Press "Enter" to skip to content

Self-esteem is Not the Answer | Heidi Landes | TEDxDayton


I used to know a lot about parenting so

I used to know a lot about parenting so much that one of my first Jobs was

much that one of my first Jobs was

much that one of my first Jobs was Dementor moms the only problem was I was

Dementor moms the only problem was I was

Dementor moms the only problem was I was 22 I had no kids of my own and I had no

22 I had no kids of my own and I had no

22 I had no kids of my own and I had no idea what I was talking about if any of

idea what I was talking about if any of

idea what I was talking about if any of those moms are here today I apologize

those moms are here today I apologize

those moms are here today I apologize because a few years later I had kids of

because a few years later I had kids of

because a few years later I had kids of my own four of them they humbled me

my own four of them they humbled me

my own four of them they humbled me there’s so many moments as a mom when I

there’s so many moments as a mom when I

there’s so many moments as a mom when I thought wow I did not see that coming we

thought wow I did not see that coming we

thought wow I did not see that coming we went to the park for a hike and my

went to the park for a hike and my

went to the park for a hike and my seven-year-old hops out of the car with

seven-year-old hops out of the car with

seven-year-old hops out of the car with no shoes just one sock and one flip-flop

no shoes just one sock and one flip-flop

no shoes just one sock and one flip-flop what or the time when I was helping my

what or the time when I was helping my

what or the time when I was helping my three-year-old with a huge floor puzzle

three-year-old with a huge floor puzzle

three-year-old with a huge floor puzzle of the United States he stuck his finger

of the United States he stuck his finger

of the United States he stuck his finger in his nose pulled it out Hey look mom

in his nose pulled it out Hey look mom

in his nose pulled it out Hey look mom Arkansas

here’s another thing I didn’t see coming

here’s another thing I didn’t see coming I was exhausted I mean I knew I would

I was exhausted I mean I knew I would

I was exhausted I mean I knew I would have to do everything for them in the

have to do everything for them in the

have to do everything for them in the beginning but I started to wonder when

beginning but I started to wonder when

beginning but I started to wonder when this was going to end going to work was

this was going to end going to work was

this was going to end going to work was easier there I didn’t have to be nice

easier there I didn’t have to be nice

easier there I didn’t have to be nice beg or bribe people into doing what they

beg or bribe people into doing what they

beg or bribe people into doing what they needed to do at work I could just tell

needed to do at work I could just tell

needed to do at work I could just tell them at home I had to tell the kids 20

them at home I had to tell the kids 20

them at home I had to tell the kids 20 times to do something and then I still

times to do something and then I still

times to do something and then I still ended up doing it myself can anyone

ended up doing it myself can anyone

ended up doing it myself can anyone relate I love my kids but I was starting

relate I love my kids but I was starting

relate I love my kids but I was starting to worry about their future how was I

to worry about their future how was I

to worry about their future how was I going to get them to college when I

going to get them to college when I

going to get them to college when I couldn’t even get them out the door with

couldn’t even get them out the door with

couldn’t even get them out the door with two shoes on and so I searched for

two shoes on and so I searched for

two shoes on and so I searched for answers what I found turned into a

answers what I found turned into a

answers what I found turned into a parenting revolution eventually my

parenting revolution eventually my

parenting revolution eventually my husband and I became parent coaches

husband and I became parent coaches

husband and I became parent coaches because we realized this news was too

because we realized this news was too

because we realized this news was too good not to share in 2015

good not to share in 2015

good not to share in 2015 we did a survey of 250 families from all

we did a survey of 250 families from all

we did a survey of 250 families from all 50 states and we asked what five words

50 states and we asked what five words

50 states and we asked what five words do you want to describe your child at

do you want to describe your child at

do you want to describe your child at age 30 the answers we heard repeatedly

age 30 the answers we heard repeatedly

age 30 the answers we heard repeatedly happy kind independent responsible

happy kind independent responsible

happy kind independent responsible disciplined yes

disciplined yes

disciplined yes but the question we have is what do we

but the question we have is what do we

but the question we have is what do we do now

do now

do now as parents to get here for the last 30

as parents to get here for the last 30

as parents to get here for the last 30 years we’ve been told as parents that we

years we’ve been told as parents that we

years we’ve been told as parents that we must instill high self-esteem did you

must instill high self-esteem did you

must instill high self-esteem did you ever wonder where this idea came from in

ever wonder where this idea came from in

ever wonder where this idea came from in the 1980s

psychologists noticed that drug addicts

psychologists noticed that drug addicts had low self-esteem and so they

had low self-esteem and so they

had low self-esteem and so they concluded high self-esteem would be the

concluded high self-esteem would be the

concluded high self-esteem would be the antidote to crime teenage pregnancy and

antidote to crime teenage pregnancy and

antidote to crime teenage pregnancy and drug abuse so government officials

drug abuse so government officials

drug abuse so government officials school leaders and parents jumped on the

school leaders and parents jumped on the

school leaders and parents jumped on the bandwagon and the self-esteem movement

bandwagon and the self-esteem movement

bandwagon and the self-esteem movement was born we joke about the idea that

was born we joke about the idea that

was born we joke about the idea that everybody gets a trophy but it is a

everybody gets a trophy but it is a

everybody gets a trophy but it is a reality promoting high self-esteem is

reality promoting high self-esteem is

reality promoting high self-esteem is embedded in our cultural psyche

embedded in our cultural psyche

embedded in our cultural psyche psychologists followed students and kids

psychologists followed students and kids

psychologists followed students and kids for up to 30 years because we fully

for up to 30 years because we fully

for up to 30 years because we fully expected to see amazing results from

expected to see amazing results from

expected to see amazing results from promoting high self-esteem it didn’t

promoting high self-esteem it didn’t

promoting high self-esteem it didn’t happen in 2003 after decades of research

happen in 2003 after decades of research

happen in 2003 after decades of research on self-esteem dr. Roy Baumeister and

on self-esteem dr. Roy Baumeister and

on self-esteem dr. Roy Baumeister and his colleagues at the University of

his colleagues at the University of

his colleagues at the University of Florida came to these conclusions

Florida came to these conclusions

Florida came to these conclusions promoting high self-esteem does not

promoting high self-esteem does not

promoting high self-esteem does not prevent children from smoking drinking

prevent children from smoking drinking

prevent children from smoking drinking taking drugs or engaging in early sex

taking drugs or engaging in early sex

taking drugs or engaging in early sex our findings do not support continued

our findings do not support continued

our findings do not support continued widespread efforts to boost self-esteem

widespread efforts to boost self-esteem

widespread efforts to boost self-esteem promoting self-esteem might just as

promoting self-esteem might just as

promoting self-esteem might just as easily promote narcissism additionally

easily promote narcissism additionally

easily promote narcissism additionally dr. Baumeister his colleagues found that

dr. Baumeister his colleagues found that

dr. Baumeister his colleagues found that certain groups of people test extremely

certain groups of people test extremely

certain groups of people test extremely high in self esteem bullies people with

high in self esteem bullies people with

high in self esteem bullies people with road rage child abusers white feeders

road rage child abusers white feeders

road rage child abusers white feeders rapists self-esteem is not the answer

but all those studies revealed something

but all those studies revealed something unexpected there actually is a childhood

unexpected there actually is a childhood

unexpected there actually is a childhood trait that predicts positive outcomes in

trait that predicts positive outcomes in

trait that predicts positive outcomes in life but the trait is self-control

life but the trait is self-control

life but the trait is self-control children with high self-control go on to

children with high self-control go on to

children with high self-control go on to become adults who are less likely to

become adults who are less likely to

become adults who are less likely to have drug and alcohol problems to be a

have drug and alcohol problems to be a

have drug and alcohol problems to be a single parent to commit a crime or to

single parent to commit a crime or to

single parent to commit a crime or to struggle financially they go on to

struggle financially they go on to

struggle financially they go on to become a

become a

become a it’s more more likely to be in good

it’s more more likely to be in good

it’s more more likely to be in good health to earn more and save more money

health to earn more and save more money

health to earn more and save more money to volunteer and give to charity and to

to volunteer and give to charity and to

to volunteer and give to charity and to be satisfied with their lives this is

be satisfied with their lives this is

be satisfied with their lives this is good news researchers concluded

good news researchers concluded

good news researchers concluded childhood self-control strongly predicts

childhood self-control strongly predicts

childhood self-control strongly predicts adult success and people of high or low

adult success and people of high or low

adult success and people of high or low intelligence in rich or poor but there’s

intelligence in rich or poor but there’s

intelligence in rich or poor but there’s even better news parents we don’t get to

even better news parents we don’t get to

even better news parents we don’t get to pick our child’s height their eye color

pick our child’s height their eye color

pick our child’s height their eye color their IQ but we can help them to develop

their IQ but we can help them to develop

their IQ but we can help them to develop greater self-control and there are

greater self-control and there are

greater self-control and there are surprisingly simple ways that we can do

surprisingly simple ways that we can do

surprisingly simple ways that we can do this it begins with a paradigm shift for

this it begins with a paradigm shift for

this it begins with a paradigm shift for a long time people thought the earth was

a long time people thought the earth was

a long time people thought the earth was the center of the universe and the Sun

the center of the universe and the Sun

the center of the universe and the Sun revolved around it then Nicholas

revolved around it then Nicholas

revolved around it then Nicholas Copernicus came along and said nope

Copernicus came along and said nope

Copernicus came along and said nope we’re wrong the earth actually revolves

we’re wrong the earth actually revolves

we’re wrong the earth actually revolves around the Sun when we focused on

around the Sun when we focused on

around the Sun when we focused on self-esteem the children are the center

self-esteem the children are the center

self-esteem the children are the center of our universe and we completely

of our universe and we completely

of our universe and we completely revolve around them and their feelings

revolve around them and their feelings

revolve around them and their feelings we are focused on keeping them happy

we are focused on keeping them happy

we are focused on keeping them happy above all else when we focus on

above all else when we focus on

above all else when we focus on self-control we teach them they are part

self-control we teach them they are part

self-control we teach them they are part of the family but they’re not the center

of the family but they’re not the center

of the family but they’re not the center we teach them to think about others that

we teach them to think about others that

we teach them to think about others that sometimes life is hard and that we have

sometimes life is hard and that we have

sometimes life is hard and that we have to do the right thing no matter how we

to do the right thing no matter how we

to do the right thing no matter how we feel even if we don’t always get a

feel even if we don’t always get a

feel even if we don’t always get a trophy let me ask you this when your

trophy let me ask you this when your

trophy let me ask you this when your alarm goes off in the morning how many

alarm goes off in the morning how many

alarm goes off in the morning how many of you jump out of it because you are

of you jump out of it because you are

of you jump out of it because you are thrilled to go to work today yes there

thrilled to go to work today yes there

thrilled to go to work today yes there are a few hands those are the people

are a few hands those are the people

are a few hands those are the people sitting next to their boss we know it

[Applause]

[Applause] those of us who are being honest know

those of us who are being honest know

those of us who are being honest know that even when we like our job we don’t

that even when we like our job we don’t

that even when we like our job we don’t always feel like going but of course we

always feel like going but of course we

always feel like going but of course we do this is I will self-control we

do this is I will self-control we

do this is I will self-control we fulfill our responsibilities no matter

fulfill our responsibilities no matter

fulfill our responsibilities no matter how we feel about it one way children

how we feel about it one way children

how we feel about it one way children practice

practice

practice I will self-control is when we expect

I will self-control is when we expect

I will self-control is when we expect them to be responsible and we give them

them to be responsible and we give them

them to be responsible and we give them real responsibilities in the war of 1812

real responsibilities in the war of 1812

real responsibilities in the war of 1812 the US Navy had 12 year olds commanding

the US Navy had 12 year olds commanding

the US Navy had 12 year olds commanding ships today we’re still waking them up

ships today we’re still waking them up

ships today we’re still waking them up packing their lunch and cleaning their

packing their lunch and cleaning their

packing their lunch and cleaning their rooms for them think about the

rooms for them think about the

rooms for them think about the difference between volunteering to help

difference between volunteering to help

difference between volunteering to help with something versus being in charge of

with something versus being in charge of

with something versus being in charge of it we treat tasks differently when we

it we treat tasks differently when we

it we treat tasks differently when we know it rests on our shoulders I used to

know it rests on our shoulders I used to

know it rests on our shoulders I used to have my children help with the laundry

have my children help with the laundry

have my children help with the laundry let me tell you they were not worried

let me tell you they were not worried

let me tell you they were not worried about it

about it

about it they knew if they didn’t do it I would

they knew if they didn’t do it I would

they knew if they didn’t do it I would but now my children are in charge of the

but now my children are in charge of the

but now my children are in charge of the laundry if they don’t do it we all have

laundry if they don’t do it we all have

laundry if they don’t do it we all have to wear dirty stinky clothes dr. Marty

to wear dirty stinky clothes dr. Marty

to wear dirty stinky clothes dr. Marty Rothman at the University of Minnesota

Rothman at the University of Minnesota

Rothman at the University of Minnesota found that children who have chores by

found that children who have chores by

found that children who have chores by the age of 4 were more successful as

the age of 4 were more successful as

the age of 4 were more successful as adults than those who began chores as

adults than those who began chores as

adults than those who began chores as teenagers knowing that they are part of

teenagers knowing that they are part of

teenagers knowing that they are part of the team and that work comes before play

the team and that work comes before play

the team and that work comes before play helps children grow in the I will

helps children grow in the I will

helps children grow in the I will self-control adults we also exercise I

self-control adults we also exercise I

self-control adults we also exercise I won’t self-control when we say no to

won’t self-control when we say no to

won’t self-control when we say no to something we want like that second piece

something we want like that second piece

something we want like that second piece of cake because we know it might lead to

of cake because we know it might lead to

of cake because we know it might lead to can’t fit into machines consequences but

can’t fit into machines consequences but

can’t fit into machines consequences but we often hesitate to let our children

we often hesitate to let our children

we often hesitate to let our children suffer consequences of their actions

suffer consequences of their actions

suffer consequences of their actions because we’re afraid of harming their

because we’re afraid of harming their

because we’re afraid of harming their self-esteem but consider this

self-esteem but consider this

self-esteem but consider this if you knew the fine for speeding was

if you knew the fine for speeding was

if you knew the fine for speeding was $10 would you speed probably what if you

$10 would you speed probably what if you

$10 would you speed probably what if you knew the fine was $10,000 would you

knew the fine was $10,000 would you

knew the fine was $10,000 would you think twice we cannot control the

think twice we cannot control the

think twice we cannot control the choices our children make now or in the

choices our children make now or in the

choices our children make now or in the future but we can teach them that bad

future but we can teach them that bad

future but we can teach them that bad choices lead to bad outcomes when my

choices lead to bad outcomes when my

choices lead to bad outcomes when my children do something obnoxious or just

children do something obnoxious or just

children do something obnoxious or just fail to complete a task it’s actually

fail to complete a task it’s actually

fail to complete a task it’s actually really tempting to ignore it to make an

really tempting to ignore it to make an

really tempting to ignore it to make an excuse or maybe just do it for them but

excuse or maybe just do it for them but

excuse or maybe just do it for them but instead I’ve started asking myself what

instead I’ve started asking myself what

instead I’ve started asking myself what will the boss say what if my son is

will the boss say what if my son is

will the boss say what if my son is working at NASA the boss asks for the

working at NASA the boss asks for the

working at NASA the boss asks for the safety report and he says ah I forgot to

safety report and he says ah I forgot to

safety report and he says ah I forgot to do that but hey look Jupiter what’s cute

do that but hey look Jupiter what’s cute

do that but hey look Jupiter what’s cute at 3 is not cute at age 23 someday our

at 3 is not cute at age 23 someday our

at 3 is not cute at age 23 someday our children will have to exercise

children will have to exercise

children will have to exercise self-control or there will be $10,000

self-control or there will be $10,000

self-control or there will be $10,000 consequences and we need to help them

consequences and we need to help them

consequences and we need to help them practice now the bottom line is

practice now the bottom line is

practice now the bottom line is self-control is cumulative when we grow

self-control is cumulative when we grow

self-control is cumulative when we grow in one area it spreads into other areas

in one area it spreads into other areas

in one area it spreads into other areas and every little bit helps so for the

and every little bit helps so for the

and every little bit helps so for the sake of our children’s future we need to

sake of our children’s future we need to

sake of our children’s future we need to start focusing on self-control today

start focusing on self-control today

start focusing on self-control today [Applause]

[Applause]

[Applause] [Music]

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *