Press "Enter" to skip to content

A Recipe for Eudaimonia | Jay Kannaiyan | TEDxGurugram


[Music]

[Music] can I get a show of hands how many of

can I get a show of hands how many of

can I get a show of hands how many of you have ever helped a stranger across

you have ever helped a stranger across

you have ever helped a stranger across the road okay that’s good

the road okay that’s good

the road okay that’s good how many of you have ever done a favor

how many of you have ever done a favor

how many of you have ever done a favor without expecting anything in return

without expecting anything in return

without expecting anything in return great now think about how you felt after

great now think about how you felt after

great now think about how you felt after doing those good deeds happy satisfied

doing those good deeds happy satisfied

doing those good deeds happy satisfied content there’s actually one word that

content there’s actually one word that

content there’s actually one word that encompasses all this it’s called you die

encompasses all this it’s called you die

encompasses all this it’s called you die Monia I know it sounds like some strange

Monia I know it sounds like some strange

Monia I know it sounds like some strange disease but it’s actually the purpose of

disease but it’s actually the purpose of

disease but it’s actually the purpose of my life in an odd turn of events I in

my life in an odd turn of events I in

my life in an odd turn of events I in fact discovered eudaimonia over a

fact discovered eudaimonia over a

fact discovered eudaimonia over a chicken curry in Bolivia eudaimonia is

chicken curry in Bolivia eudaimonia is

chicken curry in Bolivia eudaimonia is an ancient Greek word that went out of

an ancient Greek word that went out of

an ancient Greek word that went out of fashion for a few centuries but it’s

fashion for a few centuries but it’s

fashion for a few centuries but it’s making a comeback it can be broadly

making a comeback it can be broadly

making a comeback it can be broadly defined as experiencing human

defined as experiencing human

defined as experiencing human flourishing that moment of highest human

flourishing that moment of highest human

flourishing that moment of highest human good it’s similar to the philosophies of

good it’s similar to the philosophies of

good it’s similar to the philosophies of mindfulness where we are encouraged to

mindfulness where we are encouraged to

mindfulness where we are encouraged to live in the moment a central tenet is

live in the moment a central tenet is

live in the moment a central tenet is that if we could be our best self in

that if we could be our best self in

that if we could be our best self in each and every moment we would be more

each and every moment we would be more

each and every moment we would be more content satisfied and fulfilled with our

content satisfied and fulfilled with our

content satisfied and fulfilled with our life that’s in contrast to constantly

life that’s in contrast to constantly

life that’s in contrast to constantly reflecting about the past and worrying

reflecting about the past and worrying

reflecting about the past and worrying about the future I first came across

about the future I first came across

about the future I first came across eudaimonia when I was a cog in the

eudaimonia when I was a cog in the

eudaimonia when I was a cog in the corporate wheel in America I went there

corporate wheel in America I went there

corporate wheel in America I went there for engineering got a good job had a

for engineering got a good job had a

for engineering got a good job had a house car the good quality of life but

house car the good quality of life but

house car the good quality of life but something was missing that sense of

something was missing that sense of

something was missing that sense of fulfillment I questioned why was I doing

fulfillment I questioned why was I doing

fulfillment I questioned why was I doing what I was doing who said that I needed

what I was doing who said that I needed

what I was doing who said that I needed a job a mortgage and a retirement plan

a job a mortgage and a retirement plan

a job a mortgage and a retirement plan what was the purpose of my life

what was the purpose of my life

what was the purpose of my life in my quest I came across a lecture

in my quest I came across a lecture

in my quest I came across a lecture series called beyond belief and they had

series called beyond belief and they had

series called beyond belief and they had a session on eudaimonia where modern

a session on eudaimonia where modern

a session on eudaimonia where modern philosophers were espousing that human

philosophers were espousing that human

philosophers were espousing that human flourishing should be the purpose of all

flourishing should be the purpose of all

flourishing should be the purpose of all lives it’s quite a ball claim to state

lives it’s quite a ball claim to state

lives it’s quite a ball claim to state that any one thing could be the purpose

that any one thing could be the purpose

that any one thing could be the purpose of all lives but the more I learned

of all lives but the more I learned

of all lives but the more I learned about it the more worthwhile a pursuit

about it the more worthwhile a pursuit

about it the more worthwhile a pursuit of life it seemed but being our best

of life it seemed but being our best

of life it seemed but being our best self in each and every moment was that

self in each and every moment was that

self in each and every moment was that even possible perhaps in a utopian world

even possible perhaps in a utopian world

even possible perhaps in a utopian world but in the real world were constantly

but in the real world were constantly

but in the real world were constantly distracted by our anxieties was our

distracted by our anxieties was our

distracted by our anxieties was our income secure are we healthy and even

income secure are we healthy and even

income secure are we healthy and even the existential questions such as how is

the existential questions such as how is

the existential questions such as how is climate change affecting our lives with

climate change affecting our lives with

climate change affecting our lives with all this in our minds how could we focus

all this in our minds how could we focus

all this in our minds how could we focus on just being our best self in each and

on just being our best self in each and

on just being our best self in each and every moment at this point in my life in

every moment at this point in my life in

every moment at this point in my life in my mid-20s I had discovered the joys of

my mid-20s I had discovered the joys of

my mid-20s I had discovered the joys of motorcycle travel and pursued it in all

motorcycle travel and pursued it in all

motorcycle travel and pursued it in all my free time from my base in Chicago I

my free time from my base in Chicago I

my free time from my base in Chicago I explored the western US Mexico and even

explored the western US Mexico and even

explored the western US Mexico and even Alaska on a motorcycle traveling with

Alaska on a motorcycle traveling with

Alaska on a motorcycle traveling with lightweight camping gear and tools there

lightweight camping gear and tools there

lightweight camping gear and tools there is a constant awareness about security

is a constant awareness about security

is a constant awareness about security and safety

and safety

and safety but traveling exposed on two wheels the

but traveling exposed on two wheels the

but traveling exposed on two wheels the questions at the front of my mind every

questions at the front of my mind every

questions at the front of my mind every day were simple where was their gonna

day were simple where was their gonna

day were simple where was their gonna sleep tonight and did I have enough

sleep tonight and did I have enough

sleep tonight and did I have enough petrol to reach the next filling station

petrol to reach the next filling station

petrol to reach the next filling station there was no space in my mind for the

there was no space in my mind for the

there was no space in my mind for the usual worries I loved this immediacy of

usual worries I loved this immediacy of

usual worries I loved this immediacy of life it was allowing me to live in the

life it was allowing me to live in the

life it was allowing me to live in the moment not at a level where I was

moment not at a level where I was

moment not at a level where I was feeling you demonic but it was certainly

feeling you demonic but it was certainly

feeling you demonic but it was certainly a precursor this was around the same

a precursor this was around the same

a precursor this was around the same time as the financial crisis and when I

time as the financial crisis and when I

time as the financial crisis and when I also had annoying longing to return to

also had annoying longing to return to

also had annoying longing to return to India and with each and every motorcycle

India and with each and every motorcycle

India and with each and every motorcycle trip I felt I was getting closer to some

trip I felt I was getting closer to some

trip I felt I was getting closer to some realization about eudaimonia but I knew

realization about eudaimonia but I knew

realization about eudaimonia but I knew I was not gonna find it being stuck in

I was not gonna find it being stuck in

I was not gonna find it being stuck in the corporate world so I took a call and

the corporate world so I took a call and

the corporate world so I took a call and quit my job sold my house car and most

quit my job sold my house car and most

quit my job sold my house car and most other possessions besides what would fit

other possessions besides what would fit

other possessions besides what would fit on my bike and planned to ride overland

on my bike and planned to ride overland

on my bike and planned to ride overland from the u.s. to

from the u.s. to

from the u.s. to India however long that took at the

India however long that took at the

India however long that took at the outset I gave myself two years I

outset I gave myself two years I

outset I gave myself two years I researched how feasible extended

researched how feasible extended

researched how feasible extended duration journeys were and saw that some

duration journeys were and saw that some

duration journeys were and saw that some people were actually not cut out for

people were actually not cut out for

people were actually not cut out for long term travel and get bored within a

long term travel and get bored within a

long term travel and get bored within a few months they would get homesick and

few months they would get homesick and

few months they would get homesick and seek any connection to their home

seek any connection to their home

seek any connection to their home culture in these foreign lands I knew

culture in these foreign lands I knew

culture in these foreign lands I knew that I wasn’t easily gonna find

that I wasn’t easily gonna find

that I wasn’t easily gonna find connections to Indian culture in the

connections to Indian culture in the

connections to Indian culture in the places of the world that I was planning

places of the world that I was planning

places of the world that I was planning to travel through namely Latin America

to travel through namely Latin America

to travel through namely Latin America and Africa so I thought to myself if I

and Africa so I thought to myself if I

and Africa so I thought to myself if I could carry a sense of what meant home

could carry a sense of what meant home

could carry a sense of what meant home to me on this trip then perhaps I

to me on this trip then perhaps I

to me on this trip then perhaps I wouldn’t get homesick in all the short

wouldn’t get homesick in all the short

wouldn’t get homesick in all the short trips I’d made before leaving on this

trips I’d made before leaving on this

trips I’d made before leaving on this big trip the only aspect of my home life

big trip the only aspect of my home life

big trip the only aspect of my home life that I missed was strangely enough

that I missed was strangely enough

that I missed was strangely enough cooking it slowly perfected this simple

cooking it slowly perfected this simple

cooking it slowly perfected this simple and delicious chicken curry recipe over

and delicious chicken curry recipe over

and delicious chicken curry recipe over the years and I had the urge to cook it

the years and I had the urge to cook it

the years and I had the urge to cook it right away after coming home from Mexico

right away after coming home from Mexico

right away after coming home from Mexico or Alaska and so I said if I could cook

or Alaska and so I said if I could cook

or Alaska and so I said if I could cook this curry once in a while on the road I

this curry once in a while on the road I

this curry once in a while on the road I wouldn’t get homesick the journey began

wouldn’t get homesick the journey began

wouldn’t get homesick the journey began early March 2010 from Chicago and when I

early March 2010 from Chicago and when I

early March 2010 from Chicago and when I crossed the first border into Mexico I

crossed the first border into Mexico I

crossed the first border into Mexico I knew there was no turning back I sought

knew there was no turning back I sought

knew there was no turning back I sought out stays with local hosts along the way

out stays with local hosts along the way

out stays with local hosts along the way using various traveling networks and

using various traveling networks and

using various traveling networks and this opened up a wonderful insight into

this opened up a wonderful insight into

this opened up a wonderful insight into the places I was traveling through it

the places I was traveling through it

the places I was traveling through it was allowing me a locals perspective on

was allowing me a locals perspective on

was allowing me a locals perspective on things and as a way to show a gratitude

things and as a way to show a gratitude

things and as a way to show a gratitude to my host I offered to cook them my

to my host I offered to cook them my

to my host I offered to cook them my curry now this curry is prepared from

curry now this curry is prepared from

curry now this curry is prepared from scratch there are no ready-made paste or

scratch there are no ready-made paste or

scratch there are no ready-made paste or sauces it requires a lot of onions

sauces it requires a lot of onions

sauces it requires a lot of onions tomatoes ginger and garlic and so I

tomatoes ginger and garlic and so I

tomatoes ginger and garlic and so I would draft in whoever is cooking this

would draft in whoever is cooking this

would draft in whoever is cooking this curry for to help out with the

curry for to help out with the

curry for to help out with the preparation the first time I made this

preparation the first time I made this

preparation the first time I made this curry on the road was up in the

curry on the road was up in the

curry on the road was up in the mountains of San Cristobal in southern

mountains of San Cristobal in southern

mountains of San Cristobal in southern Mexico where the eucalyptus trees grow

Mexico where the eucalyptus trees grow

Mexico where the eucalyptus trees grow tall over a pitcher esque colonial town

tall over a pitcher esque colonial town

tall over a pitcher esque colonial town word spread that this Indian guy was

word spread that this Indian guy was

word spread that this Indian guy was cooking a chicken curry and soon there

cooking a chicken curry and soon there

cooking a chicken curry and soon there were 30 people hungry for curry at Hosea

were 30 people hungry for curry at Hosea

were 30 people hungry for curry at Hosea Lewis’s farmhouse

Lewis’s farmhouse

Lewis’s farmhouse I had showed up as a polite guest and

I had showed up as a polite guest and

I had showed up as a polite guest and now had taken over the kitchen directing

now had taken over the kitchen directing

now had taken over the kitchen directing people to chop onions here and diced

people to chop onions here and diced

people to chop onions here and diced tomatoes there the dinner party was a

tomatoes there the dinner party was a

tomatoes there the dinner party was a resounding success and what I noticed

resounding success and what I noticed

resounding success and what I noticed was how my relationship with Jose Luis

was how my relationship with Jose Luis

was how my relationship with Jose Luis and the others around there changed over

and the others around there changed over

and the others around there changed over the course of that single meal before I

the course of that single meal before I

the course of that single meal before I was a friendly stranger but now that I

was a friendly stranger but now that I

was a friendly stranger but now that I had cooked and fed them and by their

had cooked and fed them and by their

had cooked and fed them and by their accounts a foreign delicacy a bond had

accounts a foreign delicacy a bond had

accounts a foreign delicacy a bond had been extended and there was a strong

been extended and there was a strong

been extended and there was a strong feeling of trust there the first few

feeling of trust there the first few

feeling of trust there the first few times has happened I felt content in

times has happened I felt content in

times has happened I felt content in that moment and just thought of it as

that moment and just thought of it as

that moment and just thought of it as happy stomachs talking but the more I

happy stomachs talking but the more I

happy stomachs talking but the more I cooked this curry the more I realized

cooked this curry the more I realized

cooked this curry the more I realized that I could anticipate how my

that I could anticipate how my

that I could anticipate how my relationship was going to change for the

relationship was going to change for the

relationship was going to change for the better with any one person before the

better with any one person before the

better with any one person before the curry and after the curry a few months

curry and after the curry a few months

curry and after the curry a few months later in La Paz Bolivia Alphonso an avid

later in La Paz Bolivia Alphonso an avid

later in La Paz Bolivia Alphonso an avid motorcyclist invited me to stay with him

motorcyclist invited me to stay with him

motorcyclist invited me to stay with him and in due course I cooked the curry for

and in due course I cooked the curry for

and in due course I cooked the curry for his family he was so impressed he told

his family he was so impressed he told

his family he was so impressed he told his friend Gonzalo who a few days later

his friend Gonzalo who a few days later

his friend Gonzalo who a few days later invited me to cook the curry for his

invited me to cook the curry for his

invited me to cook the curry for his family I barged into the upscale flat

family I barged into the upscale flat

family I barged into the upscale flat and went straight to the kitchen

and went straight to the kitchen

and went straight to the kitchen Gonzales wife Carmina sceptical at this

Gonzales wife Carmina sceptical at this

Gonzales wife Carmina sceptical at this bald Indian biker now cooking up a

bald Indian biker now cooking up a

bald Indian biker now cooking up a sensory overload of a curry with chilies

sensory overload of a curry with chilies

sensory overload of a curry with chilies and garlic stood looking over me

and garlic stood looking over me

and garlic stood looking over me throughout complaining that the onions

throughout complaining that the onions

throughout complaining that the onions were getting overcooked or perhaps there

were getting overcooked or perhaps there

were getting overcooked or perhaps there was too much garlic

was too much garlic

was too much garlic she finally relented but remained wary

she finally relented but remained wary

she finally relented but remained wary of my strange culinary style until we

of my strange culinary style until we

of my strange culinary style until we sat down for the meal she took one bite

sat down for the meal she took one bite

sat down for the meal she took one bite of that curry and it melted away her

of that curry and it melted away her

of that curry and it melted away her cold shoulder she was blown away at how

cold shoulder she was blown away at how

cold shoulder she was blown away at how smooth and complex the flavors were and

smooth and complex the flavors were and

smooth and complex the flavors were and I knew I had turned her with my curry

I knew I had turned her with my curry

I knew I had turned her with my curry diplomacy

diplomacy

diplomacy [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] she was all smiles and frankly impressed

she was all smiles and frankly impressed

she was all smiles and frankly impressed how a man on a motorbike could prepare

how a man on a motorbike could prepare

how a man on a motorbike could prepare such a delicacy I felt I was at my

such a delicacy I felt I was at my

such a delicacy I felt I was at my highest self in this moment experiencing

highest self in this moment experiencing

highest self in this moment experiencing human flourishing eudaimonia I saw this

human flourishing eudaimonia I saw this

human flourishing eudaimonia I saw this pattern over and over across cultures

pattern over and over across cultures

pattern over and over across cultures and borders from Argentina to Egypt to

and borders from Argentina to Egypt to

and borders from Argentina to Egypt to Kenya and even back here in India when I

Kenya and even back here in India when I

Kenya and even back here in India when I finally arrived I began to ponder what

finally arrived I began to ponder what

finally arrived I began to ponder what was happening over this curry that was

was happening over this curry that was

was happening over this curry that was changing my relationship with people on

changing my relationship with people on

changing my relationship with people on the road in between these curries I

the road in between these curries I

the road in between these curries I mused on the idea that isn’t it a better

mused on the idea that isn’t it a better

mused on the idea that isn’t it a better state of mind to be in where we are

state of mind to be in where we are

state of mind to be in where we are around people whom we have deep

around people whom we have deep

around people whom we have deep connections with isn’t this why most of

connections with isn’t this why most of

connections with isn’t this why most of us enjoy being around our family and

us enjoy being around our family and

us enjoy being around our family and friends rather than strangers this is a

friends rather than strangers this is a

friends rather than strangers this is a good strategy as it helps us be aware of

good strategy as it helps us be aware of

good strategy as it helps us be aware of those that could harm us and this is

those that could harm us and this is

those that could harm us and this is what God our species this far thinking

what God our species this far thinking

what God our species this far thinking ahead about our safety and security but

ahead about our safety and security but

ahead about our safety and security but the downside is this makes for a cold

the downside is this makes for a cold

the downside is this makes for a cold world I feel that most people’s default

world I feel that most people’s default

world I feel that most people’s default mode is to be highly skeptical of each

mode is to be highly skeptical of each

mode is to be highly skeptical of each other and this inhibits us from being

other and this inhibits us from being

other and this inhibits us from being the highest versions of ourselves at

the highest versions of ourselves at

the highest versions of ourselves at every moment was preparing this chicken

every moment was preparing this chicken

every moment was preparing this chicken curry as simple as it sounds

curry as simple as it sounds

curry as simple as it sounds fostering deep connections with recently

fostering deep connections with recently

fostering deep connections with recently met strangers and allowing all of us to

met strangers and allowing all of us to

met strangers and allowing all of us to be at the more desirable state of being

be at the more desirable state of being

be at the more desirable state of being around people we trust

around people we trust

around people we trust instead of being skeptical it might seem

instead of being skeptical it might seem

instead of being skeptical it might seem a silly thought to arise from spending

a silly thought to arise from spending

a silly thought to arise from spending days on end in the wilderness but it’s

days on end in the wilderness but it’s

days on end in the wilderness but it’s not such a crazy idea when I see that

not such a crazy idea when I see that

not such a crazy idea when I see that people have cooked this curry for just

people have cooked this curry for just

people have cooked this curry for just once in some remote corner of the world

once in some remote corner of the world

once in some remote corner of the world still remember that curry and we’ve

still remember that curry and we’ve

still remember that curry and we’ve stayed in touch over the years as I

stayed in touch over the years as I

stayed in touch over the years as I dwelled on the idea on how this curry

dwelled on the idea on how this curry

dwelled on the idea on how this curry was creating eudaimonia I came across

was creating eudaimonia I came across

was creating eudaimonia I came across another interpretation for the word it

another interpretation for the word it

another interpretation for the word it said that eudaimonia can be found

said that eudaimonia can be found

said that eudaimonia can be found the intersection of what’s true good and

the intersection of what’s true good and

the intersection of what’s true good and beautiful now those are all subjective

beautiful now those are all subjective

beautiful now those are all subjective terms but each one of us knows when

terms but each one of us knows when

terms but each one of us knows when something is true good or beautiful as I

something is true good or beautiful as I

something is true good or beautiful as I applied this to my curry I realized that

applied this to my curry I realized that

applied this to my curry I realized that this was my actual recipe for eudaimonia

this was my actual recipe for eudaimonia

this was my actual recipe for eudaimonia it was true as for me and the dinner

it was true as for me and the dinner

it was true as for me and the dinner guests we prepared this curry from

guests we prepared this curry from

guests we prepared this curry from scratch it was good as I don’t want to

scratch it was good as I don’t want to

scratch it was good as I don’t want to brag but almost everybody who’s tasted

brag but almost everybody who’s tasted

brag but almost everybody who’s tasted this curry says it’s really quite

this curry says it’s really quite

this curry says it’s really quite delicious the secret is to caramelize

delicious the secret is to caramelize

delicious the secret is to caramelize the onions and use lots of garlic and it

the onions and use lots of garlic and it

the onions and use lots of garlic and it was beautiful as we prepared this

was beautiful as we prepared this

was beautiful as we prepared this together in a participatory way that was

together in a participatory way that was

together in a participatory way that was it

it

it I was able to create eudaimonia in my

I was able to create eudaimonia in my

I was able to create eudaimonia in my life and in those around me whenever

life and in those around me whenever

life and in those around me whenever this chicken curry was prepared it

this chicken curry was prepared it

this chicken curry was prepared it sounds so simple but the truth often is

sounds so simple but the truth often is

sounds so simple but the truth often is as I shared stories about this curry

as I shared stories about this curry

as I shared stories about this curry people following my journey asked for

people following my journey asked for

people following my journey asked for the recipe as soon as it went online

the recipe as soon as it went online

the recipe as soon as it went online friends and strangers reported that when

friends and strangers reported that when

friends and strangers reported that when they had prepared this curry some

they had prepared this curry some

they had prepared this curry some cooking for the very first time

cooking for the very first time

cooking for the very first time they were able to experience this sense

they were able to experience this sense

they were able to experience this sense of human flourishing among themselves

of human flourishing among themselves

of human flourishing among themselves and those around them I had finally

and those around them I had finally

and those around them I had finally found my purpose in life it was to share

found my purpose in life it was to share

found my purpose in life it was to share true good and beautiful moments with

true good and beautiful moments with

true good and beautiful moments with others over chicken curry

and that has brought me here today to

and that has brought me here today to share that recipe with you some think

share that recipe with you some think

share that recipe with you some think this motorcycle journey was a lifetime

this motorcycle journey was a lifetime

this motorcycle journey was a lifetime achievement but for me I feel most

achievement but for me I feel most

achievement but for me I feel most content in knowing that I had discovered

content in knowing that I had discovered

content in knowing that I had discovered a recipe for eudaimonia and how I could

a recipe for eudaimonia and how I could

a recipe for eudaimonia and how I could try and live at the highest version of

try and live at the highest version of

try and live at the highest version of myself by seeking it out it’s hard to

myself by seeking it out it’s hard to

myself by seeking it out it’s hard to attain consistently as currently running

attain consistently as currently running

attain consistently as currently running a start-up in India takes up all my

a start-up in India takes up all my

a start-up in India takes up all my day-to-day worries but having

day-to-day worries but having

day-to-day worries but having experienced eudaimonia I know that

experienced eudaimonia I know that

experienced eudaimonia I know that delivering the highest quality product

delivering the highest quality product

delivering the highest quality product that is possible each and every day is

that is possible each and every day is

that is possible each and every day is what will allow me to be content and

what will allow me to be content and

what will allow me to be content and fulfilled in this challenging world of

fulfilled in this challenging world of

fulfilled in this challenging world of entrepreneurship now how can you find

entrepreneurship now how can you find

entrepreneurship now how can you find eudaimonia in your lives it’s actually

eudaimonia in your lives it’s actually

eudaimonia in your lives it’s actually all around you you are surrounded by

all around you you are surrounded by

all around you you are surrounded by things that are true good and beautiful

things that are true good and beautiful

things that are true good and beautiful just know that when those three

just know that when those three

just know that when those three ingredients are present you are

ingredients are present you are

ingredients are present you are experiencing human flourishing and you

experiencing human flourishing and you

experiencing human flourishing and you have attained a state of being that is

have attained a state of being that is

have attained a state of being that is higher than simply being happy if you

higher than simply being happy if you

higher than simply being happy if you can I would implore you to travel to

can I would implore you to travel to

can I would implore you to travel to take a break from a current life path

take a break from a current life path

take a break from a current life path and let eudaimonia come to you and you

and let eudaimonia come to you and you

and let eudaimonia come to you and you could also seek it out with this recipe

could also seek it out with this recipe

could also seek it out with this recipe now who wants to come over for chicken

now who wants to come over for chicken

now who wants to come over for chicken curry

curry

curry thank you

thank you

thank you [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *