Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Inadequate Answers to the Definition of Art | El-ly Namatinia | TEDxYouth@ISBangkok


fountain 1917 Marcel Duchamp a urinal BA

fountain 1917 Marcel Duchamp a urinal BA in a small plumbing store in New York

in a small plumbing store in New York

in a small plumbing store in New York City rotated 90 degrees sign with the

City rotated 90 degrees sign with the

City rotated 90 degrees sign with the words our mutt 1917 was sent to a public

words our mutt 1917 was sent to a public

words our mutt 1917 was sent to a public exhibition hall one December day

exhibition hall one December day

exhibition hall one December day attached the six dollar submission fee

attached the six dollar submission fee

attached the six dollar submission fee requested by the museum the piece was

requested by the museum the piece was

requested by the museum the piece was returned back to the sender along with

returned back to the sender along with

returned back to the sender along with their six dollar contribution and a note

their six dollar contribution and a note

their six dollar contribution and a note the message sent was quite clear this is

the message sent was quite clear this is

the message sent was quite clear this is not art flash forward to 2004 fountain

not art flash forward to 2004 fountain

not art flash forward to 2004 fountain is voted the most influential works of

is voted the most influential works of

is voted the most influential works of modern art by 500 art world

modern art by 500 art world

modern art by 500 art world professionals it defied the norms of

professionals it defied the norms of

professionals it defied the norms of Contemporary Art changing the view of

Contemporary Art changing the view of

Contemporary Art changing the view of millions as to what art is and what it

millions as to what art is and what it

millions as to what art is and what it could become good afternoon my name is

could become good afternoon my name is

could become good afternoon my name is Alena Mehta and I will be discussing the

Alena Mehta and I will be discussing the

Alena Mehta and I will be discussing the inadequate answers to art that being the

inadequate answers to art that being the

inadequate answers to art that being the answers to the questions what is art

answers to the questions what is art

answers to the questions what is art what makes it good or bad and who gets

what makes it good or bad and who gets

what makes it good or bad and who gets to decide so let me ask is fountain a

to decide so let me ask is fountain a

to decide so let me ask is fountain a work of art or rather a purchase urinal

work of art or rather a purchase urinal

work of art or rather a purchase urinal which would be better utilized in a

which would be better utilized in a

which would be better utilized in a bathroom stall in France its fountain

bathroom stall in France its fountain

bathroom stall in France its fountain any good or does it display the

any good or does it display the

any good or does it display the unfortunate fall from classical art

unfortunate fall from classical art

unfortunate fall from classical art which experts are right the ones who

which experts are right the ones who

which experts are right the ones who claims fountain is vulgar and

claims fountain is vulgar and

claims fountain is vulgar and plagiarized or those who claim

plagiarized or those who claim

plagiarized or those who claim brilliance a piece reshaping the narrow

brilliance a piece reshaping the narrow

brilliance a piece reshaping the narrow foundations of art in order to answer

foundations of art in order to answer

foundations of art in order to answer these questions we must first consider

these questions we must first consider

these questions we must first consider the different definitions for the term

the different definitions for the term

the different definitions for the term art in his book what is art leo tolstoy

art in his book what is art leo tolstoy

art in his book what is art leo tolstoy writes this it may be quite long but it

writes this it may be quite long but it

writes this it may be quite long but it hardly says anything does the urinal

hardly says anything does the urinal

hardly says anything does the urinal join men and women together in the same

join men and women together in the same

join men and women together in the same feeling give them a sense of union

feeling give them a sense of union

feeling give them a sense of union adjust the progress towards a well-being

adjust the progress towards a well-being

adjust the progress towards a well-being of into

of into

of into chosen of humanity so we turn to Conte

Plato Picasso

Plato Picasso Merriam Webster’s dictionary art is

Merriam Webster’s dictionary art is

Merriam Webster’s dictionary art is something that is created with

something that is created with

something that is created with imagination and skill and that is

imagination and skill and that is

imagination and skill and that is beautiful or expresses important ideas

beautiful or expresses important ideas

beautiful or expresses important ideas or feelings but what is beauty and what

or feelings but what is beauty and what

or feelings but what is beauty and what is important once again we face

is important once again we face

is important once again we face questions of ambiguity do any of these

questions of ambiguity do any of these

questions of ambiguity do any of these definitions suffice I would argue no and

definitions suffice I would argue no and

definitions suffice I would argue no and that is what makes art so interesting

that is what makes art so interesting

that is what makes art so interesting what is considered art is constantly

what is considered art is constantly

what is considered art is constantly changing because of its subjective

changing because of its subjective

changing because of its subjective nature and we need to start being

nature and we need to start being

nature and we need to start being comfortable with the fluidity of

comfortable with the fluidity of

comfortable with the fluidity of definitions and of subjects in the film

definitions and of subjects in the film

definitions and of subjects in the film Mona Lisa smile Katherine and Watson a

Mona Lisa smile Katherine and Watson a

Mona Lisa smile Katherine and Watson a new art teacher a Wesley College asked

new art teacher a Wesley College asked

new art teacher a Wesley College asked her students to examine carcass by

her students to examine carcass by

her students to examine carcass by soutine created in 1925 following what

soutine created in 1925 following what

soutine created in 1925 following what the question is it any good

the question is it any good

the question is it any good Betty warned one of the art students

Betty warned one of the art students

Betty warned one of the art students argues that the piece fails to follow

argues that the piece fails to follow

argues that the piece fails to follow basic standards of art rules of

basic standards of art rules of

basic standards of art rules of composition color technique subject

composition color technique subject

composition color technique subject hence concluding that the piece isn’t

hence concluding that the piece isn’t

hence concluding that the piece isn’t any good but are the rules of color

any good but are the rules of color

any good but are the rules of color composition technique subject are they

composition technique subject are they

composition technique subject are they set or are they simply a manifestation

set or are they simply a manifestation

set or are they simply a manifestation of Betty’s limited exposure and

of Betty’s limited exposure and

of Betty’s limited exposure and understanding of art there’s an old

understanding of art there’s an old

understanding of art there’s an old proverb that goes beauty is in the eye

proverb that goes beauty is in the eye

proverb that goes beauty is in the eye of the beholder but what if we change

of the beholder but what if we change

of the beholder but what if we change that where beauty to the word art are we

that where beauty to the word art are we

that where beauty to the word art are we then allowing the merits of a piece to

then allowing the merits of a piece to

then allowing the merits of a piece to be decided on by each individual

be decided on by each individual

be decided on by each individual according to their definition of what

according to their definition of what

according to their definition of what art is and if we do that are we

art is and if we do that are we

art is and if we do that are we neglecting to recognize the art world

neglecting to recognize the art world

neglecting to recognize the art world the history of

the history of

the history of museum display decision celebrity art

museum display decision celebrity art

museum display decision celebrity art choices or history majors I don’t know

choices or history majors I don’t know

choices or history majors I don’t know the answer to that what I do know is

the answer to that what I do know is

the answer to that what I do know is that our definition of art change in

that our definition of art change in

that our definition of art change in 1772

1772

1772 when Francisco de Goya was first allowed

when Francisco de Goya was first allowed

when Francisco de Goya was first allowed to paint frescoes for the Zahra Gorda

to paint frescoes for the Zahra Gorda

to paint frescoes for the Zahra Gorda Cathedral

Cathedral

Cathedral despite the backlash that his art faced

despite the backlash that his art faced

despite the backlash that his art faced for failing to follow basic rules of art

for failing to follow basic rules of art

for failing to follow basic rules of art in fact until then anything but

in fact until then anything but

in fact until then anything but traditional art was simply not accepted

traditional art was simply not accepted

traditional art was simply not accepted as art Francisco de Goya defied the

as art Francisco de Goya defied the

as art Francisco de Goya defied the status quo what we consider as good art

status quo what we consider as good art

status quo what we consider as good art changed in 1890 when Vincent van Gogh

changed in 1890 when Vincent van Gogh

changed in 1890 when Vincent van Gogh sold his first and only painting the red

sold his first and only painting the red

sold his first and only painting the red vineyard

vineyard

vineyard until then the brushstrokes used by Van

until then the brushstrokes used by Van

until then the brushstrokes used by Van Gogh were not considered good art

Gogh were not considered good art

Gogh were not considered good art techniques in fact it was only after he

techniques in fact it was only after he

techniques in fact it was only after he passed away that his art became

passed away that his art became

passed away that his art became influential van Gogh defied the status

influential van Gogh defied the status

influential van Gogh defied the status quo what the art world defined as art

quo what the art world defined as art

quo what the art world defined as art changed in 1905 when Alfred Stieglitz

changed in 1905 when Alfred Stieglitz

changed in 1905 when Alfred Stieglitz and Edward Steichen formed the little

and Edward Steichen formed the little

and Edward Steichen formed the little galleries of the photo secession in New

galleries of the photo secession in New

galleries of the photo secession in New York City until then photography was not

York City until then photography was not

York City until then photography was not legitimately considered as an art form

legitimately considered as an art form

legitimately considered as an art form by most art professionalist Stieglitz

by most art professionalist Stieglitz

by most art professionalist Stieglitz and Steichen defied the status quo

and Steichen defied the status quo

and Steichen defied the status quo therefore I would argue that the

therefore I would argue that the

therefore I would argue that the greatest artists weren’t great because

greatest artists weren’t great because

greatest artists weren’t great because of the intrinsic value of their art

of the intrinsic value of their art

of the intrinsic value of their art fountain is in essence a urinal BA in a

fountain is in essence a urinal BA in a

fountain is in essence a urinal BA in a small plumbing store with a few words

small plumbing store with a few words

small plumbing store with a few words describes on the back though the

describes on the back though the

describes on the back though the greatest artists were great because of

greatest artists were great because of

greatest artists were great because of the way their art challenged or defied

the way their art challenged or defied

the way their art challenged or defied the status quo Bob Iger the CEO of

the status quo Bob Iger the CEO of

the status quo Bob Iger the CEO of Disney once said that the riskiest thing

Disney once said that the riskiest thing

Disney once said that the riskiest thing we can do is just maintain the status

we can do is just maintain the status

we can do is just maintain the status quo but sometimes the status quo

quo but sometimes the status quo

quo but sometimes the status quo suffices we should simply consider its

suffices we should simply consider its

suffices we should simply consider its merits rather than accepting what is

merits rather than accepting what is

merits rather than accepting what is because of what is therefore I would

because of what is therefore I would

because of what is therefore I would argue that the riskiest thing we can do

argue that the riskiest thing we can do

argue that the riskiest thing we can do is not question

is not question

is not question in the status quo this applies to fine

in the status quo this applies to fine

in the status quo this applies to fine art but also to politics policies

art but also to politics policies

art but also to politics policies literature ideas and music we as humans

literature ideas and music we as humans

literature ideas and music we as humans like consistency so we try to put

like consistency so we try to put

like consistency so we try to put ever-changing objects with weird shapes

ever-changing objects with weird shapes

ever-changing objects with weird shapes and different colors into structured

and different colors into structured

and different colors into structured boxes so that they are easy to

boxes so that they are easy to

boxes so that they are easy to categorize the problem arises when we

categorize the problem arises when we

categorize the problem arises when we forget that the subjective definitions

forget that the subjective definitions

forget that the subjective definitions we set on ambiguous terms are just that

we set on ambiguous terms are just that

we set on ambiguous terms are just that subjective forget that before there was

subjective forget that before there was

subjective forget that before there was a box there was an ever-changing object

a box there was an ever-changing object

a box there was an ever-changing object with weird colors and different shapes

with weird colors and different shapes

with weird colors and different shapes you know what artists you know what it

you know what artists you know what it

you know what artists you know what it feels like and what it looks like when

feels like and what it looks like when

feels like and what it looks like when you first see it but so do you and well

you first see it but so do you and well

you first see it but so do you and well so do you and you might even be

so do you and you might even be

so do you and you might even be reconsidering your initial answer to

reconsidering your initial answer to

reconsidering your initial answer to whether fountain was a work of art but

whether fountain was a work of art but

whether fountain was a work of art but that is okay because each of us have

that is okay because each of us have

that is okay because each of us have different definitions for the term art

different definitions for the term art

different definitions for the term art and those definitions can and will

and those definitions can and will

and those definitions can and will change over time to are due to our

change over time to are due to our

change over time to are due to our exposure to ideas or culture despite

exposure to ideas or culture despite

exposure to ideas or culture despite this I’m not asking you to change your

this I’m not asking you to change your

this I’m not asking you to change your definition of art despite trying I could

definition of art despite trying I could

definition of art despite trying I could not come up for a definition for an idea

not come up for a definition for an idea

not come up for a definition for an idea that encompasses so much

that encompasses so much

that encompasses so much instead I truly believe art much like

instead I truly believe art much like

instead I truly believe art much like opinions understanding ideas they reside

opinions understanding ideas they reside

opinions understanding ideas they reside in the eye of the beholder

in the eye of the beholder

in the eye of the beholder that’s you and so I’m simply asking you

that’s you and so I’m simply asking you

that’s you and so I’m simply asking you to change your perspective of art and to

to change your perspective of art and to

to change your perspective of art and to change your perspective of how you see

change your perspective of how you see

change your perspective of how you see it why you see it that way and what it

it why you see it that way and what it

it why you see it that way and what it means about you thank you

means about you thank you

means about you thank you you

”

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *