researchers in the field of AI
important researchers in the field of AI he has said it like this almost all of a
he has said it like this almost all of a
he has said it like this almost all of a ice recent progress is through one type
ice recent progress is through one type
ice recent progress is through one type and in which some input data a is used
and in which some input data a is used
and in which some input data a is used to quickly generate some response be and
to quickly generate some response be and
to quickly generate some response be and this is for example when you think about
this is for example when you think about
this is for example when you think about your smartphone and theory or the google
your smartphone and theory or the google
your smartphone and theory or the google assistance you can ask any kind of
assistance you can ask any kind of
assistance you can ask any kind of question and this
question and this
question and this language is the data a and then there is
language is the data a and then there is
language is the data a and then there is a mathematical function you don’t have
a mathematical function you don’t have
a mathematical function you don’t have to care about they transfer this input
to care about they transfer this input
to care about they transfer this input data a into an output a good answer to
data a into an output a good answer to
data a into an output a good answer to your question that is B but this output
your question that is B but this output
your question that is B but this output is already known before you are asking
is already known before you are asking
is already known before you are asking your questions so what the computer only
your questions so what the computer only
your questions so what the computer only can do is to fit with mathematical terms
can do is to fit with mathematical terms
can do is to fit with mathematical terms the input a to an already known be and
the input a to an already known be and
the input a to an already known be and because of this John Searle was arguing
because of this John Searle was arguing
because of this John Searle was arguing that artificial intelligence is not
that artificial intelligence is not
that artificial intelligence is not possible and he used the thought
possible and he used the thought
possible and he used the thought experiment to do this it’s the famous
experiment to do this it’s the famous
experiment to do this it’s the famous Chinese room officer the experiment
Chinese room officer the experiment
Chinese room officer the experiment thought experiment goes like this Searle
thought experiment goes like this Searle
thought experiment goes like this Searle is sitting in a room and someone is
is sitting in a room and someone is
is sitting in a room and someone is handing in papers with Chinese symbols
handing in papers with Chinese symbols
handing in papers with Chinese symbols on the papers and Searle has a big book
on the papers and Searle has a big book
on the papers and Searle has a big book with a lot of rules a kind of algorithm
with a lot of rules a kind of algorithm
with a lot of rules a kind of algorithm and uses this rules to transfer the
and uses this rules to transfer the
and uses this rules to transfer the symbols to other Chinese symbols and
symbols to other Chinese symbols and
symbols to other Chinese symbols and hence them out and from the outside it
hence them out and from the outside it
hence them out and from the outside it might look as if so was able to speak
might look as if so was able to speak
might look as if so was able to speak perfectly Chinese because it does
perfectly Chinese because it does
perfectly Chinese because it does exactly what zelia might do on the
exactly what zelia might do on the
exactly what zelia might do on the smartphone all answers are right
smartphone all answers are right
smartphone all answers are right everything makes sense but so in this
everything makes sense but so in this
everything makes sense but so in this room will never ever understand a word
room will never ever understand a word
room will never ever understand a word of Chinese he has no consciousness about
of Chinese he has no consciousness about
of Chinese he has no consciousness about what he’s doing he has no clue what he’s
what he’s doing he has no clue what he’s
what he’s doing he has no clue what he’s doing and this is a metaphor for what is
doing and this is a metaphor for what is
doing and this is a metaphor for what is going on in computers and as long as we
going on in computers and as long as we
going on in computers and as long as we try to teach computers this way to go
try to teach computers this way to go
try to teach computers this way to go from A to B with a mathematical function
from A to B with a mathematical function
from A to B with a mathematical function there is really no way that they can
there is really no way that they can
there is really no way that they can understand what they are doing and they
understand what they are doing and they
understand what they are doing and they won’t get intelligent and theory won’t
won’t get intelligent and theory won’t
won’t get intelligent and theory won’t become your best friend said news but
become your best friend said news but
become your best friend said news but what is wrong about this whole picture
what is wrong about this whole picture
what is wrong about this whole picture is not the definition of what a is doing
is not the definition of what a is doing
is not the definition of what a is doing in this room but what thinking is if you
in this room but what thinking is if you
in this room but what thinking is if you think about we’re thinking is thinking
think about we’re thinking is thinking
think about we’re thinking is thinking is definitely something else than just
is definitely something else than just
is definitely something else than just having a known a and a known be and
having a known a and a known be and
having a known a and a known be and tried
tried
tried get from A to B but if you start to
get from A to B but if you start to
get from A to B but if you start to think you don’t know where you end up
think you don’t know where you end up
think you don’t know where you end up you don’t know the be so inserts Chinese
you don’t know the be so inserts Chinese
you don’t know the be so inserts Chinese room there is really no room for a
room there is really no room for a
room there is really no room for a thought because everything is given up
thought because everything is given up
thought because everything is given up front and here comes higley so imagine
front and here comes higley so imagine
front and here comes higley so imagine the door of the Chinese room opens higa
the door of the Chinese room opens higa
the door of the Chinese room opens higa comes in and says lay aside your book so
comes in and says lay aside your book so
comes in and says lay aside your book so I gonna teach you how to think because
I gonna teach you how to think because
I gonna teach you how to think because this was what he was really deeply
this was what he was really deeply
this was what he was really deeply involved he said there are rules how we
involved he said there are rules how we
involved he said there are rules how we think and these rules are called logic
think and these rules are called logic
think and these rules are called logic well the logical figure is very
well the logical figure is very
well the logical figure is very complicated but I think you can simplify
complicated but I think you can simplify
complicated but I think you can simplify it to three simple rules and I hope
it to three simple rules and I hope
it to three simple rules and I hope there are no philosophers here because
there are no philosophers here because
there are no philosophers here because otherwise I get shot for this one first
otherwise I get shot for this one first
otherwise I get shot for this one first rule is no second rule is bad and the
rule is no second rule is bad and the
rule is no second rule is bad and the third rule is reflection or I give it to
third rule is reflection or I give it to
third rule is reflection or I give it to you in the words of Hegel it would be
you in the words of Hegel it would be
you in the words of Hegel it would be omnis determine a cos Nicasio which is
omnis determine a cos Nicasio which is
omnis determine a cos Nicasio which is latin and means everything that is
latin and means everything that is
latin and means everything that is dieter mind is the negation the two
dieter mind is the negation the two
dieter mind is the negation the two moments of the difference our identity
moments of the difference our identity
moments of the difference our identity and difference and finally then essence
and difference and finally then essence
and difference and finally then essence is the move is the movement from nothing
is the move is the movement from nothing
is the move is the movement from nothing to nothing and thereby back to itself
to nothing and thereby back to itself
to nothing and thereby back to itself well I know this doesn’t make really
well I know this doesn’t make really
well I know this doesn’t make really sense for you right now but I will
sense for you right now but I will
sense for you right now but I will explain it on example so if we take the
explain it on example so if we take the
explain it on example so if we take the sentence from the beginning AI is
sentence from the beginning AI is
sentence from the beginning AI is intelligence exhibited by machines then
intelligence exhibited by machines then
intelligence exhibited by machines then we can start to negate the sentence to
we can start to negate the sentence to
we can start to negate the sentence to make it more interesting AI is not
make it more interesting AI is not
make it more interesting AI is not intelligence ok now you couldn’t get it
intelligence ok now you couldn’t get it
intelligence ok now you couldn’t get it again a is intelligence no it’s not yes
again a is intelligence no it’s not yes
again a is intelligence no it’s not yes no yes no it doesn’t lead you anywhere
no yes no it doesn’t lead you anywhere
no yes no it doesn’t lead you anywhere this is what he called a bet infinity so
this is what he called a bet infinity so
this is what he called a bet infinity so you have to find another way of negating
you have to find another way of negating
you have to find another way of negating it it’s the negation of the negation and
it it’s the negation of the negation and
it it’s the negation of the negation and we could do this by finding a different
we could do this by finding a different
we could do this by finding a different word that means the engagement of
word that means the engagement of
word that means the engagement of intelligence something like stupidity so
intelligence something like stupidity so
intelligence something like stupidity so we would end up with the first sentence
we would end up with the first sentence
we would end up with the first sentence like a
like a
like a I is intelligence and stupidity and now
I is intelligence and stupidity and now
I is intelligence and stupidity and now we have a contradiction and
we have a contradiction and
we have a contradiction and contradictions are always very
contradictions are always very
contradictions are always very fascinating if you want to think about
fascinating if you want to think about
fascinating if you want to think about them more now comes the second rule we
them more now comes the second rule we
them more now comes the second rule we got some more words left in the sentence
got some more words left in the sentence
got some more words left in the sentence we got artificial and we got exhibited
we got artificial and we got exhibited
we got artificial and we got exhibited by machines and these words construct
by machines and these words construct
by machines and these words construct the difference but there is an identity
the difference but there is an identity
the difference but there is an identity within this difference because if you
within this difference because if you
within this difference because if you think about words like artificial
think about words like artificial
think about words like artificial exhibited machines you come up with an
exhibited machines you come up with an
exhibited machines you come up with an idea of something unnatural something
idea of something unnatural something
idea of something unnatural something simulated perhaps you come up with the
simulated perhaps you come up with the
simulated perhaps you come up with the idea that is about computers so we might
idea that is about computers so we might
idea that is about computers so we might end up with a sentence like AI is
end up with a sentence like AI is
end up with a sentence like AI is intelligence and stupidity because it is
intelligence and stupidity because it is
intelligence and stupidity because it is not real intelligence but fake
not real intelligence but fake
not real intelligence but fake intelligence simulated in a computer
intelligence simulated in a computer
intelligence simulated in a computer model and this is more or less the whole
model and this is more or less the whole
model and this is more or less the whole idea of Searle what he was arguing in
idea of Searle what he was arguing in
idea of Searle what he was arguing in the Chinese room but now comes the big
the Chinese room but now comes the big
the Chinese room but now comes the big surprise i created a computer model that
surprise i created a computer model that
surprise i created a computer model that uses exactly these three rules of hegel
uses exactly these three rules of hegel
uses exactly these three rules of hegel to think by itself and if you take the
to think by itself and if you take the
to think by itself and if you take the first sentence as an input like we did
first sentence as an input like we did
first sentence as an input like we did in the example the sentence artificial
in the example the sentence artificial
in the example the sentence artificial intelligence is intelligence exhibited
intelligence is intelligence exhibited
intelligence is intelligence exhibited by machines the computer will transfer
by machines the computer will transfer
by machines the computer will transfer this sentence to AI is intelligence and
this sentence to AI is intelligence and
this sentence to AI is intelligence and stupidity because it is a counter height
stupidity because it is a counter height
stupidity because it is a counter height of intelligence which is recreated
of intelligence which is recreated
of intelligence which is recreated intelligence in a created model and this
intelligence in a created model and this
intelligence in a created model and this is more or less the same we were
is more or less the same we were
is more or less the same we were thinking about in the example before and
thinking about in the example before and
thinking about in the example before and the way the computer gets there is by
the way the computer gets there is by
the way the computer gets there is by using machine learning to analyze the
using machine learning to analyze the
using machine learning to analyze the syntax of the sentence so how the words
syntax of the sentence so how the words
syntax of the sentence so how the words are connected and something which is
are connected and something which is
are connected and something which is called the Semantic Web so there is a
called the Semantic Web so there is a
called the Semantic Web so there is a known connection of words something
known connection of words something
known connection of words something might be a sooner noon for another word
might be a sooner noon for another word
might be a sooner noon for another word or something might be a type of another
or something might be a type of another
or something might be a type of another word and you can use these information
word and you can use these information
word and you can use these information to feed them into a computer model and
to feed them into a computer model and
to feed them into a computer model and because it’s a computer model you can
because it’s a computer model you can
because it’s a computer model you can now feed in any other kind of sentence
now feed in any other kind of sentence
now feed in any other kind of sentence and many sentence make a lot of sense
and many sentence make a lot of sense
and many sentence make a lot of sense and the computers constructing
and the computers constructing
and the computers constructing interesting thoughts well of course many
interesting thoughts well of course many
interesting thoughts well of course many sentence don’t make sense right now but
sentence don’t make sense right now but
sentence don’t make sense right now but it’s a prototype so what do you want but
it’s a prototype so what do you want but
it’s a prototype so what do you want but we still have the last rule the
we still have the last rule the
we still have the last rule the reflection essence is the movement from
reflection essence is the movement from
reflection essence is the movement from nothing to nothing and thereby back to
nothing to nothing and thereby back to
nothing to nothing and thereby back to itself and this is so important here
itself and this is so important here
itself and this is so important here because the whole point is my computer
because the whole point is my computer
because the whole point is my computer program has no idea what artificial
program has no idea what artificial
program has no idea what artificial intelligences I’m not claiming this this
intelligences I’m not claiming this this
intelligences I’m not claiming this this would be silly and it has no idea what a
would be silly and it has no idea what a
would be silly and it has no idea what a counter fight of recreated intelligence
counter fight of recreated intelligence
counter fight of recreated intelligence is so it starts from nothing and moves
is so it starts from nothing and moves
is so it starts from nothing and moves back to nothing but the important thing
back to nothing but the important thing
back to nothing but the important thing is that the way how you get from this
is that the way how you get from this
is that the way how you get from this first nothing to the second nothing
first nothing to the second nothing
first nothing to the second nothing there is a lot of sense in this way and
there is a lot of sense in this way and
there is a lot of sense in this way and there is a deeper connection it’s like
there is a deeper connection it’s like
there is a deeper connection it’s like you are expanding your concept and this
you are expanding your concept and this
you are expanding your concept and this is what thinking is about thinking is
is what thinking is about thinking is
is what thinking is about thinking is about expanding your concept so of
about expanding your concept so of
about expanding your concept so of course the computer still doesn’t know
course the computer still doesn’t know
course the computer still doesn’t know what a is but he knows how to connect
what a is but he knows how to connect
what a is but he knows how to connect the first part AI with a broader concept
the first part AI with a broader concept
the first part AI with a broader concept and because the result is speech and the
and because the result is speech and the
and because the result is speech and the input was speech as well the computer
input was speech as well the computer
input was speech as well the computer can now start to think about its own
can now start to think about its own
can now start to think about its own outputs this might be very very
outputs this might be very very
outputs this might be very very important because then different outputs
important because then different outputs
important because then different outputs will it lead to totally different ways
will it lead to totally different ways
will it lead to totally different ways and maybe computers will start
and maybe computers will start
and maybe computers will start developing a consciousness on their own
developing a consciousness on their own
developing a consciousness on their own based on different starting points well
based on different starting points well
based on different starting points well let me add one final word because there
let me add one final word because there
let me add one final word because there is a lot of fear about artificial
is a lot of fear about artificial
is a lot of fear about artificial intelligence going around Ellen mask is
intelligence going around Ellen mask is
intelligence going around Ellen mask is arguing about super intelligence and
arguing about super intelligence and
arguing about super intelligence and even Stephen Hawking has said super
even Stephen Hawking has said super
even Stephen Hawking has said super intelligence is very very dangerous but
intelligence is very very dangerous but
intelligence is very very dangerous but if he could really
if he could really
if he could really make computers think like humans do and
make computers think like humans do and
make computers think like humans do and not in a very very strange way which I
not in a very very strange way which I
not in a very very strange way which I described in this from A to B style but
described in this from A to B style but
described in this from A to B style but really thinking then I think there is no
really thinking then I think there is no
really thinking then I think there is no reason to believe why some entity that
reason to believe why some entity that
reason to believe why some entity that is smarter than we are but things on the
is smarter than we are but things on the
is smarter than we are but things on the same level should act like an asshole
same level should act like an asshole
same level should act like an asshole and war and terror is never very clever
and war and terror is never very clever
and war and terror is never very clever so I think if you could reach real
so I think if you could reach real
so I think if you could reach real artificial intelligence we’re going to
artificial intelligence we’re going to
artificial intelligence we’re going to see great times thank
see great times thank
see great times thank [Applause]
”
Be First to Comment